UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 10-K
 
     ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
for the fiscal year endedDECEMBER December 31, 20202023
 
      TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
for the transition period from ___________ to___________ 
Commission File Number 1-8339 

nslogo2015a04.jpg

NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)

Virginia52-1188014
(State or other jurisdiction of incorporation or organization)(I.R.S Employer Identification No.)
Three Commercial Place650 West Peachtree Street NW23510-219130308-1925
Norfolk,Atlanta,VirginiaGeorgia
(Address of principal executive offices)(Zip Code)
(757)(855)629-2680667-3655
(Registrant’s telephone number, including area code)

Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of each classTrading Symbol(s)Name of each exchange on which registered
Norfolk Southern Corporation Common Stock (Par Value $1.00)NSCNew York Stock Exchange

Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act: NONE
 
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act.  Yes   No
 
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Act.  Yes   No
 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days.  Yes    No
 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically every Interactive Data File required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T (§ 232.405 of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit such files).   Yes   No
 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer, a smaller reporting company, or an emerging growth company. See the definitions of "large accelerated filer", "accelerated filer", "smaller reporting company", and "emerging growth company" in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act.
Large accelerated filer     Accelerated filer    Non-accelerated filer    Smaller reporting company Emerging growth company
 
If an emerging growth company, indicate by check mark if the registrant has elected not to use the extended transition period for complying with any new or revised financial accounting standards provided pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act.

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has filed a report on and attestation to its management’s assessment of the effectiveness of its internal control over financial reporting under Section 404(b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (15 U.S.C. 7262(b)) by the registered public accounting firm that prepared or issued its audit report.

If securities are registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act, indicate by check mark whether the financial statements of the registrant included in the filing reflect the correction of an error to previously issued financial statements. ☐

Indicate by check mark whether any of those error corrections are restatements that required a recovery analysis of incentive-based compensation received by any of the registrant’s executive officers during the relevant recovery period pursuant to §240.10D-1(b). ☐

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Act).  Yes    No
 
The aggregate market value of the voting common equity held by non-affiliates at June 30, 20202023 was $44,745,974,634$51,455,298,277 (based on the closing price as quoted on the New York Stock Exchange on June 30, 2020)2023).
 
The number of shares outstanding of each of the registrant’s classes of common stock, at January 31, 2021: 251,911,6342024: 225,881,508 (excluding 20,320,777 shares held by the registrant’s consolidated subsidiaries).
 
DOCUMENTS INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE: Portions of the Registrant’s definitive proxy statement to be filed electronically pursuant to Regulation 14A not later than 120 days after the end of the fiscal year, are incorporated herein by reference in Part III.



TABLE OF CONTENTS

NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

   Page
 
 
 
 
  
   
  
 
  
 
 
 
  
 
 
   
 
 
  
 
 
   
 
  
   
  

K2


PART I
 
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES
 
Item 1. Business and Item 2. Properties
 
GENERAL – Norfolk Southern Corporation (Norfolk Southern) is a Norfolk, Virginia-basedan Atlanta, Georgia-based company that owns a major freight railroad, Norfolk Southern Railway Company (NSR).  We were incorporated on July 23, 1980, under the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia.  Our common stock (Common Stock) is listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) under the symbol “NSC.”
 
Unless indicated otherwise, Norfolk Southern Corporation and its subsidiaries, including NSR, are referred to collectively as NS, we, us, and our. 
 
We are primarily engaged in the rail transportation of raw materials, intermediate products, and finished goods primarily in the Southeast, East, and Midwest and, via interchange with rail carriers, to and from the rest of the United States (U.S.).  We also transport overseas freight through several Atlantic and Gulf Coast ports.  We offer the most extensive intermodal network in the eastern half of the U.S.
 
We make available free of charge through our website, www.norfolksouthern.com, our annual report on Form 10-K, quarterly reports on Form 10-Q, current reports on Form 8-K, and all amendments to those reports as soon as reasonably practicable after such material is electronically filed with or furnished to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).  In addition, the following documents are available on our website and in print to any shareholder who requests them:
Corporate Governance GuidelinesNorfolk Southern Corporation Bylaws
Charters of the Committees of the Board of Directors
Corporate Governance Guidelines
Categorical Independence Standards
The Thoroughbred Code of Ethics
Code of Ethical Conduct for Senior Financial Officers
Categorical Independence Standards for Directors
Norfolk Southern Corporation Bylaws

K3


RAILROAD OPERATIONS – At December 31, 2020,2023, we operated approximately 19,30019,100 route miles in 22 states and the District of Columbia.
 
Our system reaches many manufacturing plants, electric generating facilities, mines, distribution centers, transload facilities, and other businesses located in our service area.

nsc-20201231_g2.jpg426750 Stylized System Map for 10K_v2 FINAL.jpg

Corridors with heaviest freight volume:
New York City area to Chicago (via Allentown and Pittsburgh)
Chicago to Macon (via Cincinnati, Chattanooga, and Atlanta)
Central Ohio to Norfolk (via Columbus and Roanoke)
BirminghamCleveland to MeridianKansas City
ClevelandBirmingham to Kansas CityMeridian
Memphis to Chattanooga

K4


The miles operated, which include major leased lines between Cincinnati and Chattanooga, and an exclusive operating agreement for trackage rights over property owned by North Carolina Railroad Company, were as follows:
 Mileage Operated at December 31, 2020
Route MilesSecond
and
Other
Main
Track
Passing
Track,
Crossovers
and
Turnouts
Way and
Yard
Switching 
Total 
Owned14,540 2,678 2,004 8,310 27,532 
Operated under lease, contract or trackage
rights4,795 1,889 406 840 7,930 
Total19,335 4,567 2,410 9,150 35,462 
 Mileage Operated at December 31, 2023
Route MilesSecond
and
Other
Main
Track
Passing
Track,
Crossovers
and
Turnouts
Way and
Yard
Switching 
Total 
Owned14,312 2,676 1,953 8,142 27,083 
Operated under lease, contract or trackage
rights4,825 1,889 406 841 7,961 
Total19,137 4,565 2,359 8,983 35,044 
 
In 2022, we entered into an asset purchase and sale agreement with the Board of Trustees of the Cincinnati Southern Railway (CSR) to purchase 337 miles of railway line that extends from Cincinnati, Ohio to Chattanooga, Tennessee that we currently operate under a lease. The transaction is scheduled to close on March 15, 2024. See further discussion in Item 7 “Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” and Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.”

We operate freight service over lines with significant ongoing Amtrak and commuter passenger operations and conduct freight operations over trackage owned or leased by Amtrak, New Jersey Transit, Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority, Metro-North Commuter Railroad Company, Maryland Department of Transportation, and Michigan Department of Transportation.

The following table sets forth certain statistics relating to our operations for the past five years:
 Years ended December 31,
 20202019201820172016
Revenue ton miles (billions)164 194 207 201 191 
Revenue per thousand revenue ton miles$59.67 $58.21 $55.25 $52.38 $51.91 
Revenue ton miles (thousands) per railroad employee8,191 7,939 7,822 7,474 6,838 
Ratio of railway operating expenses to railway
operating revenues (railway operating ratio)69.3%64.7%65.4%66.6%69.6%
 Years ended December 31,
 20232022202120202019
Revenue ton miles (billions)176 179 178 164 194 
Revenue per thousand revenue ton miles$69.05 $71.35 $62.56 $59.67 $58.21 
Revenue ton miles (thousands) per railroad employee8,719 9,513 9,694 8,191 7,939 
Ratio of railway operating expenses to railway
operating revenues (railway operating ratio)76.5%62.3%60.1%69.3%64.7%

RAILWAY OPERATING REVENUES Total railway operating revenues were $9.8$12.2 billion in 2020.2023.  Following is an overview of our three commodity groups. See the discussion of merchandise revenues by major commodity group, intermodal revenues, and coal revenues and tonnage in Item 7 “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.”
 
MERCHANDISE Our merchandise commodity group is composed of four groupings: 
Agriculture, forest and consumer products includes soybeans, wheat, corn, fertilizer, livestock and poultry feed, food products, food oils, flour, sweeteners, ethanol, lumber and wood products, pulp board and paper products, wood fibers, wood pulp, scrap paper, beverages, and canned goods, and consumer products.goods.
Chemicals includes sulfur and related chemicals, petroleum products (including crude oil), chlorine and bleaching compounds, plastics, rubber, industrial chemicals, chemical wastes, sand, and sand.natural gas liquids.
K5


Metals and construction includes steel, aluminum products, machinery, scrap metals, cement, aggregates, minerals, clay, transportation equipment, and items for the U.S. military.
Automotive includes finished motor vehicles and automotive parts.

In 2020,2023, we handled 2.12.2 million merchandise carloads, which accounted for 62%61% of our total railway operating revenues.

K5


INTERMODAL Our intermodal commodity group consists of shipments moving in domestic and international containers and trailers.  These shipments are handled on behalf of intermodal marketing companies, international steamship lines, premium customers and asset owningasset-owning companies. In 2020,2023, we handled 4.03.8 million intermodal units, which accounted for 27%25% of our total railway operating revenues.
 
COAL  Coal revenues accounted for 11%14% of our total railway operating revenues in 2020.2023.  We handled 6476 million tons, or 0.60.7 million carloads, most of which originated on our lines from major eastern coal basins, with the balance from major western coal basins received via the Memphis and Chicago gateways. Our coal franchise supports the electric generation market, directly serving approximately 5030 coal-fired power plants, as well as the export, domestic metallurgical and industrial markets, primarily through direct rail and river, lake, and coastal facilities, including various terminals on the Ohio River, at Lamberts Point in Norfolk, Virginia, at the Port of Baltimore, and on Lake Erie.

FREIGHT RATES Our predominant pricing mechanisms, private contracts and exempt price quotes, are not subject to regulation. In general, market forces are the primary determinant of rail service prices.
 
RAILWAY PROPERTY
 
Our railroad infrastructure makes us capital intensive with net properties of approximately $31$33 billion on a historical cost basis.

Property Additions Property additions for the past five years were as follows:

20202019201820172016 20232022202120202019
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Road and other propertyRoad and other property$1,046 $1,371 $1,276 $1,210 $1,292 
Road and other property
Road and other property
EquipmentEquipment448 648 675 513 595 
TotalTotal$1,494 $2,019 $1,951 $1,723 $1,887 
Total
Total

Our capital spending and replacement programs are and have been designed to assure thesupport our ability to provide safe, efficient, and reliable rail transportation services.
K6


Equipment Our equipment includes owned and leased locomotives and railcars; maintenance of way equipment and machinery; other equipment and tools used in our shops, offices and facilities; and vehicles and other equipment used for maintenance, transportation, and other activities. Our equipment includes both owned equipment acquired by us, and equipment held under lease arrangements. At December 31, 2020,2023, we owned or leased the following units ofrevenue generating equipment:
OwnedLeasedTotalCapacity of
Equipment
Locomotives:   (Horsepower)
Multiple purpose3,060 — 3,060 11,901,400 
Auxiliary units138 — 138 — 
Switching— 4,400 
Total locomotives3,202 — 3,202 11,905,800 
Freight cars:   (Tons)
Gondola18,958 3,203 22,161 2,460,176 
Hopper8,723 — 8,723 992,956 
Covered hopper5,951 — 5,951 661,573 
Box2,851 617 3,468 312,994 
Flat1,494 85 1,579 133,586 
Other1,559 1,563 70,045 
Total freight cars39,536 3,909 43,445 4,631,330 
Other:
Chassis33,865 — 33,865 
Containers18,350 — 18,350 
Work equipment5,546 183 5,729 
Vehicles2,928 32 2,960 
Miscellaneous2,306 — 2,306 
Total other62,995 215 63,210 
OwnedLeasedTotalCapacity of
Equipment
Locomotives:   (Horsepower)
Multiple purpose3,162 30 3,192 12,471,795 
Auxiliary units140 — 140 — 
Switching— 4,400 
Total locomotives3,306 30 3,336 12,476,195 
Freight cars:   (Tons)
Gondola18,011 3,741 21,752 2,443,624 
Hopper7,672 — 7,672 876,433 
Covered hopper5,384 — 5,384 598,451 
Box2,189 610 2,799 257,694 
Flat1,213 676 1,889 135,106 
Other1,086 — 1,086 46,815 
Total freight cars35,555 5,027 40,582 4,358,123 
Intermodal equipment:
Chassis38,397 1,063 39,460 
Containers17,662 — 17,662 
Roadrailers1,110 — 1,110 
Total intermodal equipment57,169 1,063 58,232 
 
The following table indicates the number and year built for locomotives and freight cars owned at December 31, 2020:2023:
202020192018201720162011-
2015
2006-
2010
2005 &
Before
Total
Locomotives:        
No. of units351555652912602,4813,202
% of fleet%%%%%%77 %100 %
Freight cars:       
No. of units2004707758,7824,84024,46939,536
% of fleet%%%22 %12 %62 %100 %
202320222021202020192014-
2018
2009-
2013
2008 &
Before
Total
Locomotives:        
No. of units110362252422,7923,306
% of fleet— %— %— %— %%%%85 %100 %
Freight cars:       
No. of units1,0432361984,1956,40123,48235,555
% of fleet%%— %— %— %12 %18 %66 %100 %

K7


The following table shows the average age of our owned locomotive and freight car fleets at December 31, 20202023 and information regarding 20202023 retirements:
LocomotivesFreight Cars 
Average age – in service25.7 years25.6 years
Retirements704 units6,338 units
Average age – retired31.3 years42.7 years
 Locomotives Freight Cars 
Average age – in service28.5years25.4years
Retirements2units1,744 units
Average age – retired23.0years40.8years

Track Maintenance Of the 35,50035,000 total miles of track on which we operate, we are responsible for maintaining 28,80028,400 miles, with the remainder being operated under trackage rights from other parties responsible for maintenance.

Over 84%85% of the main line trackage (including first, second, third, and branch main tracks, all excluding rail operated pursuant to trackage rights) has rail ranging from 131 to 155 pounds per yard with the standard installation currently at 136 pounds per yard. Approximately 39% of our lines, excluding rail operated pursuant to trackage rights, carried 20 million or more gross tons per track mile during 2020.2023.

The following table summarizes several measurements regarding our track roadway additions and replacements during the past five years:
 20202019201820172016
Track miles of rail installed418 449 416 466 518 
Miles of track surfaced4,785 5,012 4,594 5,368 4,984 
Crossties installed (millions)1.8 2.4 2.2 2.5 2.3 
 20232022202120202019
Track miles of rail installed584 541 458 418 449 
Miles of track surfaced4,013 4,155 4,225 4,785 5,012 
Crossties installed (millions)2.1 2.2 2.0 1.8 2.4 

Traffic Control Of the 16,40016,200 route miles we dispatch, 11,300 miles are signalized, includingincorporate signalization. This includes 8,500 miles ofgoverned by centralized traffic control (CTC) and 2,800 miles ofutilizing automatic block signals.  OfWithin the 8,500 miles of CTC, 7,600 miles are controlled by data radio systems originating atfrom 355 base station radio sites.
 
ENVIRONMENTAL MATTERS Compliance with federal, state, and local laws and regulations relating to the protection of the environment is one of our principal goals.  To date,With the exception of our response to the Eastern Ohio Incident (the “Incident” as defined in Note 17) such compliance has not had a material effect on our financial position, results of operations, liquidity, or competitive position. SeeFor further information on the Incident and environmental matters, see Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
HUMAN CAPITAL MANAGEMENT

Workforce We employed an average of 20,20020,300 employees during 2020,2023, and 19,10020,700 employees at the end of 2020.2023. Approximately 80% of our railroad employees referred to as “craft” employees are covered by collective bargaining agreements with various labor unions.unions, and referred to as “craft” employees. See the discussion of “Labor Agreements” in Item 7 “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.”  The remainder of our workforce is composed of management employees.
 
Craft Workforce Levels and Productivity Maintaining appropriate headcount levels for our craft-employee workforce is critical to our on-time and consistent delivery of customers’ goods and operational efficiency goals. We manage this human capital metric through forecasting tools designed to ensure the optimal level of staffing to meet business demands while controlling costs.demands. We measure and monitor employee productivity based on various factors, including gross ton miles per train and engine employee.

Safety We are dedicated to providing employees with a safe workplace and the knowledge and tools they need to work safely and return home safely every day. Our commitment to an injury-free workplace is illustrated by our “I am Coming Home” safety message, which is featured prominentlyoutlined in our yards, shops,Foundation of Safety policy which focuses on rules compliance, responsibility, relationships, and facilitiesresponsiveness.
K8


Our safety programs, practices, and messaging further reinforcesreinforce the importance of working safely. We measure employee safety performance through internal metrics
K8


such as lost-timeaccidents, injuries, and serious injuries per 200,000 employee-hours andemployee-hours. We also use metrics established by the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA), such as FRA reportable to measure FRA-reportable accidents per million train miles and injuries per 200,000 employee-hours. Given that safety continues to be a top priority, and the importance of safety among our workforce and to our business, in 2020, our Board of Directors established(Board) has a standing Safety Committee that, among other duties, reviews, monitors, and evaluates our compliance with our safety programs and practices.

Attracting and Retaining Management Employees Our talent strategy for management employees is essential to attracting strong candidates in a competitive talent environment. We evaluate the effectiveness of that strategy by studying market trends, benchmarking the attractiveness of our employee value proposition, maintaining a competitive compensation package, and analyzing retention data.

We also focus on driving employee engagement, which is key to increasing employee productivity, retention, and safety. We take a data-centric approach, including the use of quarterlyperiodic surveys among management employees, to identify new initiatives that will help boost engagement and drive business results.

Employee Development and Training We provide a range of developmental programs, opportunities, skills, and resources for our employees to work safely and be successful in their careers. We provide classroom instruction, hands-on training and simulationsimulation-based training designed to improve trainingon-the-job effectiveness and safety outcomes.

We also use modern learning and performance technologies to offer robust professional growth opportunities. Through on-demand digital course offerings, custom-built learning paths, and performance-management tools,in-person facilitated content, our platforms deliverprograms provide a contemporary, convenient,holistic and inclusive approach to professional development.development throughout an employee's career.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion As a leading transportation service company, we understandrecognize that competingsuccess in the global marketplace requires recruitingrelies on the most qualified, talented,recruitment and diverse people. We striveretention of top-tier talent, as well as leveraging the expertise and experiences of individuals from all backgrounds.

In pursuit of this goal, we are dedicated to createestablishing a workplace that is diverse, equitable, and inclusive, workplace where a wide rangebroad spectrum of identities, perspectives, and experiences areis not only represented but also valued and empowered to thrive.

While our current workforce reflects a broad rangeOur Inclusion Leadership Council, comprised of backgrounds and experiences, we continue to focus on building an even more diverse workforce, using technology-driven outreach and multiple recruiting relationships to maintain a robust pipeline of diverse talent.

To underscore our commitment to cultivating a workplace experience where the unique experiences, perspectives, and contributions of all our people are valued, our senior management team recently signed a pledge reaffirming our commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion. To advance that commitment, senior leaders from acrossall departments, our seven employee resource groups, and the company serve on anDiversity, Equity, and Inclusion Leadership Council, which is accountable for setting our enterprise inclusion strategy and articulatingteam, collaborate closely to implement the plan, articulate measurable goals, and actions needed to achieve them.hold ourselves accountable.

GOVERNMENT REGULATION In addition to environmental, safety, securities, and other regulations generally applicable to all business, our railroads are subject to regulation by the U.S. Surface Transportation Board (STB).  The STB has jurisdiction to varying extents over rates, routes, customer access provisions, fuel surcharges, conditions of service, and the extension or abandonment of rail lines.  The STB has jurisdiction to determine whether we are “revenue adequate” on an annual basis based on the results of the prior year. A railroad is “revenue adequate” on an annual basis under the applicable law when its return on net investment exceeds the rail industry’s composite cost of capital.  This determination is made pursuant to a statutory requirement. The STB also has jurisdiction over the consolidation, merger, or acquisition of control of and by rail common carriers. 
 
The relaxation of economic regulation of railroads, following the Staggers Rail Act of 1980, included exemption from STB regulation of the rates and most service terms for intermodal business (trailer-on-flat-car, container-on-flat-car), rail boxcar shipments, lumber, manufactured steel, automobiles, and certain bulk commodities such as sand, gravel, pulpwood, and wood chips for paper manufacturing.  Further, all shipments that we have under contract are effectively removed from commercial regulation for the duration of the contract.  Approximately 90% of our revenues comes from either exempt shipments or shipments moving under transportation contracts; the remainder comes from shipments moving under public tariff rates.
K9


Efforts have been made over the past several years to increase federal economic regulation of the rail industry, and such efforts are expected to continue in 2021.2024.  The Staggers Rail Act of 1980 substantially balanced the interests of shippers and rail carriers, and encouraged and enabled rail carriers to innovate, invest in their infrastructure, and compete for business, thereby contributing to the economic health of the nation and to the revitalization of the industry.  Accordingly, we will continue to oppose efforts to reimpose increased economic regulation. 

Railroads are also subject to the enactment of laws by Congress and regulation by the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) (including the FRA) and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) (including the Transportation Security Administration (TSA)), which regulate most aspects of our operations related to safety, security and cybersecurity.

Government regulations are further discussed within Item 1A “Risk Factors” and the safety and security of our railroads are discussed within the “Security of Operations” section contained herein.
 
COMPETITION There is continuing strong competition among rail, water, and highway carriers.  Price is usually only one factor of importance as shippers and receivers choose a transport mode and specific hauling company. Inventory carrying costs, service reliability, ease of handling, and the desire to avoid loss and damage during transit are also important considerations, especially for higher-valued finished goods, machinery, and consumer products.  Even for raw materials, semi-finished goods, and work-in-progress, users are increasingly sensitive to transport arrangements that minimize problems at successive production stages.

Ourprimary rail competitor is CSXCorporation (CSX); both we and CSX operate throughout much of the same territory. Other railroads also operate in parts of the territory.  Wealso compete with motor carriers, water carriers, and with shippers who have the additional options of handling their own goods in private carriage, sourcing products from different geographic areas, and using substitute products.
 
Certain marketing strategies to expand reach and shipping options among railroads and between railroads and motor carriers enablerailroadsto compete more effectively in specific markets. 

SECURITY OF OPERATIONS – We continue to enhance the security of our rail system. Our comprehensive security plan is modeled on and was developed in conjunction with the security plan prepared by the Association of American Railroads (AAR) post September 11, 2001. The AAR Security Plan defines four Alert Levels and details the actions and countermeasures that are being applied across the railroad industry to mitigateas the risk of terrorist, violent extremist or seriously disruptive cyber-attack increases or decreases. The Alert Level actions include countermeasures that will be applied in three general areas: (1) operations (including transportation, engineering, and mechanical); (2) information technology and communications; and, (3) railroad police. All of our Operations Division employees are advised by their supervisors or train dispatchers, as appropriate, of any change in Alert Level and any additional responsibilities they may incur due to such change.

Our security plan also complies with U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT)DOT security regulations pertaining to training and security plans with respect to the transportation of hazardous materials. As part of the plan, security awareness training is given to all railroad employees who directly affect hazardous material transportation safety, and is integrated into hazardous material training programs. Additionally, location-specific security plans are in place for rail corridors in certain metropolitan areas referred to as High Threat Urban Areas (HTUA). Particular attention is aimed at reducing risk in a HTUA by: (1) the establishment of secure storage areas for rail cars carrying toxic-by-inhalation (TIH) materials; (2) the expedited movement of trains transporting rail cars carrying TIH materials; (3) reducing the number of unattended loaded tank cars carrying TIH materials; and (4) cooperation with federal, state, local, and tribal governments to identify those locations where security risks are the highest.

We also operate sixfour facilities that are under U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) Maritime Security Regulations. With respect to these facilities, each facility’s security plan has been approved by the applicable Captain of the Port and remains subject to inspection by the USCG.
K10



Additionally, we continue to engage in close and regular coordination with numerous federal and state agencies, including the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS),DHS, the Transportation Security Administration,TSA, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the FRA, the USCG, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, the Department of Defense, and various state Homeland Security offices.

In 2020,2023, through the COVID-19 pandemic led to cancellation of all face-to-face training, including the Safety Train Tour as part of ourNorfolk Southern Operation Awareness and Response Program as well as participation in the Transportation Community
K10


Awareness and Emergency Response Program. The need to provide training to first responders did not go away. Our Hazmat Group adapted and created online training courses as well as conducted training webinars for first responders. Even with the adverse conditions of 2020,Program, we provided rail accident response training to approximately 1,000more than 5,000 emergency responders, such as local police and fire personnel.personnel, utilizing a combination of online training and face-to-face training sessions as well as the Norfolk Southern Safety Train. We also have ongoing programs to sponsor local emergency responders at the Security and Emergency Response Training Center.

We also continually evaluate ourselves for appropriate business continuity and disaster recovery planning, with test scenarios that include cybersecurity attacks. Our risk-based information security program helps ensure our defenses and resources are aligned to address the most likely and most damaging potential attacks, to provide support for our organizational mission and operational objectives, and to keep us in the best position to detect, mitigate, and recover from a wide variety of potential attacks in a timely fashion.

Item 1A. Risk Factors

The risks set forth in the following risk factors could have a materiallymaterial adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity in a particular year or quarter, and could cause those results to differ materially from those expressed or implied in our forward-looking statements. The information set forth in this Item 1A “Risk Factors” should be read in conjunction with the rest of the information included in this annual report, including
Item 7 “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” and Item 8 “Financial Statements and Supplementary Data.” We have experienced a number of the risks described below over the past year in connection with the Incident and the Incident Proceedings (defined below). The risks described below should be read in conjunction with the information regarding the Incident and Incident Proceedings provided in Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.”

INCIDENT RISKS

As defined and as further described in Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements”, there was an Incident that occurred in the first quarter that consisted of a February 3, 2023 train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio that included 11 non-Company-owned tank cars containing hazardous materials, fires associated with the derailment that threatened certain of the tank cars, and a controlled vent and burn procedure conducted on February 6, 2023 on five of the derailed tank cars, all of which contained vinyl chloride.As a result of the Incident, we have become subject to numerous legal, regulatory, legislative and other proceedings related thereto, including but not limited to, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Investigation, the FRA Incident Investigation, the FRA Safety Assessment, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Complaint, the Ohio Complaint, the Incident Lawsuits, the Shareholder Matters, and the Incident Inquiries and Investigations, (each as defined in Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements”), in addition to other proceedings, actions, or potential changes in response to the Incident, including but not limited to those related to, among other items, train size, train length, train composition, or crew size (collectively, the “Incident Proceedings”).Set forth below are additional risks pertaining to an investment in the Company that are related to the Incident and the Incident Proceedings.

The costs, liabilities, fines, penalties, and/or financial impact resulting from or related to the Incident or the Incident Proceedings have been significant to date, may exceed expected or accrued amounts, and have and can be expected to continue to negatively affect our financial results.We have incurred and will continue to remain subject to incurring significant costs, liabilities, fines, and penalties related to the Incident and the Incident Proceedings, including amounts that may have a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity.

K11


In addition, while we have accrued estimates of probable and reasonably estimable liabilities with respect to the Incident and the Incident Proceedings (several of which are in early stages), we cannot predict the final outcome or estimate the reasonably possible range of loss with certainty and such estimates may change over time due to a variety of factors, including but not limited to those set forth in Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements” or other unfavorable or unexpected developments or outcomes which could result in our current estimates being insufficient.These estimated amounts also do not include any estimate of loss for specific items for which we believe a loss is either not probable or not reasonably estimable for the reasons set forth in Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.”As a result, our currently accrued amounts of estimated liabilities may be insufficient, and any additional, new or updated accruals could have a material adverse effect on our results of operations or financial position.

New or additional governmental regulation and/or operational changes resulting from or related to the Incident or the Incident Proceedings may negatively impact us, our customers, the rail industry, or the markets we serve.The legislative, regulatory, operational or other actions taken, protocols adopted (including by us), or changes resulting from the Incident or any of the Incident Proceedings may, either individually or in the aggregate, have a material adverse effect on us, our customers, the rail industry, or the markets we serve.We also face risks from requirements that may be imposed by the government in resolution of government actions, including, for example, restrictions on our methods of operations. Our inability to comply with the requirements of any new or additional laws, regulations or operating protocols resulting from or related to the Incident or the Incident Proceedings may have a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations, liquidity, or operations.

REGULATORY AND LEGISLATIVE RISKS

Significant governmentalGovernmental legislation, regulation, and regulationExecutive Orders over commercial, operational, tax, operating and environmentalsafety, security, or cybersecurity matters could negatively affect us, our customers, andthe rail industry or the markets we serve. Congress can enact laws, agencies can promulgate regulations, and Executive Orders can be issued that could increase economicor alter regulation ofin a way that negatively affects us, our customers, the industry.rail industry or the markets we serve. Railroads presently are subject to commercial and operational regulation by the STB, which has jurisdiction to varying extents over rates, routes, customer access provisions, fuel surcharges, conditions of service, and the extension or abandonment of rail lines.

The STB also has jurisdiction over the consolidation, merger, or acquisition of control of and by rail common carriers. Additional economicor updated regulation of the rail industry by Congress or the STB, whether under new, existing or existingamended laws or regulations, could have a significant negative impact on our ability to negotiate prices for rail services, on our railway operating revenues, and on the efficiency, conduct, or complexity of our operations. Such additional or updated industry regulation, as well as enactment of any new or updated tax laws, could also negatively impact cash flows from our operating activities and, therefore, could result in reduced capital spending on our rail network or abandonment of lines.

Railroads are also subject to the enactment of laws by Congress and regulation by the DOT (including the FRA) and the DHS (including the TSA), which regulate mostmany aspects of our operations related to safety, security and security. The Rail Safety Improvement Act of 2008,cybersecurity. Additional or updated safety, security, or cybersecurity regulation by Congress, the Surface Transportation Extension Act of 2015,DOT or DHS could have a negative impact on our business and the implementing regulations promulgated by the FRA (collectively “the PTC laws and regulations”) required us (and each other Class I railroad) to implement an interoperable positive train control system (PTC) on main lines over which five millionefficiency, conduct, or more gross tons of annual traffic and certain hazardous materials are transported, and on any main lines over which intercity or commuter rail passenger transportation is regularly provided. We completed our PTC implementation prior to the December 31, 2020 deadline. PTC is installed on 8,000complexity of our 19,300 routes miles. PTC is designed to prevent train-to-train collisions, speed-related derailments, and certain other accidents caused by human error, but it willoperations including (but not prevent all types of train accidents or incidents. The PTC system will continue to result in additionallimited to) increased operating costs, and capital expenditures, and may result in increased claims and litigation costs.litigation.

Our inability to comply with the requirements of existing or updated laws, regulations, or Executive Orders that govern our operations or the rail industry, including but not limited to those pertaining to commercial, operational, tax, safety, security, or cybersecurity matters, could have a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations or liquidity.

We are addressing multiple governmental actions as a result of the Incident, as noted in “Incident Risks” above.

K12


Federal and state environmental laws and regulations could negatively impact us and our operations. Our operations are subject to extensive federal and state environmental laws and regulations concerning, among other things,things: emissions to the air; discharges to waterways or groundwater supplies; handling, storage, transportation, and disposal of waste and other materials; and, the cleanup of hazardous material or petroleum releases. The risk of incurring environmental liability, for acts and omissions, past, present, and future, is inherent in the railroad business. This risk includes property owned by us, whether currently or in the past, that is or has been subject to a variety of uses, including our railroad operations and other industrial activity by past owners or our past and present tenants.

K11


Environmental problems that are latent or undisclosed may exist on these properties, and we could incur environmental liabilities or costs, the amount and materiality of which cannot be estimated reliably at this time, with respect to one or more of these properties. Moreover, lawsuits and claims involving other unidentified environmental sites and matters are likely to arise from time to time.

Our inability to comply with the extensive federal and state environmental laws and regulations to which we are subject could result in significant liabilities or otherwise adversely impact our operations.

As noted in “Incident Risks” above, in connection with the Incident, we are experiencing negative impacts related to environmental matters, including extensive cleanup costs and litigation related to alleged environmental impacts of the Incident.

OPERATIONAL RISKS

A significant cybersecurity incident or other disruption to our technology infrastructure could disrupt our business operations. To conduct business, we extensively rely on information and operational technology systems, and improvements in those technologies, in all aspects of our business. The COVID-19 pandemicthreat landscape is vast and includes hobbyists, cybercriminals, nation-states and state-sponsored activities. Attacks from these entities include, but is not limited to, denial of service, unauthorized access, theft of money, and data and extortion. System upgrades, redundancy and other continuity measures may be ineffective or inadequate, and our business continuity and disaster recovery planning may not be sufficient for all eventualities. Regardless of the cause, significant disruption or failure of one or more of information or operational technology systems operated by us or under control of third parties, including computer hardware, software, cloud services and communications equipment, can result in us experiencing a service interruption, data breach, or other operational difficulties. Such failures or disruptions can adversely impact our business by, among other things, preventing intercompany communications and disrupting operations that may result in direct or indirect monetary losses, damage to equipment or property, or loss of confidence in corporate competency. These events could further impact us,have a materially adverse effect on our customers,business, reputation, results of operations and financial condition. Although we maintain comprehensive security programs designed to protect our information technology systems, including our risk-based approach to cybersecurity, our reliance on the Framework for Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity drafted by the U.S Department of Commerce's National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST CSF) and our layered defense system, we are continually targeted by threat actors attempting to access our networks and we may be unable to detect or prevent a breach of our systems or disruption to our service in the future. While we have previously experienced technology outages and cybersecurity events that have impacted our systems and service, future events may result in more significant impacts to our operations, reputation or financial results. These potentially impactful future events could include service disruptions, unauthorized access to our systems, viruses, ransomware, and/or compromise, acquisition, or destruction of our data. We also could be impacted by cybersecurity events targeting third parties that we rely on for business operations, including third party vendors that have access to our systems or data and third parties who provide services and are in our supply chain andchain. Such a direct or indirect cybersecurity incident could interrupt our operations. The pandemic has negatively impacted the economy and continuesservice, cause safety failures or operational difficulties, decrease revenues, increase operating costs, impact our efficiency, damage our corporate reputation, and/or expose us to generate significant economic uncertainty. The magnitude and duration of the pandemic, and its impact on our customers and general economic conditions will influence the demand for our services and affect our revenues.litigation or government action or increased regulation, which could result in penalties, fines or judgments. In addition, COVID-19our failure to comply with or adhere to privacy-related or data protection laws and regulations could affectresult in government investigations and proceedings against us, or litigation, resulting in adverse reputational impacts, penalties, and legal liability.
K13



Our business may be seriously harmed if we fail to develop, implement, maintain, upgrade, enhance, protect and integrate our operationsinformation technology systems. If we fail to develop, acquire or implement new technology, or otherwise fail to maintain, protect or integrate our information technology systems, we may suffer a competitive disadvantage within the rail industry and business continuity if a significant numberwith companies providing alternative modes of our essential employees, overall or in a key location, are quarantined from contraction of or exposure to the disease or if governmental orders prevent our operating employees or critical suppliers from working. To the extent COVID-19 adversely affects our business and financial results, it may also have the effect of heightening many of the other risks described in the risk factors included herein.transportation service.

As a common carrier by rail, we must offer to transport hazardous materials, regardless of risk.which exposes us to significant costs and claims. Transportation of certain hazardous materials could create catastrophicor third party-owned equipment (typically used to transport such materials) creates risks of significant losses in terms of personal injury and property (including environmental) damage and compromise critical parts of our rail network. The costs of a catastrophic rail accident involving hazardous materials or third party-owned equipment could exceed our insurance coverage. We have obtained insurance for potential losses for third-party liability and first-party property damages (see Note 17 in Item 8 “Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements)Statements”); however, insurance is available from a limited number of insurers and may not continue to be available or, if available, may not be obtainable on terms acceptable to us. Any future legislation preventing the transportation of hazardous materials through specific cities could have negative impacts including increased network congestion and operating costs, reduced operating efficiency, and increased risk of an accident involving hazardous materials.

With regard to the risks arising from the transportation of hazardous materials, the Incident and the Incident Proceedings have given rise to significant costs to us and impacts on our rail network, as noted in “Incident Risks” above. With respect to third party-owned equipment, the primary risk arises from the potential for a latent defect we are unable to identify despite robust safety inspection protocols.

We face competition from other transportation providers. We are subject to competition from motor carriers, railroads and, to a lesser extent, ships, barges, and pipelines, on the basis of transit time, pricing, and quality and reliability of service. While we have primarily used primarily internal resources to build or acquire and maintain our rail system, trucks and barges have been able to use public rights-of-way maintained by public entities. Any future improvements, expenditures, legislation, or regulation changing or materially increasing the qualityefficiency or reducing the cost of one or more alternative modes of transportation in the regions in which we operate (such as granting materially greater latitude for motor carriers with respect to size or weight limitations or adoption and utilization of autonomous commercial vehicles) could have a material adverse effect on our ability to compete with other modes of transportation.

Capacity constraints could negatively impact our service and operating efficiency. We couldhave experienced and may again experience capacity constraints on our rail network related to employee or equipment shortages, increased demand for rail services, locomotive or employee shortages, severe weather, congestion on other railroads, including passenger activities, or impacts from changes to our network structure or composition. Such constraints could result in operational inefficiencies or adversely affect our operations.

Significant increases in demand for rail services could result in the unavailability of qualified personnel and resources like locomotives. Changes in workforce demographics, training requirements, and availability of qualified personnel, particularly for engineers and conductors, could have a negativenegatively impacted and may again negatively impact on our ability to meet short-term demand for rail service. Unpredicted increases in demand for rail services may exacerbate such risks and could negatively impact our operational efficiency.

TheConstraints on the supply chain or the operations of carriers with which we interchange may adversely affect our operations.Our ability to provide rail service to our customers in the U.S. and Canada depends in large part upon a functioning global supply chain and our ability to maintain collaborative relationships with connecting carriers (including shortlines and regional railroads) with respect to, among other matters, freight rates, revenue division, car supply and locomotive availability, data exchange and communications, reciprocal switching, interchange, and trackage rights. Deterioration in the operations ofsupply chain or service provided by connecting carriers, or in our relationship with those connecting carriers, could result in our inability to meet our customers’ demands or require us to use alternate train
K14


routes, which could result in significant additional costs and network inefficiencies. Additionally, any significant consolidations, mergers or operational changes among other railroads may significantly redefinealter our market access and reach.

K12


The vast majority of our employees belong to labor unions, and labor agreements, strikes, or work stoppages could adversely affect our operations. Approximately 80% of our railroad employees are covered by collective bargaining agreements with various labor unions. If unionized workers were to engage in a strike, work stoppage, or other slowdown, we could experience a significant disruption of our operations. Additionally, future national labor agreements, or renegotiation of labor agreements or provisions of labor agreements, could significantly increase our costs for health care, wages, and other benefits.

We may be negatively affected by terrorism or war. Any terrorist attack, or other similar event, any government response thereto, and war or risk of war could cause significant business interruption. Because we play a critical role in the nation’s transportation system, we could become the target of such an attack or have a significant role in the government’s preemptive approach or response to an attack or war.

Although we currently maintain insurance coverage for third-party liability arising out of war and acts of terrorism, we maintain only limited insurance coverage for first-party property damage and damage to property in our care, custody, or control caused by certain acts of terrorism. In addition, premiums for some or all of our current insurance programs covering these losses could increase dramatically, or insurance coverage for certain losses could be unavailable to us in the future.

We may be negatively affected by supply constraints resulting from disruptions in the fuel markets or the nature of some of our supplier markets.We consumed approximately 368377 million gallons of diesel fuel in 2020.2023. Fuel availability could be affected by any limitation in the fuel supply or by any imposition of mandatory allocation or rationing regulations. A severe fuel supply shortage arising from production curtailments, increased demand in existing or emerging foreign markets, disruption of oil imports, disruption of domestic refinery production, damage to refinery or pipeline infrastructure, political unrest, war or other factors could impact us as well as our customers and other transportation companies.

Due to the capital intensivecapital-intensive nature, as well as the industry-specific requirements of the rail industry, high barriers of entry exist for potential new suppliers of core railroad items, such as locomotives and rolling stock equipment. Additionally, we compete with other industries for available capacity and raw materials used in the production of locomotives and certain track and rolling stock materials. Changes in the competitive landscapes of these limited supplier markets could result in increased prices or significant shortages of materials.

Pandemics, epidemics or endemic diseases could further negatively impact us, our customers, our supply chain and our operations. The magnitude and duration of a pandemic, epidemic or endemic disease, and its impact on our customers and general economic conditions can influence the demand for our services and affect our revenues. In addition, such outbreaks could affect our operations and business continuity if a significant number of our essential employees, overall or in a key location, are unable to work from contraction of or exposure to the disease or if governmental orders prevent our employees or critical suppliers from working. To the extent such diseases adversely affect our business and financial results, they may also have the effect of heightening many of the other risks described in the risk factors included herein, or may affect our operating and financial results in a manner that is not presently known to us.

LITIGATION RISKS

We may be subject to various claims and lawsuits that could result in significant expenditures. The nature of our business exposes us to the potential for various claims and litigation related to labor and employment, personal injury, commercial disputes, freight loss and other property damage, and other matters. Job-related personal injury and occupational claims are subject to the Federal Employer’s Liability Act (FELA), which is applicable only to railroads. FELA’s fault-based tort system produces results that are unpredictable and inconsistent as compared with a no-fault worker’s compensation system. The variability inherent in this system could result in actual costs being different from the liability recorded.

A catastrophic rail accident, whether on our lines or another carrier’s, involving any or all of release of hazardous materials, freight loss, property damage, personal injury, and environmental liability could compromise critical parts of our rail network. Losses associated with such an accident involving us could exceed our insurance coverage, resulting in a material adverse effect on our liquidity. Any material changes to current litigation trends could also have a material adverse effect on our liquidity to the extent not covered by insurance.
K15



We have obtained insurance for potential losses for third-party liability and first-party property damages (see Note 17 to the Consolidated Financial Statements);damages; however, insurance is available from a limited number of insurers and may not continue to be available or, if available, may not be obtainable on terms acceptable to us.

We are incurring significant expenditures as a result of claims and lawsuits arising from the Incident and the related Incident Proceedings, as described in “Incident Risks” above.

K13HUMAN CAPITAL RISKS


Failure to attract and retain key executive officers, or skilled professional or technical employees could adversely impact our business and operations. Our success depends on our ability to attract and retain skilled employees, including a sufficient number of craft employees to enable us to efficiently conduct our operations. Difficulties in recruiting and retaining skilled employees, including train and engine workers, key executives, and other skilled professional and technical employees; the unexpected loss of such individuals; and/or our inability to successfully transition key roles could each have a material adverse effect on our business and operations.

The vast majority of our employees belong to labor unions, and the renegotiation of labor agreements or any provisions thereof, or any strikes or work stoppages (including any entered into in connection with any such negotiations), could adversely affect our operations. Approximately 80% of our railroad employees are covered by collective bargaining agreements with various labor unions. We entered into updated labor agreements with these labor unions in December 2022 and future national labor agreements, or renegotiation of labor agreements or provisions of labor agreements, could significantly increase our costs for health care, wages, and other benefits. Additionally, if our craft employees were to engage in a strike, work stoppage, or other slowdown, including in connection with the renegotiation of any such agreements or any provisions thereof, we could experience a significant disruption in our operations, thereby adversely impacting our results of operations.

CLIMATE CHANGE RISKS

Severe weather and disasters have caused, and could result inagain cause, significant business interruptions and expenditures.Severe weather conditions and other natural phenomena resulting from changing weather patterns and rising sea levels or other causes, including hurricanes, floods, fires, landslides, extreme temperatures, significant precipitation, and earthquakes, have caused, and may again cause damage to our network, our workforce to be unavailable and us to be unable to use our equipment. Additionally, shifts in weather patterns caused by climate change are expected to increase the frequency, severity or duration of certain adverse weather conditions, which could cause more significant business interruptions andthat result in increased costs, increased liabilities, and decreased revenues.

Concern over climate change has led to significant federal, state, and international legislative and regulatory efforts to limit greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Restrictions, caps, taxes, or other legislative or regulatory controls on GHG emissions, including diesel exhaust, could significantly increase our operating costs and decrease the amount of traffic we handle.

In addition, legislation and regulation related to GHGsclimate change or GHG emissions could negatively affect the markets we serve and our customers. Even without legislation or regulation, government incentives and adverse publicity relating to GHGsclimate change or GHG emissions could negatively affect the markets for certain of the commodities we carry, andor our customers that (1) use commodities we carry to produce energy including coal, (2)(including coal), use significant amounts of energy in producing or delivering the commodities we carry, or (3) manufacture or produce goods that consume significant amounts of energy.energy associated with GHG emissions.

GENERAL
K16


MACROECONOMIC AND MARKET RISKS

We may be affectednegatively impacted by changes in general economic conditions. Prolonged negativeNegative changes in domestic and global economic conditions, including reduced import and export volumes, could affect the producers and consumers of the commoditiesfreight we carry. Economic conditions could also result in bankruptcies of one or more large customers.

We may be negatively affected by energy prices. Volatility in energy prices could have a significant effect on a variety of items including, but not limited to: the economy; demand for transportation services; business related to the energy sector, including crude oil, natural gas, and coal; fuel prices; and, fuel surcharges.

We rely on technology and technology improvements in our business operations. If we experience significant disruption or failure of one or more of our information technology systems, including computer hardware, software, and communications equipment, we could experience a service interruption, a security breach, or other operational difficulties. We also face cybersecurity threats which may result in breaches of systems, or compromises of sensitive data, which may also result in service interruptions, safety failures, or operational difficulties. Such a breach, or compromise, could decrease revenues, increase operating costs, including those to protect our infrastructure, impact our efficiency, or damage our corporate reputation. Additionally, if we do not have sufficient capital to acquire new technology or we are unable to implement new technology, we may suffer a competitive disadvantage within the rail industry and with companies providing alternative modes of transportation service.

The state of capital markets could adversely affect our liquidity. We rely on the capital markets to provide some of our capital requirements, including the issuance of debt instruments and the sale of certain receivables. Significant instability or disruptions of the capital markets, including the credit markets, or deterioration of our financial position due to internal or external factors could restrict or eliminate our access to, and/or significantly increase the cost of, various financing sources, including bank credit facilities and issuance of corporate bonds. Instability or disruptions of the capital markets and deterioration of our financial position, alone or in combination, could also result in a reduction of our credit rating to below investment grade, which could prohibit or restrict us from accessing external sources of short- and long-term debt financing and/or significantly increase the associated costs.

Item 1B. Unresolved Staff Comments
 
None.

Item 1C. Cybersecurity

CYBERSECURITY RISK MANAGEMENT AND STRATEGY

Process

We use a multi-layered defensive cybersecurity strategy based on the cyber security framework drafted by the NIST. The NIST CSF is a voluntary framework of best practices to identify, protect, detect, respond to, and recover from cybersecurity matters. Based on the NIST CSF, our processes to identify, assess, and manage material risks from cybersecurity threats includes the following:

Identify
We identify risks from cybersecurity threats by first developing and maintaining an understanding of those assets essential to our operation and reputation, as well as assets that could provide value to threat actors. Any cyber act is considered a potential risk if a threat actor can use it to reduce the value of an asset, reduce our ability to utilize or otherwise access the value of an asset, or surreptitiously gain or increase their access to an asset or its value.

Assess
We assess risks from cybersecurity threats by evaluating exposure of our assets to identified cyber risks, as well as potential impacts to our operations or reputation from our inability to access or utilize an asset or realize its value, or a threat actor’s ability to gain access to an asset or its value. We further evaluate the potential materiality of these risks based on the potential impact to our operations or reputation.

Manage
We mitigate risks from cybersecurity threats by applying multiple layers of defense to ensure we have the continued ability to access or utilize an asset or its value, and deny threat actors the ability to gain or increase their access to an asset or its value. We prioritize defensive mechanisms, including administrative,
K14
K17


procedural, and technical controls, according to their relative cost and reduction in risk based on the NIST CSF.

We further monitor, test, assess, and update these processes, including working with government agencies and peers to implement practices to guard against an evolving threat environment and to ensure we remain compliant with relevant regulatory requirements.

Integration into our Risk Management Framework

Our processes to assess, identify, and manage cybersecurity risks are expressly incorporated into our enterprise risk management (ERM) framework, which includes technology as one of the five primary risk categories addressed by the ERM framework, with cybersecurity risks being one of the three subcategories within the technology risk category. As a result, our ERM leadership team works with the Chief Information Officer (CIO) and Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) to define the top areas of risk in both the technology and cybersecurity areas, with such risks incorporated into our ERM framework and mapped to the NIST CSF. Our internal ERM leadership also meets on a quarterly basis with our technology risk working group, comprised of leaders across the information technology, information security and law departments, to monitor developments in the threat landscape so that key cybersecurity threats impacting the Company continue to be identified and prioritized.

Third-Party Engagement

We employ multiple service providers from time to time to perform periodic reviews and evaluations of our cybersecurity framework, the results of which are provided to and reviewed with management, with appropriate reporting to the Finance and Risk Management Committee (F&RM Committee) of the Board. These reviews encompass a broad range of areas, including information technology system resilience, cybersecurity risk assessments, information security program assessments, external threat environment reviews, internal cybersecurity policy compliance, and near-term incident response to identify or disconfirm potential involvement of a threat actor.

Oversight of Third-Party Providers

Within our purchasing and third-party vendor management programs, we require all vendors who handle our data as well as vendors who provide technology and data services – including hardware, software, staffing, and support – to maintain certain security protections including, but not limited to, compliance with applicable data protection laws, and implementation of administrative, physical and technical safeguards to protect our data, including how our data is stored, accessed and transmitted. In addition, all providers within these service categories must sign our data security attachment that articulates the specific security standards, cybersecurity insurance, and mandatory incident reporting protocols applicable to the underlying provision of services.

Risks

Please see Item 1A. Risk Factors – Operational Risks – “A significant cybersecurity incident or other disruption to our technology infrastructure could disrupt our business operations” for our disclosures regarding the most pertinent risks we may experience from cybersecurity threats.

As noted therein, regardless of the cause, a significant disruption or failure of one or more information or operational technology systems operated by us or under control of third parties can result in service disruptions, unauthorized access to our systems, viruses, ransomware, and/or compromise, acquisition, or destruction of our data.

Such a direct or indirect cybersecurity incident could interrupt our service, cause safety failures or operational difficulties, decrease revenues, increase operating costs, impact our efficiency, damage our corporate reputation, and/or expose us to litigation, government action, increased regulation, penalties, fines or judgments, any or all
K18


which may ultimately have a materially adverse effect on our results of operations, financial condition, reputation, and business (including our strategy of operating a resilient freight railroad).

While we have previously experienced technology outages and cybersecurity events that have impacted our systems and service, future events may result in more significant impacts to our operations, reputation or financial results. As a result of these prior events, and given the potential risks that a technology outage or cybersecurity event would result in a materially adverse effect on our results of operations, financial condition, reputation, or business, we have conducted and will continue conducting, internal and third-party assessments of information technology and cybersecurity vulnerabilities, information technology resiliency, and our related processes and procedures, so that we can continue to identify and address key cybersecurity risks.

CYBERSECURITY GOVERNANCE

Board Oversight

The Norfolk Southern Board, through the F&RM Committee, has direct oversight of cybersecurity risks. The F&RM Committee receives periodic reports from the CIO and CISO regarding the primary technology risks impacting the company, including risks impacting our information and operational systems, service resiliency, cybersecurity risks, and the related threat environment. Agendas for these periodic updates may be further adjusted to address any emerging risks or key topics in greater detail, including emerging regulations, best practices, cyber readiness, and third-party assessment results. Regular updates are also provided to the F&RM Committee regarding all material or potentially material cybersecurity incidents, including root causes, and identification of and progress towards, remediation activities through completion.

The Board receives a periodic update from the Chair of the F&RM Committee regarding the matters addressed by the F&RM Committee, as well as an annual report from the CISO highlighting the emerging threat landscape, our progress executing on our defensive cybersecurity strategy, and a review of our cybersecurity incident investigation and response processes.

Management's Role

The CISO, reporting to the CIO, is directly responsible for the assessment, oversight, and management of our enterprise-wide cybersecurity strategy and governance. Our CISO has significant relevant experience in the area, including graduate and postgraduate engineering technology degrees, along with 20 years of information security experience in critical infrastructure, as well as seven years with Norfolk Southern where he guided the Company through the implementation of our multi-layered defensive cybersecurity strategy that aligns with the NIST CSF. As noted above, our technology risk working group, comprised of leaders across the information technology, information security and law departments, including our CIO, CISO and Data Privacy Officer (DPO), among others, further monitor developments in the threat landscape so that key cybersecurity threats impacting the Company continue to be identified and prioritized.

Management and Board Reporting

Cybersecurity incidents are reported directly to the CISO in accordance with the applicable incident response plan. The CISO, together with the DPO, determine incident severity and response, and in turn report material or potentially material incidents to our internal 8-K subcommittee (comprised of senior leaders from the law, accounting, finance, investor relations, and communications departments), our CEO, and our Executive Vice President Corporate Affairs and Chief Legal Officer, who in turn notify the Chairs of the Board and the F&RM Committee. The Board is promptly notified prior to filing any 8-K disclosing any material or potentially material cybersecurity incidents, with the F&RM Committee provided further updates regarding root causes and remediation efforts.

K19


We also have a cybersecurity incident response plan including specific responsive protocols administered by a predesignated incident response team, led by our CISO and DPO and comprised of other members of management. This incident response team also conducts periodic table-top exercises with management to ensure adherence to our cybersecurity incident response plan.

In an effort to deter and detect cyber threats, we also periodically provide all employees with a data protection and cybersecurity awareness training program, which covers timely and relevant topics, including phishing, password protection, confidential data protection, asset use and mobile security, and further educates employees on the importance of and process for reporting all potential incidents immediately. We also use technology-based tools to mitigate cybersecurity risks and to bolster employee-based cybersecurity programs.

Item 3. Legal Proceedings
 
In 2007, various antitrust class actions filed against us and other Class I railroads in various Federal district courts regarding fuel surcharges were consolidated in the District of Columbia by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation. In 2012, the court certified the case as a class action. The defendant railroads appealed this certification, and the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia vacated the District Court’s decision and remanded the case for further consideration. On October 10, 2017, the District Court denied class certification. The decision was upheld by the Court of Appeals on August 16, 2019. Since that decision, various individual cases have been filed in multiple jurisdictions and also consolidated in the District of Columbia. We believe the allegations in the complaints are without merit and intend to vigorously defend the cases. We do not believe the outcome of these proceedings will have a material effectFor information on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity.

In 2018, a lawsuit was filed against one of our subsidiaries by the minority ownerlegal proceedings, see Note 17 “Commitments and Contingencies” in a jointly-owned terminal
railroad company in which our subsidiary has the majority ownership. The lawsuit alleged violations of various
state laws and federal antitrust laws. It is reasonably possible that we could incur a loss in the case; however, we
intendItem 8 “Notes to vigorously defend the case and believe that we will prevail. The potential range of loss cannot be
estimated at this time.Consolidated Financial Statements.”

Item 4. Mine Safety Disclosures
 
Not applicable.

K15K20


Information About Our Executive Officers
 
Our executive officers generally are elected and designated annually by the Board of Directors (Board) at its first meeting held after the annual meeting of stockholders, and they hold office until their successors are elected. Executive officers also may be elected and designated throughout the year as the Board considers appropriate. There are no family relationships among our officers, nor any arrangement or understanding between any officer and any other person pursuant to which the officer was selected. The following table sets forth certain information, at February 1, 2021,2024, relating to our officers.
Name, Age, Present PositionBusiness Experience During Past Five Years
  
James A. Squires, 59,Alan H. Shaw, 56,
Chairman, President and
Chief Executive Officer
Present position since OctoberMay 1, 2015.2022.
Served as President from December 1, 2021 to May 1, 2022. Served as Executive Vice President and Chief Marketing Officer from May 16, 2015 to December 1, 2021.
  
Ann A. Adams, 50,53,
Executive Vice President and
Chief Transformation Officer
Present position since April 1, 2019.
Served as Vice President Human Resources from April 1, 2016 to April 1, 2019. Served as Assistant Vice President Human Resources from July 1, 2012 to April 1, 2016.
Vanessa Allen Sutherland, 49,Paul B. Duncan, 44,
Executive Vice President and
Chief LegalOperating Officer
Present position since AprilJanuary 1, 2020.2023.
Served as Senior Vice President Government RelationsTransportation and Chief Legal OfficerNetwork Operations from August 16, 2019September 1, 2022 to AprilJanuary 1, 2020. Served as Senior Vice President Law and Chief Legal Officer from April 1, 2019 to August 16, 2019.2023. Served as Vice President LawNetwork Planning and Operations from June 25, 2018March 1, 2022 to AprilSeptember 1, 2019.2022. Prior to joining Norfolk Southern, served as ChairmanVice President of the U.S. Chemical SafetyService Design and Hazard Investigation BoardPerformance for BNSF Railway from August 2015October 1, 2018 to June 2018.March 1, 2022.
Claude E. Elkins, Jr., 58,
Executive Vice President and
Chief Marketing Officer
Present position since December 1, 2021.
Served as Vice President Industrial Products from April 1, 2018 to December 1, 2021.
Mark R. George, 53,56,
Executive Vice President Finance and
Chief Financial Officer
Present position since November 1, 2019.
Prior to joining Norfolk Southern, served as Vice President, Finance and Chief Financial Officer at segments of United Technologies Corporation. The positions were Vice President Finance, Strategy, IT and Chief Financial Officer at Otis Elevator Company from October 2015 to May 2019, and Vice President Finance and Chief Financial Officer at Carrier Corporation from June 2019 until joining Norfolk Southern.
 
Cynthia M. Sanborn, 56,
Nabanita C. Nag, 48,
  
Executive Vice President and

  
Chief OperatingLegal Officer
Present position since SeptemberJuly 1, 2020.2022.
Served as Senior Vice President and Chief Legal Officer from March 1, 2022 to July 1, 2022. Served as General Counsel - Corporate from August 31, 2020 to March 1, 2022. Prior to joining Norfolk Southern, served as served as Vice President Network Planning & Operations at Union Pacific from May 2019 to September 2020 and as Regional Vice President – Western Region from February 2018 to May 2019. Previously served as Executive Vice President and Chief Operating OfficerCorporate Counsel in the Financial Management Law Group at CSXPrudential Financial from September 2015March 3, 2014 to November 2017.August 1, 2020.
Alan H. Shaw, 53,
Executive Vice President and
Chief Marketing Officer
Present position since May 16, 2015.
Clyde H. Allison, Jr., 57,Claiborne L. Moore, 44,
Vice President and Controller
Present position since JuneMarch 1, 2020.2022.
Served as Assistant Vice President and TreasurerCorporate Accounting from FebruaryMarch 15, 2019 to March 1, 2022. Served as Director Investor Relations from July 1, 2017 to June 1, 2020. Served as Vice President Internal Audit from November 1, 2013 to February 1, 2017.March 15, 2019.

K16K21


PART II
 
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

Item 5. Market for Registrant’s Common Equity, Related Stockholder Matters and Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities
STOCK INFORMATION
 
Common Stock is owned by 21,82518,962 stockholders of record as of December 31, 2020,2023, and is traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol “NSC.”
 
ISSUER PURCHASES OF EQUITY SECURITIES
Period
Total Number
of Shares
(or Units)
Purchased(1)
Average
Price Paid
per Share
(or Unit)
Total
Number of
Shares (or Units)
Purchased as
Part of Publicly
Announced Plans
or Programs(2)
Maximum Number
(or Approximate
Dollar Value)
of Shares (or Units)
that may yet be
Purchased under
the Plans or Programs(2)
October 1-31, 2020327,383 $213.70 327,383 22,425,507 
November 1-30, 2020793,494 235.37 793,022 21,632,485 
December 1-31, 2020943,868 235.65 943,713 20,688,772 
Total2,064,745   2,064,118   

Period
Total Number
of Shares
(or Units)
Purchased(1)
Average
Price Paid
per Share
(or Unit)
Total
Number of
Shares (or Units)
Purchased as
Part of the Publicly
Announced Plans
or Programs(2)
Approximate
Dollar Value
of Shares that may yet be
Purchased under the Publicly Announced
Plans or Programs(2)
October 1-31, 2023270,465 $197.70 269,938 $6,933,309,430 
November 1-30, 2023159,957 202.48 156,646 6,901,566,364 
December 1-31, 2023145,664 229.80 145,398 6,868,152,575 
Total576,086   571,982   
 
(1)Of this amount, 627 represents4,104 represent shares tendered by employees in connection with the exercise of stock options under the stockholder-approved Long-Term Incentive Plan (LTIP).
(2)On September 26, 2017,March 29, 2022, our Board of Directors authorized a new program for the repurchase of up to an additional 50 million shares$10.0 billion of Common Stock through December 31,beginning April 1, 2022. As of December 31, 2020, 20.7 million shares remain2023, $6.9 billion remains authorized for repurchase.repurchase, until such amount is exhausted.

Item 6. [Reserved]
K17K22


Item 6. Selected Financial Data
FIVE-YEAR FINANCIAL REVIEW
 20202019201820172016
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)
RESULTS OF OPERATIONS     
Railway operating revenues$9,789 $11,296 $11,458 $10,551 $9,888 
Railway operating expenses6,787 7,307 7,499 7,029 6,879 
Income from railway operations3,002 3,989 3,959 3,522 3,009 
Other income – net153 106 67 156 136 
Interest expense on debt625 604 557 550 563 
Income before income taxes2,530 3,491 3,469 3,128 2,582 
Income taxes517 769 803 (2,276)914 
Net income$2,013 $2,722 $2,666 $5,404 $1,668 
PER SHARE DATA     
Basic earnings per share$7.88 $10.32 $9.58 $18.76 $5.66 
Diluted earnings per share7.84 10.25 9.51 18.61 5.62 
Dividends3.76 3.60 3.04 2.44 2.36 
Stockholders’ equity at year-end58.67 58.87 57.30 57.57 42.73 
FINANCIAL POSITION     
Total assets$37,962 $37,923 $36,239 $35,711 $34,892 
Total debt12,681 12,196 11,145 9,836 10,212 
Stockholders’ equity14,791 15,184 15,362 16,359 12,409 
OTHER     
Property additions$1,494 $2,019 $1,951 $1,723 $1,887 
Average number of shares outstanding (thousands)255,117 263,270 277,708 287,861 293,943 
Number of stockholders at year-end21,825 23,273 24,475 25,737 27,288 
Average number of employees: 
Rail20,029 24,442 26,512 26,955 27,856 
Nonrail127 145 150 155 188 
Total20,156 24,587 26,662 27,110 28,044 

Note 1:  In 2017, as a result of the enactment of tax reform, “Railway operating expenses” included a $151 million benefit and “Income taxes” included a $3,331 million benefit, which added $3,482 million to “Net income” and $12.00 to “Diluted earnings per share.”
Note 2: On January 1, 2019, we adopted Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2016-02, “Leases (Topic 842),” which requires lessees to recognize right-of-use (ROU) assets and lease liabilities on the balance sheet for leases greater than twelve months. As a result of the adoption, the Consolidated Balance Sheets include the recognition of ROU assets of $433 million and $539 million at December 31, 2020 and 2019, respectively, and corresponding lease liabilities of $433 million and $538 million, respectively.


See accompanying consolidated financial statements and notes thereto.
K18


Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
 
Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
 
The following discussion and analysis should be read in conjunction with the Consolidated Financial Statements and Notes. Refer to Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements” for all “Note” references.
 
OVERVIEW
 
We are one of the nation’s premier transportation companies.companies, moving goods and materials that help drive the U.S. economy. We connect customers to markets and communities to economic opportunity with safe, reliable, and cost-effective shipping solutions. Our Norfolk Southern Railway Company subsidiary operates approximately 19,300 route miles in 22 states and the District of Columbia, serves every major container port in the eastern U.S., and provides efficient connections to other rail carriers.Columbia. We are a major transporter of industrial products, including agriculture, forest and consumer products, chemicals, and metals and construction materials. In addition, in the East we serve every major container port and operate the most extensive intermodal network in the East andnetwork. We are also a principal carrier of coal, automobiles, and automotive parts.

In 2020, we continued the implementation of our strategic plan, including tactical changes to our operating plan, to generate operational efficiencies, improve customer service, and deliver strongOur 2023 financial results. The COVID-19 pandemic caused significant economic disruption and, along with softening energy markets, reduced the demand for our services. Nevertheless, we executed on operational initiatives to generate efficiencies and lower our cost structure. In the face of economic headwinds that resulted in a year-over-year volume decline of 12%, we improved productivity by driving year-over-year average headcount down by 18%, and we increased asset utilization through rationalization of our locomotive fleet. These sustainable cost structure improvements will provide greater benefits as the economy recovers. However, there is still substantial uncertainty as to the pace of economic recovery and the continued effects of the pandemic on our results of operations. We continue to monitor the impact of the pandemic on our employees’ availability and remain committed to protecting our employees and providing excellent transportation service products for our customers.

SUMMARIZED RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)(% change)
Income from railway operations$3,002 $3,989 $3,959 (25 %)%
Net income$2,013 $2,722 $2,666 (26 %)%
Diluted earnings per share$7.84 $10.25 $9.51 (24 %)%
Railway operating ratio (percent)69.3 64.7 65.4 %(1 %)

Income from railway operations declined in 2020 compared to 2019 as railway operating revenues fell 13% which exceeded a 7% reduction in operating expenses. Railway operating revenues declined as lower customer demand resulted in volume reductions. Additionally, negative mix and lower fuel surcharge revenue, partially offset by increased pricing, led to lower revenue per unit. Railway operating expenses decreased due to declines in fuel price and consumption, reduced employment levels, lower volumes and operational efficiency improvements. Additionally, 2020 results were adversely impacted by a lossFebruary 2023 derailment in Eastern Ohio. The derailment of 38 railcars resulted in the release of certain chemicals that were being transported for our customers. Following the Incident (as defined and as further described in Note 17) and throughout the remainder of the year, we have worked to clean the derailment site safely and thoroughly and to monitor for any impact on asset disposalpublic health and the environment. As a result of $385 millionthe Incident, we incurred $1.1 billion of expenses primarily related to locomotives sold,our environmental cleanup and byremediation efforts at and around the site, related legal proceedings, and other Incident-related costs. As a $99 million impairment charge related to an equity method investment. For more information on the impact of these charges, see Notes 7 and 6, respectively.

Income from railway operations rose in 2019 compared to 2018 as a 3% reduction in railway operating expenses more than offset the impact of a 1% decline in railway operating revenues. In addition to higherresult, income from railway operations, net income, and diluted earnings per share growthdeclined compared to 2022, most significantly as a result of the direct costs from the Incident. Our financial results were further impacted by lower revenues and higher non-Incident-related operating expenses.

SUMMARIZED RESULTS OF OPERATIONS
20232022
202320222021vs. 2022vs. 2021
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)(% change)
Income from railway operations$2,851 $4,809 $4,447 (41 %)%
Net income$1,827 $3,270 $3,005 (44 %)%
Diluted earnings per share$8.02 $13.88 $12.11 (42 %)15 %
Railway operating ratio (percent)76.5 62.3 60.1 23 %%

Income from railway operations, net income and diluted earnings per share declined in 20192023 compared to 2022, driven by expenses incurred with our response efforts to the Incident (Note 17), lower railway operating revenues, and higher non-Incident-related railway operating expenses. Railway operating revenues declined 5% due to lower average revenue per unit, the result of lower fuel surcharge revenue and decreased intermodal storage service revenues partially offset by favorable pricing and mix. Additionally, lower volumes contributed to the decline in revenues. Expenses associated with the Incident for the year were $1.1 billion. In addition to costs resulting from the Incident, railway operating expenses increased due to inflationary pressures, investments in operational resiliency, and higher service-related costs, offset partially by lower fuel prices. The decline in net income and diluted earnings per share also benefited fromreflects the absence of a lower effectiveprior year $136 million deferred tax benefit, a result of an enactment of a change in the corporate income tax rate in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in 2022. Railway operating ratio (a measure of the amount of operating revenues consumed by operating expenses) deteriorated to 76.5 percent.

K19K23


tax rate. Our continuing share repurchase program contributedIncome from railway operations increased in 2022 compared to 2021, driven by higher railway operating revenues. Revenue growth was the result of higher fuel surcharge revenues and pricing gains, which more than offset the impact of volume declines. The rise in revenues was partly offset by increased railway operating expenses, driven by higher fuel prices, other inflationary pressures, service-related costs, increased labor-related costs primarily resulting from labor union negotiations, and higher claims-related expenses. Incremental expenses incurred in 2022 that resulted from finalized labor agreements for wages earned in 2021 and prior periods lowered diluted earnings per share growthby $0.18. Additionally, net income included a $136 million deferred tax benefit resulting from a state corporate income tax rate change, which increased diluted earnings per share by $0.58. Our share repurchase activity resulted in the percentage increase in diluted earnings per share that exceeded that of net income. Railway operating ratio deteriorated to 62.3 percent.

The following tables adjusttable adjusts our 20202023 U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (“GAAP”)(GAAP) financial results to exclude the effects of the aforementioned charges.Incident. The income tax effects on theof this non-GAAP adjustmentsadjustment were calculated based on the applicable tax rates to which the non-GAAP adjustments relate.adjustment related. We use these non-GAAP financial measures internally and believe this information provides useful supplemental information to investors to facilitate making period-to-period comparisons by excluding the 2020 charges.2023 costs arising from the Incident. While we believe that these non-GAAP financial measures are useful in evaluating our business, this information should be considered as supplemental in nature and is not meant to be considered in isolation from, or as a substitute for, the related financial information prepared in accordance with GAAP. In addition, these non-GAAP financial measures may not be the same as similar measures presented by other companies.

Non-GAAP Reconciliation for 2023
Non-GAAP Reconciliation for 2023
Non-GAAP Reconciliation for 2023
Reported
(GAAP)
Reported
(GAAP)
Eastern Ohio IncidentAdjusted
(non-GAAP)
($ in millions, except per share amounts)($ in millions, except per share amounts)
Non-GAAP Reconciliation for 2020
Income from railway operations
Reported 2020 (GAAP)Loss on Asset DisposalInvestment ImpairmentAdjusted 2020
(non-GAAP)
Income from railway operations
($ in millions, except per share amounts)
Income from railway operations
Railway operating expenses$6,787 $(385)$(99)$6,303 
Income from railway operations$3,002 $385 $99 $3,486 
Income before income taxes$2,530 $385 $99 $3,014 
Income taxes
Income taxes
Income taxesIncome taxes$517 $97 $25 $639 
Net incomeNet income$2,013 $288 $74 $2,375 
Diluted earnings per shareDiluted earnings per share$7.84 $1.12 $0.29 $9.25 
Railway operating ratio (percent)Railway operating ratio (percent)69.3 (3.9)(1.0)64.4 
K24



In the table below, references to 20202023 results and related comparisons use the adjusted, non-GAAP results from the reconciliation in the table above.

Adjusted
2023
2023
2023
Adjusted
Adjusted
Adjusted(non-GAAP)2022
20232023vs.vs.
(non-GAAP)(non-GAAP)2022202120222021
($ in millions, except per share amounts)(% change)
Adjusted
Adjusted2020
Income from railway operations
Income from railway operations
Income from railway operations$3,967 $4,809 $4,447 (18 %)%
2020(non-GAAP)2019
(non-GAAP)20192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
Net income
($ in millions, except per share amounts)(% change)
Net income
Railway operating expenses$6,303 $7,307 $7,499 (14 %)(3 %)
Income from railway operations$3,486 $3,989 $3,959 (13 %)%
Income before income taxes$3,014 $3,491 $3,469 (14 %)%
Income taxes$639 $769 $803 (17 %)(4 %)
Net incomeNet income$2,375 $2,722 $2,666 (13 %)%$2,673 $$3,270 $$3,005 (18 (18 %)%
Diluted earnings per shareDiluted earnings per share$9.25 $10.25 $9.51 (10 %)%Diluted earnings per share$11.74 $$13.88 $$12.11 (15 (15 %)15 %
Railway operating ratio (percent)Railway operating ratio (percent)64.4 64.7 65.4 — %(1 %)Railway operating ratio (percent)67.4 62.3 62.3 60.1 60.1 %%



On a non-GAAP basis excluding the impact of direct costs resulting from the Incident, income from railway operations decreased in 2023 due to lower railway operating revenues and higher railway operating expenses. Railway operating revenues declined due to decreased fuel surcharge revenue, decreased intermodal storage revenues, and lower volume, partially offset by increased pricing and favorable mix compared to the prior year. Railway operating expenses increased due to inflationary pressures, investments in operational resiliency, and higher service-related costs, partially offset by lower fuel prices.

K20K25


DETAILED RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

Railway Operating Revenues

The following tables present a three-year comparison of revenues, volumes (units), and average revenue per unit by major commodity group.
Revenues20232022
202320222021vs. 2022vs. 2021
($ in millions)(% change)
Merchandise:
Agriculture, forest and consumer
    products
$2,530 $2,493 $2,251 %11 %
Chemicals2,054 2,148 1,951 (4 %)10 %
Metals and construction1,634 1,652 1,562 (1 %)%
Automotive1,135 1,038 905 %15 %
     Merchandise7,353 7,331 6,669 — %10 %
Intermodal3,090 3,681 3,163 (16 %)16 %
Coal1,713 1,733 1,310 (1 %)32 %
 Total$12,156 $12,745 $11,142 (5 %)14 %
Revenues20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
($ in millions)(% change)
Units
Units
Units
2023
2023
2023
(in thousands)
(in thousands)
(in thousands)
Merchandise:
Merchandise:
Merchandise:Merchandise:
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
$2,116 $2,256 $2,188 (6 %)%
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
Chemicals
Chemicals
ChemicalsChemicals1,809 2,092 2,083 (14 %)— %
Metals and constructionMetals and construction1,333 1,461 1,482 (9 %)(1 %)
Metals and construction
Metals and construction
Automotive
Automotive
AutomotiveAutomotive830 994 991 (16 %)— %
Merchandise Merchandise6,088 6,803 6,744 (11 %)%
Merchandise
Merchandise
Intermodal
Intermodal
IntermodalIntermodal2,654 2,824 2,893 (6 %)(2 %)
CoalCoal1,047 1,669 1,821 (37 %)(8 %)
Coal
Coal
Total Total$9,789 $11,296 $11,458 (13 %)(1 %)
Total
Total

Units20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
(in thousands)(% change)
Merchandise:
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
704.4 763.7 790.7 (8 %)(3 %)
Chemicals482.0 588.9 604.7 (18 %)(3 %)
Metals and construction601.2 685.1 719.8 (12 %)(5 %)
Automotive329.7 394.7 403.9 (16 %)(2 %)
     Merchandise2,117.3 2,432.4 2,519.1 (13 %)(3 %)
Intermodal3,992.1 4,207.2 4,375.7 (5 %)(4 %)
Coal574.1 914.0 1,033.5 (37 %)(12 %)
Total6,683.5 7,553.6 7,928.3 (12 %)(5 %)

Revenue per Unit20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
($ per unit)(% change)
Revenue per Unit
Revenue per Unit
Revenue per Unit
2023
2023
2023
($ per unit)
($ per unit)
($ per unit)
Merchandise:
Merchandise:
Merchandise:Merchandise:
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
$3,004 $2,953 $2,767 %%
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
Agriculture, forest and consumer
products
Chemicals
Chemicals
ChemicalsChemicals3,753 3,553 3,444 %%
Metals and constructionMetals and construction2,216 2,133 2,059 %%
Metals and construction
Metals and construction
Automotive
Automotive
AutomotiveAutomotive2,518 2,517 2,453 — %%
Merchandise Merchandise2,875 2,797 2,677 %%
Merchandise
Merchandise
Intermodal
Intermodal
IntermodalIntermodal665 671 661 (1 %)%
CoalCoal1,824 1,826 1,762 — %%
Coal
Coal
Total Total1,465 1,495 1,445 (2 %)%
Total
Total

K21K26


At the beginning of 2020, we combined the agriculture products and forest and consumer commodity groups. In addition, we also made changes in the categorization of certain other commodity groups within Merchandise. Prior period railway operating revenues, units, and revenue per unit have been reclassified to conform to the current presentation (see Note 2).

Revenues decreased $1.5$589 million in 2023 but increased $1.6 billion in 2020 and $162 million in 20192022 compared to the prior years. As reflectedRevenues declined in the table below,2023 as a result of lower average revenue per unit, driven by decreases in fuel surcharge revenue and intermodal storage revenues, and volume declines. Higher revenue for both years were2022 was the result of decreased volumes and lowerincreased average revenue per unit, driven by higher fuel surcharge revenue, pricing gains, improved mix, and increased intermodal storage service charges, partially offset by pricing gains.volume declines.

The table below reflects the components of the revenue change by major commodity group.

2023 vs. 2022 2023 vs. 20222022 vs. 2021
Increase (Decrease)Increase (Decrease)
($ in millions)($ in millions)
MerchandiseMerchandiseIntermodalCoalMerchandiseIntermodalCoal
 2020 vs. 20192019 vs. 2018
Increase (Decrease)Increase (Decrease)
($ in millions)
MerchandiseIntermodalCoalMerchandiseIntermodalCoal
Volume
Volume
VolumeVolume$(881)$(144)$(621)$(232)$(111)$(210)
Fuel surchargeFuel surcharge
revenuerevenue(92)(124)(13)(14)(30)(35)
revenue
revenue
Rate, mix andRate, mix and
other
other
otherother258 98 12 305 72 93 
TotalTotal$(715)$(170)$(622)$59 $(69)$(152)
Total
Total
 
Approximately 90%95% of our revenue base is covered by contracts that include negotiated fuel surcharges. TheseFuel surcharge revenues totaled $349 million, $578 million,$1.2 billion, $1.6 billion, and $657$622 million in 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018,2021, respectively. The change in fuel surcharge revenues in each period was primarily driven by fluctuations in fuel commodity prices.

For 2024, we expect that revenue will increase modestly driven by higher volumes.

MERCHANDISE revenues decreased in 2020 but increased in 2019both 2023 and 2022 compared with the prior years. In 2020,2023, revenues decreased due towere slightly higher as pricing and volume declinesgains were nearly offset by lower fuel surcharge revenue and unfavorable mix. Increased volumes in all commodity groups whichautomotive and agriculture, forest and consumer shipments were partially offset by decreased chemicals shipments. In 2022, revenues rose due to higher average revenue per unit, driven by higher fuel surcharge revenue and increased pricing, partially offset by lower volume. Decreased volumes in metal and construction and automotive shipments more than offset higher chemical shipments.

Agriculture, forest and consumer products revenues increased in both 2023 and 2022 compared with the prior years. In 2023, the rise was the result of increased volume. Average revenue per unit was flat, the result of lower fuel surcharge revenue offset by pricing gains. Increases in ethanol and fertilizer shipments more than offset declines in shipments of wood chips and graphic paper. Increased market demand led to volume gains in ethanol and fertilizer. Volume declines in wood chips were due to customer mill closures, while lower market demand led to the decline in graphic paper. In 2019, 2022, the rise was the result of increased average revenue per unit, the result of higher fuel surcharge revenue and pricing gains, while volumes were nearly flat. Declines in pulpboard, fertilizer, and pulp, were offset by increases in soybeans, feed, and corn. Pulpboard and pulp shipments declined due to decreased demand, equipment availability, service disruptions, and production down time. Lower fertilizer shipments were driven by high fertilizer prices causing customers to draw down on existing inventories or delay purchases as well as production disruptions. Soybean volumes were higher due to increased opportunity for exports. Feed shipments were higher due to increased customer demand. Increased corn shipments were due to improved equipment cycle times.

Chemicals revenues grewdecreased in 2023 but increased in 2022 compared with the prior years. In 2023, the decrease was as a result of volume declines. Reduced shipments of crude oil, organic chemicals, and natural gas liquids, more than offset the increases in solid waste and other petroleum products. Volume declines for crude oil were driven by soft demand in the energy markets. Organic chemicals and natural gas liquids volume declined as a result
K27


of lower demand. Volume gains in solid waste were due to growth with existing customers, while the gains in petroleum products were due to growth with existing customers and new business opportunities. In 2022, the increase was the result of higher average revenue per unit, driven by fuel surcharge revenue and pricing gains, and volume growth. Increases in sand and solid waste shipments were partially offset by declines in plastics, inorganic chemicals, organic chemicals, and natural gas liquids. The increase in sand was due to greater demand resulting from sustained high natural gas prices. Solid waste shipments increased due to growth with existing customers. Plastics shipments decreased due to softening of the housing market. Declines in inorganic chemicals, organic chemicals, and natural gas liquids shipments were due to decreased demand and reduced production.

Metals and construction revenues were lower in 2023 but higher in 2022 compared with the prior years. In 2023, the decline in revenue was driven by lower average revenue per unit, the result of decreased fuel surcharge revenue partially offset by increased price. Volumes were nearly unchanged as reduced shipments of kaolin and construction materials were offset by volume gains in coil steel and scrap metal. The volume declines in kaolin were largely driven by lower demand, while the declines in construction materials were due to lower demand, extended cycle times and service challenges. Gains in coil steel volume were due to increased equipment available to handle demand, while scrap metal volume increased due to higher demand. In 2022, revenue growth was driven by higher average revenue per unit, the result of higher fuel surcharge revenue and pricing gains, partially offset by lower volume. Volumes fell largely as a result of decreased shipments of coil steel, iron and steel, and scrap metal driven by service disruptions and slower equipment cycle times.

Automotive revenues rose in both 2023 and 2022 compared with the prior years. The increase in revenues in 2023 was driven by increased volume and higher average revenue per unit, driven by favorable price. Volume increases were due to higher finished vehicle inventory levels available for rail transportation and improved equipment cycle times. The increase in revenues in 2022 was driven by higher average revenue per unit, due to higher fuel surcharge revenue and pricing gains, partially offset by volume declines. Volume declines were the result of slower equipment cycle times partially offset by fewer parts supply issues due to easing supply chain congestion when compared to the prior year.

INTERMODAL revenues decreased in 2023 but increased in 2022 compared with the prior years. The decrease in 2023 was the result of lower average revenue per unit, driven by reduced storage service charges and lower fuel surcharge revenue, and decreased volume. The increase in 2022 was the result of higher average revenue per unit, due to higher fuel surcharge revenue, pricing gains, and increased storage service charges, partially offset by decreased volume.

Intermodal units by market were as follows:
20232022
202320222021vs. 2022vs. 2021
 (units in thousands)(% change)
Domestic2,371.6 2,573.6 2,630.6 (8 %)(2 %)
International1,450.8 1,339.5 1,473.5 %(9 %)
Total3,822.4 3,913.1 4,104.1 (2 %)(5 %)

Domestic volume decreased in both 2023 and 2022 compared with the prior years. In 2023, volume declined due to a decrease in freight demand as a result of reduced consumer consumption combined with high inventories, and increased truck competition. In 2022, volume declined due to service disruptions, terminal congestion, strong over-the-road competition, and increased truck availability.

International volume increased in 2023 but decreased in 2022. The increase in 2023 was driven by ocean carriers favoring inland point intermodal traffic, partially offset by a decrease in imports. The decline in 2022 was the result of supply chain constraints, chassis shortages, and excess retail inventory.
K28



COAL revenues decreased in 2023 but increased in 2022 compared with the prior years. The decrease in 2023 was a result of decreased volumes. Average revenue per unit was flat as lower fuel surcharge revenue and pricing declines were offset by positive mix. The increase in 2022 was due to higher average revenue per unit, driven by pricing gains which were partially offset by volume declines in all commodity groups.

For 2021, merchandise revenues are expected to increase, the result of higher volume as the market continues to recover from the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and increased revenue per unit driven by pricing gains.

Agriculture, forest and consumer products revenues decreased in 2020 but increased in 2019 compared with the prior years. In 2020, the decline was the result of reduced volume partially offset by higher average revenue per unit, driven by pricing gains partially offset by lower fuel surcharge revenue. Volume declined due to the impact of COVID-19 on the demand for ethanol, corn, food service products, and building, industrial and commercial products. Revenue growth in 2019 was due to higher average revenue per unit, a result of pricing gains, which more than offset volume declines. Volume was down due to decreased shipments of ethanol, pulpboard, lumber, soybeans, pulp, woodchips, canned goods, and fertilizer, partially offset by increased corn shipments.

In 2021, agriculture, forest and consumer products revenues are expected to rise, a result of increased volume as the economic recovery continues, and revenue per unit increases resulting from pricing gains. We expect volumes to increase in most markets led by ethanol, corn, pulpboard, and food services.

Chemicals revenues fell in 2020 but rose slightly in 2019 compared with the prior years. In 2020, the decrease was the result of volume declines partially offset by higher average revenue per unit, due to pricing gains. Volume declined due to the impact from COVID-19 and ongoing disruptions in the energy market. The pandemic created an overabundance of products in the market as companies reduced stockpiles before requiring more products. Oil and petroleum shipments were negatively impacted due to reductions in gasoline/jet fuel demand and travel. In
K22


2019, the rise was the result of higher average revenue per unit, due to pricing gains, which were partially offset by volume declines. Volume declines in natural gas, sand, petroleum products, organic and inorganic chemicals, and plastics were partially offset by gains in crude oil and municipal waste.

For 2021, chemicals revenues are anticipated to increase, as a result of increased volume and revenue per unit driven by pricing gains. We expect carloads to increase due to growth in plastics, organic chemicals, petroleum products, and solid waste which is projected to be partially offset by reduced volumes of sand, crude oil and natural gas liquids.
Metals and construction revenues declined in both periods. In 2020, volume declines were partially offset by higher average revenue per unit, the result of pricing gains. Volume declines were largely the result of weakened demand due to reductions in metal and domestic vehicle production. The pandemic caused industries to suspend production which heavily impacted customers’ needs for materials and shipping of finished and semi-finished goods. These declines were partially offset by increased demand for cement. In 2019, volume declines were largely offset by higher average revenue per unit, the result of pricing gains. Volume declines in iron and steel, coil, scrap metal, and kaolin were partially offset by increases in aggregates shipments due to improved service and market strength.

For 2021, metals and construction revenues are expected to rise, a result of increased volume and revenue per unit driven by pricing gains. As the economic recovery continues, volume growth is expected in almost all markets led by scrap metal, coil, iron and steel, and construction.

Automotive revenues declined in 2020 but were flat in 2019 compared with the prior years. In 2020, revenue declines were driven by lower volume and fuel surcharge revenue, partially offset by pricing gains. The volume decline was mostly the result of unplanned automotive plant shutdowns in the first half of the year, primarily due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which was partially offset by increased demand in the second half of the year. In 2019, higher average revenue per unit, driven by price increases, offset volume declines that were primarily the result of decreases in U.S. light vehicle production and the United Automobile Workers strike in the fourth quarter.

In 2021, automotive revenues are expected to increase as a result of higher volume as inventories continue to rebuild.

INTERMODAL revenues decreased in both periods. The decline in 2020 was driven by lower volume and fuel surcharge revenue, which were partially offset by pricing gains and favorable mix. The decline in 2019 was driven by lower volume, which was partially offset by higher average revenue per unit, a result of pricing gains.

For 2021, we expect intermodal revenues to rise, the result of increased demand, expected highway conversions, and higher fuel surcharge revenue.

Intermodal units by market were as follows:
20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
 (units in thousands)(% change)
Domestic2,568.7 2,593.5 2,801.1 (1 %)(7 %)
International1,423.4 1,613.7 1,574.6 (12 %)%
Total3,992.1 4,207.2 4,375.7 (5 %)(4 %)

Domestic volume fell in both periods. While volume rebounded in the second half of 2020 due to inventory replenishmentrevenue, and a strong peak season, volume for the year was challenged by supply chain disruptions related to
K23


COVID-19 and strong over-the-road competition in the first half of the year. Volume was challenged in 2019 by stronger over-the-road competition.

For 2021, we expect higher domestic volume driven by growth from new and existing customers and continued highway conversions.

International volume fell in 2020, but rose in 2019. The decline in 2020 resulted from supply chain disruptions due to COVID-19. The rise in 2019 was due to increased demand from new and existing customers partially offset by lower shipments due to tariff concerns.volumes.

For 2021, we expect international volume growth as demand and trade continue to recover.
COAL revenues decreased in both periods. The decrease in 2020 was a result of significant volume declines. The decrease in 2019 was a result of lower volume, which was partially offset by higher average revenue per unit, driven by pricing gains.

For 2021, we expect coal revenues to decline. We anticipate overall coal volume to be down as continued declines in utility are projected to more than offset domestic metallurgical and export gains.

As shown in the following table, total tonnage decreased in both periods.2023 but increased 2022.
 20232022
202320222021vs. 2022vs. 2021
 (tons in thousands)(% change)
Utility30,419 35,705 33,169 (15 %)%
Export31,005 25,887 24,886 20 %%
Domestic metallurgical11,096 11,307 11,804 (2 %)(4 %)
Industrial3,372 3,765 3,595 (10 %)%
Total75,892 76,664 73,454 (1 %)%

 20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
 (tons in thousands)(% change)
Utility32,479 60,278 65,688 (46 %)(8 %)
Export18,900 23,324 28,046 (19 %)(17 %)
Domestic metallurgical9,441 13,562 15,500 (30 %)(13 %)
Industrial3,566 4,655 5,410 (23 %)(14 %)
Total64,386 101,819 114,644 (37 %)(11 %)

Utility coal tonnage decreased in both periods.2023 but increased in 2022 compared with the prior years. The declinedecrease in 20202023 was due to low natural gas prices, diminished industrialhigh stockpiles, and commercial electricity demand, and high stockpiles.unplanned customer outages. The declineincrease in 20192022 was due to continued headwinds from low natural gas pricesincreased demand and additional natural gas and renewable energy generating capacity, which were slightly offset by customer inventory rebuilding.service improvements.

For 2021, utility coal tonnage is expected to decrease as a result of high stockpiles and continued pressure from natural gas and renewable energy.

Export coal tonnage decreasedincreased in both periods.periods compared with prior years. The declineincreases in 2020 wasboth years were a result of weak seaborne pricing, COVID-19-related global disruptions, and import restrictions. The decline in 2019 was a result of weak thermal seaborne pricingincreased demand and coal supply disruptions at certain mines.supply.

For 2021, export coal tonnage is expected to increase due to the global recovery from COVID-19.
 
Domestic metallurgical coal tonnage was downdecreased in both 2023 and 2022 compared with the prior years. The declinedecrease in 20202023 was a reflection of continueddue to reduced domestic steel demand which led tocoke shipments resulting from idled customer facilities and lower production.facilities. The declinedecrease in 20192022 was a reflectionthe result of challenging overall market conditions including softening domestic steel demand,reduced coke shipments related to customer sourcing changes and plant outages.idled customer facilities.

For 2021, domestic metallurgical coal tonnage is expected to increase due to the recovery from COVID-19.
K24



Industrial coal tonnage decreased in both years driven by pressure from natural gas conversions and2023 but increased in 2022 compared with the prior years. The decrease in 2023 was due to reduced coal shipments related to customer sourcing changes. The increase in 2022 was the result of increased demand.

For 2021, industrial coal tonnage is expected to decrease as a result of continued pressure from natural gas conversions and customer sourcing changes.
K29


Railway Operating Expenses

Railway operating expenses summarized by major classifications were as follows:

2023
2023
2023
2023
20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
($ in millions)(% change)
Compensation and benefitsCompensation and benefits$2,373 $2,751 $2,925 (14 %)(6 %)
Compensation and benefits
Compensation and benefits
Purchased services and rents
Purchased services and rents
Purchased services and rentsPurchased services and rents1,687 1,725 1,730 (2 %)— %
FuelFuel535 953 1,087 (44 %)(12 %)
Fuel
Fuel
Depreciation
Depreciation
DepreciationDepreciation1,154 1,138 1,102 %%
Materials and otherMaterials and other653 740 655 (12 %)13 %
Loss on asset disposal385 — — 
Materials and other
Materials and other
Eastern Ohio incident
Eastern Ohio incident
Eastern Ohio incident
TotalTotal$6,787 $7,307 $7,499 (7 %)(3 %)
Total
Total

In 2020,2023, expenses fellincreased as our strategic initiativeswe incurred $1.1 billion of costs related to improve productivityenvironmental matters and asset utilization resulted in lower compensation and benefits expense, declines in fuel consumption, reduced purchased services, and lower materials expense. Fuel expense also declinedlegal proceedings resulting from the Incident (Note 17). Additionally, railway operating expenses reflected higher costs due to lower prices. These expense reductionsinflationary pressures, investments in operational resiliency, and higher service-related costs. Partially offsetting these increases were partially offset by a loss on asset disposalthe impacts of $385 million related to locomotives sold, and a $99 million impairment charge included in purchased services and rents related to an equity method investment. In 2019, expenses fell as our strategic initiatives to improve productivity resulted in lower compensation, equipment rents, and materials expense. These decreases along with lower fuel prices and consumption were partially offset by lower gains on operating property sales,the absence of retroactive wage increases recorded in 2022. In 2022, expenses increased depreciation, and a write-off of a $32 million receivableprimarily as a result of a legal dispute.higher fuel prices, other inflationary pressures, service-related costs, increased labor-related costs resulting from labor union negotiations, and higher claims expense.

Compensation and benefits decreasedincreased in 2020,2023, reflecting changes in:

employmentemployee activity levels (down $309(up $138 million),
health and welfare benefits for craft employees (down $77pay rates (up $86 million),
overtime and recrews (down $54(up $9 million),
incentive and stock-based compensation (down $38 million),
increased pay rates (up $50 million),
lower capitalized labor (additional expense of $51$30 million), and
other (down $1$5 million).

K25



In 2019,2022, compensation and benefits decreased,increased, a result of changes in:

employmentpay rates (up $188 million),
employee activity levels (down $117(up $51 million),
overtime (up $18 million),
incentive and stock-based compensation (down $83 million),
overtime and recrews (down $45 million),
higher capitalized labor (reduced expense of $9 million),
2018 employment tax refund ($31 million unfavorable in 2019),
pay rates (up $76$79 million), and
other (down $27(up $1 million).

Pay rates in 2022 were impacted by the outcome of completed labor negotiations, which resulted in retroactive wage increases and other benefits pertaining to prior years. These wage increases and benefits increased compensation and benefits by $54 million.

Our employment averaged 20,20020,300 in 2020,2023, compared with 24,60018,900 in 2019,2022, and 26,70018,500 in 2018.2021.

K30


Purchased services and rents includes the costs of services purchased from external vendors and contractors, including the net costs of operating joint (or leased) facilities with other railroads and the net cost of equipment rentals.

2023
20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
($ in millions)(% change)
Purchased servicesPurchased services$1,387 $1,434 $1,367 (3 %)%
Purchased services
Purchased services
Equipment rents
Equipment rents
Equipment rentsEquipment rents300 291 363 %(20 %)
TotalTotal$1,687 $1,725 $1,730 (2 %)— %
Total
Total

The decrease in purchased services in 2020 resulted from volume-related declines and strategic initiatives to improve productivity and asset utilization, partially offset by the $99 million impairment related to an equity method investment. The increase in purchased services in 20192023 was the result of increaseddue to higher technology-related costs, increased operational and transportation expenses, associated with our headquarters relocation,and higher engineering activity. The increase in purchased services in 2022 was due to inflationary pressures which resulted in higher intermodal-related expenses, and increased intermodal-related costs partially offset by decreasedoperational and transportation activities.expenses, as well as higher technology-related costs.

Equipment rents, which includes our cost of using equipment (mostly freight cars) owned by other railroads or private owners less the rent paid to us for the use of our equipment, increased in 2020, but decreased in 2019.both periods. In 2020,2023, the increase was primarilydue to increased intermodal equipment expenses, higher freight car lease costs, and decreased equity in TTX Company's (TTX) earnings. In 2022, the increase was the result of lower equity in TTX earnings andnetwork fluidity which led to greater time-and-mileage expenses, increased automotive and intermodal equipment expenses, partially offset by decreased intermodal equipment expenses. In 2019, the decrease was largely due to improved network velocity and the absence ofhigher short-term locomotive resource costs incurred in the prior year.costs.

Fuel expense, which includes the cost of locomotive fuel as well as other fuel used in railway operations, decreased in both periods.2023 but increased in 2022. The changedecrease in both years2023 was due to lower locomotive fuel prices (down 32% in 2020 and 8% in 2019)20%), which decreased fuel expense by $275 million. The increase in 2022 was due to higher locomotive fuel prices (up 87%) which increased expenses by $235 million in 2020 and $82 million in 2019. Additionally, locomotive$634 million. Locomotive fuel consumption was nearly flat in 2023 and decreased 18%2% in 2020 and 4% in 2019.2022. We consumed approximately 368377 million gallons of diesel fuel in 2020,2023, compared with 451376 million gallons in 20192022 and 472384 million gallons in 2018.2021.

Depreciation expense increased in both periods. In both periods, the increase was a reflection of reinvestment in our infrastructure, rolling stock, and technology. The increase in 2023 also reflects the impact of changes in group depreciable lives as a result of our periodic roadway study.

K26


Materials and other expenses decreased in 2020 but increased in 2019both 2023 and 2022 as shown in the following table.

2023
20202019
202020192018vs. 2019vs. 2018
($ in millions)(% change)
MaterialsMaterials$274 $327 $362 (16 %)(10 %)
Materials
Materials
ClaimsClaims179 193 176 (7 %)10 %
Claims
Claims
Other
Other
OtherOther200 220 117 (9 %)88 %
TotalTotal$653 $740 $655 (12 %)13 %
Total
Total
 
Materials expense decreasedincreased in 2020both 2023 and 20192022. The increases in both years were due primarily to lower maintenance requirements as a result of fewer locomotivesincreased locomotive, freight car, and freight cars in service.track materials costs.

K31


Claims expense includes costs related to personal injury, property damage, and environmental matters. The 2020 expense declined,decrease in 2023 was primarily the result of lower personal injury case development, lower costs related to environmental remediation matters partially offset byunrelated to the Incident, and a claims-related recovery. The increase in 2022 was primarily the result of higher costs associated with unfavorable personal injury case development, increased derailmentenvironmental remediation expenses, and higher lading and property damage costs. The 2019

Other expense increased in 2023 primarily due to lower gains from operating property sales and increased travel-related expenses. In 2022, other expense increased primarily due to higher costs related to environmental remediation matterstravel-related expenses, increased non-income-based taxes, and personal injury claims.

Other expense decreased in 2020, largely due to the absence of the 2019 write-off of a $32 million receivable as a result of a legal dispute. Additionally, 2020 benefited from reduced travel expenses resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. These reductions were partially offset by lower gains from sales of operating property. Other expense increased in 2019, primarily due to lower gains from sales of operating property, and the $32 million write-off.partially offset by lower relocation expenses. Gains from operating property sales amounted to $26$43 million, $64$76 million, and $158$82 million in 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018,2021, respectively.

Loss on asset disposalEastern Ohio incident

During 2020,2023, we recorded a $385$1.1 billion for costs primarily associated with environmental matters and legal proceedings. We recorded $101 million charge related toof recoveries from claims made under our insurance policies, which are included in the disposal of 703 locomotives,total amount recorded in 2023. For further details regarding the sales of which were completed during the fourth quarter. For more information on the impact of the charge,Incident, see Note 7.17 in Item 8 “Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.”

Other incomeIncomenetNet

Other income – net increased in 2020 and 2019.2023 but decreased in 2022. The increase in 20202023 was driven by the absenceresult of the prior year $49 million impairment loss related to natural resource assets that were sold in 2020, lower pension and postretirement benefit expenses, and higher net returns on corporate-owned life insurance (“COLI”) investments, which more than(COLI) and increased interest income, partially offset the absence of coal royalties andby lower gains on sales offrom non-operating property.property sales. The increasedecrease in 20192022 was driven by lower net returns on COLI partially offset by a higher COLI returnsnet pension benefit and increased gains on sales of non-operating property, which more than offset the aforementioned $49 million impairment loss.interest income.

Income taxesTaxes
 
The effective income tax rate was 20.4%21.3% in 2020,2023, compared with 22.0%20.8% in 20192022 and 23.1%22.5% in 2018.2021.  The current year benefited from a reduction of taxes upon the resolution of our 2012 amended return (see Note 4). All three years benefitedtax credits and higher COLI returns offset by reduced benefits from stock-based compensation. The effective income tax rate in 2022 and 2021 reflects favorable tax benefits associated with stock-based compensation and various state law changes (Note 4), while 2021 also benefited from higher COLI returns.

For 2021,2024, we expect an effective income tax rate between 23% and 24%.

K27


FINANCIAL CONDITION, LIQUIDITY, AND CAPITAL RESOURCES
 
Cash provided by operating activities, our principal source of liquidity, was $3.6$3.2 billion in 2020, $3.92023, $4.2 billion in 2019,2022, and $3.7$4.3 billion in 2018.2021. The decline in 2020 reflects a decrease in income from railway operations2023 reflects lower operating results, offset in part by lower income tax payments.changes in working capital. The increasedecrease in 2019 was primarily the result of2022 reflected changes in working capital, offset in part by improved operating results. We had working capital of $158$639 million at December 31, 2023 and negative working capital of $219$642 million at December 31, 2020, and 2019, respectively.2022. Cash and cash equivalents totaled $1.1$1.6 billion and $580$456 million at December 31, 2020,2023, and 2019,2022, respectively. We expect that cash on hand combined with cash provided by operating activities will be sufficient to meet our ongoing obligations. In addition, we believe our currently-available borrowing capacity, access to additional financing, and ability to reduce property additions and shareholder distributions, including share repurchases, and ability to moderate or defer property additions provide additional flexibility to meet our ongoing obligations. Nonetheless, we continue to monitorobligations in the ongoing impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, which could lead to a reduction in cash flows from operations.short- and long-term.

K32


Contractual obligationsat December 31, 2020,2023, including those that may have material cash requirements, include interest on fixed-rate long-term debt, long-term debt (Note 9), interest on fixed-rate long-term debt,asset purchase of CSR (Note 17), unconditional purchase obligations (Note 17), long-term advances from Conrail Inc. (Conrail) (Note 6), operating leases (Note 10), agreements with Consolidated Rail Corporation (CRC) (Note 6), and unrecognized tax benefits (Note 4).

TotalTotal20242025 -
2026
2027 -
2028
2029 and
Subsequent
($ in millions)
Total20212022 -
2023
2024 -
2025
2026 and
Subsequent
Other
($ in millions)
Interest on fixed-rate long-term debt
Interest on fixed-rate long-term debt
Interest on fixed-rate long-term debt
Long-term debt principalLong-term debt principal$13,693 $579 $1,156 $958 $11,000 — 
Interest on fixed-rate long-term debt13,515 568 1,062 997 10,888 — 
Asset purchase of CSR
Unconditional purchase obligationsUnconditional purchase obligations1,120 600 329 76 115 — 
Long-term advances from ConrailLong-term advances from Conrail534 — — — 534 — 
Operating leasesOperating leases504 101 143 115 145 — 
Agreements with CRCAgreements with CRC140 41 82 17 — — 
Unrecognized tax benefits*Unrecognized tax benefits*22 — — — — 22 
TotalTotal$29,528 $1,889 $2,772 $2,163 $22,682 $22 
Total
Total
 
* This amount is shown in the Other2029 and Subsequent column because the year of settlement cannot be reasonably estimated.
 
Off balance sheet arrangements consist primarily of unrecognized obligations, including unconditional purchase obligations and future interest payments on fixed-rate long-term debt, the pending purchase of the assets of CSR, and unconditional purchase obligations which are included in the table above. In addition, we entered into a synthetic lease during 2019 which is discussed further in Note 10.
 
Cash used in investing activities was $2.2 billion in 2023, $1.6 billion in 2022, and $1.2 billion in 2020, compared with $1.8 billion2021.  The increase in 2019, and $1.7 billion in 2018.  The decrease in 20202023 was primarily driven by lower property additions. In 2019, increased COLI activity and higher property additions wereand lower proceeds from property sales. In 2022, the increase is due to higher property additions partially offset by increased proceeds from property sales. We had the ability to borrow up to $750 million against our COLI policies at December 31, 2020.

Capital spending and track and equipment statistics can be found within the “Railway Property” section of Part I of this report on Form 10-K. For 2021,2024, we expect capital spending willproperty additions, excluding the purchase of the CSR, to approximate $1.6$2.3 billion.

In November 2022, we entered into an asset purchase and sale agreement with the Board of Trustees of the CSR, which was amended and restated in June 2023, to purchase approximately 337 miles of railway line that extends from Cincinnati, Ohio to Chattanooga, Tennessee. We currently operate this railway line under a lease agreement. Following the June 2023 amendment, the total purchase price for the line and other associated real and personal property included in the transaction is expected to be approximately $1.7 billion. The agreement was conditioned upon the following, among other items: (i) Cincinnati Voter Approval, which was obtained in November 2023, and (ii) the receipt of regulatory approval from the STB, which occurred in September 2023. The transaction is scheduled to close on March 15, 2024.

Cash used inprovided by financing activities was $1.9$115 million in 2023, while cash used in financing activities was $3.0 billion in 2020, compared with $2.02022 and $3.3 billion in 2019, and $2.3 billion2021.  The increase in 2018.  The changecash provided by financing activities in 20202023 reflects lower repurchases of Common Stock and debt repayments,increased proceeds from borrowings, partially offset by
reduced proceeds from borrowings. higher debt repayments. In 2019,2022, the decrease was impacted by fewerin cash used in financing activities reflects lower repurchases of Common Stock higher debt repayments, and increased proceeds from borrowings, partially offset by higher dividends.

K33


Share repurchases of $1.4$622 million in 2023, $3.1 billion in 2020, $2.12022, and $3.4 billion in 2019, and $2.8 billion in 20182021 resulted in the retirement of 7.42.8 million, 11.312.6 million, and 17.112.7 million shares, respectively. As of December 31, 2020, 20.7 million shares
K28


remain2023, $6.9 billion remains authorized by our Board of Directors for repurchase. The timing and volume of future share repurchases will be guided by our assessment of market conditions and other pertinent factors. Repurchases may be executed in the open market, through derivatives, accelerated repurchase and other negotiated transactions and through plans designed to comply with Rule 10b5-1(c) and Rule 10b-18 under the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934. Any near-term purchases under the program are expected to be made with internally generatedinternally-generated cash, cash on hand, or proceeds from borrowings.

In May 2020,November 2023, we issued $800$400 million of 3.05%5.55% senior notes due 2050, resulting in $7902034 and $600 million in net proceeds.of 5.95% senior notes due 2064.

In August 2023, we issued $600 million of 5.05% senior notes due 2030 and $1.0 billion of 5.35% senior notes due 2054.

In February 2023, we issued $500 million of 4.45% senior notes due 2033.

In May 2020,2023, we also issued $800 million of 3.155% senior notes due 2055 in exchange for $554 million of previously issued notes ($450 million at 5.1% due 2118, $42 million at 6% due 2111, $29 million at 7.9% due 2097, $26 million at 6% due 2105, and $7 million at 7.05% due 2037). As part of the debt exchange, a $4 million loss on extinguishment was recognized in “Other income – net.”

In May 2020, we also renewed and amended our accounts receivable securitization program reducing ourwith a maximum borrowing capacity from $450 million toof $400 million. Amounts under our accounts receivable securitization program are borrowed and repaid from time to time in the ordinary course for general corporate and cash management purposes. The term of our accounts receivable securitization program expires in May 2021.2024. We had no amounts outstanding under this program at December 31, 2020 or2023 and $100 million outstanding at December 31, 2019, and our2022. Our available borrowing capacity was $400 million at December 31, 2023 and $429$300 million respectively.at December 31, 2022.

In March 2020,January 2024, we renewed and amended our five-year$800 million credit agreement. We increased the program’s borrowing capacity from $750 million to $800 million. The amended agreement expires in 2025January 2029, and provides for borrowings at prevailing rates and includes covenants. We had no amounts outstanding under this facility at either December 31, 20202023 or December 31, 2019.2022, and we are in compliance with all of its covenants.

In January 2024, we also entered into a term loan credit agreement that established a 364-day, $1.0 billion, unsecured delayed draw term loan facility under which we can borrow for general corporate purposes. The term loan credit agreement provides for borrowing at prevailing rates and includes covenants that align with the $800 million credit agreement.

In addition, we have investments in general purpose COLI policies and had the ability to borrow against these policies up to $640 million and $610 million at December 31, 2023 and December 31, 2022, respectively.

Our debt-to-total capitalization ratio was 57.3% at December 31, 2023, compared with 54.4% at December 31, 2022. We discuss our credit agreement and our accounts receivable securitization program in Note 9, and we have authority from our Board of Directors to issue an additional $1.6 billion of debt or equity securities through public or private sale, all of which provide for access to additional liquidity should the need arise. Our debt-to-total capitalization ratio was 46.2% at December 31, 2020, compared with 44.5% at December 31, 2019.
9. Upcoming annual debt maturities are also disclosed in Note 9.  Overall, our goal is to maintain a capital structure with appropriate leverage to support our business strategy and provide flexibility through business cycles.

APPLICATION OF CRITICAL ACCOUNTING POLICIESESTIMATES
 
The preparation of financial statements in accordance with GAAP requires us to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities, the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements, and the reported amounts of revenues and expenses during the reporting period.  These estimates and assumptions may require judgment about matters that are inherently uncertain, and future events are likely to occur that may require us to make changes to these estimates and assumptions.  Accordingly, we regularly review these estimates and assumptions based on historical experience, changes in the business environment, and other factors we believe to be reasonable under the circumstances.  The following critical accounting
K34


Incident Contingencies

We are currently involved in certain environmental response and remediation activities and subject to numerous legal proceedings and regulatory inquiries and investigations relating to the Incident. We have accrued estimates of the probable and reasonably estimable costs for the resolution of these matters. Our environmental estimates are based upon types of remediation efforts currently anticipated, the volume of contaminants in the impacted areas, and governmental oversight and other costs, amongst other factors. Estimates associated with the legal proceedings to which we are subject are based on information that is currently available, including but not limited to an assessment of the proceedings and the potential and likely results of such proceedings.

Our current estimates of future environmental cleanup and remediation liabilities related to the Incident may change over time due to various factors, including but not limited to, the nature and extent of required future cleanup and removal activities (including those resulting from soil, water, sediment, and air assessment and investigative activities that are and will continue to be conducted at the site), and the extent and duration of governmental oversight, amongst other factors. Additionally, the final outcome of any of the legal proceedings and regulatory inquiries and investigations cannot be predicted with certainty, and developments related to the progress of such legal proceedings, inquiries, or investigations or other unfavorable or unexpected outcomes could result in additional costs or new or additionally accrued amounts that could be material to our results of operations in any particular year. Furthermore, certain costs may be recoverable under our insurance policies in effect at the date of the Incident or from third parties. Any amounts that are a subset ofrecoverable under our significant accountinginsurance policies describedor from third parties will be reflected in the period in which recovery is considered probable.

See Note 1.17 for more detailed information as it pertains to these contingencies.

Pensions and Other Postretirement Benefits
 
Accounting for pensions and other postretirement benefit plans requires us to make several estimates and assumptions (Note 12).  These include the expected rate of return from investment of the plans’ assets and the expected retirement age of employees as well as their projected earnings and mortality.  In addition, the amounts recorded are affected by changes in the interest rate environment because the associated liabilities are discounted to their present value.  We make these estimates based on our historical experience and other information we deem pertinent under the circumstances (for example, expectations of future stock market performance).  We utilize an independent actuarial consulting firm’s studies to assist us in selecting appropriate actuarial assumptions and valuing related liabilities.
 
For 2020,2023, we assumed a long-term investment rate of return of 8.25%8.0%, which was supported by our long-term total rate of return on pension plan assets since inception, as well as our expectation of future returns. A one-percentage point changedecrease to this rate of return assumption would result in a $24$25 million changeincrease in annual pension expense. We review
K29


assumptions related to our defined benefit plans annually, and while changes are likely to occur in assumptions concerning retirement age, projected earnings, and mortality, they are not expected to have a material effect on our net pension expense or net pension liability in the future. The net pension liability is recorded at net present value using discount rates that are based on the current interest rate environment in light of the timing of expected benefit payments.  We utilize analyses in which the projected annual cash flows from the pension and postretirement benefit plans are matched with yield curves based on an appropriate universe of high-quality corporate bonds.  We use the results of the yield curve analyses to select the discount rates that match the payment streams of the benefits in these plans. A one-percentage point changedecrease to this discount rate assumption would result in a $17$15 million changeincrease in annual pension expense.

Properties and Depreciation
 
Most of our assets are long-lived railway properties (Note 7). “Properties” are stated principally at cost and are depreciated using the group method whereby assets with similar characteristics, use, and expected lives are grouped
K35


together in asset classes and depreciated using a composite depreciation rate. See Note 1 for a more detailed discussion of assumptions and estimates.

Expenditures, including those on leased assets, that extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility are capitalized. Expenditures capitalized include those that are directly related to a capital project and may include materials, labor, and other direct costs, in addition to an allocable portion of indirect costs that relate to a capital project. A significant portion of our annual capital spending relates to self-constructed assets. Costs related to repairs and maintenance activities that, in our judgment, do not extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility are expensed when such repairs are performed.
 
Depreciation expense for 20202023 totaled $1.2$1.3 billion.  Our composite depreciation rates for 20202023 are disclosed in Note 7; a one-year increase (or decrease) in the estimated average useful lives of depreciable assets would have resulted in an approximate $40$47 million decrease (or increase) to annual depreciation expense.

Personal Injury
 
Claims expense, included in “Materials and other” in the Consolidated Statements of Income, includes our estimate of costs for personal injuries.  
 
To aid in valuing our personal injury liability and determining the amount to accrue with respect to such claims during the year, we utilize studies prepared by an independent actuarial consulting actuarial firm. The actuarial firm studies our historical patterns of reserving for claims and subsequent settlements, taking into account relevant outside influences. We adjust the liability quarterly based upon our assessment and the results of the study. The accuracy of our estimate of the liability is subject to inherent limitation given the difficulty of predicting future events and, as such, the ultimate loss sustained may vary from the estimated liability recorded.

See Note 17 for a more detailed discussion of the assumptions and estimates we use for personal injury.

Income Taxes
 
Our net deferred tax liability totaled $6.9$7.2 billion at December 31, 20202023 (Note 4).  This liability is estimated based on the expected future tax consequences of items recognized in the financial statements.  After application of the federal statutory tax rate to book income, judgment is required with respect to the timing and deductibility of expenses in our income tax returns.  For state income and other taxes, judgment is also required with respect to the apportionment among the various jurisdictions. A valuation allowance is recorded if we expect that it is more likely than not that deferred tax assets will not be realized. We have a $57$31 million valuation allowance on $509$570 million of deferred tax assets as of December 31, 2020,2023, reflecting the expectation that almostsubstantially all of these assets will be realized.

K30


OTHER MATTERS
 
Labor Agreements

Approximately 80% of our railroad employees are covered by collective bargaining agreements with various labor unions. Pursuant to the Railway Labor Act, these agreements remain in effect until new agreements are reached, or until the bargaining procedures mandated by the Railway Labor Act are completed. We largely bargain nationally in concert with other major railroads, represented by the National Carriers Conference Committee.  Moratorium provisions in the labor agreements govern when the railroads and unions may propose changes to the agreements. We largely bargain nationally in concert with other major railroads, represented by the National Carriers’ Conference Committee.

The currentlatest round of national bargaining commenced onconcluded in December 2022, when agreements were either ratified or enacted through legislative action for all twelve of our unions. With the conclusion of national bargaining, neither party can compel mandatory bargaining around any new proposals until November 1, 20192024.
K36



In addition, we understand the imperative to continue improving quality of life for our craft employees and remain actively engaged with both management andour unions in voluntary local discussions (none of which carry the unions serving their formal proposals for changes to the collective bargaining agreements and direct negotiations are ongoing.risk of a work stoppage) on this important issue.

Market Risks
 
We manage overall exposure to fluctuations in interest rates by issuing both fixed- and floating- rate debt instruments. At December 31, 2020,2023, we hadhave no outstanding debt subject to interest rate fluctuations. Market risk for fixed-rate debt is estimated as the potential increase in fair value resulting from a one-percentage point decrease in interest rates as of December 31, 20202023 and amounts to an increase of approximately $2.0$1.7 billion to the fair value of our debt at December 31, 2020.2023. We consider it unlikely that interest rate fluctuations applicable to these instruments will result in a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity.

New Accounting Pronouncements

For a detailed discussion of new accounting pronouncements, see Note 1.

Inflation
 
In preparing financial statements, GAAP requires the use of historical cost that disregards the effects of inflation on the replacement cost of property.  As a capital-intensive company, we have most of our capital invested in long-lived assets.  The replacement cost of these assets, as well as the related depreciation expense, would be substantially greater than the amounts reported on the basis of historical cost.

FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS
 
Certain statements in Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations are “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the “safe harbor” provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, as amended.  These statements relate to future events or our future financial performance and involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors that may cause our actual results, levels of activity, performance, or our achievements or those of our industry to be materially different from those expressed or implied by any forward-looking statements.  In some cases, forward-looking statements can be identified by terminology such as “may,” “will,” “could,” “would,” “should,” “expect,” “plan,” “anticipate,” “intend,” “believe,” “estimate,” “project,” “consider,” “predict,” “potential,” “feel,” or other comparable terminology.  We have based these forward-looking statements on our current expectations, assumptions, estimates, beliefs, and projections.  While we believe these expectations, assumptions, estimates, beliefs, and projections are reasonable, such forward-looking statements are only predictions and involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties, many of which involve factors or circumstances that are beyond our control.  These and other important factors, including those discussed in Item 1A “Risk Factors,” may cause actual results, performance, or achievements to differ materially from those expressed or implied by these forward-looking statements.  The forward-looking statements herein are made only as of the date they were first issued, and unless otherwise required by applicable securities laws, we disclaim any intention or obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events, or otherwise.

K31K37


Additional Information

Investors and others should note that we routinely use the Investor Relations, Performance Metrics and Sustainability sections of our website (norfolksouthern.investorroom.com/key-investor-information, norfolksouthern.investorroom.com/weekly-performance-reports & www.norfolksouthern.com/sustainability) to post presentations to investors and other important information, including information that may be deemed material to investors. Information about us, including information that may be deemed material, may also be announced by posts on our social media channels, including X (formerly known as Twitter) (www.twitter.com/nscorp) and LinkedIn (www.linkedin.com/company/norfolk-southern). We may also use our website and social media channels for the purpose of complying with our disclosure obligations under Regulation FD. As a result, we encourage investors, the media, and others interested in Norfolk Southern to review the information posted on our website and social media channels. The information posted on our website and social media channels is not incorporated by reference in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
 
Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk 

The information required by this item is included in Item 7 “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations” under the heading “Market Risks.”
 
K32K38


Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data
 
INDEX TO FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 Page
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

K33K39


Report of Management
 
February 4, 20215, 2024
 
To the Stockholders
Norfolk Southern Corporation:
 
Management is responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial reporting.  In order to ensure that Norfolk Southern’s internal control over financial reporting is effective, management regularly assesses such controls and did so most recently as of December 31, 2020.2023.  This assessment was based on criteria for effective internal control over financial reporting described in Internal Control Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.  Based on this assessment, management has concluded that we maintained effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2020.2023.
 
KPMG LLP, independent registered public accounting firm, has audited our financial statements and issued an attestation reportopinion on our internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2020.2023.
/s/ James A. SquiresAlan H. Shaw/s/ Mark R. George/s/ Clyde H. Allison, Jr.Claiborne L. Moore
James A. SquiresAlan H. ShawMark R. GeorgeClyde H. Allison, Jr.Claiborne L. Moore
Chairman, President andExecutive Vice President FinanceVice President and
Chief Executive Officerand Chief Financial OfficerController

K34K40


Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm

 
To the Stockholders and Board of Directors
Norfolk Southern Corporation:
 
OpinionOpinions on the Consolidated Financial Statements and Internal Control Over Financial Reporting

We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance sheets of Norfolk Southern Corporation and subsidiaries’subsidiaries (the Company) internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2020, based on criteria established in Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission. In our opinion, the Company maintained, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2020, based on criteria established in Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.

We also have audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB), the consolidated balance sheets of the Company as of December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, the related consolidated statements of income, comprehensive income, cash flows, and changes in stockholders’ equity for each of the years in the three-year period ended December 31, 2020,2023, and the related notes and financial statement schedule of valuation and qualifying accounts as listed in Item 15(A)2 (collectively, the consolidated financial statements), and. We also have audited the Company’s internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2023, based on criteria established in Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.

In our report dated February 4, 2021, expressed an unqualified opinion, on thosethe consolidated financial statements.statements referred to above present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Company as of December 31, 2023 and 2022, and the results of its operations and its cash flows for each of the years in the three-year period ended December 31, 2023, in conformity with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles. Also in our opinion, the Company maintained, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2023 based on criteria established in Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.

Basis for OpinionOpinions

The Company’s management is responsible for these consolidated financial statements, for maintaining effective internal control over financial reporting, and for its assessment of the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting, included in the accompanying Management's Annual Report of Management.on Internal Control Over Financial Reporting. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on the Company’s consolidated financial statements and an opinion on the Company’s internal control over financial reporting based on our audit.audits. We are a public accounting firm registered with the PCAOBPublic Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB) and are required to be independent with respect to the Company in accordance with the U.S. federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the PCAOB.

We conducted our auditaudits in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. Those standards require that we plan and perform the auditaudits to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial statements are free of material misstatement, whether due to error or fraud, and whether effective internal control over financial reporting was maintained in all material respects.

Our audits of the consolidated financial statements included performing procedures to assess the risks of material misstatement of the consolidated financial statements, whether due to error or fraud, and performing procedures that respond to those risks. Such procedures included examining, on a test basis, evidence regarding the amounts and disclosures in the consolidated financial statements. Our audits also included evaluating the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the consolidated financial statements. Our audit of internal control over financial reporting included obtaining an understanding of internal control over financial reporting, assessing the risk that a material weakness exists, and testing and evaluating the design and operating effectiveness of internal control based on the assessed risk. Our auditaudits also included performing such other procedures as we considered necessary in the circumstances. We believe that our audit providesaudits provide a reasonable basis for our opinion.opinions.

K41


Definition and Limitations of Internal Control Over Financial Reporting

A company’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. A company’s internal control over financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that (1) pertain to the maintenance of records that, in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the company; (2) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that receipts and expenditures of the company are being made only in accordance with authorizations of management and directors of the company; and (3) provide reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of unauthorized acquisition, use, or disposition of the company’s assets that could have a material effect on the financial statements.

K35



Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with the policies or procedures may deteriorate.


/s/ KPMG LLP
KPMG LLP
Atlanta, Georgia
February 4, 2021
K36


Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm

To the Stockholders and Board of Directors
Norfolk Southern Corporation:
Opinion on the Consolidated Financial Statements

We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance sheets of Norfolk Southern Corporation and subsidiaries (the Company) as of December 31, 2020 and 2019, the related consolidated statements of income, comprehensive income, cash flows, and changes in stockholders’ equity for each of the years in the three‑year period ended December 31, 2020, and the related notes and financial statement schedule of valuation and qualifying accounts as listed in Item 15(A)2 (collectively, the consolidated financial statements). In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Company as of December 31, 2020 and 2019, and the results of its operations and its cash flows for each of the years in the three‑year period ended December 31, 2020, in conformity with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles.

We also have audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB), the Company’s internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2020, based on criteria established in Internal Control – Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission, and our report dated February 4, 2021 expressed an unqualified opinion on the effectiveness of the Company’s internal control over financial reporting.

Change in Accounting Principle

As discussed in Note 1 to the consolidated financial statements, the Company has changed its method of accounting for leases as of January 1, 2019, due to the adoption of Accounting Standards Update 2016-02, Leases (Topic 842) and related amendments.

Basis for Opinion

These consolidated financial statements are the responsibility of the Company’s management. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these consolidated financial statements based on our audits. We are a public accounting firm registered with the PCAOB and are required to be independent with respect to the Company in accordance with the U.S. federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the PCAOB.

We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial statements are free of material misstatement, whether due to error or fraud. Our audits included performing procedures to assess the risks of material misstatement of the consolidated financial statements, whether due to error or fraud, and performing procedures that respond to those risks. Such procedures included examining, on a test basis, evidence regarding the amounts and disclosures in the consolidated financial statements. Our audits also included evaluating the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the consolidated financial statements. We believe that our audits provide a reasonable basis for our opinion.

K37


Critical Audit MatterMatters

The critical audit mattermatters communicated below is a matterare matters arising from the current period audit of the consolidated financial statements that waswere communicated or required to be communicated to the audit committee and that: (1) relatesrelate to accounts or disclosures that are material to the consolidated financial statements and (2) involved our especially challenging, subjective, or complex judgments. The communication of a critical audit mattermatters does not alter in any way our opinion on the consolidated financial statements, taken as a whole, and we are not, by communicating the critical audit mattermatters below, providing a separate opinionopinions on the critical audit mattermatters or on the accounts or disclosures to which it relates.they relate.

Sufficiency of audit evidence related to the capitalization of property expenditures

As discussed in Note 1 to the consolidated financial statements, expenditures that extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility are capitalized. The Company has recorded $31,345$33,326 million in net book value of properties at December 31, 20202023 and has recorded $1,494$2,349 million in property additions for the year ended December 31, 2020.2023. Expenditures capitalized include those that are directly related to a capital project and may include materials, labor and other direct costs, in addition to an allocable portion of indirect costs that relate to a capital project. A significant portion of the Company’s annual capital spending relates to self-constructed assets. Costs related to repair and maintenance activities, that in the Company’s judgment, do not extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility are expensed when such repairs are performed.

We identified the evaluation of the sufficiency of audit evidence related to capitalization of property expenditures as a critical audit matter. Subjective auditor judgment was required in determining procedures and evaluating audit results related to the capitalization of purchased services and compensation due to their usage for both self-constructed assets and repairs and maintenance.

The following are the primary procedures we performed to address thisthe critical audit matter. We applied auditor judgment to determine the nature and extent of procedures to be performed over capitalized property expenditures. We evaluated the design and tested the operating effectiveness of certain internal controls over the Company’s process to capitalize property expenditures, including controls over the determination of whether purchased services and compensation expenditures extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility. For a sample of property additionadditions expenditures, we inquired and inspected support to evaluate that the expenditure extended an asset’s useful life or increased its utility. We evaluated the sufficiency of audit evidence obtained by assessing the results of the procedures performed, including the appropriateness of the nature of such evidence.
K42


Eastern Ohio Incident

As discussed in Note 17 to the consolidated financial statements, the Company has recognized $464 million of liabilities attributable to the Eastern Ohio Incident (the Incident) as of December 31, 2023. For the year-ended December 31, 2023, the Company has recognized $1,116 million of expenses for costs directly attributable to the Incident, which is presented net of $101 million in insurance recoveries in the Consolidated Statements of Income. As of December 31, 2023, the Company recognized probable and reasonably estimable liabilities for environmental matters and legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental). The Company also disclosed certain legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental) where a loss is reasonably possible, but not probable, or is probable but not reasonably estimable, for which no accrual was established. In addition, as a result of the Incident, the Company disclosed that it is subject to inquiries and investigations by various government authorities and regulatory agencies.

We identified the evaluation of the recognition and measurement of liabilities for environmental matters, legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental) and inquiries and investigations arising from the Incident and the sufficiency of the related disclosures as a critical audit matter. A high degree of subjective auditor judgment was required to evaluate certain judgments and assumptions made by management when assessing the likelihood and magnitude of losses incurred and determining whether reasonable estimates of losses can be made. Specifically, the key judgments and assumptions related to the following:

the nature and extent of future cleanup and removal activities and the extent and duration of governmental oversight
the final outcome of the legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental)
the final outcome of any current or future inquiries and investigations arising from the Incident.

The following are the primary procedures that we performed to address this critical audit matter. We evaluated the design and tested the operating effectiveness of certain internal controls over the Company’s processes to 1) recognize and measure liabilities associated with environmental matters, legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental), and inquiries and investigations and 2) prepare the related financial statement disclosures. We evaluated the Company's assessment of the likelihood and magnitude of losses being incurred including whether the estimates of losses are reasonably estimable for liabilities associated with the Incident by:

assessing the estimates of environmental cleanup and remediation liabilities by comparing them to incurred costs
inquiring of management regarding the expected timeline for both probable and reasonably estimable costs for soil and water disposal and air monitoring activities as well as related governmental oversight
obtaining a legal confirmation letter from external legal counsel, and inquiring of the Company’s internal and external legal counsel regarding the likelihood and magnitude of losses related to environmental matters, legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental) and inquiries and investigations
obtaining and inspecting correspondence with government authorities and regulatory agencies for environmental matters, legal proceedings and claims (non-environmental) and inquiries and investigations.
K43


We evaluated whether the Company’s disclosures were appropriate and consistent with the information obtained in our procedures.


/s/ KPMG LLP
KPMG LLP

We have served as the Company’sCompany's auditor since 1982.

Atlanta, Georgia
February 4, 20215, 2024
K38K44


Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Consolidated Statements of Income
 Years ended December 31,
 202020192018
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)
Railway operating revenues$9,789 $11,296 $11,458 
Railway operating expenses:   
Compensation and benefits2,373 2,751 2,925 
Purchased services and rents1,687 1,725 1,730 
Fuel535 953 1,087 
Depreciation1,154 1,138 1,102 
Materials and other653 740 655 
Loss on asset disposal385 
Total railway operating expenses6,787 7,307 7,499 
Income from railway operations3,002 3,989 3,959 
Other income – net153 106 67 
Interest expense on debt625 604 557 
Income before income taxes2,530 3,491 3,469 
Income taxes517 769 803 
Net income$2,013 $2,722 $2,666 
Earnings per share:   
Basic$7.88 $10.32 $9.58 
Diluted7.84 10.25 9.51 
 Years ended December 31,
 202320222021
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)
Railway operating revenues$12,156 $12,745 $11,142 
Railway operating expenses   
Compensation and benefits2,819 2,621 2,442 
Purchased services and rents2,070 1,922 1,726 
Fuel1,170 1,459 799 
Depreciation1,298 1,221 1,181 
Materials and other832 713 547 
Eastern Ohio incident1,116 — — 
Total railway operating expenses9,305 7,936 6,695 
Income from railway operations2,851 4,809 4,447 
Other income – net191 13 77 
Interest expense on debt722 692 646 
Income before income taxes2,320 4,130 3,878 
Income taxes493 860 873 
Net income$1,827 $3,270 $3,005 
Earnings per share   
Basic$8.04 $13.92 $12.16 
Diluted8.02 13.88 12.11 


See accompanying notes to consolidated financial statements.


K39K45


Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income
 Years ended December 31,
 202020192018
 ($ in millions)
Net income$2,013 $2,722 $2,666 
Other comprehensive income (loss), before tax:   
Pension and other postretirement benefits(140)101 (148)
Other comprehensive income (loss) of equity investees(4)(9)
Other comprehensive income (loss), before tax(138)97 (157)
Income tax benefit (expense) related to items of   
other comprehensive income (loss)35 (25)38 
Other comprehensive income (loss), net of tax(103)72 (119)
Total comprehensive income$1,910 $2,794 $2,547 
 Years ended December 31,
 202320222021
 ($ in millions)
Net income$1,827 $3,270 $3,005 
Other comprehensive income, before tax:   
Pension and other postretirement benefits36 51 226 
Other comprehensive income of equity investees17 24 
Other comprehensive income, before tax40 68 250 
Income tax expense related to items of   
other comprehensive income(9)(17)(58)
Other comprehensive income, net of tax31 51 192 
Total comprehensive income$1,858 $3,321 $3,197 


See accompanying notes to consolidated financial statements.


K40K46


Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Consolidated Balance Sheets
 At December 31,
 20202019
 ($ in millions)
Assets  
Current assets:  
Cash and cash equivalents$1,115 $580 
Accounts receivable – net848 920 
Materials and supplies221 244 
Other current assets134 337 
Total current assets2,318 2,081 
Investments3,590 3,428 
Properties less accumulated depreciation of $11,985 and  
$11,982, respectively31,345 31,614 
Other assets709 800 
Total assets$37,962 $37,923 
Liabilities and stockholders’ equity  
Current liabilities:  
Accounts payable$1,016 $1,428 
Income and other taxes263 229 
Other current liabilities302 327 
Current maturities of long-term debt579 316 
Total current liabilities2,160 2,300 
Long-term debt12,102 11,880 
Other liabilities1,987 1,744 
Deferred income taxes6,922 6,815 
Total liabilities23,171 22,739 
Stockholders’ equity:  
Common Stock $1.00 per share par value, 1,350,000,000 shares  
authorized; outstanding 252,095,082 and 257,904,956 shares,  
respectively, net of treasury shares254 259 
Additional paid-in capital2,248 2,209 
Accumulated other comprehensive loss(594)(491)
Retained income12,883 13,207 
Total stockholders’ equity14,791 15,184 
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity$37,962 $37,923 
 At December 31,
 20232022
 ($ in millions)
Assets  
Current assets:  
Cash and cash equivalents$1,568 $456 
Accounts receivable – net1,147 1,148 
Materials and supplies264 253 
Other current assets292 150 
Total current assets3,271 2,007 
Investments3,839 3,694 
Properties less accumulated depreciation of $13,265 and  
$12,592, respectively33,326 32,156 
Other assets1,216 1,028 
Total assets$41,652 $38,885 
Liabilities and stockholders’ equity  
Current liabilities:  
Accounts payable$1,638 $1,293 
Short-term debt— 100 
Income and other taxes262 312 
Other current liabilities728 341 
Current maturities of long-term debt603 
Total current liabilities2,632 2,649 
Long-term debt17,175 14,479 
Other liabilities1,839 1,759 
Deferred income taxes7,225 7,265 
Total liabilities28,871 26,152 
Stockholders’ equity:  
Common Stock $1.00 per share par value, 1,350,000,000 shares  
authorized; outstanding 225,681,254 and 228,076,415 shares,  
respectively, net of treasury shares227 230 
Additional paid-in capital2,179 2,157 
Accumulated other comprehensive loss(320)(351)
Retained income10,695 10,697 
Total stockholders’ equity12,781 12,733 
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity$41,652 $38,885 

See accompanying notes to consolidated financial statements.


K41K47


Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
Years ended December 31,
 202020192018
 ($ in millions)
Cash flows from operating activities:   
Net income$2,013 $2,722 $2,666 
Reconciliation of net income to net cash provided by operating activities:   
Depreciation1,154 1,139 1,104 
Deferred income taxes142 330 173 
Gains and losses on properties(39)(42)(171)
Loss on asset disposal385 
Impairment of investment99 
Changes in assets and liabilities affecting operations:   
Accounts receivable71 87 (70)
Materials and supplies23 (37)15 
Other current assets(4)(46)
Current liabilities other than debt34 (185)223 
  Other – net(248)(118)(168)
Net cash provided by operating activities3,637 3,892 3,726 
Cash flows from investing activities:   
Property additions(1,494)(2,019)(1,951)
Property sales and other transactions333 377 204 
Investment purchases(13)(18)(10)
Investment sales and other transactions(1)(104)99 
Net cash used in investing activities(1,175)(1,764)(1,658)
Cash flows from financing activities:   
Dividends(960)(949)(844)
Common Stock transactions69 27 40 
Purchase and retirement of Common Stock(1,439)(2,099)(2,781)
Proceeds from borrowings – net of issuance costs784 2,192 2,023 
Debt repayments(381)(1,188)(750)
Other23 
Net cash used in financing activities(1,927)(1,994)(2,312)
Net increase (decrease) in cash, cash equivalents, and
      restricted cash
535 134 (244)
Cash, cash equivalents, and restricted cash:   
At beginning of year580 446 690 
At end of year$1,115 $580 $446 
Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information:   
Cash paid during the year for:   
Interest (net of amounts capitalized)$577 $555 $496 
Income taxes (net of refunds)311 543 519 
Years ended December 31,
 202320222021
 ($ in millions)
Cash flows from operating activities   
Net income$1,827 $3,270 $3,005 
Reconciliation of net income to net cash provided by operating activities:   
Depreciation1,298 1,221 1,181 
Deferred income taxes(49)83 184 
Gains and losses on properties(49)(82)(86)
Changes in assets and liabilities affecting operations:   
Accounts receivable(2)(171)(133)
Materials and supplies(11)(35)
Other current assets(54)(18)(6)
Current liabilities other than debt435 23 283 
  Other – net(216)(69)(176)
Net cash provided by operating activities3,179 4,222 4,255 
Cash flows from investing activities   
Property additions(2,349)(1,948)(1,470)
Property sales and other transactions86 263 159 
Investment purchases(124)(12)(10)
Investment sales and other transactions205 94 99 
Net cash used in investing activities(2,182)(1,603)(1,222)
Cash flows from financing activities   
Dividends(1,225)(1,167)(1,028)
Common Stock transactions(4)17 
Purchase and retirement of Common Stock(622)(3,110)(3,390)
Proceeds from borrowings3,293 1,832 1,676 
Debt repayments(1,334)(553)(584)
Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities115 (3,002)(3,309)
Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents1,112 (383)(276)
Cash and cash equivalents   
At beginning of year456 839 1,115 
At end of year$1,568 $456 $839 
Supplemental disclosures of cash flow information   
Cash paid during the year for:   
Interest (net of amounts capitalized)$653 $619 $579 
Income taxes (net of refunds)681 750 654 

See accompanying notes to consolidated financial statements.


K42K48


Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Consolidated Statements of Changes in Stockholders’ Equity
Common
Stock
Additional
Paid-in
Capital
Accum. Other
Comprehensive
Loss
Retained
Income
Total
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)
Balance at December 31, 2017$285 $2,254 $(356)$14,176 $16,359 
Comprehensive income:     
Net income   2,666 2,666 
Other comprehensive loss  (119) (119)
Total comprehensive income    2,547 
Dividends on Common Stock,     
$3.04 per share   (844)(844)
Share repurchases(17)(125) (2,639)(2,781)
Stock-based compensation87 (7)81 
Reclassification of stranded
tax effects(88)88 
Balance at December 31, 2018269 2,216 (563)13,440 15,362 
Comprehensive income:     
Net income   2,722 2,722 
Other comprehensive income  72  72 
Total comprehensive income    2,794 
Dividends on Common Stock,     
$3.60 per share   (949)(949)
Share repurchases(11)(88) (2,000)(2,099)
Stock-based compensation81  (6)76 
Balance at December 31, 2019259 2,209 (491)13,207 15,184 
Comprehensive income:     
Net income   2,013 2,013 
Other comprehensive loss  (103) (103)
Total comprehensive income    1,910 
Dividends on Common Stock,     
$3.76 per share   (960)(960)
Share repurchases(7)(59) (1,373)(1,439)
Stock-based compensation98  (4)96 
Balance at December 31, 2020$254 $2,248 $(594)$12,883 $14,791 
Common
Stock
Additional
Paid-in
Capital
Accum. Other
Comprehensive
Loss
Retained
Income
Total
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)
Balance at December 31, 2020$254 $2,248 $(594)$12,883 $14,791 
Comprehensive income:     
Net income   3,005 3,005 
Other comprehensive income  192  192 
Total comprehensive income    3,197 
Dividends on Common Stock,     
$4.16 per share   (1,028)(1,028)
Share repurchases(13)(106) (3,271)(3,390)
Stock-based compensation73 (3)71 
Balance at December 31, 2021242 2,215 (402)11,586 13,641 
Comprehensive income:     
Net income   3,270 3,270 
Other comprehensive income  51  51 
Total comprehensive income    3,321 
Dividends on Common Stock,     
$4.96 per share   (1,167)(1,167)
Share repurchases(13)(108) (2,989)(3,110)
Stock-based compensation50  (3)48 
Balance at December 31, 2022230 2,157 (351)10,697 12,733 
Comprehensive income:     
Net income   1,827 1,827 
Other comprehensive income  31  31 
Total comprehensive income    1,858 
Dividends on Common Stock,     
$5.40 per share   (1,225)(1,225)
Share repurchases(3)(24) (600)(627)
Stock-based compensation46  (4)42 
Balance at December 31, 2023$227 $2,179 $(320)$10,695 $12,781 

See accompanying notes to consolidated financial statements.


K43K49


Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
 
The following Notes are an integral part of the Consolidated Financial Statements. Certain prior year information has been reclassified to conform to current year presentation.
 
1.  Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
 
Description of Business
 
Norfolk Southern Corporation is a Virginia-basedGeorgia-based holding company engaged principally in the rail transportation business, operating 19,30019,100 route miles primarily in the Southeast, East, and Midwest. These consolidated financial statements include Norfolk Southern and its majority-owned and controlled subsidiaries (collectively, NS, we, us, and our).  Norfolk Southern’s major subsidiary is NSR.  All significant intercompany balances and transactions have been eliminated in consolidation.
 
NSR and its railroad subsidiaries transport raw materials, intermediate products, and finished goods classified in the following commodity groups (percent of total railway operating revenues in 2020)2023): intermodal (27%(25%); agriculture, forest and consumer products (22%(21%); chemicals (18%(17%); coal (14%); metals and construction (14%); coal (11%); and automotive (8%(9%). Although most of our customers are domestic, ultimate points of origination or destination for some of the products transported (particularly coal bound for export and some intermodal shipments) may be outside the U.S.  Approximately 80% of our railroad employees are covered by collective bargaining agreements with various labor unions.
 
Use of Estimates
 
The preparation of financial statements in accordance with GAAP requires us to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities, the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements, and the reported amounts of revenues and expenses during the reporting period.  We periodically review our estimates, including those related to the recoverability and useful lives of assets, as well as liabilities for litigation, environmental remediation, casualty claims, income taxes and pension and other postretirement benefits.  Changes in facts and circumstances may result in revised estimates.
 
Revenue Recognition
 
Transportation revenues are recognized proportionally as a shipment moves from origin to destination, and related expenses are recognized as incurred.  Certain of our contract refunds (which are primarily volume-based incentives) are recorded as a reduction to revenues on the basis of our best estimate of projected liability, which is based on historical activity, current shipment counts and expectation of future activity. Certain ancillary services, such as switching, demurrage and other incidental activities, may be provided to customers under their transportation contracts. These areThe revenues associated with these distinct performance obligations that are recognized at a point in time when the services are performed or as contractual obligations are met.
 
Cash Equivalents
 
“Cash equivalents” are highly liquid investments purchased three months or less from maturity.

Allowance for Doubtful Accounts
 
Our allowance for doubtful accounts was $6$7 million and $9 million at December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively.  To determine our allowance for doubtful accounts, we evaluate historical loss experience (which has not been significant), the characteristics of current accounts, and general economic conditions and trends.

K44K50


Materials and Supplies
 
“Materials and supplies,” consisting mainly of items for maintenance of property and equipment, are stated at the lower of average cost or net realizable value.  The cost of materials and supplies expected to be used in property additions or improvements is included in “Properties.”
 
Investments
  
Investments in entities over which we have the ability to exercise significant influence but do not control the entity are accounted for using the equity method, whereby the investment is carried at the cost of the acquisition plus our equity in undistributed earnings or losses since acquisition.
 
Properties
 
“Properties” are stated principally at cost and are depreciated using the group method whereby assets with similar characteristics, use, and expected lives are grouped together in asset classes and depreciated using a composite depreciation rate.  This methodology treats each asset class as a pool of resources, not as singular items.  We use approximately 75 depreciable asset classes.

Depreciation expense is based on our assumptions concerning expected service lives of our properties as well as the expected net salvage that will be received upon their retirement.  In developing these assumptions, we utilize periodic depreciation studies that are performed by an independent outside firm of consulting engineers and approved by the STB.  Our depreciation studies are conducted about every three years for equipment and every six years for track assets and other roadway property.  The frequency of these studies is consistent with guidelines established by the STB.  We adjust our rates based on the results of these studies and implement the changes prospectively.  The studies may also indicate that the recorded amount of accumulated depreciation is deficient (or in excess) of the amount indicated by the study.  Any such deficiency (or excess) is amortized as a component of depreciation expense over the remaining service lives of the affected class of property, as determined by the study. 

Key factors that are considered in developing average service life and salvage estimates include:

statistical analysis of historical retirement data and surviving asset records,
review of historical salvage received and current market rates,
review of our operations including expected changes in technology, customer demand, maintenance practices and asset management strategies,
review of accounting policies and assumptions, and
industry review and analysis.
 
The composite depreciation rate for rail in high density corridors is derived based on consideration of annual gross tons as compared to the total or ultimate capacity of rail in these corridors.  Our experience has shown that traffic density is a leading factor in the determination of the expected service life of rail in high density corridors.  In developing the respective depreciation rate, consideration is also given to several rail characteristics including age, weight, condition (new or second-hand) and type (curved or straight).  
 
We capitalize interest on major projects during the period of their construction.  Expenditures, including those on leased assets, that extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility are capitalized.  Expenditures capitalized include those that are directly related to a capital project and may include materials, labor, and other direct costs, in addition to an allocable portion of indirect costs that relate to a capital project. A significant portion of our annual capital spending relates to self-constructed assets. Removal activities occur in conjunction with replacement and are estimated based on the average percentage of time employees replacing assets spend on removal functions. Costs related to repairs and maintenance activities that, in our judgment, do not extend an asset’s useful life or increase its utility are expensed when such repairs are performed.
 
K45K51


When depreciable operating road and equipment assets are sold or retired in the ordinary course of business, the cost of the assets, net of sales proceeds or salvage, is charged to accumulated depreciation, and no gain or loss is recognized in earnings.  Actual historical cost values are retired when available, such as with most equipment assets.  The use of estimates in recording the retirement of certain roadway assets is necessary based on the impracticality of tracking individual asset costs.  When retiring rail, ties and ballast, we use statistical curves that indicate the relative distribution of the age of the assets retired.  The historical cost of other roadway assets is estimated using a combination of inflation indices specific to the rail industry and those published by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.  The indices are applied to the replacement value based on the age of the retired assets.  These indices are used because they closely correlate with the costs of roadway assets.  Gains and losses on disposal of operating land are included in “Materials and other” expenses. Gains and losses on disposal of nonoperatingnon-operating land and nonrailnon-rail assets are included in “Other income – net” since such income is not a product of our railroad operations.

A retirement is considered abnormal if it does not occur in the ordinary course of business, if it relates to disposition of a large segment of an asset class and if the retirement varies significantly from the retirement profile identified through our depreciation studies, which inherently consider the impact of normal retirements on expected service lives and depreciation rates.  Gains or losses from abnormal retirements are recognized in income from railway operations.
 
We review the carrying amount of properties whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that such carrying amount may not be recoverable based on future undiscounted cash flows.  Assets that are deemed impaired as a result of such review are recorded at the lower of carrying amount or fair value.
 
New Accounting Pronouncements

In February 2018,November 2021, the FASBFinancial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued ASU 2018-02,Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2021-10,ReclassificationGovernment Assistance (Topic 832): Disclosures by Business Entities about Government Assistance,” which requires annual disclosures when an entity has received government assistance. Entities are required to disclose the types of Certain Tax Effects from Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income.” This update is intended to reclassifygovernment assistance received, the stranded tax effects resulting from tax reform from accumulated other comprehensive income (AOCI) to retained earnings. The amountaccounting treatment for that government assistance, and the effect of the reclassification isgovernment assistance on the difference between the amount initially charged or credited directly to other comprehensive income at the previously enacted U.S. federal corporate income tax rate that remains in AOCI and the amount that would have been charged or credited directly to other comprehensive income using the U.S. federal corporate income tax rate enacted in December 2017. In the first quarter of 2018, wefinancial statements. We adopted the provisions of ASU 2018-02 resulting in an increase to “Accumulated other comprehensive loss” of $88 million and a corresponding increase to “Retained income,” with no impact on “Total stockholders’ equity.”

In February 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-02, “Leases (Topic 842),” and subsequent amendments, which replaced existing lease guidance in GAAP. We adopted thenew standard on January 1, 2019 using the modified retrospective method and used the effective date as our date of initial application. See Note 10 for additional information.

In June 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-13, “Credit Losses - Measurement of Credit Losses on Financial Instruments,” which replaced the current incurred loss impairment method with a method that reflects expected credit losses. Short-term and long-term financial assets, as defined by the standard, are impacted by immediate recognition of estimated credit losses in the financial statements, reflecting the net amount expected to be collected. Historically, losses associated from the inability to collect on accounts receivable have been insignificant, with little divergence in collection trends through varying economic cycles. We adopted the standard on January 1, 20202022 and there was no material impact to the financial statements upon adoption.

In December 2019,November 2023, the FASB issued ASU 2019-12,2023-07, “Segment Reporting (Topic 280): Improvements to Reportable Segment Disclosures. This update requires additional reportable segment disclosures, primarily through enhanced disclosures about significant segment expenses and information used to assess performance. The ASU is effective for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2023 and interim periods within fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2024. We will not early adopt the standard and are currently evaluating the effect on our financial statements.

In December 2023, the FASB issued ASU 2023-09, Simplifying the Accounting for Income Taxes (Topic 740): Improvements to Income Tax Disclosures.which adds new guidanceThis update requires additional disclosures including greater disaggregation of information in the reconciliation of the statutory rate to simplify the accounting foreffective rate and income taxes changes the accountingpaid disaggregated by jurisdiction. The ASU is effective for certain income tax transactions, and makes other minor changes.fiscal years ending after December 15, 2024. We adoptedwill not early adopt the standard on January 1, 2021 and do not expect it to have a materialare currently evaluating the effect on our financial statements.

K46K52


2. Railway Operating Revenues

The following table disaggregates our revenues by major commodity group:
202020192018
($ in millions)
Merchandise:
Agriculture, forest and consumer products$2,116 $2,256 $2,188 
Chemicals1,809 2,092 2,083 
Metals and construction1,333 1,461 1,482 
Automotive830 994 991 
Merchandise6,088 6,803 6,744 
Intermodal2,654 2,824 2,893 
Coal1,047 1,669 1,821 
Total$9,789 $11,296 $11,458 

At the beginning of 2020, we combined the agriculture products and forest and consumer commodity groups. In addition, we also made changes in the categorization of certain other commodity groups within Merchandise. Specifically, certain commodities were shifted between agriculture, forest and consumer products; chemicals; and, metals and construction. We made these changes to better align our commodity groups as a result of an organizational realignment. Prior period railway operating revenues have been reclassified to conform to the current presentation.
202320222021
($ in millions)
Merchandise:
Agriculture, forest and consumer products$2,530 $2,493 $2,251 
Chemicals2,054 2,148 1,951 
Metals and construction1,634 1,652 1,562 
Automotive1,135 1,038 905 
Merchandise7,353 7,331 6,669 
Intermodal3,090 3,681 3,163 
Coal1,713 1,733 1,310 
Total$12,156 $12,745 $11,142 

We recognize the amount of revenues to which we expect to be entitled to for the transfer of promised goods or services to customers. A performance obligation is created when a customer under a transportation contract or public tariff submits a bill of lading to us for the transport of goods. These performance obligations are satisfied as the shipments move from origin to destination. As such, transportation revenues are recognized proportionally as a shipment moves, and related expenses are recognized as incurred. These performance obligations are generally short-term in nature with transit days averaging approximately one week or less for each commodity group. The customer has an unconditional obligation to pay for the service once the service has been completed. Estimated revenues associated with in-process shipments at period-end are recorded based on the estimated percentage of service completed. We had no material remaining performance obligations at December 31, 20202023 and 2019.2022.

We may provide customers ancillary services, such as switching, demurrage and other incidental activities, under their transportation contracts. These areThe revenues associated with these distinct performance obligations that are recognized at a point in time when the services are performed or as contractual obligations are met. These revenues are included within each of the commodity groups and represent approximately 5%, 7% and 7%, respectively, of total “Railway operating revenues” on the Consolidated Statements of Income for the years ended December 31, 20202023, 2022, and 2019, and approximately 4% for the year ended December 31, 2018.2021.

Revenues related to interline transportation services that involve another railroad are reported on a net basis. Therefore, the portion of the amount that relates to another party is not reflected in revenues.

K47


Under the typical terms of our freight contracts, payment for services is due within fifteen days of billing the customer, thus there are no significant financing components. “Accounts receivable – net” on the Consolidated Balance Sheets includes both customer and non-customer receivables as follows:

December 31,December 31,
202320232022
($ in millions)($ in millions)
December 31,
20202019
($ in millions)
Customer
Customer
Customer Customer $629 $682 
Non-customerNon-customer219 238 
Accounts receivable – net Accounts receivable – net$848 $920 
Accounts receivable – net
Accounts receivable – net

Non-customer receivables include non-revenue-related amounts due from other railroads, governmental entities, and others. “Other assets” on the Consolidated Balance Sheets includes non-current customer receivables of $23 million at both December 31, 2020 and 2019.  In 2019, we wrote off a $32 million non-current customer receivable resulting from a legal dispute and this expense is included in “Materials and other” on the Consolidated Statements of Income. We do not have any material contract assets or liabilities at December 31, 20202023 and 2019.2022.

K53


3.  Other Income – Net

202020192018 202320222021
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
     
Pension and other postretirement benefits (Note 12)Pension and other postretirement benefits (Note 12)$91 $63 $61 
Corporate-owned life insurance – net85 69 (10)
COLI – net
OtherOther(23)(26)16 
TotalTotal$153 $106 $67 
Total
Total
 
4.  Income Taxes
 202020192018
 ($ in millions)
Current:   
Federal$307 $356 $499 
State68 83 131 
Total current taxes375 439 630 
Deferred:   
Federal111 280 156 
State31 50 17 
Total deferred taxes142 330 173 
Income taxes$517 $769 $803 
 202320222021
 ($ in millions)
Current:   
Federal$437 $645 $553 
State105 132 136 
Total current taxes542 777 689 
Deferred:   
Federal(27)206 186 
State(22)(123)(2)
Total deferred taxes(49)83 184 
Income taxes$493 $860 $873 

K48


Reconciliation of Statutory Rate to Effective Rate
 
“Income taxes” on the Consolidated Statements of Income differs from the amounts computed by applying the statutory federal corporate tax rate as follows:
 202320222021
 Amount%Amount%Amount%
 ($ in millions)
Federal income tax at statutory rate$487 21.0 $867 21.0 $814 21.0 
State income taxes, net of federal tax effect65 2.9 143 3.5 139 3.6 
Tax credits(27)(1.2)(10)(0.2)(10)(0.3)
State law changes— — (136)(3.3)(34)(0.8)
Other, net(32)(1.4)(4)(0.2)(36)(1.0)
Income taxes$493 21.3 $860 20.8 $873 22.5 
 202020192018
 Amount%Amount%Amount%
 ($ in millions)
Federal income tax at statutory rate$531 21.0 $733 21.0 $728 21.0 
State income taxes, net of federal tax effect85 3.3 110 3.1 120 3.5 
Excess tax benefits on stock-based compensation(39)(1.5)(29)(0.8)(22)(0.7)
Other, net(60)(2.4)(45)(1.3)(23)(0.7)
Income taxes$517 20.4 $769 22.0 $803 23.1 

On July 8, 2022, House Bill 1342 was signed into law in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, which reduced its corporate income tax rate from 9.99% to 4.99%, through a series of phased reductions beginning each tax year from January 1, 2023 through January 1, 2031. GAAP requires companies to recognize the effect of tax law changes in the period of enactment. As a result, in 2022, we recognized a $136 million benefit in “Income taxes” with a corresponding reduction in “Deferred income taxes.”
K54



Deferred Tax Assets and Liabilities

Certain items are reported in different periods for financial reporting and income tax purposes.  Deferred tax assets and liabilities are recorded in recognition of these differences.  The tax effects of temporary differences that give rise to significant portions of the deferred tax assets and deferred tax liabilities are as follows:

December 31, December 31,
20202019 20232022
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Deferred tax assets:Deferred tax assets:  Deferred tax assets:  
Accruals, including casualty and other claims
Compensation and benefits, including postretirement benefitsCompensation and benefits, including postretirement benefits$218 $222 
Accruals, including casualty and other claims93 89 
OtherOther198 202 
Total gross deferred tax assetsTotal gross deferred tax assets509 513 
Less valuation allowanceLess valuation allowance(57)(54)
Net deferred tax assetsNet deferred tax assets452 459 
Deferred tax liabilities:Deferred tax liabilities:  
Deferred tax liabilities:
Deferred tax liabilities:  
PropertyProperty(6,820)(6,714)
OtherOther(554)(560)
Total deferred tax liabilitiesTotal deferred tax liabilities(7,374)(7,274)
Deferred income taxesDeferred income taxes$(6,922)$(6,815)
Deferred income taxes
Deferred income taxes

Except for amounts for which a valuation allowance has been provided, we believe that it is more likely than not that the results of future operations will generate sufficient taxable income to realize the deferred tax assets.  The valuation allowance at the end of each year primarily relates to subsidiary state income tax net operating losses and state investment tax credits that may not be utilized prior to their expiration.  The total valuation allowance decreased by $10 million in 2023, decreased by $19 million in 2022, and increased by $3 million in 2020, $4 million in 2019, and $6 million in 2018.2021.

K49


Uncertain Tax Positions
 
A reconciliation of the beginning and ending amount of unrecognized tax benefits is as follows:
 December 31,
 20232022
 ($ in millions)
Balance at beginning of year$22 $21 
Additions based on tax positions related to the current year30 
Additions for tax positions of prior years
Reductions for tax positions of prior years(1)— 
Settlements with taxing authorities— (2)
Lapse of statutes of limitations(5)(1)
Balance at end of year$55 $22 
K55


 December 31,
 20202019
 ($ in millions)
Balance at beginning of year$24 $21 
Additions based on tax positions related to the current year
Settlements with taxing authorities(4)
Lapse of statutes of limitations(2)(1)
Balance at end of year$22 $24 
Included in the balance of unrecognized tax benefits at December 31, 20202023 are potential benefits of $17$45 million that would affect the effective tax rate if recognized.  Unrecognized tax benefits are adjusted in the period in which new information about a tax position becomes available or the final outcome differs from the amount recorded.
 
The statute of limitations on Internal Revenue Service (IRS) examinations has expired for all years prior to 2017. The IRS accepted our 2012 amended income tax return. As a result, we received a refund of $46 million and recognized a tax benefit of $19 million in 2020.  State income tax returns are generally are subject to examination for a period of three to four years after filing the return. In addition, we are generally obligated to report changes in taxable income arising from federal income tax examinations to the states within a period of up to two years from the date the federal examination is final.  We have various state income tax returns either under examination, administrative appeal, or litigation.   

5.  Fair Value Measurements
 
FASB ASCAccounting Standards Codification (ASC) 820-10, Fair Value Measurements,established a framework for measuring fair value and a fair value hierarchy that prioritizes the inputs to valuation techniques used to measure fair value into three broad levels, as follows:

Level 1Inputs to the valuation methodology are unadjusted quoted prices for identical assets or liabilities in active markets that we have the ability to access.
Level 2Inputs to the valuation methodology include:
 
•         quoted prices for similar assets or liabilities in active markets,
•         quoted prices for identical or similar assets or liabilities in inactive markets,
•         inputs other than quoted prices that are observable for the asset or liability, and
•         inputs that are derived principally from or corroborated by observable market data by
          correlation or other means.
 If the asset or liability has a specified (contractual) term, the Level 2 input must be observable for substantially the full term of the asset or liability.
Level 3Inputs to the valuation methodology are unobservable and significant to the fair value measurement.

The asset or liability’s fair value measurement level within the hierarchy is based on the lowest level of any input that is significant to the fair value measurement.

K50


Fair Values of Financial Instruments

The fair values of “Cash and cash equivalents,” “Accounts receivable net,” “Accounts payable,” and “Accounts payable”“Short-term debt” approximate carrying values because of the short maturity of these financial instruments.  The carrying value of COLI is recorded at cash surrender value and, accordingly, approximates fair value. There are no other assets or liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis at December 31, 20202023 or 2019.2022. The carrying amounts and estimated fair values, based on Level 1 inputs, of long-term debt consist of the following at December 31:

 20202019
Carrying
Amount
Fair
Value
Carrying
Amount
Fair
Value
 ($ in millions)
Long-term debt, including current maturities$(12,681)$(16,664)$(12,196)$(14,806)
 20232022
Carrying
Amount
Fair
Value
Carrying
Amount
Fair
Value
 ($ in millions)
Long-term debt, including current maturities$(17,179)$(16,631)$(15,082)$(13,846)

K56


6.  Investments
 December 31,
 20202019
 ($ in millions)
Long-term investments:  
Equity method investments:  
Conrail Inc.$1,446 $1,387 
TTX Company798 749 
Other418 510 
Total equity method investments2,662 2,646 
Corporate-owned life insurance at net cash surrender value902 767 
Other investments26 15 
Total long-term investments$3,590 $3,428 
 December 31,
 20232022
 ($ in millions)
Long-term investments:  
Equity method investments:  
Conrail$1,656 $1,584 
TTX964 918 
Other428 421 
Total equity method investments3,048 2,923 
COLI at net cash surrender value774 752 
Other investments17 19 
Total long-term investments$3,839 $3,694 

Investment in Conrail
 
Through a limited liability company, we and CSX jointly own Conrail, Inc. (Conrail), whose primary subsidiary is CRC.  We have a 58% economic and 50% voting interest in the jointly-owned entity, and CSX has the remainder of the economic and voting interests.  We are amortizing the excess of the purchase price over Conrail’s net equity using the principles of purchase accounting, based primarily on the estimated useful lives of Conrail’s depreciable property and equipment, including the related deferred tax effect of the differences in book and tax accounting bases for such assets, as all of the purchase price at acquisition was allocable to Conrail’s tangible assets and liabilities. At December 31, 2023, our investment in Conrail exceeds our share of Conrail’s underlying net equity by $480 million.

CRC owns and operates certain properties (the Shared Assets Areas) for the joint and exclusive benefit of NSR and CSX Transportation, Inc. (CSXT).  The costs of operating the Shared Assets Areas are borne by NSR and CSXT based on usage.  In addition, NSR and CSXT pay CRC a fee for access to the Shared Assets Areas. “Purchased services and rents” and “Fuel” include expenses payable to CRC for operation of the Shared Assets Areas totaling $129$164 million in 2020, $1492023, $156 million in 2019,2022, and $150$147 million in 2018.2021. Future payments for access fees due to CRC under the Shared Assets Areas agreements are as follows: $41$44 million in each of 20212024 through 2023,2028 and $17 million in 2024.thereafter. We provide certain general and administrative support functions to Conrail, the fees for which are billed in accordance with several service-provider arrangements and approximate $6 million annually.

K51


In 2020, we converted $254 million of accounts payable into long-term advances from Conrail included in “Other liabilities.” “Accounts“Accounts payable” includes $56$198 million at December 31, 2020,2023, and $264$173 million at December 31, 2019,2022, due to Conrail for the operation of the Shared Assets Areas.  “Other liabilities” includes $534 million and $280 million at December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively, for long-term advances from Conrail, maturing in 2050 that bear interest at an average rate of 1.31%.

At December 31, 2020, the difference between our investment in Conrail and our share of Conrail’s underlying net equity was $494 million. Our equity in Conrail’s earnings, net of amortization, was $70 million for 2023, $58 million for 2020, $532022, and $56 million for 2019, and $55 million for 2018.2021. These amounts partially offset the costs of operating the Shared Assets Areas and are included in “Purchased services and rents.” Equity in Conrail’s earnings is included in the “Other net” line item within operating activities in the Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows.

K57


Investment in TTX

We and 8six other North American railroads jointlycollectively own TTX, Company (TTX), a railcar pooling company that provides its owner-railroads with standardized fleets of intermodal, automotive, and general use railcars at stated rates. We have a 19.65%19.78% ownership interest in TTX.

Expenses incurred for use of TTX equipment are included in “Purchased services and rents.” This amounted to $250$274 million, $244$256 million, and $262$246 million, respectively, for the years ended December 31, 2020, 20192023, 2022 and 2018.2021. Our equity in TTX’s earnings partially offsets these costs and totaled $48$47 million for 2020, $582023 and $53 million for 2019,both 2022 and $61 million for 2018.2021. Equity in TTX’s earnings is included in the “Other net” line item within operating activities in the Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows.

Impairment ofInvestment

In 2020, we recorded an other-than-temporary impairment of $99 million related to the carrying value of an equity method investment. This non-cash impairment charge is recorded in “Purchased services and rents” on the 2020 Consolidated Statement of Income and had a $74 million impact on net income.

K52


7. Properties
 AccumulatedNet BookDepreciation  AccumulatedNet BookDepreciation
December 31, 2020CostDepreciationValue
Rate (1)
December 31, 2023December 31, 2023CostDepreciationValue
Rate (1)
($ in millions)
LandLand$2,394 $$2,394                 0
Land
Land$2,439 $— $2,439                 —
Roadway:
Roadway:
Roadway:Roadway:      
Rail and other track materialRail and other track material7,153 (1,892)5,261 2.35 %Rail and other track material8,011 (2,006)(2,006)6,005 6,005 2.41 2.41 %
TiesTies5,685 (1,601)4,084 3.41 %Ties6,205 (1,773)(1,773)4,432 4,432 3.42 3.42 %
BallastBallast2,973 (774)2,199 2.76 %Ballast3,224 (937)(937)2,287 2,287 2.80 2.80 %
Construction in processConstruction in process297 297                 0Construction in process522 — — 522 522                 —                —
Other roadwayOther roadway14,320 (3,926)10,394 2.71 %Other roadway14,663 (4,290)(4,290)10,373 10,373 2.72 2.72 %
Total roadwayTotal roadway30,428 (8,193)22,235  Total roadway32,625 (9,006)(9,006)23,619 23,619   
Equipment:Equipment:    
Equipment:
Equipment:  
LocomotivesLocomotives5,478 (1,911)3,567 3.56 %Locomotives6,091 (2,105)(2,105)3,986 3,986 3.64 3.64 %
Freight carsFreight cars2,780 (1,023)1,757 2.59 %Freight cars2,792 (1,037)(1,037)1,755 1,755 2.42 2.42 %
Computers and softwareComputers and software732 (391)341 9.86 %Computers and software1,042 (542)(542)500 500 9.36 9.36 %
Construction in processConstruction in process333 333                 0Construction in process271 — — 271 271                 —                —
Other equipmentOther equipment1,094 (399)695 4.70 %Other equipment1,241 (501)(501)740 740 4.61 4.61 %
Total equipmentTotal equipment10,417 (3,724)6,693  Total equipment11,437 (4,185)(4,185)7,252 7,252   
Other propertyOther property91 (68)23 2.24 %
Other property
Other property90 (74)16 2.48 %
Total propertiesTotal properties$43,330 $(11,985)$31,345  
Total properties
Total properties$46,591 $(13,265)$33,326  
 
K53K58


 AccumulatedNet BookDepreciation  AccumulatedNet BookDepreciation
December 31, 2019CostDepreciationValue
Rate (1)
December 31, 2022December 31, 2022CostDepreciationValue
Rate (1)
($ in millions)
LandLand$2,385 $$2,385                 0
Land
Land$2,405 $— $2,405                 —
Roadway:
Roadway:
Roadway:Roadway:      
Rail and other track materialRail and other track material7,024 (1,905)5,119 2.30 %Rail and other track material7,589 (1,971)(1,971)5,618 5,618 2.42 2.42 %
TiesTies5,536 (1,496)4,040 3.37 %Ties5,981 (1,696)(1,696)4,285 4,285 3.49 3.49 %
BallastBallast2,868 (723)2,145 2.72 %Ballast3,126 (873)(873)2,253 2,253 2.84 2.84 %
Construction in processConstruction in process360 360                 0Construction in process431 — — 431 431                 —                —
Other roadwayOther roadway14,261 (3,786)10,475 2.71 %Other roadway14,270 (3,948)(3,948)10,322 10,322 2.69 2.69 %
Total roadwayTotal roadway30,049 (7,910)22,139  Total roadway31,397 (8,488)(8,488)22,909 22,909   
Equipment:Equipment:    
Equipment:
Equipment:  
LocomotivesLocomotives5,973 (2,112)3,861 3.66 %Locomotives5,878 (2,060)(2,060)3,818 3,818 3.66 3.66 %
Freight carsFreight cars2,988 (1,148)1,840 2.45 %Freight cars2,701 (1,033)(1,033)1,668 1,668 2.51 2.51 %
Computers and softwareComputers and software732 (355)377 9.68 %Computers and software926 (476)(476)450 450 9.10 9.10 %
Construction in processConstruction in process291 291                 0Construction in process206 — — 206 206                 —                —
Other equipmentOther equipment1,082 (388)694 4.89 %Other equipment1,145 (463)(463)682 682 4.51 4.51 %
Total equipmentTotal equipment11,066 (4,003)7,063  Total equipment10,856 (4,032)(4,032)6,824 6,824   
Other propertyOther property96 (69)27 1.05 %
Other property
Other property90 (72)18 2.26 %
Total propertiesTotal properties$43,596 $(11,982)$31,614  
Total properties
Total properties$44,748 $(12,592)$32,156  

(1)Composite annual depreciation rate for the underlying assets, excluding the effects of the amortization of any deficiency (or excess) that resulted from our depreciation studies.
 
In 2020, we sold $88 million of natural resource assets that were included in “Other current assets” on the Consolidated Balance Sheet at December 31, 2019. We recorded a $49 million impairment loss in 2019 related to these assets, which is reflected in “Gains and losses on properties” in the Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows for the year ended December 31, 2019.
Loss on Asset Disposal

In 2020, we sold 703 locomotives deemed excess and no longer needed for railroad operations. We evaluated these locomotive retirements and concluded they were abnormal (see Note 1). Accordingly, we recorded a $385 million loss to adjust their carrying amount to their estimated fair value, which resulted in a $97 million tax benefit.

Capitalized Interest
 
Total interest cost incurred on debt was $639$743 million, $620$708 million, and $574$657 million during 2020, 20192023, 2022 and 2018,2021, respectively, of which $14$21 million, $16 million, and $17$11 million was capitalized during 2020, 20192023, 2022 and 2018,2021, respectively.

K54K59


8.  Current Liabilities
 December 31,
 20202019
 ($ in millions)
Accounts payable:  
Accounts and wages payable$552 $710 
Casualty and other claims (Note 17)182 212 
Vacation liability121 136 
Due to Conrail (Note 6)56 264 
Other105 106 
Total$1,016 $1,428 
Other current liabilities:  
Interest payable$141 $149 
Current operating lease liability (Note 10)89 97 
Pension benefit obligations (Note 12)19 18 
Other53 63 
Total$302 $327 
 December 31,
 20232022
 ($ in millions)
Accounts payable:  
Accounts and wages payable$997 $712 
Due to Conrail (Note 6)198 173 
Casualty and other claims (Note 17)186 170 
Vacation liability144 136 
Other113 102 
Total$1,638 $1,293 
Other current liabilities:  
Current Eastern Ohio incident liability (Note 17)$346 $— 
Interest payable193 157 
Current operating lease liability (Note 10)105 94 
Pension benefit obligations (Note 12)21 20 
Other63 70 
Total$728 $341 

9.  Debt
 
Debt maturities are presented below:

 December 31,
 20202019
 ($ in millions)
Notes and debentures, with weighted-average interest rates as of December 31, 2020:  
3.65% maturing to 2025$2,673 $3,048 
4.32% maturing 2026 to 20312,714 2,714 
4.11% maturing 2037 to 20557,497 5,904 
6.07% maturing 2097 to 2118784 1,331 
Finance leases25 
Discounts, premiums, and debt issuance costs(1,012)(809)
Total debt12,681 12,196 
Less current maturities(579)(316)
Long-term debt excluding current maturities$12,102 $11,880 

 December 31,
 20232022
 ($ in millions)
Notes and debentures, with weighted-average interest rates as of December 31, 2023:  
4.20% maturing to 2028$2,370 $3,370 
4.03% maturing 2029 to 20333,094 1,995 
4.32% maturing 2034 to 206411,247 9,247 
5.22% maturing 2097 to 21211,384 1,384 
Securitization borrowings and finance leases17 116 
Discounts, premiums, and debt issuance costs(933)(930)
Total debt17,179 15,182 
Less current maturities and short-term debt(4)(703)
Long-term debt excluding current maturities and short-term debt$17,175 $14,479 
K55K60


Long-term debt maturities subsequent to 2021 are as follows: 
2022$553 
2023603 
2024403 
2025555 
2026 and subsequent years9,988 
  
Total$12,102 
Long-term debt maturities subsequent to 2024 are as follows: 
2025$556 
2026602 
2027621 
2028602 
2029 and subsequent years14,794 
  
Total$17,175 

In November 2023, we issued $400 million of 5.55% senior notes due 2034 and $600 million of 5.95% senior notes due 2064.

In August 2023, we issued $600 million of 5.05% senior notes due 2030 and $1.0 billion of 5.35% senior notes due 2054.

In February 2023, we issued $500 million of 4.45% senior notes due 2033.

In May 2020,2023, we issued $800 million of 3.05% senior notes due 2050, resulting in $790 million in net proceeds.

In May 2020, we also issued $800 million of 3.155% senior notes due 2055 in exchange for $554 million of previously issued notes ($450 million at 5.1% due 2118, $42 million at 6% due 2111, $29 million at 7.9% due 2097, $26 million at 6% due 2105, and $7 million at 7.05% due 2037). As part of the debt exchange, a $4 million loss on extinguishment was recognized in “Other income – net.”

In May 2020, we also renewed and amended our accounts receivable securitization program reducing ourwith a maximum borrowing capacity from $450 million toof $400 million. Amounts under our accounts receivable securitization program are borrowed and repaid from time to time in the ordinary course for general corporate and cash management purposes. The term of our accounts receivable securitization program expires in May 2021.2024. Amounts received under this facility are accounted for as borrowings. We had 0no amounts outstanding at either December 31, 2020 or 2019,2023 and our$100 million (at an average variable interest rate of 5.05%) outstanding under this program at December 31, 2022, which is included within “Short-term debt”. Our available borrowing capacity was $400 million and $429$300 million respectively.

The January 1, 2019at December 31, 2023 and December 31, 2018 “Cash, cash equivalents,2022, respectively. Our accounts receivable securitization program was supported by $903 million and restricted cash” line item$883 million in the Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows includes restricted cash of $88 million,receivables at December 31, 2023 and December 31, 2022, respectively, which reflects deposits held by a third-party bond agent as collateral for certain debt obligations which matured on October 1, 2019.are included in “Accounts receivable – net”.

Credit Agreement and Debt Covenants

InWe also have in place and available an $800 million credit agreement expiring in March 2020, we renewed and amended our five-year credit agreement. We increased the program’s borrowing capacity from $750 million to $800 million. The amended agreement expires in 2025, andwhich provides for borrowings at prevailing rates and includes covenants. We had 0no amounts outstanding under this facility at either December 31, 2020,2023 or 2019.
10.  LeasesDecember 31, 2022, and we are in compliance with all of its covenants.

In February 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-02, “Leases (Topic 842),” and subsequent amendments, which replaced existing lease guidance in GAAP and requires lessees to recognize ROU assets and lease liabilities on the balance sheet for leases greater than twelve months and disclose key information about leasing arrangements. We adopted the standard on January 1, 2019 using the modified retrospective method and used the effective date as our date of initial application. Financial information will not be updated and the disclosures required under the new standard will not be provided for dates and periods before January 1, 2019. Upon adoption of the standard, we recognized ROU assets and corresponding lease liabilities of $586 million on the Consolidated Balance Sheet as of January 1, 2019. There were no adjustments to “Retained income” on adoption.Subsequent Events

In January 2024, we renewed and amended our $800 million credit agreement. The standardamended agreement expires in January 2029, and provides a number of optional practical expedients for transition. We elected the package of practical expedients under the transition guidance which permitted us not to reassess under the new standard our prior conclusions for lease identificationborrowings at prevailing rates and lease classification on expired or existing contracts and whether initial direct costs previously capitalized would qualify for capitalization under FASB ASC 842. We also elected the practical expedient related to land easements, which allowed us to not reassess our current accounting treatment for existing agreements on land easements, which are not accounted for as leases. We did not elect the hindsight practical expedient to determine the reasonably certain lease term for existing leases.includes covenants.

In January 2024, we also entered into a term loan credit agreement that established a 364-day, $1.0 billion, unsecured delayed draw term loan facility under which we can borrow for general corporate purposes. The term loan credit agreement provides for borrowing at prevailing rates and includes covenants that align with the $800 million credit agreement.
K56
K61


The standard also provides practical expedients and recognition exemptions for an entity’s ongoing accounting policy elections. We elected the short-term lease recognition exemption for all leases that qualify. This means, for those leases that qualify, we do not recognize ROU assets or lease liabilities. We also elected the practical expedient not to separate lease and non-lease components for all of our leases.10.  Leases

We are committed under long-term lease agreements for equipment, lines of road, and other property. We combine lease and non-lease components for new and reassessed leases. Some of these agreements are variable lease agreements that include usage-based payments. These agreements contain payment provisions that depend on an index or rate, initially measured using the index or rate at the lease commencement date, and are therefore not included in our future minimum lease payments. Our long-term lease agreements do not contain any material restrictive covenants.

Our equipment leases have remaining terms of less than 1 year to 57 years and our lines of road and land leases have remaining terms of less than 1 year to 137134 years. Some of these leases include options to extend the leases for up to 99 years and some include options to terminate the leases within 30 days. Because we are not reasonably certain to exercise these renewal options, the options are not considered in determining the lease term, and associated payments are excluded from future minimum lease payments.

Leases with an initial term of twelve months or less are not recorded on the balance sheet. We recognize lease expense for these leases on a straight-line basis over the lease term.

Operating lease amounts included on the Consolidated Balance Sheets are as follows:

December 31,
20202019
($ in millions)
Classification
December 31,December 31,
202320232022
($ in millions)($ in millions)
Classification
AssetsAssets
ROU assetsOther assets$433 $539 
Assets
Assets
Right-of-use (ROU) assets
Right-of-use (ROU) assets
Right-of-use (ROU) assets
LiabilitiesLiabilities
Liabilities
Liabilities
Current lease liabilities
Current lease liabilities
Current lease liabilitiesCurrent lease liabilitiesOther current liabilities$89 $97 
Non-current lease liabilitiesNon-current lease liabilitiesOther liabilities344 441 
Total lease liabilitiesTotal lease liabilities$433 $538 
Total lease liabilities
Total lease liabilities

The components of total lease expense, primarily included in “Purchased services and rents,” are as follows:
20202019
($ in millions)
Operating lease expense$109 $114 
Variable lease expense42 57 
Short-term lease expense
Total lease expense$160 $176 

202320222021
($ in millions)
Operating lease expense$115 $101 $106 
Variable lease expense84 55 44 
Short-term lease expense15 18 
Total lease expense$214 $174 $159 

In March 2019, we entered into a non-cancellable lease for an office building with an estimated construction cost of $550 million. The lease will commence upon completion ofbuilding. In 2021, the construction (for which we are a construction agent) of the office building which is expected to be inwas completed and the second half of 2021.lease commenced. The initial lease term is five years
K57


with options to renew, purchase, or sell the office building at the end of the lease term. Upon lease commencement, the ROU asset and lease liability will be determined and recorded. The lease also contains a residual value guarantee of up to 90eighty-three percent of the total construction cost.cost of $499 million.

K62


We currently operate approximately 337 miles of railway that extends from Cincinnati, Ohio to Chattanooga, Tennessee under an operating lease agreement. Lease expense associated with this agreement totaled $26 million, $25 million, and $24 million in 2023, 2022, and 2021, respectively. In 2022, we entered into an asset purchase and sale agreement with the Board of Trustees of the Cincinnati Southern Railway to purchase this line (see further discussion in Note 17). The total purchase price is expected to be approximately $1.7 billion and will close on March 15, 2024. At close, the existing lease arrangement will terminate and the assets purchased will be reflected in “Properties.”

Other information related to operating leases is as follows:
December 31,
20202019
Weighted-average remaining lease term (years) on operating leases8.188.25
Weighted-average discount rates on operating leases3.50 %3.52 %
December 31,
20232022
Weighted-average remaining lease term (years) on operating leases6.126.67
Weighted-average discount rates on operating leases3.78 %3.16 %

As the rates implicit in most of our leases are not readily determinable, we use a collateralized incremental borrowing rate based on the information available at the lease commencement date in determining the present value of future payments. We use the portfolio approach and group leases into short-, medium-, and long-term categories, applying the corresponding incremental borrowing rates to these categories.

During 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively, ROU assets obtained in exchange for new operating lease liabilities were $22$65 million and $49 million.$57 million, respectively. Cash paid for amounts included in the measurement of lease liabilities was $109$117 million and $114$100 million in 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively, and is included in operating cash flows. During 2019, cash proceeds from a sale and leaseback transaction were $82 million and the gain on the transaction was $15 million.

Future minimum lease payments under non-cancellable operating leases are as follows:
December 31, 2020
($ in millions)
2021$101 
202276 
202367 
202458 
202557 
2026 and subsequent years145 
Total lease payments504 
Less: Interest71 
Present value of lease liabilities$433 
December 31, 2023
($ in millions)
2024$116 
2025105 
202685 
202742 
202830 
2029 and subsequent years66 
Total lease payments444 
Less: Interest52 
Present value of lease liabilities$392 

K58K63



December 31, 2019
($ in millions)
2020$110 
2021104 
202279 
202370 
202461 
2025 and subsequent years206 
Total lease payments630 
Less: Interest92 
Present value of lease liabilities$538 

Operating lease expense accounted for under ASC 840 “Leases” in 2018 included $102 million for minimum rents and $102 million for contingent rents. Contingent rents are primarily comprised of usage-based payments for equipment under service contracts.
December 31, 2022
($ in millions)
2023$103 
202495 
202587 
202669 
202727 
2028 and subsequent years81 
Total lease payments462 
Less: Interest52 
Present value of lease liabilities$410 

11.  Other Liabilities

December 31, December 31,
20202019 20232022
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Long-term advances from Conrail (Note 6)Long-term advances from Conrail (Note 6)$534 $280 
Long-term advances from Conrail (Note 6)
Long-term advances from Conrail (Note 6)
Non-current operating lease liability (Note 10)Non-current operating lease liability (Note 10)344 441 
Net pension benefit obligations (Note 12)Net pension benefit obligations (Note 12)340 302 
Casualty and other claims (Note 17)
Net other postretirement benefit obligations (Note 12)Net other postretirement benefit obligations (Note 12)306 287 
Casualty and other claims (Note 17)169 171 
Non-current Eastern Ohio incident liability (Note 17)
Deferred compensationDeferred compensation107 104 
OtherOther187 159 
TotalTotal$1,987 $1,744 
Total
Total

12.  Pensions and Other Postretirement Benefits
 
We have both funded and unfunded defined benefit pension plans covering eligible employees. We also provide specified health care benefits to eligible retired employees; these plans can be amended or terminated at our option.  Under our self-insured retiree health care plan, for those participants who are not Medicare-eligible, certain health care expenses are covered for retired employees and their dependents, reduced by any deductibles, coinsurance, and, in some cases, coverage provided under other group insurance policies.  Eligible retired participants and their spouses who are Medicare-eligible are not covered under the self-insured retiree health care plan, but instead are provided with an employer-funded health reimbursement account which can be used for reimbursement of health insurance premiums or eligible out-of-pocket medical expenses.

K59K64


Pension and Other Postretirement Benefit Obligations and Plan Assets

Pension BenefitsOther Postretirement
Benefits
Pension BenefitsPension BenefitsOther Postretirement
Benefits
2020201920202019 2023202220232022
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Change in benefit obligations:Change in benefit obligations:    Change in benefit obligations:  
Benefit obligation at beginning of yearBenefit obligation at beginning of year$2,588 $2,371 $457 $466 
Service costService cost40 35 
Interest costInterest cost74 93 12 17 
Actuarial losses294 235 35 28 
Plan amendment(18)
Actuarial losses (gains)
Plan amendments
Benefits paidBenefits paid(151)(146)(39)(42)
Benefit obligation at end of yearBenefit obligation at end of year2,845 2,588 471 457 
Change in plan assets:Change in plan assets:    
Change in plan assets:
Change in plan assets:  
Fair value of plan assets at beginning of yearFair value of plan assets at beginning of year2,462 2,105 170 158 
Actual return on plan assetsActual return on plan assets345 485 21 34 
Employer contribution19 18 13 20 
Employer contributions
Benefits paidBenefits paid(151)(146)(39)(42)
Fair value of plan assets at end of yearFair value of plan assets at end of year2,675 2,462 165 170 
Funded status at end of yearFunded status at end of year$(170)$(126)$(306)$(287)
Funded status at end of year
Funded status at end of year
Amounts recognized in the Consolidated    
Balance Sheets:    
Amounts recognized in the Consolidated Balance Sheets:
Amounts recognized in the Consolidated Balance Sheets:
Amounts recognized in the Consolidated Balance Sheets:  
Other assetsOther assets$189 $194 $$
Other current liabilitiesOther current liabilities(19)(18)
Other liabilitiesOther liabilities(340)(302)(306)(287)
Net amount recognizedNet amount recognized$(170)$(126)$(306)$(287)
Net amount recognized
Net amount recognized
Amounts included in accumulated other comprehensiveAmounts included in accumulated other comprehensive    
Amounts included in accumulated other comprehensive
Amounts included in accumulated other comprehensive  
loss (before tax):loss (before tax):    loss (before tax):  
Net loss$869 $781 $57 $29 
Prior service cost (benefit)(228)(253)
Net (gain) loss
Prior service benefit

Our accumulated benefit obligation for our defined benefit pension plans is $2.6$2.0 billion and $2.3$1.9 billion at December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively.  Our unfunded pension plans, included above, which in all cases have no assets, had projected benefit obligations of $359$300 million and $320$275 million at December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively, and had accumulated benefit obligations of $330$273 million and $292$249 million at December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively.
 
K60K65


Pension and Other Postretirement Benefit Cost Components

202020192018 202320222021
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Pension benefits:Pension benefits:   
Pension benefits:
Pension benefits:  
Service costService cost$40 $35 $39 
Interest costInterest cost74 93 83 
Expected return on plan assetsExpected return on plan assets(190)(179)(177)
Amortization of net lossesAmortization of net losses51 43 57 
Amortization of prior service cost
Amortization of prior service benefit
Net cost (benefit)$(24)$(7)$
Net benefit
Net benefit
Net benefit
Other postretirement benefits:
Other postretirement benefits:
Other postretirement benefits:Other postretirement benefits:     
Service costService cost$$$
Interest costInterest cost12 17 15 
Expected return on plan assetsExpected return on plan assets(14)(14)(15)
Amortization of net losses
Amortization of prior service benefitAmortization of prior service benefit(25)(24)(24)
Net benefitNet benefit$(21)$(15)$(17)
Net benefit
Net benefit

Other Changes in Plan Assets and Benefit Obligations Recognized in Other Comprehensive Income

2020 2023
Pension
Benefits
Pension
Benefits
Other
Postretirement 
Benefits
Pension
Benefits
Other
Postretirement 
Benefits
($ in millions)
($ in millions)
Net gains arising during the year
Net gains arising during the year
Net gains arising during the year
Net loss arising during the year$139 $28 
Prior service effect of plan amendment
Prior service effect of plan amendment
Prior service effect of plan amendment
Amortization of net losses
Amortization of prior service benefit
Amortization of net losses(51)
Amortization of prior service (cost) benefit(1)25 
Total recognized in other comprehensive income
Total recognized in other comprehensive income
Total recognized in other comprehensive incomeTotal recognized in other comprehensive income$87 $53 
    
Total recognized in net periodic cost and other comprehensive incomeTotal recognized in net periodic cost and other comprehensive income$63 $32 
 
Net lossesgains arising during the year for both pension benefits and other postretirement benefits were due primarily to decreases in discount rates, partially offset by higher actual returns on plan assets.assets offset by a decrease in discount rates.

The estimated net losses and prior service credits for the pension plans that will be amortized from accumulated other comprehensive loss into net periodic cost over the next year are $66$16 million.  The estimated net lossesgains and prior service benefit for the other postretirement benefit plans that will be amortized from accumulated other comprehensive loss into net periodic benefit over the next year is $23$26 million.

K61K66


Pension and Other Postretirement Benefits Assumptions
 
Costs for pension and other postretirement benefits are determined based on actuarial valuations that reflect appropriate assumptions as of the measurement date, ordinarily the beginning of each year.  The funded status of the plans is determined using appropriate assumptions as of each year end.  A summary of the major assumptions follows:

202020192018 202320222021
Pension funded status:Pension funded status:   Pension funded status:  
Discount rateDiscount rate2.67 %3.38 %4.33 %Discount rate5.23 %5.56 %2.97 %
Future salary increasesFuture salary increases4.21 %4.21 %4.21 %Future salary increases4.44 %4.44 %4.44 %
Other postretirement benefits funded status:Other postretirement benefits funded status:   Other postretirement benefits funded status:   
Discount rateDiscount rate2.27 %3.13 %4.18 %Discount rate5.11 %5.45 %2.72 %
Pension cost:Pension cost:   Pension cost:   
Discount rate - service costDiscount rate - service cost3.71 %4.55 %4.01 %Discount rate - service cost5.75 %3.25 %3.14 %
Discount rate - interest costDiscount rate - interest cost2.92 %3.99 %3.33 %Discount rate - interest cost5.40 %2.45 %1.95 %
Return on assets in plansReturn on assets in plans8.25 %8.25 %8.25 %Return on assets in plans8.00 %8.00 %8.00 %
Future salary increasesFuture salary increases4.21 %4.21 %4.21 %Future salary increases4.44 %4.44 %4.44 %
Other postretirement benefits cost:Other postretirement benefits cost:   Other postretirement benefits cost:   
Discount rate - service cost
Discount rate - service cost
3.41 %4.39 %3.83 %
Discount rate - service cost
5.56 %3.01 %2.71 %
Discount rate - interest costDiscount rate - interest cost2.69 %3.83 %3.13 %Discount rate - interest cost5.23 %2.13 %1.57 %
Return on assets in plansReturn on assets in plans8.00 %8.00 %8.00 %Return on assets in plans7.75 %7.75 %7.75 %
Health care trend rateHealth care trend rate6.25 %6.50 %6.30 %Health care trend rate7.00 %6.50 %6.00 %

To determine the discount rates used to measure our benefit obligations, we utilize analyses in which the projected annual cash flows from the pension and other postretirement benefit plans were matched with yield curves based on an appropriate universe of high-quality corporate bonds.  We use the results of the yield curve analyses to select the discount rates that match the payment streams of the benefits in these plans.

We use a spot rate approach to estimate the service cost and interest cost components of net periodic benefit cost for our pension and other postretirement benefit plans.
 
Health Care Cost Trend Assumptions
 
For measurement purposes at December 31, 2020,2023, increases in the per capita cost of pre-Medicare covered health care benefits were assumed to be 6.00%6.5% for 2021.2024.  We assume the rate will ratably decrease to an ultimate rate of 5.0% for 20252030 and remain at that level thereafter.
Assumed health care cost trend rates affect the amounts reported in the financial statements.  To illustrate, a one-percentage point change in the assumed health care cost trend would have the following effects:

 One-percentage Point
 IncreaseDecrease
 ($ in millions)
Increase (decrease) in:  
Total service and interest cost components$$(1)
Postretirement benefit obligation(8)

K62


Asset Management
 
NaNThirteen investment firms manage our defined benefit pension plan’s assets under investment guidelines approved by our Benefits Investment Committee that is composed of members of our management.  Investments are restricted to domestic and international equity securities, domestic and international fixed income securities, and unleveraged exchange-traded options and financial futures.  Limitations restrict investment concentration and use of certain derivative investments.  The target asset allocation for equity is 75% of the pension plan’s assets.  Fixed income investments must consist predominantly of securities rated investment grade or higher. Equity investments must be in liquid securities listed on national exchanges.  No investment is permitted in our securities (except through commingled pension trust funds).
 
K67


Our pension plan’s weighted-average asset allocations, by asset category, were as follows:
Percentage of Plan
Assets at December 31,
 20202019
Domestic equity securities52 %50 %
International equity securities24 %24 %
Debt securities22 %24 %
Cash and cash equivalents%%
Total100 %100 %

Percentage of Plan
Assets at December 31,
 20232022
Domestic equity securities50 %53 %
Debt securities24 %26 %
International equity securities24 %20 %
Cash and cash equivalents%%
Total100 %100 %

The other postretirement benefit plan assets consist primarily of trust-owned variable life insurance policies with an asset allocation at December 31, 20202023 of 68%66% in equity securities and 32%34% in debt securities compared with 67%64% in equity securities and 33%36% in debt securities at December 31, 2019.2022.  The target asset allocation for equity is between 50% and 75% of the plan’s assets.
 
The plans’ assumed future returns are based principally on the asset allocations and historical returns for the plans’ asset classes determined from both actual plan returns and, over longer time periods, expected market returns for those asset classes.  For 2021,2024, we assume an 8.00% return on pension plan assets.

K63


Fair Value of Plan Assets
 
The following is a description of the valuation methodologies used for pension plan assets measured at fair value.
 
Common Stock:stock:  Shares held by the plan at year end are valued at the official closing price as defined by the exchange or at the most recent trade price of the security at the close of the active market.
 
Common collective trusts:  The readily determinable fair value is based on the published fair value per unit of the trusts.  The common collective trusts hold equity securities, fixed income securities and cash and cash equivalents.
 
Fixed income securities:  Valued based on quotes received from independent pricing services or at an estimated price at which a dealer would pay for the security at year end using observable market-based inputs.

Commingled funds:  The readily determinable fair value is based on the published fair value per unit of the funds.  The commingled funds hold equity securities.
 
Cash and cash equivalents:  Short-term Treasury bills or notes are valued at an estimated price at which a dealer would pay for the security at year end using observable market-based inputs; money market funds are valued at the closing price reported on the active market on which the funds are traded.
 
K68


The following table sets forth the pension plan’s assets by valuation technique level, within the fair value hierarchy. There were no level 3 valued assets at December 31, 20202023 or 2019.2022.

December 31, 2020 December 31, 2023
Level 1Level 2Total Level 1Level 2Total
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Common stockCommon stock$1,483 $$1,483 
Common stock
Common stock
Common collective trusts:Common collective trusts:   Common collective trusts:  
International equity securitiesInternational equity securities399 399 
Debt securitiesDebt securities297 297 
Domestic equity securities
Fixed income securities:Fixed income securities:
Government and agencies securities
Government and agencies securities
Government and agencies securitiesGovernment and agencies securities146 146 
Corporate bondsCorporate bonds117 117 
Mortgage and other asset-backed securitiesMortgage and other asset-backed securities24 24 
Commingled fundsCommingled funds149 149 
Cash and cash equivalentsCash and cash equivalents60 60 
Total investmentsTotal investments$1,543 $1,132 $2,675 
Total investments
Total investments

K64


December 31, 2019 December 31, 2022
Level 1Level 2Total Level 1Level 2Total
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Common stockCommon stock$1,329 $$1,329 
Common stock
Common stock
Common collective trusts:Common collective trusts:   Common collective trusts:  
International equity securitiesInternational equity securities377 377 
Debt securitiesDebt securities303 303 
Domestic equity securities
Fixed income securities:Fixed income securities:
Government and agencies securities
Government and agencies securities
Government and agencies securitiesGovernment and agencies securities172 172 
Corporate bondsCorporate bonds84 84 
Mortgage and other asset-backed securitiesMortgage and other asset-backed securities26 26 
Commingled fundsCommingled funds121 121 
Commingled funds
Commingled funds
Cash and cash equivalentsCash and cash equivalents50 50 
Total investmentsTotal investments$1,379 $1,083 $2,462 
Total investments
Total investments
 
The following is a description of the valuation methodologies used for other postretirement benefit plan assets measured at fair value.
 
Trust-owned life insurance:  Valued at our share of the net assets ofinterest in trust-owned life insurance issued by a major insurance company.  The underlying investments of that trustowned by the insurance company consist of a U.S. stock account and a U.S. bond account but may retain cash at times as well. The U.S. stock account and U.S. bond account are valued based on readily determinable fair values.

K69


The other postretirement benefit plan assets consisted of trust-owned life insurance with fair values of $165$138 million and $170$122 million at December 31, 20202023 and 2019,2022, respectively, and are valued under level 2 of the fair value hierarchy. There were no level 1 or level 3 valued assets.
 
Contributions and Estimated Future Benefit Payments
 
In 2021,2024, we expect to contribute approximately $19$22 million to our unfunded pension plans for payments to pensioners and approximately $36$31 million to our other postretirement benefit plans for retiree health and death benefits.  We do not expect to contribute to our funded pension plan in 2021.2024. 

Benefit payments, which reflect expected future service, as appropriate, are expected to be paid as follows:

Pension
Benefits
Other
Postretirement 
Benefits
 ($ in millions)
2021$147 $36 
2022146 35 
2023145 33 
2024145 32 
2025144 31 
Years 2026 – 2030719 142 
Pension
Benefits
Other
Postretirement 
Benefits
 ($ in millions)
2024$151 $31 
2025149 30 
2026148 29 
2027148 28 
2028148 27 
Years 2029 – 2033743 127 
 
K65


Other Postretirement Coverage
 
Under collective bargaining agreements, Norfolk Southern and certain subsidiaries participate in a multi-employer benefit plan, which provides certain postretirement health care and life insurance benefits to eligible craft employees.  Premiums under this plan are expensed as incurred and totaled $22$11 million, $13 million, and $21 million in 2020, $31 million in 2019, and $35 million in 2018.2023, 2022, 2021, respectively.
 
Section 401(k) Plans
 
Norfolk Southern and certain subsidiaries provide Section 401(k) savings plans for employees.  Under the plans, we match a portion of employee contributions, subject to applicable limitations.  Our matching contributions, recorded as an expense, totaled $21$25 million, in 2020, $22 million, in 2019, and $23 million in 2018.2023, 2022, 2021, respectively.

13.  Stock-Based Compensation
 
Under the stockholder-approved LTIP, the Human Capital Management and Compensation Committee (Committee), which is made up of nonemployee members of the Board, or the Chief Executive Officer (when delegated authority by such Committee), may grant stock options, stock appreciation rights (SARs), restricted stock units (RSUs), restricted shares, performance share units (PSUs), and performance shares, up to a maximum of 104,125,000 shares of our Common Stock, of which 8,995,5827,731,573 remain available for future grants as of December 31, 2020.2023.  
 
The number of shares remaining for issuance under the LTIP is reduced (i) by 1 for each award granted as a stock option or stock-settled SAR, or (ii) by 1.61 for an award made in the form other than a stock option or stock-settled SAR.  Under the Board-approved Thoroughbred Stock Option Plan (TSOP), the Committee may grant stock options up to a maximum of 6,000,000 shares of Common Stock. We use newly issued shares to satisfy any exercises and awards under the LTIP and the TSOP.

K70


The LTIP also permits the payment, on a current or a deferred basis and in cash or in stock, of dividend equivalents on shares of Common Stock covered by stock options, RSUs, or PSUs in an amount commensurate with regular quarterly dividends paid on Common Stock.  With respect to stock options, if employment of the participant is terminated for any reason, including retirement, disability, or death, we have no further obligation to make any dividend equivalent payments.  Regarding RSUs, we have no further obligation to make any dividend equivalent payments unless employment of the participant is terminated as a result of qualifying retirement or disability. Should an employee terminate employment, they are not required to forfeit dividend equivalent payments already received.  Outstanding PSUs do not receive dividend equivalent payments.
 
The Committee granted stock options, RSUs and PSUs pursuant to the LTIP for the last three years as follows:

202020192018
 GrantedWeighted- Average Grant-Date Fair ValueGrantedWeighted- Average Grant-Date Fair ValueGrantedWeighted- Average Grant-Date Fair Value
2023202320222021
Granted GrantedWeighted- Average Grant-Date Fair ValueGrantedWeighted- Average Grant-Date Fair ValueGrantedWeighted- Average Grant-Date Fair Value
Stock optionsStock options43,770$52.05 47,360$45.74 40,960$41.70 
RSUsRSUs178,190210.11 219,710164.47 217,290148.37 
PSUsPSUs78,830212.66 102,250160.97 92,314147.47 

Beginning in 2018, recipientsRecipients of certain RSUs and PSUs pursuant to the LTIP who retire prior to October 1st will forfeit awards received in the current year. Receipt of certain LTIP awards is contingent on the recipient having executed a non-compete agreement with the company.

K66


We account for our grants of stock options, RSUs, PSUs, and dividend equivalent payments in accordance with FASB ASC 718, “Compensation - Stock Compensation.” Accordingly, all awards result in charges to net income while dividend equivalent payments, which are all related to equity classified awards, are charged to retained income. Compensation cost for the awards is recognized on a straight-line basis over the requisite service period for the entire award. Related compensation costs and tax benefits during the years were:

202020192018 202320222021
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
Stock-based compensation expenseStock-based compensation expense$28 $53 $47 
Stock-based compensation expense
Stock-based compensation expense
Total tax benefitTotal tax benefit44 37 33 

Stock Options
 
Option exercise prices will be at least the higher of (i) the average of the high and low prices at which Common Stock is traded on the grant date, or (ii) the closing price of Common Stock on the grant date.  All options are subject to a vesting period of at least one year, and the term of the option will not exceed ten years. Holders of the options granted under the LTIP who remain actively employed receive cash dividend equivalent payments for four years in an amount equal to the regular quarterly dividends paid on Common Stock.

For all years, options granted under the LTIP and the TSOP may not be exercised prior to the fourth and third anniversaries of the date of grant, respectively, or if the optionee retires or dies before that anniversary date, may not be exercised before the later of one year after the grant date or the date of the optionee’s retirement or death.
 
The fair value of each option awarded was measured on the date of grant using the Black-Scholes valuation model. Expected volatility is based on implied volatility from traded options on, and historical volatility of, Common Stock.  Historical data is used to estimate option exercises and employee terminations within the valuation model. Historical exercise data is used to estimate the average expected option term. The average risk-free interest rate is
K71


based on the U.S. Treasury yield curve in effect at the time of grant.  A dividend yield of 0zero was used for the LTIP options during the vesting period.  For 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018,2021, a dividend yield of 1.76%2.24%, 2.06%1.85%, and 1.94%1.64%, respectively, was used for allthe vested period during the remaining expected option term for LTIP options.

The assumptions for the LTIP grants for the last three years are shown in the following table:

202020192018 202320222021
Average expected volatilityAverage expected volatility22 %23 %24 %
Average expected volatility
Average expected volatility27 %27 %26 %
Average risk-free interest rateAverage risk-free interest rate1.47 %2.56 %2.55 %Average risk-free interest rate3.54 %1.80 %0.75 %
Average expected option termAverage expected option term7.5 years7.2 years7.2 yearsAverage expected option term7.0 years6.5 years7.5 years

K67


A summary of changes in stock options is presented below:

Stock
Options
Stock
Options
Weighted- Average
Exercise Price 
Stock
Options
Weighted- Average
Exercise Price 
Outstanding at December 31, 20192,677,449 $91.51 
Outstanding at December 31, 2022
Outstanding at December 31, 2022
Outstanding at December 31, 2022
GrantedGranted43,770 213.54 
ExercisedExercised(1,171,786)86.12 
ForfeitedForfeited(23,308)156.02 
Outstanding at December 31, 20201,526,125 98.17 
Outstanding at December 31, 2023
Outstanding at December 31, 2023
Outstanding at December 31, 2023
 
The aggregate intrinsic value of options outstanding at December 31, 20202023 was $213$66 million with a weighted-average remaining contractual term of 4.64.0 years.  Of these options outstanding, 1,220,685570,428 were exercisable and had an aggregate intrinsic value of $183$66 million with a weighted-average exercise price of $87.75$123.27 and a weighted-average remaining contractual term of 2.91.6 years.

The following table provides information related to options exercised for the last three years:
 202020192018
 ($ in millions)
Options exercised1,171,786 770,597 840,175 
Total intrinsic value$144 $86 $72 
Cash received upon exercise98 53 58 
Related tax benefits realized29 18 16 
 202320222021
 ($ in millions)
Options exercised206,016 307,660 470,632 
Total intrinsic value$27 $54 $83 
Cash received upon exercise19 25 42 
Related tax benefits realized12 17 
 
At December 31, 2020,2023, total unrecognized compensation related to options granted under the LTIP was $1$3 million, and is expected to be recognized over a weighted-average period of approximately 2.4 years.

K72


Restricted Stock Units
 
Beginning in 2018, RSUs granted primarily have a four-year ratable restriction period and will be settled through the issuance of shares of Common Stock. RSUs granted prior to 2018 have a five-year restriction period and will also be settled through the issuance of shares of Common Stock. Certain RSU grants include cash dividend equivalent payments during the restriction period in an amount equal to regular quarterly dividends paid on Common Stock. The fair value of each RSU was measured on the date of grant as the average of the high and low prices at which Common Stock is traded on the grant date, adjusted for the impact of dividend equivalent payments as applicable.

202020192018 202320222021
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
RSUs vestedRSUs vested204,665 166,197 160,200 
RSUs vested
RSUs vested
Common Stock issued net of tax withholdingCommon Stock issued net of tax withholding146,047 119,346 99,968 
Related tax benefit realized$$$
Related tax benefits realized

K68


A summary of changes in RSUs is presented below:

RSUsRSUsWeighted-
Average
Grant-Date
Fair Value
RSUsWeighted-
Average
Grant-Date
Fair Value
Nonvested at December 31, 2019666,172 $127.77 
Nonvested at December 31, 2022
Nonvested at December 31, 2022
Nonvested at December 31, 2022
GrantedGranted178,190 210.11 
VestedVested(204,665)130.87 
ForfeitedForfeited(39,457)171.33 
Nonvested at December 31, 2020600,240 148.29 
Nonvested at December 31, 2023
Nonvested at December 31, 2023
Nonvested at December 31, 2023
 
At December 31, 2020,2023, total unrecognized compensation related to RSUs was $29$45 million, and is expected to be recognized over a weighted-average period of approximately 2.42.5 years. 
 
Performance Share Units
 
PSUs provide for awards based on the achievement of certain predetermined corporate performance goals at the end of a three-year cycle and are settled through the issuance of shares of Common Stock. All PSUs will earn out based on the achievement of performance conditions and some will also earn out based on a market condition. The market condition fair value was measured on the date of grant using a Monte Carlo simulation model.

202020192018 202320222021
($ in millions) ($ in millions)
PSUs earnedPSUs earned235,935 331,099 154,189 
PSUs earned
PSUs earned
Common Stock issued net of tax withholdingCommon Stock issued net of tax withholding156,477 221,241 94,399 
Related tax benefit realized$$$
Related tax benefits realized

K73


A summary of changes in PSUs is presented below:

PSUsPSUsWeighted-
Average
Grant-Date
Fair Value
PSUsWeighted-
Average
Grant-Date
Fair Value
Balance at December 31, 2019456,510 $114.04 
Balance at December 31, 2022
Balance at December 31, 2022
Balance at December 31, 2022
GrantedGranted78,830 212.66 
EarnedEarned(235,935)89.70 
UnearnedUnearned(33,705)58.77 
ForfeitedForfeited(25,600)177.41 
Balance at December 31, 2020240,100 171.34 
Balance at December 31, 2023
Balance at December 31, 2023
Balance at December 31, 2023
 
At December 31, 2020,2023, total unrecognized compensation related to PSUs granted under the LTIP was $5$2 million, and is expected to be recognized over a weighted-average period of approximately 1.7 years.

K69


Shares Available and Issued
 
Shares of Common Stock available for future grants and issued in connection with all features of the LTIP and the TSOP at December 31, were as follows:
 202020192018
Available for future grants:   
LTIP8,995,582 9,294,726 8,644,108 
TSOP435,699 434,401 422,973 
Issued:   
LTIP1,270,208 852,869 820,746 
TSOP204,102 258,315 213,796 
 202320222021
Available for future grants:   
LTIP7,731,573 8,238,993 8,609,075 
TSOP436,571 436,402 435,867 
Issued:   
LTIP315,700 503,090 632,279 
TSOP40,640 35,002 72,639 
 
K74


14. Stockholders’ Equity

Common Stock

Common Stock is reported net of shares held by our consolidated subsidiaries (Treasury Shares). Treasury Shares at December 31, 20202023 and 20192022 amounted to 20,320,777, with a cost of $19 million at both dates.   

Accumulated Other Comprehensive Loss

The components of “Other comprehensive income (loss)”income” reported in the Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income and changes in the cumulative balances of “Accumulated other comprehensive loss” reported in the Consolidated Balance Sheets consisted of the following:

Balance
at Beginning
of Year
Balance
at Beginning
of Year
Net IncomeReclassification
Adjustments
Balance
at End
of Year
Balance
at Beginning
of Year
Net Income
(Loss)
Reclassification
Adjustments
Balance
at End
of Year
($ in millions)    
Year ended December 31, 2023Year ended December 31, 2023  
($ in millions)    
Year ended December 31, 2020    
Pensions and other postretirement liabilities
Pensions and other postretirement liabilities
Pensions and other postretirement liabilitiesPensions and other postretirement liabilities$(421)$(125)$20 $(526)
Other comprehensive income of equity investeesOther comprehensive income of equity investees(70)(68)
Accumulated other comprehensive lossAccumulated other comprehensive loss$(491)$(123)$20 $(594)
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
Year ended December 31, 2019    
Year ended December 31, 2022
Year ended December 31, 2022
Year ended December 31, 2022  
Pensions and other postretirement liabilitiesPensions and other postretirement liabilities$(497)$61 $15 $(421)
Other comprehensive loss of equity investees(66)(4)(70)
Pensions and other postretirement liabilities
Pensions and other postretirement liabilities
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Accumulated other comprehensive lossAccumulated other comprehensive loss$(563)$57 $15 $(491)
Accumulated other comprehensive loss
Accumulated other comprehensive loss

K70K75


Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)
 
“Other comprehensive income (loss)”income” reported in the Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income consisted of the following:

Pretax
Amount
Pretax
Amount
Tax
(Expense)
Benefit
Net-of-Tax
Amount
Pretax
Amount
Tax
(Expense)
Benefit
Net-of-Tax
Amount
($ in millions)
($ in millions)
Year ended December 31, 2020   
Net loss arising during the year:   
Year ended December 31, 2023Year ended December 31, 2023  
Net gain arising during the year:Net gain arising during the year:  
Pensions and other postretirement benefits Pensions and other postretirement benefits$(167)$42 $(125)
Reclassification adjustments for costs included in net incomeReclassification adjustments for costs included in net income27 (7)20 
Subtotal Subtotal(140)35 (105)
Subtotal
Subtotal
Other comprehensive income of equity investeesOther comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive loss$(138)$35 $(103)
Other comprehensive income
Other comprehensive income
Other comprehensive income
Year ended December 31, 2019   
Year ended December 31, 2022
Year ended December 31, 2022
Year ended December 31, 2022  
Net gain arising during the year:Net gain arising during the year:   Net gain arising during the year:  
Pensions and other postretirement benefits Pensions and other postretirement benefits$81 $(20)$61 
Reclassification adjustments for costs included in net incomeReclassification adjustments for costs included in net income20 (5)15 
�� Subtotal101 (25)76 
Subtotal
Subtotal
Subtotal
Other comprehensive loss of equity investees(4)(4)
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive incomeOther comprehensive income$97 $(25)$72 
Other comprehensive income
Other comprehensive income
Year ended December 31, 2018   
Net loss arising during the year:   
Year ended December 31, 2021
Year ended December 31, 2021
Year ended December 31, 2021  
Net gain arising during the year:Net gain arising during the year:  
Pensions and other postretirement benefits Pensions and other postretirement benefits$(181)$45 $(136)
Reclassification adjustments for costs included in net incomeReclassification adjustments for costs included in net income33 (8)25 
Subtotal Subtotal(148)37 (111)
Subtotal
Subtotal
Other comprehensive loss of equity investees(9)(8)
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive income of equity investees
Other comprehensive loss$(157)$38 $(119)
Other comprehensive income
Other comprehensive income
Other comprehensive income

K76


15.  Stock Repurchase Programs
 
We repurchased and retired 7.42.8 million, 11.312.6 million, and 17.112.7 million shares of Common Stock under our stock repurchase programs in 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018,2021, respectively, at a cost of $1.4 billion, $2.1$627 million, $3.1 billion, and $2.8$3.4 billion, respectively.respectively, inclusive of excise taxes in 2023. 

K71


On September 26, 2017,March 29, 2022, our Board of Directors authorized a new program for the repurchase of up to an additional 50 million shares$10.0 billion of
Common Stock through December 31,beginning April 1, 2022. As of December 31, 2020, 20.7 million shares remain2023, $6.9 billion remains authorized for repurchase. Our previous share repurchase program terminated on March 31, 2022.

16.  Earnings Per Share
 
The following table sets forth the calculation of basic and diluted earnings per share:
 BasicDiluted
 202020192018202020192018
 ($ in millions except per share amounts, shares in millions)
Net income$2,013 $2,722 $2,666 $2,013 $2,722 $2,666 
Dividend equivalent payments(3)(5)(6)(2)(1)
Income available to common stockholders$2,010 $2,717 $2,660 $2,011 $2,722 $2,665 
Weighted-average shares outstanding255.1 263.3 277.7 255.1 263.3 277.7 
Dilutive effect of outstanding options      
and share-settled awards   1.5 2.3 2.5 
Adjusted weighted-average shares outstanding   256.6 265.6 280.2 
Earnings per share$7.88 $10.32 $9.58 $7.84 $10.25 $9.51 
 BasicDiluted
 202320222021202320222021
 ($ in millions except per share amounts, shares in millions)
Net income$1,827 $3,270 $3,005 $1,827 $3,270 $3,005 
Dividend equivalent payments(3)(2)(2)(3)(1)— 
Income available to common stockholders$1,824 $3,268 $3,003 $1,824 $3,269 $3,005 
Weighted-average shares outstanding226.9 234.8 246.9 226.9 234.8 246.9 
Dilutive effect of outstanding options      
and share-settled awards   0.5 0.8 1.2 
Adjusted weighted-average shares outstanding   227.4 235.6 248.1 
Earnings per share$8.04 $13.92 $12.16 $8.02 $13.88 $12.11 

In each year, dividend equivalent payments were made to certain holders of stock options and RSUs.  For purposes of computing basic earnings per share, dividend equivalent payments made to holders of stock options and RSUs were deducted from net income to determine income available to common stockholders.  For purposes of computing diluted earnings per share, we evaluate on a grant-by-grant basis those stock options and RSUs receiving dividend equivalent payments under the two-class and treasury stock methods to determine which method is more dilutive for each grant.  For those grants for which the two-class method was more dilutive, net income was reduced by dividend equivalent payments to determine income available to common stockholders. There are 0 options excluded from theThe dilution calculations due toexclude options having exercise prices exceeding the average market price of Common Stock as follows: 0.1 million for each of the years ended December 31, 2020, 2019,2023 and 2018.2022, and none for the year ended December 31, 2021.

17.  Commitments and Contingencies
 
Eastern Ohio Incident

Summary

On February 3, 2023, a train operated by us derailed in East Palestine, Ohio. The derailed equipment included 38 railcars, 11 of which were non-Company-owned tank cars containing hazardous materials. Fires associated with the derailment threatened certain of the tank cars. There was concern about the risk that the contents of five of the tank cars carrying vinyl chloride might polymerize, which would have posed the risk of a catastrophic explosion. As a
K77


consequence, on February 6, 2023, the local incident commander (the East Palestine Fire Chief)—in consultation with the incident command that included, among others, federal, state and local officials and Norfolk Southern—opted to conduct a controlled vent and burn of five derailed tank cars, all of which contained vinyl chloride. This procedure involved creating holes in the five tank cars to drain the vinyl chloride into adjacent trenches that had been dug into the ground where such vinyl chloride was then burned, with any material remaining after burning of the vinyl chloride being remediated. The February 3rd derailment, the associated fire, and the resulting vent and burn of the tank cars containing vinyl chloride on February 6th is hereinafter referred to as the “Incident.”

In response to the Incident, we have been working to clean the site safely and thoroughly, including those activities described in the Environmental Matters section below with respect to potentially impacted air, soil and water and to monitor for any impact on public health and the environment. We are working with federal, state, and local officials to mitigate impacts from the Incident, including, among other efforts, conducting environmental monitoring and clean-up activities (as more fully described below), operating a family assistance center to provide financial support to affected members of the East Palestine and surrounding communities, and committing additional financial support to the community.

Financial Impact

Although we cannot predict the final outcome or estimate the reasonably possible range of loss with certainty, we recognized $1.1 billion of expense in 2023 for costs directly attributable to the Incident (including amounts accrued for the probable and reasonably estimable liabilities for those environmental and non-environmental matters described below) which is presented in “Eastern Ohio incident” on the Consolidated Statements of Income. The total expense recognized includes the impact of $101 million in insurance recoveries received in 2023 from claims made under our insurance policies. We recorded a deferred tax asset (Note 4) of $249 million related to the Incident expecting that certain expenses will be deductible for tax purposes in future periods or offset with insurance recoveries. During 2023, our cash expenditures attributable to the Incident, net of insurance proceeds received, were $652 million, which are presented in “Net cash provided by operating activities” on the Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows. The difference between the recognized expense and cash expenditures during 2023 of $464 million comprises primarily of our current estimates of probable and reasonably estimable liabilities principally associated with environmental matters and legal proceedings, which are discussed in further detail below.

Certain costs recorded in 2023 may be recoverable under our insurance policies in effect at the date of the Incident or from third parties. To date, we have recognized $101 million in insurance recoveries. Any additional amounts recoverable under our insurance policies or from third parties will be reflected in future periods in which recovery is considered probable. For additional information about our insurance coverage, see “Insurance” below.

Environmental Matters – In response to the Incident, we have been working with federal, state, and local officials such as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Ohio EPA, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), and the Columbiana County Health District to conduct environmental response and remediation activities, including but not limited to, air monitoring, indoor air quality screenings, municipal water and private water well testing, residential, commercial, and agricultural soil sampling, surface water and groundwater sampling, re-routing a local waterway around the affected site, capturing and shipping stormwater that enters the impacted derailment site to proper disposal facilities, and excavating and disposing of potentially affected soil at hazardous waste landfills or incinerators. The U.S. EPA issued a Unilateral Administrative Order (UAO) on February 21, 2023 containing various requirements, including the submission of numerous work plans to assess and remediate various environmental media and performance of certain removal actions at the affected site. On February 24, 2023, we submitted to the U.S. EPA our Notice of Intent to Comply with the UAO and are currently cooperating with U.S. EPA as well as the Ohio EPA and Pennsylvania DEP, pursuant to the UAO and the directives issued thereunder. On October 18, 2023, the U.S. EPA issued a second unilateral order under Section 311(c) of the Clean Water Act (CWA), requiring preparation of additional environmental work
K78


plans. We timely submitted our Notice of Intent to Comply with the CWA order and continue to cooperate with the U.S. EPA, as well as state agencies, in compliance with the CWA order.

We are also subject to the following legal proceedings that principally relate to the environmental impact of the Incident:

The DOJ and the U.S. EPA filed a civil complaint (the DOJ Complaint) in the Northern District of Ohio (Eastern Division) seeking injunctive relief, cost recovery and civil penalties for violations of the Clean Water Act and seeking cost recovery under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). The Ohio Attorney General (AG) also filed a CERCLA lawsuit (the Ohio Complaint) in the Northern District of Ohio (Eastern Division) seeking statutory damages for a variety of tort and environmental claims under CERCLA and various state laws. The DOJ and Ohio AG cases have been consolidated for discovery purposes. We have filed an answer, and on June 30, 2023, we filed a third-party complaint bringing in numerous parties involved in the Incident.

In connection with the foregoing items, we recognized $836 million of expense during 2023, of which $517 million was paid during 2023, related to probable obligations that are reasonably estimable, in accordance with FASB ASC 410-30, “Environmental Obligations.” Our current estimate includes ongoing and future environmental cleanup activities and remediation efforts, governmental oversight costs (including those incurred by the U.S. EPA and the Ohio EPA), and other related costs, including those in connection with the DOJ Complaint (including potential civil penalties related to violations of the Clean Water Act). Our current estimates of future environmental cleanup and remediation liabilities related to the Incident may change over time due to various factors, including but not limited to, the nature and extent of required future cleanup and removal activities (including those resulting from soil, water, sediment, and air assessment and investigative activities that are currently being, and will continue to be, conducted at the site), and the extent and duration of governmental oversight, amongst other factors. As clean-up efforts progress and more information is available, we will review these estimates and revise as appropriate.

Legal Proceedings and Claims (Non-Environmental) – To date, numerous non-environmental legal actions have commenced with respect to the Incident, including those more specifically set forth below.

There is a consolidated putative class action pending in the Northern District of Ohio (Eastern Division) in which plaintiffs allege various claims, including negligence, gross negligence, strict liability, and nuisance, and seeking as relief compensatory and punitive damages, medical monitoring and business losses. The putative class is defined by reference to a class area covering a 30-mile radius. On July 12, 2023, we filed a third-party complaint bringing in multiple parties involved in the Incident. The court in the putative class action has established a fact discovery deadline of February 5, 2024. Another putative class action is pending in the Western District of Pennsylvania, brought by Pennsylvania school districts and students. On August 22, 2023, three school districts voluntarily dismissed their actions, then individual lawsuits. On the same day, six Pennsylvania school districts and students filed a putative class action lawsuit alleging negligence, strict liability, nuisance, and trespass, and seeking damages and health monitoring. On December 8, 2023, the school districts amended their complaint to add additional companies as defendants in the action. The putative class action and individual lawsuits are collectively referred to herein as the Incident Lawsuits. In accordance with FASB ASC 450, “Contingencies,” we have recognized a $116 million loss during 2023 with respect to the Incident Lawsuits and related contingencies, of which $34 million has been paid. At this time, we are unable to estimate the possible loss or range of loss in excess of the amounts accrued regarding the Incident Lawsuits. However, for the reasons set forth below, our estimated loss or range of loss with respect to the Incident Lawsuits may change from time to time, and it is reasonably possible that we will incur actual losses in excess of the amounts currently accrued and such additional amounts may be material. While we continue to
K79


work with parties with respect to potential resolution pathways, no assurance can be given that we will be successful in doing so and we cannot predict the outcome of these matters.

We have received securities and derivative litigation and multiple shareholder document and litigation demand letters, including a securities class action lawsuit under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 initially filed in the Southern District of Ohio alleging multiple securities law violations but since transferred to the Northern District of Georgia, a securities class action lawsuit under the Securities Act of 1933 filed in the Southern District of New York alleging misstatements in association with our debt offerings, and a shareholder derivative complaint in Virginia state court asserting claims for breach of fiduciary duties, waste of corporate assets, and unjust enrichment in connection with safety of the Company's operations (collectively, the Shareholder Matters). On February 2, 2024, defendants filed a motion to dismiss the amended complaint in the Securities Act lawsuit. No responsive pleadings have been filed yet with respect to the other Shareholder Matters.

With respect to the Incident-related litigation and regulatory matters, we record a liability for loss contingencies through a charge to earnings when we conclude that it is probable that a liability has been incurred and the amount of the liability can be reasonably estimated, and disclose such liability if we conclude it to be material. Any adjustments to the recorded liability will be reflected in earnings in the periods in which such adjustments become known. Because the final outcome of any of these legal proceedings cannot be predicted with certainty, developments related to the progress of such legal proceedings or other unfavorable or unexpected developments or outcomes could result in additional costs or new or additionally accrued amounts that could be material to our results of operations in a particular year or quarter. In addition, if it is reasonably possible that we will incur Incident-related losses in excess of the amounts currently recorded as a loss contingency, we disclose the potential range of loss, if reasonably estimable, or we disclose that we cannot reasonably estimate such an amount at this time. For Incident-related litigation and regulatory matters where a loss may be reasonably possible, but not probable, or probable but not reasonably estimable, no accrual is established but the matter, if potentially material, is disclosed.

Our estimates of probable losses and reasonably possible losses are based upon currently available information and involve significant judgement and a variety of assumptions, given that (1) these legal and regulatory proceedings are in early stages; (2) discovery may not be completed; (3) damages sought in these legal and regulatory proceedings can be unsubstantiated or indeterminate; (4) there are often significant facts in dispute; and/or (5) there is a wide range of possible outcomes. Accordingly, our estimated range of loss with respect to these matters may change from time to time, and actual losses may exceed current estimates. At this time, we are unable to estimate the possible loss or range of loss in excess of the amounts accrued with respect to the matters described above.

In addition to the costs associated with environmental matters and legal proceedings and claims, we incurred $265 million in other expenses directly related to the Incident in 2023 pertaining to legal fees, community support, and other response-related activities. The amounts recorded by us in 2023 do not include any estimate of loss for the following additional items, for which we believe a loss is either not probable or not reasonably estimable for the reasons noted: (i) the overall cost to us for the healthcare fund being developed in conjunction with relevant stakeholders, including the Ohio AG, for affected residents (given the preliminary nature of such discussions), which amount will impact our loss contingency analysis with respect to the Incident Lawsuits described above, or (ii) any fines or penalties (in excess of the liabilities established for Clean Water Act-related civil penalties) that may be imposed as a result of the Incident Inquiries and Investigations, as more specifically set forth and defined below (the outcome of which are uncertain at this time). Additionally, with the exception of amounts recognized during 2023, potential recoveries under our insurance coverage, which may apply to various Incident-related expenses or liabilities as more specifically set forth further below, have not yet been recorded (given the preliminary nature of discussions with our insurers). No amounts have been recorded related to potential recoveries
K80


from other third parties, which may reduce amounts payable by our insurers under our applicable insurance coverage.

Inquiries and Investigations

As set forth above, we are subject to inquiries and investigations by numerous federal, state, and local government authorities and regulatory agencies regarding the Incident, including but not limited to, the DOJ and the U.S. EPA, the Ohio EPA, the NTSB, the FRA, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, the Ohio AG, and the Pennsylvania AG. Further details regarding the NTSB and FRA investigations are set forth below. We are cooperating with all inquiries and investigations, including responding to civil and criminal subpoenas and other requests for information (the aforementioned inquiries and investigations, as well as the civil and criminal subpoenas are collectively referred to herein as the Incident Inquiries and Investigations). Aside from the FRA Safety Assessment (defined and described below), the outcome of any current or future Incident Inquiries and Investigations is uncertain at this time, including any related fines, penalties or settlements. Therefore, our expenses for 2023 do not include estimates of the total amount that we may incur for any such fines, penalties or settlements.

Subsequent to the Incident, investigators from the NTSB examined railroad equipment and track conditions; reviewed data from the signal system, wayside defect detectors, local surveillance cameras, and the lead locomotive’s event recorder and forward-facing and inward-facing image recorders; and completed certain interviews (the NTSB Investigation). The NTSB issued a preliminary report indicating that one of the cars involved in the derailment appeared to have a wheel bearing in the final stage of overheat failure moments before the derailment. Their preliminary report also indicates that the rail crew was operating the train within our rules; the rail crew operated the train below the track speed limit, the wayside heat detectors were operating as designed; and once the rail crew was alerted by the wayside detector, they immediately began to stop the train. The NTSB conducted a subsequent investigative field hearing in East Palestine, Ohio on June 22 and 23, 2023. The NTSB’s investigation remains ongoing. We expect the NTSB to issue a final report, with a probable cause determination and safety recommendations, in 2024.

Concurrent with the NTSB Investigation, the FRA is also investigating the Incident. Similar in scope to the NTSB Investigation, the FRA is examining railroad equipment, track conditions, hazardous materials train placement and routing, and emergency response (the FRA Incident Investigation). The FRA Incident Investigation may result in the assessment of civil penalties. In addition to the FRA Incident Investigation, the FRA completed a 60-day supplemental safety assessment (the FRA Safety Assessment). The FRA Safety Assessment included a review of findings from a previously completed 2022 system audit and an assessment of operational elements including, but not limited to: track, signal, and rolling stock maintenance, inspection and repair practices; protection of employees; communications between transportation departments and mechanical and engineering staff; operation control center procedures and dispatcher training. The overall scope of the FRA Safety Assessment was to examine our safety culture. The FRA issued a public report in early August and included its findings and recommended corrective actions. The FRA Incident Investigation remains ongoing.

Other Commitments and Contingencies

Lawsuits
 
We and/or certain subsidiaries are defendants in numerous lawsuits and other claims relating principally to railroad operations.  When we conclude that it is probable that a liability has been incurred and the amount of the liability can be reasonably estimated, it is accrued through a charge to earnings and, if material, disclosed below. While the ultimate amount of liability incurred in any of these lawsuits and claims is dependent on future developments, in our opinion, the recorded liability is adequate to cover the future payment of such liability and claims. However, the final outcome of any of these lawsuits and claims cannot be predicted with certainty, and unfavorable or unexpected outcomes could result in additional accruals that could be significant to results of operations in a particular year or quarter. Any adjustments to the recorded liability will be reflected in earnings in the periods in which such adjustments become known. For lawsuits and other claims where a loss may be reasonably possible, but not
K81


probable, or is probable but not reasonably estimable, no accrual is established but the matter, if potentially material, is disclosed below. We routinely review relevant information with respect to our lawsuits and other claims and update our accruals, disclosures and estimates of reasonably possible loss based on such reviews.

K72


In 2007, various antitrust class actions filed against us and other Class I railroads in various Federal district courts regarding fuel surcharges were consolidated in the District of Columbia by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation. In 2012, the court certified the case as a class action. The defendant railroads appealed this certification, and the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia vacated the District Court’s decision and remanded the case for further consideration. On October 10, 2017, the District Court denied class certification. The decision was upheld by the Court of Appeals on August 16, 2019. Since that decision, various individual cases have been filed in multiple jurisdictions and also consolidated in the District of Columbia. We believe the allegations in the complaints are without merit and intend to vigorously defend the cases. We do not believe the outcome of these proceedings will have a material effect on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity.

In 2018, a lawsuit was filed against one of our subsidiaries by the minority owner in a jointly-owned terminal railroad company in which our subsidiary has the majority ownership. The lawsuit alleged violations of various state laws and federal antitrust laws. ItOn January 3, 2023, the court granted summary judgment to us on all of the compensatory claims but denied summary judgment for all equitable relief claims. On January 18, 2023, the court dismissed the federal equitable relief claims, leaving the state equitable relief claims as the sole remaining issue under consideration. On April 19, 2023, the court disposed of all remaining state equitable relief claims. The court's dismissals were appealed and the case is currently before the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. We will continue to vigorously defend the lawsuit and, although it is reasonably possible that we could incur a loss in the case; however,case, we intend to vigorously defend the case and believe that we will prevail. TheHowever, given that litigation is inherently unpredictable and subject to uncertainties, there can be no assurances that the final outcome of the litigation (including the related appeal) will not be material. Until such appeal is final, we cannot reasonably estimate the potential loss or range of loss cannot be estimated atassociated with this time.matter.

Casualty Claims
 
Casualty claims include employee personal injury and occupational claims as well as third-party claims, all exclusive of legal costs.  To aid in valuing our personal injury liability and determining the amount to accrue with respect to such claims during the year, we utilize studies prepared by an independent consulting actuarial firm.  Job-related personal injury and occupational claims are subject to the FELA, which is applicable only to railroads. FELA’s fault-based tort system produces results that are unpredictable and inconsistent as compared with a no-fault workers’ compensation system.  The variability inherent in thisFELA’s fault-based tort system could result in actual costs being different from the liability recorded.  While the ultimate amount of claims incurred is dependent on future developments, in our opinion, the recorded liability is adequate to cover the future payments of claims and is supported by the most recent actuarial study.  In all cases, we record a liability when the expected loss for the claim is both probable and reasonably estimable.
 
Employee personal injury claimsTheOther than Incident-related matters noted above, the largest component of claims expense is employee personal injury costs.  The independent actuarial firm we engage provides quarterly studies to aid in valuing our employee personal injury liability and estimating personal injury expense.  The actuarial firm studies our historical patterns of reserving for claims and subsequent settlements, taking into account relevant outside influences.  The actuarial firm uses the results of these analyses to estimate the ultimate amount of liability. We adjust the liability quarterly based upon our assessment and the results of the study. The accuracy of our estimate of the liability is subject to inherent limitation given the difficulty of predicting future events such as jury decisions, court interpretations, or legislative changes. As a result, actual claim settlements may vary from the estimated liability recorded.

Occupational claims – Occupational claims include injuries and illnesses alleged to be caused by exposures which occur over time as opposed to injuries or illnesses caused by a specific accident or event. Types of occupational claims commonly seen allege exposure to asbestos and other claimed toxic substances resulting in respiratory diseases or cancer. Many such claims are being asserted by former or retired employees, some of whom have not
K82


been employed in the rail industry for decades.  The independent actuarial firm provides an estimate of the occupational claims liability based upon our history of claim filings, severity, payments, and other pertinent facts.  The liability is dependent upon judgments we make as to the specific case reserves as well as judgments of the actuarial firm in the quarterly studies.  The actuarial firm’sOur estimate of ultimate loss includes a provision for those claims that have been incurred but not reported.  This provision is derived by analyzing industry data and projecting our experience. We adjust the liability quarterly based upon our assessment and the results of the study.  However, it is possible that the recorded liability may not be adequate to cover the future payment of claims.  Adjustments to the recorded liability are reflected in operating expenses in the periods in which such adjustments become known.

K73


Third-party claims – We record a liability for third-party claims including those for highway crossing accidents, trespasser and other injuries, property damage, and lading damage. The actuarial firm assists us with the calculation of potential liability for third-party claims, except lading damage, based upon our experience including the number and timing of incidents, amount of payments, settlement rates, number of open claims, and legal defenses. We adjust the liability quarterly based upon our assessment and the results of the study. Given the inherent uncertainty in regard to the ultimate outcome of third-party claims, it is possible that the actual loss may differ from the estimated liability recorded.
 
Environmental Matters
 
We are subject to various jurisdictions’ environmental laws and regulations. We record a liability where such liability or loss is probable and reasonably estimable. Environmental specialists regularly participate in ongoing evaluations of all known sites and in determining any necessary adjustments to liability estimates.  
 
OurIn addition to environmental claims associated with the Incident, our Consolidated Balance Sheets include liabilities for other environmental exposures of $54$60 million at December 31, 2020,2023, and $56$66 million at December 31, 2019,2022, of which $15 million is classified as a current liability at the end of both 2020 and 2019.periods.  At December 31, 2020,2023, the liability represents our estimates of the probable cleanup, investigation, and remediation costs based on available information at 10081 known locations and projects compared with 11085 locations and projects at December 31, 2019.2022. At December 31, 2020, 172023, twenty-one sites accounted for $40$48 million of the liability, and no individual site was considered to be material. We anticipate that most of this liability will be paid out over five years; however, some costs will be paid out over a longer period.
 
At 11eight locations, one or more of our subsidiaries in conjunction with a number of other parties have been identified as potentially responsible parties under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act of 1980CERCLA or comparable state statutes that impose joint and several liability for cleanup costs. We calculate our estimated liability for these sites based on facts and legal defenses applicable to each site and not solely on the basis of the potential for joint liability.
 
WithAs set forth above, with respect to known environmental sites (whether identified by us or by the Environmental Protection AgencyU.S. EPA or comparable state authorities), estimates of our ultimate potential financial exposure for a given site or in the aggregate for all such sites can change over time because of the widely varying costs of currently available cleanup techniques, unpredictable contaminant recovery and reduction rates associated with available cleanup technologies, the likely development of new cleanup technologies, the difficulty of determining in advance the nature and full extent of contamination and each potential participant’s share of any estimated loss (and that participant’s ability to bear it), and evolving statutory and regulatory standards governing liability.
 
The risk of incurring environmental liability for acts and omissions, past, present, and future, is inherent in the railroad business. Some of the commodities we transport, particularly those classified as hazardous materials, pose special risks that we work diligently to reduce. In addition, several of our subsidiaries own, or have owned, land used as operating property, or which is leased and operated by others, or held for sale. Because environmental problems that are latent or undisclosed may exist on these properties, there can be no assurance that we will not incur environmental liabilities or costs with respect to one or more of them, the amount and materiality of which cannot be estimated reliably at this time. Moreover, lawsuits and claims involving these and potentially other
K83


unidentified environmental sites and matters are likely to arise from time to time. The resulting liabilities could have a significant effect on financial position, results of operations, or liquidity in a particular year or quarter.
 
Based on our assessment of the facts and circumstances now known, we believe we have recorded the probable and reasonably estimable costs for dealing with those environmental matters of which we are aware.  Further, we believe that it is unlikely that any known matters, either individually or in the aggregate, will have a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations, or liquidity.

K74Labor Agreements


Approximately 80% of our railroad employees are covered by collective bargaining agreements with various labor unions. Pursuant to the Railway Labor Act, these agreements remain in effect until new agreements are reached, or until the bargaining procedures mandated by the Railway Labor Act are completed. Moratorium provisions in the labor agreements govern when the railroads and unions may propose changes to the agreements. We largely bargain nationally in concert with other major railroads, represented by the National Carriers’ Conference Committee.

The latest round of national bargaining concluded in December 2022, when agreements were either ratified or enacted through legislative action for all twelve of our unions.With the conclusion of national bargaining, neither party can compel mandatory bargaining around any new proposals until November 1, 2024.

In addition, we understand the imperative to continue improving quality of life for our craft employees and remain actively engaged with our unions in voluntary local discussions (none of which carry the risk of a work stoppage) on this important issue.

Insurance
 
We purchase insurance covering legal liabilities for bodily injury and property damage to third parties. ThisOur current liability insurance provides coveragelimits for approximately 93% of covered losses above $75 million and below $800$734 million ($1.1 billion for specific perils) per occurrence and/or policy year. In addition, we purchase insurance coveringfor damage to property owned by us or in our care, custody, or control. ThisOur current property insurance coversprovides limits for approximately 85%82% of potentialcovered losses above $75 million and below $275 million per occurrence and/or policy year.

Insurance coverage with respect to the Incident is subject to certain conditions, including but not limited to our insurers’ reservation of rights to further investigate and contest coverage, the express restrictions and sub-limits of coverage, and various policy exclusions, including those for some governmental fines or penalties. Some (re)insurers have disputed certain payments we have made, for example, as part of our effort to respond to, mitigate, and compensate for the impact to the community and affected residents and businesses. We are pursuing coverage with respect to the Incident, and we have recognized $101 million in insurance recoveries in 2023, principally from excess liability (re)insurers.

Purchase Commitments
 
At December 31, 2020,2023, we had outstanding purchase commitments totaling approximately $1.1$1.4 billion through 2053 for locomotives, locomotive diesel fuel,modernizations, long-term technology support and development contracts, track material, long-term service contracts, track and yard expansion projectsvehicles.

Asset Purchase and Sale Agreement

In November 2022, we entered into an asset purchase and sale agreement with the Board of Trustees of the Cincinnati Southern Railway to purchase approximately 337 miles of railway line that extends from Cincinnati, Ohio to Chattanooga, Tennessee which we currently operate under a lease agreement. The agreement is conditioned upon the following, among other items: (i) approval by the voters of the City of Cincinnati (Cincinnati Voter Approval), which was obtained in connection with our capital programs, freight carsNovember 2023, and containers through 2030.(ii) the receipt of regulatory approval from the U.S. Surface
K84


Transportation Board (STB), which occurred in September 2023. In June 2023, we entered into an amended and restated asset purchase and sale agreement which increased the purchase price by $500,000 and clarified the impact of Cincinnati Voter Approval on the closing timeline. Following the June 2023 amendment, the total purchase price for the line and other associated real and personal property included in the transaction is expected to be approximately $1.7 billion. The transaction is scheduled to close on March 15, 2024.

Change-In-Control Arrangements
 
We have compensation agreements with certain officers and key employees that become operative only upon a change in control of Norfolk Southern, as defined in those agreements. The agreements provide generally for payments based on compensation at the time of a covered individual’s involuntary or other specified termination and for certain other benefits.

Indemnifications

In a number of instances, we have agreed to indemnify lenders for additional costs they may bear as a result of certain changes in laws or regulations applicable to their loans. Such changes may include impositions or modifications with respect to taxes, duties, reserves, liquidity, capital adequacy, special deposits, and similar requirements relating to extensions of credit by, deposits with, or the assets or liabilities of such lenders. The nature and timing of changes in laws or regulations applicable to our financings are inherently unpredictable, and therefore our exposure in connection with the foregoing indemnifications cannot be quantified. No liability has been recorded related to these indemnifications.

K75K85


NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES
QUARTERLY FINANCIAL DATA
(Unaudited)
 Three Months Ended
 March 31June 30 September 30December 31
 ($ in millions, except per share amounts)
2020    
Railway operating revenues$2,625 $2,085 $2,506 $2,573 
Income from railway operations568 610 840 984 
Net income381 392 569 671 
Earnings per share:   
Basic1.48 1.53 2.23 2.65 
Diluted1.47 1.53 2.22 2.64 
2019    
Railway operating revenues$2,840 $2,925 $2,841 $2,690 
Income from railway operations966 1,065 996 962 
Net income677 722 657 666 
Earnings per share:    
Basic2.53 2.72 2.50 2.56 
Diluted2.51 2.70 2.49 2.55 

K76


Item 9.  Changes in and Disagreements with Accountants on Accounting and Financial Disclosure
 
Not applicable.
 
Item 9A.  Controls and Procedures
 
Disclosure Controls and Procedures
 
Our Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, with the assistance of management, evaluated the effectiveness of our disclosure controls and procedures (as such term is defined in Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (Exchange Act)) at December 31, 2020.2023.  Based on such evaluation, our officers have concluded that, at December 31, 2020,2023, our disclosure controls and procedures were effective to ensure that information required to be disclosed in our reports under the Exchange Act is recorded, processed, summarized, and reported, within the time period specified in the SEC’s rules and forms, and that such information is accumulated and communicated to management, including the Chief Executive Officer and the Chief Financial Officer, as appropriate, to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure.
 
Management’s Annual Report on Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
 
We are responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial reporting. Our internal control over financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that pertain to our ability to record, process, summarize, and report reliable financial data.  We recognize that there are inherent limitations in the effectiveness of any internal control over financial reporting, including the possibility of human error and the circumvention or overriding of internal control.  Accordingly, even effective internal control over financial reporting can provide only reasonable assurance with respect to financial statement preparation.  Further, because of changes in conditions, the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting may vary over time.
 
Our Board of Directors, acting through its Audit Committee, is responsible for the oversight of our accounting policies, financial reporting, and internal control.  The Audit Committee of our Board of Directors is comprised of outside directors who are independent of management.  The independent registered public accounting firm and our internal auditors have full and unlimited access to the Audit Committee, with or without management, to discuss the adequacy of internal control over financial reporting, and any other matters which they believe should be brought to the attention of the Audit Committee.
 
We have issued a report of our assessment of internal control over financial reporting, and our independent registered public accounting firm has issued an attestation reportopinion on our internal control over financial reporting at December 31, 2020.2023.  These reports appear in Item 8 of this report on Form 10-K.

Changes in Internal Control Over Financial Reporting

During the fourth quarter of 2020,2023, we have not identified any changes in internal control over financial reporting that have materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially effect, our internal control over financial reporting.
 
K86


Item 9B.  Other Information
 
None.Director and Officer Trading Arrangements

None of our directors or officers (as defined in Rule 16a-1(f) of the Exchange Act) adopted or terminated a Rule 10b5-1 trading arrangement or a non-Rule 10b5-1 trading arrangement (as defined in Item 408(c) of Regulation S-K) during the fourth quarter of 2023.

Item 9C.  Disclosure Regarding Foreign Jurisdictions that Prevent Inspections
Not applicable.
K77K87


PART III
 
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES
 
Item 10.  Directors, Executive Officers and Corporate Governance
 
In accordance with General Instruction G(3), information called for by Part III, Item 10, is incorporated herein by reference from the information appearing under the caption “Election of Directors,” under the caption “Delinquent Section 16(a) Reports,” under the caption “Committees of the Board,” under the caption “Shareholder Recommendations and Nominations,” and under the caption “The Thoroughbred Code of Ethics” into our definitive Proxy Statement for our 20212024 Annual Meeting of Stockholders, which definitive Proxy Statement will be filed electronically with the SEC pursuant to Regulation 14A.  The information regarding executive officers called for by Item 401 of Regulation S-K is included in Part I hereof beginning under “Information about our Executive Officers.”
 
Item 11.  Executive Compensation
 
In accordance with General Instruction G(3), information called for by Part III, Item 11, is incorporated herein by reference from the information:
under the caption “Compensation of Directors;”
under the caption “Compensation Discussion and Analysis,” the information appearing in the “Summary Compensation Table” and the “2020 Grants of Plan-Based Awards” table, including the narrative to such tables, the “Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End 2020” and “Option Exercises and Stock Vested in 2020” tables, and the tabular and narrative information appearing under the subcaptions “Retirement Benefits,” “Deferred Compensation,” and “Potential Payments Upon a Change in Control or Other Termination of Employment;” and,
under the captions “Compensation Committee Interlocks and Insider Participation,” “Compensation Policy Risk Assessment,” and “Compensation Committee Report,”
in each case included in our definitive Proxy Statement for our 20212024 Annual Meeting of Stockholders, which definitive Proxy Statement will be filed electronically with the SEC pursuant to Regulation 14A.
 
K78K88


Item 12.  Security Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and Management and Related Stockholder Matters
 
In accordance with General Instruction G(3), information on security ownership of certain beneficial owners and management called for by Part III, Item 12, is incorporated herein by reference from the information appearing under the caption “Beneficial Ownership of Stock” into our definitive Proxy Statement for our 20212024 Annual Meeting of Stockholders, which definitive Proxy Statement will be filed electronically with the SEC pursuant to Regulation 14A.
 
Equity Compensation Plan Information (at December 31, 2020)2023)
Plan
Category
Number of
securities
to be issued upon
exercise of
outstanding options,
warrants and rights
Weighted-
average
exercise price
of outstanding
options, warrants
and rights
Number of securities
remaining available
for future issuance
under equity
compensation plans (1)
 (a)(b)(c)
Equity compensation plans   
approved by securities holders(2)
2,387,953 (3)$100.09 (5)8,995,582 
Equity compensation plans
not approved by securities holders258,359 (4)88.72 435,699 (6)
Total2,646,312  9,431,281 
Plan
Category
Number of
securities
to be issued upon
exercise of
outstanding options,
warrants and rights
Weighted-
average
exercise price
of outstanding
options, warrants
and rights
Number of securities
remaining available
for future issuance
under equity
compensation plans (1)
 (a)(b)(c)
Equity compensation plans   
approved by securities holders(2)
1,507,054 (3)$165.30 (5)7,731,573 
Equity compensation plans
not approved by securities holders109,206 (4)96.35 436,571 (6)
Total1,616,260  8,168,144 
 
(1)Excludes securities reflected in column (a).
(2)LTIP.
(3)Includes options, RSUs and PSUs granted under LTIP that will be settled in shares of Common Stock.
(4)TSOP.
(5)Calculated without regard to 1,120,187872,863 outstanding RSUs and PSUs at December 31, 2020.2023.
(6)Reflects shares remaining available for grant under TSOP.

Norfolk Southern Corporation Long-Term Incentive Plan
 
Established on June 28, 1983, and approved by our stockholders at their Annual Meeting held on May 10, 1984, LTIP was adopted to promote the success of our company by providing an opportunity for non-employee Directors, officers, and other key employees to acquire a proprietary interest in Norfolk Southern Corporation (the Corporation).  The Board of Directors amended LTIP on January 23, 2015, which amendment was approved by shareholders on May 14, 2015, to include the reservation for issuance of an additional 8,000,000 shares of authorized but unissued Common Stock.
 
The amended LTIP adopted a fungible share reserve ratio so that, for awards granted after May 13, 2010, the number of shares remaining for issuance under the amended LTIP will be reduced (i) by 1 for each award granted as an option or stock-settled SAR, or (ii) by 1.61 for an award made in the form other than an option or stock-settled SAR.  Any shares of Common Stock subject to options, PSUs, restricted shares, or RSUs which are not issued as Common Stock will again be available for award under LTIP after the expiration or forfeiture of an award.
 
K79K89


Non-employee Directors, officers, and other key employees residing in the United States of AmericaU.S. or Canada are eligible for selection to receive LTIP awards.  Under LTIP, the Committee, or the Corporation’s chief executive officer to the extent the Committee delegates award-making authority pursuant to LTIP, may grant incentive stock options, nonqualified stock options, SARs, RSUs, restricted shares, PSUs and performance shares.  In addition, dividend equivalent payments may be awarded for options, RSUs and PSUs.  Awards under LTIP may be made subject to forfeiture under certain circumstances and the Committee may establish such other terms and conditions for the awards as provided in LTIP.
 
The option price is at least the higher of (i) the average of the high and low prices at which Common Stock is traded on the date of grant, or (ii) the closing price of Common Stock on the date of the grant.  All options are subject to a vesting period of at least one year, and the term of the option will not exceed ten years.  LTIP specifically prohibits option repricing without stockholder approval, except that adjustments may be made in the event of changes in our capital structure or Common Stock.
 
PSUs entitle a recipient to receive performance-based compensation at the end of a three-year cycle based on our performance during that period.  For the 20202023 PSU awards, corporate performance will be based directly on return on average capital invested, with total return to stockholders and revenue growth serving as a modifier,modifiers, and will be settled in shares of Common Stock.
 
RSUs are payable in cash or in shares of Common Stock at the end of a restriction period.  During the restriction period, the holder of the RSUs has no beneficial ownership interest in the Common Stock represented by the RSUs and has no right to vote the shares represented by the units or to receive dividends (except for dividend equivalent payment rights that may be awarded with respect to the RSUs).  The Committee at its discretion may waive the restriction period, but settlement of any RSUs will occur on the same settlement date as would have applied absent a waiver of restrictions, if no performance goals were imposed. RSUs will be settled in shares of Common Stock.
 
Norfolk Southern Corporation Thoroughbred Stock Option Plan
 
Our Board of Directors adopted TSOP on January 26, 1999, to promote the success of our company by providing an opportunity for management employees to acquire a proprietary interest in our company and thereby to provide an additional incentive to management employees to devote their maximum efforts and skills to the advancement, betterment, and prosperity of our company and our stockholders.  Under TSOP there were 6,000,000 shares of authorized but unissued Common Stock reserved for issuance.  TSOP has not been and is not required to have been approved by our stockholders.
 
Active full-time management employees residing in the U.S. or Canada are eligible for selection to receive TSOP awards.  Under TSOP, the Committee, or the Corporation’s chief executive officer to the extent the Committee delegates award-making authority pursuant to TSOP, may grant nonqualified stock options subject to such terms and conditions as provided in TSOP.
 
The option price may not be less than the average of the high and low prices at which Common Stock is traded on the date of the grant.  All options are subject to a vesting period of at least one year, and the term of the option will not exceed ten years.  TSOP specifically prohibits repricing without stockholder approval, except for capital adjustments.
 
K80K90


Norfolk Southern Corporation Directors’ Restricted Stock Plan (Plan)
 
The Plan was adopted on January 1, 1994, and was designed to increase ownership of Common Stock by our non-employee Directors so as to further align their ownership interest in our company with that of our stockholders.  The Plan has not been and is not required to have been approved by our stockholders.  
 
Effective January 23, 2015, the Board amended the Plan to provide that no additional awards will be made under the Plan. Prior to that amendment, only non-employee Directors who are not and never have been employees of our company were eligible to participate in the Plan.  Upon becoming a Director, each eligible Director received a one-time grant of 3,000 restricted shares of Common Stock. No additional shares may be granted under the Plan.  No individual member of the Board exercised discretion concerning the eligibility of any Director or the number of shares granted.
 
The restriction period applicable to restricted shares granted under the Plan begins on the date of the grant and ends on the earlier of the recipient’s death or the day after the recipient ceases to be a Director by reason of disability or retirement.  During the restriction period, shares may not be sold, pledged, or otherwise encumbered.  Directors forfeit the restricted shares if they cease to serve as a Director of our company for reasons other than their disability, retirement, or death.
 
Item 13.  Certain Relationships and Related Transactions, and Director Independence
 
In accordance with General Instruction G(3), information called for by Part III, Item 13, is incorporated herein by reference from the information appearing under the caption “Related Persons Transactions” and under the caption “Director Independence” into our definitive Proxy Statement for our 20212024 Annual Meeting of Stockholders, which definitive Proxy Statement will be filed electronically with the SEC pursuant to Regulation 14A.

Item 14.  Principal AccountingAccountant Fees and Services
 
Our independent registered public accounting firm is KPMG LLP, Atlanta, GA, Auditor Firm ID: 185.

In accordance with General Instruction G(3), information called for by Part III, Item 14, is incorporated herein by reference from the information appearing under the caption “Ratification of Appointment of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” into our definitive Proxy Statement for our 20212024 Annual Meeting of Stockholders, which definitive Proxy Statement will be filed electronically with the SEC pursuant to Regulation 14A.

K81K91


PART IV
 
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

Item 15.  Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedule
Schedules
   Page
(A)The following documents are filed as part of this report: 
 1. 
 
 
 
 
 
 2.Financial Statement Schedule:Schedules:
 The following consolidated financial statement schedule should be read in connection with the consolidated financial statements:
 Index to Consolidated Financial Statement ScheduleSchedules
 Schedules other than the one listed above are omitted either because they are not required or are inapplicable, or because the information is included in the consolidated financial statements or related notes. 
 3.Exhibits 
Exhibit NumberDescription 
2.1
3
Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws
 
(i)(a) 
(i)(b)
(i)(c)
(ii)

K82
K92




4Instruments Defining the Rights of Security Holders, Including Indentures:
(a)Indenture, dated as of January 15, 1991, from Norfolk Southern Corporation to First Trust of New York, National Association, as Trustee, is incorporated by reference to Exhibit 4.1 to Norfolk Southern Corporation’s Registration Statement on Form S-3 (No. 33-38595).
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)(l)
K83


(n)(m)
K93


(o)(n)
(p)(o)
(q)(p)
(r)
(s)
(t)(q)
(u)(r)
(v)
(w)(s)
(x)(t)
(y)(u)
(z)(v)
(aa)(w)
(bb)(x)
(cc)
K84


(dd)(y)
(ee)(z)
(ff)(aa)
(gg)(bb)
(hh)(cc)
K94


(ii)(dd)
(jj)(ee)
(ff)
(gg)
(hh)
(ii)
(jj)
(kk)
(ll)
In accordance with Item 601(b)(4)(iii) of Regulation S-K, copies of other instruments of Norfolk Southern Corporation and its subsidiaries with respect to the rights of holders of long-term debt are not filed herewith, or incorporated by reference, but will be furnished to the Commission upon request.
10Material Contracts -
(a)
(b)
(c)
K95


(d)
(e)
K85


(f)
(g)
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
(n)
(o)
K96


(p)
(q)
K86


(r)*,**
(s)*
(t)*
(u)(t)*,**
(v)*,*(u)*
(w)*
(x)(v)
(y)(w)*
(z)(x)*,**
(aa)*
(y)
(z)
(aa)
(bb)
(cc)
K97


(dd)
(cc)
(dd)
(ee)
K87


(ff)
(gg)
(hh)
(ii)
(jj)
(kk)
(ll)
(mm)
(nn)
(oo)
(pp)
(qq)
(rr)
(ss)
(tt)
(uu)
K88


(vv)
(ww)
(xx)*
(yy)(ff)*
(zz)(gg)*
(aaa)*
(bbb)
(ccc)*,**
(ddd)(hh)*,**
(eee)(ii)*,**
(fff)(jj)*,**
(ggg)*,*(kk)*
(hhh)*
Performance Criteria for bonuses payable in 2022 for the 2021 incentive year.On November 16, 2020, the Compensation Committee of the Norfolk Southern Corporation Board of Directors adopted the following performance criteria for determining bonuses payable in 2022 for the 2021 incentive year under the Norfolk Southern Corporation Executive Management Incentive Plan: 60% based on operating ratio, 20% based on operating income, and 20% based on strategic plan objectives.
(iii)
K89


(jjj)*
(kkk)*
(lll)(ll)
(mmm)*,*(mm)*
(nnn)*,**
(ooo)*,**
(ppp)*
(qqq)(nn)*
(rrr)(oo)*
(sss)(pp)*
(ttt)(qq)
(uuu)
(vvv)(rr)
K98


(www)(ss)
(tt)
(xxx)(uu)
(vv)
(ww)*
(xx)
21**
23**
K90


31-A**
31-B**
32**
97*,**
101**The following financial information from Norfolk Southern Corporation’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2020,2023, formatted in Inline Extensible Business Reporting Language (iXBRL) includes:  (i) the Consolidated Statements of Income for each of the years ended December 31, 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018;2021; (ii) the Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income for each of the years ended December 31, 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018;2021; (iii) the Consolidated Balance Sheets at December 31, 20202023 and 2019;2022; (iv) the Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows for each of the years ended December 31, 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018;2021; (v) the Consolidated Statements of Changes in Stockholders’ Equity for each of the years ended December 31, 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 2018;2021; and (vi) the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.
104**Cover Page Interactive Data File (formatted as Inline XBRL and contained in Exhibit 101).
* Management contract or compensatory arrangement.
** Filed herewith.
K99


(B)Exhibits.
 The Exhibits required by Item 601 of Regulation S-K as listed in Item 15(A)3 are filed herewith or incorporated by reference.
(C)Financial Statement Schedules.
Financial statement schedules and separate financial statements specified by this Item are included in Item 15(A)2 or are otherwise not required or are not applicable.
Exhibits 23, 31, and 32 are included in copies assembled for public dissemination. All exhibits are included in the 20202023 Form 10-K posted on our website at www.norfolksouthern.com under “Invest in NS”“Investors” “Financial Reports” and “SEC Filings” or you may request copies by writing to:
Office of Corporate Secretary
Norfolk Southern Corporation
Three Commercial Place650 West Peachtree Street NW
Norfolk, Virginia 23510-9219Atlanta, Georgia 30308-1925 

K91K100


Item 16.  Form 10-K Summary

Not applicable.

K92K101


POWER OF ATTORNEY
 
Each person whose signature appears on the next page under SIGNATURES hereby authorizes Vanessa Allen SutherlandNabanita C. Nag and Mark R. George, or any one of them, to execute in the name of each such person, and to file, any amendments to this report, and hereby appoints Vanessa Allen SutherlandNabanita C. Nag and Mark R. George, or any one of them, as attorneys-in-fact to sign on hisher or herhis behalf, individually and in each capacity stated below, and to file, any and all amendments to this report.
 
SIGNATURES
 
Pursuant to the requirements of Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Norfolk Southern Corporation has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned, thereunto duly authorized, on this 4th5th day of February, 2021.2024.

/s/ James A. SquiresAlan H. Shaw
By:James A. SquiresAlan H. Shaw
(Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer)

K93K102


Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, this report has been signed below on this 4th5th day of February, 2021,2024, by the following persons on behalf of Norfolk Southern Corporation and in the capacities indicated.
SignatureTitle
/s/ James A. SquiresAlan H. Shaw
(James A. Squires)Alan H. Shaw)
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer and Director
(Principal Executive Officer)
/s/ Mark R. George
(Mark R. George)
Executive Vice President Finance and Chief Financial Officer
(Principal Financial Officer)
/s/ Clyde H. Allison, Jr.Claiborne L. Moore
(Clyde H. Allison, Jr.)Claiborne L. Moore)
Vice President and Controller
(Principal Accounting Officer)
/s/ Amy E. Miles
(Amy E. Miles)
Independent Chair and Director
/s/ Thomas D. Bell, Jr.
(Thomas D. Bell, Jr.)
Director
/s/ Mitchell E. Daniels, Jr.
(Mitchell E. Daniels, Jr.)
Director
/s/ Philip S. Davidson
(Philip S. Davidson)
Director
/s/ Francesca A. DeBiase
(Francesca A. DeBiase)
Director
/s/ Marcela E. Donadio
(Marcela E. Donadio)
Director
/s/ John C. Hufford,Huffard, Jr.
(John C. Hufford,Huffard, Jr.)
Director
/s/ Christopher T. Jones
(Christopher T. Jones)
Director
/s/ Thomas C. Kelleher
(Thomas C. Kelleher)
Director
/s/ Steven F. Leer
(Steven F. Leer)
Director
/s/ Michael D. Lockhart
(Michael D. Lockhart)
Director
/s/ Amy E. Miles
(Amy E. Miles)
Director
/s/ Claude Mongeau
(Claude Mongeau)
Director
/s/ Jennifer F. Scanlon
(Jennifer F. Scanlon)
Director
/s/ John R. Thompson
(John R. Thompson)
Director

K94K103


Schedule II
Norfolk Southern Corporation and Subsidiaries
Valuation and Qualifying Accounts
Years ended December 31, 2020, 2019,2023, 2022, and 20182021
($ in millions)
  Additions charged to:    
Beginning
Balance
Expenses
Other
Accounts 
DeductionsEnding
Balance
Year ended December 31, 2020
Current portion of casualty and 
other claims included in
accounts payable$212 $27 $81 (2)$138 (3)$182 
Casualty and other claims
included in other liabilities171 80 (1)82 (4)169 
Year ended December 31, 2019
Current portion of casualty and 
other claims included in 
accounts payable$213 $22 $131 (2)$154 (3)$212 
Casualty and other claims
included in other liabilities158 89 (1)76 (4)171 
Year ended December 31, 2018
Current portion of casualty and 
other claims included in 
accounts payable$187 $32 $145 (2)$151 (3)$213 
Casualty and other claims
included in other liabilities179 85 (1)106 (4)158 
  Additions charged to:    
Beginning
Balance
Expenses
Other
Accounts 
DeductionsEnding
Balance
Year ended December 31, 2023
Current portion of casualty and 
other claims included in
accounts payable$170 $51 $84 (2)$(119)(3)$186 
Casualty and other claims
included in other liabilities218 153 (1)— (150)(4)221 
Year ended December 31, 2022
Current portion of casualty and 
other claims included in 
accounts payable$166 $43 $88 (2)$127 (3)$170 
Casualty and other claims
included in other liabilities170 147 (1)— 99 (4)218 
Year ended December 31, 2021
Current portion of casualty and
other claims included in
accounts payable$182 $20 $80 (2)$116 (3)$166 
Casualty and other claims
included in other liabilities169 77 (1)— 76 (4)170 
 
(1)Includes adjustments for changes in estimates for prior years’ claims.
(2)Includes revenue refunds and overcharges provided through deductions from operating revenues and transfers  
from other accounts.
(3)Payments and reclassifications to/from accounts payable.
(4)Payments and reclassifications to/from other liabilities.

K95K104