AMENDMENT NUMBER I

                                       TO

               SPLIT DOLLAR INSURANCE AND DEATH BENEFIT AGREEMENT

                                 BY AND BETWEEN

                            NATIONAL FUEL GAS COMPANY
                                       AND

                                  Bruce H. Hale


         This Amendment Number I to the Split Dollar Insurance and Death Benefit
Agreement is made and entered into this 29th day of March, 1999 , by and between
National Fuel Gas Company (the "Company") and Bruce H. Hale (the "Executive").

         WHEREAS,  Company and  Executive  are parties to a certain Split Dollar
Insurance  and  Death  Benefit  Agreement  made as of  September  15,  1997 (the
"Agreement"); and

         WHEREAS,   Company  and  Executive  agree  to  this  amendment  of  the
Agreement,  as permitted in Article XI, to revise the  calculation  of the Death
Benefit  therein to  include  restricted  stock  awarded in lieu of a cash award
under  the  Company's  Annual  At  Risk  Compensation   Incentive  Program  (the
"AARCIP").

         NOW THEREFORE,  in  consideration  of the premises and mutual covenants
contained herein, the parties hereto agree as follows:

         1 . Article VI,  Paragraph  A shall be amended to insert the  following
sentence after the first complete sentence thereof:

                  "Awards of restricted  stock made to the Executive for service
         in the  Company's  fiscal  year 1996 or later to  supplement  an AARCIP
         award  for that  fiscal  year,  which  was  approximately  equal to the
         maximum AARCIP award then  permissible  consistent with the shareholder
         approval applicable to that AARCIP award, shall also be included in the
         calculation of the  Executive's  Death Benefit at the rate of two times
         the most recent such award of restricted  stock, if any. The restricted
         stock shall be valued at the  average of the high and low market  value
         on the grant date."

         2. The amendments to the Agreement, contained herein, will be effective
as of the date of this  Amendment  Number I and shall  remain in effect  for the
entire term of the Agreement.

         3.  All  other  terms  and  provisions  of the  Agreement  that are not
inconsistent  with the terms and  conditions  of this  Amendment  Number I shall
remain in effect and are incorporated herein by reference.

         4. This Amendment Number I is binding upon the parties hereto and their
assigns.

         IN WITNESS  WHEREOF,  the parties  hereto  have  caused this  Amendment
Number I to the  Split  Dollar  Insurance  and  Death  Benefit  Agreement  to be
executed,  with full knowledge of its contents and with the intent to be legally
bound, on the date first written above.


NATIONAL FUEL GAS COMPANY                              EXECUTIVE

By: /s/ Philip C. Ackerman                             /s/ Bruce H. Hale
- --------------------------                             -----------------
Name:   Philip C. Ackerman                             Name: Bruce H. Hale
Title:  Senior Vice President                          Date: Mar 9, 1999
Date:  3/29/99

Witnessed:                                             Witnessed:
/s/ Janet M. Conrad                                    /s/ Robert J. Dauer
- -------------------                                    -------------------

3/29/99                                                3/9/99
- -------                                                ------
Date                                                   Date