1
Ameriana News Release


Ameriana Bancorp
2118 Bundy Avenue
P.O. Box H
New Castle, Indiana                       Contact:  Jerome J. Gassen
47632-1048                                President and Chief Executive Officer
765-529-2230-1-800-487-2118                                       (765)529-2230

          AMERIANA BANCORP REPORTS THIRD QUARTER, YEAR-TO-DATE RESULTS

NEW CASTLE, Ind. (October 31, 2005) - Ameriana Bancorp  (NASDAQ/NM:  ASBI) today
announced results for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2005.

      Net income for the third  quarter  totaled  $396,000  or $0.12 per diluted
share  compared with net income of $412,000 or $0.13 per diluted share  reported
in the same  period  last year.  Net  income  for the first nine  months of 2005
totaled  $1,886,000  or $0.59 per  diluted  share  compared  with net  income of
$1,318,000 or $0.42 per diluted share in the year-earlier period.

      Net income for the first nine months of 2005 reflected total recoveries of
$3,400,000 in the Commercial Money Center ("CMC") matter, including a payment of
$2,300,000 received during the first quarter in settlement of litigation against
one of the  sureties  for the lease pools and a payment of  $1,100,000  received
during the second  quarter in  settlement of the CMC  bankruptcy.  These amounts
were recorded as  recoveries  to the allowance for loan losses,  resulting in an
adjustment for loan losses of $2,997,000 for the nine months ended September 30,
2005,  compared  with  provision for loan losses of $275,000 for the nine months
ended  September 30, 2004. The provision for loan losses in the third quarter of
2005  remained  low because of  another,  although  smaller,  recovery of a loan
previously charged off.

      Net interest  income for the third  quarter was  $2,526,000  compared with
$2,669,000 in the  year-earlier  period.  Net interest income for the first nine
months of 2005 was $7,429,000  versus  $8,197,000 in the comparable  period last
year.

      Non-accrual  loans  declined  $4,211,000 or 60% to $2,839,000 in the third
quarter  versus the second quarter of 2005 and were 51% below the year-end level
of $5,736,000.  The decrease was primarily due to the  foreclosure of collateral
on a  commercial  real estate  loan,  the  successful  restructuring  of another
commercial  real estate loan, and the partial  charge-off of a third  commercial
real estate loan.

      Commenting on the results, Jerome J. Gassen, President and Chief Executive
Officer,  said,  "With rising  interest  rates  throughout the year - pressuring
deposit  costs  and  resulting  in a  relatively  flat  yield  curve -  Ameriana
continues to confront a difficult rate  environment.  We are actively working to
manage our interest rate risk and, at the same time, our asset quality  measures
have  continued  to improve to help counter  these  conditions.  This  progress,
coupled with recent recoveries on loans and leases that were previously  written
off, has provided a positive  offset to the continued  rate  compression we have
experienced.  Also,  we continue to see the benefit of cost control  initiatives
implemented  earlier,  which was  particularly  evident in the third  quarter as
other expenses  declined 5% primarily due to lower pension costs versus the same
period last year following  modifications to our plan in 2004 and because of the
voluntary payment we made toward our pension liability earlier this year.

                                     -MORE-


 2

ASBI Reports Third Quarter Results
Page 2
October 31, 2005

      "During the third  quarter,  we achieved loan growth that  reflects  other
Company  initiatives  to  build  our  business  -  with  increased  emphasis  on
commercial   lending,"  Gassen   continued.   "As  we  pursue  these  and  other
initiatives,  we will continue to seek further efficiencies in our operations to
help improve our overall performance going forward."

      During the third quarter,  Ameriana reclassified all investment securities
in its  portfolio  previously  accounted for as "held to maturity" to "available
for sale." This new  classification,  which  provides the Company with increased
flexibility   to  address   changing   interest  rate  risks  or  capitalize  on
opportunities  to  generate  higher  interest  earnings,  had no  effect  on the
Company's  earnings  for the  third  quarter.  Unrealized  net  losses  on these
investments,  however,  were  recorded as a reduction in  shareholders'  equity,
resulting  in a decline  in this  balance  compared  with the  earlier  reported
quarters.  These previously unrealized net losses reflected primarily the rising
rate environment that has existed for more than one year.

      Ameriana  Bancorp is a bank  holding  company.  Through  its wholly  owned
subsidiary,  Ameriana Bank and Trust SB, the Company offers an extensive line of
banking  services and provides a range of investments  and  securities  products
through branches in the central Indiana area. As its name implies, Ameriana Bank
and Trust SB also offers trust and investment management services.  The Bank has
interests  in Family  Financial  Holdings,  Inc.  and  Indiana  Title  Insurance
Company, and owns Ameriana Insurance Agency, a full-service insurance agency.

      This news release contains  forward-looking  statements within the meaning
of the federal securities laws. Statements in this release that are not strictly
historical are forward-looking and are based upon current  expectations that may
differ materially from actual results. These forward-looking  statements involve
risks and  uncertainties  that could cause actual  results to differ  materially
from  those  anticipated  by  the  statements  made  herein.   These  risks  and
uncertainties  involve general economic trends,  changes in interest rates, loss
of deposits and loan demand to other financial institutions, substantial changes
in financial  markets;  changes in real estate value and the real estate market,
regulatory  changes,  possibility  of unforeseen  events  affecting the industry
generally,  the  uncertainties  associated  with  newly  developed  or  acquired
operations,  the outcome of pending litigation, and market disruptions and other
effects of terrorist activities.  The Company undertakes no obligation to update
these  forward-looking  statements to reflect events or circumstances  after the
date  hereof or to  reflect  the  occurrence  of  unforeseen  events,  except as
required  under  the  rules  and  regulations  of the  Securities  and  Exchange
Commission.

                                     -MORE-

 3

ASBI Reports Third Quarter Results
Page 3
October 31, 2005


                                AMERIANA BANCORP
                        UNAUDITED FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS
                   (In thousands, except per share amounts)

                                      THREE MONTHS ENDED      NINE MONTHS ENDED
                                         SEPTEMBER 30            SEPTEMBER 30
- --------------------------------------------------------    ------------------
                                        2005      2004        2005       2004
- ---------------------------------------------   --------    --------   -------

Interest income                       $ 5,056   $  4,566    $ 14,550   $13,640
Interest expense                        2,530      1,897       7,121     5,443
                                      -------   --------    --------   -------
Net interest income                     2,526      2,669       7,429     8,197
Provision (adjustment) for loan
    losses                                 35          75         (2,997)  275
                                      -------      ------      --------- -----
Net interest income after provision
  for loan losses                       2,491      2,594      10,426     7,922
Other income                              949        978       3,065     3,000
Other expense                           3,073      3,241      11,311     9,809
                                      -------   --------    --------   -------
Income before income taxes                 367       331       2,180     1,113
Income tax (benefit) expense               (29)      (81)        294      (205)
                                      --------  --------    --------   -------
Net income                            $   396   $    412    $  1,886   $ 1,318
                                      =======   ========    ========   =======
Earnings per share:
  Basic                               $  0.13   $   0.13    $   0.60   $  0.42
                                      =======   ========    =========  =======
  Diluted                             $  0.12   $   0.13    $   0.59   $  0.42
                                      =======   ========    =========  =======

Weighted average shares outstanding:
  Basic                                 3,162      3,149       3,156     3,149
                                      =======   ========    ========   =======
  Diluted                               3,173      3,174       3,170     3,172
                                      =======   ========    ========   =======

Dividends declared per share          $  0.16   $   0.16    $   0.48   $  0.48
                                      =======   ========    ========   =======


                                                 SEPT. 30    DEC. 31   SEPT. 30
                                                  2005        2004       2004
                                                --------    --------   -------
Total assets                                    $442,216    $428,553  $434,046
Cash and cash equivalents                         13,552      17,053    19,024
Investment securities held to maturity                --     158,322   160,103
Investment securities available for sale         172,358      12,032    11,975
Loans, net                                       209,057     196,344   198,172
Deposits                                         323,926     344,047   335,820
Borrowed funds                                    74,029      40,390    51,119
Shareholders' equity                              36,748      38,643    39,131
Loans accounted for on a non-accrual basis         2,839       5,736     4,876
Book value per share                               11.62       12.26     12.43

                                     -END-