AMENDMENT NO. 9 TO THE
                               NOBLE AFFILIATES
                       THRIFT AND PROFIT SHARING PLAN


      Pursuant to the provisions of Section 8.1 thereof, the Noble Affiliates

Thrift and Profit Sharing Plan, as amended and restated effective as of January

1, 1988 (the "Plan"), is hereby amended in the following respects only:

      FIRST:  Section 1.1(c) of the Plan is hereby amended by adding the

following sentence to the end thereof:

      In determining the Basic Compensation of an Employee, the rules of Section
      414(q)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code shall apply, except that in
      applying such rules, the term "family" shall include only the spouse of
      the Employee and any lineal descendants of the Employee who have not
      attained age 19 prior to the end of the Plan Year.

      SECOND:  Section 3.6 of the Plan is hereby amended by adding the

following subsection to the end thereof:

            (d)  Any provision of this Plan to the contrary notwithstanding, in
      addition to the above limitations of this Section, the sum of the actual
      deferral percentage and the contribution percentage for the group of
      Highly Compensated Employees as determined pursuant to and after
      application of subsections (b) and (c) of this Section shall not exceed
      the "aggregate limit."  The "aggregate limit" shall be equal to the
      greater of:

                  (1)  the sum of: (i) 1.25 times the greater of the relevant
            actual deferral percentage or the relevant contribution percentage,
            and (ii) two percentage points plus the lesser of the relevant
            actual deferral percentage or the relevant contribution percentage,
            provided that the amount in this clause (ii) shall not exceed twice
            the lesser of the relevant actual deferral percentage or the
            relevant contribution percentage; or

                  (2)  the sum of: (i) 1.25 times the lesser of the relevant
            actual deferral percentage or the relevant contribution percentage,
            and (ii) two percentage points plus the greater of the relevant
            actual deferral percentage or the relevant contribution percentage,
            provided that the amount in this clause (ii) shall not exceed twice
            the greater of the relevant actual deferral percentage or the
            relevant contribution percentage.






      The "relevant actual deferral percentage" means the actual deferral
      percentage determined pursuant to subsection (b) of this Section for
      the group of Employees who are not Highly Compensated Employees.
      The "relevant contribution percentage" means the contribution
      percentage determined pursuant to subsection (c) of this Section for the
      group of Employees who are not Highly Compensated Employees.  In the event
      that the aggregate limit is exceeded in any year, then the actual deferral
      percentage and/or contribution percentage for Participants who are members
      of the group of Highly Compensated Employees shall be reduced by reducing
      first any Pre-Tax Contributions and then any Matching Contributions made
      for such Plan Year for or on behalf of the Highly Compensated Employees
      with the largest individual actual deferral percentages and/or
      contribution percentages to the largest uniform actual deferral percentage
      and/or contribution percentage (commencing with the Highly Compensated
      Employee with the largest actual deferral percentage and/or contribution
      percentage and reducing his or her actual deferral percentage and/or
      contribution percentage to the extent necessary to satisfy the above
      restrictions or to lower such actual deferral percentage and/or
      contribution percentage to the actual deferral percentage and/or
      contribution percentage of the Highly Compensated Employee with the next
      highest actual deferral percentage and/or contribution percentage, and
      repeating this process as necessary) that permits the sum of the actual
      deferral percentage and contribution percentage for said group of Highly
      Compensated Employees to satisfy the above restrictions.  If any portion
      of a Pre-Tax Contribution made on behalf of a Participant is distributed
      to such Participant pursuant to this subsection, any portion of a Matching
      Contribution (along with any income allocable thereto) made for such
      Participant that matches the distributed Pre-Tax Contribution shall be
      forfeited.  Any additional Matching Contributions made for a Participant
      which cannot be credited to the Employer Matching Account of such
      Participant for a Plan Year because of the limitation contained in this
      subsection (along with any income allocable thereto) shall be forfeited if
      forfeitable, but if not forfeitable, distributed to such Participant
      within 2 1/2 months after the end of such year.  If for a Plan Year the
      Compensation received by an Employee is treated pursuant to Section 1.1(p)
      as Compensation received by a Highly Compensated Employee, then this
      subsection shall be applied to such Employees for such Plan Year in
      accordance with regulations under Section 401(k) and (m) of the Internal
      Revenue Code.



                                     -2-




      IN WITNESS WHEREOF, this Amendment has been executed this

19th day of May, 1994, to be effective as of January 1, 1989.

                                       NOBLE AFFILIATES, INC.



                                       By:  /S/  ROBERT KELLEY
                                          ----------------------------------
                                           Title: Chairman, President &
                                                   Chief Executive Officer
                                       - 3 -