Exhibit 4.6
================================================================================
                          EXCHANGE GUARANTEE AGREEMENT


                                     between


                        Symons International Group, Inc.
                             (as Exchange Guarantor)


                                       and


                            Wilmington Trust Company

                                  (as Trustee)


                                   dated as of


                               ____________, 1997

================================================================================






                             CROSS REFERENCE TABLE*


Section of                                                 Section of
Trust Indenture Act                                        Exchange Guarantee
of 1939, as Amended                                        Agreement

310(a).......................................................4.1(a)
310(b).......................................................4.1(c), 2.B
310(c).......................................................Inapplicable
311(a).......................................................2.2(b)
311(b).......................................................2.2(b)
311(c).......................................................Inapplicable
312(a).......................................................2.2(a)
312(b).......................................................2.2(b)
313..........................................................2.3
314(a).......................................................2.4
314(b).......................................................Inapplicable
314(c).......................................................2.5
314(d).......................................................Inapplicable
314(e).......................................................1.1, 2.5, 3.2
314(f).......................................................2.1, 3.2
315(a).......................................................3.1(d)
315(b).......................................................2.7
315(c).......................................................3.1
315(d).......................................................3.1(d)
316(a).......................................................1.1, 2.6, 5.4
316(b).......................................................5.3
316(c).......................................................8.2
317(a).......................................................Inapplicable
317(b).......................................................Inapplicable
318(a).......................................................2.1(b)
318(b).......................................................2.1
318(c).......................................................2.1(a)






- --------
     *   This  Cross-Reference  Table does not  constitute  part of the Exchange
         Guarantee  Agreement and shall not affect the  interpretation of any of
         its terms or provisions.






                                TABLE OF CONTENTS


                                                                           Page
                                                                           ----

              ARTICLE I. DEFINITIONS.......................................  2
SECTION 1.1.  Definitions..................................................  2

              ARTICLE II.  TRUST INDENTURE ACT.............................  4
SECTION 2.1.  Trust Indenture Act; Application.............................  4
SECTION 2.2.  List of Holders..............................................  4
SECTION 2.3.  Reports by the Exchange Guarantee Trustee....................  5
SECTION 2.4.  Periodic Reports to the Exchange Guarantee Trustee...........  5
SECTION 2.5.  Evidence of Compliance with Condition Precedent..............  5
SECTION 2.6.  Events of Default; Waiver....................................  5
SECTION 2.7.  Event of Default; Notice.....................................  5
SECTION 2.8.  Conflicting Interests........................................  6

              ARTICLE III. POWERS, DUTIES AND RIGHTS OF THE EXCHANGE
              GUARANTEE TRUSTEE............................................  6
SECTION 3.1.  Powers and Duties of the Exchange Guarantee Trustee..........  6
SECTION 3.2.  Certain Rights of Exchange Guarantee Trustee.................  8
SECTION 3.3.  Indemnity....................................................  9

              ARTICLE IV.  EXCHANGE GUARANTEE TRUSTEE...................... 10
SECTION 4.1.  Exchange Guarantee Trustee; Eligibility...................... 10
SECTION 4.2.  Appointment, Removal and Resignation of the Exchange
               Guarantee Trustee........................................... 10

              ARTICLE V.  GUARANTEE........................................ 11
SECTION 5.1.  Exchange Guarantee........................................... 11
SECTION 5.2.  Waiver of Notice and Demand.................................. 11
SECTION 5.3.  Obligations Not Affected..................................... 11
SECTION 5.4.  Rights of Holders............................................ 12
SECTION 5.5.  Guarantee of Payment......................................... 13
SECTION 5.6.  Subrogation.................................................. 13
SECTION 5.7.  Independent Obligations...................................... 13

              ARTICLE VI.  SUBORDINATION................................... 13
SECTION 6.1.  Subordination................................................ 13

              ARTICLE VII.  TERMINATION.................................... 15
SECTION 7.1.  Termination.................................................. 15

                                        i






              ARTICLE VIII.  MISCELLANEOUS................................. 15
SECTION 8.1.  Successors and Assigns....................................... 15
SECTION 8.2.  Amendments................................................... 15
SECTION 8.3.  Notices...................................................... 16
SECTION 8.4.  Benefit...................................................... 17
SECTION 8.5.  Interpretation............................................... 17
SECTION 8.6.  Governing Law................................................ 17


                                       ii





                          EXCHANGE GUARANTEE AGREEMENT

         This EXCHANGE GUARANTEE AGREEMENT,  dated as of ____________,  1997, is
executed  and  delivered by Symons  International  Group,  Inc.,  a  corporation
organized under the laws of the State of Indiana ("Exchange Guarantor"),  having
its principal office at 4720 Kingsway Drive,  Indianapolis,  Indiana, 46205, and
Wilmington  Trust Company,  a Delaware  banking  corporation  duly organized and
existing  under the laws of the State of  Delaware,  as trustee  (the  "Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee"),  for the benefit of the Holders (as defined  herein)  from
time to time of the Exchange  Preferred  Securities  (as defined  herein) of SIG
Capital Trust I, a Delaware statutory business trust (the "Issuer").

         WHEREAS,  pursuant to the terms of an Amended and Restated  Declaration
of Trust dated as of August 12, 1997 (the "Declaration"),  among the trustees of
Issuer, the Exchange Guarantor, as sponsor, and the holders from time to time of
undisclosed  beneficial  interests  in the assets of the  Issuer,  the Issuer is
issuing  on the date  hereof  35,000  Exchange  Preferred  Securities  having an
aggregate   liquidation   amount  of  $135,000,000,   such  Exchange   Preferred
Securitiesbeing  designated as 9 1/2% Exchange  Preferred  Securities (and being
herein  referred to as the "Exchange  Preferred  Securities") in connection with
the consummation of the Exchange Offer (as defined in the Declaration);

         WHEREAS, as incentive for the Holders of Preferred Securities issued on
August 12, 1997 to exchange the  Preferred  Securities  for  Exchange  Preferred
Securities in the Exchange Offer, the Exchange Guarantor desires irrevocably and
unconditionally  to guarantee,  to the extent set forth  herein,  payment to the
Holders of the Exchange Preferred  Securities the Guarantee Payments (as defined
herein) and to make certain other payments on the terms and conditions set forth
herein.

         NOW,  THEREFORE,  in  consideration  of the  exchange by each Holder of
Exchange  Preferred  Securities,  which exchange the Exchange  Guarantor  hereby
shall  benefit the  Exchange  Guarantor,  the  Exchange  Guarantor  executes and
delivers this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement for the benefit of the Holders from
time to time of the Exchange Preferred Securities.

                             ARTICLE I. DEFINITIONS

         SECTION 1.1.  Definitions.

         As used in this Exchange Guarantee Agreement, the terms set forth below
shall,  unless the context  otherwise  requires,  have the  following  meanings.
Capitalized  or otherwise  defined terms used but not otherwise  defined  herein
shall have the meanings  assigned to such terms in the  Declaration as in effect
on the date hereof.

         "Affiliate" of any specified  Person means any other Person directly or
indirectly controlling or controlled by or under direct common control with such
specified Person; provided, however, that an Affiliate of the Exchange Guarantor
shall not be deemed to include the  Issuer.  For the  purposes  of this  defini-
tion,  "control"  when used with respect to







any specified  Person means the power to direct the  management  and policies of
such Person,  directly or  indirectly,  whether  through the ownership of voting
securities,   by  contract  or  otherwise;   and  the  terms  "controlling"  and
"controlled" have meanings correlative to the foregoing.

         "Common Security" means an undivided  beneficial interest in the assets
of the Issuer,  having a Liquidation  Amount (as defined in the  Declaration) of
$1,000 and having the rights provided therefor in the Declaration, including the
right to  receive  Distributions  and a  Liquidation  Distribution  as  provided
therein.

         "Event of Default" means a default by the Exchange  Guarantor on any of
its payment obligations under this Exchange Guarantee Agreement.

         "Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee" means Wilmington Trust Company,  until a
Successor  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee has been appointed and has accepted such
appointment  pursuant  to the terms of this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  and
thereafter means each such Successor Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

         "Guarantee  Payments"  means the following  payments or  distributions,
without duplication,  with respect to the Exchange Preferred Securities,  to the
extent not paid or made by or on behalf of the Issuer:  (i) any  accumulated and
unpaid Distributions  required to be paid on the Exchange Preferred  Securities,
to the  extent  the  Issuer  has  funds  legally  available  therefor,  (ii) the
Redemption Price with respect to the Exchange  Preferred  Securities  called for
redemption,  to the extent the Issuer has funds legally  available  therefor and
(iii) upon a voluntary or involuntary dissolution,  winding up or liquidation of
the Issuer  (unless the  Exchange  Notes are  distributed  to the Holders of the
Exchange  Preferred  Securities),  the  lesser  of  (a)  the  aggregate  of  the
liquidation  amount and all accrued  and unpaid  distributions  on the  Exchange
Preferred  Securities to the date of payment, to the extent the Issuer has funds
legally  available  therefor  and (b) the  amount of cash  assets of the  Issuer
remaining  legally  available  for  distribution  to  Holders  of  the  Exchange
Preferred Securities upon liquidation of the Issuer.

         "Holder"  means any holder,  as  registered on the books and records of
the Issuer, of any Exchange Preferred  Securities;  provided,  however,  that in
determining  whether  the  holders  of  the  requisite  percentage  of  Exchange
Preferred Securities have given any request, demand,  authorization,  direction,
notice,  consent or waiver  hereunder,  "Holder"  shall not include the Exchange
Guarantor,  any Trustee,  or any  Affiliate of the Exchange  Guarantor or of any
Trustee.

         "Indenture" means the Senior Subordinated  Indenture dated as of August
12, 1997, among the Exchange Guarantor and Wilmington Trust Company, as trustee.

         "List of Holders" has the meaning specified in Section 2.2(a).

                                        2





         "Majority in liquidation  amount of the  Securities"  means,  except as
provided by the Trust Indenture Act, a vote by the Holder(s),  voting separately
as a class, of more than 50% of the liquidation  amount of all then  outstanding
Exchange Preferred Securities issued by the Issuer.

         "Officers'  Certificate" means a certificate signed by (a) the Chairman
and Chief Executive Officer,  President or Vice President, and by the Treasurer,
an Assistant Treasurer, the Controller, the Secretary or an Assistant Secretary,
or (b) any two members of the Board of Directors of the Company,  and  delivered
to the appropriate Trustee. Any Officers'  Certificate delivered with respect to
compliance with a condition or covenant provided for in this Exchange  Guarantee
Agreement shall include:

         (a) a statement that each officer signing the Officers' Certificate has
read the covenant or condition and the definitions relating thereto;

         (b) a brief  statement  of the nature and scope of the  examination  or
investigation undertaken by each officer in rendering the Officers' Certificate;

         (c) a  statement  that  each  officer  has  made  such  examination  or
investigation as, in such officer's opinion, is necessary to enable such officer
to express an informed opinion as to whether such covenant or condition has been
complied with; and

         (d) a statement  as to whether,  in the opinion of each  officer,  such
condition or covenant has been complied with.

         "Person" means any individual,  corporation, estate, partnership, joint
venture,  association,  joint-stock company,  limited liability company,  trust,
unincorporated  organization,  or government or any agency,  instrumentality  or
political subdivision thereof, or any other entity of whatever nature.

         "Responsible  Officer"  means,  with respect to the Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee,  any Senior Vice  President,  any Vice  President,  any Assistant  Vice
President,  the Secretary, any Assistant Secretary, the Treasurer, any Assistant
Treasurer,  any Trust Officer or Assistant Trust Officer or any other officer of
the Corporate Trust Department of the above-designated  officers and also means,
with respect to a particular  corporate trust matter,  any other officer to whom
such matter is referred  because of that officer's  knowledge of and familiarity
with the particular subject.

         "Senior Indebtedness" has the meaning specified in the Indenture.

         "Successor  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee"  means a  successor  Exchange
Guarantee Trustee  possessing the  qualifications  to act as Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee under Section 4.1.


                                        3





         "Trust Indenture Act" means the Trust Indenture Act of 1939 as in force
at the date as of which this instrument was executed; provided, however, that in
the event the Trust  Indenture  Act of 1939 is amended  after such date,  "Trust
Indenture Act" means, to the extent  required by any such  amendment,  the Trust
Indenture Act of 1939 as so amended.

                         ARTICLE II. TRUST INDENTURE ACT

         SECTION 2.1.  Trust Indenture Act; Application.

         (a) This Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement is subject to the provisions of
the Trust Indenture Act that are required to be part of this Exchange  Guarantee
Agreement and shall, to the extent applicable, be governed by such provisions.

         (b) If and to the extent that any provision of this Exchange  Guarantee
Agreement limits, qualifies or conflicts with the duties imposed by Sections 310
to 317,  inclusive,  of the Trust  Indenture  Act,  such  imposed  duties  shall
control.

         SECTION 2.2.  List of Holders.

         (a) The Exchange  Guarantor  shall  furnish or cause to be furnished to
the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee (a)  semiannually,  on or before February 15 and
August 15 of each year, a list, in such form as the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee
may  reasonably  require,  of the names and  addresses of the Holders  ("List of
Holders") as of a date not more than 15 days prior to the delivery thereof,  and
(b) at such  other  times as the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  may  request  in
writing,  within 30 days after the receipt by the Exchange Guarantor of any such
request,  a List of Holders as of a date not more than 15 days prior to the time
such list is furnished,  in each case to the extent such  information  is in the
possession  or control  of the  Exchange  Guarantor  and is not  identical  to a
previously  supplied list of Holders or has not  otherwise  been received by the
Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee in its  capacity as such.  The  Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee may destroy any List of Holders  previously  given to it on receipt of a
new List of Holders.

         (b) The Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee shall comply with its  obligations
under Section  311(a),  Section 311(b) and Section 312(b) of the Trust Indenture
Act.

         SECTION 2.3.  Reports by the Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

         Not later than April 30 of each year,  commencing  April 30, 1998,  the
Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  provide to the Holders  such reports as are
required by Section 313 of the Trust  Indenture  Act, if any, in the form and in
the manner  provided by Section 313 of the Trust  Indenture  Act.  The  Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee shall also comply with the  requirements of Section 313(d) of
the Trust Indenture Act.

         SECTION 2.4.  Periodic Reports to the Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

                                        4





         The Exchange Guarantor shall provide to the Exchange Guarantee Trustee,
the Securities and Exchange  Commission and the Holders such documents,  reports
and  information,  if any, as required by Section 314 of the Trust Indenture Act
and the compliance  certificate  required by Section 314 of the Trust  Indenture
Act, in the form, in the manner and at the times  required by Section 314 of the
Trust Indenture Act.

         SECTION 2.5.  Evidence of Compliance with Condition Precedent.

         The Exchange  Guarantor shall provide to the Exchange Guarantee Trustee
such evidence of compliance with such conditions precedent, if any, provided for
in this Exchange Guarantee Agreement that relate to any of the matters set forth
in  Section  314(c) of the Trust  Indenture  Act.  Any  certificate  or  opinion
required to be given by an officer  pursuant to Section  314(c) (1) may be given
in the form of an Officers' Certificate.

         SECTION 2.6.  Events of Default; Waiver.

         The Holders of a Majority in liquidation  amount of the Securities may,
by vote,  on behalf of the  Holders,  waive any past  Event of  Default  and its
consequences.  Upon such waiver, any such Event of Default shall cease to exist,
and any Event of Default  arising  therefrom shall be deemed to have been cured,
for every purpose of this Exchange Guarantee Agreement, but no such waiver shall
extend to any  subsequent  or other  default  or Event of  Default or impair any
right consequent therefrom.

         SECTION 2.7.  Event of Default; Notice.

         (a) The  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall,  within 90 days after the
occurrence  of an Event  of  Default,  transmit  by mail,  first  class  postage
prepaid, to the Holders,  notices of all Events of Default known to the Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee,  unless such  defaults  have been cured before the giving of
such notice, provided, that, except in the case of a default in the payment of a
Guarantee  Payment,  the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  be  protected  in
withholding such notice if and so long as the Board of Directors,  the executive
committee or a trust committee of directors and/or  Responsible  Officers of the
Exchange Guarantee Trustee in good faith determines that the withholding of such
notice is in the interests of the Holders.

         (b)  The  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  not be  deemed  to  have
knowledge of any Event of Default  unless the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee shall
have  received  written  notice,  or a  Responsible  Officer  charged  with  the
administration  of the Declaration  shall have obtained written notice,  of such
Event of Default.

         SECTION 2.8.  Conflicting Interests.


                                        5





         The Declaration  shall be deemed to be  specifically  described in this
Exchange Guarantee Agreement for the purposes of clause (i) of the first proviso
contained in Section 310(b) of the Trust Indenture Act.

        ARTICLE III. POWERS, DUTIES AND RIGHTS OF THE EXCHANGE GUARANTEE
                      TRUSTEE

         SECTION 3.1.  Powers and Duties of the Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

         (a) This  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  shall be held by the Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee for the benefit of the Holders,  and the  Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee  shall not  transfer  this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement to any Person
except a Holder  exercising his or her rights pursuant to Section 5.4 (iv) or to
a Successor  Exchange Guarantee Trustee on acceptance by such Successor Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee of its  appointment  to act as Successor  Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee.  The right,  title and interest of the Exchange Guarantee Trustee shall
automatically vest in any Successor Exchange Guarantee Trustee,  upon acceptance
by such Successor Exchange Guarantee Trustee of its appointment  hereunder,  and
such  vesting and  cessation of title shall be  effective  whether  conveyancing
documents have been executed and delivered  pursuant to the  appointment of such
Successor Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

         (b) If an Event of Default has occurred and is continuing, the Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee  shall  enforce this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  for the
benefit of the Holders.

         (c) The Exchange Guarantee Trustee,  before the occurrence of any Event
of Default and after the curing of all Events of Default that may have occurred,
shall  undertake  to perform only such duties as are  specifically  set forth in
this Exchange Guarantee  Agreement,  and no implied covenants shall be read into
this Exchange Guarantee  Agreement against the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee.  In
case an Event of  Default  has  occurred  (that  has not  been  cured or  waived
pursuant to Section 2.6), the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee shall exercise such of
the rights and powers vested in it by this Exchange Guarantee Agreement, and use
the same degree of care and skill in its exercise  thereof,  as a prudent person
would  exercise or use under the  circumstance  in the conduct of his or her own
affairs.

         (d)  No  provision  of  this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  shall  be
construed to relieve the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee from liability for its own
negligent  action,  its  own  negligent  failure  to  act  or  its  own  willful
misconduct, except that:

                  (i) prior to the  occurrence of any Event of Default and after
         the  curing or  waiving  of all such  Events of  Default  that may have
         occurred:

                           (A)  the  duties  and  obligations  of  the  Exchange
                  Guarantee  Trustee shall be  determined  solely by the express
                  provisions  of  this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement,  and the
                  Exchange Guarantee Trustee shall not be liable 

                                        6





                  except for  the  performance of such duties and obligations as
                  are specifically set forth in this Exchange Guarantee
                  Agreement; and

                           (B) in the  absence  of bad  faith on the part of the
                  Exchange Guarantee Trustee, the Exchange Guarantee Trustee may
                  conclusively  rely, as to the truth of the  statements and the
                  correctness  of  the  opinions  expressed  therein,  upon  any
                  certificates or opinions  furnished to the Exchange  Guarantee
                  Trustee and  conforming to the  requirements  of this Exchange
                  Guarantee Agreement;  but in the case of any such certificates
                  or  opinions  that by any  provision  hereof  or of the  Trust
                  Indenture Act are specifically required to be furnished to the
                  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee,  the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee
                  shall be under a duty to examine the same to determine whether
                  they conform to the  requirements  of this Exchange  Guarantee
                  Agreement;

                  (ii) the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall not be liable for
         any error of judgment  made in good faith by a  Responsible  Officer of
         the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee,  unless it shall be proved  that the
         Exchange  Guarantee Trustee was negligent in ascertaining the pertinent
         facts upon which such judgment was made;

                  (iii) the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee shall not be liable with
         respect to any action  taken or omitted to be taken by it in good faith
         in  accordance  with the  direction  of the  holders of not less than a
         Majority in liquidation amount of the Securities  relating to the time,
         method and place of conducting any proceeding for any remedy  available
         to the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee,  or exercising  any trust or power
         conferred  upon the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  under this  Exchange
         Guarantee Agreement; and

                  (iv) no provision of this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement shall
         require the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee to expend or risk his own funds
         or otherwise incur personal  financial  liability in the performance of
         any of its duties or in the exercise of any of its rights or powers, if
         the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall have  reasonable  grounds  for
         believing  that  the  repayment  of  such  funds  or  liability  is not
         reasonably  assured  to it under the terms of this  Exchange  Guarantee
         Agreement or adequate  indemnity  against such risk or liability is not
         reasonably assured to it.

         SECTION 3.2.  Certain Rights of Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

         (a)      Subject to the provisions of Section 3.1:

                  (i) The Exchange Guarantee Trustee may rely and shall be fully
         protected  in acting or  refraining  from acting  upon any  resolution,
         certificate,  statement,  instrument, opinion, report, notice, request,
         direction, consent, order, bond, debenture, note, or other evidence of
         indebtedness or other paper or document

                                        7





         reasonably believed by it to be genuine and to have been  signed,  sent
         or presented by the proper party or parties.

                  (ii)  any   direction  or  act  of  the   Exchange   Guarantor
         contemplated by this Exchange Guarantee Agreement shall be sufficiently
         evidenced  by an  Officers'  Certificate  unless  otherwise  prescribed
         herein.

                  (iii)  Whenever,   in  the  administration  of  this  Exchange
         Guarantee  Agreement,  the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall deem it
         desirable  that a  matter  be  proved  or  established  before  taking,
         suffering  or  omitting  to take any  action  hereunder,  the  Exchange
         Guarantee  Trustee  (unless  other  evidence  is  herein   specifically
         prescribed)  may, in the absence of bad faith on its part,  request and
         rely upon an Officers'  Certificate which, upon receipt of such request
         from the Exchange Guarantee Trustee, shall be promptly delivered by the
         Exchange Guarantor.

                  (iv) The  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee may consult  with legal
         counsel,  and the written  advice or opinion of such legal counsel with
         respect to legal matters shall be full and complete  authorization  and
         protection  in respect of any action  taken,  suffered or omitted to be
         taken by it hereunder in good faith and in accordance  with such advice
         or opinion.  Such legal  counsel may be legal  counsel to the  Exchange
         Guarantor or any of its Affiliates and may be one of its employees. The
         Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  have the right at any time to seek
         instructions  concerning the  administration of this Exchange Guarantee
         Agreement from any court of competent jurisdiction.

                  (v)  The  Exchange   Guarantee   Trustee  shall  be  under  no
         obligation to exercise any of the rights or powers vested in it by this
         Exchange Guarantee Agreement at the request or direction of any Holder,
         unless  such  Holder  shall have  provided  to the  Exchange  Guarantee
         Trustee  such  adequate  security  and  indemnity  as would  satisfy  a
         reasonable  person in the position of the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee,
         against the costs,  expenses  (including  attorneys' fees and expenses)
         and  liabilities  that might be incurred by it in  complying  with such
         request or  direction,  including  such  reasonable  advances as may be
         requested by the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee;  provided that,  nothing
         contained  in this  Section  3.2(a) (v) shall be taken to  relieve  the
         Exchange Guarantee Trustee, upon the occurrence of an Event of Default,
         of its  obligation  to exercise  the rights and powers  vested in it by
         this Exchange Guarantee Agreement.

                  (vi) The Exchange Guarantee Trustee shall not be bound to make
         any  investigation  into the facts or matters stated in any resolution,
         certificate,  statement,  instrument, opinion, report, notice, request,
         direction,  consent,  order, bond,  debenture,  note, other evidence of
         indebtedness  or other paper or document,  but the  Exchange  Guarantee
         Trustee,   in  its  discretion,   may  make  such  further  inquiry  or
         investigation into such facts or matters as it may see fit.


                                        8





                  (vii) The  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee may execute any of the
         trusts or powers  hereunder  or  perform  any duties  hereunder  either
         directly or by or through  its agents or  attorneys,  and the  Exchange
         Guarantee  Trustee  shall  not be  responsible  for any  misconduct  or
         negligence on the part of any such agent or attorney appointed with due
         care by it hereunder.

                  (viii)  Whenever  in  the   administration  of  this  Exchange
         Guarantee  Agreement  the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  deem it
         desirable to receive  instructions with respect to enforcing any remedy
         or right or take any other action  hereunder,  the  Exchange  Guarantee
         Trustee (A) may request  instructions from the Holders, (B) may refrain
         from  enforcing  such remedy or right or taking such other action until
         such instructions are received, and (C) shall be protected in acting in
         accordance with such instructions.

         (b) No provision of this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement shall be deemed
to impose any duty or  obligation on the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee to perform
any act or acts or exercise any right,  power,  duty or obligation  conferred or
imposed on it in any jurisdiction in which it shall be illegal,  or in which the
Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee shall be  unqualified  or incompetent in accordance
with  applicable  law, to perform  any such act or acts or to exercise  any such
right, power, duty or obligation.  No permissive power or authority available to
the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  be  construed  to be a duty  to act in
accordance with such power and authority.

         SECTION 3.3.  Indemnity.

         The  Exchange  Guarantor  agrees to indemnify  the  Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee for,  and to hold it harmless  against,  any loss,  liability or expense
incurred without  negligence or bad faith on the part of the Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee,  arising out of or in connection with the acceptance or  administration
of this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement,  including  the costs and  expenses  of
defending  itself against any claim or liability in connection with the exercise
or performance of any of its powers or duties  hereunder  (including the fees of
counsel,  provided  that the  selection  of such  counsel will be subject to the
consent of the  Exchange  Guarantor,  which  consent  shall not be  unreasonably
withheld).  The Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee will not claim or exact any lien or
charge on any Guarantee  Payments as a result of any amount due to it under this
Exchange Guarantee Agreement.


                     ARTICLE IV. EXCHANGE GUARANTEE TRUSTEE

         SECTION 4.1.  Exchange Guarantee Trustee; Eligibility.

         (a)      There shall at all times be a Exchange Guarantee Trustee which
                  shall:

                  (i)      not be an Affiliate of the Exchange Guarantor; and

                                        9







                  (ii)  be a  Person  that is  eligible  pursuant  to the  Trust
         Indenture Act to act as such and has a combined  capital and surplus of
         at  least  $50,000,000,   and  shall  be  a  corporation   meeting  the
         requirements  of Section  310(c) of the Trust  Indenture  Act.  If such
         corporation publishes reports of condition at least annually,  pursuant
         to  law  or  to  the  requirements  of  the  supervising  or  examining
         authority,  then,  for the  purposes of this  Section and to the extent
         permitted by the Trust Indenture Act, the combined  capital and surplus
         of such  corporation  shall be deemed to be its  combined  capital  and
         surplus  as set  forth  in its  most  recent  report  of  condition  so
         published.

         (b) If at any time the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall cease to be
eligible to so act under Section 4.1(e),  the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee shall
immediately resign in the manner and with the effect set out in Section 4.2(c).

         (c)  If  the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  has or  shall  acquire  any
"conflicting  interest"  within  the  meaning  of  Section  310(b)  of the Trust
Indenture Act, the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee and Exchange  Guarantor shall in
all respects comply with the provisions of Section 310(b) of the Trust Indenture
Act.

         SECTION 4.2.  Appointment, Removal and Resignation of the Exchange 
                       Guarantee Trustee.

         (a) Subject to Section 4.2(b),  the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee may be
appointed or removed without cause at any time by the Exchange Guarantor.

         (b)  The  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  not be  removed  until a
Successor  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee has been appointed and has accepted such
appointment by written instrument  executed by such Successor Exchange Guarantee
Trustee and delivered to the Exchange Guarantor.

         (c) The  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  appointed  hereunder  shall hold
office until a Successor Exchange Guarantee Trustee shall have been appointed or
until its removal or resignation. The Exchange Guarantee Trustee may resign from
office  (without  need for prior or subsequent  accounting)  by an instrument in
writing executed by the Exchange Guarantee Trustee and delivered to the Exchange
Guarantor,  which resignation  shall not take effect until a Successor  Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee has been  appointed  and has  accepted  such  appointment  by
instrument in writing executed by such Successor  Exchange Guarantee Trustee and
delivered  to the  Exchange  Guarantor  and  the  resigning  Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee.

         (d)  If  no  Successor  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall  have  been
appointed  and  accepted  appointment  as provided in this Section 4.2 within 60
days after delivery to the Exchange  Guarantor of an instrument of  resignation,
the resigning Exchange Guarantee

                                       10





Trustee may  petition,  at the expense of the Exchange  Guarantor,  any court of
competent  jurisdiction  for  appointment  of  a  Successor  Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee. Such court may thereupon,  after prescribing such notice, if any, as it
may deem proper, appoint a Successor Exchange Guarantee Trustee.

                              ARTICLE V. GUARANTEE

         SECTION 5.1.  Exchange Guarantee.

         The Exchange Guarantor irrevocably and unconditionally agrees to pay in
full or a senior  subordinated  basis,  to the extent set forth  herein,  to the
Holders the Guarantee Payments (without  duplication of amounts theretofore paid
by or on behalf of the  Issuer),  as and when due,  regardless  of any  defense,
right of setoff or counterclaim which the Issuer may have or assert,  other than
the defense of payment. The Exchange Guarantor's  obligation to make a Guarantee
Payment  may be  satisfied  by direct  payment  of the  required  amounts by the
Exchange  Guarantor  to the Holders or by causing the Issuer to pay such amounts
to the Holders.

         SECTION 5.2.  Waiver of Notice and Demand.

         The  Exchange  Guarantor  hereby  waives  notice of  acceptance  of the
Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  and of any  liability to which it applies or may
apply, presentment,  demand for payment, any right to require a proceeding first
against  the  Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee,  Issuer or any other  Person  before
proceeding against the Exchange Guarantor, protest, notice of nonpayment, notice
of dishonor, notice of redemption and all other notices an demands.

         SECTION 5.3.  Obligations Not Affected.

         The  obligations,  covenants,  agreements  and  duties of the  Exchange
Guarantor under this Exchange Guarantee Agreement shall in no way be affected or
impaired by reason of the happening from time to time of any of the following:

         (a) the release or waiver,  by  operation of law or  otherwise,  of the
performance  or  observance  by the Issuer of any express or implied  agreement,
covenant,  term or condition relating to the Exchange Preferred Securities to be
performed or observed by the Trust;


         (b) the  extension  of time for the payment by the Issuer of all or any
portion of the Distributions,  Redemption Price, Liquidation Distribution or any
other sums payable under the terms of the Exchange  Preferred  Securities or the
extension of time for the performance of any other obligation under, arising out
of, or in connection with, the Exchange Preferred Securities;

         (c) any failure,  omission,  delay or lack of diligence on. the part of
the Holders to enforce, assert or exercise any right, privilege, power or remedy
conferred  on the  Holders

                                       11





pursuant  to the  terms  of the  Exchange  Preferred Securities,  or any  action
on the part of the  Issuer  granting  indulgence  or extension of any kind;

         (d) the voluntary or involuntary liquidation,  dissolution, sale of any
collateral, receivership,  insolvency, bankruptcy, assignment for the benefit of
creditors, reorganization., arrangement, composition or readjustment of debt of,
or other  similar  proceedings  affecting the Issuer or any of the assets of the
Issuer;

         (e)      any invalidity of, or defect or deficiency in, the Exchange 
Preferred Securities;

         (f)      the settlement or compromise of any obligation guaranteed 
hereby or hereby incurred; or

         (g) any other circumstance whatsoever that might otherwise constitute a
legal or equitable  discharge or defense of a guarantor,  it being the intent of
this Section 5.3 that the obligations of the Exchange Guarantor  hereunder shall
be absolute and unconditional under any and all circumstances. There shall be no
obligation  of the  Holders to give  notice to, or obtain  the  consent  of, the
Exchange Guarantor with respect to the happening of any of the foregoing.

         SECTION 5.4.  Rights of Holders.

         The Exchange Guarantor  expressly  acknowledges that: (i) this Exchange
Guarantee  Agreement will be deposited with the Exchange Guarantee Trustee to be
held for the benefit of the Holders; (ii) the Exchange Guarantee Trustee has the
right to enforce  this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement on behalf of the Holders;
(iii) the Holders of a Majority in liquidation amount of the Securities have the
right to direct the time,  method and place of conducting any proceeding for any
remedy available to the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee in respect of this Exchange
Guarantee Agreement or exercising any trust or power conferred upon the Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee under this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement;  and (iv) upon the
occurrence of an Event of Default,  any Holder may institute a legal  proceeding
directly  against  the  Exchange  Guarantor  to enforce  its  rights  under this
Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement,  without first  instituting  a legal  proceeding
against the Exchange Guarantee Trustee, the Issuer or any other Person.

         SECTION 5.5.  Guarantee of Payment.

         This Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  creates a guarantee of payment and
not of  collection.  This Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  will not be discharged
except by payment of the  Guarantee  Payments in full  (without  duplication  of
amounts  theretofore paid by the Issuer out of funds legally available therefor)
or upon distribution of Notes to Holders as provided in the Declaration.

         SECTION 5.6.  Subrogation.

                                       12







         The Exchange  Guarantor  shall be  subrogated to all (if any) rights of
the Holders  against the Issuer in respect of any amounts paid to the Holders by
the Exchange  Guarantor under this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement and shall have
the right to waive  payment by the Issuer  pursuant  to Section  5.1;  provided,
however, that the Exchange Guarantor shall not (except to the extent required by
mandatory provisions of law) be entitled to enforce or exercise any rights which
it may acquire by way of subrogation or any  indemnity,  reimbursement  or other
agreement,  in all cases as a result of payment  under this  Exchange  Guarantee
Agreement, at the time of any such payment, any amounts are due and unpaid under
this Exchange Guarantee  Agreement.  If any amount shall be paid to the Exchange
Guarantor in violation of the preceding sentence,  the Exchange Guarantor agrees
to hold such  amount in trust for the Holders and to pay over such amount to the
Holders.

         SECTION 5.7.  Independent Obligations.

         The Exchange Guarantor  acknowledges that its obligations hereunder are
independent  of the  obligations  of the Issuer  with  respect  to the  Exchange
Preferred  Securities  and that  the  Exchange  Guarantor  shall  be  liable  as
principal and as debtor  hereunder to make  Guarantee  Payments  pursuant to the
terms of this Exchange Guarantee Agreement notwithstanding the occurrence of any
event  referred to in  subsection  (a) through  (g),  inclusive,  of Section 5.3
hereof.

                            ARTICLE VI. SUBORDINATION

         SECTION 6.1.  Subordination.

         (a) This  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  will  constitute an unsecured
obligation  of the Exchange  Guarantor and will rank  subordinate  and junior in
right of payment to all Senior Indebtedness of the Exchange Guarantor.

         (b) The  Exchange  Guarantor  may not make a  Guarantee  Payment to the
Holders if (i) any  Senior  Indebtedness  of the  Exchange  Guarantor  having an
outstanding  principal  amount  at  the  time  of  determination  in  excess  of
$10,000,000  (the  "Specified  Indebtedness")  is not paid  when due or (ii) any
other default on Specified Senior  Indebtedness of the Exchange Guarantor occurs
and the  maturity  of such  Specified  Senior  Indebtedness  is  accelerated  in
accordance with its terms, unless, in either case, the default has been cured or
waived and any such  acceleration  has been rescinded or such  Specified  Senior
Indebtedness has been paid in full.  However,  the Exchange Guarantor may make a
Guarantee Payment without regard to the foregoing if the Exchange  Guarantor and
the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee receive  written notice  approving such payment
from a representative of the Specified Senior Indebtedness with respect to which
either  of the  events  set  forth  in  clause  (i) or (ii)  of the  immediately
preceding sentence has occurred and is continuing. During the continuance of any
default (other than a default described in clause (i) or (ii) of the second pre-
ceding  sentence) with respect to any Specified Senior  Indebtedness of the 
Exchange Guarantor pursuant to which the maturity  thereof may be accelerated  
immediately  without  further notice  

                                       13





(except such notice as may be required to effect such  acceleration)  or
the  expiration of any applicable  grace  periods,  the guarantor may not make a
Guarantee Payment to the holders of Exchange  Preferred  Securities for a period
(a  "Payment  Blockage  Period")  commencing  upon the  receipt by the  Exchange
Guarantee  Trustee (with a copy to the Exchange  Guarantor) of written notice (a
"Blockage  Notice") of such  default from the  representative  of the holders of
such Specified  Senior  Indebtedness  specifying an election to effect a Payment
Blockage  Period and  ending 179 days  thereafter  (or  earlier if such  Payment
Blockage  Period is terminated (i) by written  notice to the Exchange  Guarantee
Trustee and the Exchange  Guarantor  from the  representative  of the holders of
such Specified Senior Indebtedness, (ii) because the default giving rise to such
Blockage Notice is no longer  continuing or (iii) because such Specified  Senior
Indebtedness has been repaid in full).  Notwithstanding the provisions described
in the  immediately  preceding  sentence,  unless the holders of such  Specified
Senior  Indebtedness or the  representative of such holders have accelerated the
maturity of such  Specified  Senior  Indebtedness,  the Exchange  Guarantor  may
resume Guarantee  Payments after the end of such Payment  Blockage  Period.  The
Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  shall not be  subject  to more than one  Payment
Blockage Period in any consecutive 360-day period, irrespective of the number of
defaults with respect to Specified Senior Indebtedness during such period.

         (c) Upon any  payment or  distribution  of the  assets of the  Exchange
Guarantor upon a total or partial  liquidation or dissolution or  reorganization
of or similar proceeding relating to the Exchange Guarantor or its property, the
holders of Senior  Indebtedness  of the Exchange  Guarantor  will be entitled to
receive  payment in full,  and until the  Senior  Indebtedness  of the  Exchange
Guarantor  is paid in full,  any  payment or  distribution  to which the Holders
would be  entitled  but for this  Section  6.1 will be made to  holders  of such
Senior  Indebtedness as their interests may appear. If a Distribution is made to
the Holders,  that, due to this Section 6.1,  should not have been made to them,
such  Holders  are  required  to hold it in  trust  for the  holders  of  Senior
Indebtedness  of the  Exchange  Guarantor  and pay it  over  to  them  as  their
interests may appear.

         (d) If a Guarantee  Payment is to be made by the Exchange  Guarantor to
the Holders,  the Exchange  Guarantor or the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee  shall
promptly notify the holders of Senior  Indebtedness of the Exchange Guarantor or
the  representative  of such holders of such  Guarantee  Payment.  If any Senior
Indebtedness of the Exchange  Guarantor is outstanding,  the Exchange  Guarantor
may  not  pay  such  Guarantee  Payment  until  five  Business  Days  after  the
representative  of all  the  issues  of  Senior  Indebtedness  of  the  Exchange
Guarantor  receives notice of such Guarantee  Payment and,  thereafter,  may pay
such  Guarantee  Payment  only if the  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  otherwise
permits payment at that time.

                            ARTICLE VII. TERMINATION

         SECTION 7.1.  Termination.

                                       14






         This Exchange Guarantee  Agreement shall terminate and be of no further
force and effect upon (i) full payment of the  Redemption  Price of the Exchange
Preferred Securities,  (ii) the distribution of Exchange Notes to the Holders in
exchange for all of the Exchange  Preferred  Securities or (iii) full payment of
the amounts payable in accordance with the Declaration  upon  liquidation of the
Issuer.  Notwithstanding  the foregoing,  this Exchange Guarantee Agreement will
continue to be  effective or will be  reinstated,  as the case may be, if at any
time any Holder must  restore  payment of any sums paid with respect to Exchange
Preferred Securities or this Exchange Guarantee Agreement.

                           ARTICLE VIII. MISCELLANEOUS

         SECTION 8.1.  Successors and Assigns.

         All  guarantees  and  agreements in this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement
shall bind the successors,  assigns, receivers,  trustees and representatives of
the  Exchange  Guarantor  and shall  inure to the  benefit of the Holders of the
Exchange  Preferred  Securities  then  outstanding.  Except in connection with a
consolidation, merger or sale involving the Exchange Guarantor that is permitted
under Article  Eight of the Indenture and pursuant to which the assignee  agrees
in  writing to perform  the  Exchange  Guarantor's  obligations  hereunder,  the
Exchange Guarantor shall not assign its obligations hereunder.

         SECTION 8.2.  Amendments.

         Except with  respect to any changes  that do not  adversely  affect the
rights of the Holders in any  material  respect (in which case no consent of the
Holders will be required), this Exchange Guarantee Agreement may only be amended
with  the  prior  approval  of the  Holders  of not  less  than  a  Majority  in
liquidation  amount  of  all  outstanding  Exchange  Preferred  Securities.  The
provisions of Article VI of the Declaration  concerning  meetings of the Holders
shall apply to the giving of such approval.  This Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement
shall not be amended  without the prior receipt by the Exchange  Guarantor of an
opinion of  independent  tax counsel to the effect that such  amendment  of this
Exchange Guarantee  Agreement will not result in the recognition of income, gain
or loss by the Holders.

         SECTION 8.3.  Notices.

         Any notice,  request or other communication required or permitted to be
given  hereunder  shall be in  writing,  duly  signed by the party  giving  such
notice, and delivered, telecopied or mailed by first class mail as follows:

         (a) if given to the Exchange Guarantor,  to the address set forth below
or such other address, facsimile number or to the attention of such other Person
as the Exchange Guarantor may give notice to the Holders:

                  Symons International Group, Inc.


                                       15



                  4720 Kingsway Drive
                  Indianapolis, IN 46205

                  Facsimile No.:  (317) 259-6395
                  Attention:  David L. Bates

         (b) If given to the Issuer, in care of the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee,
at the Issuer's (and the Exchange  Guarantee  Trustee's) address set forth below
or such other address as the Exchange  Guarantee Trustee on behalf of the Issuer
may given notice to the Holders:

                  SIG Capital Trust I

                  c/o Wilmington Trust Company
                  1100 North Market Street
                  Rodney Square North
                  Wilmington, Delaware 19890

                  Facsimile No.:
                  Attention:  Corporate Trust Administration

         (c) if given to any  Holder,  at the address set forth on the books and
records of the Trust.

         All notices  hereunder shall be deemed to have been given when received
in person,  telecopied  with receipt  confirmed,  or mailed by first class mail,
postage  prepaid,  except that if a notice or other document is refused delivery
or cannot be  delivered  because  of a changed  address  of which no notice  was
given,  such notice or other  document shall be deemed to have been delivered on
the date of such refusal or inability to deliver.

         SECTION 8.4.  Benefit.

         This  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  is solely for the  benefit of the
Holders  and  is  not  separately   transferable  from  the  Exchange  Preferred
Securities.

         SECTION 8.5.  Interpretation.

         In this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement,  unless the context  otherwise
requires:

         (a) capitalized terms used in this Exchange Guarantee Agreement but not
defined in the preamble hereto have the respective  meanings assigned to them in
Section 1.1;

         (b) a term defined  anywhere in this Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement has
the same meaning throughout;

                                       16





         (c) all  references  to "the  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement"  or "this
Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement"  are to this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  as
modified, supplemented or amended from time to time;

         (d) all references to this Exchange Guarantee Agreement to Articles and
Sections  are to Articles  and  Sections of this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement
unless  otherwise  defined in this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement or unless the
context otherwise requires;

         (e) a term defined in the Trust Indenture Act has the same meaning when
used in this  Exchange  Guarantee  Agreement  unless  otherwise  defined in this
Exchange Guarantee Agreement or unless the context otherwise requires;

         (f) a reference to the singular includes the plural and vice versa; and

         (g) the masculine, feminine or neuter genders used herein shall include
the masculine, feminine and neuter genders.

         SECTION 8.6.  Governing Law.

     THIS EXCHANGE  GUARANTEE  AGREEMENT  SHALL BE GOVERNED BY AND CONSTRUED AND
INTERPRETED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK.

         This instrument may be executed in any number of counterparts,  each of
which so executed shall be deemed to be an original,  but all such  counterparts
shall together constitute but one and the same instruments.



                                       17




         THIS  EXCHANGE  GUARANTEE  AGREEMENT is executed as of the day and year
first above written.

                                   Symons International Group, Inc.


                                   By:_______________________________________
                                   Name:  Alan G. Symons
                                   Title:  Chief Executive Officer



                                   By:_______________________________________
                                   Name:  Gary P. Hutchcraft
                                   Title:  Vice President


                                   Wilmington Trust Company,
                                   as Exchange Guarantee Trustee


                                   By:_______________________________________
                                   Name:____________________________________
                                   Title:_____________________________________


                                       18