MALIZIA SPIDI & FISCH, PC
                                ATTORNEYS AT LAW

1100 NEW YORK AVENUE, N.W.                            1900 SOUTH ATHERTON STREET
SUITE 340 WEST                                                         SUITE 101
WASHINGTON, D.C.  20005                                 STATE COLLEGE, PA  16801
(202) 434-4660                                                    (814) 272-3502
FACSIMILE: (202) 434-4661                             FACSIMILE:  (814) 272-3514

TIFFANY A. HASSELMAN                                 WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL NUMBER
HASSELMAN@MALIZIALAW.COM                                          (202) 434-8389



VIA EDGAR AND HAND DELIVERY
- ---------------------------

July 22, 2005

Mr. Todd K. Schiffman
Assistant Director
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C.  20002

         Re:      American Bancorp of New Jersey, Inc.
                  Form S-1 and the related Preliminary Proxy Statement
                  File No. 333-125957

Dear Mr. Schiffman:

         Transmitted with this letter for filing, on behalf of American Bancorp
of New Jersey, Inc., (the "Company") is pre-effective Amendment No. 1 to the
Registration Statement on Form S-1. This filing is marked to show changes made
since the original filing of the Form S-1. Page numbers refer to the pages in
the revised prospectus filed herewith.

Form S-1
- --------
Prospectus Cover Page
- ---------------------

          1.   Revise the "(w)e are offering...." paragraph on the cover page to
               state that subscribers will be either resolicited if the offering
               is  extended  beyond the 2005 date or the monies will be promptly
               refunded.

         We have made the change as requested.



MALIZIA SPIDI & FISCH, PC

Mr. Todd K. Schiffman
July 22, 2005
Page 2

Prospectus Summary
- ------------------
Tax Effects of Conversion - page 5
- ----------------------------------

          2.   Revise the first  sentence to start with,  "We have  received tax
               opinions that indicate (as a general matter....)".

         We have made the change as requested.

How to Purchase Stock in the Offering - page 8
- ----------------------------------------------

          3.   Revise  the first  paragraph  to  briefly  discuss  what is being
               certified.

         We have made the change as requested.

Our Use of the Proceeds Raised from the Sale of Stock - page 9
- --------------------------------------------------------------

          4.   Revise the first  paragraph to add a range of dollar  amounts for
               the ESOP purchases.

         We have made the change as requested.

Risk Factors - page 14
- ----------------------

          5.   Revise the second  risk on page 14 to  indicate  the  anticipated
               costs  to open a de novo  branch  and any  anticipated  costs  to
               establish the new operations center. State approximately how many
               branches you expect to open and any tentative  schedule.  Include
               similar disclosure in the use of proceeds section.

         We have made the change as requested.

          6.   Revise  the first risk on page 16 to  indicate  that based on the
               $10  offering  price and assuming  all stock  issuable  under the
               plans are issued,  the  approximate  value of the stock under the
               Plans approximates $18 million dollars.

         We have made the change as requested.

          7.   Revise to add a risk  factor for changes in  shareholder  rights,
               such as, our new organizational  structure will result in changes
               in shareholder  rights for existing  holders and briefly describe
               therein the material changes in those rights.

         We have made the change as requested. Please see the newly added risk
factor on page 16.



MALIZIA SPIDI & FISCH, PC

Mr. Todd K. Schiffman
July 22, 2005
Page 3

          8.   Include  a  risk  factor  which  discusses   increased   expenses
               resulting  from the expansion of the branch network and increased
               loan production.

         We have made the change as requested. Please see the newly added risk
factor on page 17.

Use of Proceeds - page 18
- -------------------------

          9.   Revise the paragraph on page 19 (immediately  below the table) to
               briefly  discuss the current and  anticipated  operations  of the
               holding company and the dollar amount  available for dividends as
               of the most recent practicable date.

         We have made the change as requested.

         We believe, however, that it is more appropriate to explain the
regulatory restrictions on dividends from the new holding company than to give a
specific dollar amount, given that the full amount of the proceeds retained at
the holding company are theoretically available for payment as dividends but
obviously the full amount would not in reality be paid out as dividends.

The Conversion
- --------------

          10.  Revise to add a subsection titled,  "Pricing  Characteristics and
               After-Market  Trends" and include therein  information similar to
               pages 4.15 and 4.16 of the RP appraisal  for at least the periods
               being reported upon by the financial  statements  included in the
               filing.

         We have made the change as requested. We have included this new
subsection under the section titled "The Offering" rather than including it
under "The Conversion." Please see the new disclosure included at page 132.

Effect of the Conversion on Minority Stockholders
- -------------------------------------------------

          11.  Revise to add a subsection on, "Effect on Stockholder Rights" and
               summarize  therein the changes in stockholders  rights  resulting
               from the Exchange of Shares and the Conversion.

         We have made the change as requested. Please see the new subsection
titled "Comparison of Stockholders' Rights of ASB Holding Company and American
Bancorp of New Jersey, Inc." at page 112.



MALIZIA SPIDI & FISCH, PC

Mr. Todd K. Schiffman
July 22, 2005
Page 4

Dissenters' and Appraisal Rights - page 111
- -------------------------------------------

          12.  Revise to add a  cross-reference  to a "to be included"  Appendix
               that  contains  the law  governing  these  rights  to  revise  to
               summarize the rights herein. Also include the specific steps that
               must be taken  and/or  avoided  by those  holders  who may assert
               these rights.

         We have made the change as requested and have also included an
appendix. Please see the new disclosure included at page 110.

General
- -------

          13.  To the extent the effectiveness of the registration  statement is
               delayed,  please revise to include updated financial  information
               under Rule 3-12 of Regulation S-X.

         We are aware of this requirement.

          14.  Please   ensure  you  include  an  updated   consent   from  your
               independent accountant in the pre-effective amendment.

         An updated consent is included with this amendment.

MD&A
- ----
General
- -------

          15.  Please  revise  management's  discussion  and analysis to include
               discussion  for the  comparison of the operating  results for the
               years  ended  September  30, 2003 and 2002.  Please  refer to the
               requirements of Regulation S-K, Item 303.

         We have made the change as requested.

Recently Regulatory and Accounting Developments - page 55
- ---------------------------------------------------------

          16.  In your description of recently issued accounting pronouncements,
               please revise this  discussion to address the impact of the newly
               issued accounting pronouncements. Please refer to the guidance in
               SAB Topic 11: M, which states the requirements regarding recently
               issued accounting pronouncements.

         We have made the change as requested.




MALIZIA SPIDI & FISCH, PC

Mr. Todd K. Schiffman
July 22, 2005
Page 5

Financial Statements
- --------------------

Note 1:Summary of Significant Accounting Policies-Earnings per Share - page F-14
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

          17.  Please  revise to clarify why you have not  included  outstanding
               stock  options in  determining  diluted EPS for the period  ended
               March 30, 2005.  Consider the need to provide a reconciliation of
               the calculation of EPS under SFAS 128.

         We have added language regarding anti-dilutiveness for the six months
ended March 31, 2005. A reconciliation under SFAS 128 has not been added since
there is no dilutive effect for the options for the period reported.

Note 6: Premises and Equipment - page F-23
- ------------------------------------------

          18.  Please  revise to  disclose  the  scheduled  closing  date of the
               acquisition of the branch site in Essex County,  and the terms of
               the  agreement  (i.e.   balance  to  be  paid  in  cash,   etc.).
               Additionally,  disclose  why the  balance  due at  closing is not
               included  in  the  schedule  of  contractual  obligations  in the
               Management's Discussion and Analysis section. Disclose where this
               commitment has been accrued on the balance sheet.

         We  have  added  disclosure  to  Note  6  regarding  the  terms  of the
agreement. We have included in the commitments discussion in the MD&A at page 53
disclosure regarding the balance due at closing. There is currently no scheduled
closing date,  and  management  is unable to speculate as to a possible  closing
date as there are unresolved title and environmental issues. Because this is not
an unconditional commitment,  the balance due at closing has not been accrued or
recorded in the financial statements at this time.

Note 12: Stock-Based Compensation - page F-30
- ---------------------------------------------

          19.  Please   revise  your   disclosure   to  include  the   following
               information,  by reference to  paragraphs  46 and 47 of SFAS 123,
               regarding  the stock  option plan for the period  ended March 30,
               2005.

               o    Description  of the plan  including the general terms of the
                    awards, such as vesting requirements.
               o    The number of  weighted-average  exercise  prices of options
                    for  each  of  the   following   group  of  options:   those
                    outstanding at the beginning of the year, those  exercisable
                    at the  end of  the  year,  and  those  granted,  exercised,
                    forfeited and expired.
               o    The weighted average contractual life of the options.

         We have made the change as requested.



MALIZIA SPIDI & FISCH, PC

Mr. Todd K. Schiffman
July 22, 2005
Page 6

Preliminary Proxy Comments
- --------------------------
Q & A
- -----

               20.  Revise to  include  information  regarding  dissenters'  and
                    appraisal  rights.  In this  regard,  refer  readers  to the
                    Appendix  and also  include the  specific  steps to be taken
                    and/or avoided to perfect these rights.

                  We have made the change as requested.

                                      * * *

         We hope that the foregoing is responsive  to the staff's  comments.  We
request that the staff advise us as soon as possible of any additional comments.

                                                Sincerely,


                                                /s/Tiffany A. Hasselman
                                                --------------------------------
                                                Tiffany A. Hasselman


Enclosure

cc:      Michael R. Clampitt, Esq., U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
         Mr. Fred G. Kowal, President and Chief Operating Officer
         Mr. Eric B. Heyer, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
         Ms. Wendy L. Campbell, Crowe Chizek and Company LLC
         Samuel J. Malizia, Esq.
         Richard Fisch, Esq.