EXHIBIT 4.19.4

                    THIRD AMENDMENT TO SHAREHOLDER AGREEMENT

         This THIRD AMENDMENT TO SHAREHOLDER  AGREEMENT (this  "Amendment") made
as of  September  14,  2000,  by and among  VALUESTAR  CORPORATION,  a  Colorado
corporation (the "Company"),  SEACOAST CAPITAL PARTNERS LIMITED  PARTNERSHIP,  a
Delaware  Limited  Partnership  ("Seacoast"),  PACIFIC  MEZZANINE  FUND,  L.P. a
California  limited  partnership  ("Pacific")  and TANGENT GROWTH FUND,  L.P., a
California  limited  partnership  ("Tangent")  (individually  and  collectively,
"Purchaser"),  and Jim Stein ("Stein"), James A. Barnes ("Barnes"), and Jerry E.
Polis ("Polis") (individually and collectively, the "Shareholder").

         WHEREAS, the Company,  Purchaser and Shareholder have entered into that
certain  Shareholder  Agreement,  dated as of March 31, 1999, as amended on July
22, 1999 and December 8, 1999 (collectively, the "Shareholder Agreement" and, as
further amended hereby, the "Agreement")

         WHEREAS,  in  connection  with a Series C Convertible  Preferred  Stock
financing  of  the  Company,   Shareholder  has  requested  that  Purchaser  and
Shareholder make certain amendments to the Shareholder Agreement,  and Purchaser
and  Shareholder  are willing to do so upon the terms and  conditions  set forth
herein.

         NOW,  THEREFORE,  in consideration of the premises herein contained and
other good and valuable consideration,  the receipt and sufficiency of which are
hereby acknowledged, the parties hereto, intending to be legally bound, agree as
follows:

         1. DEFINITIONS. All capitalized terms used but not otherwise defined in
this Amendment shall have the meanings ascribed to them in the Agreement. Unless
otherwise  specified,  all section  references  herein  refer to sections of the
Shareholder.

         2. AMENDMENT TO ARTICLE VI - First Refusal; and Co-Sale Rights. Each of
Seacoast,  Pacific and Tangent  hereby agree that solely for purposes of Article
VI of the  Shareholder  Agreement,  Shareholder  shall only mean Stein.  Neither
Barnes nor Polis nor any Capital Stock now owned or later  acquired by either of
them or otherwise held by Barnes or Polis or their  affiliates  shall be subject
to any of the provisions set forth in Article VI of the Shareholder Agreement.

         3.  AMENDMENT  TO ARTICLE  VII  -Voting  Agreement.  Each of  Seacoast,
Pacific and Tangent  hereby  agree that  Barnes' and Polis'  voting  obligations
under  Article VIII of the  Shareholders  Agreement  with respect to any Capital
Stock now owned or later  acquired by either of them or their  affiliates  shall
expire at such time that Barnes or Polis,  as the case may be, are no longer the
beneficial  owners with respect to such shares of Capital Stock,  whether or not
they continue to own other shares of Capital Stock.

                                      -1-



         4. MISCELLANEOUS.

         4.1 Survival of Representations and Warranties. All representations and
warranties made in the Shareholder,  including, without limitation, any document
furnished in  connection  with this  Amendment,  shall survive the execution and
delivery of this Amendment and the Other  Agreements,  and no  investigation  by
Purchaser or any closing shall affect the  representations and warranties or the
right of Purchaser to rely upon them.

         4.2 Reference to Shareholder  Agreement.  The Shareholder Agreement and
any and all other agreements, documents or instruments now or hereafter executed
and  delivered  pursuant  to the terms  hereof or  pursuant  to the terms of the
Shareholder  Agreement,  as  amended  hereby,  are  hereby  amended  so that any
reference  in  the  Shareholder  Agreement  and  such  other  Agreements  to the
Shareholder  Agreement  shall mean a reference to the  Shareholder  Agreement as
amended hereby.

         4.3 Expenses of Purchaser.  As provided in the  Shareholder  Agreement,
the Company agrees to pay on demand all costs and expenses incurred by Purchaser
in connection with the preparation,  negotiation and execution of this Amendment
and  any  other  agreements   executed  pursuant  hereto,   including,   without
limitation, the reasonable costs and fees of Purchaser's legal counsel.

         4.4  Severability.  Any provision of this  Amendment held by a court of
competent  jurisdiction  to be  invalid  or  unenforceable  shall not  impair or
invalidate  the  remainder of this  Amendment  and the effect  thereof  shall be
confined to the provision so held to be invalid or unenforceable.

         4.5 Successors and Assigns. This Amendment will inure to the benefit of
and be binding  upon the  parties  hereto and their  respective  successors  and
permitted assigns.

         4.6  Headings.  The headings of the sections  and  subsections  of this
Amendment are inserted for convenience only and do not constitute a part of this
Amendment.

         4.7  Counterparts.  This  Amendment  may be  executed  in any number of
counterparts, which shall collectively constitute one agreement.

         4.8 Law  Governing.  THIS  AMENDMENT  SHALL  BE  DEEMED  TO  HAVE  BEEN
SUBSTANTIALLY  NEGOTIATED  AND MADE IN THE  STATE  OF  CALIFORNIA  AND  SHALL BE
INTERPRETED AND THE RIGHTS OF THE PARTIES DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE LAWS
OF THE UNITED  STATES  APPLICABLE  THERETO AND THE INTERNAL LAWS OF THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA APPLICABLE TO AN AGREEMENT EXECUTED, DELIVERED AND PERFORMED THEREIN,
WITHOUT GIVING EFFECT TO THE CHOICE-OF-LAW  RULES THEREOF OR ANY OTHER PRINCIPLE
THAT  COULD  REQUIRE  THE  APPLICATION  OF THE  SUBSTANTIVE  LAW  OF  ANY  OTHER
JURISDICTION.

         4.9 Waiver; Modification. NO PROVISION OF THIS AMENDMENT MAY BE

                                      -2-




WAIVED, CHANGED OR MODIFIED, OR THE DISCHARGE THEREOF ACKNOWLEDGED,  ORALLY, BUT
ONLY BY AN AGREEMENT IN WRITING SIGNED BY THE PARTY AGAINST WHOM THE ENFORCEMENT
OF ANY WAIVER, CHANGE, MODIFICATION OR DISCHARGE IS SOUGHT.

         4.10 Final  Agreement.  THE SHAREHOLDER  AGREEMENT,  AS AMENDED HEREBY,
REPRESENTS  THE ENTIRE  EXPRESSION  OF THE PARTIES  WITH  RESPECT TO THE SUBJECT
MATTER  HEREOF  AND  THEREOF  ON  THE  DATE  THIS  AMENDMENT  IS  EXECUTED.  THE
SHAREHOLDER AGREEMENT, AS AMENDED HEREBY, MAY NOT BE CONTRADICTED BY EVIDENCE OF
PRIOR,  CONTEMPORANEOUS OR SUBSEQUENT ORAL AGREEMENTS OF THE PARTIES.  THERE ARE
NO UNWRITTEN ORAL AGREEMENTS BETWEEN THE PARTIES.




               [THE REMAINDER OF THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY BLANK]

                                      -3-





         IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Company,  Purchaser and Shareholder have caused
this Amendment to be executed and delivered as of the date first written,  which
execution may be done in counterparts.


                  COMPANY:

                                   VALUESTAR CORPORATION


                                   By: /s/ James Stein
                                       ---------------
                                   Name:   James Stein
                                   Its:    Chief Executive Officer


                  SHAREHOLDER:


                                   /s/ James Stein
                                   ---------------
                                   James Stein


                                   /s/ James A. Barnes
                                   -------------------
                                   James A. Barnes,  individually,  as President
                                   of Sunrise Capital,  Inc. and General Partner
                                   of  Tiffany   Investments,   and  as  General
                                   Partner   of  Tiffany   Investments   Limited
                                   Partnership


                                   /s/ Jerry E. Polis
                                   ------------------
                                   Jerry E. Polis, individually, as President of
                                   Davric  Corporation  and Trustee of the Jerry
                                   E. Polis Family Trust

                                      -4-





                  PURCHASER:

                  SEACOAST CAPITAL PARTNERS LIMITED
                  PARTNERSHIP
                           By:      Seacoast I Advisors, LLC,
                                    its general partner

                           By:      /s/ Jeffrey J. Holland
                                    ----------------------
                           Name:    Jeffrey J. Holland
                           Its:     Vice President


                  PACIFIC MEZZANINE FUND, L.P.
                           By:      Pacific Private Capital
                                    its general partner

                           By:      /s/ Nathan W. Bell
                                    ------------------
                           Name:    Nathan W. Bell
                           Its:     General Partner

                  TANGENT GROWTH FUND, L.P.
                           By:      Tangent Fund Management, LLC
                                    its general partner

                           By:      /s/ Mark P. Gilles
                                    ------------------
                           Name:    Mark P. Gilles
                           Its:     Vice President

                                      -5-