EXHIBIT 5.9
[FREEHILLS LETTERHEAD]
March 5, 2004 Our ref Patrick Lowden:36G
Doc no Sydney\004579122
Burns, Philp & Company Limited
Burns Philp Capital Pty Limited
Each Subsidiary Guarantor listed in Schedule 1
Level 23
56 Pitt Street
SYDNEY NSW 2000
Dear Sirs
BURNS PHILP CAPITAL PTY LIMITED - ISSUE OF US$100 MILLION SENIOR SECURITIES DUE
2010
We have acted as Australian legal advisors to Burns, Philp & Company Limited
(ACN 000 000 359) (PARENT) in connection with an offer to exchange (EXCHANGE
OFFER) by Burns Philp Capital Pty Limited (ACN 100 768 803) (ISSUER) and the
Co-issuer of US$100 million Senior Notes due 2010 (EXCHANGE NOTES) which are
being registered under the Securities Act of 1933 of the United States of
America (SECURITIES ACT) for its existing Senior Notes due 2010 (OLD NOTES), as
described in the Registration Statement on Form F-4 relating to the Exchange
Offer (REGISTRATION STATEMENT) initially filed with the United States Securities
and Exchange Commission (COMMISSION) on 30 July 2003. The Old Notes were issued
and the Exchange Notes are proposed to be issued under an Indenture dated 16
June 2003 between the Issuer, the Co-issuer, the Parent, certain "Subsidiary
Guarantors" as defined therein and Wells Fargo Bank, National Association
(INDENTURE). We note that our role in connection with the Exchange Offer has
been limited to the rendering of this opinion (together with two other opinions
dated on or about the same date as this opinion to be filed with the
Registration Statement) and that we have not been involved in the preparation of
the Registration Statement and make no comment on it.
1 DOCUMENTS
We have searched the records referred to in paragraph 1(g) and examined
originals, or copies certified or otherwise identified to our satisfaction, of
such documents, corporate records and other instruments as we have deemed
necessary or appropriate for purposes of this opinion, including:
(a) a copy of the Indenture;
(b) a copy of a supplemental indenture dated 8 August 2003 between the
Issuer, the Co-issuer, the Parent, certain "Subsidiary Guarantors" as
defined therein and certain "Additional Subsidiary Guarantors" as
defined therein (SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE);
(c) a copy of:
(1) minutes of meeting or written resolutions of the board of
directors of each Original Relevant Party held or adopted (as
the case may be) on:
(a) in the case of the Parent, 21 May 2003 and 23 May
2003;
(b) in the case of BPC1 Pty Limited, 20 May 2003 and 23
May 2003; and
(c) in the case of each other Original Relevant Party,
14 May 2003 and 27 May 2003;
(2) minutes of meeting of a committee of the board of directors of
the Parent dated 2 June 2003 and 16 June 2003;
(3) a circular resolution of the board of directors of Goodman
Fielder adopted on 19 June 2003;
(4) extracts of minutes of meetings of the board of directors of
each GF Relevant Party other than Goodman Fielder held on 19
June 2003;
(5) an extract from a circular resolution of the board of
directors of Goodman Fielder, and extracts of minutes of
meeting of the board of directors of each GF Relevant Party
other than Goodman Fielder, held or adoptedas the case may be)
on 5 August 2003;
(6) records of resolutions of all the members of Goodman Fielder
passed on 19 September 2003 and of each other GF Relevant
Party passed on 13 October 2003;
(7) a circular resolution of the board of directors of Goodman
Fielder adopted on 19 September 2003, and minutes of meetings
of the board of directors of each GF Relevant Party other than
Goodman Fielder held on 13 October 2003;
(8) a Ratification Deed:
(a) dated 22 September 2003 and executed by Goodman
Fielder; and
(b) dated 16 October 2003 and executed by each GF
Relevant Party other than Goodman Fielder;
(d) original certificates signed by an officer of each Relevant Party
dated 5 March 2004 and the attachments referred to in them;
(e) a copy of the power of attorney of each Relevant Party dated 27 May
2003 (in the case of the Original Relevant Parties) or 23 June 2003 (in
the case of the GF Relevant Parties);
(f) a certified copy of:
(1) the constitution of Goodman Fielder as at 19 June 2003; and
(2) the current constitution of each Relevant Party;
(g) documents arising from on-line searches of records at the ASIC made on
4 March 2004 and 5 March 2004 in relation to each Relevant Party; and
(h) a certified extract from the register of members of each Relevant
Party.
2 DEFINITIONS
In this Opinion expressions defined in this Opinion have the meanings given and:
(a) ASIC means the Australian Securities and Investments Commission;
(b) AUSTRALIA means the Commonwealth of Australia;
PAGE 2
(c) CO-ISSUER means Burns Philp Capital (U.S.) Inc.;
(d) CONSTITUTIONS means the documents referred to in paragraph 1(f)(2);
(e) COMPANY EXTRACT means the documents referred to in paragraph 1(g);
(f) CORPORATIONS ACT means the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth);
(g) DOCUMENT means a document referred to in paragraphs 1(a) to (b)
inclusive and:
(1) in respect of each Original Relevant Party, means the
Indenture; and
(2) in respect of each GF Relevant Party, means the Supplemental
Indenture;
(h) GF RELEVANT PARTY means each of the Subsidiary Guarantors listed in
schedule 2;
(i) ORIGINAL RELEVANT PARTY means:
(1) the Issuer;
(2) the Parent;
(3) each of the Subsidiary Guarantors listed in schedule 1;
(j) POWER OF ATTORNEY means a power of attorney referred to in paragraph
1(e);
(k) RELEVANT JURISDICTION means, as the context requires, the State of New
South Wales and Australia;
(l) RELEVANT LAWS means the laws of the Relevant Jurisdictions;
(m) RELEVANT PARTY means each of the Original Relevant Parties and each of
the GF Relevant Parties;
(n) RESOLUTION means a resolution of the board of directors, a committee of
the board of directors or the members of a Relevant Party referred to
in the documents referred to in paragraph 1(c);
(o) SECURITY has the meaning given in the Indenture;
(p) SUBSIDIARY GUARANTORS means each of the Guarantors listed in schedule 1
or 2.
3 OPINION
Based on the documents referred to in paragraph 1 and subject to the assumptions
and qualifications set out in this Opinion, we are of the opinion that:
(a) each Relevant Party is registered and validly existing under the laws
of the Relevant Jurisdictions;
(b) each Relevant Party has the corporate power to enter into and perform
its obligations under its Document;
(c) each Relevant Party has taken all necessary corporate action to
authorise or ratify the execution of, and the performance of its
obligations under, its Document;
PAGE 3
(d) each Relevant Party has validly executed, or ratified its execution of,
its Document; and
(e) the execution or ratification by a Relevant Party of, and the
performance by the Relevant Party of its obligations under, its
Document does not and will not result in a breach or violation by the
Relevant Party of any of the terms or provisions of the constitution of
the Relevant Party.
4 ASSUMPTIONS
In this Opinion we have assumed the following matters, and we have not made any
independent investigation of, or enquiries in respect of, those matters:
(a) in relation to the Document and each other document examined by us:
(1) all signatories, seals, dates, duty stamps and markings are
authentic;
(2) if a copy or a specimen, it conforms in all respects to the
original;
(3) it is accurate, complete and up-to-date;
(4) it has been duly authorised, executed and delivered by all
parties to it under, and its execution, delivery and
performance by all parties to it complies with, all applicable
laws (other than, in respect of a Relevant Party and its
Document, the Relevant Laws);
(b) as of the date of the searches referred to in paragraph 1(g), all
information required by law to be notified to the ASIC in relation to
the Relevant Parties (whether or not any period for notification had
expired) had been so notified, the records of the ASIC were in relation
to the Relevant Parties accurate, complete and up-to-date and those
records were correctly recorded in the Company Extracts;
(c) the Securities will not be offered, issued or sold in a manner contrary
to the selling restrictions relating to Australia set forth on page
(ii) of the prospectus included in the Registration Statement;
(d) in relation to the execution, delivery and performance by each Relevant
Party of its Document, including each Resolution, the directors,
secretaries and agents of the Relevant Party properly performed their
duties to the Relevant Party;
(e) each Relevant Party and each other party to a Document is solvent at
the time of, and after giving effect to, the entry into of each
Document to which it is a party; and
(f) the correctness of each statement, determination or resolution set out
in:
(1) the certificates referred to in paragraph 1(d);
(2) the documents referred to in paragraph 1(c).
5 QUALIFICATIONS
This Opinion is subject to the following qualifications:
(a) this Opinion relates only to the laws of the Relevant Jurisdictions in
force at the time of giving this Opinion. We neither express nor imply
any opinion as to, and have not made any investigation of, the laws of
any
PAGE 4
other jurisdiction. We are under, and assume, no obligation to inform
any person of, or of the effect of, any future changes to those or any
other laws;
(b) we express no opinion as to the enforceability of any Document;
(c) in rendering this Opinion we have construed the Documents and made the
statements set out in this Opinion as lawyers admitted to practice in
the State of New South Wales without reference to the meaning or effect
they may have in any other jurisdiction or anything other than their
plain words.
This Opinion is strictly limited to the matters stated in it and does not apply
by implication to other matters.
This Opinion is only given:
(a) in respect of and is limited to the Relevant Laws as applied by the
courts of the Relevant Jurisdictions which are in force at 9.00 am
Sydney time on the date of this letter;
(b) on the basis that it will be governed by and construed in accordance
with the laws of the Relevant Jurisdictions.
We hereby consent to the filing of this opinion as an exhibit to the
Registration Statement and to being named in the prospectus included therein as
having provided this opinion. In giving such consent, we do not thereby admit
that we come within the category of persons whose consent is required under
Section 7 of the Securities Act or the rules and regulations of the Commission
thereunder.
Yours faithfully
FREEHILLS
/s/ Freehills
Patrick Lowden
Partner
PAGE 5
SCHEDULE 1
SUBSIDIARY GUARANTOR REGISTRATION NUMBER
BPC1 Pty Limited 101 665 918
Burns Philp Australia Pty Ltd 101 664 082
Burns Philp Camellia Pty Limited 003 925 040
Burns Philp Food Holdings Pty Limited 000 003 010
Burns Philp Food Overseas Holdings Limited 000 010 711
Burns Philp Food Overseas Investments Pty Limited 101 664 840
Burns Philp Food Properties Pty Limited 008 443 856
Burns Philp Food Services Pty Limited 003 994 250
Burns Philp Middle East Pty Limited 077 288 021
Burns Philp Overseas Holdings Limited 004 474 551
Burns Philp Pakistan Pty Limited 068 581 653
Burns Philp South America Pty Limited 072 208 309
Burns Philp Technology and Development Pty Limited 003 994 241
Burns Philp Technology Pty Limited 061 602 506
Burns Philp Treasury (Australia) Limited 003 731 986
Indonesian Yeast Company Pty Limited 061 753 026
Mauri Fermentation Argentina Pty Limited 003 994 312
Mauri Fermentation Brazil Pty Limited 060 142 038
Mauri Fermentation Chile Pty Limited 061 325 157
Mauri Fermentation China Pty Limited 051 675 775
Mauri Fermentation India Pty Limited 063 797 759
Mauri Fermentation Indonesia Pty Limited 001 515 617
Mauri Fermentation Malaysia Pty Limited 051 611 628
Mauri Fermentation Philippines Pty Limited 068 581 493
Mauri Fermentation Vietnam Pty Limited 066 107 426
Mauri Yeast Australia Pty Limited 003 853 656
PAGE 6
SCHEDULE 2
GF RELEVANT PARTY REGISTRATION NUMBER
BCW Hotplate Bakery Pty Limited ACN 081 688 011
Country Bake Bakeries Pty Limited ACN 009 423 769
Ernest Adams Australia Pty Limited ACN 002 626 137
ETA Foods Pty Limited ACN 000 982 007
Fielder Gillespie Davis Finance Pty Limited ACN 078 216 065
G F Australia Pty Limited ACN 000 082 324
G F D Australia Pty Limited ACN 004 106 129
G F Defiance Pty Limited ACN 054 283 706
GF Finance International Pty Limited ACN 053 916 733
GF Finance Pty Limited ACN 009 979 471
GF Fresh Pty Limited ACN 083 952 283
GF Group Services Pty Limited ACN 003 889 996
GF Trade Finance Pty Limited ACN 086 651 390
G Wood Son and Company Proprietary Limited ACN 007 870 797
Gillespie Bros Holdings Pty Limited ACN 008 407 109
Goodman Fielder Consumer Foods Pty Limited ACN 000 024 546
Goodman Fielder Field Operations Pty Limited ACN 082 246 437
Goodman Fielder Food Services Pty Limited ACN 009 480 906
Goodman Fielder Ingredients Pty Limited ACN 000 147 580
Goodman Fielder International Pty Limited ACN 000 095 509
Goodman Fielder Pty Limited ACN 000 003 958
ML (WA) Export Pty Limited ACN 000 173 964
Mowbray Industries Pty Limited ACN 008 401 198
Namregtown International Pty Limited ACN 003 995 506
Provincial Traders Foods Pty Limited ACN 008 593 253
QBA Properties Pty Limited ACN 000 357 111
Quality Bakers Australia Pty Limited ACN 004 205 449
Rochna Pty Limited ACN 007 558 947
Stuart Bakery Pty Limited ACN 009 596 730
Sunicrust Bakeries Pty Limited ACN 004 402 582
The Uncle Tobys Company Pty Limited ACN 000 008 962
Uncle Tobys Properties Pty Limited ACN 004 211 812
William Jackett & Son Pty Limited ACN 007 874 213
PAGE 7
[FREEHILLS LETTERHEAD]
5 March 2004 Our ref Patrick Lowden:
Matter no 80427585
Doc no Sydney\004595826
Burns, Philp & Company Limited
Burns Philp Capital Pty Limited
Each Subsidiary Guarantor listed in Schedule 1
Level 23
56 Pitt Street
SYDNEY NSW 2000
Dear Sirs
BURNS PHILP CAPITAL PTY LIMITED - ISSUE OF US$100 MILLION SENIOR SECURITIES DUE
2010
We have acted as Australian legal advisors to Burns, Philp & Company Limited
(ACN 000 000 359) (PARENT) in connection with an offer to exchange (EXCHANGE
OFFER) by Burns Philp Capital Pty Limited (ACN 100 768 803) (Issuer) and Burns
Philp Capital (U.S.) Inc (CO-ISSUER) of US$100 million Senior Notes due 2010
(EXCHANGE NOTES) which are being registered under the Securities Act of 1933 of
the United States of America (SECURITIES ACT) for its existing Senior Notes due
2010 (OLD NOTES), as described in the Registration Statement on Form F-4
relating to the Exchange Offer (REGISTRATION STATEMENT) initially filed with the
United States Securities and Exchange Commission (COMMISSION) on 30 July 2003.
The Old Notes were issued and the Exchange Notes are proposed to be issued under
an Indenture dated 16 June 2003 between the Issuer, the Co-issuer, the Parent,
certain `Subsidiary Guarantors" as defined therein and Wells Fargo Bank,
National Association (INDENTURE). We note that our role in connection with the
Exchange Offer has been limited to the rendering of this opinion (together with
two other opinions dated on or about the same date as this opinion to be filed
with the Registration Statement) and that we have not been involved in the
preparation of the Registration Statement and make no comment on it.
1 DOCUMENTS
We have examined originals, or copies certified or otherwise identified to our
satisfaction, of such documents, corporate records and other instruments as we
have deemed necessary or appropriate for purposes of this opinion, including the
following document (the POWER OF ATTORNEY):
a Power of Attorney, undated, which we are instructed was executed on or about
27 May 2003 by Burns Philp Deutschland GmbH, Burns Philp Deutschland Grundbesitz
GmbH, Burns Philp Deutschland Export Nahrungsmittel-Vertriebsgesellschaft mbH,
Deutsche Hefewerke GmbH & Co. oHG and Deutsche Hefewerke Verwaltungs GmbH.
2 DEFINITIONS
In this Opinion:
(a) AUSTRALIA means the Commonwealth of Australia; and
(b) RELEVANT JURISDICTION means, as the context requires, the State of New
South Wales and Australia.
3 OPINION
Based on the documents referred to in paragraph 1 and subject to the assumptions
and qualifications set out in this Opinion, we are of the opinion that the
appropriate federal courts of Australia or the Supreme Court of New South Wales,
in each case having or exercising jurisdiction, would give effect to the choice
of laws specified in the Power of Attorney to govern the Power of Attorney.
4 ASSUMPTIONS
In this Opinion we have assumed the following matters and have not any
independent investigation of, or enquiries in respect of, those matters:
(a) the copy of the Power of Attorney provided to us is accurate, complete and
up-to-date;
(b) the Power of Attorney is in full force and effect, has been validly
executed by and is binding on and enforceable against each party to it in
accordance with its terms and those parties are duly incorporated under
all applicable laws; and
(c) the choice of laws specified in the Power of Attorney is bona fides and
not unconnected with the commercial realities of the transactions
contemplated by the Power of Attorney.
5 QUALIFICATIONS
This Opinion is subject to the following qualifications:
(a) this Opinion relates only to the laws of the Relevant Jurisdictions in
force at the time of giving this Opinion. We neither express nor imply any
opinion as to, and have not made any investigation of, the laws of any
other jurisdiction. We are under, and assume, no obligation to inform any
person of, or of the effect of, any future changes to those or any other
laws;
(b) the courts of the Relevant Jurisdictions will not give effect to a choice
of law to govern a document if to do so would be contrary to public policy
(but there is nothing on the face of the Power of Attorney that causes us
to believe that giving effect to the choice of law contained in the Powers
of Attorney would be contrary to public policy); and
(c) in rendering this Opinion we have construed the Power of Attorney and made
the statements set out in this Opinion as lawyers admitted to practice in
the State of New South Wales without reference to the meaning or
effect they may have in any other jurisdiction or anything other than
their plain words.
This Opinion is strictly limited to the matters stated in it and does not apply
by implication to other matters.
This Opinion is only given:
(a) in respect of and is limited to the laws of the Relevant Jurisdictions as
applied by the courts of the Relevant Jurisdictions which are in force at
9.00 am Sydney time on the date of this letter;
(b) on the basis that it will be governed by and construed in accordance with
the laws of the Relevant Jurisdictions.
We hereby consent to the filing of this opinion as an exhibit to the
Registration Statement and to being named in the prospectus included therein as
having provided this opinion. In giving such consent, we do not thereby admit
that we come within the category of persons whose consent is required under
Section 7 of the Securities Act or the rules and regulations of the Commission
thereunder.
Yours faithfully
FREEHILLS
/s/ Freehills
Patrick Lowden
Partner