<Page>
Exhibit 5.1
BROWN, WINICK, GRAVES, GROSS,
BASKERVILLE AND SCHOENEBAUM, P.L.C.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
<Table>
666 GRAND AVENUE, SUITE 2000 Richard W. Baskerville Sean P. Moore Valerie D. Bandstra Patents and Trademarks
DES MOINES, IOWA 50309-2510 Bruce Graves Nancy S. Boyd Alexander M. Johnson G. Brian Pingel
Steven C. Schoenebaum James L. Pray James S. Niblock Camille L. Urban
Harold N. Schneebeck Brenton D. Soderstrum Ann Holden Kendell
TELEPHONE: (515) 242-2400 Paul D. Hietbrink Michael D. Treinen Rebecca A. Brommel
FACSIMILE: (515) 283-0231 William C. Brown Scott L. Long Mark E. Roth
Richard K. Updegraff Ronni F. Begleiter Tina R. Thompson
Paul E. Carey Miranda L. Hughes Brian M. Green
URL: www.ialawyers.com Douglas E. Gross Kelly D. Hamborg Dustin D. Smith
John D. Hunter William E. Hanigan Adam W. Jones Of Counsel:
James H. Gilliam Mary A. Ericson Catherine C. Cownie Marvin Winick
Robert D. Andeweg Barbara B. Burnett Erick D. Prohs
Offices in: Alice Eastman Helle Michael J. Green Laura N. Martino
West Des Moines, Iowa Michael R. Blaser Michael A. Dee Amy R. Piepmeier
Pella, Iowa Thomas D. Johnson Danielle Dixon Smid Walter R. Brown (1921-2000)
Christopher R. Sackett Brian P. Rickert
WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL NO.
(515) 242-2477
WRITER'S E-MAIL ADDRESS
hughes@ialawyers.com
</Table>
May 24, 2005
Board of Directors
Advanced BioEnergy, LLC
910 9th Street
Fairmont, NE 68354
Re: 2005 Registration
Dear Sirs:
In connection with the proposed offer and sale of up to 6,732,500 units of the
membership interests (the "Membership Units") of Advanced BioEnergy, LLC (the
"Company"), we have made such legal examination and inquiries as we have deemed
advisable or necessary for the purpose of rendering this opinion and have
examined originals or copies of the following documents and corporate records:
1. The Company's Certificate of Formation;
2. The Company's Amended and Restated Operating Agreement;
3. The Company's resolutions of the Board of Directors authorizing the
issuance of units; and
4. The Company's Registration Statement, as filed by Advanced BioEnergy,
LLC with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission on May
___, 2005.
In rendering our opinions we have relied upon, with the consent of the Company
and its members: (i) the representations of the Company and its members and
other representatives as set forth in the aforementioned documents as to factual
matters; and (ii) certificates and assurances from public officials and from
members and other representatives of the Company as we have deemed necessary for
purposes of expressing the opinions expressed herein. We have not undertaken any
independent investigation to determine or verify any information and
representations made by the Company and its members and representatives in the
foregoing documents or in such certificates, and we have relied upon such
information and representations in expressing our opinions.
<Page>
May 24, 2005
Page 2
We have assumed in rendering these opinions that no person or party has taken
any action inconsistent with the terms of the above-described documents or
prohibited by law.
The opinions expressed herein shall be effective only as of the date of this
opinion letter. The opinions set forth herein are based upon existing law and
regulations, all of which are subject to change prospectively and retroactively.
Our opinions are based on the facts and the above documents as they exist on the
date of this letter, and we assume no obligation to revise or supplement such
opinions as to future changes of law or fact. This opinion letter is limited to
the matters stated herein and no opinions are to be implied or inferred beyond
the matters expressly stated herein.
Based on our examination and inquiry, we are of the opinion that, upon
effectiveness of the Registration Statement, and when issued and sold in the
manner referred to in the Registration Statement and under the applicable
subscription agreement(s), the Membership Units will be duly authorized, fully
paid and non-assessable
Sincerely,
Miranda L. Hughes