data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/67c9f/67c9f63c8157c152c63fd7eba648a92789de74d2" alt="" Curtin University of Technology | Molecular Pharmacology (USA) Limited |
Influence of trace elements on the TNF-α suppression of an anti-arthritic cream |
Heather Benson*, Prue Hart#, Andrew Barker** Maud Eijkenboom*** *School of Pharmacy, Curtin University of Technology, GPO Box U1987, Perth, WA 6845, Australia #Telethon Institute for Child Health Research, Perth, W.Australia **West Australian Institute for Medical Research, Perth, W. Australia ***Molecular Pharmacology Limited (USA), Australian division, Perth, W. Australia |
| | |
INTRODUCTION An extract of the anti arthritic Thermalife Cream (AUSTR 27419) anti-contains 13 trace elements (Table 1). Diffusion studies were undertaken to assess the permeability of human epidermis to the trace elements (exps.1 and 2, Fig. 1). Non-penetrating trace elements were discarded from the test formula (T2), and compared with the original formula (T1) for in vitro antiinflammatory efficacy (TNF-α secretion in LPS-challenged human monocytes). | | Figure Excluded
Fig.1: Franz-type Diffusion cell |
| Table 1: Concentration (μg/g) of trace elements in T1. | | | RESULTS Zinc was the only trace element to penetrate the human epidermis significantly ( Exp.1: 0.59 [T1] vs 0.22 [control]; Exp.2: 0.039 [T1] vs 0.02 [control]). Both formulations strongly suppressed LPSinduced TNF-α secretion. T2 with zinc only was more effective than T1 (Treat: F2,12=57.13, p<0.0001; LPS: F1,12=245.47, p<0.0001; Treat by LPS: F2,12=70.01, p<0.0001). |
| Metallic Species | Concentration in T1 | | |
| Nickel sulphate heptahydrate | 0.52 μg/g | | |
| Sodium fluoride | 1.2 μg/g | | |
| Cupric sulphate | 1.0 μg/g | | |
| Zinc Chloride | 2.35 μg/g | | |
| Ammonium molybdate | 0.35 μg/g | | |
| Cobaltous chloride hexahydrate | 1.0 μg/g | | | |
| Ferrous sulfate | 10 0 μg/g | | | |
| Manganese sulfate | 1.82 μg/g | | | |
| Magnesium sulfate heptahydrate | 4.0 μg/g | | | |
| Sodium gold chloride | 1.75 μg/g | | | |
| Ammonium vanadate | 0.0012 μg/g | | | |
| Potassium chromate | 0.0105 μg/g | | | |
| Boric acid | 1.15 μg/g | | | |
| | |
METHODS Exps.1 and 2: Human epidermis was mounted in vertical Franz type diffusion cells (stratum corneum facing up). T1 cream (n=4) or no cream (n=4) was applied to the donor compartment of diffusion cells, with PBS in the receptor compartment (3.0ml; stirred continuously at 37oC). 240 Min after administration the receptor fluid was analysed for presence of metal ions by ICP-MS. A replication study (exp. 2) used a different skin donor. Exp. 3: Human monocyte cultures (10% FCS, 5% CO2) were either stimulated with 500ng/ml LPS (E.coli 0111:B4,) or not in the presence of 10% T1, 10% T2, or no treatment. 24 Hours after incubation, culture media were collected, centrifuged, and assayed (cytokine ELISA). Statistical analyses used a Treat by LPS ANOVA (p < 0.05). | | Figure Excluded Fig. 2: Suppression of TNF-α secretion in LPS-challenged human monocytes, measured in triplicate 24hrs after treatment with 10% T1 (13 trace elements), 10% T2 (zinc chloride), or no treatment. |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/35864/358640130c95822370d3edccf521aaf6960026d9" alt="" | | |
CONCLUSION In the T1 cream base, zinc was the only trace element that could penetrate human epidermis in vitro. The efficacy of Thermalife extracts to reduce LPS-stimulated human monocyte TNF-α secretion in vitro was retained and enhanced in a formulation with only zinc chloride as trace element. |