Disclosure of Compensation Related Costs, Share-based Payments [Text Block] | Note 10Stock Incentives In April 2014, the Orchids Paper Products Company 2014 Stock Incentive Plan (the “2014 Plan”) was approved. The 2014 Plan replaced the Orchids Paper Products Company 2005 Stock Incentive Plan (the “2005 Plan”) and provides for the granting of stock options and other stock based awards to employees and Board members selected by the Board's compensation committee. The Company's policy is to issue shares of remaining authorized common stock to satisfy option exercises under the 2014 Plan. A total of 400,000 164,200 zero five 10 Stock options with time-based vesting conditions The Company uses the Black-Scholes option valuation model to estimate the grant date fair value of stock options issued with time-based vesting conditions, as this model was developed for use in estimating the fair value of traded options which have no vesting restrictions and are fully transferable. Option valuation models require the input of highly subjective assumptions including the expected stock price volatility. Estimated volatility is calculated based on actual historical volatility of the Company's common stock from the Company's initial public offering date to the grant date. The Company's dividend yield assumption is based on the expected dividend yield as of the grant date. Expected life is calculated based on the average of the service period and the contractual term of the option, using the simplified method for "plain vanilla" options, due to limited available exercise information. The Company expenses the cost of these options granted over the vesting period of the option based on the grant-date fair value of the award. Grant Number Date Risk-Free Expected Grant of Exercise Fair Interest Estimated Dividend Life Date Shares Price Value Rate Volatility Yield (in years) May 2014 35,000 $ 29.65 $ 7.50 2.62 % 41 % 4.72 % 5 Jun 2014 5,000 30.09 7.67 2.63 41 4.65 5 May 2015 40,000 22.49 4.64 2.13 40 6.23 5 Nov 2015 68,000 29.58 7.37 2.32 40 4.73 6 Jan 2016 5,000 27.77 6.56 2.00 40 5.04 6 May 2016 40,000 31.33 7.57 1.74 40 4.47 5 Sep 2016 20,000 28.48 4.53 1.36 30 4.92 6 In 2015, 3,750 Stock options with market-based vesting conditions The Company uses a Monte Carlo option valuation model to estimate the grant date fair value of stock options issued with market-based vesting conditions, as these options include a market condition. Option valuation models require the input of highly subjective assumptions including the expected stock price volatility, dividend yield and expected life of the option. Estimated volatility is calculated based on a mix of historical and implied volatility during the expected life of the options. Historical volatility is considered since the Company’s initial public offering and implied volatility is based on the publicly traded options of a three company peer group within the paper industry. The Company's dividend yield assumption is based on the Company’s average historical dividend yield and current dividend yield as of the grant date. Expected life is calculated based on the average of the service period and the contractual term of the option, using the simplified method for "plain vanilla" options. The Company expenses the cost of these options granted over the implicit, or derived, service period of the option based on the completed Monte Carlo models. During 2014 and 2015, the Board of Directors granted options to purchase 145,000 28,600 2014 options 2015 options Tranche 1 $ 34.79 $ 29.56 Tranche 2 42.35 36.00 Tranche 3 51.43 43.71 Tranche 4 60.50 51.43 Any unvested portion of the options shall expire five years from the date of grant and the options shall terminate ten years after the date of grant. The following table details the options granted to certain members of management that were valued using the Monte Carlo valuation model and the assumptions used in the valuation model for those grants during 2014 and 2015: Grant Derived Date Risk-Free Expected Service Number Exercise Fair Interest Estimated Dividend Life Period Grant Date of Shares Price Value Rate Volatility Yield (in years) (in years) Jan 2014 -Tranche 1 10,000 $ 31.13 $ 5.64 1.98 % 31 % 4.50 % 5.15 0.31 Jan 2014 -Tranche 2 10,000 31.13 5.46 1.98 31 4.50 5.58 1.15 Jan 2014 -Tranche 3 10,000 31.13 5.03 1.98 31 4.50 5.97 1.94 Jan 2014 -Tranche 4 10,000 31.13 4.27 1.98 31 4.50 6.25 2.50 Feb 2014 -Tranche 1 25,000 30.88 5.51 1.98 31 4.60 5.17 0.35 Feb 2014 -Tranche 2 25,000 30.88 5.35 1.98 31 4.60 5.60 1.19 Feb 2014 -Tranche 3 25,000 30.88 4.88 1.98 31 4.60 5.99 1.98 Feb 2014 -Tranche 4 25,000 30.88 4.15 1.98 31 4.60 6.27 2.54 May 2014 -Tranche 1 1,250 28.19 5.06 2.03 31 4.70 5.36 0.71 May 2014 -Tranche 2 1,250 28.19 4.74 2.03 31 4.70 5.78 1.56 May 2014 -Tranche 3 1,250 28.19 4.02 2.03 31 4.70 6.14 2.29 May 2014 -Tranche 4 1,250 28.19 3.29 2.03 31 4.70 6.39 2.79 Sep 2015 -Tranche 1 7,150 25.24 4.44 1.82 34 5.20 5.20 0.40 Sep 2015 -Tranche 2 7,150 25.24 3.92 1.82 34 5.20 5.51 1.02 Sep 2015 -Tranche 3 7,150 25.24 3.11 1.82 34 5.20 5.77 1.54 Sep 2015 -Tranche 4 7,150 25.24 2.36 1.82 34 5.20 5.93 1.87 In 2014, none of these options vested, as the share price of the Company’s common stock did not reach any of the share prices required for vesting. Additionally, 25,000 7,150 29.56 25,000 5,000 3,750 18,750 34.79 18,750 1,800 Stock options issued outside of the 2014 Plan In April 2014, the Company’s stockholders voted to approve the options granted to Mr. Jeffrey S. Schoen, the Company’s President and Chief Executive Officer, on November 8, 2013. Upon his appointment as an officer of the Company, Mr. Schoen was granted an option to purchase up to 400,000 30.25 Share price closes at or above the following percentage of the option purchase price of $30.25 Number of shares that become vested 115% (share price $34.79) 100,000 140% (share price $42.35) 100,000 170% (share price $51.43) 100,000 200% (share price $60.50) 100,000 These options were granted outside of the 2005 Plan and the 2014 Plan. Any unvested portion of the option shall expire five years from the date of grant and the option shall terminate ten years after the date of grant. The Company used a Monte Carlo option valuation model to estimate the grant date fair value of each tranche of 100,000 Grant Derived Number Date Risk-Free Expected Service of Exercise Fair Interest Estimated Dividend Life Period Shares Price Value Rate Volatility Yield (in years) (in years) Tranche 1 100,000 $ 30.25 $ 5.18 2.10 % 30 % 4.60 % 4.99 0.40 Tranche 2 100,000 $ 30.25 5.04 2.10 30 4.60 5.42 1.25 Tranche 3 100,000 $ 30.25 4.31 2.10 30 4.60 5.79 2.00 Tranche 4 100,000 $ 30.25 3.50 2.10 30 4.60 6.04 2.50 In 2016, Tranche 1 of the options granted to Mr. Schoen, or 100,000 34.79 Total option expense The Company recognized the following expenses related to all options granted during 2016, 2015 and 2014 under the 2005 Plan, the 2014 Plan and the Schoen options: Year ended December 31, 2016 2015 2014 (In thousands) Time-based vesting options $ 430 $ 298 $ 308 Market-based vesting options 133 705 1,520 Total compensation expense related to stock options $ 563 $ 1,003 $ 1,828 Summary of option activity The following tables summarize activity related to options granted under the 2005 Plan, the 2014 Plan and the Schoen options: Weighted Weighted Average Weighted Aggregate Average Remaining Average Intrinsic Exercise Contractual Grant Date Value Number Price Life Fair Value (in thousands) Balance, December 31, 2013 180,000 $ 16.46 Granted 585,000 30.36 $ 4.83 Exercised (5,750) 13.80 $ 103 Forfeited (25,000) 31.13 Balance, December 31, 2014 734,250 27.06 Granted 136,600 26.59 $ 5.75 Exercised (11,250) 18.64 $ 50 Forfeited/Expired (33,750) 27.78 Balance, December 31, 2015 825,850 27.07 Granted 65,000 30.18 $ 6.56 Exercised (28,000) 11.22 $ 606 Forfeited (24,550) 30.25 Balance, December 31, 2016 838,300 27.74 7.25 years $ 1,271 Exercisable at December 31, 2016 412,100 $ 25.46 6.92 years $ 1,253 The following table summarizes options outstanding and exercisable under the 2005 Plan, the 2014 Plan and the Schoen options as of December 31, 2016: Options Outstanding Options Exercisable Weighted Weighted Average Weighted Average Remaining Average Exercise Contractual Exercise Exercise price range Number Price Life Number Price $7.48 - $8.58 7,500 $ 8.03 1.79 years 7,500 $ 8.03 $11.95 - $17.85 81,000 $ 16.10 4.14 years 81,000 $ 16.10 $21.70 - $31.33 749,800 $ 29.20 7.64 years 323,600 $ 28.21 838,300 412,100 The following table summarizes information about stock option vesting during the years ended December 31: Stock Options Vested During Fair Value the Year (in thousands) 2016 180,100 $ 1,062 2015 61,750 321 2014 46,334 344 As of December 31, 2016, there was $ 359,000 3.2 During the years ended December 31, 2016, 2015 and 2014, the Company received $ 314,000 210,000 79,000 38,000 23,000 16,000 171,000 20,000 2.0 Restricted stock In February 2013, the Company granted 16,000 21.695 3,000 44,000 51,000 The following tables summarize activity related to unvested restricted stock granted under the 2005 Plan as of December 31, 2016 and for the year then ended: Weighted Average Grant Date Number Fair Value Balance, December 31, 2015 2,000 $ 21.70 Vested (2,000) 21.70 Balance, December 31, 2016 - The following table summarizes information about restricted stock vesting during the years ended December 31: Restricted Stock Vested During Fair Value the Year (in thousands) 2016 2,000 $ 53 2015 2,333 63 2014 2,666 58 No shares of restricted stock were granted in the years ending December 31, 2016, 2015 or 2014. |