Incentive Plans | 12. INCENTIVE PLANS Share-Based Incentive Plan Awards A description of Lazard Ltd’s 2008 Plan and 2005 Plan and activity with respect thereto during the three month and nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015 is presented below. Shares Available Under the 2008 Plan and 2005 Plan The 2008 Plan authorizes the issuance of shares of Class A common stock pursuant to the grant or exercise of stock options, stock appreciation rights, restricted stock units (“RSUs”) and other equity-based awards. Under the 2008 Plan, the maximum number of shares available is based on a formula that limits the aggregate number of shares that may, at any time, be subject to awards that are considered “outstanding” under the 2008 Plan to 30% of the then-outstanding shares of Class A common stock. The 2005 Plan authorized the issuance of up to 25,000,000 shares of Class A common stock pursuant to the grant or exercise of stock options, stock appreciation rights, RSUs and other equity-based awards. Each RSU or similar award granted under the 2005 Plan represents a contingent right to receive one share of Class A common stock, at no cost to the recipient. The fair value of such awards is generally determined based on the closing market price of Class A common stock at the date of grant. The 2005 Plan expired in the second quarter of 2015, although unvested awards granted under the 2005 Plan remain outstanding and continue to be subject to its terms. The following reflects the amortization expense recorded with respect to share-based incentive plans within “compensation and benefits” expense (with respect to RSUs, performance-based restricted stock units (“PRSUs”) and restricted stock awards) and “professional services” expense (with respect to deferred stock units (“DSUs”)) within the Company’s accompanying condensed consolidated statements of operations for the three month and nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015: Three Months Ended September 30, Nine Months Ended September 30, 2016 2015 2016 2015 Share-based incentive awards: RSUs $ 39,447 $ 38,156 $ 134,419 $ 129,490 PRSUs 11,252 10,207 38,276 24,819 Restricted Stock 7,015 3,635 38,833 19,088 DSUs 53 16 808 713 Total $ 57,767 $ 52,014 $ 212,336 $ 174,110 The ultimate amount of compensation and benefits expense relating to share-based awards is dependent upon the actual number of shares of Class A common stock that vest. The Company periodically assesses the forfeiture rates used for such estimates, including as a result of any applicable performance conditions. A change in estimated forfeiture rates results in a cumulative adjustment to previously recorded compensation and benefits expense and also would cause the aggregate amount of compensation expense recognized in future periods to differ from the estimated unrecognized compensation expense described below. The Company’s share-based incentive plans and awards are described below. RSUs and DSUs RSUs generally require future service as a condition for the delivery of the underlying shares of Class A common stock (unless the recipient is then eligible for retirement under the Company’s retirement policy) and convert into shares of Class A common stock on a one-for-one basis after the stipulated vesting periods. PRSUs, which are RSUs that are also subject to service-based vesting conditions, have additional performance conditions, and are described below. The grant date fair value of the RSUs, net of an estimated forfeiture rate, is amortized over the vesting periods or requisite service periods (generally one-third after two years, and the remaining two-thirds after the third year), and is adjusted for actual forfeitures over such period. RSUs generally include a dividend participation right that provides that during vesting periods each RSU is attributed additional RSUs (or fractions thereof) equivalent to any dividends paid on Class A common stock during such period. During the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, dividend participation rights required the issuance of 969,054 and 603,608 RSUs, respectively. Non-executive members of the Board of Directors of Lazard Group, who are the same Non-Executive Directors of Lazard Ltd (“Non-Executive Directors”), receive approximately 55% of their annual compensation for service on the Board of Directors and its committees in the form of DSUs, which resulted in 38,771 and 23,961 DSUs granted in connection with annual compensation during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Their remaining compensation is payable in cash, which they may elect to receive in the form of additional DSUs under the Directors’ Fee Deferral Unit Plan described below. DSUs are convertible into shares of Class A common stock at the time of cessation of service to the Board of Directors. DSUs include a cash dividend participation right equivalent to dividends paid on Class A common stock. The Company’s Directors’ Fee Deferral Unit Plan permits the Non-Executive Directors to elect to receive additional DSUs in lieu of some or all of their cash fees. The number of DSUs granted to a Non-Executive Director pursuant to this election will equal the value of cash fees that the applicable Non-Executive Director has elected to forego pursuant to such election, divided by the market value of a share of Class A common stock on the date immediately preceding the date of the grant. During the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, 7,407 and 1,761 DSUs, respectively, had been granted pursuant to such Plan. DSU awards are expensed at their fair value on their date of grant, inclusive of amounts related to the Directors’ Fee Deferral Unit Plan. The following is a summary of activity relating to RSUs and DSUs during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015: RSUs DSUs Units Weighted Average Grant Date Fair Value Units Weighted Average Grant Date Fair Value Balance, January 1, 2016 9,599,658 $ 44.06 312,670 $ 35.98 Granted (including 969,054 RSUs relating to dividend participation) 6,649,625 $ 34.64 46,178 $ 34.98 Forfeited (181,337 ) $ 39.79 - - Vested (4,527,559 ) $ 39.16 (84,759 ) $ 35.30 Balance, September 30, 2016 11,540,387 $ 40.62 274,089 $ 36.02 Balance, January 1, 2015 13,529,116 $ 35.19 286,227 $ 34.21 Granted (including 603,608 RSUs relating to dividend participation) 4,111,619 $ 48.84 25,722 $ 55.43 Forfeited (461,297 ) $ 43.49 - - Vested (7,159,642 ) $ 30.87 - - Balance, September 30, 2015 10,019,796 $ 43.50 311,949 $ 35.96 In connection with RSUs that vested during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, the Company satisfied its minimum statutory tax withholding requirements in lieu of delivering 1,416,643 and 1,940,996 shares of Class A common stock during such respective nine month periods. Accordingly, 3,110,916 and 5,218,646 shares of Class A common stock held by the Company were delivered during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. As of September 30, 2016, estimated unrecognized RSU compensation expense was approximately $174,364, with such expense expected to be recognized over a weighted average period of approximately 0.9 years subsequent to September 30, 2016. Restricted Stock The following is a summary of activity related to shares of restricted Class A common stock associated with compensation arrangements during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015: Restricted Shares Weighted Average Grant Date Fair Value Balance, January 1, 2016 713,738 $ 47.12 Granted 1,795,258 $ 36.74 Forfeited (33,943 ) $ 40.49 Vested (802,276 ) $ 37.09 Balance, September 30, 2016 1,672,777 $ 40.92 Balance, January 1, 2015 729,827 $ 38.63 Granted 576,886 $ 50.88 Forfeited (45,500 ) $ 50.24 Vested (512,516 ) $ 39.25 Balance, September 30, 2015 748,697 $ 46.94 In connection with shares of restricted Class A common stock that vested during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, the Company satisfied its minimum statutory tax withholding requirements in lieu of delivering 132,984 and 94,745 shares of Class A common stock during such respective nine month periods. Accordingly, 669,292 and 417,771 shares of Class A common stock held by the Company were delivered during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. The restricted stock awards include a cash dividend participation right equivalent to dividends paid on Class A common stock during the period, which will vest concurrently with the underlying restricted stock award. At September 30, 2016, estimated unrecognized restricted stock expense was approximately $38,512, with such expense to be recognized over a weighted average period of approximately 1.0 years subsequent to September 30, 2016. PRSUs PRSUs are subject to both performance-based and service-based vesting conditions. The number of shares of Class A common stock that a recipient will receive upon vesting of a PRSU will be calculated by reference to certain performance metrics that relate to Lazard Ltd’s performance over a three-year period. The target number of shares of Class A common stock subject to each PRSU is one; however, based on the achievement of the performance criteria, the number of shares of Class A common stock that may be received in connection with each PRSU generally can range from zero to two times the target number. PRSUs will vest on a single date three years following the date of the grant, provided the applicable service and performance conditions are satisfied. However, PRSUs granted in 2013 vested 33% in March 2015 and 67% in March 2016. In addition, the performance metrics applicable to each PRSU will be evaluated on an annual basis at the end of each fiscal year during the performance period and, if Lazard Ltd has achieved a threshold level of performance with respect to the fiscal year, 25% of the target number of shares of Class A common stock subject to each PRSU will no longer be at risk of forfeiture based on the achievement of performance criteria. PRSUs include dividend participation rights that provide that during vesting periods the target number of PRSUs (or, following the relevant performance period, the actual number of shares of Class A common stock that are no longer subject to performance conditions) receive dividend equivalents at the same rate that dividends are paid on Class A common stock during such period. These dividend equivalents are credited as RSUs that are not subject to the performance-based vesting criteria but are otherwise subject to the same restrictions as the underlying PRSUs to which they relate. The following is a summary of activity relating to PRSUs during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015: PRSUs Weighted Average Grant Date Fair Value Balance, January 1, 2016 1,019,038 $ 44.49 Granted (a) 627,956 $ 32.91 Vested (417,021 ) $ 38.43 Balance, September 30, 2016 1,229,973 $ 40.63 Balance, January 1, 2015 1,347,148 $ 37.79 Granted (a) 368,389 $ 52.85 Vested (696,499 ) $ 35.96 Balance, September 30, 2015 1,019,038 $ 44.49 (a) Represents PRSU awards granted during the relevant year at the target payout level. In connection with PRSUs that vested during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, the Company satisfied its minimum statutory tax withholding requirements in lieu of delivering 64,169 and 32,086 shares of Class A common stock during such respective nine month periods. Accordingly, 352,852 and 664,413 shares of Class A common stock held by the Company were delivered during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015. Compensation expense recognized for PRSU awards is determined by multiplying the number of shares of Class A common stock underlying such awards that, based on the Company’s estimate, are considered probable of vesting, by the grant date fair value. As of September 30, 2016, the total estimated unrecognized compensation expense was approximately $17,330, and the Company expects to amortize such expense over a weighted-average period of approximately 0.7 years subsequent to September 30, 2016. LFI and Other Similar Deferred Compensation Arrangements Commencing in February 2011, the Company granted LFI to eligible employees. In connection with LFI and other similar deferred compensation arrangements, which generally require future service as a condition for vesting, the Company recorded a prepaid compensation asset and a corresponding compensation liability on the grant date based upon the fair value of the award. The prepaid asset is amortized on a straight-line basis over the applicable vesting periods or requisite service periods (which are generally similar to the comparable periods for RSUs), and is charged to “compensation and benefits” expense within the Company’s condensed consolidated statement of operations. LFI and similar deferred compensation arrangements that do not require future service are expensed immediately. The related compensation liability is accounted for at fair value as a derivative liability, which contemplates the impact of estimated forfeitures, and is adjusted for changes in fair value primarily related to changes in value of the underlying investments. The following is a summary of activity relating to LFI and other similar deferred compensation arrangements during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015: Prepaid Compensation Asset Compensation Liability Balance, January 1, 2016 $ 75,703 $ 193,574 Granted 51,871 51,871 Settled - (75,583 ) Forfeited (1,967 ) (3,435 ) Amortization (56,784 ) - Change in fair value related to: Increase in fair value of underlying investments - 4,707 Adjustment for estimated forfeitures - 3,551 Other (1,232 ) 585 Balance, September 30, 2016 $ 67,591 $ 175,270 Prepaid Compensation Asset Compensation Liability Balance, January 1, 2015 $ 73,278 $ 207,306 Granted 89,817 89,817 Settled - (94,899 ) Forfeited (3,610 ) (6,873 ) Amortization (64,136 ) - Change in fair value related to: Decrease in fair value of underlying investments - (9,903 ) Adjustment for estimated forfeitures - 5,219 Other (184 ) (2,030 ) Balance, September 30, 2015 $ 95,165 $ 188,637 The amortization of the prepaid compensation asset will generally be recognized over a weighted average period of approximately 0.8 years subsequent to September 30, 2016. The following is a summary of the impact of LFI and other similar deferred compensation arrangements on “compensation and benefits” expense within the accompanying condensed consolidated statements of operations for the three month and nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015: Three Months Ended September 30, Nine Months Ended September 30, 2016 2015 2016 2015 Amortization, net of forfeitures $ 18,116 $ 21,168 $ 58,867 $ 66,092 Change in the fair value of underlying investments 6,909 (12,145 ) 4,707 (9,903 ) Total $ 25,025 $ 9,023 $ 63,574 $ 56,189 |