Schedule of incurred losses and LAE and cumulative paid losses and LAE | AmTrust Reinsurance: All Other Lines This category includes all lines except Workers' Compensation, General Liability and Commercial Auto from the AmTrust Small Commercial Business and Specialty Program Divisions. The predominant exposures are property and auto physical damage. All Other Lines Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance (excluding impact of ADC) At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Impact of ADC Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 27,630 $ 28,724 $ 28,715 $ 29,149 $ 29,237 $ 29,070 $ 29,576 $ 29,574 $ 29,519 $ 252 $ — 2009 12,516 20,349 11,959 13,329 14,309 14,492 16,088 15,653 14,617 259 — 2010 14,440 15,182 24,718 15,484 16,078 16,105 17,071 17,059 15,438 159 — 2011 18,822 19,948 26,343 27,509 22,359 22,616 23,376 23,506 21,469 29 — 2012 14,697 18,443 19,426 21,898 18,673 19,850 20,260 19,578 2,023 82 2013 17,806 17,630 28,058 22,918 21,313 21,669 21,735 2,429 131 2014 20,597 25,268 26,021 24,958 26,278 24,929 3,350 62 2015 52,706 54,857 49,631 49,463 47,882 2,849 167 2016 79,654 74,948 72,384 73,602 9,276 166 2017 104,637 96,812 92,904 9,381 151 2018 96,910 103,489 2,048 65 2019 37,945 2,550 — Total $ 503,107 $ 34,605 $ 824 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 25,776 $ 29,710 $ 29,900 $ 31,217 $ 29,388 $ 29,177 $ 30,833 $ 30,683 $ 29,234 2009 7,891 8,084 8,743 11,093 13,105 13,870 15,224 15,051 14,009 2010 12,373 12,332 13,012 15,375 15,748 16,058 16,919 16,786 15,285 2011 13,840 16,424 17,571 21,279 22,044 22,715 23,892 23,661 21,481 2012 10,308 14,031 16,033 16,936 17,946 18,205 18,685 17,559 2013 11,877 15,997 17,509 20,258 20,456 20,447 19,343 2014 12,028 20,277 20,940 22,018 26,194 21,405 2015 28,929 45,208 42,631 41,962 44,179 2016 42,795 69,805 65,452 63,234 2017 48,903 80,726 80,735 2018 56,539 86,455 2019 22,095 Total 435,014 All outstanding liabilities prior to 2008, net of reinsurance (2 ) Total net reserves excluding impact of ADC $ 68,091 Impact of ADC (824 ) Total net reserves including impact of ADC $ 67,267 Workers' Compensation Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance (excluding impact of ADC) At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Impact of ADC Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 80,800 $ 81,493 $ 82,438 $ 81,240 $ 82,301 $ 83,039 $ 83,622 $ 84,710 $ 83,952 $ 28 $ 2,962 2009 102,240 102,245 103,864 109,213 106,204 105,901 107,165 110,175 109,664 2,287 4,612 2010 106,799 113,880 118,209 120,243 125,020 124,073 123,968 127,215 127,381 4,933 6,591 2011 104,923 125,549 130,712 132,728 133,995 133,916 135,379 138,600 139,685 7,253 7,943 2012 136,960 168,016 173,946 171,040 172,692 181,616 192,087 188,879 9,945 12,885 2013 237,019 245,765 238,392 242,447 261,915 276,249 273,571 21,269 20,974 2014 379,589 365,515 382,260 419,748 457,363 455,521 47,774 41,920 2015 474,140 474,212 526,269 551,145 545,271 58,111 59,535 2016 528,906 568,006 627,728 603,529 89,376 72,793 2017 615,957 654,362 613,577 72,161 93,752 2018 592,566 580,528 70,919 105,435 2019 12,751 2,227 — Total $ 3,734,309 $ 386,283 $ 429,402 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 68,400 $ 72,823 $ 76,018 $ 77,370 $ 78,161 $ 79,230 $ 81,159 $ 82,436 $ 82,709 2009 71,963 83,464 89,462 93,425 96,396 98,811 100,103 101,823 102,877 2010 61,322 82,614 95,120 103,280 108,171 114,639 115,014 115,959 116,332 2011 33,089 69,357 91,414 105,584 114,107 115,966 122,579 124,315 125,843 2012 45,030 88,382 119,059 138,706 150,543 158,807 164,512 168,154 2013 56,249 121,182 168,785 199,300 216,527 227,502 234,342 2014 69,512 189,954 268,467 321,258 355,414 370,176 2015 86,695 246,616 338,642 388,640 417,736 2016 110,051 284,501 380,602 428,651 2017 111,508 274,596 448,551 2018 110,954 409,986 2019 3,907 Total 2,909,264 All outstanding liabilities prior to 2008, net of reinsurance 687 Total net reserves excluding impact of ADC $ 825,732 Impact of ADC (429,402 ) Total net reserves including impact of ADC $ 396,330 Diversified Reinsurance - European Capital Solutions The European Capital Solutions business is mainly a portfolio of assumed reinsurance in Europe which is now in run-off. Maiden Reinsurance began writing treaty reinsurance contracts under this initiative in 2016 therefore only four calendar years of the Company's incurred and paid loss development by accident year have been provided in the tables below. Diversified Reinsurance - European Capital Solutions Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2016 $ 4,839 $ 4,911 $ 5,318 $ 5,563 $ 1,052 2017 8,699 10,085 8,997 2,333 2018 22,617 24,490 11,380 2019 15,381 5,487 Total $ 54,431 $ 20,252 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2016 $ 780 $ 2,311 $ 3,271 $ 4,635 2017 1,926 4,070 5,744 2018 3,188 8,321 2019 3,195 Total 21,895 Total net reserves $ 32,536 The following tables represent information on the Company's incurred loss and LAE and cumulative paid loss and LAE, both net of reinsurance, by significant line of business since 2011 for our AmTrust Reinsurance segment. All data shown for the AmTrust in the tables that follow are from the Company’s quota share contracts with AmTrust, both the multi-year AmTrust Quota Share and the annually renewable European Hospital Liability Quota Share. AmTrust purchases significant reinsurance for losses above $10 million covered by the AmTrust Quota Share. The Company’s share of AmTrust’s losses net of reinsurance in the AmTrust Quota Share is generally 40% . Additionally, for the Specialty Program portion of Covered Business only, AmTrust will be responsible for ultimate net loss otherwise recoverable from Maiden Reinsurance to the extent that the loss ratio to Maiden Reinsurance, which shall be determined on an inception to date basis from July 1, 2007 through the date of calculation, is between 81.5% and 95% . Above and below the defined corridor, Maiden Reinsurance has reinsured losses at its proportional 40% share per the AmTrust Quota Share. Effective July 31, 2019, the Loss Corridor was amended such that the maximum amount covered is $40,500 , the amount calculated by Maiden Reinsurance for the Loss Corridor coverage as of March 31, 2019 . Any development above this maximum amount will be subject to the coverage of the LPT/ADC Agreement. Recoverables from the LPT/ADC Agreement are displayed in the column " Impact of ADC " in the tables below. Amounts have been allocated to Accident Year and line of business according to the timing of the respective losses, based on the currently projected payout patterns. These allocations may shift over time as actual payments are made and payout patterns are re–estimated. Please refer to " Note 1 — Organization " for additional information . General Liability Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance (excluding impact of ADC) At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Impact of ADC Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 28,786 $ 31,921 $ 33,051 $ 33,792 $ 34,169 $ 35,985 $ 36,627 $ 37,605 $ 36,996 $ 138 $ 336 2009 19,311 28,384 29,123 30,902 32,418 34,040 34,863 35,138 35,410 846 545 2010 15,783 28,850 34,761 36,455 38,536 38,298 41,597 42,884 43,062 674 972 2011 11,334 24,731 35,628 40,557 42,100 45,303 49,338 52,746 53,499 553 1,522 2012 21,281 33,445 42,450 48,851 50,800 55,991 59,948 63,429 2,499 1,990 2013 42,021 43,116 66,869 68,641 79,731 89,204 92,032 4,705 3,182 2014 65,469 66,558 77,930 99,873 111,970 116,085 8,374 6,009 2015 118,111 95,766 122,942 139,518 154,071 26,113 9,213 2016 98,149 114,864 120,911 148,371 36,850 13,932 2017 116,158 133,533 165,268 63,568 18,961 2018 121,991 153,822 86,599 24,871 2019 5,427 5,611 — Total $ 1,067,472 $ 236,530 $ 81,533 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 20,935 $ 26,288 $ 29,384 $ 32,849 $ 32,423 $ 32,765 $ 34,935 $ 36,699 $ 34,893 2009 7,840 13,904 19,727 24,298 28,312 30,924 32,878 33,473 32,487 2010 5,140 11,187 19,010 26,429 30,948 34,125 37,317 39,214 39,888 2011 2,813 6,072 12,158 22,963 31,619 39,350 41,257 47,141 49,178 2012 5,084 13,224 18,020 29,752 40,864 45,775 53,526 56,538 2013 4,996 10,226 32,249 44,698 58,377 70,074 76,996 2014 3,503 24,581 36,026 57,678 77,259 86,101 2015 20,849 33,963 52,350 79,291 98,278 2016 6,402 21,959 45,855 67,064 2017 6,967 27,001 51,545 2018 7,907 24,618 2019 27 Total 617,613 All outstanding liabilities prior to 2008, net of reinsurance 207 Total net reserves excluding impact of ADC $ 450,066 Impact of ADC (81,533 ) Total net reserves including impact of ADC $ 368,533 AmTrust Reinsurance: Workers’ Compensation This reserve class consists of the Workers’ Compensation portion of the AmTrust Quota Share. The business is written in the U.S. by AmTrust from both their Small Commercial Business and Specialty Program business units. The Small Commercial Business unit focuses on writing smaller, niche workers' compensation exposures in generally low-hazard occupations. Workers’ Compensation business written in the Specialty Program unit is typically part of programs consisting of multiple lines of business. The business is produced by managing general agents with AmTrust regularly adding new programs and terminating or renegotiating unprofitable ones. Our initial underwriting year loss projections are generally based on the ELR method, derived from historical performance after the consideration of loss and premium trends. Since it is proportional exposure, and due to the size and the classes of business insured by AmTrust, this reserving class is much shorter tailed than a traditional workers compensation book, and the transition to the BF and the LD methods happens relatively quickly, within the first several years. The following tables represent information on the Company's incurred loss and LAE and cumulative paid loss and LAE, both net of reinsurance, since 2011 for our Diversified Reinsurance segment. The development tables below included reserves acquired from the loss portfolio transfer agreement associated with the GMAC International Insurance Services ("IIS") business as at November 30, 2010 of $98,827 . For the purposes of disclosure, the reserves from the loss portfolio transfer was allocated to the original accident year. Many pro-rata contracts are big enough that specific company development patterns are used. The ELR from the pricing of the account is typically used for the first year or more until the data suggests an alternative result is likely. Use of the ELR method transitions to the BF and then the LD method. For smaller contracts, benchmark development patterns may be used in both the pricing to establish the ELR and the reserving. The use of benchmark patterns is more prevalent in excess of loss business and the movement to experience based methods is slower. Diversified Reinsurance - International The international business written by our IIS team is mainly proportional treaty business, a significant portion of which is Personal Auto quota share but also comprises credit life quota share. Life and personal accident business is also written on a direct basis by Maiden LF. The IIS team works with insurance partners, automobile manufacturers and their related credit providers and other organizations to design and implement insurance programs in both auto distribution-related and other consumer insurance products. For the auto quota share exposure, our initial underwriting year loss projections are generally based on the ELR method, derived from account pricing analyses. Payment and reporting patterns are short-tailed, and the movement away from the ELR to BF or LD methods typically happens very rapidly. Credit life reserves are primarily a function of reporting lag, typically only one or several months on average. The reserves are calculated using a FS methodology, where the frequency is a function of the average claims lag and the average per claims severity. Commercial Auto Liability Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance (excluding impact of ADC) At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Impact of ADC Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 29,890 $ 32,769 $ 33,700 $ 34,522 $ 34,584 $ 35,975 $ 35,521 $ 35,382 $ 35,542 $ 103 $ 9 2009 22,183 26,275 28,551 30,812 31,024 30,468 30,919 31,033 31,064 498 61 2010 26,239 33,457 37,154 38,043 40,193 40,523 42,146 41,996 42,070 1,616 (22 ) 2011 16,193 24,292 29,577 32,578 33,839 34,790 36,149 36,065 34,643 343 305 2012 20,863 32,691 40,076 44,812 48,116 46,150 45,753 45,917 17 40 2013 33,473 44,771 50,647 59,702 63,162 62,163 63,620 325 339 2014 47,525 55,023 73,966 82,427 89,299 92,572 408 2,395 2015 66,967 92,955 106,560 119,141 127,560 4,427 3,851 2016 121,828 118,210 144,077 171,504 14,692 6,001 2017 156,575 189,257 220,457 47,729 7,647 2018 177,150 224,780 93,666 11,108 2019 79,172 54,012 — Total $ 1,168,901 $ 217,836 $ 31,734 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2008 $ 25,207 $ 29,386 $ 30,975 $ 32,643 $ 33,536 $ 34,074 $ 34,803 $ 35,284 $ 36,968 2009 14,532 18,736 22,959 26,975 29,226 29,829 29,842 30,204 31,194 2010 14,203 21,050 28,602 34,855 37,734 39,413 39,750 40,282 40,395 2011 5,721 12,333 18,813 25,808 29,769 32,362 33,130 33,155 33,451 2012 6,693 14,979 26,508 35,460 43,745 44,165 45,555 45,751 2013 8,267 19,865 34,379 48,122 57,349 59,600 62,331 2014 8,450 22,858 42,960 64,459 79,766 87,458 2015 13,102 39,179 62,945 86,433 107,707 2016 19,071 48,595 76,635 113,174 2017 26,863 69,657 115,623 2018 30,018 67,080 2019 9,456 Total 750,588 All outstanding liabilities prior to 2008, net of reinsurance 26 Total net reserves excluding impact of ADC $ 418,339 Impact of ADC (31,734 ) Total net reserves including impact of ADC $ 386,605 AmTrust Reinsurance: Commercial Auto Liability Commercial Auto Liability is written in the U.S. and included in the Small Commercial Business and Specialty Program business units within the AmTrust Quota Share. The Small Commercial Business unit focuses on writing smaller niche business, typically under-served by the broader insurance market, and policies typically have limits of $1,000 . Auto Liability business written in the Small Commercial Business unit grew substantially following a large renewal rights acquisition completed by AmTrust in 2014. Commercial Auto Liability business written in the Specialty Program unit is typically part of programs consisting of multiple lines of business. Our initial underwriting year loss projections are generally based on the ELR method, derived from historical performance after the consideration of loss and premium trends. This proportional exposure is relatively short tailed, and the transition to the BF and the LD methods happens relatively quickly, within the first several years. AmTrust Reinsurance: European Hospital Liability AmTrust entered this line of business in Italy in 2010 when it believed there were significant opportunities in what had traditionally been an under-performing market. European Hospital Liability policies are written on a claim made basis. Maiden wrote a separate annually renewable contract covering this exposure in 2011 which is not part of the AmTrust Quota Share. Currently, most exposure remains in Italy with a modest amount of exposure to other European nations. The European Hospital Liability Quota Share is a claims made exposure, and in many instances claims are eventually closed with no liability. This phenomena is estimated during the reserving process, and can result in a provision for pure IBNR (reserves for claims which have not yet been reported) which is minimal or negative. This estimate will vary as the exposure matures which could result in changes to the level of reserves. Also, severity for known claims and expenses can increase over time, which requires a provision for IBNR. The net result is a relatively small amount of IBNR. Our initial underwriting year loss projections are generally based on the ELR method, derived from historical performance after the consideration of loss and premium trends. Loss reporting for this line is unique, as a large proportion of claims are initially reserved but eventually closed with no payment, as the insurer is found to have no liability after investigation of the fundamentals of the claim. In addition, the underlying insurance policies we assume are subject to deductibles on both a per claim and aggregate basis. For these reasons, the LD method is not typically employed in the estimate of loss. After the first several years, we utilize a FS methodology; frequency is estimated on a reported claim basis and adjusted for an estimate of the proportion of claims which will close with no payment, while severity is estimated on both a gross and net of deductible basis. European Hospital Liability Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2011 $ 49,278 $ 23,018 $ 35,631 $ 49,228 $ 46,827 $ 64,479 $ 62,523 $ 59,950 $ 62,206 $ (820 ) 2012 79,120 80,638 79,856 102,396 91,598 86,732 112,088 116,921 6,642 2013 48,611 61,072 63,708 83,695 76,528 98,090 103,900 7,854 2014 50,574 53,255 57,043 63,471 80,033 85,260 9,101 2015 47,151 45,778 59,603 65,533 68,661 7,260 2016 44,146 50,821 66,517 69,033 9,530 2017 40,641 51,781 53,894 12,564 2018 44,242 31,379 6,313 2019 15,763 6,457 Total $ 607,017 $ 64,901 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2011 $ 1,088 $ 4,310 $ 12,717 $ 23,336 $ 28,547 $ 35,469 $ 41,037 $ 45,196 $ 48,949 2012 4,769 15,247 34,701 45,197 58,108 68,517 76,481 82,557 2013 2,963 14,905 25,644 39,128 49,188 55,123 62,317 2014 4,171 11,748 24,420 34,757 39,001 46,004 2015 3,444 10,952 22,612 28,858 34,656 2016 3,554 10,557 17,492 23,268 2017 1,268 4,380 7,507 2018 913 2,248 2019 11,371 Total 318,877 Total net reserves $ 288,140 Diversified Reinsurance - International Incurred loss and LAE, net of reinsurance At December 31, 2019 For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total IBNR Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2010 $ 79,487 $ 78,840 $ 78,727 $ 78,476 $ 76,857 $ 78,931 $ 80,932 $ 80,625 $ 81,665 $ 986 2011 49,772 48,321 48,342 48,525 48,483 48,313 48,692 48,937 48,896 4 2012 50,292 48,576 48,850 48,955 49,037 49,298 49,017 48,969 52 2013 44,973 50,106 51,424 50,926 51,527 51,747 52,136 (135 ) 2014 42,760 48,529 48,397 48,291 48,065 48,141 187 2015 42,980 44,394 44,885 44,323 44,339 (224 ) 2016 38,763 40,767 40,105 40,064 (146 ) 2017 36,855 36,308 35,234 956 2018 45,000 42,954 3,388 2019 36,408 9,317 Total $ 478,806 $ 14,385 Cumulative paid loss and LAE, net of reinsurance For the Year Ended December 31, 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Accident Year: Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited Unaudited 2010 $ 34,452 $ 43,364 $ 48,163 $ 49,897 $ 51,487 $ 53,002 $ 54,482 $ 56,164 $ 57,601 2011 24,326 45,078 46,695 47,932 48,350 48,582 48,723 48,837 48,902 2012 23,614 40,318 42,698 43,785 44,112 44,695 44,808 44,822 2013 24,294 43,591 46,072 47,416 47,884 48,099 48,177 2014 23,859 42,138 44,409 45,632 45,889 45,995 2015 21,864 39,449 41,502 42,533 42,947 2016 22,590 36,708 38,537 39,284 2017 19,185 33,592 35,333 2018 20,818 37,349 2019 17,003 Total 417,413 Total net reserves $ 61,393 AmTrust Reinsurance: General Liability This reserve class consists of the General Liability portion of the AmTrust Quota Share. The business is written in the U.S. by AmTrust from both their Small Commercial Business and Specialty Program business units. The Small Commercial Business unit focuses on writing smaller niche business, typically under-served by the broader insurance market, which typically have limits of $1,000 . General Liability business written in the Small Commercial Business unit grew substantially following AmTrust’s renewal rights acquisition in 2014. Specialty Program business may contain a mix of exposures from retail operations, contractors, manufacturers, and other premises. Our initial underwriting year loss projections are generally based on the ELR method, derived from historical performance after the consideration of loss and premium trends. This proportional exposure is medium tailed, and the IBNR is typically derived from the use of the initial ELR for the first several years following the earning of the exposure, followed by a transition to the BF and the LD methods. |