Allowance for Loan Losses | 2. Allowance for Loan Losses Our provisions for loan losses represent the periodic expense of maintaining an allowance sufficient to absorb incurred probable losses, net of expected recoveries, in the held-for-investment loan portfolios. The evaluation of the provisions for loan losses is inherently subjective, as it requires material estimates that may be susceptible to significant changes. We segregate our Private Education Loan portfolio into two classes of loans in monitoring and assessing credit risk — Troubled Debt Restructurings (“TDRs”) and Non-TDRs. We believe that the allowance for loan losses is appropriate to cover probable losses incurred in the loan portfolios. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Allowance for Loan Losses Metrics Three Months Ended September 30, 2018 (Dollars in millions) FFELP Private Education Loans Other Loans Total Allowance for Loan Losses Beginning balance $ 82 $ 1,297 $ 10 $ 1,389 Total provision 10 75 — 85 Net adjustment resulting from the change in the charge-off rate (1) — (32 ) — (32 ) Net charge-offs remaining (2) (13 ) (116 ) — (129 ) Total net charge-offs (13 ) (148 ) — (161 ) Reclassification of interest reserve (3) — 2 — 2 Ending balance $ 79 $ 1,226 $ 10 $ 1,315 Allowance Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment — TDR $ — $ 1,134 $ 9 $ 1,143 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 79 92 1 172 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (4) — — — — Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (4) — — — — Ending total allowance $ 79 $ 1,226 $ 10 $ 1,315 Loans Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment — TDR $ — $ 10,497 $ 29 $ 10,526 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 70,778 11,459 49 82,286 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (4) 2,941 2,282 — 5,223 Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (4) — 231 — 231 Ending total loans (5) $ 73,719 $ 24,469 $ 78 $ 98,266 Net charge-offs as a percentage of average loans in repayment, excluding the net adjustment resulting from the change in the charge-off rate (1) .09 % 2.08 % — % Net adjustment resulting from the change in charge-off rate as a percentage of average loans in repayment (1) — % .57 % — % Allowance coverage of charge-offs 1.5 2.1 — Allowance as a percentage of the ending total loan balance .11 % 5.01 % 12.71 % Allowance as a percentage of the ending loans in repayment .13 % 5.57 % 12.71 % Ending total loans (5) $ 73,719 $ 24,469 $ 78 Average loans in repayment $ 61,956 $ 22,158 $ 77 Ending loans in repayment $ 60,959 $ 21,997 $ 78 (1) In third-quarter 2018, the portion of the loan amount charged off at default on Private Education Loans increased from 79 percent to 80.5 percent. This did not impact the provision for loan losses as previously this had been reserved through the allowance for loan losses. This charge resulted in a $32 million reduction to the balance of the receivable for partially charged-off loan balance. (2) Charge-offs are reported net of expected recoveries. For Private Education Loans, the expected recovery amount is transferred to the receivable for partially charged-off loan balance. Charge-offs include charge-offs against the receivable for partially charged-off loans which represents the difference between what was expected to be recovered and any shortfalls in what was actually recovered in the period. See “Receivable for Partially Charged-Off Private Education Loans” for further discussion. (3) Represents the additional allowance related to the amount of uncollectible interest reserved within interest income that is transferred in the period to the allowance for loan losses when interest is capitalized to a loan’s principal balance. (4) The Purchased Credit Impaired Loans’ losses are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as these loans are separately reserved for, if needed. No allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2018. The losses of the Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as the remaining purchased discount associated with the FFELP and Private Education Loans of $38 million and $343 million, respectively, as of September 30, 2018 is greater than the incurred losses and as a result no allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2018. (5) Ending total loans for Private Education Loans includes the receivable for partially charged-off loans. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Three Months Ended September 30, 2017 (Dollars in millions) FFELP Loans Private Education Loans Other Loans Total Allowance for Loan Losses Beginning balance $ 61 $ 1,286 $ 15 $ 1,362 Total provision 10 95 — 105 Charge-offs (1) (10 ) (96 ) (3 ) (109 ) Reclassification of interest reserve (2) — 2 — 2 Ending balance $ 61 $ 1,287 $ 12 $ 1,360 Allowance Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment — TDR $ — $ 1,169 $ 10 $ 1,179 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 61 118 2 181 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (3) — — — — Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (3) — — — — Ending total allowance $ 61 $ 1,287 $ 12 $ 1,360 Loans Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment - TDR $ — 10,961 30 $ 10,991 Collectively evaluated for impairment Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 79,923 11,790 34 91,747 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (3) 3,362 2,656 — 6,018 Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (3) — 258 — 258 Ending total loans (4) $ 83,285 $ 25,665 $ 64 $ 109,014 Charge-offs as a percentage of average loans in repayment .05 % 1.63 % 16.22 % Allowance coverage of charge-offs 1.7 3.4 .9 Allowance as a percentage of the ending total loan balance .07 % 5.02 % 18.59 % Allowance as a percentage of the ending loans in repayment .09 % 5.73 % 18.59 % Ending total loans (4) $ 83,285 $ 25,665 $ 64 Average loans in repayment $ 68,168 $ 23,112 $ 85 Ending loans in repayment $ 66,220 $ 22,448 $ 64 (1) Charge-offs are reported net of expected recoveries. For Private Education Loans, the expected recovery amount is transferred to the receivable for partially charged-off loan balance. Charge-offs include charge-offs against the receivable for partially charged-off loans which represents the difference between what was expected to be recovered and any shortfalls in what was actually recovered in the period. See “Receivable for Partially Charged-Off Private Education Loans” for further discussion. (2) Represents the additional allowance related to the amount of uncollectible interest reserved within interest income that is transferred in the period to the allowance for loan losses when interest is capitalized to a loan’s principal balance. (3) The Purchased Credit Impaired Loans’ losses are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as these loans are separately reserved for, if needed. No allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2017. The losses of the Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as the remaining purchased discount associated with the FFELP and Private Education Loans of $45 million and $405 million, respectively, as of September 30, 2017 is greater than the incurred losses and as a result no allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2017. (4) Ending total loans for Private Education Loans includes the receivable for partially charged-off loans. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Nine Months Ended September 30, 2018 (Dollars in millions) FFELP Loans Private Education Loans Other Loans Total Allowance for Loan Losses Beginning balance $ 60 $ 1,297 $ 10 $ 1,367 Total provision 60 224 — 284 Net adjustment resulting from the change in the charge-off rate (1) — (32 ) — (32 ) Net charge-offs remaining (2) (41 ) (269 ) — (310 ) Total net charge-offs (41 ) (301 ) — (342 ) Reclassification of interest reserve (3) — 6 — 6 Ending balance $ 79 $ 1,226 $ 10 $ 1,315 Allowance Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment - TDR $ — $ 1,134 $ 9 $ 1,143 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 79 92 1 172 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (4) — — — — Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (4) — — — — Ending total allowance $ 79 $ 1,226 $ 10 $ 1,315 Loans Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment - TDR $ — $ 10,497 $ 29 $ 10,526 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 70,778 11,459 49 82,286 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (4) 2,941 2,282 — 5,223 Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (4) — 231 — 231 Ending total loans (5) $ 73,719 $ 24,469 $ 78 $ 98,266 Net charge-offs as a percentage of average loans in repayment, excluding the net adjustment resulting from the change in the charge-off rate (1) .09 % 1.61 % — % Net adjustment resulting from the change in charge-off rate as a percentage of average loans in repayment (1) — % .19 % — % Allowance coverage of charge-offs 1.4 3.0 — Allowance as a percentage of the ending total loan balance .11 % 5.01 % 13.02 % Allowance as a percentage of the ending loans in repayment .13 % 5.57 % 13.02 % Ending total loans (5) $ 73,719 $ 24,469 $ 78 Average loans in repayment $ 63,934 $ 22,367 $ 74 Ending loans in repayment $ 60,959 $ 21,997 $ 78 (1) In third-quarter 2018, the portion of the loan amount charged off at default on Private Education Loans increased from 79 percent to 80.5 percent. This charge resulted in a $32 million reduction to the balance of the receivable for partially charged-off loan balance. (2) Charge-offs are reported net of expected recoveries. For Private Education Loans, the expected recovery amount is transferred to the receivable for partially charged-off loan balance. Charge-offs include charge-offs against the receivable for partially charged-off loans which represents the difference between what was expected to be recovered and any shortfalls in what was actually recovered in the period. See “Receivable for Partially Charged-Off Private Education Loans” for further discussion. (3) Represents the additional allowance related to the amount of uncollectible interest reserved within interest income that is transferred in the period to the allowance for loan losses when interest is capitalized to a loan’s principal balance. (4) The Purchased Credit Impaired Loans’ losses are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as these loans are separately reserved for, if needed. No allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2018. The losses of the Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as the remaining purchased discount associated with the FFELP and Private Education Loans of $38 million and $343 million, respectively, as of September 30, 2018 is greater than the incurred losses and as a result no allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2018. (5) Ending total loans for Private Education Loans includes the receivable for partially charged-off loans. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Nine Months Ended September 30, 2017 (Dollars in millions) FFELP Loans Private Education Loans Other Loans Total Allowance for Loan Losses Beginning balance $ 67 $ 1,351 $ 15 $ 1,433 Total provision 30 285 2 317 Charge-offs (1) (36 ) (355 ) (5 ) (396 ) Reclassification of interest reserve (2) — 6 — 6 Ending balance $ 61 $ 1,287 $ 12 $ 1,360 Allowance Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment - TDR $ — $ 1,169 $ 10 $ 1,179 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 61 118 2 181 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (3) — — — — Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (3) — — — — Ending total allowance $ 61 $ 1,287 $ 12 $ 1,360 Loans Ending Balance: Individually evaluated for impairment - TDR $ — $ 10,961 $ 30 $ 10,991 Collectively evaluated for impairment: Excluding Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount and Purchased Credit Impaired Loans 79,923 11,790 34 91,747 Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount (3) 3,362 2,656 — 6,018 Purchased Credit Impaired Loans (3) — 258 — 258 Ending total loans (4) $ 83,285 $ 25,665 $ 64 $ 109,014 Charge-offs as a percentage of average loans in repayment .07 % 2.14 % 3.92 % Allowance coverage of charge-offs 1.3 2.7 1.7 Allowance as a percentage of the ending total loan balance .07 % 5.02 % 18.59 % Allowance as a percentage of the ending loans in repayment .09 % 5.73 % 18.59 % Ending total loans (4) $ 83,285 $ 25,665 $ 64 Average loans in repayment $ 68,791 $ 22,180 $ 186 Ending loans in repayment $ 66,220 $ 22,448 $ 64 (1) Charge-offs are reported net of expected recoveries. For Private Education Loans, the expected recovery amount is transferred to the receivable for partially charged-off loan balance. Charge-offs include charge-offs against the receivable for partially charged-off loans which represents the difference between what was expected to be recovered and any shortfalls in what was actually recovered in the period. See “Receivable for Partially Charged-Off Private Education Loans” for further discussion. (2) Represents the additional allowance related to the amount of uncollectible interest reserved within interest income that is transferred in the period to the allowance for loan losses when interest is capitalized to a loan’s principal balance. (3) The Purchased Credit Impaired Loans’ losses are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as these loans are separately reserved for, if needed. No allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2017. The losses of the Purchased Non-Credit Impaired Loans acquired at a discount are not provided for by the allowance for loan losses in the above table as the remaining purchased discount associated with the FFELP and Private Education Loans of $45 million and $405 million, respectively, as of September 30, 2017 is greater than the incurred losses and as a result no allowance for loan losses has been established for these loans as of September 30, 2017. (4) Ending total loans for Private Education Loans includes the receivable for partially charged-off loans. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Key Credit Quality Indicators FFELP Loans are substantially insured and guaranteed as to their principal and accrued interest in the event of default. The key credit quality indicator for this portfolio is loan status. The impact of changes in loan status is incorporated quarterly into the allowance for loan losses calculation. FFELP Loan Delinquencies September 30, 2018 December 31, 2017 (Dollars in millions) Balance % Balance % Loans in-school/grace/deferment (1) $ 4,160 $ 4,711 Loans in forbearance (2) 8,600 8,533 Loans in repayment and percentage of each status: Loans current 54,005 88.6 % 59,264 87.3 % Loans delinquent 31-60 days (3) 1,978 3.2 2,638 3.9 Loans delinquent 61-90 days (3) 947 1.6 1,763 2.6 Loans delinquent greater than 90 days (3) 4,029 6.6 4,188 6.2 Total FFELP Loans in repayment 60,959 100 % 67,853 100 % Total FFELP Loans, gross 73,719 81,097 FFELP Loan unamortized premium 617 666 Total FFELP Loans 74,336 81,763 FFELP Loan allowance for losses (79 ) (60 ) FFELP Loans, net $ 74,257 $ 81,703 Percentage of FFELP Loans in repayment 82.7 % 83.7 % Delinquencies as a percentage of FFELP Loans in repayment 11.4 % 12.7 % FFELP Loans in forbearance as a percentage of loans in repayment and forbearance 12.4 % 11.2 % (1) Loans for customers who may still be attending school or engaging in other permitted educational activities and are not yet required to make payments on their loans, e.g., residency periods for medical students or a grace period for bar exam preparation, as well as loans for customers who have requested and qualify for other permitted program deferments such as military, unemployment, or economic hardships. (2) Loans for customers who have used their allowable deferment time or do not qualify for deferment, that need additional time to obtain employment or who have temporarily ceased making full payments due to hardship or other factors such as disaster relief. (3) The period of delinquency is based on the number of days scheduled payments are contractually past due. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) For Private Education Loans, the key credit quality indicators are FICO scores, school type, the existence of a cosigner, the loan status and loan seasoning. The FICO scores and school type are assessed at origination. The other Private Education Loan key quality indicators can change and are incorporated quarterly into the allowance for loan losses calculation. The following table highlights the principal balance (excluding the receivable for partially charged-off loans) of our Private Education Loan portfolio stratified by the key credit quality indicators. Private Education Loan Credit Quality Indicators TDRs September 30, 2018 December 31, 2017 (Dollars in millions) Balance (2) % of Balance Balance (2) % of Balance Credit Quality Indicators Original Winning FICO Scores: FICO 640 and above $ 9,283 92 % $ 9,647 92 % FICO below 640 848 8 889 8 Total $ 10,131 100 % $ 10,536 100 % School Type: Not-for-profit $ 7,997 79 % $ 8,247 78 % For-profit 2,134 21 2,289 22 Total $ 10,131 100 % $ 10,536 100 % Cosigners: With cosigner $ 6,258 62 % $ 6,441 61 % Without cosigner 3,873 38 4,095 39 Total $ 10,131 100 % $ 10,536 100 % Seasoning (1) 1-12 payments $ 365 4 % $ 506 5 % 13-24 payments 491 5 644 6 25-36 payments 723 7 947 9 37-48 payments 1,026 10 1,271 12 More than 48 payments 7,071 70 6,691 63 Not yet in repayment 455 4 477 5 Total $ 10,131 100 % $ 10,536 100 % (1) Number of months in active repayment for which a scheduled payment was received. (2) Balance equals the gross Private Education Loans. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Private Education Loan Credit Quality Indicators Non-TDRs September 30, 2018 December 31, 2017 (Dollars in millions) Balance (2) % of Balance Balance (2) % of Balance Credit Quality Indicators Original Winning FICO Scores: FICO 640 and above $ 13,142 96 % $ 13,752 96 % FICO below 640 508 4 592 4 Total $ 13,650 100 % $ 14,344 100 % School Type: Not-for-profit $ 11,499 84 % $ 12,431 87 % For-profit 2,151 16 1,913 13 Total $ 13,650 100 % $ 14,344 100 % Cosigners: With cosigner $ 7,453 55 % $ 9,193 64 % Without cosigner 6,197 45 5,151 36 Total $ 13,650 100 % $ 14,344 100 % Seasoning (1) 1-12 payments $ 2,553 19 % $ 1,424 10 % 13-24 payments 758 6 437 3 25-36 payments 334 2 466 3 37-48 payments 450 3 867 6 More than 48 payments 9,118 67 10,566 74 Not yet in repayment 437 3 584 4 Total $ 13,650 100 % $ 14,344 100 % (1) Number of months in active repayment for which a scheduled payment was received. (2) Balance equals the gross Private Education Loans. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Private Education Loan Delinquencies TDRs September 30, 2018 December 31, 2017 (Dollars in millions) Balance % Balance % Loans in-school/grace/deferment (1) $ 455 $ 477 Loans in forbearance (2) 707 681 Loans in repayment and percentage of each status: Loans current 7,767 86.6 % 8,333 88.9 % Loans delinquent 31-60 days (3) 385 4.3 351 3.7 Loans delinquent 61-90 days (3) 250 2.8 207 2.2 Loans delinquent greater than 90 days (3) 567 6.3 487 5.2 Total TDR loans in repayment 8,969 100 % 9,378 100 % Total TDR loans, gross 10,131 10,536 TDR loans unamortized discount (213 ) (225 ) Total TDR loans 9,918 10,311 TDR loans receivable for partially charged-off loans 366 385 TDR loans allowance for losses (1,134 ) (1,171 ) TDR loans, net $ 9,150 $ 9,525 Percentage of TDR loans in repayment 88.5 % 89.0 % Delinquencies as a percentage of TDR loans in repayment 13.4 % 11.1 % Loans in forbearance as a percentage of TDR loans in repayment and forbearance 7.3 % 6.8 % (1) Deferment includes customers who have returned to school or are engaged in other permitted educational activities and are not yet required to make payments on their loans, e.g., residency periods for medical students or a grace period for bar exam preparation. (2) Loans for customers who have requested extension of grace period generally during employment transition or who have temporarily ceased making full payments due to hardship or other factors such as disaster relief, consistent with established loan program servicing policies and procedures. (3) The period of delinquency is based on the number of days scheduled payments are contractually past due. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Private Education Loan Delinquencies Non-TDRs September 30, 2018 December 31, 2017 (Dollars in millions) Balance % Balance % Loans in-school/grace/deferment (1) $ 437 $ 584 Loans in forbearance (2) 185 214 Loans in repayment and percentage of each status: Loans current 12,838 98.6 % 13,257 97.9 % Loans delinquent 31-60 days (3) 82 .6 120 .9 Loans delinquent 61-90 days (3) 39 .3 59 .4 Loans delinquent greater than 90 days (3) 69 .5 110 .8 Total non-TDR loans in repayment 13,028 100 % 13,546 100 % Total non-TDR loans, gross 13,650 14,344 Non-TDR loans unamortized discount (583 ) (699 ) Total non-TDR loans 13,067 13,645 Non-TDR loans receivable for partially charged-off loans 322 375 Non-TDR loans allowance for losses (92 ) (126 ) Non-TDR loans, net $ 13,297 $ 13,894 Percentage of non-TDR loans in repayment 95.4 % 94.4 % Delinquencies as a percentage of non-TDR loans in repayment 1.4 % 2.1 % Loans in forbearance as a percentage of non- TDR loans in repayment and forbearance 1.4 % 1.6 % (1) Deferment includes customers who have returned to school or are engaged in other permitted educational activities and are not yet required to make payments on their loans, e.g., residency periods for medical students or a grace period for bar exam preparation. (2) Loans for customers who have requested extension of grace period generally during employment transition or who have temporarily ceased making full payments due to hardship or other factors such as disaster relief, consistent with established loan program servicing policies and procedures. (3) The period of delinquency is based on the number of days scheduled payments are contractually past due. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Receivable for Partially Charged-Off Private Education Loans At the end of each month, for loans that are 212 or more days past due, we charge off the estimated loss of a defaulted loan balance. We refer to the remaining loan balance as the “receivable for partially charged-off loans.” Actual recoveries are applied against this receivable balance. If actual periodic recoveries are less than expected, the difference is immediately charged off through the allowance for Private Education Loan losses. The following table summarizes the activity in the receivable for partially charged-off Private Education Loans. Three Months Ended September 30, Nine Months Ended September 30, (Dollars in millions) 2018 2017 2018 2017 Receivable at beginning of period $ 724 $ 784 $ 760 $ 815 Expected future recoveries of current period defaults (1) 29 24 68 88 Recoveries (2) (33 ) (37 ) (107 ) (121 ) Charge-offs (3) (32 ) — (33 ) (11 ) Receivable at end of period $ 688 $ 771 $ 688 $ 771 (1) Represents our estimate of the amount to be collected in the future. (2) Current period cash collections. (3) Represents the current period recovery shortfall — the difference between what was expected to be collected and what was actually collected. Additionally, in third-quarter 2018, the portion of the loan amount charged off at default increased from 79 percent to 80.5 percent. This change resulted in a $32 million reduction to the balance of the receivable for partially charged-off loans. These amounts are included in total charge-offs as reported in the “Allowance for Private Education Loan Losses” table. Troubled Debt Restructurings (“TDRs”) We sometimes modify the terms of loans for customers experiencing financial difficulty. Where we have granted either a forbearance of greater than three months, an interest rate reduction or an extended repayment plan, these are classified as TDRs. Approximately 64 percent and 61 percent of the loans granted forbearance have qualified as a TDR loan at September 30, 2018 and December 31, 2017, respectively. The unpaid principal balance of TDR loans that were in an interest rate reduction program as of September 30, 2018 and December 31, 2017 was $2.0 billion and $2.7 billion, respectively. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) At September 30, 2018 and December 31, 2017, all of our TDR loans had a related allowance recorded. The following table provides the recorded investment, unpaid principal balance and related allowance for our TDR loans. TDRs (Dollars in millions) September 30, 2018 December 31, 2017 Recorded investment (1) $ 10,482 $ 10,890 Total ending loans (2) $ 10,497 $ 10,921 Related allowance $ 1,134 $ 1,171 (1) Recorded investment is equal to the unpaid principal balance (which includes the receivable for partially charged-off loans), accrued interest and unamortized discount. (2) Total ending loans includes the receivable for partially charged-off loans. The following tables provide the average recorded investment and interest income recognized for our TDR loans. Three Months Ended September 30, Nine Months Ended September 30, (Dollars in millions) 2018 2017 2018 2017 Average recorded investment $ 10,568 $ 10,944 $ 10,717 $ 11,016 Interest income recognized $ 196 $ 180 $ 563 $ 528 The following table provides the amount of loans modified in the periods presented that resulted in a TDR. Additionally, the table summarizes charge-offs occurring in the TDR portfolio, as well as TDRs for which a payment default occurred in the current period within 12 months of the loan first being designated as a TDR. We define payment default as 60 days past due for this disclosure. Three Months Ended September 30, Nine Months Ended September 30, (Dollars in millions) 2018 2017 2018 2017 Modified loans (1) $ 163 $ 200 $ 470 $ 618 Charge-offs (2) $ 123 $ 80 $ 243 $ 280 Payment default $ 35 $ 43 $ 105 $ 144 (1) Represents period ending balance of loans that have been modified during the period and resulted in a TDR. (2) Represents loans that charged off that were classified as TDRs. 2. Allowance for Loan Losses (Continued) Accrued Interest Receivable The following table provides information regarding accrued interest receivable on our Private Education Loans. (Dollars in millions) Total Greater Than 90 Days Past Due Allowance for Uncollectible Interest September 30, 2018 TDR $ 198 $ 28 $ 19 Non-TDR 160 4 8 Total $ 358 $ 32 $ 27 December 31, 2017 TDR $ 196 $ 20 $ 20 Non-TDR 187 4 6 Total $ 383 $ 24 $ 26 |