Exhibit 99.3
PRO FORMA VALUATION UPDATE REPORT
SECOND STEP CONVERSION
Kearny Financial Corp.| Fairfield, New Jersey
PROPOSED HOLDING COMPANY FOR:
Kearny Federal Savings Bank | Fairfield, New Jersey
Dated as of January 16, 2015

1100 North Glebe Road Suite 600
Arlington, Virginia 22201
703.528.1700
rpfinancial.com

January 16, 2015
Boards of Directors
Kearny MHC
Kearny Financial Corp.
Kearny Federal Savings Bank
120 Passaic Avenue
Fairfield, New Jersey 07004
Members of the Boards of Directors:
We have completed and hereby provide an updated appraisal of the estimated pro forma market value of the common stock which is to be issued in connection with the mutual-to-stock conversion described below.
This Appraisal is furnished pursuant to the requirements stipulated in the Code of Federal Regulations and has been prepared in accordance with the “Guidelines for Appraisal Reports for the Valuation of Savings and Loan Associations Converting from Mutual to Stock Form of Organization” of the Office of Thrift Supervision (“OTS”) and accepted by the Federal Reserve Board (“FRB”) and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”), and applicable regulatory interpretations thereof. Our original appraisal report, dated August 8, 2014 (the “Original Appraisal”), which was filed in conjunction with the Application for Conversion that was subsequent withdrawn, is incorporated herein by reference as confirmed by the FRB. As in the preparation of our Original Appraisal, we believe the data and information used herein is reliable; however, we cannot guarantee the accuracy and completeness of such information.
On September 4, 2014, the respective Boards of Directors of Kearny MHC (the “MHC”) and Kearny Financial Corp. (“KRNY”) adopted the plan of conversion and reorganization (the “Plan of Conversion”) whereby the MHC will convert to stock form. As a result of the conversion, KRNY, which currently owns all of the issued and outstanding common stock of the Kearny Federal Savings Bank (the “Bank”), will be succeed by a Maryland corporation with the name of Kearny Financial Corp. (“Kearny Financial” or the “Company”). Following the conversion, the MHC will no longer exist. For purposes of this document, the existing consolidated entity will hereinafter also be referred to as Kearny Financial or the Company, unless otherwise identified as KRNY. As of December 31, 2014, the MHC had a majority ownership interest in, and its principal asset consisted of, approximately 77.12% of the common stock (the “MHC Shares”) of KRNY. The remaining 22.88% of KRNY’s common stock is owned by public stockholders.
It is our understanding that Kearny Financial will offer its stock, representing the majority ownership interest held by the MHC, in a subscription offering to Eligible Account Holders, Tax-Qualified Plans including the Bank’s employee savings and stock ownership plan (the “ESOP”), Supplemental Eligible Account Holders and Other Members, as such terms are defined for purposes of applicable federal regulatory requirements governing mutual-to-stock conversions. To the extent that shares remain available for purchase after satisfaction of all subscriptions received in the subscription offering, the shares may offered for sale to the public at large in a
| | |
| |
Washington Headquarters | | |
Three Ballston Plaza 1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 600 Arlington, VA 22201 www.rpfinancial.com | | Telephone: (703) 528-1700 Fax No.: (703) 528-1788 Toll-Free No.: (866) 723-0594 E-Mail: mail@rpfinancial.com |
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 2
community offering and a syndicated or firm commitment underwritten offering. Upon completing the mutual-to-stock conversion and stock offering (the “second-step conversion”), the Company will be 100% owned by public shareholders, the publicly-held shares of KRNY will be exchanged for shares in the Company at a ratio that retains their ownership interest at the time the conversion is completed and the MHC assets will be consolidated with the Company.
In connection with the second-step conversion, the Company will contribute $5 million of Kearny Financial common stock and $5 million of cash to Kearny Federal Savings Foundation (the “Foundation”).
This updated appraisal reflects the following noteworthy items: (1) a review of recent developments in Kearny Financial’s financial condition, including financial data through December 31, 2014; (2) an updated comparison of Kearny Financials financial condition and operating results versus the Peer Group companies identified in the Original Appraisal; and (3) a review of stock market conditions since the date of the Original Appraisal.
The estimated pro forma market value is defined as the price at which Kearny Financial’s common stock, immediately upon completion of the second-step offering, would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or sell and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts.
Our valuation is not intended, and must not be construed, as a recommendation of any kind as to the advisability of purchasing shares of the common stock. Moreover, because such valuation is necessarily based upon estimates and projections of a number of matters, all of which are subject to change from time to time, no assurance can be given that persons who purchase shares of common stock in the conversion will thereafter be able to buy or sell such shares at prices related to the foregoing valuation of the pro forma market value thereof. RP Financial is not a seller of securities within the meaning of any federal and state securities laws and any report prepared by RP Financial shall not be used as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any securities. RP Financial maintains a policy which prohibits the company, its principals or employees from purchasing stock of its client institutions.
Discussion of Relevant Considerations
Table 1 presents summary balance sheet and income statement details for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 and updated financial information through December 31, 2014. Kearny Financial’s assets increased by $37.9 million or 1.1% from June 30, 2014 to December 31, 2014, which was largely related to loan growth partially offset by decreases in cash and total investment securities during the six month period. Overall, cash and investments (inclusive of FHLB stock) decreased from $1.518 billion or 43.25% of assets at June 30, 2014 to $1.478 billion or 41.67% of assets at December 31, 2014. Loans receivable increased from $1.729 billion or 49.26% of assets at June 30, 2014 to $1.801 billion or 50.78% of assets at December 31, 2014. The balances for bank-owned life insurance (“BOLI”) and goodwill and other intangible assets were respectively slightly higher and lower at December 31, 2014 compared to June 30, 2014.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 3
Table 1
Kearny Financial Corp.
Recent Financial Data
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | At June 30, 2014 | | | At Dec. 31, 2014 | |
| | Amount | | | Assets | | | Amount | | | Assets | |
| | ($000) | | | (%) | | | ($000) | | | (%) | |
Balance Sheet Data | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Total assets | | $ | 3,510,009 | | | | 100.00 | % | | $ | 3,547,869 | | | | 100.00 | % |
Cash, cash equivalents | | | 135,034 | | | | 3.85 | | | | 96,436 | | | | 2.72 | |
| | | | |
Securities available for sale | | | 407,898 | | | | 11.62 | | | | 420,458 | | | | 11.85 | |
Securities held to maturity | | | 216,414 | | | | 6.17 | | | | 219,906 | | | | 6.20 | |
MBS available for sale | | | 437,223 | | | | 12.46 | | | | 391,548 | | | | 11.04 | |
MBS held to maturity | | | 295,658 | | | | 8.42 | | | | 322,529 | | | | 9.09 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Total investment securities | | | 1,357,193 | | | | 38.67 | | | | 1,354,441 | | | | 38.18 | |
| | | | |
Loans receivable, net | | | 1,729,084 | | | | 49.26 | | | | 1,801,487 | | | | 50.78 | |
Bank-owned life insurance | | | 88,820 | | | | 2.53 | | | | 90,126 | | | | 2.54 | |
FHLB stock | | | 25,990 | | | | 0.74 | | | | 27,382 | | | | 0.77 | |
Goodwill/ Other intangible assets | | | 109,381 | | | | 3.12 | | | | 109,281 | | | | 3.08 | |
| | | | |
Deposits | | | 2,479,941 | | | | 70.65 | | | | 2,464,845 | | | | 69.47 | |
Borrowings | | | 512,257 | | | | 14.59 | | | | 563,002 | | | | 15.87 | |
Total equity | | | 494,676 | | | | 14.09 | | | | 493,234 | | | | 13.90 | |
Tangible equity | | | 385,295 | | | | 10.98 | | | | 383,953 | | | | 10.82 | |
| | |
| | 12 Months Ended June 30, 2014 | | | 12 Months Ended Dec. 31, 2014 | |
| | Amount | | | Avg. Assets | | | Amount | | | Avg. Assets | |
| | ($000) | | | (%) | | | ($000) | | | (%) | |
Summary Income Statement | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Interest income | | $ | 95,819 | | | | 2.92 | % | | $ | 100,196 | | | | 2.92 | % |
Interest expense | | | (21,998 | ) | | | (0.67 | ) | | | (23,948 | ) | | | (0.70 | ) |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Net interest income | | | 73,821 | | | | 2.25 | | | | 76,248 | | | | 2.22 | |
Provisions for loan losses | | | (3,381 | ) | | | (0.10 | ) | | | (4,244 | ) | | | (0.12 | ) |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Net interest income after prov. | | | 70,440 | | | | 2.15 | | | | 72,004 | | | | 2.10 | |
Non-interest operating income | | | 6,967 | | | | 0.21 | | | | 6,885 | | | | 0.20 | |
Gain on sale of loans | | | 80 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 36 | | | | 0.00 | |
Gain(loss) on sale securities | | | 1,517 | | | | 0.05 | | | | 1,298 | | | | 0.04 | |
Gain (loss) on sale of REO | | | (441 | ) | | | (0.01 | ) | | | (588 | ) | | | (0.02 | ) |
Merger related expenses | | | (391 | ) | | | (0.01 | ) | | | (391 | ) | | | (0.01 | ) |
Non-interest operating expense | | | (63,767 | ) | | | (1.94 | ) | | | (66,219 | ) | | | (1.93 | ) |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Income before income tax expense | | | 14,405 | | | | 0.44 | | | | 13,025 | | | | 0.38 | |
Income taxes | | | (4,217 | ) | | | (0.13 | ) | | | (3,318 | ) | | | (0.10 | ) |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Net income | | $ | 10,188 | | | | 0.31 | % | | $ | 9,707 | | | | 0.28 | % |
Sources: Kearny Financial’s prospectus, audited and unaudited financial statements, and RP Financial calculations.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 4
Updated credit quality measures showed the balance of non-performing assets remained stable during the six month period ended December 31, 2014, with non-performing assets totaling $26.9 million at June 30. 2014 and at December 31, 2014. Non-performing assets equaled 0.76% of assets at December 31, 2014. As of December 31, 2014, non-performing assets consisted of $25.0 million of non-accruing loans and $1.9 million of real estate owned.
The Company’s interest-bearing funding composition showed a slight decrease in deposits and a slight increase in borrowings during the six month period ended December 31, 2014. Deposits decreased from $2.480 billion or 70.65% of assets at June 30, 2014 to $2.465 billion or 69.47% of assets at December 31, 2014. Borrowings increased from $512.3 million or 14.59% of assets at June 30, 2014 to $563.0 million or 15.87% of assets at December 31, 2014. The increase in borrowings was due to a $54.9 million increase in FHLB advances partially offset by a $4.2 million net decline in outstanding overnight “sweep account” balances linked to customer demand deposits.
Kearny Financial’s equity decreased from $494.7 million or 14.09% of assets at June 30, 2014 to $493.2 million or 13.90% of assets at December 31, 2014 and tangible equity decreased from $385.3 million or 10.98% of assets at June 30, 2014 to $384.0 million or 10.82% of assets at December 31, 2014. Most of the reduction in equity was related to the exercise of the remaining vested and outstanding options granted under the Company’s 2005 Stock Compensation Plan and Incentive Plan, which resulted in a $7.2 million reduction in equity. The decrease in stockholders’ equity also reflected an increase in accumulated other comprehensive loss. Largely offsetting the reduction in equity during the six month period was net income of $5.1 million and, a reduction of unearned ESOP shares for plan shares earned during the period and a net decrease in Treasury stock resulting from the re-issuance of 107,382 shares at an average cost of $11.48 per share resulting from the exercise of stock options during the quarter.
Kearny Financial’s operating results for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 and December 31, 2014 are also set forth in Table 1. The Company’s reported earnings decreased from $10.2 million or 0.31% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 to $9.7 million or 0.28% of average assets for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014. The decrease in net income was primarily due to increases in loan loss provisions and operating expenses, which were somewhat offset by an increase in net interest income.
Kearny Financial’s net interest income increased from $73.8 million or 2.25% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 to $76.2 million or 2.22% of average assets for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014. The increase in net interest income was due to a more significant increase in interest income compared to interest expense, in which the increase in interest income was related to an increase in the average balance of interest-earning assets as the yield on interest-earning assets declined by two basis points during the six months ended December 31, 2014 compared to the year ago six month period. The increase in interest expense was due to an increase in the average balance of interest-bearing liabilities, as well as a six basis point increase in the cost of interest-bearing liabilities during the six month period ended December 31, 2014 compared to the year ago six month period. Accordingly, notwithstanding the increase in net interest income during the most recent twelve month period, Kearny Financial’s interest rate spread decreased from 2.35% during six month period ended December 31, 2013 to 2.27% during the six month period ended December 31, 2014.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 5
Operating expenses increased from $63.8 million or 1.94% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 to $66.2 million or 1.93% of average assets during the twelve months ended December 31, 2014. Most of the increase in operating expenses was related an increase in salaries and employee benefit expense, which included increased compensation costs resulting from the acquisition of Atlas Bank on June 30, 2014. Overall, Kearny Financial’s updated ratios for net interest income and operating expenses provided for a fairly stable expense coverage ratio (net interest income divided by operating expenses), as Kearny Financial’s expense coverage ratios equaled 1.16x for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 and 1.15x for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014.
Non-interest operating income (inclusive of gain on sale of loans) was slightly lower during the most recent twelve month period, decreasing from $7.1 million or 0.21% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 to $6.9 million or 0.20% of average assets for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014. Overall, when factoring non-interest operating income into core earnings, the Company’s updated efficiency ratio of 79.75% (operating expenses, as a percent of net interest income and non-interest operating income) was slightly less favorable compared to the 78.86% efficiency ratio recorded for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014.
The Company’s updated earnings showed a slight decrease in non-operating income, which was due to a decrease in gains on sale of securities and a slightly higher loss on the sale of real estate owned. Non-operating merger related expenses reflected no change in the Company’s updated earnings. Overall, non-operating income decreased from $685,000 or 0.03% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 to $319,000 or 0.01% of average assets for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014.
Slightly higher loan loss provisions were established in the most recent twelve period, increasing from $3.4 million or 0.10% of average assets for the twelve months ended June 30, 2014 to $4.2 million or 0.12% of average assets for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014. The increase in loan loss provisions during the most recent twelve month period was largely related to loan growth, including growth of commercial rea estate loans and commercial business loans, and an increase in specific losses recognized on non-performing loans individually reviewed for impairment. As of December 31, 2014, the Company maintained an allowance for loan losses of $12.9 million equal to 50.37% of non-performing loans.
| 2. | Peer Group Financial Comparisons |
Tables 2 and 3 present the financial characteristics and operating results for Kearny Financial, the Peer Group and all publicly-traded thrifts. The Company’s and the Peer Group’s ratios are based on financial results through December 31, 2014 and September 30, 2014, respectively.
In general, the comparative balance sheet ratios for the Company and the Peer Group did not vary significantly from the ratios exhibited in the Original Appraisal. Consistent with the Original Appraisal, the Company’s updated interest-earning asset composition reflected
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 6
Table 2
Balance Sheet Composition and Growth Rates
Comparable Institution Analysis
As of September 30, 2014
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Balance Sheet as a Percent of Assets | | | Balance Sheet Annual Growth Rates | | | Regulatory Capital | |
| | | | | | Cash & Equivalents | | | MBS & Invest | | | BOLI | | | Net Loans (1) | | | Deposits | | | Borrowed Funds | | | Sub. Debt | | | Total Equity | | | Goodwill & Intang | | | Tangible Equity | | | Assets | | | MBS, Cash & Investments | | | Loans | | | Deposits | | | Borrows. & Subdebt | | | Total Equity | | | Tangible Equity | | | Tier 1 Leverage | | | Tier 1 Risk- Based | | | Risk- Based Capital | |
Kearny Financial Corp. of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
December 31, 2014 | | | | | | | 2.72 | % | | | 38.95 | % | | | 2.54 | % | | | 50.78 | % | | | 69.47 | % | | | 15.87 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 13.90 | % | | | 3.08 | % | | | 10.82 | % | | | 8.87 | % | | | 2.06 | % | | | 16.73 | % | | | 3.67 | % | | | 41.86 | % | | | 6.18 | % | | | 8.01 | % | | | 10.51 | % | | | 19.07 | % | | | 19.73 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
All Public Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 4.81 | % | | | 20.03 | % | | | 1.84 | % | | | 69.24 | % | | | 73.55 | % | | | 11.16 | % | | | 0.40 | % | | | 13.67 | % | | | 0.72 | % | | | 12.96 | % | | | 8.62 | % | | | -0.75 | % | | | 12.99 | % | | | 7.08 | % | | | 21.69 | % | | | 19.61 | % | | | 19.27 | % | | | 12.72 | % | | | 20.18 | % | | | 21.26 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 3.45 | % | | | 17.14 | % | | | 1.83 | % | | | 71.25 | % | | | 74.83 | % | | | 9.40 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 12.84 | % | | | 0.02 | % | | | 11.71 | % | | | 4.33 | % | | | -3.28 | % | | | 8.78 | % | | | 2.27 | % | | | 4.58 | % | | | 2.98 | % | | | 3.44 | % | | | 12.02 | % | | | 17.50 | % | | | 18.58 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
State of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 2.94 | % | | | 21.99 | % | | | 2.47 | % | | | 68.37 | % | | | 68.81 | % | | | 14.78 | % | | | 0.17 | % | | | 15.19 | % | | | 1.05 | % | | | 14.14 | % | | | 7.78 | % | | | 0.83 | % | | | 12.33 | % | | | 4.80 | % | | | 16.20 | % | | | 28.47 | % | | | 31.41 | % | | | 12.37 | % | | | 17.07 | % | | | 18.10 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 2.29 | % | | | 19.47 | % | | | 2.28 | % | | | 70.82 | % | | | 69.36 | % | | | 12.21 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 13.41 | % | | | 0.50 | % | | | 10.83 | % | | | 7.24 | % | | | -1.07 | % | | | 11.29 | % | | | 0.70 | % | | | 17.54 | % | | | 2.28 | % | | | 2.98 | % | | | 10.07 | % | | | 15.87 | % | | | 17.09 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Recent Conversions(2) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BNCL | | Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 5.74 | % | | | 33.90 | % | | | 0.95 | % | | | 52.35 | % | | | 79.21 | % | | | 5.08 | % | | | 0.57 | % | | | 13.84 | % | | | 2.92 | % | | | 10.93 | % | | | -5.87 | % | | | -12.83 | % | | | -0.42 | % | | | -6.21 | % | | | -9.07 | % | | | -1.40 | % | | | -1.39 | % | | | 10.76 | % | | | 20.97 | % | | | 22.24 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 4.10 | % | | | 18.73 | % | | | 1.93 | % | | | 71.40 | % | | | 67.04 | % | | | 18.01 | % | | | 0.64 | % | | | 12.97 | % | | | 1.14 | % | | | 11.84 | % | | | 18.36 | % | | | 9.46 | % | | | 22.66 | % | | | 16.17 | % | | | 37.55 | % | | | 14.25 | % | | | 10.24 | % | | | 11.36 | % | | | 18.61 | % | | | 19.59 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 1.60 | % | | | 19.47 | % | | | 2.09 | % | | | 70.12 | % | | | 72.44 | % | | | 14.43 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 12.52 | % | | | 0.57 | % | | | 9.93 | % | | | 7.39 | % | | | -7.42 | % | | | 10.85 | % | | | 1.20 | % | | | 26.69 | % | | | 4.35 | % | | | 4.41 | % | | | 10.84 | % | | | 17.05 | % | | | 18.30 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BKMU | | Bank Mutual Corporation | | WI | | | 1.47 | % | | | 22.17 | % | | | 2.63 | % | | | 68.84 | % | | | 72.44 | % | | | 11.99 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 12.52 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 12.51 | % | | | -0.27 | % | | | -21.57 | % | | | 10.85 | % | | | -4.70 | % | | | 35.96 | % | | | 4.35 | % | | | 4.41 | % | | | 11.39 | % | | | 17.01 | % | | | 18.26 | % |
CFFN | | Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. | | KS | | | 8.22 | % | | | 26.42 | % | | | 0.62 | % | | | 63.18 | % | | | 47.19 | % | | | 36.39 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 15.13 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 15.13 | % | | | 7.39 | % | | | 12.77 | % | | | 4.59 | % | | | 0.95 | % | | | 26.69 | % | | | -8.53 | % | | | -8.53 | % | | | 13.16 | % | | | 32.96 | % | | | 33.20 | % |
DCOM | | Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. | | NY | | | 1.35 | % | | | 2.31 | % | | | 1.30 | % | | | 92.04 | % | | | 59.82 | % | | | 25.16 | % | | | 1.61 | % | | | 10.41 | % | | | 1.27 | % | | | 9.14 | % | | | 9.19 | % | | | -7.42 | % | | | 10.61 | % | | | 0.52 | % | | | 39.22 | % | | | 7.91 | % | | | 9.11 | % | | | 9.35 | % | | | NA | | | | NA | |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 2.29 | % | | | 28.73 | % | | | 4.38 | % | | | 61.38 | % | | | 51.65 | % | | | 26.26 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 21.12 | % | | | 0.57 | % | | | 20.55 | % | | | 7.24 | % | | | -20.36 | % | | | 30.60 | % | | | 1.20 | % | | | 56.04 | % | | | -13.74 | % | | | -14.02 | % | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
NWBI | | Northwest Bancshares, Inc. | | PA | | | 3.75 | % | | | 13.91 | % | | | 1.83 | % | | | 75.19 | % | | | 72.92 | % | | | 11.22 | % | | | 1.32 | % | | | 13.76 | % | | | 2.29 | % | | | 11.46 | % | | | -1.03 | % | | | -17.78 | % | | | 4.07 | % | | | -0.31 | % | | | 1.38 | % | | | -5.43 | % | | | -6.69 | % | | | 12.79 | % | | | 19.03 | % | | | 20.29 | % |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 1.20 | % | | | 22.66 | % | | | 2.41 | % | | | 70.82 | % | | | 77.15 | % | | | 11.55 | % | | | 1.19 | % | | | 9.47 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 9.47 | % | | | 0.98 | % | | | -14.36 | % | | | 7.22 | % | | | 0.70 | % | | | 2.69 | % | | | 2.28 | % | | | 2.28 | % | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 0.58 | % | | | 14.54 | % | | | 2.13 | % | | | 80.17 | % | | | 52.18 | % | | | 29.78 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 16.16 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 16.16 | % | | | 13.93 | % | | | 24.39 | % | | | 12.87 | % | | | 17.83 | % | | | 17.54 | % | | | -1.29 | % | | | -1.29 | % | | | 16.30 | % | | | 18.70 | % | | | 19.90 | % |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 1.05 | % | | | 19.47 | % | | | 2.09 | % | | | 70.12 | % | | | 68.04 | % | | | 17.71 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 13.41 | % | | | 4.80 | % | | | 8.61 | % | | | 14.68 | % | | | 4.74 | % | | | 17.66 | % | | | 8.99 | % | | | 46.69 | % | | | 13.28 | % | | | 13.10 | % | | | 9.05 | % | | | 12.04 | % | | | 13.10 | % |
TRST | | TrustCo Bank Corp NY | | NY | | | 13.76 | % | | | 17.59 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 66.27 | % | | | 86.97 | % | | | 3.93 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 8.50 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 8.49 | % | | | 2.76 | % | | | -8.25 | % | | | 8.94 | % | | | 2.33 | % | | | -2.84 | % | | | 9.90 | % | | | 9.92 | % | | | 8.56 | % | | | 17.05 | % | | | 18.30 | % |
UBNK | | United Financial Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 1.60 | % | | | 19.93 | % | | | 2.29 | % | | | 71.11 | % | | | 75.82 | % | | | 9.64 | % | | | 1.56 | % | | | 12.26 | % | | | 2.33 | % | | | 9.93 | % | | | 139.46 | % | | | 151.80 | % | | | 130.39 | % | | | 138.11 | % | | | 203.13 | % | | | 120.67 | % | | | 79.33 | % | | | 10.28 | % | | | 13.48 | % | | | 14.08 | % |
WSFS | | WSFS Financial Corporation | | DE | | | 9.85 | % | | | 18.26 | % | | | 1.59 | % | | | 66.23 | % | | | 73.27 | % | | | 14.43 | % | | | 1.40 | % | | | 9.96 | % | | | 1.22 | % | | | 8.74 | % | | | 7.65 | % | | | 0.09 | % | | | 11.44 | % | | | 12.27 | % | | | -13.42 | % | | | 27.38 | % | | | 25.04 | % | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
(1) | Includes loans held for sale. |
(2) | Ratios are based on the date of the most recent financial statements disclosed in the offering prospectus. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Copyright (c) 2015 by RP® Financial, LC.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 7
Table 3
Income as Percent of Average Assets and Yields, Costs, Spreads
Comparable Institution Analysis
For the 12 Months Ended September 30, 2014
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | Net Interest Income | | | | | | Non- Interest Income | | | | | | Non-Op. Items | | | | | | Yields, Costs, and Spreads | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Net Income | | | Income | | | Expense | | | NII | | | Loss Provis. on IEA | | | NII After Provis. | | | Gain on Sale of Loans | | | Other Non-Int Income | | | Total Non-Int Expense | | | Net Gains/ Losses (1) | | | Extrao. Items | | | Provision for Taxes | | | Yield On IEA | | | Cost Of IBL | | | Yld-Cost Spread | | | MEMO: Assets/ FTE Emp. | | | MEMO: Effective Tax Rate | |
| | | | | | (%) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Kearny Financial Corp. of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
December 31, 2014 | | | | | | | 0.28 | % | | | 2.92 | % | | | 0.70 | % | | | 2.22 | % | | | 0.12 | % | | | 2.10 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.20 | % | | | 1.93 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.10 | % | | | 3.16 | % | | | 0.88 | % | | | 2.28 | % | | $ | 7,780 | | | | 25.47 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
All Public Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 0.64 | % | | | 3.63 | % | | | 0.62 | % | | | 3.00 | % | | | 0.09 | % | | | 2.92 | % | | | 0.24 | % | | | 0.59 | % | | | 2.97 | % | | | -0.02 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.14 | % | | | 3.89 | % | | | 0.79 | % | | | 3.11 | % | | $ | 5,986 | | | | 27.74 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 0.60 | % | | | 3.58 | % | | | 0.61 | % | | | 3.02 | % | | | 0.07 | % | | | 2.92 | % | | | 0.04 | % | | | 0.44 | % | | | 2.83 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.26 | % | | | 3.84 | % | | | 0.81 | % | | | 3.13 | % | | $ | 5,095 | | | | 31.58 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
State of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 0.62 | % | | | 3.51 | % | | | 0.65 | % | | | 2.86 | % | | | 0.12 | % | | | 2.74 | % | | | 0.02 | % | | | 0.32 | % | | | 2.08 | % | | | -0.04 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.33 | % | | | 3.81 | % | | | 0.82 | % | | | 3.05 | % | | $ | 8,767 | | | | 33.64 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 0.60 | % | | | 3.47 | % | | | 0.69 | % | | | 2.96 | % | | | 0.09 | % | | | 2.76 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.23 | % | | | 2.03 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.38 | % | | | 3.82 | % | | | 0.86 | % | | | 3.16 | % | | $ | 7,913 | | | | 34.47 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Recent Conversions(2) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BNCL | | Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 0.29 | % | | | 3.12 | % | | | 0.52 | % | | | 2.60 | % | | | 0.10 | % | | | 2.50 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 0.48 | % | | | 2.63 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.07 | % | | | 3.37 | % | | | 0.66 | % | | | 2.71 | % | | $ | 5,560 | | | | 18.58 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 0.85 | % | | | 3.59 | % | | | 0.63 | % | | | 2.96 | % | | | 0.08 | % | | | 2.87 | % | | | 0.03 | % | | | 0.57 | % | | | 2.10 | % | | | -0.10 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.42 | % | | | 3.86 | % | | | 0.81 | % | | | 3.05 | % | | $ | 8,482 | | | | 30.65 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 0.82 | % | | | 3.47 | % | | | 0.51 | % | | | 3.09 | % | | | 0.07 | % | | | 2.97 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 0.42 | % | | | 2.03 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.39 | % | | | 3.82 | % | | | 0.68 | % | | | 3.19 | % | | $ | 7,395 | | | | 34.08 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BKMU | | Bank Mutual Corporation | | WI | | | 0.58 | % | | | 3.39 | % | | | 0.43 | % | | | 2.96 | % | | | 0.07 | % | | | 2.89 | % | | | 0.08 | % | | | 0.87 | % | | | 2.91 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.35 | % | | | 3.77 | % | | | 0.55 | % | | | 3.22 | % | | $ | 3,499 | | | | 37.90 | % |
CFFN | | Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. | | KS | | | 0.82 | % | | | 3.07 | % | | | 1.12 | % | | | 1.95 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 1.94 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.24 | % | | | 0.96 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.40 | % | | | 3.15 | % | | | 1.36 | % | | | 1.79 | % | | $ | 13,800 | | | | 32.53 | % |
DCOM | | Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. | | NY | | | 1.02 | % | | | 4.08 | % | | | 1.14 | % | | | 2.95 | % | | | -0.03 | % | | | 2.98 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.18 | % | | | 1.46 | % | | | 0.02 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.70 | % | | | 4.28 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 2.93 | % | | $ | 11,754 | | | | 40.84 | % |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 0.75 | % | | | 3.33 | % | | | 0.55 | % | | | 2.78 | % | | | 0.04 | % | | | 2.74 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.31 | % | | | 1.85 | % | | | -0.01 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.44 | % | | | 3.60 | % | | | 0.85 | % | | | 2.75 | % | | $ | 9,916 | | | | 36.98 | % |
NWBI | | Northwest Bancshares, Inc. | | PA | | | 0.82 | % | | | 3.85 | % | | | 0.73 | % | | | 3.12 | % | | | 0.26 | % | | | 2.87 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.86 | % | | | 2.71 | % | | | 0.12 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.31 | % | | | 4.23 | % | | | 0.95 | % | | | 3.28 | % | | $ | 3,850 | | | | 27.56 | % |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 0.74 | % | | | 3.48 | % | | | 0.31 | % | | | 3.16 | % | | | 0.09 | % | | | 3.08 | % | | | 0.04 | % | | | 0.73 | % | | | 2.54 | % | | | -0.18 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.39 | % | | | 3.63 | % | | | 0.38 | % | | | 3.25 | % | | $ | 6,420 | | | | 34.47 | % |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 1.35 | % | | | 4.25 | % | | | 1.06 | % | | | 3.20 | % | | | 0.02 | % | | | 3.18 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.19 | % | | | 1.32 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.70 | % | | | 4.49 | % | | | 1.30 | % | | | 3.19 | % | | $ | 16,169 | | | | 34.08 | % |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 0.90 | % | | | 3.47 | % | | | 0.51 | % | | | 2.96 | % | | | 0.07 | % | | | 2.90 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 0.49 | % | | | 2.03 | % | | | -0.09 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.38 | % | | | 3.82 | % | | | 0.68 | % | | | 3.14 | % | | $ | 8,427 | | | | 29.79 | % |
TRST | | TrustCo Bank Corp NY | | NY | | | 0.97 | % | | | 3.42 | % | | | 0.34 | % | | | 3.09 | % | | | 0.12 | % | | | 2.97 | % | | | 0.01 | % | | | 0.38 | % | | | 1.83 | % | | | 0.05 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.60 | % | | | 3.49 | % | | | 0.40 | % | | | 3.09 | % | | $ | 6,253 | | | | 38.13 | % |
UBNK | | United Financial Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 0.20 | % | | | 3.64 | % | | | 0.41 | % | | | 3.23 | % | | | 0.17 | % | | | 3.06 | % | | | 0.08 | % | | | 0.42 | % | | | 2.50 | % | | | -0.85 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 3.98 | % | | | 0.58 | % | | | 3.40 | % | | $ | 7,395 | | | | -0.18 | % |
WSFS | | WSFS Financial Corporation | | DE | | | 1.18 | % | | | 3.46 | % | | | 0.34 | % | | | 3.12 | % | | | 0.10 | % | | | 3.02 | % | | | 0.09 | % | | | 1.60 | % | | | 3.01 | % | | | -0.14 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.39 | % | | | 4.00 | % | | | 0.46 | % | | | 3.54 | % | | $ | 5,818 | | | | 25.02 | % |
(1) | Net gains/losses includes gain/loss on sale of securities and nonrecurring income and expense. |
(2) | Ratios are based on the date of the most recent financial statements disclosed in the offering prospectus. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Copyright (c) 2015 by RP® Financial, LC.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 8
a higher concentration of cash and investments and a lower concentration of loans. Overall, the Company’s and the Peer Group’s updated interest-earning assets-to-assets ratios equaled 92.45% and 94.23%, respectively.
Kearny Financial’s updated funding composition continued to show fairly similar concentrations of deposits and borrowings relatively to the comparable Peer Group ratios. Updated interest-bearing liabilities-to-assets ratios equaled 85.34% and 85.69% for the Company and the Peer Group, respectively. Kearny Financial’s updated tangible equity-to-assets ratio equaled 10.82%, which remained slightly below the comparable Peer Group ratio of 11.84%. Overall, Kearny Financial’s updated interest-earning assets-to-interest-bearing liabilities (“IEA/IBL”) ratio equaled 108.33%, which remained slightly below the comparable Peer Group ratio of 109.97%. As discussed in the Original Appraisal, the additional capital realized from stock proceeds should serve to increase Kearny Financial’s IEA/IBL ratio, as the level of interest-bearing liabilities funding assets will be lower due to the increase in capital realized from the offering and the net proceeds realized from the offering will be primarily deployed into interest-earning assets.
Updated growth rates for Kearny Financial and the Peer Group are based on annual growth rates for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014 and September 30, 2014, respectively. Kearny Financial recorded an 8.87% increase in assets, which was primarily attributable to a 16.73% increase in loans supplemented with a 2.06% increase in cash and investments. Comparatively, asset growth for the Peer Group equaled 18.36%, which continued to reflect acquisition growth involving the merger of United Financial Bancorp and Rockville Financial. The Peer Group’s asset growth was primarily attributable to a 22.66% increase in loans and was supplemented with a 9.46% increase in cash and investments.
On the funding side of the balance sheet, Kearny Financial’s asset growth was funded by deposit growth of 3.67% and a 41.86% increase in borrowings. Comparatively, asset growth for the Peer Group was funded by a 16.17% increase in deposits and a 37.55% increase in borrowings. Updated tangible net worth growth rates showed an increase of 8.01% for the Company and a 10.24% increase for the Peer Group. As noted in the Original Appraisal, the Company’s post-conversion capital growth rate will initially be constrained by maintenance of a higher pro forma capital position. Dividend payments and stock repurchases, pursuant to regulatory limitations and guidelines, could also potentially slow the Company’s capital growth rate in the longer term following the stock offering.
Table 3 displays comparative operating results for Kearny Financial and the Peer Group, based on the Company’s and the Peer Group’s earnings for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014 and September 30, 2014, respectively. Kearny Financial and the Peer Group reported net income to average assets ratios of 0.28% and 0.85%, respectively. Higher ratios for net interest income and non-interest operating income continued to represent earnings advantages for the Peer Group, which were partially offset by earnings advantages maintained by the Company with respect to a lower operating expense ratio, a higher level of net gains and a lower effective tax rate.
In terms of core earnings strength, updated expense coverage ratios posted by Kearny Financial and the Peer Group equaled 1.15x and 1.41x, respectively. The Peer Group’s higher expense coverage continued to be supported by a higher net interest income ratio, which
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 9
was partially offset by the Company’s lower operating expense ratio. The Peer Group’s higher net interest income ratio was primarily realized through maintenance of a higher interest income ratio and, to a lesser extent, a slightly lower interest expense ratio.
Non-interest operating income remained a larger contributor to the Peer Group’s earnings, as such income amounted to 0.20% and 0.60% of the Company’s and the Peer Group’s average assets, respectively. Accordingly, taking non-interest operating income into account in assessing Kearny Financial’s core earnings strength relative to the Peer Group’s, the Company’s updated efficiency ratio of 79.75% remained higher or less favorable than the Peer Group’s efficiency ratio of 58.99%.
Net gains and losses realized from the sale of assets and other non-operating items continued to have a slightly more favorable impact on the Company’s earnings, as the Company reported net non-operating gains equal to 0.01% of average assets and the Peer Group reported a net non-operating loss equal to 0.10% of average assets. As set forth in the Original Appraisal, typically such gains and losses are discounted in valuation analyses as they tend to have a relatively high degree of volatility, and, thus, are not considered part of core operations. Extraordinary items remained a non-factor in the Company’s and the Peer Group’s updated earnings.
Loan loss provisions remained a comparable factor for the Company and Peer Group, with loan loss provisions established by the Company and the Peer Group equaling 0.12% and 0.08% of average assets, respectively.
The Company’s effective tax rate of 25.47% remained lower than the Peer Group’s effective tax rate of 30.65%. As set forth in the prospectus, the Company’s effective marginal tax rate is equal to 35.0%.
The Company’s updated credit quality measures continued to imply a fairly similar degree of credit risk exposure relative to the Peer Group’s implied credit risk exposure. As shown in Table 4, the Company’s ratios for non-performing/assets and non-performing loans/loans equaled 0.76% and 1.38%, respectively, versus comparable measures of 1.12% and 1.40% for the Peer Group. The Company’s and the Peer Group’s loss reserves as a percent of non-performing loans equaled 50.37% and 84.10%, respectively. Loss reserves maintained as percent of loans receivable equaled 0.69% for the Company, versus 1.02% for the Peer Group. Net loan charge-offs remained a comparable factor for the Company and the Peer Group, as net loan charge-offs as a percent of loans equaled 0.17% for the Company and 0.16% for the Peer Group.
| 3. | Stock Market Conditions |
Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the performance of the broader stock market has been mixed. Following the first week of August 2014, the broader stock market generally drifted higher through the balance of August as investors were encouraged by the absence of more negative geopolitical news coming out of the Middle East and Ukraine along with a favorable report on housing starts for July. The S&P 500 closed above 2000 for the first time in late-August. Stocks traded higher to close out the first week of September, as weaker-than-expected job growth reflected in the August employment report lessened expectations of a
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 10
Table 4
Credit Risk Measures and Related Information
Comparable Institution Analysis
As of September 30, 2014
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | NPAs & | | | | | | | | | | | | Rsrves/ | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | REO/ | | | 90+Del/ | | | NPLs/ | | | Rsrves/ | | | Rsrves/ | | | NPAs & | | | Net Loan | | | NLCs/ | |
| | | | | | Assets | | | Assets (1) | | | Loans (1) | | | Loans HFI | | | NPLs (1) | | | 90+Del (1) | | | Chargeoffs (2) | | | Loans | |
| | | | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($000) | | | (%) | |
Kearny Financial Corp. of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
December 31, 2014 | | | | | | | 0.05 | % | | | 0.76 | % | | | 1.38 | % | | | 0.69 | % | | | 50.37 | % | | | 46.78 | % | | $ | 3,153 | | | | 0.17 | % |
| | | | | | | | | |
All Public Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 0.34 | % | | | 2.03 | % | | | 2.36 | % | | | 1.26 | % | | | 79.40 | % | | | 67.94 | % | | $ | 3,521 | | | | 0.21 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 0.17 | % | | | 1.40 | % | | | 1.69 | % | | | 1.12 | % | | | 59.99 | % | | | 49.06 | % | | $ | 774 | | | | 0.12 | % |
| | | | | | | | | |
State of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 0.42 | % | | | 1.93 | % | | | 2.17 | % | | | 1.02 | % | | | 66.50 | % | | | 58.15 | % | | $ | 3,383 | | | | 0.21 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 0.08 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 1.60 | % | | | 1.06 | % | | | 52.74 | % | | | 50.10 | % | | $ | 1,841 | | | | 0.13 | % |
| | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Recent Conversions(3) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BNCL | | Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 0.05 | % | | | 1.05 | % | | | 1.88 | % | | | 2.22 | % | | | 117.99 | % | | | 112.91 | % | | $ | 10,788 | | | | 0.46 | % |
| | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | | 0.12 | % | | | 1.12 | % | | | 1.40 | % | | | 1.02 | % | | | 84.10 | % | | | 70.80 | % | | $ | 5,421 | | | | 0.16 | % |
Medians | | | | | | | 0.12 | % | | | 1.00 | % | | | 1.28 | % | | | 1.20 | % | | | 68.07 | % | | | 66.51 | % | | $ | 2,282 | | | | 0.12 | % |
| | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BKMU | | Bank Mutual Corporation | | WI | | | 0.23 | % | | | 0.76 | % | | | 0.76 | % | | | 1.39 | % | | | 182.41 | % | | | 128.07 | % | | $ | 1,839 | | | | 0.12 | % |
CFFN | | Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. | | KS | | | 0.04 | % | | | 0.54 | % | | | 0.79 | % | | | 0.15 | % | | | 18.62 | % | | | 17.20 | % | | $ | 1,004 | | | | 0.02 | % |
DCOM | | Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. | | NY | | | 0.02 | % | | | 0.58 | % | | | 0.55 | % | | | 0.47 | % | | | 85.74 | % | | | 74.62 | % | | $ | 37 | | | | 0.00 | % |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 0.02 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 2.12 | % | | | 1.44 | % | | | 68.07 | % | | | 66.51 | % | | $ | 1,841 | | | | 0.12 | % |
NWBI | | Northwest Bancshares, Inc. | | PA | | | 0.19 | % | | | 1.86 | % | | | 2.18 | % | | | 1.20 | % | | | 55.19 | % | | | 49.34 | % | | $ | 24,415 | | | | 0.42 | % |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 0.28 | % | | | 2.02 | % | | | 2.43 | % | | | 0.99 | % | | | 40.67 | % | | | 35.02 | % | | $ | 6,582 | | | | 0.41 | % |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 0.12 | % | | | 0.71 | % | | | 0.73 | % | | | 1.21 | % | | | 166.30 | % | | | 138.26 | % | | $ | 695 | | | | 0.03 | % |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 0.08 | % | | | 1.50 | % | | | 2.01 | % | | | 1.06 | % | | | 52.74 | % | | | 50.10 | % | | $ | 7,878 | | | | 0.14 | % |
TRST | | TrustCo Bank Corp NY | | NY | | | 0.14 | % | | | 1.16 | % | | | 1.52 | % | | | 1.51 | % | | | 99.33 | % | | | 87.34 | % | | $ | 6,810 | | | | 0.23 | % |
UBNK | | United Financial Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 0.05 | % | | | 0.84 | % | | | 0.98 | % | | | 0.59 | % | | | 59.69 | % | | | 50.02 | % | | $ | 2,282 | | | | 0.09 | % |
WSFS | | WSFS Financial Corporation | | DE | | | 0.13 | % | | | 1.00 | % | | | 1.28 | % | | | 1.24 | % | | | 96.32 | % | | | 82.30 | % | | $ | 6,252 | | | | 0.21 | % |
(1) | Includes TDRs for the Company and the Peer Group. |
(2) | Net loan chargeoffs are shown on a last twelve month basis. |
(3) | Ratios are based on the date of the most recent financial statements disclosed in the offering prospectus. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obrained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Copyright (c) 2015 by RP® Financial, LC.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 11
near term rate hike by the Federal Reserve. Escalating tensions in Ukraine and the upcoming meeting of the Federal Reserve weighed on the stock market heading into mid-September. Reassuring comments from the Federal Reserve that short-term rates will remain near zero for a “considerable time” contributed to the Dow Jones Industrial Average (“DJIA”) closing at a record high following the Federal Reserve’s mid-September policy meeting. Concerns about the pace of China’s economic growth and some favorable economic reports on the U.S. economy provided for an up and down stock market at the close of third quarter.
Volatility continued to prevail in the broader stock market at the start of the fourth quarter of 2014, with concerns about a softening global economy contributing to a sell-off at the beginning of the fourth quarter that was followed by a rebound supported by a favorable employment report for September. Heightened concerns over slowing economic growth in Europe, a disappointing retail sales report for September and the uncertain outlook for third quarter earnings fueled a sharp decline in the broader stock market in mid-October, with the DJIA declining 5% over five trading sessions. Stocks rallied following the sell-off with such factors as some favorable third quarter earnings reports, increased expectations that the European Central Bank would increase stimulus, a rise in U.S. consumer sentiment in October and an increase in September housing starts contributing to the gains. The upward trend in the broader stock market continued into the first half of November, with the DJIA closing at record highs for five consecutive trading sessions following the mid-term election. The positive trend in the broader stock market continued during the second half of November and into early-December, as investors cheered China’s rate cut. Led by a rebound in big energy stocks and a favorable employment report for November, the DJIA and S&P 500 closed at record highs in early-December. Pressured by steepening declines in oil prices and fresh signs of economic weakness in Europe and Japan, stocks retreated heading into mid-December. Buoyed by the Federal Reserve’s pledge to be patient when it comes to raising interest rates and stronger-than-expected third quarter GDP growth, stocks rallied in the second half of December. The DJIA closed above 18000 for the first time on December 23, 2014 and posted gains for seven consecutive trading sessions through December 26, 2014. Stocks retreated at the close of 2014, which was largely attributable to profit taking.
Stocks tumbled at the start of 2015, as oil fell below $50 per barrel and fresh worries about Europe’s economy stoked fears of deflation. A rebound in oil prices supported a two day rebound in the broader stock market, which was followed by a downward trend through mid-January. Factors contributing to the downturn included a further drop in oil prices, a weak reading for December wage growth, disappointing retail sales for December and lackluster fourth quarter earnings results posted by some of the nation’s largest banks. After five consecutive sessions of losses, some upbeat reports on the U.S. economy and a rebound in energy shares contributed to a stock market rally heading into the second half of January. On January 16, 2015, the DJIA closed at 17511.57 or 5.77% higher since the date of the Original Appraisal and the NASDAQ closed at 4634.38 or 6.03% higher since the date of the Original Appraisal.
The market for thrift stocks has also been somewhat mixed since the date of the Original Appraisal, but, overall, thrift stocks underperformed the broader stock market. Thrift stocks edged higher along with the broader stock market during the last three weeks of August 2014, with the favorable report for July housing starts contributing to stock market gains in the thrift sector. Investors shrugged off the disappointing employment report for August, as the thrift
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 12
sector showed little movement during the first two weeks of September. Financial shares edged higher following the Federal Reserve’s mid-September policy meeting, based on comments that the Federal Reserve was staying the course regarding interest rate monetary policies. Concerns about a global economic slowdown dragged bank and thrift stocks lower at the close of the third quarter.
Financial shares traded in line with the broader stock market in early-October 2014, initially trading lower on the global economic outlook and then rebounding in response to September employment data showing stronger-than-expected job growth. The rebound was short-lived, as the financial sector participated in the broader stock market sell-off in mid-October. Third quarter earnings releases posted by some of the big banks showed net interest margins continued to be squeezed by low interest rates. Some favorable reports on September housing starts and existing home sales helped thrift stocks to rebound modestly following the sell-off. Thrift stocks participated in the broader stock market rally that extended in mid-November, as the Federal Reserve’s late-October policy statement repeated its pledge to keep interest rates low for the foreseeable future and indicated a brighter economic outlook. Signs of financial sector merger activity picking up also contributed to the gains in thrift stocks heading into mid-November. Thrift shares traded in a narrow range during the second half of November and then retreated at the start of December, as disappointing economic reports coming out of China and Europe impacted the broader stock market. November’s favorable employment report boosted the thrift sector at the close of the first week of December, which was followed by a downturn in financial shares going into mid-December as the prolonged slump in oil prices raised doubts about the health of the global economy and sparked a sell-off in the broader stock market. Financial shares rebounded along with the broader stock market during the second half of December, as the Federal Reserve’s comments on remaining patient with its approach to future rate increases were well received by bank investors.
Thrift stocks followed the broader stock market lower during the first half of January 2015, as a weak report for December retail sales and fourth quarter bank earnings showing net interest margins continued to be squeezed depressed financial stocks in general. The broader stock market rally at the start of the second half of January boosted thrift shares as well. On January 16, 2015, the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts closed at 707.6, an increase of 0.63% since August 8, 2014.
Consistent with the performance of the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts, the updated pricing measures for the Peer Group and all publicly-traded thrifts were generally little changed since the date of the Original Appraisal. The relative large declines in the Peer Group’s P/E multiples since the date of the Original Appraisal were largely related to Northfield Bancorp’s P/E multiples going from relative high multiples to not meaningful (“NM”) P/E multiples. Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the stock prices of nine out of the eleven Peer Group companies were higher as of January 16, 2015. A comparative pricing analysis of the Peer Group and all publicly-traded thrifts is shown in the following table, based on closing stock market prices as of August 8, 2014 and January 16, 2015.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 13
Average Pricing Characteristics
| | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | At Aug. 8, 2014 | | | At Jan. 16, 2015 | | | % Change | |
Peer Group | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Price/Earnings (x) | | | 18.51x | | | | 16.48x | | | | (10.97 | %) |
Price/Core Earnings (x) | | | 18.72 | | | | 16.11 | | | | (13.94 | ) |
Price/Book (%) | | | 120.63 | % | | | 123.42 | % | | | 2.31 | |
Price/Tangible Book (%) | | | 132.96 | | | | 136.48 | | | | 2.65 | |
Price/Assets (%) | | | 15.63 | | | | 15.65 | | | | 0.13 | |
Avg. Mkt. Capitalization ($Mil) | | $ | 764.47 | | | $ | 782.02 | | | | 2.30 | |
| | | |
All Publicly-Traded Thrifts | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Price/Earnings (x) | | | 17.73x | | | | 17.80x | | | | 0.39 | % |
Price/Core Earnings (x) | | | 17.65 | | | | 17.51 | | | | (0.79 | ) |
Price/Book (%) | | | 107.44 | % | | | 106.45 | % | | | (0.92 | ) |
Price/Tangible Book (%) | | | 115.47 | | | | 114.48 | | | | (0.86 | ) |
Price/Assets (%) | | | 13.13 | | | | 13.64 | | | | 3.88 | |
Avg. Mkt. Capitalization ($Mil) | | $ | 402.94 | | | $ | 439.15 | | | | 8.99 | |
As set forth in the Original Appraisal, the “new issue” market is separate and distinct from the market for seasoned issues like the Peer Group companies in that the pricing ratios for converting issues are computed on a pro forma basis, specifically: (1) the numerator and denominator are both impacted by the conversion offering amount, unlike existing stock issues in which price change affects only the numerator; and (2) the pro forma pricing ratio incorporates assumptions regarding source and use of proceeds, effective tax rates, stock plan purchases, etc. which impact pro forma financials, whereas pricing for existing issues are based on reported financials. The distinction between the pricing of converting and existing issues is perhaps most evident in the case of the price/book (“P/B”) ratio in that the P/B ratio of a converting thrift will typically result in a discount to book value, whereas in the current market for existing thrifts the P/B ratio may reflect a premium to book value. Therefore, it is appropriate to also consider the market for new issues, both at the time of the conversion and in the aftermarket.
For purposes of comparable data in connection with the valuation of the Company, recent second-step conversion offerings are viewed to be the most relevant. As shown in Table 5, two second-step conversion offerings have been completed during the past three months. The average closing pro forma price/tangible book ratio of the two recent second-step conversion offerings equaled 87.50%. On average, the two second-step conversion offerings had price appreciation of 1.30% after their first week of trading. As of January 16, 2015, the two recent second-step conversion offerings showed an average price increase of 2.70% from their respective IPO prices.
Of the two recent second-step conversion offerings, Beneficial Bancorp’s second-step offering is viewed to be more comparable to Kearny Financial’s second-step offering. Beneficial Bancorp’s second-step offering closed on January 13, 2015. Gross
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 14
Table 5
Pricing Characteristics and After-Market Trends
Conversions Completed in the Last Three Months
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Institutional Information | | | Pre-Conversion Data | | | Offering Information | | | Contribution to Char. Found. | | | Insider Purchases | | | | |
| | | | | | | | Financial Info. | | | Asset Quality | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | % Off Incl. Fdn.+Merger Shares | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Excluding Foundation | | | | | | % of | | | Benefit Plans | | | | | | Initial | |
| | Conversion | | | | | | | | | Equity/ | | | NPAs/ | | | Res. | | | Gross | | | % | | | % of | | | Exp./ | | | | | | Public Off. | | | | | | Recog. | | | Stk | | | Mgmt.& | | | Div. | |
Institution | | Date | | | Ticker | | | Assets | | | Assets | | | Assets | | | Cov. | | | Proc. | | | Offer | | | Mid. | | | Proc. | | | Form | | | Excl. Fdn. | | | ESOP | | | Plans | | | Option | | | Dirs. | | | Yield | |
| | | | | | | | ($Mil) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($Mil.) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%)(1) | | | (%) | |
Standard Conversions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
MB Bancorp, Inc. - MD | | | 12/30/14 | | | | MBCQ- OTC Pink | | | $ | 136 | | | | 12.75 | % | | | 3.02 | % | | | 43 | % | | $ | 21.2 | | | | 100 | % | | | 132 | % | | | 5.0 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 8.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 2.7 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
Melrose Bancorp, Inc. - MA* | | | 10/22/14 | | | | MELR- NASDAQ | | | $ | 195 | | | | 11.05 | % | | | 0.43 | % | | | 62 | % | | $ | 27.2 | | | | 100 | % | | | 105 | % | | | 5.4 | % | | | C/S | | | $ | 300K/3.75 | % | | | 8.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 11.0 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | Averages - Standard Conversions: | | | $ | 165 | | | | 11.90 | % | | | 1.73 | % | | | 53 | % | | $ | 24.2 | | | | 100 | % | | | 119 | % | | | 5.2 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 8.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 6.9 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | Medians - Standard Conversions: | | | $ | 165 | | | | 11.90 | % | | | 1.73 | % | | | 53 | % | | $ | 24.2 | | | | 100 | % | | | 119 | % | | | 5.2 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 8.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 6.9 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
Second Step Conversions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. - PA* | | | 1/13/15 | | | | BNCL- NASDAQ | | | $ | 4,360 | | | | 14.03 | % | | | 0.86 | % | | | 146 | % | | $ | 503.8 | | | | 61 | % | | | 92 | % | | | 1.7 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 4.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 0.2 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc. - NY* | | | 10/17/14 | | | | PBHC- NASDAQ | | | $ | 545 | | | | 8.20 | % | | | 1.33 | % | | | 80 | % | | $ | 26.4 | | | | 61 | % | | | 132 | % | | | 5.6 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 4.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 8.6 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | Averages - Second Step Conversions: | | | $ | 2,452 | | | | 11.12 | % | | | 1.10 | % | | | 113 | % | | $ | 265.1 | | | | 61 | % | | | 112 | % | | | 3.6 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 4.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 4.4 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | Medians - Second Step Conversions: | | | $ | 2,452 | | | | 11.12 | % | | | 1.10 | % | | | 113 | % | | $ | 265.1 | | | | 61 | % | | | 112 | % | | | 3.6 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 4.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 4.4 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | Averages - All Conversions: | | | $ | 1,309 | | | | 11.51 | % | | | 1.41 | % | | | 83 | % | | $ | 144.6 | | | | 80 | % | | | 115 | % | | | 4.4 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 6.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 5.6 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | Medians - All Conversions: | | | $ | 370 | | | | 11.90 | % | | | 1.10 | % | | | 71 | % | | $ | 26.8 | | | | 80 | % | | | 118 | % | | | 5.2 | % | | | N.A. | | | | N.A. | | | | 6.0 | % | | | 4.0 | % | | | 10.0 | % | | | 5.7 | % | | | 0.00 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Institutional Information | | | Pro Forma Data | | | | | | | | | | | | Post-IPO Pricing Trends | |
| | | | | | | | Pricing Ratios(2)(5) | | | Financial Charac. | | | | | | Closing Price: | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | First | | | | | | After | | | | | | After | | | | | | | | | | |
| | Conversion | | | | | | | | | Core | | | | | | Core | | | | | | Core | | | IPO | | | Trading | | | % | | | First | | | % | | | First | | | % | | | Thru | | | % | |
Institution | | Date | | | Ticker | | | P/TB | | | P/E | | | P/A | | | ROA | | | TE/A | | | ROE | | | Price | | | Day | | | Chge | | | Week(3) | | | Chge | | | Month(4) | | | Chge | | | 1/16/15 | | | Chge | |
| | | | | | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | ($) | | | (%) | |
Standard Conversions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
MB Bancorp, Inc. - MD | | | 12/30/14 | | | | MBCQ- OTC Pink | | | | 60.6 | % | | | NM | | | | 13.8 | % | | | -1.3 | % | | | 22.7 | % | | | -5.9 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 10.45 | | | | 4.5 | % | | $ | 10.59 | | | | 5.9 | % | | $ | 10.70 | | | | 7.0 | % | | $ | 10.70 | | | | 7.0 | % |
Melrose Bancorp, Inc. - MA* | | | 10/22/14 | | | | MELR- NASDAQ | | | | 64.2 | % | | | 47.1x | | | | 13.0 | % | | | 0.3 | % | | | 20.3 | % | | | 1.4 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 13.05 | | | | 30.5 | % | | $ | 13.05 | | | | 30.5 | % | | $ | 13.15 | | | | 31.5 | % | | $ | 13.07 | | | | 30.7 | % |
| | | Averages - Standard Conversions: | | | | 62.4 | % | | | 47.1x | | | | 13.4 | % | | | -0.5 | % | | | 21.5 | % | | | -2.3 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 11.75 | | | | 17.5 | % | | $ | 11.82 | | | | 18.2 | % | | $ | 11.93 | | | | 19.3 | % | | $ | 11.89 | | | | 18.9 | % |
| | | Medians - Standard Conversions: | | | | 62.4 | % | | | 47.1x | | | | 13.4 | % | | | -0.5 | % | | | 21.5 | % | | | -2.3 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 11.75 | | | | 17.5 | % | | $ | 11.82 | | | | 18.2 | % | | $ | 11.93 | | | | 19.3 | % | | $ | 11.89 | | | | 18.9 | % |
Second Step Conversions | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. - PA* | | | 1/13/15 | | | | BNCL- NASDAQ | | | | 88.2 | % | | | 57.9x | | | | 17.2 | % | | | 0.3 | % | | | 20.0 | % | | | 1.3 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 10.82 | | | | 8.2 | % | | $ | 10.73 | | | | 7.3 | % | | $ | 10.73 | | | | 7.3 | % | | $ | 10.73 | | | | 7.3 | % |
Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc. - NY* | | | 10/17/14 | | | | PBHC- NASDAQ | | | | 86.8 | % | | | 20.9x | | | | 7.7 | % | | | 0.4 | % | | | 11.1 | % | | | 4.2 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 9.75 | | | | -2.5 | % | | $ | 9.52 | | | | -4.8 | % | | $ | 9.63 | | | | -3.7 | % | | $ | 9.81 | | | | -1.9 | % |
| | | Averages - Second Step Conversions: | | | | 87.5 | % | | | 39.4x | | | | 12.4 | % | | | 0.3 | % | | | 15.6 | % | | | 2.7 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 10.29 | | | | 2.9 | % | | $ | 10.13 | | | | 1.3 | % | | $ | 10.18 | | | | 1.8 | % | | $ | 10.27 | | | | 2.7 | % |
| | | Medians - Second Step Conversions: | | | | 87.5 | % | | | 39.4x | | | | 12.4 | % | | | 0.3 | % | | | 15.6 | % | | | 2.7 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 10.29 | | | | 2.9 | % | | $ | 10.13 | | | | 1.3 | % | | $ | 10.18 | | | | 1.8 | % | | $ | 10.27 | | | | 2.7 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | Averages - All Conversions: | | | | 74.9 | % | | | 41.9x | | | | 12.9 | % | | | -0.1 | % | | | 18.5 | % | | | 0.2 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 11.02 | | | | 10.2 | % | | $ | 10.97 | | | | 9.7 | % | | $ | 11.05 | | | | 10.5 | % | | $ | 11.08 | | | | 10.8 | % |
| | | Medians - All Conversions: | | | | 75.5 | % | | | 47.1x | | | | 13.4 | % | | | 0.3 | % | | | 20.1 | % | | | 1.4 | % | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 10.64 | | | | 6.4 | % | | $ | 10.66 | | | | 6.6 | % | | $ | 10.72 | | | | 7.2 | % | | $ | 10.72 | | | | 7.2 | % |
Note: * - Appraisal performed by RP Financial; BOLD = RP Fin. Did the business plan, “NT” - Not Traded; “NA” - Not Applicable, Not Available; C/S-Cash/Stock.
(1) | As a percent of MHC offering for MHC transactions. |
(2) | Does not take into account the adoption of SOP 93-6. |
(3) | Latest price if offering is less than one week old. |
(4) | Latest price if offering is more than one week but less than one month old. |
(5) | Mutual holding company pro forma data on full conversion basis. |
(6) | Simultaneously completed acquisition of another financial institution. |
(7) | Simultaneously converted to a commercial bank charter. |
January 16, 2015
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 15
proceeds raised in Beneficial Bancorp’s second-step offering totaled $503.8 million, which was between the minimum and midpoint of the offering range. Beneficial Bancorp’s closing pro forma price/tangible book ratio equaled 88.18% and as of January 16, 2015 Beneficial Bancorp’s stock price was up 7.3% from its IPO price.
Shown in Table 6 are the current pricing ratios for the fully-converted offerings completed during the past three months that trade on NASDAQ or an Exchange, which includes both of the second-step conversion offerings. The current average P/TB ratio for the recent fully-converted offerings equaled 87.88%, based on closing stock prices as of January 16, 2015.
As set forth in the Original Appraisal, RP Financial’s analysis of stock market conditions also considered recent trading activity in Kearny Financial’s stock. Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the trading price of the Company’s stock ranged from a low closing price of $12.99 on October 10, 2014 to a high closing price of $15.98 on August 19, 2014. As of January 16, 2015, the Company’s closing stock price was $13.68 per share which equaled an 11.00% decrease from Kearny Financial’s closing stock price of $15.37 per share as of the August 8, 2014 date of the Original Appraisal.
Summary of Adjustments
In the Original Appraisal, we made the following adjustments to Kearny Financial’s pro forma value based upon our comparative analysis to the Peer Group:
| | |
Key Valuation Parameters: | | PreviousValuation Adjustment |
Financial Condition | | Slight Upward |
Profitability, Growth and Viability of Earnings | | Moderate Downward |
Asset Growth | | Slight Upward |
Primary Market Area | | No Adjustment |
Dividends | | No Adjustment |
Liquidity of the Shares | | No Adjustment |
Marketing of the Issue | | No Adjustment |
Management | | No Adjustment |
Effect of Govt. Regulations and Regulatory Reform | | No Adjustment |
The factors concerning the valuation parameters of primary market area, dividends, liquidity of the shares, management and effect of government regulations and regulatory reform did not change since the Original Appraisal. Accordingly, those parameters were not discussed further in this update.
In terms of balance sheet strength, on a pro forma basis the Company’s updated financial condition continued to warrant a slight upward adjustment, based on upward adjustments for the Company’s slightly more favorable credit quality, balance sheet liquidity and stronger pro forma capital position. A moderate downward adjustment remained appropriate for earnings, as the Company’s reported and core earnings remained less favorable compared to the Peer Group’s reported and core earnings. A slight upward adjustment remained appropriate for the Company’s asset growth, based on the Company’s higher pro forma capital position that
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 16
Table 6
Market Pricing Comparatives
Prices As of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | Market Capitalization | | | Per Share Data | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | Core | | | Book | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Dividends(4) | | | Financial Characteristics(6) | |
| | | | Price/ | | | Market | | | 12 Month | | | Value/ | | | Pricing Ratios(3) | | | Amount/ | | | | | | Payout | | | Total | | | Equity/ | | | Tang Eq/ | | | NPAs/ | | | Reported | | | Core | |
Financial Institution | | Share(1) | | | Value | | | EPS(2) | | | Share | | | P/E | | | P/B | | | P/A | | | P/TB | | | P/Core | | | Share | | | Yield | | | Ratio(5) | | | Assets | | | Assets | | | Assets | | | Assets | | | ROA | | | ROE | | | ROA | | | ROE | |
| | | | ($) | | | ($Mil) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | (x) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($Mil) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | |
All Non-MHC Public Companies | | $ | 16.56 | | | $ | 439.15 | | | $ | 0.88 | | | $ | 15.30 | | | | 17.80x | | | | 106.45 | % | | | 13.64 | % | | | 114.48 | % | | | 17.51x | | | $ | 0.29 | | | | 1.79 | % | | | 50.03 | % | | $ | 3,149 | | | | 13.52 | % | | | 12.91 | % | | | 2.00 | % | | | 0.65 | % | | | 5.34 | % | | | 0.67 | % | | | 5.34 | % |
Converted Last 3 Months (no MHC) | | $ | 11.20 | | | $ | 322.40 | | | $ | 0.29 | | | $ | 13.68 | | | | 45.86x | | | | 81.74 | % | | | 14.33 | % | | | 87.88 | % | | | 48.61x | | | $ | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | $ | 1,866 | | | | 18.12 | % | | | 17.14 | % | | | 0.87 | % | | | 0.33 | % | | | 2.32 | % | | | 0.31 | % | | | 2.17 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Converted Last 3 Months (no MHC) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
MELR | | Melrose Bancorp, Inc. of MA | | $ | 13.07 | | | $ | 36.98 | | | $ | 0.21 | | | $ | 15.57 | | | | 62.24x | | | | 83.94 | % | | | 17.03 | % | | | 83.94 | % | | | 62.24x | | | $ | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | $ | 217 | | | | 20.28 | % | | | 20.28 | % | | | 0.43 | % | | | 0.28 | % | | | 1.36 | % | | | 0.28 | % | | | 1.36 | % |
PBHC | | Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc. of NY | | $ | 9.81 | | | $ | 42.70 | | | $ | 0.48 | | | $ | 12.57 | | | | 18.87x | | | | 78.03 | % | | | 7.52 | % | | | 85.08 | % | | | 20.49x | | | $ | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | $ | 568 | | | | 11.93 | % | | | 11.13 | % | | | 1.33 | % | | | 0.40 | % | | | 4.15 | % | | | 0.37 | % | | | 3.81 | % |
BNCL | | Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. of PA | | $ | 10.73 | | | $ | 887.53 | | | $ | 0.17 | | | $ | 12.89 | | | | 56.47x | | | | 83.24 | % | | | 18.43 | % | | | 94.62 | % | | | 63.12x | | | $ | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | % | | | 0.00 | % | | $ | 4,814 | | | | 22.14 | % | | | 20.01 | % | | | 0.86 | % | | | 0.32 | % | | | 1.44 | % | | | 0.30 | % | | | 1.34 | % |
(1) | Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share. |
(2) | EPS (estimate core basis) is based on actual trailing 12 month data, adjusted to omit non-operating items on a tax-effected basis. |
(3) | P/E = Price to earnings; P/B = Price to book; P/A = Price to assets; P/TB = Price to tangible book value; and P/Core = Price to core earnings. |
(4) | Indicated 12 month dividend, based on last quarterly dividend declared. |
(5) | Indicated 12 month dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month estimated core earnings. |
(6) | ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances. |
(7) | Excludes from averages and medians those companies the subject of actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this report has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Copyright (c) 2015 by RP® Financial, LC.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 17
will provide the Company with greater leverage capacity compared to the Peer Group’s leverage capacity.
The general market for thrift stocks showed little change since the date of the Original Appraisal, with the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts increasing 0.63% since the date of the Original Appraisal compared to an increase of 5.77% in the DJIA. Similar to the SNL Index for all publicly-traded thrifts, the updated pricing measures for the Peer Group were generally consistent with their pricing measures reflected in the Original Appraisal. Two second-step conversion offerings have been completed during the past three months. Pathfinder Bancorp’s second-step conversion offering was completed on October 17, 2014 and, as January 16, 2015, Pathfinder Bancorp’s stock price was down 1.9% from its IPO price. Beneficial Bancorp’s second-step conversion offering was completed on January 13, 2015, and, as January 16, 2015, Beneficial Bancorp’s stock price was up 7.3% from its IPO price. Kearny Financial’s stock price was down 11.00% since the date of the Original Appraisal and the $13.68 closing price on January 16, 2015 was slightly below the midpoint of the offering range as set forth in the Original Appraisal. Overall, in light of the recent volatility in the broader stock market and the decrease in Kearny Financial’s stock price since the date of Original Appraisal, marketing of the issue has been revised from no adjustment to a slight downward adjustment.
Overall, taking into account the foregoing factors, RP Financial concluded that as of January 16, 2015, the aggregate pro forma market value of Kearny Financial’s conversion stock equaled $893,152,780 at the midpoint equal to a 5.34% decrease from the Original Appraisal midpoint value. Based on the sale of a 77.13% ownership interest to the public, the midpoint of the public offering decreased from $725.0 million to $685.0 million. The MHC’s 77.13% ownership interest is consistent with the pro forma assumptions set forth in the prospectus, which is based on Kearny Financial’s shares outstanding as of December 31, 2014 adjusted for the the dilution resulting from net assets held by the MHC at December 31, 2014 (see Exhibit 4). The MHC’s ownership interest as of December 31, 2014 equaled 77.12%.
Valuation Approaches
In applying the accepted valuation methodology promulgated by the regulatory agencies, i.e., the pro forma market value approach, we considered the three key pricing ratios in valuing Kearny Financial’s to-be-issued stock — price/earnings (“P/E”), price/book (“P/B”), and price/assets (“P/A”) approaches — all performed on a pro forma basis including the effects of the conversion proceeds.
In computing the pro forma impact of the offering and the related pricing ratios, the valuation parameters utilized in the Original Appraisal were updated with Kearny Financial’s financial data as of December 31, 2014.
Consistent with the Original Appraisal, this updated appraisal continues to be based primarily on fundamental analysis techniques applied to the Peer Group, including the P/E approach, the P/B approach and the P/A approach. Also consistent with the Original Appraisal, this updated appraisal incorporates a “technical” analysis of recently completed offerings, including principally the P/B approach which (as discussed in the Original Appraisal) is the most meaningful pricing ratio as the pro forma P/E ratios reflect an assumed reinvestment rate and do not yet reflect the actual use of proceeds.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 18
RP Financial also considered the trading price of Kearny Financial’s stock, which had a closing price of $13.68 as of January 16, 2015, a decrease of 11.00% from its closing price as of August 8, 2014. The $13.68 closing trading price implied a pro forma market capitalization for Kearny Financial of approximately $921.7 million, which is slightly above the midpoint of the updated valuation range.
The Company has adopted “Employers’ Accounting for Employee Stock Ownership Plans” (“ASC 718-40”), which causes earnings per share computations to be based on shares issued and outstanding excluding unreleased ESOP shares. For purposes of preparing the pro forma pricing analyses, we have reflected all shares issued in the offering, including all ESOP shares, to capture the full dilutive impact, particularly since the ESOP shares are economically dilutive, receive dividends and can be voted. However, we did consider the impact of ASC 718-40 in the valuation.
1.P/E Approach. The application of the P/E valuation method requires calculating the Company’s pro forma market value by applying a valuation P/E multiple to the pro forma earnings base. In applying this technique, we considered both reported earnings and a recurring earnings base, that is, earnings adjusted to exclude any one-time non-operating items, plus the estimated after-tax earnings benefit of the reinvestment of the net proceeds. The Company’s reported earnings equaled $9.707 million for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014. In deriving Kearny Financial’s core earnings, the adjustments made to reported earnings were to eliminate net gains on the sale of investments securities equal to $1.298 million, loss on sale of real estate owned equal to $588,000 and merger related expenses equal to $391,000. As shown below, assuming an effective marginal tax rate of 35.0% for the earnings adjustments, the Company’s core earnings were estimated to equal $9.499 million for the twelve months ended December 31, 2014.
| | | | |
| | Amount | |
| | ($000) | |
| |
Net income | | $ | 9,707 | |
Deduct: Net gain on sale of investment securities(1) | | | (844 | ) |
Add back: Loss on sale of real estate owned(1) | | | 382 | |
Add back: Merger related expenses(1) | | | 254 | |
| | | | |
Core earnings estimate | | $ | 9,499 | |
| | | | |
(1) | Adjustments were tax effected at 35.0% |
Based on Kearny Financial’s reported and estimated core earnings, and incorporating the impact of the pro forma assumptions discussed previously, the Company’s reported and core P/E multiples at the $893.2 million midpoint value equaled 80.12 times and 81.64 times, respectively. The Company’s updated reported and core P/E multiples provided for premiums of 386.17% and 406.77% relative to the Peer Group’s average reported and core P/E multiples of 16.48 times and 16.11 times, respectively (versus premiums of 349.11% and 362.18% relative to the Peer Group’s average reported and core P/E multiples as indicated in the Original Appraisal). The Company’s updated reported and core P/E multiples indicated premiums of 418.24% and 443.54% relative to the Peer Group’s median reported and core P/E multiples, which equaled 15.46 times and 15.02 times, respectively (versus premiums of 409.38% and 445.18% relative to the Peer Group’s median reported and core P/E multiples as
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 19
indicated in the Original Appraisal). The Company’s pro forma P/E ratios based on reported earnings at the minimum and the maximum equaled 69.63 times and 90.17 times, respectively, and based on core earnings at the minimum and the maximum equaled 70.99 times and 91.84 times, respectively. The Company’s implied conversion pricing ratios relative to the Peer Group’s pricing ratios are indicated in Table 7, and the pro forma calculations are detailed in Exhibits 2 and 3.
2.P/B Approach. P/B ratios have generally served as a useful benchmark in the valuation of thrift stocks, with the greater determinant of long term value being earnings. In applying the P/B approach, we considered both reported book value and tangible book value. Based on the $893.2 million midpoint value, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios equaled 81.10% and 90.01%, respectively. In comparison to the average P/B and P/TB ratios indicated for the Peer Group of 123.42% and 136.48%, respectively, Kearny Financial’s updated ratios reflected a discount of 34.29% on a P/B basis and a discount of 34.05% on a P/TB basis (versus discounts of 31.38% and 31.12% from the Peer Group’s average P/B and P/TB ratios as indicated in the Original Appraisal). In comparison to the median P/B and P/TB ratios indicated for the Peer Group of 118.96% and 129.34%, respectively, Kearny Financial’s updated ratios reflected discounts of 31.83% and 30.41% at the $893.2 million midpoint value (versus discounts of 27.19% and 29.87% from the Peer Group’s median P/B and P/TB ratios as indicated in the Original Appraisal). At the maximum of the range, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios equaled 85.98% and 94.61%, respectively. In comparison to the Peer Group’s average P/B and P/TB ratios, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the maximum of the range reflected discounts of 30.34% and 30.68%, respectively. In comparison to the Peer Group’s median P/B and P/TB ratios, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the maximum of the range reflected discounts of 27.72% and 26.85%, respectively.
In addition to the fundamental analysis applied to the Peer Group, RP Financial utilized a technical analysis of recent conversion offerings. As indicated in the Original Appraisal, the pricing characteristics of recent conversion offerings are not the primary determinate of value. Consistent with the Original Appraisal, particular focus was placed on the P/TB approach in this analysis since the P/E multiples do not reflect the actual impact of reinvestment and the source of the conversion funds (i.e., external funds versus deposit withdrawals).
As discussed previously, the two recently completed second-step offerings had an average forma price/tangible book ratio at closing of 87.50% (see Table 5). In comparison, the Company’s pro forma price/tangible book ratio at the midpoint value reflects an implied premium of 2.87%. The average current P/TB ratio of the two recently completed second-step offerings, based on closing stock prices as of January 16, 2015 equaled 89.85%. In comparison to the current average P/TB ratio for the two recent second-step conversion offerings, the Company’s P/TB ratio at the midpoint value reflects an implied premium of 0.18%.
As previously noted, of the two recently completed second-step offering, Beneficial Bancorp’s was viewed to be more comparable to Kearny Financial’s second-step offering. Beneficial Bancorp’s pro forma price/tangible book ratio at closing equaled 88.18%. In comparison, the Company’s pro forma price/tangible book ratio at the midpoint value reflects an implied premium of 2.08%. Beneficial Bancorp’s current P/TB ratio, based on closing stock prices as of January 16, 2014, equaled 94.62%. In comparison to Beneficial Bancorp’s current
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 20
Table 7
Public Market Pricing Versus Peer Group
Kearny Financial Corp. and the Comparables
As of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Market | | | Per Share Data | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Capitalization | | | Core | | | Book | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Dividends(3) | | | Financial Characteristics(5) | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Price/ | | | Market | | | 12 Month | | | Value/ | | | Pricing Ratios(2) | | | Amount/ | | | | | | Payout | | | Total | | | Equity/ | | | Tang. Eq./ | | | NPAs/ | | | Reported | | | Core | | | Exchange | | | 2nd Step | |
| | | | | | Share | | | Value | | | EPS(1) | | | Share | | | P/E | | | P/B | | | P/A | | | P/TB | | | P/Core | | | Share | | | Yield | | | Ratio(4) | | | Assets | | | Assets | | | T. Assets | | | Assets | | | ROAA | | | ROAE | | | ROAA | | | ROAE | | | Ratio | | | Proceeds | |
| | | | | | ($) | | | ($Mil) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | (x) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($Mil) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (X) | | | ($Mil) | |
Kearny Financial Corp. of NJ | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Maximum | | | | | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 1,026.38 | | | $ | 0.11 | | | $ | 11.63 | | | | 90.17x | | | | 85.98 | % | | | 24.16 | % | | | 94.61 | % | | | 91.84x | | | $ | 0.08 | | | | 0.80 | % | | | 73.48 | % | | $ | 4,248 | | | | 28.10 | % | | | 26.20 | % | | | 0.63 | % | | | 0.27 | % | | | 0.95 | % | | | 0.26 | % | | | 0.94 | % | | | 1.5156x | | | $ | 787.75 | |
Midpoint | | | | | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 893.13 | | | $ | 0.12 | | | $ | 12.34 | | | | 80.12x | | | | 81.10 | % | | | 21.49 | % | | | 90.01 | % | | | 81.64x | | | $ | 0.08 | | | | 0.80 | % | | | 65.31 | % | | $ | 4,156 | | | | 26.51 | % | | | 24.52 | % | | | 0.65 | % | | | 0.27 | % | | | 1.01 | % | | | 0.26 | % | | | 0.99 | % | | | 1.3179x | | | $ | 685.00 | |
Minimum | | | | | | $ | 10.00 | | | $ | 759.93 | | | $ | 0.14 | | | $ | 13.29 | | | | 69.63x | | | | 75.24 | % | | | 18.70 | % | | | 84.39 | % | | | 70.99x | | | $ | 0.08 | | | | 0.80 | % | | | 56.79 | % | | $ | 4,064 | | | | 24.85 | % | | | 22.77 | % | | | 0.66 | % | | | 0.27 | % | | | 1.08 | % | | | 0.26 | % | | | 1.06 | % | | | 1.1202x | | | $ | 582.25 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
All Non-MHC Public Companies(6) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | $ | 16.56 | | | $ | 439.15 | | | $ | 0.88 | | | $ | 15.30 | | | | 17.80x | | | | 106.45 | % | | | 13.64 | % | | | 114.48 | % | | | 17.51x | | | $ | 0.29 | | | | 1.79 | % | | | 50.03 | % | | $ | 3,149 | | | | 13.52 | % | | | 12.91 | % | | | 2.00 | % | | | 0.65 | % | | | 5.34 | % | | | 0.67 | % | | | 5.34 | % | | | | | | | | |
Median | | | | | | $ | 13.52 | | | $ | 108.89 | | | $ | 0.76 | | | $ | 14.45 | | | | 16.22x | | | | 98.21 | % | | | 12.89 | % | | | 102.41 | % | | | 15.74x | | | $ | 0.24 | | | | 1.47 | % | | | 41.74 | % | | $ | 1,025 | | | | 12.67 | % | | | 11.70 | % | | | 1.49 | % | | | 0.62 | % | | | 5.13 | % | | | 0.62 | % | | | 5.05 | % | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
All Non-MHC State of NJ(6) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | $ | 13.82 | | | $ | 897.74 | | | $ | 0.74 | | | $ | 13.22 | | | | 18.20x | | | | 105.60 | % | | | 17.57 | % | | | 115.66 | % | | | 16.91x | | | $ | 0.37 | | | | 2.62 | % | | | 57.99 | % | | $ | 4,754 | | | | 16.58 | % | | | 15.63 | % | | | 1.18 | % | | | 0.77 | % | | | 5.38 | % | | | 0.81 | % | | | 5.72 | % | | | | | | | | |
Medians | | | | | | $ | 14.42 | | | $ | 507.29 | | | $ | 0.76 | | | $ | 12.49 | | | | 15.68x | | | | 104.28 | % | | | 16.88 | % | | | 116.33 | % | | | 15.37x | | | $ | 0.26 | | | | 2.30 | % | | | 49.92 | % | | $ | 2,617 | | | | 14.79 | % | | | 13.61 | % | | | 1.17 | % | | | 0.72 | % | | | 5.54 | % | | | 0.80 | % | | | 5.98 | % | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
CBNJ | | Cape Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 9.06 | | | $ | 103.97 | | | $ | 0.57 | | | $ | 12.19 | | | | 15.89x | | | | 74.33 | % | | | 9.61 | % | | | 88.77 | % | | | 15.81x | | | $ | 0.24 | | | | 2.65 | % | | | 42.11 | % | | $ | 1,082 | | | | 12.93 | % | | | 11.06 | % | | | 1.60 | % | | | 0.58 | % | | | 4.47 | % | | | 0.58 | % | | | 4.48 | % | | | | | | | | |
CSBK | | Clifton Bancorp Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 13.35 | | | $ | 356.13 | | | $ | 0.25 | | | $ | 13.41 | | | | NM | | | | 99.56 | % | | | 29.39 | % | | | 99.56 | % | | | NM | | | $ | 0.24 | | | | 1.80 | % | | | 95.43 | % | | $ | 1,212 | | | | 29.52 | % | | | 29.52 | % | | | 0.41 | % | | | 0.54 | % | | | 2.34 | % | | | 0.53 | % | | | 2.32 | % | | | | | | | | |
ISBC | | Investors Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 10.81 | | | $ | 3,867.38 | | | $ | 0.40 | | | $ | 9.92 | | | | 31.41x | | | | 109.00 | % | | | 21.69 | % | | | 111.94 | % | | | 27.00x | | | $ | 0.16 | | | | 1.48 | % | | | 34.64 | % | | $ | 17,833 | | | | 19.90 | % | | | 19.47 | % | | | 0.88 | % | | | 0.71 | % | | | 5.28 | % | | | 0.83 | % | | | 6.18 | % | | | | | | | | |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 14.33 | | | $ | 701.90 | | | $ | 0.40 | | | $ | 12.20 | | | | NM | | | | 117.47 | % | | | 24.82 | % | | | 120.73 | % | | | NM | | | $ | 0.28 | | | | 1.95 | % | | | 66.67 | % | | $ | 2,925 | | | | 21.12 | % | | | 20.67 | % | | | 1.34 | % | | | 0.75 | % | | | 2.95 | % | | | 0.77 | % | | | 3.02 | % | | | | | | | | |
OSHC | | Ocean Shore Holding Co. | | NJ | | $ | 14.50 | | | $ | 93.10 | | | $ | 0.95 | | | $ | 16.25 | | | | 15.26x | | | | 89.22 | % | | | 9.02 | % | | | 93.86 | % | | | 15.28x | | | $ | 0.24 | | | | 1.66 | % | | | 25.26 | % | | $ | 1,040 | | | | 10.11 | % | | | 9.66 | % | | | 1.00 | % | | | 0.60 | % | | | 5.79 | % | | | 0.60 | % | | | 5.78 | % | | | | | | | | |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | $ | 16.52 | | | $ | 281.02 | | | $ | 1.15 | | | $ | 12.77 | | | | 16.52x | | | | 129.34 | % | | | 12.25 | % | | | 129.34 | % | | | 14.37x | | | $ | 0.52 | | | | 3.15 | % | | | 49.00 | % | | $ | 2,309 | | | | 9.47 | % | | | 9.47 | % | | | 2.02 | % | | | 0.74 | % | | | 7.85 | % | | | 0.85 | % | | | 9.08 | % | | | | | | | | |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | $ | 14.69 | | | $ | 658.45 | | | $ | 0.95 | | | $ | 11.60 | | | | 15.46x | | | | 126.65 | % | | | 20.47 | % | | | 126.65 | % | | | 15.45x | | | $ | 0.70 | | | | 4.77 | % | | | 100.00 | % | | $ | 3,217 | | | | 16.16 | % | | | 16.16 | % | | | 0.71 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 7.76 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 7.76 | % | | | | | | | | |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 17.26 | | | $ | 1,119.95 | | | $ | 1.27 | | | $ | 17.40 | | | | 14.63x | | | | 99.20 | % | | | 13.30 | % | | | 154.44 | % | | | 13.54x | | | $ | 0.60 | | | | 3.48 | % | | | 50.85 | % | | $ | 8,419 | | | | 13.41 | % | | | 9.05 | % | | | 1.50 | % | | | 0.90 | % | | | 6.61 | % | | | 0.97 | % | | | 7.15 | % | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Averages | | | | | | $ | 18.67 | | | $ | 782.02 | | | $ | 1.36 | | | $ | 14.68 | | | | 16.48x | | | | 123.42 | % | | | 15.65 | % | | | 136.48 | % | | | 16.11x | | | $ | 0.45 | | | | 3.06 | % | | | 94.11 | % | | $ | 5,087 | | | | 12.95 | % | | | 11.93 | % | | | 1.14 | % | | | 0.85 | % | | | 7.01 | % | | | 0.95 | % | | | 7.84 | % | | | | | | | | |
Medians | | | | | | $ | 14.33 | | | $ | 696.12 | | | $ | 0.80 | | | $ | 12.20 | | | | 15.46x | | | | 118.96 | % | | | 14.02 | % | | | 129.34 | % | | | 15.02x | | | $ | 0.52 | | | | 3.15 | % | | | 56.33 | % | | $ | 4,582 | | | | 12.26 | % | | | 10.16 | % | | | 1.08 | % | | | 0.82 | % | | | 6.61 | % | | | 0.90 | % | | | 7.46 | % | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Comparable Group | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
BKMU | | Bank Mutual Corporation | | WI | | $ | 6.78 | | | $ | 315.73 | | | | NA | | | $ | 6.03 | | | | 21.87x | | | | 112.47 | % | | | 13.58 | % | | | 112.52 | % | | | NM | | | $ | 0.16 | | | | 2.36 | % | | | 48.39 | % | | $ | 2,328 | | | | 12.22 | % | | | 12.21 | % | | | NA | | | | 0.63 | % | | | 5.13 | % | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | | | | | | |
CFFN | | Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. | | KS | | $ | 12.60 | | | $ | 1,772.23 | | | $ | 0.56 | | | $ | 10.59 | | | | 22.50x | | | | 118.96 | % | | | 18.00 | % | | | 118.96 | % | | | 22.58x | | | $ | 0.30 | | | | 2.38 | % | | | 144.64 | % | | $ | 9,865 | | | | 15.13 | % | | | 15.13 | % | | | 0.54 | % | | | 0.82 | % | | | 5.00 | % | | | 0.82 | % | | | 4.98 | % | | | | | | | | |
DCOM | | Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. | | NY | | $ | 15.29 | | | $ | 563.48 | | | $ | 1.18 | | | $ | 12.38 | | | | 12.85x | | | | 123.53 | % | | | 12.85 | % | | | 140.69 | % | | | 12.98x | | | $ | 0.56 | | | | 3.66 | % | | | 47.06 | % | | $ | 4,384 | | | | 10.41 | % | | | 9.25 | % | | | 0.53 | % | | | 1.02 | % | | | 9.62 | % | | | 1.01 | % | | | 9.53 | % | | | | | | | | |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 14.33 | | | $ | 701.90 | | | $ | 0.40 | | | $ | 12.20 | | | | NM | | | | 117.47 | % | | | 24.82 | % | | | 120.73 | % | | | NM | | | $ | 0.28 | | | | 1.95 | % | | | 66.67 | % | | $ | 2,925 | | | | 21.12 | % | | | 20.67 | % | | | 1.34 | % | | | 0.75 | % | | | 2.95 | % | | | 0.77 | % | | | 3.02 | % | | | | | | | | |
NWBI | | Northwest Bancshares, Inc. | | PA | | $ | 12.00 | | | $ | 1,140.23 | | | $ | 0.65 | | | $ | 11.33 | | | | 16.90x | | | | 105.87 | % | | | 14.56 | % | | | 127.06 | % | | | 18.46x | | | $ | 0.52 | | | | 4.33 | % | | | 228.17 | % | | $ | 7,827 | | | | 13.76 | % | | | 11.73 | % | | | 1.85 | % | | | 0.82 | % | | | 5.87 | % | | | 0.75 | % | | | 5.37 | % | | | | | | | | |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | $ | 16.52 | | | $ | 281.02 | | | $ | 1.15 | | | $ | 12.77 | | | | 16.52x | | | | 129.34 | % | | | 12.25 | % | | | 129.34 | % | | | 14.37x | | | $ | 0.52 | | | | 3.15 | % | | | 49.00 | % | | $ | 2,309 | | | | 9.47 | % | | | 9.47 | % | | | 2.02 | % | | | 0.74 | % | | | 7.85 | % | | | 0.85 | % | | | 9.08 | % | | | | | | | | |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | $ | 14.69 | | | $ | 658.45 | | | $ | 0.95 | | | $ | 11.60 | | | | 15.46x | | | | 126.65 | % | | | 20.47 | % | | | 126.65 | % | | | 15.45x | | | $ | 0.70 | | | | 4.77 | % | | | 100.00 | % | | $ | 3,217 | | | | 16.16 | % | | | 16.16 | % | | | 0.71 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 7.76 | % | | | 1.35 | % | | | 7.76 | % | | | | | | | | |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | $ | 17.26 | | | $ | 1,119.95 | | | $ | 1.27 | | | $ | 17.40 | | | | 14.63x | | | | 99.20 | % | | | 13.30 | % | | | 154.44 | % | | | 13.54x | | | $ | 0.60 | | | | 3.48 | % | | | 50.85 | % | | $ | 8,419 | | | | 13.41 | % | | | 9.05 | % | | | 1.50 | % | | | 0.90 | % | | | 6.61 | % | | | 0.97 | % | | | 7.15 | % | | | | | | | | |
TRST | | TrustCo Bank Corp NY | | NY | | $ | 6.78 | | | $ | 643.38 | | | $ | 0.45 | | | $ | 4.11 | | | | 14.55x | | | | 165.00 | % | | | 14.02 | % | | | 165.23 | % | | | 15.02x | | | $ | 0.26 | | | | 3.87 | % | | | 56.33 | % | | $ | 4,582 | | | | 8.50 | % | | | 8.49 | % | | | 1.16 | % | | | 0.97 | % | | | 11.82 | % | | | 0.94 | % | | | 11.45 | % | | | | | | | | |
UBNK | | United Financial Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | $ | 13.63 | | | $ | 696.12 | | | $ | 0.66 | | | $ | 12.38 | | | | NM | | | | 110.13 | % | | | 13.50 | % | | | 136.01 | % | | | 20.68x | | | $ | 0.40 | | | | 2.93 | % | | | 235.29 | % | | $ | 5,314 | | | | 12.26 | % | | | 10.16 | % | | | 0.75 | % | | | 0.20 | % | | | 1.60 | % | | | 0.77 | % | | | 6.08 | % | | | | | | | | |
WSFS | | WSFS Financial Corporation | | DE | | $ | 75.51 | | | $ | 709.69 | | | $ | 6.32 | | | $ | 50.70 | | | | 13.02x | | | | 148.95 | % | | | 14.83 | % | | | 169.67 | % | | | 11.95x | | | $ | 0.60 | | | | 0.79 | % | | | 8.79 | % | | $ | 4,783 | | | | 9.96 | % | | | 8.85 | % | | | 0.99 | % | | | 1.18 | % | | | 12.85 | % | | | 1.28 | % | | | 14.02 | % | | | | | | | | |
(1) | Core income, on a diluted per-share basis. Core income is net income after taxes and before extraordinary items, less net income attributable to noncontrolling interest, gain on the sale of securities, amortization of intangibles, goodwill and nonrecurring items. Assumed tax rate is 35%. |
(2) | P/E = Price to earnings; P/B = Price to book; P/A = Price to assets; P/TB = Price to tangible book value; and P/Core = Price to core earnings. P/E and P/Core =NM if the ratio is negative or above 35x. |
(3) | Indicated 12 month dividend, based on last quarterly dividend declared. |
(4) | Indicated 12 month dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month earnings. |
(5) | ROAA (return on average assets) and ROAE (return on average equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month earnings and average equity and assets balances. |
(6) | Excludes from averages and medians those companies the subject of actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this report has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 21
P/TB ratio, the Company’s P/TB ratio at the midpoint value reflects an implied discount of 4.87%.
3.P/A Approach. P/A ratios are generally not as a reliable indicator of market value, as investors do not place significant weight on total assets as a determinant of market value. Investors place significantly greater weight on book value and earnings – which have received greater weight in our valuation analysis. At the $893.2 million midpoint value Kearny Financial’s pro forma P/A ratio equaled 21.49%. In comparison to the Peer Group’s average P/A ratio of 15.65%, Kearny Financial’s P/A ratio indicated a premium of 37.32% (versus a premium of 45.30% at the midpoint valuation in the Original Appraisal). In comparison to the Peer Group’s median P/A ratio of 14.02%, Kearny Financial’s P/A ratio at the $893.2 million midpoint value indicated a premium of 53.28% (versus a premium of 65.28% at the midpoint valuation in the Original Appraisal).
Valuation Conclusion
Based on the foregoing, it is our opinion that, as of January 16, 2015, the estimated aggregate pro forma valuation of the shares of the Company to be issued and outstanding at the end of the conversion offering – including (1) newly-issued shares representing the MHC’s current ownership interest in the Company; (2) exchange shares issued to existing public shareholders of the Company; and (3) shares issued to the Foundation – was $893,152,780 at the midpoint, equal to 89,315,278 shares at a per share value of $10.00. The resulting range of value and pro forma shares, all based on $10.00 per share, are as follows:
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | Total Shares | | | Offering Shares | | | Exchange Shares Issued to Public Shareholders | | | Foundation Shares | | | Exchange Ratio | |
Shares | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Maximum | | | 102,637,570 | | | | 78,775,000 | | | | 23,362,570 | | | | 500,000 | | | | 1.5156 | |
Midpoint | | | 89,315,278 | | | | 68,500,000 | | | | 20,315,278 | | | | 500,000 | | | | 1.3179 | |
Minimum | | | 75,992,987 | | | | 58,225,000 | | | | 17,267,987 | | | | 500,000 | | | | 1.1202 | |
| | | | | |
Distribution of Shares | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Maximum | | | 100.00 | % | | | 76.75 | % | | | 22.77 | % | | | 0.49 | % | | | | |
Midpoint | | | 100.00 | % | | | 76.69 | % | | | 22.75 | % | | | 0.56 | % | | | | |
Minimum | | | 100.00 | % | | | 76.62 | % | | | 22.72 | % | | | 0.66 | % | | | | |
| | | | | |
Aggregate Market Value at $10 per share | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Maximum | | $ | 1,026,375,700 | | | $ | 787,750,000 | | | $ | 233,625,700 | | | $ | 5,000,000 | | | | | |
Midpoint | | $ | 893,152,780 | | | $ | 685,000,000 | | | $ | 203,152,780 | | | $ | 5,000,000 | | | | | |
Minimum | | $ | 759,929,870 | | | $ | 582,250,000 | | | $ | 172,679,870 | | | $ | 5,000,000 | | | | | |
Establishment of the Exchange Ratio
Conversion regulations provide that in a conversion of a mutual holding company, the minority shareholders are entitled to exchange the public shares for newly issued shares in the fully converted company. The Boards of Directors of the MHC and KRNY have independently determined the exchange ratio, which has been designed to preserve the current aggregate
Boards of Directors
January 16, 2015
Page 22
percentage ownership in the Company held by the public shareholders. The exchange ratio to be received by the existing minority shareholders of the Company will be determined at the end of the offering, based on the total number of shares sold in the subscription, community and syndicated or firm commitment underwritten offerings and the final appraisal. Based on the valuation conclusion herein, the resulting offering value and the $10.00 per share offering price, the indicated exchange ratio at the midpoint is 1.3179 shares for every one public share held by public shareholders. Furthermore, based on the offering range of value, the indicated exchange ratio is 1.1202 at the minimum and1.5156 at the maximum. RP Financial expresses no opinion on the proposed exchange of newly issued Company shares for the shares held by the public shareholders or on the proposed exchange ratio.
|
Respectfully submitted, |
|
RP® FINANCIAL, LC. |
|
 |
|
Ronald S. Riggins |
President and Managing Director |
|
 |
|
Gregory E. Dunn |
Director |
EXHIBITS
LIST OF EXHIBITS
| | |
Exhibit Number | | Description |
| |
1 | | Stock Prices: As of January 16, 2015 |
| |
2 | | Pro Forma Analysis Sheet |
| |
3 | | Pro Forma Effect of Conversion Proceeds |
| |
4 | | Calculation of Minority Ownership Dilution in a Second Step Offering |
| |
5 | | Firm Qualifications Statement |
EXHIBIT 1
Stock Prices
As of January 16, 2015
RP® Financial, LC.
Exhibit 1-A
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Market Capitalization | | | Price Change Data | | | Current Per Share Financials | |
| | | | | | Price/ | | | Shares | | | Market | | | 52 Week (1) | | | | | | % Change From | | | LTM | | | LTM Core | | | BV/ | | | TBV/ | | | Assets/ | |
| | | | | | Share(1) | | | Outstanding | | | Capitalization | | | High | | | Low | | | Last Wk | | | Last Wk | | | 52 Wks (2) | | | MRY (2) | | | EPS (3) | | | EPS (3) | | | Share | | | Share (4) | | | Share | |
| | | | | | ($) | | | (000) | | | ($Mil) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | |
Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
ALLB | | Alliance Bancorp, Inc. of Pennsylvania | | PA | | | 17.73 | | | | 4,027 | | | | 71.4 | | | | 18.41 | | | | 15.10 | | | | 17.67 | | | | 0.37 | | | | 17.72 | | | | -3.70 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 16.30 | | | | 16.30 | | | | 105.15 | |
ANCB | | Anchor Bancorp | | WA | | | 20.52 | | | | 2,550 | | | | 52.3 | | | | 22.00 | | | | 16.75 | | | | 20.42 | | | | 0.49 | | | | 18.96 | | | | 0.59 | | | | 0.23 | | | | 0.22 | | | | 21.04 | | | | 21.04 | | | | 151.20 | |
ABCW | | Anchor BanCorp Wisconsin Inc. | | WI | | | 34.85 | | | | 9,245 | | | | 322.2 | | | | 37.96 | | | | 28.00 | | | | 34.83 | | | | 0.06 | | | | NA | | | | 1.19 | | | | 1.46 | | | | 1.39 | | | | 23.22 | | | | 23.22 | | | | 227.85 | |
ASBB | | ASB Bancorp, Inc. | | NC | | | 20.35 | | | | 4,378 | | | | 89.1 | | | | 21.96 | | | | 17.15 | | | | 21.00 | | | | -3.10 | | | | 16.35 | | | | -5.35 | | | | 0.50 | | | | 0.47 | | | | 21.53 | | | | 21.53 | | | | 171.07 | |
AF | | Astoria Financial Corporation | | NY | | | 12.48 | | | | 99,793 | | | | 1,245.4 | | | | 14.67 | | | | 11.96 | | | | 12.58 | | | | -0.79 | | | | -9.50 | | | | -6.59 | | | | 0.85 | | | | 0.85 | | | | 14.69 | | | | 12.83 | | | | 154.92 | |
AFCB | | Athens Bancshares Corporation | | TN | | | 25.74 | | | | 1,802 | | | | 46.4 | | | | 30.50 | | | | 19.00 | | | | 25.40 | | | | 1.34 | | | | 32.00 | | | | 1.34 | | | | 1.50 | | | | 1.53 | | | | 23.10 | | | | 23.03 | | | | 167.52 | |
ACFC | | Atlantic Coast Financial Corporation | | FL | | | 3.91 | | | | 15,509 | | | | 60.6 | | | | 4.49 | | | | 3.73 | | | | 3.95 | | | | -1.01 | | | | -11.14 | | | | -1.51 | | | | -0.99 | | | | -0.83 | | | | 4.54 | | | | 4.54 | | | | 46.03 | |
BKMU | | Bank Mutual Corporation | | WI | | | 6.78 | | | | 46,568 | | | | 315.7 | | | | 7.35 | | | | 5.74 | | | | 6.66 | | | | 1.80 | | | | -4.24 | | | | -1.17 | | | | 0.31 | | | | NA | | | | 6.03 | | | | 6.03 | | | | 50.00 | |
BFIN | | BankFinancial Corporation | | IL | | | 11.40 | | | | 21,102 | | | | 240.6 | | | | 12.17 | | | | 9.06 | | | | 11.57 | | | | -1.47 | | | | 19.75 | | | | -3.88 | | | | 0.37 | | | | 0.39 | | | | 8.59 | | | | 8.50 | | | | 67.34 | |
BNCL | | Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 10.73 | | | | 82,715 | | | | 887.5 | | | | 13.05 | | | | 10.03 | | | | 10.91 | | | | -1.65 | | | | 4.81 | | | | -3.81 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 0.23 | | | | 7.40 | | | | 5.84 | | | | 52.71 | |
BHBK | | Blue Hills Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 13.01 | | | | 28,467 | | | | 370.4 | | | | 13.74 | | | | 11.25 | | | | 13.23 | | | | -1.66 | | | | NA | | | | -4.20 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 14.41 | | | | 13.92 | | | | 59.25 | |
BOFI | | BofI Holding, Inc. | | CA | | | 80.21 | | | | 14,814 | | | | 1,188.2 | | | | 106.55 | | | | 64.62 | | | | 80.34 | | | | -0.16 | | | | 1.56 | | | | 3.08 | | | | 4.20 | | | | 4.35 | | | | 27.57 | | | | 27.57 | | | | 325.71 | |
BYFC | | Broadway Financial Corporation | | CA | | | 1.31 | | | | 29,077 | | | | 38.1 | | | | 2.95 | | | | 0.96 | | | | 1.46 | | | | -10.27 | | | | 9.18 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.09 | | | | 0.09 | | | | 1.36 | | | | 1.36 | | | | 11.62 | |
BLMT | | BSB Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 18.58 | | | | 9,063 | | | | 168.4 | | | | 19.35 | | | | 14.93 | | | | 18.90 | | | | -1.69 | | | | 21.76 | | | | -0.27 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 14.91 | | | | 14.91 | | | | 147.38 | |
CBNJ | | Cape Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 9.06 | | | | 11,475 | | | | 104.0 | | | | 11.26 | | | | 8.82 | | | | 9.23 | | | | -1.84 | | | | -13.05 | | | | -3.72 | | | | 0.57 | | | | 0.57 | | | | 12.19 | | | | 10.21 | | | | 94.27 | |
CFFN | | Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. | | KS | | | 12.60 | | | | 140,653 | | | | 1,772.2 | | | | 13.12 | | | | 11.61 | | | | 12.42 | | | | 1.45 | | | | 5.00 | | | | -1.41 | | | | 0.56 | | | | 0.56 | | | | 10.59 | | | | 10.59 | | | | 70.14 | |
CARV | | Carver Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 5.86 | | | | 3,696 | | | | 21.7 | | | | 17.87 | | | | 5.40 | | | | 5.73 | | | | 2.27 | | | | -18.61 | | | | -6.24 | | | | -0.32 | | | | -0.01 | | | | 2.30 | | | | 2.30 | | | | 174.27 | |
CFBK | | Central Federal Corporation | | OH | | | 1.29 | | | | 15,824 | | | | 20.4 | | | | 1.78 | | | | 1.18 | | | | 1.28 | | | | 0.78 | | | | -6.52 | | | | 5.74 | | | | 0.05 | | | | 0.01 | | | | 1.45 | | | | 1.45 | | | | 19.44 | |
CHFN | | Charter Financial Corporation | | GA | | | 11.13 | | | | 17,025 | | | | 189.5 | | | | 11.56 | | | | 10.02 | | | | 11.30 | | | | -1.50 | | | | 3.44 | | | | -2.79 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 12.32 | | | | 12.06 | | | | 59.35 | |
CHEV | | Cheviot Financial Corp. | | OH | | | 13.40 | | | | 6,708 | | | | 89.9 | | | | 14.25 | | | | 10.12 | | | | 13.60 | | | | -1.47 | | | | 30.35 | | | | -5.70 | | | | 0.40 | | | | 0.34 | | | | 14.13 | | | | 12.53 | | | | 85.40 | |
CBNK | | Chicopee Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 16.04 | | | | 5,311 | | | | 85.2 | | | | 17.96 | | | | 13.56 | | | | 16.54 | | | | -3.02 | | | | -7.28 | | | | -4.24 | | | | -0.04 | | | | -0.05 | | | | 16.69 | | | | 16.69 | | | | 117.84 | |
CSBK | | Clifton Bancorp Inc. | | NJ | | | 13.35 | | | | 26,676 | | | | 356.1 | | | | 13.78 | | | | 11.29 | | | | 13.27 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 1.01 | | | | -1.77 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 13.41 | | | | 13.41 | | | | 45.42 | |
CWAY | | Coastway Bancorp, Inc. | | RI | | | 11.25 | | | | 4,949 | | | | 55.7 | | | | 11.89 | | | | 10.04 | | | | 11.33 | | | | -0.71 | | | | 3.02 | | | | -3.18 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 14.22 | | | | 14.22 | | | | 91.22 | |
DCOM | | Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. | | NY | | | 15.29 | | | | 36,853 | | | | 563.5 | | | | 18.23 | | | | 14.02 | | | | 15.45 | | | | -1.04 | | | | -9.42 | | | | -6.08 | | | | 1.19 | | | | 1.18 | | | | 12.38 | | | | 10.87 | | | | 118.97 | |
ENFC | | Entegra Financial Corp. | | NC | | | 14.69 | | | | 6,546 | | | | 96.2 | | | | 14.94 | | | | 12.60 | | | | 14.69 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NA | | | | 2.08 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 15.94 | | | | 15.94 | | | | 135.10 | |
ESSA | | ESSA Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 11.90 | | | | 11,444 | | | | 136.2 | | | | 12.25 | | | | 10.20 | | | | 11.96 | | | | -0.50 | | | | 4.02 | | | | -0.83 | | | | 0.79 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 14.44 | | | | 13.34 | | | | 137.61 | |
EVER | | EverBank Financial Corp | | FL | | | 17.90 | | | | 123,058 | | | | 2,202.7 | | | | 20.61 | | | | 16.40 | | | | 18.09 | | | | -1.05 | | | | 0.90 | | | | -6.09 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 1.07 | | | | 12.77 | | | | 12.36 | | | | 166.67 | |
FCAP | | First Capital, Inc. | | IN | | | 24.70 | | | | 2,741 | | | | 67.7 | | | | 24.77 | | | | 20.00 | | | | 24.75 | | | | -0.20 | | | | 21.08 | | | | 1.48 | | | | 2.03 | | | | 1.98 | | | | 20.50 | | | | 18.54 | | | | 167.96 | |
FBNK | | First Connecticut Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 15.51 | | | | 16,026 | | | | 248.6 | | | | 16.75 | | | | 14.23 | | | | 15.31 | | | | 1.31 | | | | -0.45 | | | | -4.96 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 14.56 | | | | 14.56 | | | | 149.48 | |
FDEF | | First Defiance Financial Corp. | | OH | | | 33.38 | | | | 9,343 | | | | 311.9 | | | | 35.70 | | | | 24.88 | | | | 33.45 | | | | -0.21 | | | | 32.41 | | | | -2.00 | | | | 2.29 | | | | 2.31 | | | | 29.69 | | | | 22.84 | | | | 230.23 | |
FFNM | | First Federal of Northern Michigan Bancorp, Inc. | | MI | | | 5.60 | | | | 3,727 | | | | 20.9 | | | | 6.30 | | | | 4.69 | | | | 5.48 | | | | 2.19 | | | | 10.45 | | | | 2.00 | | | | 0.52 | | | | NA | | | | 8.04 | | | | 7.68 | | | | 83.69 | |
FFNW | | First Financial Northwest, Inc. | | WA | | | 12.24 | | | | 15,379 | | | | 188.2 | | | | 12.43 | | | | 9.93 | | | | 12.06 | | | | 1.49 | | | | 13.54 | | | | 1.66 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 11.76 | | | | 11.76 | | | | 59.52 | |
FBC | | Flagstar Bancorp, Inc. | | MI | | | 16.25 | | | | 56,271 | | | | 914.4 | | | | 22.88 | | | | 14.41 | | | | 16.38 | | | | -0.79 | | | | -18.87 | | | | 3.31 | | | | 0.98 | | | | 2.42 | | | | 19.28 | | | | 19.28 | | | | 171.05 | |
FXCB | | Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 16.47 | | | | 12,011 | | | | 197.8 | | | | 18.08 | | | | 15.68 | | | | 16.62 | | | | -0.90 | | | | -5.07 | | | | -1.20 | | | | 0.66 | | | | 0.66 | | | | 14.78 | | | | 14.78 | | | | 89.47 | |
FSBW | | FS Bancorp, Inc. | | WA | | | 18.23 | | | | 3,236 | | | | 59.0 | | | | 18.60 | | | | 15.50 | | | | 18.47 | | | | -1.30 | | | | 7.24 | | | | -0.11 | | | | 1.19 | | | | 1.16 | | | | 19.78 | | | | 19.78 | | | | 145.75 | |
GTWN | | Georgetown Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 16.55 | | | | 1,828 | | | | 30.2 | | | | 18.56 | | | | 14.08 | | | | 16.75 | | | | -1.19 | | | | 6.16 | | | | 0.61 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 16.45 | | | | 16.45 | | | | 147.59 | |
HBK | | Hamilton Bancorp, Inc. | | MD | | | 12.60 | | | | 3,413 | | | | 43.0 | | | | 14.48 | | | | 10.04 | | | | 12.99 | | | | -3.00 | | | | -10.00 | | | | -3.08 | | | | -0.28 | | | | -0.34 | | | | 17.31 | | | | 16.48 | | | | 85.92 | |
HFFC | | HF Financial Corp. | | SD | | | 14.20 | | | | 7,055 | | | | 100.2 | | | | 15.00 | | | | 12.92 | | | | 14.35 | | | | -1.07 | | | | 7.14 | | | | 1.76 | | | | 1.06 | | | | 1.05 | | | | 14.54 | | | | 13.86 | | | | 178.20 | |
HIFS | | Hingham Institution for Savings | | MA | | | 82.24 | | | | 2,129 | | | | 175.1 | | | | 90.77 | | | | 66.12 | | | | 86.04 | | | | -4.42 | | | | 4.90 | | | | -5.48 | | | | 10.44 | | | | NA | | | | 57.08 | | | | 57.08 | | | | 729.16 | |
HMNF | | HMN Financial, Inc. | | MN | | | 12.55 | | | | 4,470 | | | | 56.1 | | | | 13.95 | | | | 8.94 | | | | 12.56 | | | | -0.08 | | | | 17.51 | | | | 1.21 | | | | 4.86 | | | | 4.86 | | | | 14.45 | | | | 14.45 | | | | 132.97 | |
HBCP | | Home Bancorp, Inc. | | LA | | | 22.89 | | | | 7,115 | | | | 162.9 | | | | 23.50 | | | | 19.12 | | | | 22.95 | | | | -0.26 | | | | 10.79 | | | | -0.22 | | | | 1.27 | | | | 1.57 | | | | 21.24 | | | | 20.58 | | | | 177.07 | |
HFBL | | Home Federal Bancorp, Inc. of Louisiana | | LA | | | 19.30 | | | | 2,198 | | | | 42.4 | | | | 20.30 | | | | 17.32 | | | | 19.30 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 11.30 | | | | -1.18 | | | | 1.37 | | | | 1.32 | | | | 19.36 | | | | 19.36 | | | | 154.88 | |
HMST | | HomeStreet, Inc. | | WA | | | 17.33 | | | | 14,857 | | | | 257.5 | | | | 20.05 | | | | 15.95 | | | | 17.46 | | | | -0.74 | | | | -12.25 | | | | -0.46 | | | | 1.05 | | | | 1.20 | | | | 19.83 | | | | 18.86 | | | | 233.88 | |
IROQ | | IF Bancorp, Inc. | | IL | | | 16.54 | | | | 4,378 | | | | 72.4 | | | | 17.49 | | | | 15.90 | | | | 16.79 | | | | -1.49 | | | | -2.14 | | | | -2.19 | | | | 0.86 | | | | 0.89 | | | | 18.78 | | | | 18.78 | | | | 123.39 | |
ISBC | | Investors Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 10.81 | | | | 357,759 | | | | 3,867.4 | | | | 11.36 | | | | 9.68 | | | | 10.81 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 8.35 | | | | -3.70 | | | | 0.34 | | | | 0.40 | | | | 9.92 | | | | 9.66 | | | | 49.85 | |
JXSB | | Jacksonville Bancorp, Inc. | | IL | | | 22.14 | | | | 1,799 | | | | 39.8 | | | | 24.00 | | | | 19.40 | | | | 23.00 | | | | -3.74 | | | | 13.07 | | | | -3.74 | | | | 1.65 | | | | 1.50 | | | | 25.02 | | | | 23.50 | | | | 173.42 | |
LPSB | | La Porte Bancorp, Inc. | | IN | | | 12.65 | | | | 5,727 | | | | 72.4 | | | | 12.86 | | | | 10.60 | | | | 12.44 | | | | 1.68 | | | | 17.13 | | | | 1.28 | | | | 0.78 | | | | 0.76 | | | | 14.62 | | | | 13.08 | | | | 89.16 | |
LABC | | Louisiana Bancorp, Inc. | | LA | | | 22.20 | | | | 2,797 | | | | 62.1 | | | | 24.10 | | | | 17.91 | | | | 22.10 | | | | 0.45 | | | | 21.84 | | | | -1.11 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 20.67 | | | | 20.67 | | | | 115.04 | |
MCBK | | Madison County Financial, Inc. | | NE | | | 20.10 | | | | 3,032 | | | | 61.0 | | | | 23.00 | | | | 16.74 | | | | 20.10 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 14.53 | | | | 3.93 | | | | 1.02 | | | | 1.05 | | | | 20.35 | | | | 20.01 | | | | 99.56 | |
MLVF | | Malvern Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 12.55 | | | | 6,558 | | | | 82.3 | | | | 12.79 | | | | 10.13 | | | | 12.56 | | | | -0.08 | | | | 16.20 | | | | 3.80 | �� | | | 0.05 | | | | 0.05 | | | | 11.71 | | | | 11.71 | | | | 82.68 | |
MELR | | Melrose Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 13.07 | | | | 2,830 | | | | 37.0 | | | | 14.12 | | | | 12.75 | | | | 13.18 | | | | -0.83 | | | | NA | | | | -1.28 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 75.17 | |
EBSB | | Meridian Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 11.30 | | | | 54,708 | | | | 618.2 | | | | 11.60 | | | | 9.16 | | | | 11.27 | | | | 0.27 | | | | 19.77 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 0.38 | | | | 0.30 | | | | 10.44 | | | | 10.19 | | | | 57.92 | |
CASH | | Meta Financial Group, Inc. | | SD | | | 32.78 | | | | 6,194 | | | | 203.0 | | | | 46.38 | | | | 32.24 | | | | 34.00 | | | | -3.59 | | | | -19.91 | | | | -6.45 | | | | 2.53 | | | | 2.62 | | | | 28.33 | | | | 27.91 | | | | 331.62 | |
NVSL | | Naugatuck Valley Financial Corporation | | CT | | | 9.17 | | | | 7,002 | | | | 64.2 | | | | 9.24 | | | | 7.09 | | | | 8.82 | | | | 3.91 | | | | 27.65 | | | | 7.07 | | | | -0.31 | | | | -0.25 | | | | 8.49 | | | | 8.49 | | | | 69.85 | |
NHTB | | New Hampshire Thrift Bancshares, Inc. | | NH | | | 15.60 | | | | 8,258 | | | | 128.8 | | | | 16.12 | | | | 14.05 | | | | 15.40 | | | | 1.30 | | | | 2.36 | | | | -0.13 | | | | 1.09 | | | | 1.16 | | | | 15.88 | | | | 9.24 | | | | 179.60 | |
NYCB | | New York Community Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 15.45 | | | | 442,647 | | | | 6,838.9 | | | | 17.36 | | | | 13.75 | | | | 15.74 | | | | -1.84 | | | | -9.38 | | | | -3.44 | | | | 1.07 | | | | 1.07 | | | | 13.05 | | | | 7.53 | | | | 109.97 | |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 14.33 | | | | 48,981 | | | | 701.9 | | | | 15.15 | | | | 12.27 | | | | 14.35 | | | | -0.14 | | | | 11.26 | | | | -3.18 | | | | 0.39 | | | | 0.40 | | | | 12.20 | | | | 11.87 | | | | 59.71 | |
NWBI | | Northwest Bancshares, Inc. | | PA | | | 12.00 | | | | 95,019 | | | | 1,140.2 | | | | 15.11 | | | | 11.79 | | | | 12.04 | | | | -0.33 | | | | -18.09 | | | | -4.23 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 0.65 | | | | 11.33 | | | | 9.44 | | | | 82.37 | |
OSHC | | Ocean Shore Holding Co. | | NJ | | | 14.50 | | | | 6,421 | | | | 93.1 | | | | 15.00 | | | | 13.30 | | | | 14.16 | | | | 2.40 | | | | 5.61 | | | | 1.26 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 16.25 | | | | 15.45 | | | | 161.98 | |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 16.52 | | | | 17,011 | | | | 281.0 | | | | 19.47 | | | | 13.94 | | | | 16.27 | | | | 1.54 | | | | -3.45 | | | | -3.62 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 1.15 | | | | 12.77 | | | | 12.77 | | | | 135.72 | |
ONFC | | Oneida Financial Corp. | | NY | | | 12.85 | | | | 7,022 | | | | 90.2 | | | | 13.85 | | | | 12.12 | | | | 12.85 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 5.50 | | | | -1.15 | | | | 0.92 | | | | 0.75 | | | | 13.51 | | | | 9.75 | | | | 112.04 | |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 14.69 | | | | 44,823 | | | | 658.4 | | | | 16.84 | | | | 13.69 | | | | 14.61 | | | | 0.55 | | | | -4.98 | | | | -4.61 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 11.60 | | | | 11.60 | | | | 71.77 | |
PBHC | | Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 9.81 | | | | 4,352 | | | | 42.7 | | | | 10.20 | | | | 8.20 | | | | 9.92 | | | | -1.11 | | | | 19.96 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 0.57 | | | | 0.52 | | | | 7.39 | | | | 6.34 | | | | 130.98 | |
PBCT | | People’s United Financial, Inc. | | CT | | | 14.28 | | | | 307,800 | | | | 4,395.4 | | | | 15.50 | | | | 13.61 | | | | 14.59 | | | | -2.12 | | | | -7.09 | | | | -5.93 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 15.05 | | | | 8.22 | | | | 116.95 | |
PBSK | | Poage Bankshares, Inc. | | KY | | | 14.88 | | | | 3,882 | | | | 57.8 | | | | 16.60 | | | | 12.46 | | | | 14.65 | | | | 1.57 | | | | 5.91 | | | | 0.07 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 17.21 | | | | 16.63 | | | | 106.07 | |
PBCP | | Polonia Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 10.39 | | | | 3,336 | | | | 34.7 | | | | 10.91 | | | | 8.80 | | | | 10.45 | | | | -0.57 | | | | 2.87 | | | | -0.57 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 11.64 | | | | 11.64 | | | | 89.30 | |
PROV | | Provident Financial Holdings, Inc. | | CA | | | 15.10 | | | | 9,152 | | | | 138.2 | | | | 16.18 | | | | 13.75 | | | | 15.37 | | | | -1.76 | | | | 3.85 | | | | -0.20 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 15.84 | | | | 15.84 | | | | 120.94 | |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 17.26 | | | | 64,887 | | | | 1,120.0 | | | | 19.28 | | | | 16.06 | | | | 17.48 | | | | -1.26 | | | | -6.25 | | | | -4.43 | | | | 1.18 | | | | 1.27 | | | | 17.40 | | | | 11.18 | | | | 129.74 | |
PBIP | | Prudential Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 12.15 | | | | 9,367 | | | | 113.8 | | | | 12.50 | | | | 10.45 | | | | 12.25 | | | | -0.82 | | | | 14.41 | | | | -2.80 | | | | 0.19 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 13.56 | | | | 13.56 | | | | 56.10 | |
PULB | | Pulaski Financial Corp. | | MO | | | 12.09 | | | | 12,073 | | | | 146.0 | | | | 12.90 | | | | 9.14 | | | | 12.39 | | | | -2.42 | | | | 3.51 | | | | -1.95 | | | | 0.88 | | | | 0.88 | | | | 9.60 | | | | 9.26 | | | | 114.31 | |
RVSB | | Riverview Bancorp, Inc. | | WA | | | 4.38 | | | | 22,472 | | | | 98.4 | | | | 4.55 | | | | 3.02 | | | | 4.43 | | | | -1.13 | | | | 44.08 | | | | -2.23 | | | | 0.86 | | | | 0.86 | | | | 4.46 | | | | 3.33 | | | | 37.45 | |
RP® Financial, LC.
Exhibit 1-A
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part One
Prices As of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Market Capitalization | | | Price Change Data | | | Current Per Share Financials | |
| | | | | | Price/ | | | Shares | | | Market | | | 52 Week (1) | | | | | | % Change From | | | LTM | | | LTM Core | | | BV/ | | | TBV/ | | | Assets/ | |
| | | | | | Share(1) | | | Outstanding | | | Capitalization | | | High | | | Low | | | Last Wk | | | Last Wk | | | 52 Wks (2) | | | MRY (2) | | | EPS (3) | | | EPS (3) | | | Share | | | Share (4) | | | Share | |
| | | | | | ($) | | | (000) | | | ($Mil) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | | | ($) | |
Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
SVBI | | Severn Bancorp, Inc. | | MD | | | 4.57 | | | | 10,067 | | | | 46.0 | | | | 5.04 | | | | 4.26 | | | | 4.50 | | | | 1.56 | | | | -6.35 | | | | 0.68 | | | | -0.62 | | | | -0.62 | | | | 5.57 | | | | 5.54 | | | | 76.42 | |
SIFI | | SI Financial Group, Inc. | | CT | | | 11.21 | | | | 12,783 | | | | 143.3 | | | | 12.00 | | | | 10.66 | | | | 11.01 | | | | 1.82 | | | | -4.68 | | | | -1.06 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 0.38 | | | | 12.21 | | | | 10.74 | | | | 104.84 | |
SBCP | | Sunshine Bancorp, Inc. | | FL | | | 12.40 | | | | 4,232 | | | | 52.5 | | | | 12.73 | | | | 11.21 | | | | 12.25 | | | | 1.22 | | | | NA | | | | 1.39 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 15.05 | | | | 15.05 | | | | 52.66 | |
TBNK | | Territorial Bancorp Inc. | | HI | | | 21.42 | | | | 9,970 | | | | 213.5 | | | | 23.11 | | | | 19.56 | | | | 21.54 | | | | -0.56 | | | | -5.01 | | | | -0.60 | | | | 1.51 | | | | 1.40 | | | | 21.77 | | | | 21.77 | | | | 166.14 | |
TSBK | | Timberland Bancorp, Inc. | | WA | | | 10.55 | | | | 7,053 | | | | 74.4 | | | | 11.83 | | | | 9.02 | | | | 10.62 | | | | -0.66 | | | | 5.18 | | | | -0.47 | | | | 0.80 | | | | 0.81 | | | | 11.75 | | | | 10.94 | | | | 105.71 | |
TRST | | TrustCo Bank Corp NY | | NY | | | 6.78 | | | | 94,893 | | | | 643.4 | | | | 7.50 | | | | 6.20 | | | | 6.77 | | | | 0.15 | | | | -2.45 | | | | -6.61 | | | | 0.47 | | | | 0.45 | | | | 4.11 | | | | 4.10 | | | | 48.29 | |
UCBA | | United Community Bancorp | | IN | | | 11.88 | | | | 4,659 | | | | 55.3 | | | | 12.58 | | | | 10.41 | | | | 11.83 | | | | 0.42 | | | | 10.20 | | | | 2.15 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 0.44 | | | | 14.95 | | | | 14.30 | | | | 112.23 | |
UCFC | | United Community Financial Corp. | | OH | | | 5.12 | | | | 49,689 | | | | 254.4 | | | | 5.62 | | | | 3.17 | | | | 5.38 | | | | -4.83 | | | | 41.05 | | | | -4.66 | | | | 0.98 | | | | 0.99 | | | | 4.70 | | | | 4.70 | | | | 36.26 | |
UBNK | | United Financial Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 13.63 | | | | 51,073 | | | | 696.1 | | | | 14.67 | | | | 12.01 | | | | 13.67 | | | | -0.29 | | | | -4.35 | | | | -5.08 | | | | 0.17 | | | | 0.66 | | | | 12.38 | | | | 10.02 | | | | 104.04 | |
WSBF | | Waterstone Financial, Inc. | | WI | | | 13.24 | | | | 34,420 | | | | 455.7 | | | | 13.33 | | | | 10.08 | | | | 12.95 | | | | 2.24 | | | | 25.35 | | | | 0.68 | | | | 0.36 | | | | 0.36 | | | | 13.03 | | | | 13.01 | | | | 52.28 | |
WAYN | | Wayne Savings Bancshares, Inc. | | OH | | | 13.20 | | | | 2,822 | | | | 37.2 | | | | 14.59 | | | | 10.58 | | | | 13.11 | | | | 0.69 | | | | 23.25 | | | | -1.49 | | | | 0.88 | | | | 0.89 | | | | 14.24 | | | | 13.63 | | | | 146.59 | |
WEBK | | Wellesley Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 18.90 | | | | 2,454 | | | | 46.4 | | | | 20.00 | | | | 17.52 | | | | 18.95 | | | | -0.26 | | | | -4.50 | | | | -1.52 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 19.89 | | | | 19.89 | | | | 206.01 | |
WBB | | Westbury Bancorp, Inc. | | WI | | | 16.05 | | | | 5,022 | | | | 80.6 | | | | 16.86 | | | | 13.90 | | | | 16.30 | | | | -1.53 | | | | 15.38 | | | | -2.13 | | | | -0.31 | | | | -0.22 | | | | 17.04 | | | | 17.04 | | | | 113.25 | |
WFD | | Westfield Financial, Inc. | | MA | | | 7.24 | | | | 18,794 | | | | 136.1 | | | | 8.00 | | | | 6.85 | | | | 7.19 | | | | 0.70 | | | | -0.28 | | | | -1.36 | | | | 0.33 | | | | 0.31 | | | | 7.67 | | | | 7.67 | | | | 69.77 | |
WBKC | | Wolverine Bancorp, Inc. | | MI | | | 23.75 | | | | 2,268 | | | | 53.9 | | | | 24.10 | | | | 21.45 | | | | 23.99 | | | | -1.00 | | | | 7.95 | | | | -0.84 | | | | 0.81 | | | | 0.81 | | | | 27.05 | | | | 27.05 | | | | 149.31 | |
WSFS | | WSFS Financial Corporation | | DE | | | 75.51 | | | | 9,399 | | | | 709.7 | | | | 79.97 | | | | 63.74 | | | | 75.04 | | | | 0.63 | | | | 0.29 | | | | -1.79 | | | | 5.80 | | | | 6.32 | | | | 50.70 | | | | 44.50 | | | | 508.87 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
MHCs | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
WVFC | | WVS Financial Corp. | | PA | | | 10.90 | | | | 2,050 | | | | 22.3 | | | | 12.50 | | | | 10.75 | | | | 10.81 | | | | 0.83 | | | | -11.38 | | | | 1.11 | | | | 0.50 | | | | 0.51 | | | | 15.50 | | | | 15.50 | | | | 154.72 | |
GCBC | | Greene County Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NY | | | 29.50 | | | | 4,217 | | | | 124.4 | | | | 30.87 | | | | 24.97 | | | | 29.50 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 16.46 | | | | -1.99 | | | | 1.55 | | | | 1.55 | | | | 14.89 | | | | 14.89 | | | | 165.77 | |
KRNY | | Kearny Financial Corp. (MHC) | | NJ | | | 13.68 | | | | 67,375 | | | | 921.7 | | | | 16.23 | | | | 10.91 | | | | 13.64 | | | | 0.29 | | | | 17.02 | | | | -0.51 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 0.17 | | | | 7.30 | | | | 5.68 | | | | 52.41 | |
KFFB | | Kentucky First Federal Bancorp (MHC) | | KY | | | 8.07 | | | | 8,520 | | | | 68.8 | | | | 8.97 | | | | 7.47 | | | | 8.02 | | | | 0.61 | | | | -1.59 | | | | -1.22 | | | | 0.23 | | | | 0.23 | | | | 7.84 | | | | 6.15 | | | | 34.71 | |
LSBK | | Lake Shore Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NY | | | 13.35 | | | | 5,939 | | | | 79.3 | | | | 14.00 | | | | 11.95 | | | | 13.60 | | | | -1.84 | | | | 8.71 | | | | -1.55 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 11.74 | | | | 11.74 | | | | 81.93 | |
MGYR | | Magyar Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NJ | | | 8.20 | | | | 5,815 | | | | 47.7 | | | | 9.20 | | | | 7.36 | | | | 8.35 | | | | -1.80 | | | | 11.26 | | | | -2.84 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 7.90 | | | | 7.90 | | | | 91.21 | |
MSBF | | MSB Financial Corp. (MHC) | | NJ | | | 10.57 | | | | 5,010 | | | | 53.0 | | | | 10.75 | | | | 7.00 | | | | 10.15 | | | | 4.14 | | | | 29.85 | | | | 3.12 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 8.21 | | | | 8.21 | | | | 68.95 | |
NECB | | NorthEast Community Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NY | | | 7.13 | | | | 12,376 | | | | 88.2 | | | | 7.44 | | | | 6.55 | | | | 7.06 | | | | 0.99 | | | | -1.11 | | | | -1.25 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 8.37 | | | | 8.28 | | | | 40.57 | |
OFED | | Oconee Federal Financial Corp. (MHC) | | SC | | | 20.01 | | | | 5,871 | | | | 117.5 | | | | 21.50 | | | | 16.73 | | | | 20.01 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 13.47 | | | | 0.05 | | | | 0.66 | | | | NA | | | | 13.27 | | | | 13.27 | | | | 60.82 | |
PSBH | | PSB Holdings, Inc. (MHC) | | CT | | | 7.51 | | | | 6,542 | | | | 49.1 | | | | 9.20 | | | | 6.04 | | | | 7.58 | | | | -0.94 | | | | 17.70 | | | | -3.48 | | | | 0.18 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 7.93 | | | | 6.87 | | | | 72.14 | |
TFSL | | TFS Financial Corporation (MHC) | | OH | | | 14.12 | | | | 299,345 | | | | 4,226.8 | | | | 15.38 | | | | 11.25 | | | | 14.25 | | | | -0.91 | | | | 19.86 | | | | -5.14 | | | | 0.22 | | | | NA | | | | 6.10 | | | | 6.07 | | | | 39.43 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Under Acquisition | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
CMSB | | CMS Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 12.95 | | | | 1,863 | | | | 24.1 | | | | 13.00 | | | | 8.95 | | | | 12.96 | | | | -0.08 | | | | 37.77 | | | | 0.54 | | | | 0.33 | | | | 0.44 | | | | 12.01 | | | | 12.01 | | | | 146.74 | |
COBK | | Colonial Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 13.31 | | | | 3,860 | | | | 51.4 | | | | 13.97 | | | | 10.11 | | | | 13.35 | | | | -0.30 | | | | 5.97 | | | | -0.67 | | | | 0.27 | | | | 0.27 | | | | 16.27 | | | | 16.27 | | | | 143.18 | |
ESBF | | ESB Financial Corporation | | PA | | | 17.71 | | | | 18,029 | | | | 319.3 | | | | 19.49 | | | | 11.46 | | | | 17.54 | | | | 0.97 | | | | 32.96 | | | | -6.49 | | | | 0.97 | | | | 0.96 | | | | 11.59 | | | | 9.25 | | | | 107.90 | |
HBNK | | Hampden Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 19.63 | | | | 5,498 | | | | 107.9 | | | | 21.49 | | | | 15.05 | | | | 20.16 | | | | -2.63 | | | | 22.31 | | | | -7.45 | | | | 0.83 | | | | 0.88 | | | | 15.49 | | | | 15.49 | | | | 128.35 | |
HBOS | | Heritage Financial Group, Inc. | | GA | | | 24.61 | | | | 9,190 | | | | 226.2 | | | | 26.11 | | | | 17.28 | | | | 25.42 | | | | -3.19 | | | | 30.56 | | | | -4.98 | | | | 1.12 | | | | 1.38 | | | | 17.42 | | | | 16.02 | | | | 191.02 | |
HCBK | | Hudson City Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 9.12 | | | | 528,765 | | | | 4,819.7 | | | | 10.35 | | | | 8.53 | | | | 9.56 | | | | -4.65 | | | | -1.78 | | | | -9.93 | | | | 0.33 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 9.11 | | | | 8.82 | | | | 70.28 | |
PEOP | | Peoples Federal Bancshares, Inc. | | MA | | | 21.31 | | | | 6,239 | | | | 133.0 | | | | 22.97 | | | | 17.66 | | | | 21.68 | | | | -1.71 | | | | 19.12 | | | | -5.46 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 0.34 | | | | 16.65 | | | | 16.65 | | | | 96.37 | |
SMPL | | Simplicity Bancorp, Inc. | | CA | | | 17.16 | | | | 7,393 | | | | 126.9 | | | | 18.43 | | | | 15.61 | | | | 17.28 | | | | -0.69 | | | | 5.15 | | | | 0.06 | | | | 0.72 | | | | 0.76 | | | | 18.60 | | | | 18.07 | | | | 116.77 | |
SIBC | | State Investors Bancorp, Inc. | | LA | | | 20.76 | | | | 2,308 | | | | 47.9 | | | | 20.80 | | | | 14.97 | | | | 20.65 | | | | 0.53 | | | | 36.13 | | | | 0.19 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 17.99 | | | | 17.99 | | | | 116.50 | |
(1) | Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share. |
(2) | Or since offering price if converted of first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized. |
(3) | EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing 12 month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis. |
(4) | Excludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.). |
(5) | ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances. |
(6) | Annualized based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement. |
(7) | Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month earnings. |
(8) | Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics. |
(9) | For MHC institutions, market value reflects share price multiplied by public (non-MHC) shares. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Copyright (c) 2015 by RP® Financial, LC.
RP® Financial, LC.
Exhibit 1-B
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Key Financial Ratios | | | Asset Quality Ratios | | | Pricing Ratios | | | Dividend Data (6) | |
| | | | | | Equity/ | | | Tang Equity/ | | | Reported Earnings | | | Core Earnings | | | NPAs/ | | | Rsvs/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Div/ | | | Dividend | | | Payout | |
| | | | | | Assets(1) | | | Assets(1) | | | ROA(5) | | | ROE(5) | | | ROA(5) | | | ROE(5) | | | Assets | | | NPLs | | | Earnings | | | Book | | | Assets | | | Tang Book | | | Core Earnings | | | Share | | | Yield | | | Ratio (7) | |
| | | | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | (%) | |
Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
ALLB | | Alliance Bancorp, Inc. of Pennsylvania | | PA | | | 15.50 | | | | 15.50 | | | | 0.46 | | | | 2.84 | | | | 0.46 | | | | 2.84 | | | | 1.93 | | | | 75.10 | | | | 36.94 | | | | 108.76 | | | | 16.86 | | | | 108.76 | | | | 36.94 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 1.35 | | | | 45.83 | |
ANCB | | Anchor Bancorp | | WA | | | 13.92 | | | | 13.92 | | | | 0.14 | | | | 1.03 | | | | 0.13 | | | | 0.97 | | | | 4.68 | | | | 33.39 | | | | NM | | | | 97.52 | | | | 13.57 | | | | 97.52 | | | | 95.05 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
ABCW | | Anchor BanCorp Wisconsin Inc. | | WI | | | 10.19 | | | | 10.19 | | | | 0.62 | | | | 6.39 | | | | 0.59 | | | | 6.10 | | | | 4.60 | | | | 93.80 | | | | 23.85 | | | | 150.06 | | | | 15.30 | | | | 150.06 | | | | 24.99 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
ASBB | | ASB Bancorp, Inc. | | NC | | | 12.59 | | | | 12.59 | | | | 0.30 | | | | 2.19 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 2.06 | | | | 2.33 | | | | 70.40 | | | | 40.70 | | | | 94.50 | | | | 11.90 | | | | 94.50 | | | | 43.31 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
AF | | Astoria Financial Corporation | | NY | | | 10.31 | | | | 9.22 | | | | 0.59 | | | | 6.03 | | | | 0.59 | | | | 6.02 | | | | 1.73 | | | | 50.36 | | | | 14.68 | | | | 84.98 | | | | 8.12 | | | | 97.29 | | | | 14.70 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 1.28 | | | | 18.82 | |
AFCB | | Athens Bancshares Corporation | | TN | | | 13.79 | | | | 13.75 | | | | 0.90 | | | | 6.45 | | | | 0.92 | | | | 6.57 | | | | 2.68 | | | | 56.65 | | | | 17.16 | | | | 111.42 | | | | 15.37 | | | | 111.78 | | | | 16.86 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 0.78 | | | | 10.00 | |
ACFC | | Atlantic Coast Financial Corporation | | FL | | | 9.87 | | | | 9.87 | | | | -0.84 | | | | -9.49 | | | | -0.70 | | | | -7.92 | | | | 4.23 | | | | 29.10 | | | | NM | | | | 86.03 | | | | 8.49 | | | | 86.03 | | | | NM | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
BKMU | | Bank Mutual Corporation | | WI | | | 12.22 | | | | 12.21 | | | | 0.63 | | | | 5.13 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 21.87 | | | | 112.47 | | | | 13.58 | | | | 112.52 | | | | NA | | | | 0.16 | | | | 2.36 | | | | 48.39 | |
BFIN | | BankFinancial Corporation | | IL | | | 12.76 | | | | 12.63 | | | | 0.52 | | | | 4.19 | | | | 0.54 | | | | 4.40 | | | | 1.67 | | | | 73.61 | | | | 30.81 | | | | 132.71 | | | | 16.93 | | | | 134.18 | | | | 29.26 | | | | 0.12 | | | | 1.05 | | | | 21.62 | |
BNCL | | Beneficial Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 14.03 | | | | 11.42 | | | | 0.37 | | | | 2.70 | | | | 0.42 | | | | 3.08 | | | | 0.38 | | | | 358.40 | | | | 53.65 | | | | 145.01 | | | | 20.34 | | | | 183.61 | | | | 47.13 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
BHBK | | Blue Hills Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 24.31 | | | | 23.69 | | | | -0.24 | | | | -1.61 | | | | -0.20 | | | | -1.33 | | | | 0.27 | | | | 278.60 | | | | NA | | | | 90.32 | | | | 21.96 | | | | 93.47 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
BOFI | | BofI Holding, Inc. | | CA | | | 8.54 | | | | 8.54 | | | | 1.57 | | | | 17.95 | | | | 1.63 | | | | 18.60 | | | | 0.53 | | | | 80.74 | | | | 19.10 | | | | 290.93 | | | | 24.57 | | | | 290.93 | | | | 18.43 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
BYFC | | Broadway Financial Corporation | | CA | | | 8.12 | | | | 8.12 | | | | 0.53 | | | | 6.76 | | | | 0.54 | | | | 6.80 | | | | 8.13 | | | | 36.32 | | | | 14.56 | | | | 96.65 | | | | 7.85 | | | | 96.65 | | | | 14.56 | | | | 0.04 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
BLMT | | BSB Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 10.12 | | | | 10.12 | | | | 0.31 | | | | 2.73 | | | | 0.31 | | | | 2.73 | | | | 0.66 | | | | 94.22 | | | | 45.32 | | | | 124.62 | | | | 12.61 | | | | 124.62 | | | | 45.32 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
CBNJ | | Cape Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 12.93 | | | | 11.06 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 4.47 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 4.48 | | | | 1.60 | | | | 81.32 | | | | 15.89 | | | | 74.33 | | | | 9.61 | | | | 88.77 | | | | 15.81 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 2.65 | | | | 42.11 | |
CFFN | | Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. | | KS | | | 15.13 | | | | 15.13 | | | | 0.82 | | | | 5.00 | | | | 0.82 | | | | 4.98 | | | | 0.54 | | | | 18.62 | | | | 22.50 | | | | 118.96 | | | | 18.00 | | | | 118.96 | | | | 22.58 | | | | 0.30 | | | | 2.38 | | | | 144.64 | |
CARV | | Carver Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 8.25 | | | | 8.25 | | | | -0.27 | | | | -3.11 | | | | -0.08 | | | | -0.96 | | | | 3.03 | | | | 42.86 | | | | NM | | | | 254.45 | | | | 3.61 | | | | 254.45 | | | | NM | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
CFBK | | Central Federal Corporation | | OH | | | 11.17 | | | | 11.17 | | | | 0.37 | | | | 3.89 | | | | 0.11 | | | | 1.12 | | | | 2.77 | | | | 90.96 | | | | 25.80 | | | | 88.80 | | | | 6.89 | | | | 88.80 | | | | 180.17 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
CHFN | | Charter Financial Corporation | | GA | | | 22.26 | | | | 21.90 | | | | 0.56 | | | | 2.28 | | | | 0.50 | | | | 2.05 | | | | 1.13 | | | | 98.02 | | | | 39.75 | | | | 90.35 | | | | 20.12 | | | | 92.30 | | | | 44.20 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.80 | | | | 71.43 | |
CHEV | | Cheviot Financial Corp. | | OH | | | 16.54 | | | | 14.95 | | | | 0.45 | | | | 2.80 | | | | 0.37 | | | | 2.33 | | | | 2.53 | | | | 18.13 | | | | 33.50 | | | | 94.86 | | | | 15.69 | | | | 106.98 | | | | 39.98 | | | | 0.36 | | | | 2.69 | | | | 90.00 | |
CBNK | | Chicopee Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 14.16 | | | | 14.16 | | | | -0.03 | | | | -0.23 | | | | -0.04 | | | | -0.26 | | | | 2.08 | | | | 41.37 | | | | NM | | | | 96.12 | | | | 13.61 | | | | 96.12 | | | | NM | | | | 0.28 | | | | 1.75 | | | | NM | |
CSBK | | Clifton Bancorp Inc. | | NJ | | | 29.52 | | | | 29.52 | | | | 0.54 | | | | 2.34 | | | | 0.53 | | | | 2.32 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 64.74 | | | | 53.08 | | | | 99.56 | | | | 29.39 | | | | 99.56 | | | | 53.65 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 1.80 | | | | 95.43 | |
CWAY | | Coastway Bancorp, Inc. | | RI | | | 15.59 | | | | 15.59 | | | | -0.29 | | | | -2.09 | | | | -0.05 | | | | -0.38 | | | | 3.61 | | | | 19.61 | | | | NA | | | | 79.10 | | | | 12.33 | | | | 79.10 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
DCOM | | Dime Community Bancshares, Inc. | | NY | | | 10.41 | | | | 9.25 | | | | 1.02 | | | | 9.62 | | | | 1.01 | | | | 9.53 | | | | 0.53 | | | | 85.74 | | | | 12.85 | | | | 123.53 | | | | 12.85 | | | | 140.69 | | | | 12.98 | | | | 0.56 | | | | 3.66 | | | | 47.06 | |
ENFC | | Entegra Financial Corp. | | NC | | | 11.80 | | | | 11.80 | | | | NA | | | | 6.19 | | | | NA | | | | 4.77 | | | | 4.49 | | | | 35.10 | | | | NA | | | | 92.18 | | | | 10.87 | | | | 92.18 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
ESSA | | ESSA Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 10.62 | | | | 9.90 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 5.01 | | | | 0.63 | | | | 5.36 | | | | 2.00 | | | | 30.09 | | | | 15.06 | | | | 82.44 | | | | 8.76 | | | | 89.18 | | | | 14.09 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 2.35 | | | | 35.44 | |
EVER | | EverBank Financial Corp | | FL | | | 8.39 | | | | 8.16 | | | | 0.70 | | | | 7.79 | | | | 0.78 | | | | 8.72 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 59.99 | | | | 18.84 | | | | 140.14 | | | | 10.81 | | | | 144.85 | | | | 16.65 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 0.89 | | | | 14.74 | |
FCAP | | First Capital, Inc. | | IN | | | 12.23 | | | | 11.19 | | | | 1.24 | | | | 10.28 | | | | 1.21 | | | | 10.05 | | | | 1.13 | | | | 98.21 | | | | 12.17 | | | | 120.48 | | | | 14.71 | | | | 133.26 | | | | 12.46 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 3.40 | | | | 41.38 | |
FBNK | | First Connecticut Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 9.75 | | | | 9.75 | | | | 0.34 | | | | 3.14 | | | | 0.34 | | | | 3.14 | | | | 1.27 | | | | 61.55 | | | | 32.31 | | | | 106.50 | | | | 10.39 | | | | 106.50 | | | | 32.31 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.29 | | | | 35.42 | |
FDEF | | First Defiance Financial Corp. | | OH | | | 12.93 | | | | 10.26 | | | | 1.07 | | | | 8.39 | | | | 1.08 | | | | 8.49 | | | | 2.53 | | | | 50.03 | | | | 14.58 | | | | 112.42 | | | | 14.54 | | | | 146.13 | | | | 14.42 | | | | 0.70 | | | | 2.10 | | | | 27.29 | |
FFNM | | First Federal of Northern Michigan Bancorp, Inc. | | MI | | | 9.61 | | | | 9.22 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 7.05 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 1.23 | | | | 153.14 | | | | 10.77 | | | | 69.63 | | | | 6.69 | | | | 72.92 | | | | NA | | | | 0.08 | | | | 1.43 | | | | 15.38 | |
FFNW | | First Financial Northwest, Inc. | | WA | | | 19.86 | | | | 19.86 | | | | 1.29 | | | | 6.33 | | | | 1.29 | | | | 6.33 | | | | 7.34 | | | | 20.32 | | | | 15.90 | | | | 104.11 | | | | 20.68 | | | | 104.11 | | | | 15.88 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.63 | | | | 25.97 | |
FBC | | Flagstar Bancorp, Inc. | | MI | | | 14.04 | | | | 14.04 | | | | 0.80 | | | | 5.91 | | | | 1.38 | | | | 10.16 | | | | 5.38 | | | | 61.31 | | | | 16.58 | | | | 84.27 | | | | 9.77 | | | | 84.27 | | | | 6.72 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
FXCB | | Fox Chase Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 16.59 | | | | 16.59 | | | | 0.69 | | | | 4.29 | | | | 0.69 | | | | 4.29 | | | | 1.03 | | | | 121.37 | | | | 24.95 | | | | 111.47 | | | | 18.49 | | | | 111.47 | | | | 24.95 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 2.91 | | | | 90.91 | |
FSBW | | FS Bancorp, Inc. | | WA | | | 13.57 | | | | 13.57 | | | | 0.82 | | | | 5.66 | | | | 0.80 | | | | 5.53 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 484.33 | | | | 15.32 | | | | 92.16 | | | | 12.51 | | | | 92.16 | | | | 15.67 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 1.32 | | | | 19.33 | |
GTWN | | Georgetown Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 11.14 | | | | 11.14 | | | | 0.47 | | | | 4.29 | | | | 0.47 | | | | 4.29 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 23.31 | | | | 100.62 | | | | 11.21 | | | | 100.62 | | | | 23.31 | | | | 0.17 | | | | 1.03 | | | | 23.59 | |
HBK | | Hamilton Bancorp, Inc. | | MD | | | 20.14 | | | | 19.37 | | | | -0.32 | | | | -1.58 | | | | -0.39 | | | | -1.91 | | | | 3.04 | | | | 25.45 | | | | NM | | | | 72.80 | | | | 14.66 | | | | 76.44 | | | | NM | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
HFFC | | HF Financial Corp. | | SD | | | 8.16 | | | | 7.81 | | | | 0.59 | | | | 7.48 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 7.38 | | | | 1.36 | | | | 61.20 | | | | 13.39 | | | | 97.62 | | | | 7.97 | | | | 102.41 | | | | 13.56 | | | | 0.45 | | | | 3.17 | | | | 42.45 | |
HIFS | | Hingham Institution for Savings | | MA | | | 7.83 | | | | 7.83 | | | | 1.52 | | | | 19.30 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 7.88 | | | | 144.07 | | | | 11.28 | | | | 144.07 | | | | NA | | | | 1.12 | | | | 1.36 | | | | 20.11 | |
HMNF | | HMN Financial, Inc. | | MN | | | 13.56 | | | | 13.56 | | | | 3.90 | | | | 30.23 | | | | 3.90 | | | | 30.23 | | | | 2.73 | | | | 62.06 | | | | 2.58 | | | | 86.83 | | | | 9.70 | | | | 86.83 | | | | 2.58 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
HBCP | | Home Bancorp, Inc. | | LA | | | 12.00 | | | | 11.67 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 6.05 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 7.49 | | | | 1.40 | | | | 59.26 | | | | 18.02 | | | | 107.76 | | | | 12.93 | | | | 111.20 | | | | 14.55 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 1.22 | | | | 5.51 | |
HFBL | | Home Federal Bancorp, Inc. of Louisiana | | LA | | | 12.53 | | | | 12.53 | | | | 0.93 | | | | 6.49 | | | | 0.90 | | | | 6.25 | | | | 0.03 | | | | NM | | | | 14.09 | | | | 99.69 | | | | 12.49 | | | | 99.69 | | | | 14.63 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 1.45 | | | | 19.71 | |
HMST | | HomeStreet, Inc. | | WA | | | 8.48 | | | | 8.10 | | | | 0.51 | | | | 5.63 | | | | 0.58 | | | | 6.40 | | | | 3.11 | | | | 22.39 | | | | 16.50 | | | | 87.38 | | | | 7.41 | | | | 91.89 | | | | 14.47 | | | | 0.44 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 10.48 | |
IROQ | | IF Bancorp, Inc. | | IL | | | 15.22 | | | | 15.22 | | | | 0.62 | | | | 4.28 | | | | 0.64 | | | | 4.41 | | | | 1.09 | | | | 76.56 | | | | 19.23 | | | | 88.09 | | | | 13.41 | | | | 88.09 | | | | 18.65 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 11.63 | |
ISBC | | Investors Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 19.90 | | | | 19.47 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 5.28 | | | | 0.83 | | | | 6.18 | | | | 0.88 | | | | 126.33 | | | | 31.41 | | | | 109.00 | | | | 21.69 | | | | 111.94 | | | | 27.00 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 1.48 | | | | 34.64 | |
JXSB | | Jacksonville Bancorp, Inc. | | IL | | | 14.43 | | | | 13.67 | | | | 0.95 | | | | 6.81 | | | | 0.87 | | | | 6.20 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 13.42 | | | | 88.49 | | | | 12.77 | | | | 94.20 | | | | 14.74 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 1.45 | | | | 19.39 | |
LPSB | | La Porte Bancorp, Inc. | | IN | | | 16.09 | | | | 14.64 | | | | 0.85 | | | | 5.27 | | | | 0.82 | | | | 5.11 | | | | 2.12 | | | | 35.58 | | | | 16.22 | | | | 86.51 | | | | 13.92 | | | | 96.70 | | | | 16.73 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 1.26 | | | | 20.51 | |
LABC | | Louisiana Bancorp, Inc. | | LA | | | 17.97 | | | | 17.97 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 4.61 | | | | 0.83 | | | | 4.59 | | | | 0.31 | | | | 229.02 | | | | 22.20 | | | | 107.42 | | | | 19.30 | | | | 107.42 | | | | 22.27 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 0.90 | | | | 95.00 | |
MCBK | | Madison County Financial, Inc. | | NE | | | 20.47 | | | | 20.20 | | | | 1.01 | | | | 4.69 | | | | 1.04 | | | | 4.84 | | | | NA | | | | NM | | | | 19.71 | | | | 98.78 | | | | 20.22 | | | | 100.46 | | | | 19.09 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 1.19 | | | | 23.53 | |
MLVF | | Malvern Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 14.16 | | | | 14.16 | | | | 0.06 | | | | 0.43 | | | | 0.05 | | | | 0.39 | | | | 0.99 | | | | 134.97 | | | | NM | | | | 107.21 | | | | 15.18 | | | | 107.21 | | | | NM | | | | 0.11 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
MELR | | Melrose Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 10.17 | | | | 10.17 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 61.68 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
EBSB | | Meridian Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 18.02 | | | | 17.67 | | | | 0.72 | | | | 6.57 | | | | 0.56 | | | | 5.17 | | | | 1.40 | | | | 62.93 | | | | 30.09 | | | | 108.25 | | | | 19.51 | | | | 110.91 | | | | 38.23 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
CASH | | Meta Financial Group, Inc. | | SD | | | 8.51 | | | | 8.39 | | | | 0.81 | | | | 10.01 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 10.37 | | | | 0.27 | | | | 99.30 | | | | 12.96 | | | | 115.70 | | | | 9.85 | | | | 117.44 | | | | 12.51 | | | | 0.52 | | | | 1.59 | | | | 20.55 | |
NVSL | | Naugatuck Valley Financial Corporation | | CT | | | 12.15 | | | | 12.15 | | | | -0.42 | | | | -3.54 | | | | -0.34 | | | | -2.90 | | | | 1.65 | | | | 91.56 | | | | NM | | | | 107.98 | | | | 13.12 | | | | 107.98 | | | | NM | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
NHTB | | New Hampshire Thrift Bancshares, Inc. | | NH | | | 10.38 | | | | 6.94 | | | | 0.64 | | | | 6.30 | | | | 0.68 | | | | 6.70 | | | | 1.16 | | | | 55.85 | | | | 14.31 | | | | 98.21 | | | | 8.81 | | | | 168.83 | | | | 13.43 | | | | 0.52 | | | | 3.33 | | | | 47.71 | |
NYCB | | New York Community Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 11.87 | | | | 7.21 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 8.28 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 8.25 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 199.13 | | | | 14.44 | | | | 118.36 | | | | 14.05 | | | | 205.25 | | | | 14.49 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 6.47 | | | | 93.46 | |
NFBK | | Northfield Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 21.12 | | | | 20.67 | | | | 0.75 | | | | 2.95 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 3.02 | | | | 1.34 | | | | 68.07 | | | | 36.74 | | | | 117.47 | | | | 24.82 | | | | 120.73 | | | | 35.85 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 1.95 | | | | 66.67 | |
NWBI | | Northwest Bancshares, Inc. | | PA | | | 13.76 | | | | 11.73 | | | | 0.82 | | | | 5.87 | | | | 0.75 | | | | 5.37 | | | | 1.85 | | | | 55.19 | | | | 16.90 | | | | 105.87 | | | | 14.56 | | | | 127.06 | | | | 18.46 | | | | 0.52 | | | | 4.33 | | | | 228.17 | |
OSHC | | Ocean Shore Holding Co. | | NJ | | | 10.11 | | | | 9.66 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 5.79 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 5.78 | | | | 1.00 | | | | 40.17 | | | | 15.26 | | | | 89.22 | | | | 9.02 | | | | 93.86 | | | | 15.28 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 1.66 | | | | 25.26 | |
OCFC | | OceanFirst Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 9.47 | | | | 9.47 | | | | 0.74 | | | | 7.85 | | | | 0.85 | | | | 9.08 | | | | 2.02 | | | | 40.67 | | | | 16.52 | | | | 129.34 | | | | 12.25 | | | | 129.34 | | | | 14.37 | | | | 0.52 | | | | 3.15 | | | | 49.00 | |
ONFC | | Oneida Financial Corp. | | NY | | | 12.06 | | | | 9.02 | | | | 0.84 | | | | 6.95 | | | | 0.69 | | | | 5.75 | | | | 0.21 | | | | 252.42 | | | | 13.97 | | | | 95.13 | | | | 11.47 | | | | 131.74 | | | | 17.03 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 3.74 | | | | 52.17 | |
ORIT | | Oritani Financial Corp. | | NJ | | | 16.16 | | | | 16.16 | | | | 1.35 | | | | 7.76 | | | | 1.35 | | | | 7.76 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 166.30 | | | | 15.46 | | | | 126.65 | | | | 20.47 | | | | 126.65 | | | | 15.45 | | | | 0.70 | | | | 4.77 | | | | 100.00 | |
PBHC | | Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 7.96 | | | | 7.22 | | | | 0.48 | | | | 5.75 | | | | 0.44 | | | | 5.28 | | | | 1.72 | | | | 55.17 | | | | 17.19 | | | | 132.72 | | | | 7.62 | | | | 154.72 | | | | 18.96 | | | | 0.12 | | | | 1.22 | | | | 14.83 | |
PBCT | | People’s United Financial, Inc. | | CT | | | 12.87 | | | | 7.47 | | | | 0.75 | | | | 5.44 | | | | 0.75 | | | | 5.46 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 17.00 | | | | 94.87 | | | | 12.21 | | | | 173.69 | | | | 16.95 | | | | 0.66 | | | | 4.62 | | | | 97.92 | |
PBSK | | Poage Bankshares, Inc. | | KY | | | 16.22 | | | | 15.76 | | | | 0.22 | | | | 1.30 | | | | 0.47 | | | | 2.76 | | | | 0.97 | | | | 68.37 | | | | NM | | | | 86.46 | | | | 14.03 | | | | 89.50 | | | | 30.73 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.34 | | | | 100.00 | |
PBCP | | Polonia Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 13.03 | | | | 13.03 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.02 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.02 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | | | | 89.29 | | | | 11.63 | | | | 89.29 | | | | NM | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
PROV | | Provident Financial Holdings, Inc. | | CA | | | 13.10 | | | | 13.10 | | | | 0.67 | | | | 4.99 | | | | 0.67 | | | | 4.99 | | | | 1.46 | | | | 65.94 | | | | 19.61 | | | | 95.33 | | | | 12.49 | | | | 95.33 | | | | 19.61 | | | | 0.44 | | | | 2.91 | | | | 54.55 | |
PFS | | Provident Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 13.41 | | | | 9.05 | | | | 0.90 | | | | 6.61 | | | | 0.97 | | | | 7.15 | | | | 1.50 | | | | 52.74 | | | | 14.63 | | | | 99.20 | | | | 13.30 | | | | 154.44 | | | | 13.54 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 3.48 | | | | 50.85 | |
PBIP | | Prudential Bancorp, Inc. | | PA | | | 24.63 | | | | 24.63 | | | | 0.34 | | | | 1.38 | | | | 0.29 | | | | 1.18 | | | | 1.49 | | | | 32.36 | | | | 63.95 | | | | 89.60 | | | | 22.07 | | | | 89.60 | | | | 74.89 | | | | 0.12 | | | | 0.99 | | | | 47.37 | |
PULB | | Pulaski Financial Corp. | | MO | | | 8.12 | | | | 7.86 | | | | 0.87 | | | | 9.72 | | | | 0.87 | | | | 9.74 | | | | 3.75 | | | | 34.78 | | | | 13.74 | | | | 125.98 | | | | 10.23 | | | | 130.57 | | | | 13.68 | | | | 0.38 | | | | 3.14 | | | | 43.18 | |
RVSB | | Riverview Bancorp, Inc. | | WA | | | 11.98 | | | | 9.22 | | | | 2.37 | | | | 21.04 | | | | 2.38 | | | | 20.89 | | | | 3.37 | | | | 48.72 | | | | 5.09 | | | | 98.12 | | | | 11.70 | | | | 131.72 | | | | 5.09 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
RP® Financial, LC.
Exhibit 1-B
Weekly Thrift Market Line - Part Two
Prices As of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | Key Financial Ratios | | | Asset Quality Ratios | | | Pricing Ratios | | | Dividend Data (6) | |
| | | | | | Equity/ | | | Tang Equity/ | | | Reported Earnings | | | Core Earnings | | | NPAs/ | | | Rsvs/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Price/ | | | Div/ | | | Dividend | | | Payout | |
| | | | | | Assets(1) | | | Assets(1) | | | ROA(5) | | | ROE(5) | | | ROA(5) | | | ROE(5) | | | Assets | | | NPLs | | | Earnings | | | Book | | | Assets | | | Tang Book | | | Core Earnings | | | Share | | | Yield | | | Ratio (7) | |
| | | | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (%) | | | (x) | | | ($) | | | (%) | | | (%) | |
Companies | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
SVBI | | Severn Bancorp, Inc. | | MD | | | 10.75 | | | | 10.72 | | | | -0.52 | | | | -4.95 | | | | -0.52 | | | | -4.95 | | | | 5.80 | | | | 23.42 | | | | NM | | | | 82.02 | | | | 6.19 | | | | 82.51 | | | | NM | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
SIFI | | SI Financial Group, Inc. | | CT | | | 11.65 | | | | 10.39 | | | | 0.30 | | | | 2.60 | | | | 0.35 | | | | 3.09 | | | | 0.71 | | | | 92.78 | | | | 35.03 | | | | 91.80 | | | | 10.69 | | | | 104.40 | | | | 29.53 | | | | 0.12 | | | | 1.07 | | | | 37.50 | |
SBCP | | Sunshine Bancorp, Inc. | | FL | | | 28.59 | | | | 28.59 | | | | NA | | | | -0.67 | | | | NA | | | | -0.75 | | | | 4.64 | | | | 19.43 | | | | NA | | | | 82.38 | | | | 23.55 | | | | 82.38 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NA | |
TBNK | | Territorial Bancorp Inc. | | HI | | | 13.11 | | | | 13.11 | | | | 0.87 | | | | 6.62 | | | | 0.80 | | | | 6.13 | | | | 0.47 | | | | 21.69 | | | | 14.19 | | | | 98.37 | | | | 12.89 | | | | 98.37 | | | | 15.26 | | | | 0.64 | | | | 2.99 | | | | 46.36 | |
TSBK | | Timberland Bancorp, Inc. | | WA | | | 11.10 | | | | 10.42 | | | | 0.79 | | | | 7.08 | | | | 0.80 | | | | 7.14 | | | | 5.08 | | | | 37.62 | | | | 13.19 | | | | 89.82 | | | | 9.97 | | | | 96.40 | | | | 13.06 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.90 | | | | 22.50 | |
TRST | | TrustCo Bank Corp NY | | NY | | | 8.50 | | | | 8.49 | | | | 0.97 | | | | 11.82 | | | | 0.94 | | | | 11.45 | | | | 1.16 | | | | 99.33 | | | | 14.55 | | | | 165.00 | | | | 14.02 | | | | 165.23 | | | | 15.02 | | | | 0.26 | | | | 3.87 | | | | 56.33 | |
UCBA | | United Community Bancorp | | IN | | | 13.44 | | | | 12.94 | | | | 0.38 | | | | 2.72 | | | | 0.41 | | | | 2.93 | | | | 2.73 | | | | 41.01 | | | | 28.98 | | | | 79.47 | | | | 10.68 | | | | 83.06 | | | | 26.95 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 2.02 | | | | 58.54 | |
UCFC | | United Community Financial Corp. | | OH | | | 12.97 | | | | 12.97 | | | | 2.81 | | | | 24.58 | | | | 2.84 | | | | 24.79 | | | | 2.79 | | | | 39.55 | | | | 5.22 | | | | 108.84 | | | | 14.12 | | | | 108.89 | | | | 5.18 | | | | 0.04 | | | | 0.78 | | | | 2.04 | |
UBNK | | United Financial Bancorp, Inc. | | CT | | | 12.26 | | | | 10.16 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.60 | | | | 0.77 | | | | 6.08 | | | | 0.75 | | | | 59.69 | | | | NM | | | | 110.13 | | | | 13.50 | | | | 136.01 | | | | 20.68 | | | | 0.40 | | | | 2.93 | | | | 235.29 | |
WSBF | | Waterstone Financial, Inc. | | WI | | | 24.93 | | | | 24.90 | | | | 0.70 | | | | 3.23 | | | | 0.70 | | | | 3.23 | | | | 4.39 | | | | 38.45 | | | | 36.78 | | | | 101.61 | | | | 25.33 | | | | 101.74 | | | | 36.78 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 1.51 | | | | 55.56 | |
WAYN | | Wayne Savings Bancshares, Inc. | | OH | | | 9.72 | | | | 9.34 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 6.24 | | | | 0.61 | | | | 6.34 | | | | 1.98 | | | | 33.88 | | | | 15.00 | | | | 92.68 | | | | 9.00 | | | | 96.82 | | | | 14.76 | | | | 0.36 | | | | 2.73 | | | | 39.77 | |
WEBK | | Wellesley Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 9.63 | | | | 9.63 | | | | 0.38 | | | | 3.78 | | | | 0.37 | | | | 3.76 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 24.55 | | | | 95.02 | | | | 9.15 | | | | 95.02 | | | | 24.68 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 0.53 | | | | 9.74 | |
WBB | | Westbury Bancorp, Inc. | | WI | | | 15.21 | | | | 15.21 | | | | -0.26 | | | | -1.59 | | | | -0.19 | | | | -1.15 | | | | 1.28 | | | | 82.48 | | | | NM | | | | 94.18 | | | | 14.32 | | | | 94.18 | | | | NM | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
WFD | | Westfield Financial, Inc. | | MA | | | 11.01 | | | | 11.01 | | | | 0.49 | | | | 4.19 | | | | 0.46 | | | | 3.93 | | | | 0.68 | | | | 86.78 | | | | 21.94 | | | | 94.44 | | | | 10.39 | | | | 94.44 | | | | 23.37 | | | | 0.12 | | | | 1.66 | | | | 63.64 | |
WBKC | | Wolverine Bancorp, Inc. | | MI | | | 18.15 | | | | 18.15 | | | | 0.55 | | | | 2.84 | | | | 0.55 | | | | 2.84 | | | | 1.68 | | | | 162.46 | | | | 29.32 | | | | 87.81 | | | | 15.94 | | | | 87.81 | | | | 29.32 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 74.07 | |
WSFS | | WSFS Financial Corporation | | DE | | | 9.96 | | | | 8.85 | | | | 1.18 | | | | 12.85 | | | | 1.28 | | | | 14.02 | | | | 0.99 | | | | 96.32 | | | | 13.02 | | | | 148.95 | | | | 14.83 | | | | 169.67 | | | | 11.95 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 0.79 | | | | 8.79 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
MHCs | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
WVFC | | WVS Financial Corp. | | PA | | | 10.02 | | | | 10.02 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 3.14 | | | | 0.33 | | | | 3.18 | | | | 0.15 | | | | 51.08 | | | | 21.80 | | | | 70.34 | | | | 7.05 | | | | 70.34 | | | | 21.54 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 1.47 | | | | 32.00 | |
GCBC | | Greene County Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NY | | | 8.98 | | | | 8.98 | | | | 0.98 | | | | 10.96 | | | | 0.98 | | | | 10.96 | | | | 1.09 | | | | 105.61 | | | | 19.03 | | | | 198.09 | | | | 17.80 | | | | 198.09 | | | | 19.03 | | | | 0.72 | | | | 2.44 | | | | 45.81 | |
KRNY | | Kearny Financial Corp. (MHC) | | NJ | | | 13.93 | | | | 11.18 | | | | 0.31 | | | | 2.21 | | | | 0.33 | | | | 2.30 | | | | 0.85 | | | | 43.66 | | | | NM | | | | 187.36 | | | | 26.10 | | | | 240.91 | | | | 81.61 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
KFFB | | Kentucky First Federal Bancorp (MHC) | | KY | | | 22.73 | | | | 18.74 | | | | 0.63 | | | | 2.88 | | | | 0.63 | | | | 2.88 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 35.09 | | | | 102.87 | | | | 23.38 | | | | 131.18 | | | | 35.09 | | | | 0.40 | | | | 4.96 | | | | 173.91 | |
LSBK | | Lake Shore Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NY | | | 14.33 | | | | 14.33 | | | | 0.70 | | | | 5.05 | | | | 0.68 | | | | 4.86 | | | | 1.22 | | | | 32.61 | | | | 22.25 | | | | 113.71 | | | | 16.29 | | | | 113.71 | | | | 23.13 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 2.10 | | | | 46.67 | |
MGYR | | Magyar Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NJ | | | 8.66 | | | | 8.66 | | | | 0.11 | | | | 1.25 | | | | 0.10 | | | | 1.20 | | | | 5.15 | | | | 28.41 | | | | NM | | | | 103.82 | | | | 8.99 | | | | 103.82 | | | | 85.42 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
MSBF | | MSB Financial Corp. (MHC) | | NJ | | | 11.90 | | | | 11.90 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 2.39 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 2.39 | | | | 5.65 | | | | 19.12 | | | | 52.85 | | | | 128.81 | | | | 15.33 | | | | 128.81 | | | | 52.85 | | | | 0.00 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
NECB | | NorthEast Community Bancorp, Inc. (MHC) | | NY | | | 20.63 | | | | 20.46 | | | | 0.26 | | | | 1.17 | | | | 0.27 | | | | 1.21 | | | | 4.97 | | | | 18.40 | | | | NM | | | | 85.20 | | | | 17.58 | | | | 86.07 | | | | 69.09 | | | | 0.12 | | | | 1.68 | | | | 120.00 | |
OFED | | Oconee Federal Financial Corp. (MHC) | | SC | | | 21.68 | | | | 21.68 | | | | 1.05 | | | | 4.95 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 0.61 | | | | 54.15 | | | | 30.32 | | | | 150.77 | | | | 32.69 | | | | 150.77 | | | | NA | | | | 0.40 | | | | 2.00 | | | | 60.61 | |
PSBH | | PSB Holdings, Inc. (MHC) | | CT | | | 10.99 | | | | 9.67 | | | | 0.23 | | | | 2.08 | | | | 0.26 | | | | 2.33 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 41.72 | | | | 94.70 | | | | 10.41 | | | | 109.26 | | | | 37.32 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 0.00 | | | | NM | |
TFSL | | TFS Financial Corporation (MHC) | | OH | | | 15.58 | | | | 15.51 | | | | 0.57 | | | | 3.52 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 2.24 | | | | 33.56 | | | | 64.18 | | | | 231.56 | | | | 36.09 | | | | 232.79 | | | | NA | | | | 0.28 | | | | 1.98 | | | | 63.64 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Under Acquisition | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
CMSB | | CMS Bancorp, Inc. | | NY | | | 8.73 | | | | 8.73 | | | | 0.25 | | | | 2.82 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 3.66 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | 39.24 | | | | 107.81 | | | | 8.87 | | | | 107.81 | | | | 29.20 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
COBK | | Colonial Financial Services, Inc. | | NJ | | | 11.36 | | | | 11.36 | | | | 0.18 | | | | 1.64 | | | | 0.18 | | | | 1.61 | | | | 3.74 | | | | 25.32 | | | | 49.30 | | | | 81.80 | | | | 9.30 | | | | 81.80 | | | | 49.13 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
ESBF | | ESB Financial Corporation | | PA | | | 10.55 | | | | 8.59 | | | | 0.91 | | | | 8.95 | | | | 0.90 | | | | 8.88 | | | | 1.04 | | | | 37.63 | | | | 18.26 | | | | 152.78 | | | | 16.20 | | | | 191.38 | | | | 18.43 | | | | 0.40 | | | | 2.26 | | | | 41.24 | |
HBNK | | Hampden Bancorp, Inc. | | MA | | | 12.14 | | | | 12.14 | | | | 0.64 | | | | 5.20 | | | | 0.67 | | | | 5.51 | | | | 1.48 | | | | 55.99 | | | | 23.65 | | | | 126.70 | | | | 15.38 | | | | 126.70 | | | | 22.32 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 1.63 | | | | 33.73 | |
HBOS | | Heritage Financial Group, Inc. | | GA | | | 9.11 | | | | 8.44 | | | | 0.60 | | | | 6.60 | | | | 0.74 | | | | 8.14 | | | | 0.88 | | | | 85.65 | | | | 21.97 | | | | 141.30 | | | | 12.87 | | | | 153.59 | | | | 17.80 | | | | 0.28 | | | | 1.14 | | | | 25.00 | |
HCBK | | Hudson City Bancorp, Inc. | | NJ | | | 12.96 | | | | 12.60 | | | | 0.43 | | | | 3.43 | | | | 0.32 | | | | 2.56 | | | | 2.90 | | | | 24.25 | | | | 27.62 | | | | 100.09 | | | | 12.97 | | | | 103.36 | | | | 36.98 | | | | 0.16 | | | | 1.76 | | | | 48.48 | |
PEOP | | Peoples Federal Bancshares, Inc. | | MA | | | 17.28 | | | | 17.28 | | | | 0.24 | | | | 1.39 | | | | 0.33 | | | | 1.88 | | | | 0.35 | | | | 189.91 | | | | NM | | | | 127.98 | | | | 22.11 | | | | 127.98 | | | | 62.75 | | | | 0.20 | | | | 0.94 | | | | 76.00 | |
SMPL | | Simplicity Bancorp, Inc. | | CA | | | 15.93 | | | | 15.54 | | | | 0.61 | | | | 3.78 | | | | 0.64 | | | | 3.97 | | | | 1.82 | | | | 28.15 | | | | 23.83 | | | | 92.24 | | | | 14.69 | | | | 94.97 | | | | 22.64 | | | | 0.36 | | | | 2.10 | | | | 48.61 | |
SIBC | | State Investors Bancorp, Inc. | | LA | | | 15.44 | | | | 15.44 | | | | 0.39 | | | | 2.45 | | | | 0.39 | | | | 2.45 | | | | 1.14 | | | | 46.18 | | | | 50.63 | | | | 115.39 | | | | 17.82 | | | | 115.39 | | | | 50.63 | | | | NA | | | | NA | | | | NM | |
(1) | Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share. |
(2) | Or since offering price if converted of first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized. |
(3) | EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing 12 month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis. |
(4) | Exludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.). |
(5) | ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances. |
(6) | Annualized based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement. |
(7) | Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month earnings. |
(8) | Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics. |
(9) | For MHC institutions, market value reflects share price multiplied by public (non-MHC) shares. |
Source: SNL Financial, LC. and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.
Copyright (c) 2015 by RP® Financial, LC.
EXHIBIT 2
Pro Forma Analysis Sheet
EXHIBIT 2
PRO FORMA ANALYSIS SHEET
Kearny Financial Corp.
Prices as of January 16, 2015
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Valuation Midpoint Pricing Multiples | | | | | Symbol | | Subject at Midpoint | | Peer Group | | | New Jersey | | | All Public | |
| | | | | | Mean | | | Median | | | Mean | | | Median | | | Mean | | | Median | |
Price-earnings multiple | | | = | | | P/E | | | 80.12x | | | | | | 16.48x | | | | 15.46x | | | | 18.20x | | | | 15.66x | | | | 17.80x | | | | 16.22x | |
Price-core earnings multiple | | | = | | | P/CE | | | 81.64x | | | | | | 16.11x | | | | 15.02x | | | | 16.91x | | | | 15.37x | | | | 17.51x | | | | 15.74x | |
Price-book ratio | | | = | | | P/B | | | 81.10 | % | | | | | 123.42 | % | | | 118.96 | % | | | 105.60 | % | | | 104.28 | % | | | 106.45 | % | | | 98.21 | % |
Price-tangible book ratio | | | = | | | P/TB | | | 90.01 | % | | | | | 136.48 | % | | | 129.34 | % | | | 115.66 | % | | | 116.33 | % | | | 114.48 | % | | | 102.41 | % |
Price-assets ratio | | | = | | | P/A | | | 21.49 | % | | | | | 15.65 | % | | | 14.02 | % | | | 17.57 | % | | | 16.88 | % | | | 13.64 | % | | | 12.89 | % |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Valuation Parameters | | | | | | | | | Adjusted | | | | |
Pre-Conversion Earnings (Y) | | $ | 9,709,327 | | | (12 Mths 12/14(2) | | ESOP Stock (% of Offering + Foundation) (E) | | | 5.00 | % | | | | |
Pre-Conversion Core Earnings (YC) | | $ | 9,501,327 | | | (12 Mths 12/14(2) | | Cost of ESOP Borrowings (S) | | | 0.00 | % | | | | |
Pre-Conversion Book Value (B) | | $ | 493,451,000 | | | (2) | | ESOP Amortization (T) | | | 20.00 | | | | Years | |
Pre-Conv. Tang. Book Value (B) | | $ | 384,170,000 | | | (2) | | Stock Program (% of Offering + Foundation (M) | | | 2.50 | % | | | | |
Pre-Conversion Assets (A) | | $ | 3,548,086,000 | | | (2) | | Stock Programs Vesting (N) | | | 5.00 | | | | Years | |
Reinvestment Rate (R) | | | 1.65 | % | | | | Fixed Expenses | | $ | 3,185,000 | | | | | |
Tax rate (TAX) | | | 35.00 | % | | | | Variable Expenses (Blended Commission %) | | | 2.95 | % | | | | |
After Tax Reinvest. Rate (R) | | | 1.07 | % | | | | Percentage Sold (PCT) | | | 77.1264 | % | | | | |
Est. Conversion Expenses (1)(X) | | | 3.41 | % | | | | MHC Assets | | $ | 217,000 | | | | | |
Insider Purchases | | $ | 2,545,000 | | | | | Options as (% of Offering + Foundation) (O1) | | | 6.00 | % | | | | |
Price/Share | | $ | 10.00 | | | | | Estimated Option Value (O2) | | | 22.30 | % | | | | |
Foundation Cash Contribution (FC) | | $ | 5,000,000 | | | | | Option Vesting Period (O3) | | | 5.00 | | | | Years | |
Foundation Stock Contribution (FS) | | $ | 5,000,000 | | | | | % of Options taxable (O4) | | | 25.00 | % | | | | |
Foundation Tax Benefit (FT) | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Calculation of Pro Forma Value After Conversion
| | | | | | | | | | | | |
1. | | V= | | P/E * (Y - FC * R) | | | V= | | | $ | 893,352,780 | |
| | | | 1 - P/E * PCT * ((1-X-E-M-FS)*R - (1-TAX)*(E/T) - (1-TAX)*(M/N)-(1-TAX*O4)*(O1*O2/O3))) | | | | | | | | |
| | | | |
2. | | V= | | P/Core E * (YC) | | | V= | | | $ | 893,152,780 | |
| | | | 1 - P/Core E * PCT * ((1-X-E-M-FS)*R - (1-TAX)*(E/T) - (1-TAX)*(M/N)-(1-TAX*O4)*(O1*O2/O3))) | | | | | | | | |
| | | | |
3. | | V= | | P/TB * (B-FC+FT) | | | V= | | | $ | 893,152,780 | |
| | | | 1 - P/B * PCT * (1-X-E-M) | | | | | | | | |
| | | | |
4. | | V= | | P/TB * (B-FC+FT) | | | V= | | | $ | 893,152,780 | |
| | | | 1 - P/TB * PCT * (1-X-E-M) | | | | | | | | |
| | | | |
5. | | V= | | P/A * (A-FC+FT) | | | V= | | | $ | 893,152,780 | |
| | | | 1 - P/A * PCT * (1-X-E-M) | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Shares | | | | | 2nd Step | | | Full | | | Plus: | | | Total Market | | | | |
| | 2nd Step | | | Exchange | | | Conversion | | | Foundation | | | Capitalization | | | Exchange | |
Conclusion | | Offering Shares | | | Shares | | | Shares | | | Shares | | | Shares | | | Ratio | |
Maximum | | | 78,775,000 | | | | 23,362,570 | | | | 102,137,570 | | | | 500,000 | | | | 102,637,570 | | | | 1.5156 | |
Midpoint | | | 68,500,000 | | | | 20,315,278 | | | | 88,815,278 | | | | 500,000 | | | | 89,315,278 | | | | 1.3179 | |
Minimum | | | 58,225,000 | | | | 17,267,987 | | | | 75,492,987 | | | | 500,000 | | | | 75,992,987 | | | | 1.1202 | |
| | | | | | |
Market Value | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | 2nd Step | | | Full | | | | | | Total Market | | | | |
| | 2nd Step | | | Exchange | | | Conversion | | | Foundation | | | Capitalization | | | | |
Conclusion | | Offering Value | | | Shares Value | | | $ Value | | | $ Value | | | $ Value | | | | |
Maximum | | $ | 787,750,000 | | | $ | 233,625,700 | | | $ | 1,021,375,700 | | | | 5,000,000 | | | $ | 1,026,375,700 | | | | | |
Midpoint | | $ | 685,000,000 | | | $ | 203,152,780 | | | $ | 888,152,780 | | | | 5,000,000 | | | $ | 893,152,780 | | | | | |
Minimum | | $ | 582,250,000 | | | $ | 172,679,870 | | | $ | 754,929,870 | | | | 5,000,000 | | | $ | 759,929,870 | | | | | |
(1) | Estimated offering expenses at midpoint of the offering. |
(2) | Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvesment of $217,000 of MHC net assets. |
EXHIBIT 3
Pro Forma Effect of Conversion Proceeds
Exhibit 3
PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS
Kearny Financial Corp.
At the Minimum of the Range
| | | | | | |
1. | | Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio | | | | |
| | Fully Converted Value | | $ | 759,929,870 | |
| | Exchange Ratio | | | 1.12021 | |
| | |
| | 2nd Step Offering Proceeds | | $ | 582,250,000 | |
| | Less: Estimated Offering Expenses | | | 20,333,425 | |
| | | | | | |
| | 2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds (Including Foundation) | | $ | 561,916,575 | |
| | |
2. | | Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds | | | | |
| | |
| | Net Conversion Proceeds | | $ | 561,916,575 | |
| | Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation | | | (5,000,000 | ) |
| | Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1) | | | (29,362,500 | ) |
| | Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2) | | | (14,681,250 | ) |
| | | | | | |
| | Net Cash Proceeds | | $ | 512,872,825 | |
| | Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return | | | 1.07 | % |
| | | | | | |
| | Earnings Increase | | $ | 5,500,561 | |
| | Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings | | | 0 | |
| | Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3) | | | (954,281 | ) |
| | Less: RRP Vesting (3) | | | (1,908,563 | ) |
| | Less: Option Plan Vesting (4) | | | (1,433,976 | ) |
| | | | | | |
| | Net Earnings Increase | | $ | 1,203,741 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
3. | | Pro Forma Earnings | | | | | Before Conversion(5) | | | Net Earnings Increase | | | After Conversion | |
| | 12 Months ended December 31, 2014 (reported) | | | | | | $ | 9,709,327 | | | $ | 1,203,741 | | | $ | 10,913,068 | |
| | 12 Months ended December 31, 2014 (core) | | | | | | $ | 9,501,327 | | | $ | 1,203,741 | | | $ | 10,705,068 | |
| | | | | |
4. | | Pro Forma Net Worth | | Before Conversion(5) | | | Net Cash Proceeds | | | Tax Benefit and Other | | | After Conversion | |
| | December 31, 2014 | | $ | 493,451,000 | | | $ | 512,872,825 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 1,009,823,825 | |
| | December 31, 2014 (Tangible) | | $ | 384,170,000 | | | $ | 512,872,825 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 900,542,825 | |
| | | | | |
5. | | Pro Forma Assets | | Before Conversion(5) | | | Net Cash Proceeds | | | Tax Benefit and Other | | | After Conversion | |
| | December 31, 2014 | | $ | 3,548,086,000 | | | $ | 512,872,825 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 4,064,458,825 | |
| | |
(1) Includes ESOP purchases of 5% of the second step offering. | | |
(2) Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering. | | |
(3) ESOP amortized over 20 years, RRP amortized over 5 years, tax effected at: 35.00% | | |
(4) Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 5 year vesting, and assuming 25% taxable. | | |
(5) Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets. | | |
Exhibit 3
PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS
Kearny Financial Corp.
At the Midpoint of the Range
| | | | | | |
1. | | Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio | | | | |
| | Fully Converted Value | | $ | 893,152,780 | |
| | Exchange Ratio | | | 1.31790 | |
| | |
| | 2nd Step Offering Proceeds | | $ | 685,000,000 | |
| | Less: Estimated Offering Expenses | | | 23,364,550 | |
| | | | | | |
| | 2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds (Including Foundation) | | $ | 661,635,450 | |
| | |
2. | | Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds | | | | |
| | |
| | Net Conversion Proceeds | | $ | 661,635,450 | |
| | Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation | | | (5,000,000 | ) |
| | Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1) | | | (34,500,000 | ) |
| | Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2) | | | (17,250,000 | ) |
| | | | | | |
| | Net Cash Proceeds | | $ | 604,885,450 | |
| | Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return | | | 1.07 | % |
| | | | | | |
| | Earnings Increase | | $ | 6,487,396 | |
| | Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings | | | 0 | |
| | Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3) | | | (1,121,250 | ) |
| | Less: RRP Vesting (3) | | | (2,242,500 | ) |
| | Less: Option Plan Vesting (4) | | | (1,684,877 | ) |
| | | | | | |
| | Net Earnings Increase | | $ | 1,438,770 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
3. | | Pro Forma Earnings | | | | | Before Conversion(5) | | | Net Earnings Increase | | | After Conversion | |
| | 12 Months ended December 31, 2014 (reported) | | | | | | $ | 9,709,327 | | | $ | 1,438,770 | | | $ | 11,148,097 | |
| | 12 Months ended December 31, 2014 (core) | | | | | | $ | 9,501,327 | | | $ | 1,438,770 | | | $ | 10,940,097 | |
| | | | | |
4. | | Pro Forma Net Worth | | Before Conversion (5) | | | Net Cash Proceeds | | | Tax Benefit of Foundation | | | After Conversion | |
| | December 31, 2014 | | $ | 493,451,000 | | | $ | 604,885,450 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 1,101,836,450 | |
| | December 31, 2014 (Tangible) | | $ | 384,170,000 | | | $ | 604,885,450 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 992,555,450 | |
| | | | | |
5. | | Pro Forma Assets | | Before Conversion (5) | | | Net Cash Proceeds | | | Tax Benefit of Foundation | | | After Conversion | |
| | December 31, 2014 | | $ | 3,548,086,000 | | | $ | 604,885,450 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 4,156,471,450 | |
(1) | Includes ESOP purchases of 5% of the second step offering. |
(2) | Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering. |
(3) | ESOP amortized over 20 years, RRP amortized over 5 years, tax effected at: 35.00% |
(4) | Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 5 year vesting, and assuming 25% taxable. |
(5) | Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets. |
Exhibit 3
PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS
Kearny Financial Corp.
At the Maximum of the Range
| | | | | | |
1. | | Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio | | | | |
| | Fully Converted Value | | $ | 1,026,375,700 | |
| | Exchange Ratio | | | 1.51558 | |
| | |
| | 2nd Step Offering Proceeds | | $ | 787,750,000 | |
| | Less: Estimated Offering Expenses | | | 26,395,675 | |
| | | | | | |
| | 2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds (Including Foundation) | | $ | 761,354,325 | |
| | |
2. | | Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds | | | | |
| | |
| | Net Conversion Proceeds | | $ | 761,354,325 | |
| | Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation | | | (5,000,000 | ) |
| | Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1) | | | (39,637,500 | ) |
| | Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2) | | | (19,818,750 | ) |
| | | | | | |
| | Net Cash Proceeds | | $ | 696,898,075 | |
| | Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return | | | 1.07 | % |
| | | | | | |
| | Earnings Increase | | $ | 7,474,232 | |
| | Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings | | | 0 | |
| | Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3) | | | (1,288,219 | ) |
| | Less: RRP Vesting (3) | | | (2,576,438 | ) |
| | Less: Option Plan Vesting (4) | | | (1,935,777 | ) |
| | | | | | |
| | Net Earnings Increase | | $ | 1,673,799 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
3. | | Pro Forma Earnings | | | | | Before Conversion(5) | | | Net Earnings Increase | | | After Conversion | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | 12 Months ended December 31, 2014 (reported) | | | | | | $ | 9,709,327 | | | $ | 1,673,799 | | | $ | 11,383,126 | |
| | 12 Months ended December 31, 2014 (core) | | | | | | $ | 9,501,327 | | | $ | 1,673,799 | | | $ | 11,175,126 | |
| | | | | |
4. | | Pro Forma Net Worth | | Before Conversion (5) | | | Net Cash Proceeds | | | Tax Benefit of Foundation | | | After Conversion | |
| | December 31, 2014 | | $ | 493,451,000 | | | $ | 696,898,075 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 1,193,849,075 | |
| | December 31, 2014 (Tangible) | | $ | 384,170,000 | | | $ | 696,898,075 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 1,084,568,075 | |
| | | | | |
5. | | Pro Forma Assets | | Before Conversion (5) | | | Net Cash Proceeds | | | Tax Benefit of Foundation | | | After Conversion | |
| | December 31, 2014 | | $ | 3,548,086,000 | | | $ | 696,898,075 | | | $ | 3,500,000 | | | $ | 4,248,484,075 | |
| | |
(1) Includes ESOP purchases of 5% of the second step offering. | | |
(2) Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering. | | |
(3) ESOP amortized over 20 years, RRP amortized over 5 years, tax effected at: 35.00% | | |
(4) Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 5 year vesting, and assuming 25% taxable. | | |
(5) Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets. | | |
EXHIBIT 4
Calculation of Minority Ownership Dilution in a Second-Step Offering
Exhibit 4
Kearny Financial Corp.
Impact of MHC Assets & Waived Dividends on Minority Ownership In 2nd Step
Stock Ownership Data as of December 31, 2014
Financial Data as of December 31, 2014
Reflects Pro Forma Market Value as of January 16, 2015
Key Input Assumptions
| | | | | | |
Mid-Tier Stockholders’ Equity | | $ | 493,234,000 | | | (BOOK) |
Aggregate Dividends Waived by MHC | | $ | 0 | | | (WAIVED DIVIDENDS) |
Minority Ownership Interest | | | 22.8792 | % | | (PCT) |
Pro Forma Market Value | | $ | 893,152,780 | | | (VALUE) |
Market Value of MHC Assets (Other than Stock in Mid-Tier) | | $ | 217,000 | | | (MHC ASSETS) |
Adjustment for MHC Assets & Waived Dividends - 2 Step Calculation (as required by FDIC & FRB)
| | | | | | |
| | | | (BOOK - WAIVED DIVIDENDS) x PCT |
Step 1: To Account for Waiver of Dividends | | = | | BOOK |
| | | |
| | = | | 22.8792% | | |
| | |
| | | | (VALUE - MHC ASSETS) x Step 1 |
Step 2: To Account for MHC Assets | | = | | VALUE |
| | | |
| | = | | 22.8736% | | (rounded) |
Current Ownership
| | | | | | | | |
MHC Shares | | | 51,960,337 | | | | 77.12 | % |
Public Shares | | | 15,414,910 | | | | 22.88 | % |
Total Shares | | | 67,375,247 | | | | 100.00 | % |
EXHIBIT 5
Firm Qualifications Statement
RP FINANCIAL, LC.
Advisory | Planning | Valuation
FIRM QUALIFICATION STATEMENT
RP® Financial, LC. (“RP Financial”) provides financial and management consulting, merger advisory and valuation services to the financial services companies, including banks, thrifts, credit unions, insurance companies, mortgage companies and others. We offer a broad array of services, high quality and prompt service, hands-on involvement by our senior staff, careful structuring of strategic initiatives and sophisticated valuation and other analyses consistent with industry practices and regulatory requirements. Our staff has extensive consulting, valuation, financial advisory and industry backgrounds.
STRATEGIC PLANNING SERVICES
RP Financial’s strategic planning services, for established or de novo banking companies, provide effective feasible plans with quantifiable results to enhance shareholder value, achieve regulatory approval or realize other objectives. We conduct situation analyses; establish mission/vision statements, develope strategic goals and objectives; and identify strategies to enhance value, address capital, increase earnings, manage risk and tackle operational or organizational matters. Our proprietary financial simulation models facilitate the evaluation of the feasibility, impact and merit of alternative financial strategies.
MERGER ADVISORY SERVICES
RP Financial’s merger advisory services include targeting buyers and sellers, assessing acquisition merit, conducting due diligence, negotiating and structuring deal terms, preparing merger business plans and financial simulations, rendering fairness opinions, preparing fair valuation analyses and supporting post-merger strategies. RP Financial is also expert in de novo charters, shelf charters and failed bank deals with loss sharing or other assistance. Through financial simulations, valuation proficiency and regulatory familiarity, RP Financial’s merger advisory services center on enhancing shareholder returns.
VALUATION SERVICES
RP Financial’s extensive valuation practice includes mergers, thrift stock conversions, insurance company demutualizations, merger valuation and goodwill impairment, ESOPs, going private, secondary offerings and other purposes. We are highly experienced in performing appraisals conforming with regulatory guidelines and appraisal standards. RP Financial is the nation’s leading valuation firm for thrift stock conversions, with offerings ranging up to $4 billion.
MANAGEMENT STUDIES
RP Financial provides effective organizational planning, and we are often engaged to prepare independent management studies required for regulatory enforcement actions. We evaluate Board, management and staffing needs, assess existing talent and capabilities and make strategic recommendations for new positions, replacement, succession and other organizational matters.
ENTERPRISE RISK ASSESSMENT SERVICES
RP Financial provides effective enterprise risk assessment consulting services to assist our clients in evaluating the degree to which they have properly identified, understood, measured, monitored and controlled enterprise risk as part of a deliberate risk/reward strategy and to help them implement strategies to mitigate risk, enhance performance, ensure effective reporting and compliance with laws and regulations and avoid potential future damage to their reputation and associated consequences and to mitigate residual risk and unanticipated losses.
OTHER CONSULTING SERVICES
RP Financial provides other consulting services including evaluating regulatory changes, development diversification and branching strategies, conducting feasibility studies and other research, and preparing management studies in response to regulatory enforcement actions. We assist clients with CRA plans and revising policies and procedures. Our other consulting services are aided by proprietary valuation and financial simulation models.
KEY PERSONNEL (Years of Relevant Experience & Contact Information)
| | | | |
Ronald S. Riggins, Managing Director (34) | | (703) 647-6543 | | rriggins@rpfinancial.com |
William E. Pommerening, Managing Director (31) | | (703) 647-6546 | | wpommerening@rpfinancial.com |
Marcus Faust, Director (27) | | (703) 647-6553 | | mfaust@rpfinancial.com |
Gregory E. Dunn, Director (32) | | (703) 647-6548 | | gdunn@rpfinancial.com |
James P. Hennessey, Director (29) | | (703) 647-6544 | | jhennessey@rpfinancial.com |
James J. Oren, Director (28) | | (703) 647-6549 | | joren@rpfinancial.com |
Timothy M. Biddle, Senior Vice President (25) | | (703) 647-6552 | | tbiddle@rpfinancial.com |
Carla H. Pollard, Senior Vice President (26) | | (703) 647-6556 | | cpollard@rpfinancial.com |
| | | | |
RP Financial, LC. 1100 North Glebe Road, Suite 600 Arlington, VA 22201 | | 1 | | Phone:(703) 528-1700 Fax:(703) 528-1788 www.rpfinancial.com |