On March 26, 2018, the trial court granted the Company’s motion for attorneys’ fees, expert fees, and costs associated with the Company’s defense of the above litigation, and ordered the parties to address the amount of the award. The Company provided a detailed explanation of its attorneys’ fees, expert fees, and costs of such award, which Regeneron responded to, seeking a reduction of the amount. The matter was fully briefed as of May 18, 2018, and the court issued an Order on June 25, 2018, which published on July 10, 2018, granting the Company’s motion for $8,332,453.46 in attorneys’ fees, $465,390.34 in expert fees, and $1,717,100.69 in litigation expenses and costs, along withpre- and post-judgment interest. Regeneron appealed the decision awarding attorneys’ fees to the Company to the Federal Circuit, filing its opening brief on November 7, 2018.
On March 11, 2014, Regeneron served a writ in the Netherlands alleging that the Company was infringing one or more claims in their European patent EP 1 360 287 B1. The Company had opposed that patent in June 2014. On September 17, 2014, Regeneron’s patent EP 1 360 287 B1 was revoked in its entirety by the European Opposition Division of the European Patent Office (the “EPO”). In Europe, an appeal hearing occurred in October and November 2015 at the Technical Board of Appeal for the EPO at which time the patent was reinstated to Regeneron with amended claims. On October 2, 2017, the Company filed an appeal with the Technical Board of Appeal for the EPO to address whether the patent having claims amended during the course of opposition complies with Art. 84 EPC, Art. 123(2) EPC and Rule 80 EPC. On May 25, 2018, at Regeneron’s request, a hearing before the Technical Board of Appeals for the EPO was scheduled for September 13, 2018, to address whether the description of EP 1 360 287 B1 patent having claims amended during the course of opposition complies with Art. 84 EPC, Art. 123(2) EPC and Rule 80 EPC. The Technical Board of Appeals provided preliminary views on the matter on August 23, 2018, after which the Company’s appeal filed on October 2, 2017 was withdrawn on September 5, 2018.
The costs incurred in the above litigation and opposition were €0.6 million and €1.5 million for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2018, respectively, as compared to €0.2 million and €0.6 million for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2017, respectively, and are included in the consolidated statement of profit or loss and comprehensive loss for the period.
Regeneron also previously raised opposition proceedings against certain of the Company’s patents in jurisdictions including Europe, Japan and Australia.
On December 20, 2018, the Company signed a global settlement and cross-license agreement with Regeneron, where the parties have agreed to end all pending litigation and opposition proceedings pertaining to the Company’s and Regeneron’s respective antibody generation technologies. Regeneron also purchased 600,000 of the Company’s common shares at a price of $25 per share for total aggregate proceeds of $15.0 million. Under the terms of the settlement, Regeneron has agreed to withdraw its appeal of the decision awarding attorneys’ fees to the Company as a result of the U.S. District Court litigation described above, and the Company has agreed to dismiss its fee award. In addition, Regeneron has agreed to dismiss its stayed case in the Netherlands asserting the EP 1 360 287 B1 patent, and both parties have agreed to withdraw all pending oppositions.
On April 5, 2018, an unnamed third party and Regeneron filed notices of opposition against the Company’s EP 2604625 patent, entitled “Generation of Binding Molecules,” in the EPO. The notices asserted, as applicable, added subject matter, lack of novelty, lack of inventive step, and insufficiency. Regeneron will no longer be pursuing this opposition pursuant to December 20, 2018 settlement. On August 20, 2018, the Company timely responded to these submissions, with proceedings to be ongoing. As this opposition proceeding continues, the Company cannot be certain that the Company will ultimately prevail.
From time to time, the Company may be involved in various other claims and legal proceedings relating to claims arising out of the Company’s operations. The Company is not currently a party to any other material legal proceedings.
13. Employee Benefits
Details of the employee benefits are as follows:
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| | Three months ended September 30, | | | Nine months ended September 30, | |
| | 2018 | | | 2017 | | | 2018 | | | 2017 | |
| | (euros in thousands) | |
Salaries and wages | | | 2,780 | | | | 2,696 | | | | 8,285 | | | | 6,878 | |
WBSO subsidy | | | (1,591 | ) | | | (744 | ) | | | (3,491 | ) | | | (2,749 | ) |
Social security premiums | | | 198 | | | | 150 | | | | 647 | | | | 443 | |
Health insurance | | | 50 | | | | 94 | | | | 238 | | | | 156 | |
Pension costs | | | 178 | | | | 183 | | | | 568 | | | | 505 | |
Share award expense | | | 2,034 | | | | 2,654 | | | | 6,588 | | | | 10,534 | |
Other personnel expense | | | 409 | | | | 272 | | | | 842 | | | | 536 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
Total employee benefits expense | | | 4,058 | | | | 5,305 | | | | 13,677 | | | | 16,303 | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
20