• If significant decisions of the entity are made at the board of directors level.
Pursuant to paragraphs 55 and 56 of the Constitution of AARK (see Annex F of the Registration Statement), the board shall have the authority to make all significant decisions related to the day-today operations of AARK. The board of AARK comprises three directors, two of which shall be nominated by the four (out of seven) independent directors to serve on the board of the Combined Company.
• The period of time which WWAC will be able to control the board of directors considering the change in voting interests subsequent to the exchange agreement.
The owners of AARK are expected to have control of the Combined Company before the exchange agreement via board control and subsequent to the exchange agreement via holding a majority of the voting rights, which is expected to be the case in the minimum, interim and maximum redemption scenarios.
• Consideration of substantive participating rights of the AARK shareholder.
Please refer to the response to the first bullet point above for details of management’s considerations of the above.
• The risk factor on page 13 states management of Aeries will become the management of ATI. In the same risk factors, it appears representatives of AARK and Aeries and their appointees will have the majority of the members of the ATI board.
Management considered the guidance under ASC 805-10-55-12d, and noted that AARK’s executive team will make up the executive team of the Combined Company. Please refer to the section “Management of ATI following the Business Combination” in the S-4 for details of these officers.
• The post exchange table on page 15 indicates the Sole Shareholder of AARK (who is Venu Kamar, Chairman of and majority shareholder in Aeries) and Exchanging Aeries Holders combined will own the majority of outstanding ATI ordinary shares.
Management considered the guidance under ASC 805-10-55-12a, and noted that at consummation of the transaction, a majority of the Class A ordinary shares of the Combined Company will be held by public shareholders of WWAC. Pursuant to the exchange agreements, from and after April 1, 2024 and subject to certain exercise conditions, the Combined Company shall have the right to purchase from any shareholder the Aeries Shares or AARK Ordinary Shares held by such shareholder (the “Exchanged Shares”) in exchange for the delivery of Class A ordinary shares of Aeries Technology, Inc. In addition, each shareholder of Aeries and AARK ordinary shares shall be entitled to deliver Exchanged Shares in exchange for the delivery of Class A ordinary shares of Aeries Technology, Inc. The Company agrees with the Staff’s comment that post exchange, the owners of AARK will own the majority of outstanding ATI ordinary shares.
• Disclosures on pages 48, 74 and 111 of the concentration of voting control with the Class V Shareholder.
Refer to the response to the first bullet point above for details of management’s considerations of the above.
In addition to the points raised by the Staff in the comments above, we note the following additional factors from ASC 805 that were evaluated by us:
| • | | In consideration of ASC 805-10-55-13, we noted WWAC’s assets are represented by deposits in a trust fund account that are solely to be applied towards a business combination subject to redemptions. AARK represents an operating entity (group) with operating assets, revenues and earnings significantly larger than WWAC. Hence this factor points to AARK being larger entity and thus, the accounting acquirer. |
| • | | AARK has never been a publicly traded entity; therefore, the fair value of its equity is less objectively determinable. However, the transaction is based upon an estimated pre-money equity valuation of $349 million, and the ranges of acquisition consideration (assuming either minimum, medium, and maximum redemption of common stock by WWAC shareholders) are greater than WWAC’s market capitalization. Therefore, since AARK is the combining entity that transfers a premium over the precombination fair value of WWAC, the Company believes this factor points toward AARK being the accounting acquirer. |
In accordance with the above assessment, it was thus determined that AARK is the accounting acquirer.
8