Exhibit 5.1
June 30, 2011
[Letterhead of Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP]
Alpha Natural Resources, Inc.
Guarantors listed on Schedule I hereto
c/o Alpha Natural Resources, Inc.
One Alpha Place
P.O. Box 2345
Abingdon, Virginia 24212
Re: Registration Statement on Form S-3 |
Ladies and Gentlemen:
We have acted as special counsel to Alpha Natural Resources, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the “Company”), in connection with the preparation and filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”) pursuant to the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”) of the registration statement on Form S-3 (No. 333-165473), as amended by Post-Effective Amendment No. 1 and Post-Effective Amendment No. 2 (as so amended, the “Registration Statement”), of the Company and the guarantors listed on Schedule I hereto (the “Guarantors”), relating to the offering from time to time, together or separately in one or more series (if applicable), of (i) shares of the Company’s common stock, par value $0.01 per share (the “Common Stock”); (ii) shares of the Company’s preferred stock, par value $0.01 per share (the “Preferred Stock”); (iii) fractional interests in shares of Preferred Stock evidenced by depositary receipts (the “Depositary Shares”); (iv) senior or subordinated debt securities of the Company (which may be convertible into Common Stock) (the “Debt Securities”); (v) guarantees by the Guarantors of the Preferred Stock (the “Preferred Guarantees”) or the Debt Securities (the “Debt Guarantees” and, together with the Preferred Guarantees, the “Guarantees”); (vi) warrants to purchase debt or equity securities of the Company (the “Warrants”); (vii) contracts for the purchase or sale of Common Stock, Preferred Stock, Depositary Shares or Debt Securities (or any combination thereof), currencies or commodities (the “Purchase Contracts”); and (viii) units consisting of one or more Purchase Contracts, Warrants, Debt Securities, shares of Preferred Stock, shares of Common Stock or any combination thereof (the “Units”). The Common Stock, Preferred Stock, Depositary Shares, Debt Securities, Guarantees, Warrants, Purchase Contracts and Units are referred to herein collectively as the “Securities.”
The Securities being registered under the Registration Statement will have an indeterminate aggregate initial offering price and will be offered on a continuous or delayed basis pursuant to the provisions of Rule 415 under the Securities Act.
The Depositary Shares are to be issued from time to time under one or more deposit agreements (each such deposit agreement, a “Deposit Agreement”) to be entered into between the Company and the depositary to be named therein.
The Debt Securities may be either senior debt securities or subordinated debt securities and may be guaranteed by some or all of the Guarantors. Any senior debt securities and related Debt Guarantees, if any, may be issued pursuant to the indenture dated as of June 1, 2011 (the “June 2011 Senior Indenture”) entered into among the Company, the Guarantors and Union Bank, N.A., as Trustee (the “Trustee”) or another indenture that may be entered into among the Company, the Guarantors and the Trustee (together with the June 2011 Senior Indenture, the “Senior Indenture”). Any subordinated debt securities and related Debt Guarantees, if any may be issued pursuant to a subordinated indenture (as amended or supplemented, the “Subordinated Indenture” and together with the Senior Indenture, the “Indentures”) to be entered into among the Company, the Guarantors and the Trustee.
The Preferred Guarantees are to be issued under a guarantee agreement (the “Preferred Guarantee Agreement”) to be entered into between the Company and the guarantee trustee to be named therein.
The Warrants are to be issued from time to time under one or more warrant agreements (each such warrant agreement, a “Warrant Agreement”) to be entered into between the Company and the warrant agent to be named therein.
The Purchase Contracts are to be issued from time to time under (i) one or more purchase contract agreements (each such purchase contract agreement, a “Purchase Contract Agreement”) to be entered into between the Company and the purchase contract agent to be named therein or (ii) the Senior Indenture.
The Units are to be issued from time to time under one or more unit agreements (each such unit agreement, a “Unit Agreement”) to be entered into between the Company and the unit agent to be named therein.
In arriving at the opinion expressed below, we have reviewed the following documents:
| (a) | the Registration Statement and the documents incorporated by reference therein; |
| (b) | the Senior Indenture and the form of the Subordinated Indenture, each filed as exhibits to the Registration Statement, including the form of Debt Guarantee; and |
| (c) | copies of the Company’s Restated Certificate of Incorporation, as amended, and Amended and Restated By-Laws certified by the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware and the corporate secretary of the Company, respectively. |
In addition, we have reviewed the originals or copies certified or otherwise identified to our satisfaction of all such corporate records of the Company and such other documents, and we have made such investigations of law, as we have deemed appropriate as a basis for the opinions expressed below.
In rendering the opinions expressed below, we have assumed the authenticity of all documents submitted to us as originals and the conformity to the originals of all documents submitted to us as copies. In addition, we have assumed and have not verified the accuracy as to factual matters of each document we have reviewed.
Based on the foregoing, and subject to the further assumptions and qualifications set forth below, it is our opinion that:
1. The Common Stock, including Common Stock to be issued upon conversion, exchange or exercise of any other Security in accordance with its terms, will be validly issued by the Company, fully paid and nonassessable.
2. The Preferred Stock will be validly issued by the Company, fully paid and nonassessable.
3. The Depositary Shares to be sold by the Company, upon the due issuance by the Depositary of depositary receipts (including any master depositary receipt issued in connection therewith) evidencing such Depositary Shares against the deposit of the shares of Preferred Stock in respect thereof in accordance with the provisions of the Deposit Agreement, will be validly issued and the persons in whose names the depositary receipts are registered will be entitled to the rights specified therein and in the Deposit Agreement.
4. The Debt Securities will be the valid, binding and enforceable obligations of the Company, entitled to the benefits of the applicable Indenture.
5. The Guarantees will be the valid, binding and enforceable obligations of the applicable Guarantor, entitled to the benefits of the applicable Indenture or Preferred Guarantee Agreement, as the case may be.
6. The Warrants will be the valid, binding and enforceable obligations of the Company.
7. The Purchase Contracts will be the valid, binding and enforceable obligations of the Company.
8. The Units will be the valid, binding and enforceable obligations of the Company.
Insofar as the foregoing opinions relate to the validity, binding effect or enforceability of any agreement or obligation of the Company or any Guarantor, (a) we have assumed that the Company or such Guarantor and each other party to such agreement or obligation has satisfied or, prior to the issuance of the Securities, will satisfy, those legal requirements that are applicable to it to the extent necessary to make such agreement or obligation enforceable against it and (b) such opinions are subject to applicable bankruptcy, insolvency and similar laws affecting creditors’ rights generally and to general principles of equity.
In rendering the opinions expressed above, we have further assumed that (i) the Company (and each Guarantor, if applicable) will authorize the offering and issuance of the Securities and will duly authorize, approve and establish the final terms and conditions thereof, which terms will conform to the descriptions thereof in the Registration Statement and, in the case of the Debt Securities and the Debt Guarantees, to the terms of the applicable Indenture, and will not violate any applicable law, conflict with any matter of public policy, result in a default under or breach of any agreement or instrument binding upon the Company (or such Guarantor) or violate any requirement or restriction imposed by any court or governmental body having jurisdiction over the Company (or such Guarantor); (ii) the Board of Directors of the Company will duly authorize, establish and approve the terms of the Preferred Stock as contemplated by the Company’s Restated Certificate of Incorporation, as amended, and the Company (and each Guarantor, if applicable) will duly authorize, execute and deliver the applicable Deposit Agreement, Indentures, Guarantees, Preferred Guarantee Agreement, Warrant Agreement, Purchase Contract Agreement and Unit Agreement and any other agreement necessary with respect to the Securities or contemplated by such Securities, any agreement governing those Securities or the Registration Statement and will take any other appropriate additional corporate action, the Senior Indenture will conform to the June 2011 Senior Indenture and the Subordinated Indenture and the Debt Guarantees will conform to the forms thereof filed as exhibits to the Registration Statement; (iii) any receipts evidencing Depositary Shares, Warrants, Purchase Contracts or Units and any agreement governing those Securities will be governed by New York law; (iv) the Securities will be offered, issued, sold and delivered in compliance with applicable law and any requirements therefor set forth in any corporate action authorizing such Securities and any agreement governing those Securities and in the manner contemplated by the Registration Statement; (v) the Securities will be offered, sold and delivered to, and paid for by, the purchasers thereof at the price specified in, and in accordance with the terms of, an agreement or agreements duly authorized, executed and delivered by the parties thereto, which price, in the case of Common Stock or Preferred Stock, shall not be less than the par value of such Common Stock or Preferred Stock; and (vi) if issued in certificated form, certificates representing the Securities will be duly executed and delivered and, to the extent required by any applicable agreement, duly authenticated and countersigned, and if issued in book-entry form, the Securities will be duly registered to the extent required by any applicable agreement.
In rendering the opinions expressed in paragraphs 4 and 5 above, we have assumed that each series of Debt Securities (and related Guarantees) will be issued with an original aggregate principal amount (or in the case of Debt Securities issued at original issue discount, an aggregate issue price) of $2,500,000 or more.
In rendering the opinion expressed in paragraph 5, we express no opinion with respect to the enforceability of the first sentence of the second paragraph of the form of Debt Guarantee contained in Section 2.02 of the Indentures or any similar provision in the Preferred Guarantees or any Preferred Guarantee Agreement to the effect that the applicable Guarantor is liable as a primary rather than secondary obligor.
We note that any designation in the Securities or any applicable agreement governing those Securities of the U.S. federal courts sitting in New York City as the venue for actions or proceedings relating to such Securities is (notwithstanding any waiver thereof) subject to the power of such courts to transfer actions pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1404(a) or to dismiss such actions or proceedings on the grounds that such a federal court is an inconvenient forum for such an action or proceeding.
We note that by statute New York provides that a judgment or decree rendered in a currency other than the currency of the United States shall be converted into U.S. dollars at the rate of exchange prevailing on the date of entry of the judgment or decree. There is no corresponding federal statute and no controlling Federal court decision on this issue. Accordingly, we express no opinion as to whether a Federal court would award a judgment in a currency other than U.S. dollars or, if it did so, whether it would order conversion of the judgment into U.S. dollars. In addition, to the extent that any Securities or applicable agreement governing those Securities includes a provision relating to indemnification against any loss in obtaining currency due from a court judgment in another currency, we express no opinion as to the enforceability of such provision.
The foregoing opinions are limited to the federal law of the United States of America, the law of the State of New York and the General Corporation Law of the State of Delaware (including the applicable provisions of the Delaware Constitution and reported judicial decisions interpreting the General Corporation Law of the State of Delaware).
We hereby consent to the use of our name in the prospectus constituting a part of the Registration Statement under the heading “Legal Matters” and in any prospectus supplement related thereto as counsel for the Company that has passed on the validity of the Securities, and to the use of this opinion as a part (Exhibit 5.1) of the Registration Statement. In giving this consent, we do not thereby admit that we are within the category of persons whose consent is required under Section 7 of the Securities Act or the rules and regulations of the Commission thereunder. The opinions expressed herein are rendered on and as of the date hereof, and we assume no obligation to advise you or any other person, or to make any investigations, as to any legal developments or factual matters arising subsequent to the date hereof that might affect the opinions expressed herein.
Very truly yours, CLEARY GOTTLIEB STEEN & HAMILTON LLP By: /s/ Sandra L. Flow Sandra L. Flow, a Partner |
Schedule I
| Guarantor | State of Incorporation or Organization |
| A. T. Massey Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Alex Energy, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Alliance Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Alpha American Coal Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha American Coal Holding, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Appalachia Holdings, Inc. | Delaware |
| Alpha Appalachia Services, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Alpha Australia, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Australia Services, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Coal Resources Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Coal Sales Co., LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Coal West, Inc. | Delaware |
| Alpha Energy Sales, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha European Sales, Inc. | Virginia |
| Alpha Gas and Oil Company | Louisiana |
| Alpha India, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Land and Reserves, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Midwest Holding Company | Delaware |
| Alpha Natural Resources, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Natural Resources International, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Natural Resources Services, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha PA Coal Terminal, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Shipping and Chartering, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Sub One, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Sub Two, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Sub Three, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Sub Four, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Sub Five, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Terminal Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Alpha Wyoming Land Company, LLC | Delaware |
| AMFIRE, LLC | Delaware |
| AMFIRE Holdings, LLC | Delaware |
| AMFIRE Mining Company, LLC | Delaware |
| AMFIRE WV, L.P. | Delaware |
| Appalachia Coal Sales Company, Inc. | Virginia |
| Appalachia Holding Company | Virginia |
| Aracoma Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Axiom Excavating and Grading Services, LLC | Delaware |
| Bandmill Coal Corporation | West Virginia |
| Bandytown Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Barbara Holdings Inc. | Delaware |
| Barnabus Land Company | West Virginia |
| Belfry Coal Corporation | West Virginia |
| Ben Creek Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Big Bear Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Big Laurel Mining Corporation | Virginia |
| Black Dog Coal, LLC | Virginia |
| Black King Mine Development Co. | West Virginia |
| Black Mountain Resources LLC | Virginia |
| Bluff Spur Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Boone East Development Co. | West Virginia |
| Boone Energy Company | West Virginia |
| Boone West Development Co. | West Virginia |
| Brooks Run Mining Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Buchanan Energy Company, LLC | Virginia |
| Bull Mountain Mining Corporation | Virginia |
| Callaway Land and Reserves, LLC | Delaware |
| Castle Gate Holding Company | Delaware |
| Cave Spur Coal LLC | Virginia |
| Central Penn Energy Company, Inc. | Pennsylvania |
| Central West Virginia Energy Company | West Virginia |
| Ceres Land Company | West Virginia |
| Clear Fork Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Cloverlick Coal Company LLC | Virginia |
| Cloverlick Management LLC | Virginia |
| Coal Gas Recovery, LLC | Delaware |
| Cobra Natural Resources, LLC | Delaware |
| Coral Energy Services, LLC | Delaware |
| Corral Creek Holding, LLC | Delaware |
| Crystal Fuels Company | West Virginia |
| Cumberland Coal Resources, LP | Delaware |
| Cumberland Equipment Corporation | Virginia |
| Cumberland Resources Corporation | Virginia |
| Dehue Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Delbarton Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Delta Mine Holding Company | Delaware |
| Demeter Land Company | West Virginia |
| Dickenson-Russell Coal Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Dickenson-Russell Land and Reserves, LLC | Delaware |
| Dorchester Associates LLC | Virginia |
| Dorchester Enterprises, Incorporated | Virginia |
| Douglas Pocahontas Coal Corporation | West Virginia |
| DRIH Corporation | Delaware |
| Dry Systems Technologies, Inc. | Delaware |
| Duchess Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Eagle Energy, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Elk Run Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Emerald Coal Resources, LP | Delaware |
| En Route LLC | Virginia |
| Energy Development Corporation | West Virginia |
| Enterprise Land and Reserves, LLC | Delaware |
| Enterprise Mining Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Esperanza Coal Co., LLC | Delaware |
| Exeter Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Foglesong Energy Company | West Virginia |
| Foundation Mining, LLC | Delaware |
| Foundation PA Coal Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Foundation Royalty Company | Delaware |
| Freeport Mining, LLC | Delaware |
| Freeport Resources Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Goals Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Green Valley Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Greyeagle Coal Company | Kentucky |
| Guest Mountain Mining Corporation | Virginia |
| Haden Farms, Inc. | Virginia |
| Hanna Land Company, LLC | Kentucky |
| Harlan Reclamation Services LLC | Virginia |
| Hazy Ridge Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Herndon Processing Company, LLC | West Virginia |
| High Splint Coal LLC | Virginia |
| Highland Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Hopkins Creek Coal Company | Kentucky |
| Independence Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Jacks Branch Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Joboner Coal Company | Kentucky |
| JST Land Company | Virginia |
| JST Mining Company | Virginia |
| JST Resources LLC | Virginia |
| Kanawha Energy Company | West Virginia |
| Kepler Processing Company, LLC | West Virginia |
| Kingston Mining, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Kingston Processing, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Kingston Resources, Inc. | Kentucky |
| Kingwood Mining Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Knox Creek Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Laurel Creek Co., Inc. | Delaware |
| Lauren Land Company | Kentucky |
| Laxare, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Litwar Processing Company, LLC | West Virginia |
| Logan County Mine Services, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Long Fork Coal Company | Kentucky |
| Lynn Branch Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Maggard Branch Coal LLC | Virginia |
| Majestic Mining, Inc. | Texas |
| Maple Meadow Mining Company | Delaware |
| Marfork Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Martin County Coal Corporation | Kentucky |
| Maxxim Rebuild Co., LLC | Delaware |
| Maxxim Shared Services, LLC | Delaware |
| Maxxum Carbon Resources, LLC | Delaware |
| McDowell-Wyoming Coal Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Meadow Branch Coal LLC | Virginia |
| Meadow Branch Mining Corporation | Virginia |
| Mill Branch Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Mountain Management, Incorporated | Virginia |
| New Market Land Company | West Virginia |
| New Ridge Mining Company | Kentucky |
| New River Energy Corporation | West Virginia |
| Neweagle Coal Sales Corp. | Virginia |
| Neweagle Development Corp. | Virginia |
| Neweagle Industries, Inc. | Virginia |
| Neweagle Mining Corp. | Virginia |
| Nicco Corporation | West Virginia |
| Nicewonder Contracting, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Nicholas Energy Company | West Virginia |
| Nine Mile Spur LLC | Virginia |
| North Fork Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Odell Processing Inc. | West Virginia |
| Omar Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Osaka Mining Corporation | Virginia |
| Palladian Lime, LLC | Delaware |
| Panther Mining LLC | Virginia |
| Paramont Coal Company Virginia, LLC | Delaware |
| Paynter Branch Mining, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Peerless Eagle Coal Co. | West Virginia |
| Pennsylvania Land Holdings Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Pennsylvania Services Corporation | Delaware |
| Performance Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Peter Cave Mining Company | Kentucky |
| Pigeon Creek Processing Corporation | Virginia |
| Pilgrim Mining Company, Inc. | Kentucky |
| Pioneer Fuel Corporation | West Virginia |
| Pioneer Mining, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Plateau Mining Corporation | Delaware |
| Powell River Resources Corporation | Virginia |
| Power Mountain Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Premium Energy, LLC | Delaware |
| Raven Resources, Inc. | Florida |
| Rawl Sales & Processing Co. | West Virginia |
| Red Ash Sales Company, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Resource Development LLC | Virginia |
| Resource Land Company LLC | Virginia |
| River Processing Corporation | Delaware |
| Rivereagle Corp. | Virginia |
| Riverside Energy Company, LLC | West Virginia |
| Riverton Coal Production Inc. | Delaware |
| Riverton Coal Sales, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Road Fork Development Company, Inc. | Kentucky |
| Robinson-Phillips Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Rockspring Development, Inc. | Delaware |
| Roda Resources LLC | Virginia |
| Rostraver Energy Company | Pennsylvania |
| Ruhrkohle Trading Corporation | West Virginia |
| Rum Creek Coal Sales, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Russell Fork Coal Company | West Virginia |
| SC Coal Corporation | Delaware |
| Scarlet Development Company | Pennsylvania |
| Shannon-Pocahontas Coal Corporation | West Virginia |
| Shannon-Pocahontas Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Shenandoah Capital Management Corp. | West Virginia |
| Sidney Coal Company, Inc. | Kentucky |
| Simmons Fork Mining, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Solomons Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Spartan Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Stillhouse Mining LLC | Virginia |
| Stirrat Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Stone Mining Company | Kentucky |
| Support Mining Company | West Virginia |
| Sycamore Fuels, Inc. | West Virginia |
| T. C. H. Coal Co. | Kentucky |
| Talon Loadout Company | West Virginia |
| Tennessee Consolidated Coal Company | Tennessee |
| Tennessee Energy Corp. | Tennessee |
| Town Creek Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Trace Creek Coal Company | Pennsylvania |
| Tucson Limited Liability Company | West Virginia |
| Twin Star Mining, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Vantage Mining Company | Kentucky |
| Virginia Energy Company, LLC | Delaware |
| Wabash Mine Holding Company | Delaware |
| Warrick Holding Company | Delaware |
| West Kentucky Energy Company | Kentucky |
| White Buck Coal Company | West Virginia |
| White Flame Energy, Inc. | West Virginia |
| Williams Mountain Coal Company | West Virginia |
| Winifrede Coal Corporation | Virginia |
| Wyomac Coal Company, Inc. | West Virginia |