Loans | 4. Loans Our assessment of the allowance for loan losses is based on an evaluation of the loan portfolio, recent loss experience, current economic conditions and other pertinent factors. An analysis of the allowance for loan losses by portfolio segment for the three months ended September 30, follows: Commercial Mortgage Installment Payment Plan Receivables Subjective Allocation Total (In thousands) 2016 Balance at beginning of period $ 6,039 $ 9,956 $ 1,139 $ 52 $ 5,526 $ 22,712 Additions (deductions) Provision for loan losses (153 ) (247 ) 208 - 17 (175 ) Recoveries credited to allowance 474 195 236 - - 905 Loans charged against the allowance (365 ) (561 ) (473 ) - - (1,399 ) Balance at end of period $ 5,995 $ 9,343 $ 1,110 $ 52 $ 5,543 $ 22,043 2015 Balance at beginning of period $ 6,707 $ 11,465 $ 1,461 $ 65 $ 4,888 $ 24,586 Additions (deductions) Provision for loan losses (26 ) (47 ) (49 ) (5 ) (117 ) (244 ) Recoveries credited to allowance 637 286 250 - - 1,173 Loans charged against the allowance (190 ) (379 ) (342 ) - - (911 ) Balance at end of period $ 7,128 $ 11,325 $ 1,320 $ 60 $ 4,771 $ 24,604 An analysis of the allowance for loan losses by portfolio segment for the nine months ended September 30, follows: Commercial Mortgage Installment Payment Plan Receivables Subjective Allocation Total (In thousands) 2016 Balance at beginning of period $ 5,670 $ 10,391 $ 1,181 $ 56 $ 5,272 $ 22,570 Additions (deductions) Provision for loan losses (1,220 ) (885 ) 399 (4 ) 271 (1,439 ) Recoveries credited to allowance 1,944 871 808 - - 3,623 Loans charged against the allowance (399 ) (1,034 ) (1,278 ) - - (2,711 ) Balance at end of period $ 5,995 $ 9,343 $ 1,110 $ 52 $ 5,543 $ 22,043 2015 Balance at beginning of period $ 5,445 $ 13,444 $ 1,814 $ 64 $ 5,223 $ 25,990 Additions (deductions) Provision for loan losses 479 (881 ) (179 ) (4 ) (452 ) (1,037 ) Recoveries credited to allowance 1,722 843 853 - - 3,418 Loans charged against the allowance (518 ) (2,081 ) (1,168 ) - - (3,767 ) Balance at end of period $ 7,128 $ 11,325 $ 1,320 $ 60 $ 4,771 $ 24,604 Allowance for loan losses and recorded investment in loans by portfolio segment follows: Commercial Mortgage Installment Payment Plan Receivables Subjective Allocation Total (In thousands) September 30, 2016 Allowance for loan losses Individually evaluated for impairment $ 3,325 $ 6,717 $ 333 $ - $ - $ 10,375 Collectively evaluated for impairment 2,670 2,626 777 52 5,543 11,668 Total ending allowance balance $ 5,995 $ 9,343 $ 1,110 $ 52 $ 5,543 $ 22,043 Loans Individually evaluated for impairment $ 16,087 $ 60,891 $ 5,101 $ - $ 82,079 Collectively evaluated for impairment 770,642 464,234 263,973 31,188 1,530,037 Total loans recorded investment 786,729 525,125 269,074 31,188 1,612,116 Accrued interest included in recorded investment 1,753 2,292 717 - 4,762 Total loans $ 784,976 $ 522,833 $ 268,357 $ 31,188 $ 1,607,354 December 31, 2015 Allowance for loan losses Individually evaluated for impairment $ 2,708 $ 7,818 $ 457 $ - $ - $ 10,983 Collectively evaluated for impairment 2,962 2,573 724 56 5,272 11,587 Total ending allowance balance $ 5,670 $ 10,391 $ 1,181 $ 56 $ 5,272 $ 22,570 Loans Individually evaluated for impairment $ 16,868 $ 66,375 $ 5,888 $ - $ 89,131 Collectively evaluated for impairment 733,399 433,931 228,827 34,599 1,430,756 Total loans recorded investment 750,267 500,306 234,715 34,599 1,519,887 Accrued interest included in recorded investment 1,869 2,270 698 - 4,837 Total loans $ 748,398 $ 498,036 $ 234,017 $ 34,599 $ 1,515,050 Loans on non-accrual status and past due more than 90 days (“Non-performing Loans”) follow: 90+ and Still Accruing Non- Accrual Total Non- Performing Loans (In thousands) September 30, 2016 Commercial Income producing - real estate $ - $ 658 $ 658 Land, land development and construction - real estate - 211 211 Commercial and industrial - 2,517 2,517 Mortgage 1-4 family - 4,429 4,429 Resort lending - 1,624 1,624 Home equity - 1st lien - 273 273 Home equity - 2nd lien - 353 353 Purchased loans - - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - 96 96 Home equity - 2nd lien - 249 249 Loans not secured by real estate - 384 384 Other - 3 3 Payment plan receivables Full refund - - - Partial refund - 4 4 Other - - - Total recorded investment $ - $ 10,801 $ 10,801 Accrued interest included in recorded investment $ - $ - $ - December 31, 2015 Commercial Income producing - real estate $ - $ 1,027 $ 1,027 Land, land development and construction - real estate 49 401 450 Commercial and industrial 69 2,028 2,097 Mortgage 1-4 family - 4,744 4,744 Resort lending - 1,094 1,094 Home equity - 1st lien - 187 187 Home equity - 2nd lien - 147 147 Purchased loans - 2 2 Installment Home equity - 1st lien - 106 106 Home equity - 2nd lien - 443 443 Loans not secured by real estate - 421 421 Other - 2 2 Payment plan receivables Full refund - 2 2 Partial refund - 2 2 Other - 1 1 Total recorded investment $ 118 $ 10,607 $ 10,725 Accrued interest included in recorded investment $ 2 $ - $ 2 An aging analysis of loans by class follows: Loans Past Due Loans not Total 30-59 days 60-89 days 90+ days Total Past Due Loans (In thousands) September 30, 2016 Commercial Income producing - real estate $ - $ - $ 541 $ 541 $ 273,461 $ 274,002 Land, land development and construction - real estate - - 133 133 53,836 53,969 Commercial and industrial 105 116 457 678 458,080 458,758 Mortgage 1-4 family 2,180 1,461 4,429 8,070 285,892 293,962 Resort lending 1,975 - 1,624 3,599 103,597 107,196 Home equity - 1st lien 107 - 273 380 27,542 27,922 Home equity - 2nd lien 226 73 353 652 52,882 53,534 Purchased loans 7 1 - 8 42,503 42,511 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 474 179 96 749 13,079 13,828 Home equity - 2nd lien 133 72 249 454 15,064 15,518 Loans not secured by real estate 291 114 384 789 236,376 237,165 Other 10 4 3 17 2,546 2,563 Payment plan receivables Full refund 258 70 - 328 10,035 10,363 Partial refund 506 313 4 823 14,041 14,864 Other 159 40 - 199 5,762 5,961 Total recorded investment $ 6,431 $ 2,443 $ 8,546 $ 17,420 $ 1,594,696 $ 1,612,116 Accrued interest included in recorded investment $ 67 $ 28 $ - $ 95 $ 4,667 $ 4,762 December 31, 2015 Commercial Income producing - real estate $ 203 $ 209 $ 647 $ 1,059 $ 305,155 $ 306,214 Land, land development and construction - real estate - - 252 252 44,231 44,483 Commercial and industrial 785 16 151 952 398,618 399,570 Mortgage 1-4 family 1,943 640 4,744 7,327 269,880 277,207 Resort lending 307 - 1,094 1,401 114,619 116,020 Home equity - 1st lien 50 - 187 237 22,327 22,564 Home equity - 2nd lien 439 54 147 640 50,618 51,258 Purchased loans 9 1 2 12 33,245 33,257 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 315 107 106 528 16,707 17,235 Home equity - 2nd lien 231 149 443 823 19,727 20,550 Loans not secured by real estate 567 83 421 1,071 193,680 194,751 Other 15 3 2 20 2,159 2,179 Payment plan receivables Full refund 492 62 2 556 21,294 21,850 Partial refund 415 228 2 645 5,834 6,479 Other 110 3 1 114 6,156 6,270 Total recorded investment $ 5,881 $ 1,555 $ 8,201 $ 15,637 $ 1,504,250 $ 1,519,887 Accrued interest included in recorded investment $ 53 $ 17 $ 2 $ 72 $ 4,765 $ 4,837 Impaired loans are as follows: September 30, 2016 December 31, 2015 Impaired loans with no allocated allowance (In thousands) TDR $ 541 $ 2,518 Non - TDR 133 203 Impaired loans with an allocated allowance TDR - allowance based on collateral 3,472 4,810 TDR - allowance based on present value cash flow 76,701 81,002 Non - TDR - allowance based on collateral 902 260 Non - TDR - allowance based on present value cash flow - - Total impaired loans $ 81,749 $ 88,793 Amount of allowance for loan losses allocated TDR - allowance based on collateral $ 1,710 $ 2,436 TDR - allowance based on present value cash flow 8,361 8,471 Non - TDR - allowance based on collateral 304 76 Non - TDR - allowance based on present value cash flow - - Total amount of allowance for loan losses allocated $ 10,375 $ 10,983 Impaired loans by class are as follows (1): September 30, 2016 December 31, 2015 Recorded Investment Unpaid Principal Balance Related Allowance Recorded Investment Unpaid Principal Balance Related Allowance With no related allowance recorded: (In thousands) Commercial Income producing - real estate $ 541 $ 787 $ - $ 641 $ 851 $ - Land, land development & construction-real estate 133 709 - 818 1,393 - Commercial and industrial - - - 1,245 1,241 - Mortgage 1-4 family 1 305 - 23 183 - Resort lending - - - - - - Home equity - 1st lien - - - - - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - - - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - 67 - - 76 - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - - - - Loans not secured by real estate - - - - - - Other - - - - - - 675 1,868 - 2,727 3,744 - With an allowance recorded: Commercial Income producing - real estate 7,813 7,951 561 8,377 9,232 516 Land, land development & construction-real estate 389 391 67 1,690 1,778 296 Commercial and industrial 7,211 7,566 2,697 4,097 4,439 1,896 Mortgage 1-4 family 43,038 44,922 4,173 47,792 49,808 5,132 Resort lending 17,295 17,327 2,488 18,148 18,319 2,662 Home equity - 1st lien 239 244 32 168 172 9 Home equity - 2nd lien 318 400 24 244 325 15 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2,108 2,223 105 2,364 2,492 143 Home equity - 2nd lien 2,461 2,480 191 2,929 2,951 271 Loans not secured by real estate 530 566 37 587 658 42 Other 2 2 - 8 8 1 81,404 84,072 10,375 86,404 90,182 10,983 Total Commercial Income producing - real estate 8,354 8,738 561 9,018 10,083 516 Land, land development & construction-real estate 522 1,100 67 2,508 3,171 296 Commercial and industrial 7,211 7,566 2,697 5,342 5,680 1,896 Mortgage 1-4 family 43,039 45,227 4,173 47,815 49,991 5,132 Resort lending 17,295 17,327 2,488 18,148 18,319 2,662 Home equity - 1st lien 239 244 32 168 172 9 Home equity - 2nd lien 318 400 24 244 325 15 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2,108 2,290 105 2,364 2,568 143 Home equity - 2nd lien 2,461 2,480 191 2,929 2,951 271 Loans not secured by real estate 530 566 37 587 658 42 Other 2 2 - 8 8 1 Total $ 82,079 $ 85,940 $ 10,375 $ 89,131 $ 93,926 $ 10,983 Accrued interest included in recorded investment $ 330 $ 338 (1) There were no impaired payment plan receivables or purchased mortgage loans at September 30, 2016 or December 31, 2015 Average recorded investment in and interest income earned on impaired loans by class for the three month periods ending September 30, follows (1): 2016 2015 Average Recorded Investment Interest Income Recognized Average Recorded Investment Interest Income Recognized With no related allowance recorded: (In thousands) Commercial Income producing - real estate $ 551 $ - $ 5,133 $ 45 Land, land development & construction-real estate 133 - 932 14 Commercial and industrial - - 1,922 68 Mortgage 1-4 family 12 3 24 3 Resort lending - - - - Home equity - 1st lien - - - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - 3 - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - - Loans not secured by real estate - - - - Other - - - - 696 6 8,011 130 With an allowance recorded: Commercial Income producing - real estate 8,000 111 14,655 154 Land, land development & construction-real estate 1,117 3 1,993 2 Commercial and industrial 7,145 69 6,431 37 Mortgage 1-4 family 44,256 470 49,706 554 Resort lending 17,372 161 18,414 163 Home equity - 1st lien 241 2 157 2 Home equity - 2nd lien 280 6 185 - Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2,140 34 2,474 47 Home equity - 2nd lien 2,585 37 2,999 47 Loans not secured by real estate 536 9 645 10 Other 4 - 10 - 83,676 902 97,669 1,016 Total Commercial Income producing - real estate 8,551 111 19,788 199 Land, land development & construction-real estate 1,250 3 2,925 16 Commercial and industrial 7,145 69 8,353 105 Mortgage 1-4 family 44,268 473 49,730 557 Resort lending 17,372 161 18,414 163 Home equity - 1st lien 241 2 157 2 Home equity - 2nd lien 280 6 185 - Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2,140 37 2,474 47 Home equity - 2nd lien 2,585 37 2,999 47 Loans not secured by real estate 536 9 645 10 Other 4 - 10 - Total $ 84,372 $ 908 $ 105,680 $ 1,146 (1) There were no impaired payment plan receivables or purchased mortgage loans during the three month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Average recorded investment in and interest income earned on impaired loans by class for the nine month periods ending September 30, follows (1): 2016 2015 Average Recorded Investment Interest Income Recognized Average Recorded Investment Interest Income Recognized With no related allowance recorded: (In thousands) Commercial Income producing - real estate $ 632 $ 2 $ 5,490 $ 170 Land, land development & construction-real estate 405 7 986 57 Commercial and industrial 616 21 2,345 195 Mortgage 1-4 family 12 9 18 5 Resort lending - - 15 - Home equity - 1st lien - - - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - 4 - 1 Home equity - 2nd lien 4 - - - Loans not secured by real estate - - - - Other - - - - 1,669 43 8,854 428 With an allowance recorded: Commercial Income producing - real estate 8,153 318 13,752 452 Land, land development & construction-real estate 1,352 29 2,351 35 Commercial and industrial 5,929 151 7,304 117 Mortgage 1-4 family 45,728 1,447 51,078 1,644 Resort lending 17,705 480 18,523 507 Home equity - 1st lien 223 6 159 6 Home equity - 2nd lien 231 11 154 6 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2,233 118 2,582 141 Home equity - 2nd lien 2,723 122 3,086 147 Loans not secured by real estate 557 28 669 29 Other 5 - 11 1 84,839 2,710 99,669 3,085 Total Commercial Income producing - real estate 8,785 320 19,242 622 Land, land development & construction-real estate 1,757 36 3,337 92 Commercial and industrial 6,545 172 9,649 312 Mortgage 1-4 family 45,740 1,456 51,096 1,649 Resort lending 17,705 480 18,538 507 Home equity - 1st lien 223 6 159 6 Home equity - 2nd lien 231 11 154 6 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2,233 122 2,582 142 Home equity - 2nd lien 2,727 122 3,086 147 Loans not secured by real estate 557 28 669 29 Other 5 - 11 1 Total $ 86,508 $ 2,753 $ 108,523 $ 3,513 (1) There were no impaired payment plan receivables or purchased mortgage loans during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Our average investment in impaired loans was approximately $84.4 million and $105.7 million for the three-month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively and $86.5 million and $108.5 million for the nine-month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Cash receipts on impaired loans on non-accrual status are generally applied to the principal balance. Interest income recognized on impaired loans during the three months ending September 30, 2016 and 2015, was approximately $0.9 million and $1.1 million, respectively and was approximately $2.8 million and $3.5 million during the nine months ending September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Troubled debt restructurings follow: September 30, 2016 Commercial Retail Total (In thousands) Performing TDRs $ 12,642 $ 62,299 $ 74,941 Non-performing TDRs(1) 2,352 3,421 (2) 5,773 Total $ 14,994 $ 65,720 $ 80,714 December 31, 2015 Commercial Retail Total (In thousands) Performing TDRs $ 13,318 $ 68,194 $ 81,512 Non-performing TDRs(1) 3,041 3,777 (2) 6,818 Total $ 16,359 $ 71,971 $ 88,330 (1) Included in non-performing loans table above. (2) Also includes loans on non-accrual at the time of modification until six payments are received on a timely basis. We allocated $10.1 million and $10.9 million of specific reserves to customers whose loan terms have been modified in troubled debt restructurings as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, respectively. During the nine months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, the terms of certain loans were modified as troubled debt restructurings. The modification of the terms of such loans generally included one or a combination of the following: a reduction of the stated interest rate of the loan; an extension of the maturity date at a stated rate of interest lower than the current market rate for new debt with similar risk; or a permanent reduction of the recorded investment in the loan. Modifications involving a reduction of the stated interest rate of the loan have generally been for periods ranging from 9 months to 36 months but have extended to as much as 480 months in certain circumstances. Modifications involving an extension of the maturity date have generally been for periods ranging from 1 month to 60 months but have extended to as much as 230 months in certain circumstances. Loans that have been classified as troubled debt restructurings during the three-month periods ended Number of Contracts Pre-modification Recorded Balance Post-modification Recorded Balance (Dollars in thousands) 2016 Commercial Income producing - real estate 2 $ 180 $ 180 Land, land development & construction-real estate - - - Commercial and industrial 2 175 158 Mortgage 1-4 family 2 204 207 Resort lending - - - Home equity - 1st lien - - - Home equity - 2nd lien 2 77 78 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 2 82 85 Home equity - 2nd lien 1 7 7 Loans not secured by real estate 1 34 34 Other - - - Total 12 $ 759 $ 749 2015 Commercial Income producing - real estate - $ - $ - Land, land development & construction-real estate - - - Commercial and industrial 1 48 26 Mortgage 1-4 family 3 343 344 Resort lending - - - Home equity - 1st lien - - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - Loans not secured by real estate 1 19 19 Other - - - Total 5 $ 410 $ 389 (1) There were no payment plan receivables or purchased mortgage loans classified as troubled debt restructurings during the three month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. Loans that have been classified as troubled debt restructurings during the nine-month periods ended Number of Contracts Pre-modification Recorded Balance Post-modification Recorded Balance (Dollars in thousands) 2016 Commercial Income producing - real estate 4 $ 290 $ 290 Land, land development & construction-real estate - - - Commercial and industrial 6 1,933 1,916 Mortgage 1-4 family 5 396 470 Resort lending 1 116 117 Home equity - 1st lien 1 107 78 Home equity - 2nd lien 2 77 78 Installment Home equity - 1st lien 6 141 145 Home equity - 2nd lien 5 133 136 Loans not secured by real estate 2 46 46 Other - - - Total 32 $ 3,239 $ 3,276 2015 Commercial Income producing - real estate 2 $ 229 $ 234 Land, land development & construction-real estate - - - Commercial and industrial 4 301 273 Mortgage 1-4 family 9 1,373 1,189 Resort lending 1 313 309 Home equity - 1st lien - - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien 5 190 164 Home equity - 2nd lien 3 58 58 Loans not secured by real estate 2 19 25 Other - - - Total 26 $ 2,483 $ 2,252 (1) There were no payment plan receivables or purchased mortgage loans classified as troubled debt restructurings during the nine month periods ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively. The troubled debt restructurings described above for 2016 increased the allowance for loan losses by $0.34 million and resulted in charge offs of $0.02 million during the three months ended September 30, 2016, and increased the allowance by $0.69 million and resulted in charge offs of $0.02 million during the nine months ended September 30, 2016. The troubled debt restructurings described above for 2015 decreased the allowance for loan losses by $0.05 million and resulted in zero charge offs during the three months ended September 30, 2015, and increased the allowance by $0.05 million and resulted in zero charge offs during the nine months ended September 30, 2015. Loans that have been classified as troubled debt restructurings during the past twelve months and that Number of Contracts Recorded Balance (Dollars in thousands) 2016 Commercial Income producing - real estate - $ - Land, land development & construction-real estate - - Commercial and industrial - - Mortgage 1-4 family - - Resort lending - - Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Loans not secured by real estate - - Other - - - $ - 2015 Commercial Income producing - real estate - $ - Land, land development & construction-real estate - - Commercial and industrial - - Mortgage 1-4 family 1 54 Resort lending - - Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Loans not secured by real estate - - Other - - 1 $ 54 Loans that have been classified as troubled debt restructurings during the past twelve months and that Number of Contracts Recorded Balance (Dollars in thousands) 2016 Commercial Income producing - real estate - $ - Land, land development & construction-real estate - - Commercial and industrial - - Mortgage 1-4 family - - Resort lending - - Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Loans not secured by real estate - - Other - - - $ - 2015 Commercial Income producing - real estate - $ - Land, land development & construction-real estate - - Commercial and industrial 2 157 Mortgage 1-4 family 1 54 Resort lending - - Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Installment Home equity - 1st lien - - Home equity - 2nd lien - - Loans not secured by real estate 1 4 Other - - 4 $ 215 A loan is considered to be in payment default generally once it is 90 days contractually past due under the modified terms. There were no troubled debt restructurings that subsequently defaulted during the three and nine months ended September 30, 2016. The troubled debt restructurings that subsequently defaulted described above for 2015 decreased the allowance for loan losses by $0.01 million and resulted in zero charge offs during the three months ended September 30, 2015 and had no impact on the allowance for loan losses and resulted in zero charge offs during the nine months ended September 30, 2015. In order to determine whether a borrower is experiencing financial difficulty, we perform an evaluation of the probability that the borrower will be in payment default on any of its debt in the foreseeable future without the modification. This evaluation is performed under our internal underwriting policy. Credit Quality Indicators For commercial loans, we use a loan rating system that is similar to those employed by state and federal banking regulators. Loans are graded on a scale of 1 to 12. A description of the general characteristics of the ratings follows: Rating 1 through 6 Rating 7 and 8 Rating 9 Rating 10 and 11 Rating 12 The following table summarizes loan ratings by loan class for our commercial loan segment: Commercial Non-watch Watch Substandard Non- Total (In thousands) September 30, 2016 Income producing - real estate $ 268,940 $ 4,000 $ 404 $ 658 $ 274,002 Land, land development and construction - real estate 53,559 199 - 211 53,969 Commercial and industrial 439,036 10,727 6,478 2,517 458,758 Total $ 761,535 $ 14,926 $ 6,882 $ 3,386 $ 786,729 Accrued interest included in total $ 1,676 $ 56 $ 21 $ - $ 1,753 December 31, 2015 Income producing - real estate $ 296,898 $ 6,866 $ 1,423 $ 1,027 $ 306,214 Land, land development and construction - real estate 40,844 2,995 243 401 44,483 Commercial and industrial 371,357 19,502 6,683 2,028 399,570 Total $ 709,099 $ 29,363 $ 8,349 $ 3,456 $ 750,267 Accrued interest included in total $ 1,729 $ 108 $ 32 $ - $ 1,869 For each of our mortgage and installment segment classes, we generally monitor credit quality based on the credit scores of the borrowers. These credit scores are generally updated semi-annually. The following tables summarize credit scores by loan class for our mortgage and installment loan segments: Mortgage (1) 1-4 Family Resort Lending Home Equity 1st Lien Home Equity 2nd Lien Purchased Loans Total (In thousands) September 30, 2016 800 and above $ 32,310 $ 12,054 $ 5,590 $ 8,288 $ 4,816 $ 63,058 750-799 88,959 38,472 9,551 19,103 26,721 182,806 700-749 60,455 30,934 5,052 11,278 10,831 118,550 650-699 53,748 13,530 3,690 8,259 - 79,227 600-649 27,848 6,218 1,365 3,342 - 38,773 550-599 15,413 2,467 738 1,542 - 20,160 500-549 7,955 871 484 1,246 - 10,556 Under 500 5,097 596 172 244 - 6,109 Unknown 2,177 2,054 1,280 232 143 5,886 Total $ 293,962 $ 107,196 $ 27,922 $ 53,534 $ 42,511 $ 525,125 Accrued interest included in total $ 1,386 $ 473 $ 104 $ 210 $ 119 $ 2,292 December 31, 2015 800 and above $ 28,760 $ 13,943 $ 4,374 $ 7,696 $ 2,310 $ 57,083 750-799 78,802 40,888 7,137 17,405 23,283 167,515 700-749 56,519 31,980 4,341 11,022 6,940 110,802 650-699 51,813 17,433 3,203 7,691 - 80,140 600-649 27,966 4,991 1,467 3,684 - 38,108 550-599 16,714 3,070 1,027 1,918 - 22,729 500-549 10,610 1,051 572 1,295 - 13,528 Under 500 4,708 554 244 265 - 5,771 Unknown 1,315 2,110 199 282 724 4,630 Total $ 277,207 $ 116,020 $ 22,564 $ 51,258 $ 33,257 $ 500,306 Accrued interest included in total $ 1,396 $ 477 $ 87 $ 196 $ 114 $ 2,270 (1) Credit scores have been updated within the last twelve months. Installment(1) Home Equity 1st Lien Home Equity 2nd Lien Loans not Secured by Real Estate Other Total (In thousands) September 30, 2016 800 and above $ 1,373 $ 1,953 $ 51,471 $ 108 $ 54,905 750-799 3,031 3,558 110,667 680 117,936 700-749 2,170 2,872 43,616 812 49,470 650-699 2,690 3,244 18,322 522 24,778 600-649 2,193 1,668 4,080 281 8,222 550-599 1,310 1,348 1,690 52 4,400 500-549 895 631 1,126 48 2,700 Under 500 134 233 309 25 701 Unknown 32 11 5,884 35 5,962 Total $ 13,828 $ 15,518 $ 237,165 $ 2,563 $ 269,074 Accrued interest included in total $ 58 $ 57 $ 582 $ 20 $ 717 December 31, 2015 800 and above $ 1,792 $ 1,782 $ 44,254 $ 58 $ 47,886 750-799 4,117 5,931 86,800 531 97,379 700-749 2,507 3,899 34,789 694 41,889 650-699 3,508 4,182 16,456 499 24,645 600-649 2,173 2,153 4,979 200 9,505 550-599 1,800 1,346 1,997 109 5,252 500-549 1,056 855 1,170 61 3,142 Under 500 223 370 385 23 1,001 Unknown 59 32 3,921 4 4,016 Total $ 17,235 $ 20,550 $ 194,751 $ 2,179 $ 234,715 Accrued interest included in total $ 78 $ 83 $ 520 $ 17 $ 698 (1) Credit scores have been updated within the last twelve months. Mepco Finance Corporation (“Mepco”) is a wholly-owned subsidiary of our Bank that operates a vehicle service contract payment plan business throughout the United States. See Note #14 for more information about Mepco’s business. As of September 30, 2016, approximately 33.2% of Mepco’s outstanding payment plan receivables relate to programs in which a third party insurer or risk retention group is obligated to pay Mepco the full refund owing upon cancellation of the related service contract (including with respect to both the portion funded to the service contract seller and the portion funded to the administrator). These receivables are shown as “Full Refund” in the table below. Another approximately 47.7% of Mepco’s outstanding payment plan receivables as of September 30, 2016, relate to programs in which a third party insurer or risk retention group is obligated to pay Mepco the refund owing upon cancellation only with respect to the unearned portion previously funded by Mepco to the administrator (but not to the service contract seller). These receivables are shown as “Partial Refund” in the table below. The balance of Mepco’s outstanding payment plan receivables relate to programs in which there is no insurer or risk retention group that has any contractual liability to Mepco for any portion of the refund amount. These receivables are shown as “Other” in the table below. For each class of our payment plan receivables we monitor financial information on the counterparties as we evaluate the credit quality of this portfolio. The following table summarizes credit ratings of insurer or risk retention group counterparties by class of payment plan receivable: Payment Plan Receivables Full Refund Partial Refund Other Total (In thousands) September 30, 2016 AM Best rating A+ $ - $ 8 $ - $ 8 A 1,094 13,696 - 14,790 A- 977 1,110 3,458 5,545 B+ - - 2,502 2,502 Not rated 8,292 50 1 8,343 Total $ 10,363 $ 14,864 $ 5,961 $ 31,188 December 31, 2015 AM Best rating A+ $ - $ 6 $ - $ 6 A 2,712 5,203 - 7,915 A- 3,418 1,177 6,265 10,860 Not rated 15,720 93 5 15,818 Total $ 21,850 $ 6,479 $ 6,270 $ 34,599 Although Mepco has contractual recourse against various counterparties for refunds owing upon cancellation of vehicle service contracts, see Note #14 below regarding certain risks and difficulties associated with collecting these refunds. Foreclosed residential real estate properties included in other real estate and repossessed assets on our Condensed Consolidated Statements of Financial Condition totaled $1.8 million and $2.8 million at September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, respectively. Retail mortgage loans secured by residential real estate properties for which formal foreclosure proceedings are in process according to local requirements totaled $0.4 million and $1.1 million at September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, respectively. |