Past Due Loans, Allowance For Credit Losses, Impaired Loans, and TDRS | PAST DUE LOANS, ALLOWANCE FOR CREDIT LOSSES, IMPAIRED LOANS, AND TDRS Past Due and Non-accrual Loans The following table presents an aging analysis of the Company 's past due loans as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015 . The aging is determined without regard to accrual status. The table also presents non-performing loans, consisting of non-accrual loans (the majority of which are past due) and loans 90 days or more past due and still accruing interest, as of each balance sheet date. Aging Analysis of Past Due Loans and Non-performing Loans by Class (Dollar amounts in thousands) Aging Analysis (Accruing and Non-accrual) Non-performing Loans Current 30-89 Days Past Due 90 Days or More Past Due Total Past Due Total Loans Non- accrual 90 Days or More Past Due, Still Accruing Interest As of September 30, 2016 Commercial and industrial $ 2,833,642 $ 9,099 $ 6,658 $ 15,757 $ 2,849,399 $ 13,823 $ 2,154 Agricultural 406,947 2,460 164 2,624 409,571 184 — Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 1,516,820 5,816 14,402 20,218 1,537,038 17,670 82 Multi-family 623,386 1,321 598 1,919 625,305 316 454 Construction 400,809 767 281 1,048 401,857 287 — Other commercial real estate 964,135 3,254 3,466 6,720 970,855 3,361 932 Total commercial real estate 3,505,150 11,158 18,747 29,905 3,535,055 21,634 1,468 Total corporate loans 6,745,739 22,717 25,569 48,286 6,794,025 35,641 3,622 Home equity 727,433 3,591 2,236 5,827 733,260 4,916 165 1-4 family mortgages 385,024 1,869 1,252 3,121 388,145 3,240 235 Installment 229,881 1,853 296 2,149 232,030 — 296 Total consumer loans 1,342,338 7,313 3,784 11,097 1,353,435 8,156 696 Covered loans 23,905 319 98 417 24,322 492 — Total loans $ 8,111,982 $ 30,349 $ 29,451 $ 59,800 $ 8,171,782 $ 44,289 $ 4,318 As of December 31, 2015 Commercial and industrial $ 2,516,197 $ 4,956 $ 3,573 $ 8,529 $ 2,524,726 $ 5,587 $ 857 Agricultural 387,109 245 86 331 387,440 355 — Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 1,386,383 2,647 6,424 9,071 1,395,454 6,875 4 Multi-family 526,625 541 1,158 1,699 528,324 796 548 Construction 216,377 — 505 505 216,882 905 — Other commercial real estate 922,531 3,575 5,084 8,659 931,190 5,611 661 Total commercial real estate 3,051,916 6,763 13,171 19,934 3,071,850 14,187 1,213 Total corporate loans 5,955,222 11,964 16,830 28,794 5,984,016 20,129 2,070 Home equity 647,175 3,247 3,046 6,293 653,468 5,310 216 1-4 family mortgages 350,980 2,680 2,194 4,874 355,854 3,416 528 Installment 136,780 753 69 822 137,602 20 69 Total consumer loans 1,134,935 6,680 5,309 11,989 1,146,924 8,746 813 Covered loans 29,808 405 562 967 30,775 555 174 Total loans $ 7,119,965 $ 19,049 $ 22,701 $ 41,750 $ 7,161,715 $ 29,430 $ 3,057 Allowance for Credit Losses The Company maintains an allowance for credit losses at a level deemed adequate by management to absorb estimated losses inherent in the existing loan portfolio. See Note 1 , " Summary of Significant Accounting Policies ," for the accounting policy for the allowance for credit losses. A rollforward of the allowance for credit losses by portfolio segment for the quarters and nine months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015 is presented in the table below. Allowance for Credit Losses by Portfolio Segment (Dollar amounts in thousands) Commercial, Industrial, and Agricultural Office, Retail, and Industrial Multi- family Construction Other Commercial Real Estate Consumer Covered Loans Reserve for Unfunded Commitments Total Allowance for Credit Losses Quarter ended September 30, 2016 Beginning balance $ 40,084 $ 12,985 $ 2,926 $ 2,239 $ 7,474 $ 13,003 $ 1,394 $ 1,400 $ 81,505 Charge-offs (1,760 ) (2,193 ) — — (509 ) (1,488 ) — — (5,950 ) Recoveries 615 42 69 9 94 326 — — 1,155 Net charge-offs (1,145 ) (2,151 ) 69 9 (415 ) (1,162 ) — — (4,795 ) Provision for loan losses and other 3,579 3,019 1,048 916 1,488 50 (102 ) (400 ) 9,598 Ending balance $ 42,518 $ 13,853 $ 4,043 $ 3,164 $ 8,547 $ 11,891 $ 1,292 $ 1,000 $ 86,308 Quarter ended September 30, 2015 Beginning balance $ 33,729 $ 11,345 $ 2,451 $ 1,890 $ 6,367 $ 10,820 $ 4,861 $ 1,816 $ 73,279 Charge-offs (1,948 ) (563 ) (68 ) — (598 ) (1,172 ) (8 ) — (4,357 ) Recoveries 347 106 1 114 506 213 7 — 1,294 Net charge-offs (1,601 ) (457 ) (67 ) 114 (92 ) (959 ) (1 ) — (3,063 ) Provision for loan losses and other 3,247 967 226 (559 ) (181 ) 1,144 (744 ) (591 ) 3,509 Ending balance $ 35,375 $ 11,855 $ 2,610 $ 1,445 $ 6,094 $ 11,005 $ 4,116 $ 1,225 $ 73,725 Nine months ended September 30, 2016 Beginning balance $ 37,074 $ 13,116 $ 2,462 $ 1,440 $ 6,088 $ 11,812 $ 1,638 $ 1,225 $ 74,855 Charge-offs (5,684 ) (4,358 ) (288 ) (134 ) (2,833 ) (3,973 ) (2 ) — (17,272 ) Recoveries 1,693 153 95 44 314 975 — — 3,274 Net charge-offs (3,991 ) (4,205 ) (193 ) (90 ) (2,519 ) (2,998 ) (2 ) — (13,998 ) Provision for loan losses and other 9,435 4,942 1,774 1,814 4,978 3,077 (344 ) (225 ) 25,451 Ending balance $ 42,518 $ 13,853 $ 4,043 $ 3,164 $ 8,547 $ 11,891 $ 1,292 $ 1,000 $ 86,308 Nine months ended September 30, 2015 Beginning balance $ 29,458 $ 10,992 $ 2,249 $ 2,297 $ 8,327 $ 12,145 $ 7,226 $ 1,816 $ 74,510 Charge-offs (13,524 ) (2,613 ) (565 ) (15 ) (2,442 ) (2,723 ) (634 ) — (22,516 ) Recoveries 1,993 460 8 334 1,902 853 120 — 5,670 Net charge-offs (11,531 ) (2,153 ) (557 ) 319 (540 ) (1,870 ) (514 ) — (16,846 ) Provision for loan losses and other 17,448 3,016 918 (1,171 ) (1,693 ) 730 (2,596 ) (591 ) 16,061 Ending balance $ 35,375 $ 11,855 $ 2,610 $ 1,445 $ 6,094 $ 11,005 $ 4,116 $ 1,225 $ 73,725 The table below provides a breakdown of loans and the related allowance for credit losses by portfolio segment as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015 . Loans and Related Allowance for Credit Losses by Portfolio Segment (Dollar amounts in thousands) Loans Allowance for Credit Losses Individually Evaluated for Impairment Collectively Evaluated for Impairment PCI Total Individually Evaluated for Impairment Collectively Evaluated for Impairment PCI Total As of September 30, 2016 Commercial, industrial, and agricultural $ 11,903 $ 3,242,734 $ 4,333 $ 3,258,970 $ — $ 41,880 $ 638 $ 42,518 Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 16,459 1,507,622 12,957 1,537,038 20 12,459 1,374 13,853 Multi-family 398 612,554 12,353 625,305 — 3,840 203 4,043 Construction 34 397,206 4,617 401,857 — 3,014 150 3,164 Other commercial real estate 1,813 955,735 13,307 970,855 17 7,442 1,088 8,547 Total commercial real estate 18,704 3,473,117 43,234 3,535,055 37 26,755 2,815 29,607 Total corporate loans 30,607 6,715,851 47,567 6,794,025 37 68,635 3,453 72,125 Consumer — 1,343,225 10,210 1,353,435 — 11,369 522 11,891 Covered loans — 16,094 8,228 24,322 — 119 1,173 1,292 Reserve for unfunded commitments — — — — — 1,000 — 1,000 Total loans $ 30,607 $ 8,075,170 $ 66,005 $ 8,171,782 $ 37 $ 81,123 $ 5,148 $ 86,308 As of December 31, 2015 Commercial, industrial, and agricultural $ 2,871 $ 2,902,361 $ 6,934 $ 2,912,166 $ 883 $ 35,378 $ 813 $ 37,074 Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 6,162 1,376,789 12,503 1,395,454 715 10,833 1,568 13,116 Multi-family 800 526,037 1,487 528,324 — 2,367 95 2,462 Construction 178 212,671 4,033 216,882 — 1,160 280 1,440 Other commercial real estate 3,665 913,161 14,364 931,190 — 5,367 721 6,088 Total commercial real estate 10,805 3,028,658 32,387 3,071,850 715 19,727 2,664 23,106 Total corporate loans 13,676 5,931,019 39,321 5,984,016 1,598 55,105 3,477 60,180 Consumer — 1,135,959 10,965 1,146,924 — 11,425 387 11,812 Covered loans — 20,856 9,919 30,775 — 248 1,390 1,638 Reserve for unfunded commitments — — — — — 1,225 — 1,225 Total loans $ 13,676 $ 7,087,834 $ 60,205 $ 7,161,715 $ 1,598 $ 68,003 $ 5,254 $ 74,855 Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment The following table presents loans individually evaluated for impairment by class of loan as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015 . PCI loans are excluded from this disclosure. Impaired Loans Individually Evaluated by Class (Dollar amounts in thousands) As of September 30, 2016 As of December 31, 2015 Recorded Investment In Recorded Investment In Loans with No Specific Reserve Loans with a Specific Reserve Unpaid Principal Balance Specific Reserve Loans with No Specific Reserve Loans with a Specific Reserve Unpaid Principal Balance Specific Reserve Commercial and industrial $ 11,903 $ — $ 13,984 $ — $ 1,673 $ 1,198 $ 4,592 $ 883 Agricultural — — — — — — — — Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 15,784 675 21,072 20 4,654 1,508 12,083 715 Multi-family 398 — 398 — 800 — 941 — Construction 34 — 34 — 178 — 299 — Other commercial real estate 1,543 270 2,599 17 3,665 — 4,403 — Total commercial real estate 17,759 945 24,103 37 9,297 1,508 17,726 715 Total impaired loans individually evaluated for impairment $ 29,662 $ 945 $ 38,087 $ 37 $ 10,970 $ 2,706 $ 22,318 $ 1,598 The following table presents the average recorded investment and interest income recognized on impaired loans by class for the quarters and nine months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015 . PCI loans are excluded from this disclosure. Average Recorded Investment and Interest Income Recognized on Impaired Loans by Class (Dollar amounts in thousands) Quarters Ended September 30, 2016 2015 Average Interest Income Recognized (1) Average Interest Income Recognized (1) Commercial and industrial $ 7,829 $ 57 $ 5,968 $ 37 Agricultural — — — — Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 16,101 3 8,814 4 Multi-family 399 11 925 12 Construction 34 — 2,995 118 Other commercial real estate 2,561 — 3,442 15 Total commercial real estate 19,095 14 16,176 149 Total impaired loans $ 26,924 $ 71 $ 22,144 $ 186 Nine Months Ended September 30, 2016 2015 Average Interest (1) Average Interest (1) Commercial and industrial $ 5,312 $ 107 $ 10,457 $ 113 Agricultural — — — — Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 12,012 80 10,158 37 Multi-family 500 12 868 13 Construction 70 — 4,833 118 Other commercial real estate 3,190 72 3,222 34 Total commercial real estate 15,772 164 19,081 202 Total impaired loans $ 21,084 $ 271 $ 29,538 $ 315 (1) Recorded using the cash basis of accounting. Credit Quality Indicators Corporate loans and commitments are assessed for credit risk and assigned ratings based on various characteristics, such as the borrower's cash flow, leverage, and collateral. Ratings for commercial credits are reviewed periodically. The following tables present credit quality indicators by class for corporate and consumer loans, excluding covered loans, as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015 . Corporate Credit Quality Indicators by Class, Excluding Covered Loans (Dollar amounts in thousands) Pass Special Mention (1) (4) Substandard (2) (4) Non-accrual (3) Total As of September 30, 2016 Commercial and industrial $ 2,643,655 $ 110,716 $ 81,205 $ 13,823 $ 2,849,399 Agricultural 375,484 17,735 16,168 184 409,571 Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 1,444,815 38,672 35,881 17,670 1,537,038 Multi-family 616,820 4,399 3,770 316 625,305 Construction 389,174 69 12,327 287 401,857 Other commercial real estate 941,072 12,427 13,995 3,361 970,855 Total commercial real estate 3,391,881 55,567 65,973 21,634 3,535,055 Total corporate loans $ 6,411,020 $ 184,018 $ 163,346 $ 35,641 $ 6,794,025 As of December 31, 2015 Commercial and industrial $ 2,379,992 $ 86,263 $ 52,884 $ 5,587 $ 2,524,726 Agricultural 381,523 — 5,562 355 387,440 Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 1,320,164 32,627 35,788 6,875 1,395,454 Multi-family 517,412 6,146 3,970 796 528,324 Construction 201,496 4,678 9,803 905 216,882 Other commercial real estate 898,746 13,179 13,654 5,611 931,190 Total commercial real estate 2,937,818 56,630 63,215 14,187 3,071,850 Total corporate loans $ 5,699,333 $ 142,893 $ 121,661 $ 20,129 $ 5,984,016 (1) Loans categorized as special mention exhibit potential weaknesses that require the close attention of management since these potential weaknesses may result in the deterioration of repayment prospects in the future. (2) Loans categorized as substandard exhibit well-defined weaknesses that may jeopardize the liquidation of the debt. These loans continue to accrue interest because they are well secured and collection of principal and interest is expected within a reasonable time. (3) Loans categorized as non-accrual exhibit well-defined weaknesses that may jeopardize the liquidation of the debt or result in a loss if the deficiencies are not corrected. (4) Total special mention and substandard loans includes accruing TDR s of $841,000 as of September 30, 2016 and $862,000 as of December 31, 2015 . Consumer Credit Quality Indicators by Class, Excluding Covered Loans (Dollar amounts in thousands) Performing Non-accrual Total As of September 30, 2016 Home equity $ 728,344 $ 4,916 $ 733,260 1-4 family mortgages 384,905 3,240 388,145 Installment 232,030 — 232,030 Total consumer loans $ 1,345,279 $ 8,156 $ 1,353,435 As of December 31, 2015 Home equity $ 648,158 $ 5,310 $ 653,468 1-4 family mortgages 352,438 3,416 355,854 Installment 137,582 20 137,602 Total consumer loans $ 1,138,178 $ 8,746 $ 1,146,924 TDR s TDR s are generally performed at the request of the individual borrower and may include forgiveness of principal, reduction in interest rates, changes in payments, and maturity date extensions. The table below presents TDR s by class as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015 . See Note 1, "Summary of Significant Accounting Policies," for the accounting policy for TDR s. TDR s by Class (Dollar amounts in thousands) As of September 30, 2016 As of December 31, 2015 Accruing Non-accrual (1) Total Accruing Non-accrual (1) Total Commercial and industrial $ 286 $ 150 $ 436 $ 294 $ 1,050 $ 1,344 Commercial real estate: Office, retail, and industrial 157 — 157 164 — 164 Multi-family 588 172 760 598 186 784 Other commercial real estate 324 — 324 340 — 340 Total commercial real estate 1,069 172 1,241 1,102 186 1,288 Total corporate loans 1,355 322 1,677 1,396 1,236 2,632 Home equity 181 879 1,060 494 667 1,161 1-4 family mortgages 832 389 1,221 853 421 1,274 Total consumer loans 1,013 1,268 2,281 1,347 1,088 2,435 Total loans $ 2,368 $ 1,590 $ 3,958 $ 2,743 $ 2,324 $ 5,067 (1) These TDR s are included in non-accrual loans in the preceding tables. TDR s are included in the calculation of the allowance for credit losses in the same manner as impaired loans. There were no specific reserves related to TDR s as of September 30, 2016 and there were $758,000 in specific reserves related to TDR s as of December 31, 2015 . No TDR s were restructured during the quarters and nine months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015. Accruing TDR s that do not perform in accordance with their modified terms are transferred to non-accrual. There were no material TDR s that defaulted within twelve months of the restructure date during the quarters and nine months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015 . A rollforward of the carrying value of TDR s for the quarters and nine months ended September 30, 2016 and 2015 is presented in the following table. TDR Rollforward (Dollar amounts in thousands) Quarters Ended Nine Months Ended 2016 2015 2016 2015 Accruing Beginning balance $ 2,491 $ 3,067 $ 2,743 $ 3,704 Additions — 120 — 120 Net payments received (22 ) (355 ) (91 ) (746 ) Returned to performing status — — — — Net transfers to non-accrual (101 ) (61 ) (284 ) (307 ) Ending balance 2,368 2,771 2,368 2,771 Non-accrual Beginning balance 1,690 2,070 2,324 19,904 Additions — 325 — 325 Net payments received (31 ) (29 ) (609 ) (15,483 ) Charge-offs (170 ) (61 ) (409 ) (2,687 ) Net transfers from accruing 101 61 284 307 Ending balance 1,590 2,366 1,590 2,366 Total TDRs $ 3,958 $ 5,137 $ 3,958 $ 5,137 For TDR s to be removed from TDR status in the calendar year after the restructuring, the loans must (i) have an interest rate and terms that reflect market conditions at the time of restructuring, and (ii) be in compliance with the modified terms. Loans that were not restructured at market rates and terms, that are not in compliance with the modified terms, or for which there is a concern about the future ability of the borrower to meet its obligations under the modified terms, continue to be separately reported as restructured until paid in full or charged-off. There were no material commitments to lend additional funds to borrowers with TDR s as of September 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015 . |