Mr. George Ohsiek, Jr., Branch Chief April 15, 2005
Division of Corporation Finance
Securities Exchange Commission
Washington, D.C. 20549
Re: Bernard Chaus, Inc. (the "Company")
Form 10-K for the year ended June 30, 2004
Filed September 28, 2004
Dear Mr. Ohsiek:
We are in receipt of your letter dated March 22, 2005 with regard to the
Company's Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2004. The following are
our responses to the comments:
Notes To Consolidated Financial Statements
Note 2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
Credit Terms, page F-7
1. We read your response to comment 5. Please tell us how the transferee
has assumed the full risk of collection, since you do not receive
payments from the transferee until they receive payments from your
customers. It appears that you have received a beneficial interest in
the factored receivables. Also, tell us the timing of when you record
the sale of the receivables and when you consider the transaction for
the transfer of the receivables to be complete. See paragraphs 9-12 of
SFAS 140.
We believe that the transferee (CIT) has assumed the full risk of
collection. The factoring agreement with CIT specifically states, "You
sell and assign to us, and we purchase as absolute owner, all accounts
arising from your sales of inventory or rendition of services,
including those under any trade names, through any divisions and
through any selling agent." The terms of the factoring agreement
specify payment terms from CIT and we do receive payment from CIT if
our customers do not pay timely. As defined in the factoring agreement,
we receive payment from the factor as of the earlier of: a) the date
that CIT has been paid by the Company's customers; b) the date of the
customer's longest maturity of the customer's invoices then outstanding
if the customer is in a bankruptcy or insolvency proceeding; or c) the
last day of the third month following the customer's longest maturity
date of the customer's invoices then outstanding if the receivable
remains unpaid. Therefore, the transferee has assumed the full risk of
collection and we have not received a beneficial interest in the
factored receivables.
- - 2 -
We believe that we meet the criteria in paragraph 9 of SFAS 140 to
treat the factoring arrangement as a sale of receivables: 9a) The
factored receivables are isolated from the Company. Customers make
payments on the receivables directly to CIT; 9b) CIT, as transferee,
has the right to pledge or exchange the assets it received, and no
condition both constrains the transferee from taking advantage of its
right to pledge or exchange and provides more than a trivial benefit to
the Company; and 9c) The Company does not maintain effective control
over the transferred assets. CIT assumes the credit risk on the
receivables and CIT is not able to return the receivables to the
Company.
In accordance with SFAS 140 paragraphs 9-11, we record the sale of
receivables upon completion of the transfer of the financial assets
(receivables), which is subsequent to recording revenue on the sale of
inventory to customers. At that time, we derecognize the receivables
sold, recognize all assets obtained and liabilities incurred (if any)
in consideration as proceeds of the sale, measure at fair value assets
obtained and liabilities incurred in the sale, and recognize in
earnings any gain or loss on the sale, including factoring fees or
charges.
On a prospective basis, in future periodic filings, we will expand our
existing disclosures in Note 2 as drafted below.
Draft Note 2. - Credit Terms:
Through March 31, 2004, the Company extended credit to the majority of
its customers through a factoring agreement with The CIT
Group/Commercial Services, Inc. ("CIT"). Under the factoring
arrangement, the Company receives payment from CIT as of the earlier
of: a) the date that CIT has been paid by the Company's customers; b)
the date of the customer's longest maturity of the customer's invoices
then outstanding if the customer is in a bankruptcy or insolvency
proceeding; or c) the last day of the third month following the
customer's longest maturity date of the customer's invoices then
outstanding if the receivable remains unpaid. CIT assumes only the risk
of the Company's customers' insolvency or non-payment. All other
receivable risks for customer deductions that reduce the customer
receivable balances are retained by the Company, including, but not
limited to, allowable customer markdowns, operational chargebacks,
disputes, discounts, and returns. Effective March 31, 2004, the
Company, the Company's SL Danielle subsidiary and CIT agreed to
terminate the Factoring Agreements between them. In connection with the
termination of those Factoring Agreements, the Company's Cynthia Steffe
Acquisition subsidiary and CIT entered into an amendment of their
Factoring Agreement revising only the factoring commission. Receivables
related to sales of Cynthia Steffe product lines continue to be
factored. At March 31, 2004, approximately 98% of the Company's
accounts receivable were being serviced by CIT under the factoring
arrangement. Effective April 1, 2004 the Company extends credit to its
customers, other than customers of CS Acquisition based upon an
evaluation of the customer's financial condition and credit history. At
June 30, 2004, approximately 95% of the Company's accounts receivable
was non factored.
* * * * *
Very truly yours,
/s/ Barton Heminover
Barton Heminover
Chief Financial Officer