Consolidation | Consolidation The condensed consolidated financial statements include the accounts of the Company, its subsidiaries as well as investment products that are consolidated. Voting interest entities ("VOEs") are consolidated when the Company is considered to have a controlling financial interest, which is typically present when the Company owns a majority of the voting interest in an entity or otherwise has the power to govern the financial and operating policies of the entity. The Company evaluates any variable interest entities ("VIEs") in which the Company has a variable interest for consolidation. A VIE is an entity in which either: (a) the equity investment at risk is not sufficient to permit the entity to finance its own activities without additional financial support; or (b) where as a group, the holders of the equity investment at risk do not possess: (i) the power through voting or similar rights to direct the activities that most significantly impact the entity’s economic performance, (ii) the obligation to absorb expected losses or the right to receive expected residual returns of the entity, or (iii) proportionate voting and economic interests and where substantially all of the entity’s activities either involve or are conducted on behalf of an investor with disproportionately fewer voting rights. If an entity has any of these characteristics, it is considered a VIE and is required to be consolidated by its primary beneficiary. The primary beneficiary is the entity that has both the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the VIE’s economic performance and has the obligation to absorb losses of, or the right to receive benefits from, the VIE that could potentially be significant to the VIE. In the normal course of its business, the Company sponsors various investment products, some of which are consolidated by the Company. CIP include both VOEs, made up primarily of open-end funds in which the Company holds a controlling financial interest, and VIEs, which primarily consist of CLOs of which the Company is considered the primary beneficiary. The consolidation and deconsolidation of these investment products have no impact on net income (loss) attributable to stockholders. The Company’s risk with respect to these investment products is limited to its beneficial interests in these products. The Company has no right to the benefits from, and does not bear the risks associated with, these investment products beyond the Company’s investments in, and fees generated from, these products. The following table presents the balances of the CIP that, after intercompany eliminations, are reflected in the condensed consolidated balance sheets as of September 30, 2019 and December 31, 2018 : As of September 30, 2019 December 31, 2018 VIEs VIEs VOEs CLOs Other VOEs CLOs Other ($ in thousands) Cash and cash equivalents $ 8,717 $ 74,032 $ 413 $ 1,029 $ 51,363 $ 559 Investments 79,434 1,908,324 31,165 12,923 1,709,266 27,379 Other assets 2,584 13,684 554 228 30,426 403 Notes payable — (1,821,243 ) — — (1,620,260 ) — Securities purchased payable and other liabilities (2,658 ) (81,018 ) (377 ) (823 ) (69,737 ) (146 ) Noncontrolling interests (37,307 ) (11,912 ) (1,167 ) (2,348 ) (13,958 ) (36 ) Net interests in CIP $ 50,770 $ 81,867 $ 30,588 $ 11,009 $ 87,100 $ 28,159 Consolidated CLOs The majority of the Company's CIP that are VIEs are CLOs. At September 30, 2019 , the Company consolidated five CLOs. The financial information for certain of these CLOs is included in the Company's condensed consolidated financial statements one-month in arrears based upon the availability of financial information. Majority-owned consolidated private funds, whose primary purpose is to invest in CLOs for which the Company serves as the collateral manager, are also included. Investments of CLOs The CLOs' investments of $1.9 billion at September 30, 2019 represented bank loan investments, which comprise the majority of the CLOs' portfolio asset collateral and are senior secured corporate loans across a variety of industries. These bank loan investments mature at various dates between 2020 and 2027 and pay interest at LIBOR plus a spread of up to 8.75% . The CLOs may elect to reinvest any prepayments received on bank loan investments between October 2019 and October 2021, depending on the CLO. Generally, subsequent prepayments received after the reinvestment period must be used to pay down the note obligations. At September 30, 2019 , the fair value of the senior bank loans exceeded the unpaid principal balance by $56.8 million . Notes Payable of CLOs The CLOs have issued notes payable with a total value, at par, of $2.0 billion , consisting of senior secured floating rate notes payable with a par value of $1.8 billion and subordinated notes with a par value of $173.0 million . These note obligations bear interest at variable rates based on LIBOR plus a pre-defined spread. The principal amounts outstanding of these note obligations mature on dates ranging from October 2027 to April 2029. The Company’s beneficial interests and maximum exposure to loss related to these consolidated CLOs is limited to: (a) ownership in the subordinated notes, and (b) accrued management fees. The secured notes of the consolidated CLOs have contractual recourse only to the related assets of the CLO and are classified as financial liabilities. Although these beneficial interests are eliminated upon consolidation, the application of the measurement alternative prescribed by ASU 2014-13 results in the net assets of the consolidated CLOs shown above to be equivalent to the beneficial interests retained by the Company at September 30, 2019 , as shown in the table below: As of September 30, 2019 ($ in thousands) Subordinated notes $ 80,315 Accrued investment management fees 1,552 Total Beneficial Interests $ 81,867 The following table represents income and expenses of the consolidated CLOs included in the Company’s Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations for the period indicated: Nine Months Ended September 30, ($ in thousands) 2019 Income: Realized and unrealized gain (loss), net $ (2,116 ) Interest income 85,346 Total Income 83,230 Expenses: Other operating expenses 2,960 Interest expense 72,030 Total Expense 74,990 Noncontrolling interests 297 Net Income (loss) attributable to CIP $ 8,537 As summarized in the table below, the application of the measurement alternative as prescribed by ASU 2014-13 results in the consolidated net income summarized above to be equivalent to the Company’s own economic interests in the consolidated CLOs, which are eliminated upon consolidation: Nine Months Ended September 30, ($ in thousands) 2019 Distributions received and unrealized gains (losses) on the subordinated notes held by the Company $ 3,345 Investment management fees 5,192 Total Economic Interests $ 8,537 Fair Value Measurements of CIP The assets and liabilities of CIP measured at fair value on a recurring basis as of September 30, 2019 and December 31, 2018 by fair value hierarchy level were as follows: As of September 30, 2019 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total ($ in thousands) Assets Cash equivalents $ 74,032 $ — $ — $ 74,032 Debt investments 21,686 1,934,395 12,610 1,968,691 Equity investments 49,701 39 492 50,232 Derivatives 105 884 — 989 Total Assets Measured at Fair Value $ 145,524 $ 1,935,318 $ 13,102 $ 2,093,944 Liabilities Notes payable $ — $ 1,821,243 $ — $ 1,821,243 Derivatives 133 1,071 — 1,204 Short sales 424 — — 424 Total Liabilities Measured at Fair Value $ 557 $ 1,822,314 $ — $ 1,822,871 As of December 31, 2018 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total ($ in thousands) Assets Cash equivalents $ 51,363 $ — $ — $ 51,363 Debt investments 5,306 1,724,714 6,848 1,736,868 Equity investments 12,700 — — 12,700 Total Assets Measured at Fair Value $ 69,369 $ 1,724,714 $ 6,848 $ 1,800,931 Liabilities Notes payable $ — $ 1,620,260 $ — $ 1,620,260 Short sales 707 — — 707 Total Liabilities Measured at Fair Value $ 707 $ 1,620,260 $ — $ 1,620,967 The following is a discussion of the valuation methodologies used for the assets and liabilities of the Company’s CIP measured at fair value: Cash equivalents represent investments in money ma rket funds. Cash investments in actively traded money market funds are valued using published net asset values and are classified as Level 1. Debt and equity investments represent the underlying debt, equity and other securities held in CIP. Equity investments are valued at the official closing price on the exchange on which the securities are traded and are generally categorized within Level 1. Level 2 investments represent most debt securities, including bank loans and certain equity securities (including non-U.S. securities), for which closing prices are not readily available or are deemed to not reflect readily available market prices, and are valued using an independent pricing service. Debt investments are valued based on quotations received from independent pricing services or from dealers who make markets in such securities. Bank loan investments, which are included as debt investments, are generally priced at the average mid-point of bid and ask quotations obtained from a third-party pricing service. Fair value may also be based upon valuations obtained from independent third-party brokers or dealers utilizing matrix pricing models that consider information regarding securities with similar characteristics. In certain instances, fair value has been determined utilizing discounted cash flow analyses or single broker non-binding quotes. Depending on the nature of the inputs, these assets are classified as Level 1, 2 or 3 within the fair value measurement hierarchy. Level 3 investments include debt and equity securities that are not widely traded, are illiquid or are priced by dealers based on pricing models used by market makers in the security. Derivative assets and liabilities represent futures contracts, swaps contracts, option contracts and forward contracts held in CIP. Derivative instruments in an asset position are classified as other assets of CIP in the Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets. Derivative instruments in a liability position are classified as liabilities of CIP within the Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets. The change in fair value of such derivatives is recorded in realized and unrealized gain (loss) on investments of CIP, net, in the Condensed Consolidated Statements of Operations. Depending on the nature of the inputs, these derivative assets and liabilities are classified as Level 1, 2 or 3 within the fair value measurement hierarchy. In connection with entering into these derivative contracts, these CIP may be required to pledge an amount of cash equal to the appropriate “initial margin” requirements. The cash pledged or on deposit is recorded in the Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets of the Company as Cash pledged or on deposit of CIP. The fair value of such derivatives at September 30, 2019 was immaterial. Notes payable represent notes issued by CLO CIP and are measured using the measurement alternative in ASU 2014-13. Accordingly, the fair value of CLO liabilities is measured as the fair value of CLO assets less the sum of: (a) the fair value of the beneficial interests held by the Company, and (b) the carrying value of any beneficial interests that represent compensation for services. Short sales are transactions in which a security is sold that is not owned or is owned but there is no intention to deliver, in anticipation that the price of the security will decline. Short sales are recorded in the condensed consolidated balance sheets within other liabilities of CIP and are classified as Level 1 based on the underlying equity security. The securities purchase payable at September 30, 2019 and December 31, 2018 approximated fair value due to the short-term nature of the instruments. The following table is a reconciliation of assets of CIP for Level 3 investments for which significant unobservable inputs were used to determine fair value: Nine Months Ended September 30, ($ in thousands) 2019 2018 Level 3 Investments of CIP (1) Balance at beginning of period $ 6,848 $ 34,781 Realized gains (losses), net (95 ) 1,993 Change in unrealized gains (losses), net 294 602 Purchases 2,157 7,122 Sales (5,414 ) (13,892 ) Transfers to Level 2 (42,232 ) (34,119 ) Transfers from Level 2 51,544 4,517 Balance at end of period $ 13,102 $ 1,004 (1) The investments that are categorized as Level 3 were valued utilizing third-party pricing information without adjustment. All transfers are deemed to occur at the end of period. Transfers between Level 2 and Level 3 were due to trading activities at period end. Nonconsolidated VIEs The Company serves as the collateral manager for other collateralized loan and collateralized bond obligations (collectively, "CDOs") that are not consolidated. The assets and liabilities of these CDOs reside in bankruptcy remote, special purpose entities in which the Company has no ownership of, nor holds any notes issued by, the CDOs, and provides neither recourse nor guarantees. The Company has determined that the investment management fees it receives for serving as collateral manager for these CDOs did not represent a variable interest since: (a) the fees the Company earns are compensation for services provided and are commensurate with the level of effort required to provide the investment management services; (b) the Company does not hold other interests in the CDOs that individually, or in the aggregate, would absorb more than an insignificant amount of the CDOs' expected losses or receive more than an insignificant amount of the CDOs' expected residual return; and (c) the investment management arrangement only includes terms, conditions and amounts that are customarily present in arrangements for similar services negotiated at arm's length. The Company has interests in certain other entities that are VIEs that the Company does not consolidate as it is not the primary beneficiary of those entities. The Company is not the primary beneficiary as its interest in these entities does not provide the Company with the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the entities' economic performance. At September 30, 2019 , the carrying value and maximum risk of loss related to the Company's interest in these VIEs was $13.8 million |