Allowance for Credit Losses | NOTE 4: Allowance for Credit Losses The Corporation conducts an analysis of the collectability of the loan portfolio on a regular basis and uses this analysis to assess the sufficiency of the allowance for credit losses on loans and to determine the necessary provision for credit losses. The Corporation segmented the loan portfolio into three loan portfolios based on common risk characteristics. The Commercial portfolio consists of commercial real estate loans, commercial business loans, commercial and consumer real estate construction loans, land acquisition and development loans, and builder lines. The Consumer portfolio consists of residential mortgage loans, equity lines, and other consumer loans. The Consumer Finance portfolio consists of automobile and marine and RV loans. The following table shows the allowance for credit losses activity by loan portfolio for the nine months ended September 30, 2024 and 2023: Consumer (Dollars in thousands) Commercial Consumer Finance Total Allowance for credit losses: Balance at December 31, 2023 $ 12,315 $ 3,758 $ 23,578 $ 39,651 Provision charged to operations 1,160 440 8,100 9,700 Loans charged off — (293) (11,707) (12,000) Recoveries of loans previously charged off 28 125 3,267 3,420 Balance at September 30, 2024 $ 13,503 $ 4,030 $ 23,238 $ 40,771 Consumer (Dollars in thousands) Commercial Consumer Finance Total Allowance for credit losses: Balance at December 31, 2022 $ 11,219 $ 3,330 $ 25,969 $ 40,518 Impact of ASC 326 adoption on non-PCD loans (617) 98 406 (113) Impact of ASC 326 adoption on PCD loans 595 9 — 604 Provision charged to operations 839 362 4,250 5,451 Loans charged off (16) (240) (9,306) (9,562) Recoveries of loans previously charged off 144 136 3,070 3,350 Balance at September 30, 2023 $ 12,164 $ 3,695 $ 24,389 $ 40,248 The following table presents a breakdown of the provision for credit losses for the periods indicated. Three Months Ended September 30, Nine Months Ended September 30, (Dollars in thousands) 2024 2023 2024 2023 Provision for credit losses: Provision for loans $ 3,700 $ 2,100 $ 9,700 $ 5,451 Provision for unfunded commitments — (50) 50 349 Total $ 3,700 $ 2,050 $ 9,750 $ 5,800 The table below details the recorded balance of the classes of loans within the commercial and consumer loan portfolios by loan rating, which is reviewed on a quarterly basis, and year of origination as of September 30, 2024: Revolving Revolving Term Loans Recorded Balance by Origination Year Loans Loans Recorded Converted (Dollars in thousands) 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 Prior Balance to Term 1 Total Commercial real estate: Loan Rating Pass $ 71,877 $ 80,522 $ 123,080 $ 143,969 $ 112,031 $ 163,489 $ — $ 112 $ 695,080 Special Mention — — — 5,624 — 943 — — 6,567 Total $ 71,877 $ 80,522 $ 123,080 $ 149,593 $ 112,031 $ 164,432 $ — $ 112 $ 701,647 Commercial business: Loan Rating Pass $ 6,189 $ 14,223 $ 19,158 $ 14,247 $ 10,710 $ 25,128 $ 25,587 $ — $ 115,242 Special Mention 24 52 — — — — — — 76 Substandard Nonaccrual — — — — — — — 92 92 Total $ 6,213 $ 14,275 $ 19,158 $ 14,247 $ 10,710 $ 25,128 $ 25,587 $ 92 $ 115,410 Construction - commercial real estate: Loan Rating Pass $ 38,479 $ 50,213 $ 61,410 $ — $ 4,970 $ — $ — $ — $ 155,072 Total $ 38,479 $ 50,213 $ 61,410 $ — $ 4,970 $ — $ — $ — $ 155,072 Land acquisition and development: Loan Rating Pass $ 19,073 $ 2,114 $ 2,662 $ 1,324 $ 8,601 $ — $ — $ — $ 33,774 Total $ 19,073 $ 2,114 $ 2,662 $ 1,324 $ 8,601 $ — $ — $ — $ 33,774 Builder lines: Loan Rating Pass $ 23,913 $ 3,436 $ 1,430 $ 481 $ — $ 404 $ — $ — $ 29,664 Total $ 23,913 $ 3,436 $ 1,430 $ 481 $ — $ 404 $ — $ — $ 29,664 Construction - consumer real estate: Loan Rating Pass $ 11,329 $ 5,099 $ 358 $ — $ — $ — $ 88 $ — $ 16,874 Total $ 11,329 $ 5,099 $ 358 $ — $ — $ — $ 88 $ — $ 16,874 Residential mortgage: Loan Rating Pass $ 39,210 $ 58,659 $ 84,733 $ 40,701 $ 36,323 $ 49,080 $ — $ — $ 308,706 Special Mention — 869 — — — 223 — — 1,092 Substandard — — — — 102 179 — — 281 Substandard Nonaccrual 128 — — — — 388 — — 516 Total $ 39,338 $ 59,528 $ 84,733 $ 40,701 $ 36,425 $ 49,870 $ — $ — $ 310,595 Equity lines: Loan Rating Pass $ 23 $ — $ — $ — $ 70 $ 839 $ 58,050 $ 239 $ 59,221 Special Mention — — — — — — — 76 76 Substandard — — — — — — — 89 89 Substandard Nonaccrual — — — — — — — 20 20 Total $ 23 $ — $ — $ — $ 70 $ 839 $ 58,050 $ 424 $ 59,406 Other consumer: Loan Rating Pass $ 3,842 $ 2,841 $ 1,828 $ 336 $ 163 $ 611 $ 46 $ — $ 9,667 Total $ 3,842 $ 2,841 $ 1,828 $ 336 $ 163 $ 611 $ 46 $ — $ 9,667 Total: Loan Rating Pass $ 213,935 $ 217,107 $ 294,659 $ 201,058 $ 172,868 $ 239,551 $ 83,771 $ 351 $ 1,423,300 Special Mention 24 921 — 5,624 — 1,166 — 76 7,811 Substandard — — — — 102 179 — 89 370 Substandard Nonaccrual 128 — — — — 388 — 112 628 Total $ 214,087 $ 218,028 $ 294,659 $ 206,682 $ 172,970 $ 241,284 $ 83,771 $ 628 $ 1,432,109 1 Equity lines include $154,000 of revolving loans converted to term during the nine months ended September 30, 2024. The table below details the recorded balance of the classes of loans within the commercial and consumer loan portfolios by loan rating, which is reviewed on a quarterly basis, and year of origination as of December 31, 2023: Revolving Revolving Term Loans Recorded Balance by Origination Year Loans Loans Recorded Converted (Dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 Prior Balance to Term 1 Total Commercial real estate: Loan Rating Pass $ 81,324 $ 125,278 $ 155,805 $ 121,365 $ 37,383 $ 140,158 $ — $ 119 $ 661,432 Special Mention — — 5,731 — — 959 — — 6,690 Total $ 81,324 $ 125,278 $ 161,536 $ 121,365 $ 37,383 $ 141,117 $ — $ 119 $ 668,122 Commercial business: Loan Rating Pass $ 18,682 $ 18,190 $ 17,219 $ 12,062 $ 14,847 $ 15,339 $ 18,686 $ 261 $ 115,286 Special Mention 62 — — — — — — — 62 Total $ 18,744 $ 18,190 $ 17,219 $ 12,062 $ 14,847 $ 15,339 $ 18,686 $ 261 $ 115,348 Construction - commercial real estate: Loan Rating Pass $ 29,346 $ 36,907 $ — $ 3,515 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 69,768 Total $ 29,346 $ 36,907 $ — $ 3,515 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 69,768 Land acquisition and development: Loan Rating Pass $ 4,562 $ 4,665 $ 9,844 $ 9,993 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 29,064 Total $ 4,562 $ 4,665 $ 9,844 $ 9,993 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 29,064 Builder lines: Loan Rating Pass $ 17,919 $ 5,124 $ 1,221 $ — $ 404 $ — $ — $ — $ 24,668 Total $ 17,919 $ 5,124 $ 1,221 $ — $ 404 $ — $ — $ — $ 24,668 Construction - consumer real estate: Loan Rating Pass $ 7,889 $ 3,240 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 94 $ — $ 11,223 Total $ 7,889 $ 3,240 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 94 $ — $ 11,223 Residential mortgage: Loan Rating Pass $ 59,441 $ 91,086 $ 44,292 $ 40,089 $ 11,524 $ 46,192 $ — $ — $ 292,624 Special Mention — — — — — 44 — — 44 Substandard — — — 103 — 165 — — 268 Substandard Nonaccrual — — — — 62 258 — — 320 Total $ 59,441 $ 91,086 $ 44,292 $ 40,192 $ 11,586 $ 46,659 $ — $ — $ 293,256 Equity lines: Loan Rating Pass $ — $ — $ 34 $ 70 $ — $ 857 $ 50,120 $ 344 $ 51,425 Special Mention — — — — — — — 85 85 Substandard — — — — 5 — — — 5 Substandard Nonaccrual — — — — — 9 — 68 77 Total $ — $ — $ 34 $ 70 $ 5 $ 866 $ 50,120 $ 497 $ 51,592 Other consumer: Loan Rating Pass $ 6,263 $ 2,762 $ 606 $ 282 $ 101 $ 519 $ 46 $ — $ 10,579 Substandard Nonaccrual — — — — 9 — — — 9 Total $ 6,263 $ 2,762 $ 606 $ 282 $ 110 $ 519 $ 46 $ — $ 10,588 Total: Loan Rating Pass $ 225,426 $ 287,252 $ 229,021 $ 187,376 $ 64,259 $ 203,065 $ 68,946 $ 724 $ 1,266,069 Special Mention 62 — 5,731 — — 1,003 — 85 6,881 Substandard — — — 103 5 165 — — 273 Substandard Nonaccrual — — — — 71 267 — 68 406 Total $ 225,488 $ 287,252 $ 234,752 $ 187,479 $ 64,335 $ 204,500 $ 68,946 $ 877 $ 1,273,629 1 All balances shown in this column were converted to term during the year ended December 31, 2023. The table below details the recorded balance of the classes of loans within the consumer finance loan portfolio by credit rating at the time of origination and year of origination as of September 30, 2024: Revolving Term Loans Recorded Balance by Origination Year Loans Revolving Converted (Dollars in thousands) 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 Prior Loans to Term Total Consumer finance - automobiles: Credit rating 1 Very good $ 19,654 $ 11,317 $ 8,863 $ 2,796 $ 550 $ 125 $ — $ — $ 43,305 Good 32,490 28,443 32,578 10,822 1,948 514 — — 106,795 Fairly good 34,183 36,945 41,542 19,129 3,878 2,274 — — 137,951 Fair 19,812 23,501 27,507 15,261 4,392 2,988 — — 93,461 Marginal 3,940 4,875 6,473 5,571 2,056 1,958 — — 24,873 Total $ 110,079 $ 105,081 $ 116,963 $ 53,579 $ 12,824 $ 7,859 $ — $ — $ 406,385 Consumer finance - marine and recreational vehicles: Credit rating 1 Very good $ 8,523 $ 6,487 $ 13,137 $ 8,397 $ 8,277 $ 4,003 $ — $ — $ 48,824 Good 4,589 6,593 7,135 1,395 1,208 684 — — 21,604 Fairly good — 203 186 35 28 35 — — 487 Total $ 13,112 $ 13,283 $ 20,458 $ 9,827 $ 9,513 $ 4,722 $ — $ — $ 70,915 Total: Credit rating 1 Very good $ 28,177 $ 17,804 $ 22,000 $ 11,193 $ 8,827 $ 4,128 $ — $ — $ 92,129 Good 37,079 35,036 39,713 12,217 3,156 1,198 — — 128,399 Fairly good 34,183 37,148 41,728 19,164 3,906 2,309 — — 138,438 Fair 19,812 23,501 27,507 15,261 4,392 2,988 — — 93,461 Marginal 3,940 4,875 6,473 5,571 2,056 1,958 — — 24,873 Total $ 123,191 $ 118,364 $ 137,421 $ 63,406 $ 22,337 $ 12,581 $ — $ — $ 477,300 1 Credit ratings with a FICO score greater than 739 are considered Very Good, FICO scores ranging from 670-739 are considered Good, FICO scores ranging from 625-669 are considered Fairly Good, FICO scores ranging from 580-624 are considered Fair and FICO scores less than 580 are considered Marginal. The table below details the recorded balance of the classes of loans within the consumer finance loan portfolio by credit rating at the time of origination and year of origination as of December 31, 2023: Revolving Term Loans Recorded Balance by Origination Year Loans Revolving Converted (Dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 Prior Loans to Term Total Consumer finance - automobiles: Credit rating 1 Very good $ 14,916 $ 12,395 $ 4,291 $ 1,012 $ 277 $ 22 $ — $ — $ 32,913 Good 35,203 42,800 15,530 3,338 1,090 325 — — 98,286 Fairly good 44,227 54,968 26,645 6,186 3,984 1,470 — — 137,480 Fair 28,779 36,794 22,266 7,014 4,808 1,908 — — 101,569 Marginal 6,359 8,956 7,715 3,322 2,832 1,844 — — 31,028 Total $ 129,484 $ 155,913 $ 76,447 $ 20,872 $ 12,991 $ 5,569 $ — $ — $ 401,276 Consumer finance - marine and recreational vehicles: Credit rating 1 Very good $ 7,481 $ 15,000 $ 9,857 $ 9,952 $ 2,518 $ 2,438 $ — $ — $ 47,246 Good 7,419 8,130 1,602 1,384 410 453 — — 19,398 Fairly good 265 221 37 30 — 37 — — 590 Total $ 15,165 $ 23,351 $ 11,496 $ 11,366 $ 2,928 $ 2,928 $ — $ — $ 67,234 Total: Credit rating 1 Very good $ 22,397 $ 27,395 $ 14,148 $ 10,964 $ 2,795 $ 2,460 $ — $ — $ 80,159 Good 42,622 50,930 17,132 4,722 1,500 778 — — 117,684 Fairly good 44,492 55,189 26,682 6,216 3,984 1,507 — — 138,070 Fair 28,779 36,794 22,266 7,014 4,808 1,908 — — 101,569 Marginal 6,359 8,956 7,715 3,322 2,832 1,844 — — 31,028 Total $ 144,649 $ 179,264 $ 87,943 $ 32,238 $ 15,919 $ 8,497 $ — $ — $ 468,510 1 Credit ratings with a FICO score greater than 739 are considered Very Good, FICO scores ranging from 670-739 are considered Good, FICO scores ranging from 625-669 are considered Fairly Good, FICO scores ranging from 580-624 are considered Fair and FICO scores less than 580 are considered Marginal. The following table details the current period gross charge-offs of loans by year of origination for the nine months ended September 30, 2024: Revolving Current Period Gross Charge-offs by Origination Year Loans Revolving Converted (Dollars in thousands) 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 Prior Loans to Term Total Residential mortgage $ 3 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 3 Other consumer 1 204 19 5 — — 62 — — 290 Consumer finance - automobiles 367 2,275 5,053 2,691 457 573 — — 11,416 Consumer finance - marine and recreational vehicles — 56 160 34 27 14 — — 291 Total $ 574 $ 2,350 $ 5,218 $ 2,725 $ 484 $ 649 $ — $ — $ 12,000 1 Gross charge-offs of other consumer loans for the nine months ended September 30, 2024 included $193,000 of demand deposit overdrafts that originated in 2024. The following table details the current period gross charge-offs of loans by year of origination for the nine months ended September 30, 2023: Revolving Current Period Gross Charge-offs by Origination Year Loans Revolving Converted (Dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 Prior Loans to Term Total Commercial business $ — $ 16 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 16 Equity lines — — — — — 8 — — 8 Other consumer 1 199 25 — 3 2 3 — — 232 Consumer finance - automobiles 490 4,396 2,628 583 477 567 — — 9,141 Consumer finance - marine and recreational vehicles — 82 — 40 6 37 — — 165 Total $ 689 $ 4,519 $ 2,628 $ 626 $ 485 $ 615 $ — $ — $ 9,562 1 Gross charge-offs of other consumer loans for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 included $199,000 of demand deposit overdrafts that originated in 2023. Gross charge-offs increased for the nine months ended September 30, 2024 compared to the same period in 2023 due primarily to higher charge-offs within the consumer finance-automobile portfolio segment as a result of an increase in the number of delinquent loans and repossessions and a higher average charge-off per unit as a result of larger loan amounts due to higher automobile values during 2020 and 2021 and a decline in wholesale values of used automobiles since then. As of September 30, 2024 and December 31, 2023, the Corporation had no collateral dependent loans for which repayment was expected to be derived substantially through the operation or sale of the collateral and where the borrower is experiencing financial difficulty. |