UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
SCHEDULE 14A
Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Filed by the Registrantx
Filed by a Party other than the Registrant¨
Check the appropriate box:
¨ | | Preliminary Proxy Statement |
¨ | | Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2)) |
¨ | | Definitive Proxy Statement |
x | | Definitive Additional Materials |
¨ | | Soliciting Material Pursuant to Rule 14a-12 |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd.
(Name of Registrant as Specified In Its Charter)
(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement, if other than the Registrant)
Payment of Filing Fee (Check the appropriate box):
¨ | | Fee computed on table below per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11. |
| 1) | | Title of each class of securities to which transaction applies: |
| 2) | | Aggregate number of securities to which transaction applies: |
| 3) | | Per unit price or other underlying value of transaction computed pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 0-11 (set forth the amount on which the filing fee is calculated and state how it was determined): |
| 4) | | Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction: |
¨ | | Fee paid previously with preliminary materials. |
¨ | | Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing. |
| 1) | | Amount Previously Paid: |
| 2) | | Form, Schedule or Registration Statement No.: |
Exhibit 99.1
[SALIX LETTERHEAD]
June 13, 2003
Dear Stockholder:
On June 4, 2003, Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. made a presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services or ISS, a company that advises institutional shareholders in connection with proxy solicitations. A copy of the presentation was filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on June 4, 2003. In the presentation, Salix made several references to the comments of independent research analysts. While for the reasons described below Salix believes that the term independent accurately describes those analysts, we are providing this supplemental disclosure to describe in detail the role of the various research analysts that cover Salix and the role of the investment banking division of Wachovia Securities that serves as Salix’s financial advisor. It is our understanding that in issuing its report recommending a vote in favor of Salix’s slate of directors, ISS was aware of the information set forth below.
As we have disclosed in previous SEC filings, specifically in our Schedule 14D-9 and in the third paragraph under the heading “Solicitation of Proxies” on page 26 of our definitive proxy statement filed with the SEC and mailed to you on May 27, 2003, Wachovia Securities is serving as Salix’s financial advisor in connection with Salix’s analysis and consideration of, and response to, the outstanding tender offer of Saule Holdings, Inc., a wholly-owned subsidiary of Axcan Pharma Inc. Salix has agreed to pay Wachovia an advisory fee and a transaction fee. The advisory fee consists of $250,000 per month for each of April, May and June 2003, and approximately $100,000 monthly thereafter, provided the engagement has not been terminated. The transaction fee, if any, would equal $1,000,000 plus a success fee to be determined on the basis of the enterprise value ascribed to the Salix transaction. The full amount of the advisory fee paid by Salix shall be credited against any transaction fee. Salix has also agreed to reimburse Wachovia for all reasonable and customary expenses, including reasonable attorneys’ fees and to indemnify Wachovia and its affiliates against liabilities relating to or arising out of this engagement. In addition, in 2002, Wachovia provided investment banking services to Salix in connection with Salix’s public offering of common stock, and in the ordinary course of business, Wachovia and its affiliates may actively trade or hold the common stock for their own accounts or for the accounts of customers, and accordingly, may at any time hold a long or short position in Salix common stock.
One of the analysts quoted in the ISS presentation, Michael Tong, is employed by Wachovia Securities. We do not believe, or have any reason to believe, that Mr. Tong has communicated with either Salix’s management or Salix’s financial advisors at Wachovia
concerning any aspect of Salix’s engagement of Wachovia in connection with the Tender Offer or the proxy solicitation. Nor do we believe that Salix’s engagement of Wachovia has in any way altered the independence of Mr. Tong’s analysis. In fact, Mr. Tong’s reports on Salix include a certification that the views expressed in those reports accurately reflect his personal views and that no part of his compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific recommendations or views expressed. In addition, Wachovia Securities includes in these reports a statement that it does not compensate its research personnel for specific investment banking services transactions, although report authors receive compensation that is based on (among other factors) Wachovia Securities’ overall investment banking revenues.
The analysts at Leerink Swann & Company and Thomas Weisel Partners LLC are also described as independent in the June 4, 2003 ISS presentation. As disclosed in Salix’s SEC filings, including, specifically, its registration statement on Form S-3 (File No. 333-82558) originally filed on February 12, 2002, Leerink Swann and Thomas Weisel Partners were each co-managers of Salix’s March 2002 public offering and respectively received approximately $460,000 and $650,000 from Salix for such services. Each of these companies has also disclosed in their analysts’ reports that it intends to seek investment banking compensation from Salix in the next three months, which Salix believes is standard disclosure for these and many other investment banks. Salix believes that these disclosures were included to enable these companies to solicit business from Salix in the future. To Salix’s knowledge, Salix does not owe any compensation to these companies, nor will any be owed in the future. The analyst for Thomas Weisel Partners includes certifications in his reports similar to those of Mr. Tong.
Finally, C.J. Sylvester, an analyst at UBS Warburg, was also described as independent in the ISS presentation. UBS Warburg has disclosed in its reports, and Salix disclosed in its Form S-3 referenced above, within the past year, UBS Warburg or an affiliate acted as co-manager in the placement of Salix securities and had received approximately $1,300,000 in compensation for investment banking services to Salix. To Salix’s knowledge, Salix does not owe any compensation to UBS Warburg, nor will any be owed in the future. Mr. Sylvester includes in his reports similar certifications to Mr. Tong’s.
We would like to note that on April 14, 2003, Mr. Sylvester stated that Salix stock was fully valued at $10.19. On April 23, 2003 and May 14, 2003, Salix publicly disclosed estimates of sales of its second drug candidate, Rifaximin, and on May 14, 2003 Salix also publicly disclosed first quarter results beating analysts’ estimates, as well as increased sales estimates for its existing product, Colazal®, for 2003 and 2004. On May 15, 2003, Mr. Sylvester raised his price estimate for Salix stock to $13 per share and made the comments included in the ISS presentation.
We believe that it is also important to note that analysts at Thomas Weisel Partners and UBS Warburg provide research coverage on Axcan Pharma. Furthermore, over the past 15 months the investment banking divisions of such firms have received compensation for investment banking services provided with respect to the issuance of securities by Axcan.
Enclosed is a copy of the ISS presentation, including supplemental disclosures on pages 29 to 30 about the relationships between Salix and the companies that employ these
2
analysts. The revised presentation also makes clear that the forward-looking numbers used in the “Peer Group Valuation” slide on page 29 of the updated presentation are taken from First Call, and that those consensus First Call numbers for Salix consist of estimates from Leerink Swann & Company, Thomas Weisel Partners LLC, UBS Warburg, and Wachovia the only companies that provided coverage for the stock at the time of the presentation. (On June 5, 2003, Roth Capital, with whom Salix has no relationship whatsoever, initiated coverage with a price target of $15.00 per share.)
Again, while for the reasons described above Salix believes that the term independent accurately describes these analysts, we are providing this supplemental disclosure to describe in detail the role of the various research analysts that cover Salix and the role of the investment banking division of Wachovia Securities that serves as Salix’s financial advisor.
Sincerely, | | |
| |
/s/ Carolyn J. Logan | | |
Carolyn J. Logan President and CEO | | |
3
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_01.jpg)
Exhibit 99.2
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd.
Presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services
June 4, 2003
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd.
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_02.jpg)
WHY SUPPORT THE INCUMBENT
BOARD OF DIRECTORS?
| l | | Strong business execution |
| — | | Salix’s Board has consistently made decisions that have enhanced stockholder value |
| — | | Salix is at the cusp of realizing the benefit of our efforts and success in executing our business plan |
| — | | Salix is poised for significant growth and profitability, and can better enhance stockholder value by continuing to execute its business plan |
| l | | Good Corporate Governance |
| — | | Independent, experienced Board |
| l | | Incumbent Board more aligned with stockholders |
| — | | Salix’s D&O own 15.5% of outstanding common stock |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 2
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_03.jpg)
CORPORATE PROFILE
| l | | Specialty pharmaceutical company |
| n | | Gastroenterology-focused |
| l | | Headquarters: Raleigh, NC |
| n | | 84-member sales and marketing team |
| l | | COLAZAL® product revenues |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 3
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_04.jpg)
MISSION STATEMENT
Salix Pharmaceuticals is dedicated
to being the leading specialty
pharmaceutical company providing
products to gastroenterologists
and their patients
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 4
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_05.jpg)
SALIX HAS A CLEAR, FOCUSED
STRATEGY
Enhance stockholder value:
| l | | In-license selective late-stage/marketed product candidates |
| — | | U.S. gastroenterology focus |
| — | | Reduce risk and capital commitment |
| l | | Complete any required development and secure FDA approval |
| l | | Sell products through specialty sales force |
| — | | Establish franchise with U.S. gastroenterologists |
| — | | Sell products that serve unmet needs |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 5
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_06.jpg)
SALIX HAS SUCCESSFULLY
EXECUTED ITS BUSINESS PLAN
| l | | Premier Specialty Sales Force |
| l | | COLAZAL®—approved and marketed |
| l | | Rifaximin—FDA approvable letter |
| l | | Granulated mesalamine—scheduled to enter Phase III |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 6
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_07.jpg)
PREMIER
GASTROENTEROLOGY
SALES FORCE
| l | | 84-member sales and marketing team |
| l | | Experienced, incentivized professionals |
| l | | Reputation for integrity and quality |
| l | | Established franchise with gastroenterologists |
| l | | Infrastructure in place to be leveraged with future products |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 7
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_08.jpg)
COLAZAL
| l | | Approved for first-line treatment of mildly to moderately active ulcerative colitis (UC) |
| l | | The fastest growing drug of its kind in the marketplace based upon 2002 prescriptions |
| l | | COLAZAL revenue alone is expected to provide profitability in the second half of 2004 |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 8
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_09.jpg)
COLAZAL
TOTAL PRESCRIPTIONS
[GRAPHICS APPEARS HERE]
Source: NDC
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 9
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_10.jpg)
5-ASA MARKET SHARE CHANGE SINCE
COLAZAL LAUNCH
[GRAPHICS APPEARS HERE]
Source: NDC Health Called-On Physicians
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 10
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_11.jpg)
RIFAXIMIN
| l | | A unique, broad-spectrum, gastrointestinal-specific, non-absorbed, oral antibiotic |
| l | | FDA approvable letter received October 2002 |
| l | | FDA approvable letter response—4Q/2003 |
| l | | Anticipated launch—mid-2004 |
| l | | Approval in 2004 provides profitability for 2004 |
| l | | Expected to be bigger than COLAZAL with a potential U.S. annual retail market in excess of 12 million patients and $2 billion |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 11
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_12.jpg)
RIFAXIMIN
(CONTINUED)
| l | | Travelers’ diarrhea—First indication |
| l | | Over 100 clinical publications for a broad range of GI diseases |
| l | | Clinical studies for additional potential uses |
| n | | Hepatic encephalopathy, Crohn’s disease |
| n | | Pouchitis,C. difficile-associated diarrhea |
| n | | Small bowel overgrowth, TD prophylaxis |
| l | | Salix intends to seek FDA approval for additional indications |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 12
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_13.jpg)
GRANULATED MESALAMINE
| l | | In-licensed from Dr. Falk Pharma, a leading European gastroenterology company |
| l | | Given unique release mechanism, Salix intends to develop for: |
| — | | expanded ulcerative colitis treatment options |
| — | | improved dosing regimens |
| l | | Patent protected to 2018 |
| l | | First right of negotiation for certain other products |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 13
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_14.jpg)
SALIX IS SUCCESSFULLY EXECUTING
ITS BUSINESS PLAN
| l | | Salix has made tremendous progress over three years in building a thriving specialty pharmaceutical franchise |
| l | | Salix has proven its ability to in-license, complete any required development, and launch and sell drugs through our focused specialty sales force |
| l | | Salix is at the cusp of realizing the benefit of our efforts and success in executing our business plan |
| l | | Salix is poised for significant growth and profitability, and can better enhance stockholder value by continuing to execute its business plan |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 14
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_15.jpg)
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 15
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_16.jpg)
SALIX IS GOVERNED BY AN
INDEPENDENT BOARD
| | |
John F. Chappell | | IO | | Former Chairman, Worldwide Pharmaceuticals, SmithKline Beecham plc (28 yrs pharmaceutical executive) |
| | |
Thomas W. D’Alonzo | | IO | | Former President, PPD, Inc. & Glaxo, Inc. (17 yrs pharmaceutical executive) |
| | |
Richard A. Franco | | IO | | Former Chairman and CEO, LipoScience, Inc. & Trimeris, Inc. (32 yrs health care and pharmaceutical executive) |
| | |
Carolyn J. Logan | | I | | President, CEO and Director (22 yrs pharmaceutical executive) |
| | |
Robert P. Ruscher | | I | | Executive Chairman (9 yrs pharmaceutical executive) |
IO = Independent outsider I = Insider
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 16
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_17.jpg)
KEY BOARD COMMITTEES ARE FULLY
INDEPENDENT
Audit, Compensation and Nominating Committee members
John F. Chappell
Chair, Compensation
Thomas W. D’Alonzo
Chair, Audit
Richard A. Franco
Chair, Nominating
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 17
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_18.jpg)
SALIX BOARD’S INTERESTS ARE
ALIGNED WITH ITS STOCKHOLDERS
| | Shares Owned
| | % O.S.**
| |
Salix Directors* | | 1,624,396 | | 7.6 | % |
Axcan (Saule Holdings) | | 100 | | 0.0005 | % |
* | | Salix Officers and Directors hold an aggregate of 3.3 million shares of SLXP common stock, representing 15.5 % of O.S. The aggregate market value of their equity holdings is25 times greater than their annual salaries. |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 18
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_19.jpg)
SALIX PRACTICES GOOD
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
| l | | All directors elected annually |
| l | | Stockholders can amend the bylaws by majority vote |
| l | | Holders of 10% can call special meetings |
| l | | Merger can be approved by simple majority vote |
| l | | Original Rights Plan approved by stockholders |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 19
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_20.jpg)
SALIX PRACTICES GOOD
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
(CONTINUED)
| l | | The CEO and Chairman roles are separated, and have been since 1999 |
| l | | All directors have excellent meeting attendance |
| l | | Non-audit fees consistently lower than audit fees |
| l | | Auditor appointment ratified by stockholders annually |
| l | | Active involvement of outside directors and advisors |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 20
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_21.jpg)
SHAREHOLDER RIGHTS PLAN
| l | | Approved by shareholders (94% of votes cast) in June 2000 |
| l | | Updated January 2003 after Salix: |
| — | | Reincorporated from a British Virgin Islands corporation to a Delaware corporation in 2002 |
| — | | Changed from Toronto Stock Exchange listing to Nasdaq listing in 2000 |
| l | | Plan was not updated or adopted in response to any discussions with Axcan |
| l | | Rights plan before and after January 2003 update would have same practical effect with respect to Axcan tender |
| l | | Rights plan periodically evaluated with respect to the best interests of stockholders |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 21
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_22.jpg)
GOOD CORPORATE
GOVERNANCE IN ACTION
The Salix Board has a record of carefully considering indications of
interest and being advised of, understanding and complying
with, their fiduciary duties
AXCAN Tender Offer
| l | | Board has met formally 6 times |
| — | | over 17 hours of meetings/deliberations |
| l | | Sought and utilized advice from independent advisors, including: |
| — | | Leading medical authorities |
| l | | Both decisions to reject Axcan’s offers were affirmed by independent Board members in closed meetings without insider directors |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 22
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_23.jpg)
SALIX HAS ALWAYS BEEN WILLING TO
MEET WITH THIRD PARTIES AND
DISCUSS STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVES
CONTACTS WITH AXCAN
April 1999—January 2003
During this period, Salix estimates that there were over 30 communications between Salix and Axcan in the form of meetings, telephone calls, letters and substantive e-mails. Salix never failed to respond to a telephone call or request for a meeting from Axcan.
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 23
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_24.jpg)
SALIX HAS ALWAYS BEEN WILLING TO
MEET WITH THIRD PARTIES AND
DISCUSS STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVES
(CONTINUED)
CONTACTS WITH AXCAN
January 2003—April 2003
January 2003
Salix seeks to postpone meeting scheduled for January 30, 2003
February—March 2003
No communication between Salix and Axcan
April 2003
Axcan initiates hostile tender offer and related actions
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 24
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_25.jpg)
THE SALIX BOARD HAS A HISTORY OF
MAKING STRATEGIC DECISIONS THAT
ENHANCE STOCKHOLDER VALUE
| l | | Axcan first sought to acquire Salix on Dec. 14, 1999 when SLXP stock was trading on the TSE at US$ 0.12 per share |
| — | | The Salix Board determined that its stock at that time did not adequately reflect true value in light of potential for balsalazide (COLAZAL), and that Salix stockholders would best be served by Salix’s execution of its business plan |
| — | | A 12/99 premiums paid analysis (similar to that currently used by Axcan to justify its current $10.50 offer) would have implied that an offer below $1.00 per share would have been “fair value” for Salix |
| — | | Twelve months later, Salix announced US launch of COLAZAL (1/22/01), and Salix stock closed at $9.50 |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 25
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_26.jpg)
SALIX HAS ADDED SIGNIFICANT
STOCKHOLDER VALUE
SLXP and AXCA Relative Stock Price Performance
Between Axcan’s 12/14/99 Initial Inquiry
and one day prior to its 4/10/03 Offer
SLXP: 62-fold increase AXCA: 2.7-fold increase
Clearly, by successfully implementing its current business plan initiated in 1999, Salix has added significant stockholder value
Clearly, Salix stockholders were better served by the Salix Board’s decision in late 1999 and 2000 to execute its business plan and launch COLAZAL, rather than sell to Axcan when the Salix stock did not reflect the true value of its first product
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 26
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_27.jpg)
THE SALIX BOARD BELIEVES STOCKHOLDERS WILL
ONCE AGAIN BE BETTER SERVED
BY EXECUTING THE BUSINESS PLAN
Now, 12 months prior to the projected launch of Salix’s second product, Rifaximin, Axcan is once again trying to acquire Salix at a time when Salix is poised for substantial growth, but when its stock is substantially undervalued
The Salix Board believes stockholders will once again be better served by executing Salix’s business plan and launching its second product, rather than selling to Axcan when the Salix stock does not reflect the true value of its gastroenterology franchise, its second product, Rifaximin, or its third product, granulated mesalamine
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 27
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_28.jpg)
VALUATION
CONSIDERATIONS
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 28
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_29.jpg)
PEER GROUP VALUATION SHOWS SALIX IS
SIGNIFICANTLY UNDERVALUED
ENTERPRISE VALUE* / REVENUE
| | | | Valuation Data
|
Comparable Company(1)
| | 6/2/2003 Price
| | Revenue(2)
| | Enterprise Value/ Revenue(3)
|
| | LTM
| | 2003E
| | 2004E
| | LTM
| | 2003E
| | 2004E
|
Alkermes | | $ | 13.11 | | $ | 15.5 | | $ | 52.0 | | $ | 67.2 | | 18.9x | | 17.3x | | 13.4x |
Connetics | | | 16.53 | | | 51.7 | | | 69.2 | | | 93.1 | | 8.7x | | 7.1x | | 5.3x |
Medicines Co. | | | 23.31 | | | 47.3 | | | 84.4 | | | 134.9 | | 20.3x | | 11.4x | | 7.1x |
MGI Pharma | | | 20.70 | | | 26.2 | | | 52.8 | | | 102.1 | | 17.0x | | 9.3x | | 4.8x |
| | | | | | | |
| | | | | | | | | | | | Mean | | 16.2x | | 11.3x | | 7.6x |
| | | | | | | |
Salix(4) | | $ | 11.80 | | $ | 38.8 | | $ | 52.3 | | $ | 81.8 | | 5.3x | | 3.9x | | 2.5x |
(1) | | Peer group comprised of specialty pharma companies projected to be profitable in next 24 months |
(2) | | LTM=Last twelve months |
(3) | | Estimates obtained from First Call |
(4) | | First Call estimates comprised of research reports from Leerink Swann, Thomas Weisel Partners, UBS Warburg and Wachovia Securities |
* | | Enterprise value = market value of equity plus net debt |
$ | | in millions, except per share numbers |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 29
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_30.jpg)
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH
ANALYSTS’ COMMENTS
| l | | The following five (5) slides show selected comments from research analysts that cover Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. |
| l | | Salix has retained the investment banking division of Wachovia Securities as its financial advisor in connection with the Axcan hostile tender offer and proxy solicitation and has agreed to pay Wachovia an advisory fee and a transaction fee. In addition, in March 2002 Wachovia provided investment banking services to Salix in connection with Salix’s public offering of common stock. |
| l | | Leerink Swann & Company, Thomas Weisel Partners LLC and UBS Warburg also participated in Salix’s public offering as co-managers. To Salix’s knowledge, Salix does not owe any compensation to these companies, nor will it in the future. |
| l | | Notwithstanding the foregoing, Salix believes that the term independent accurately describes the research analysts quoted herein because: |
| · | | Investment banks have procedures to prevent inappropriate communication between their research and investment banking divisions |
| · | | Analysts’ reports express the personal views of the analysts |
| · | | Analysts are not paid based on fees from specific investment banking transactions |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 30
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_31.jpg)
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH ANALYSTS’
COMMENTS
AXCAN TENDER OFFER AND SALIX STRATEGIC PLAN
l | | “Axcan has raised its hostile offer for SLXP to $10.50 per share (from $8.75 per share)…We believe that the new bid does not fully reflect the potential of rifaximin…We believe SLXP shareholders could potentially derive more value from approval and launch of Rifaximin, rather than trading in the shares prematurely at $10.50.” (M Tong—Wachovia 5/20/03) |
l | | “We believe that the majority of SLXP shareholders are growth investors and own shares in anticipation of continued growth of COLAZAL and future product launches. The rifaximin launch in FY04 represents a pivotal point for Salix and will push the company towards profitability, in our opinion.” |
(D Ellis—Thomas Weisel Partners (TWP) 4/10/03)
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 31
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_32.jpg)
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH ANALYSTS’
COMMENTS
(CONTINUED)
AXCAN TENDER OFFER AND SALIX STRATEGIC PLAN
l | | “We believe SLXP’s current share price does not fully reflect Rifaximin’s intrinsic value potential.” (M Tong—Wachovia 5/14/03) |
l | | “We believe the Company has sufficient financial flexibility to execute product acquisitions that could complement its existing sales and market efforts. The company expects to turn profitable in H2 2004, with or without Rifaximin. Our analysis supports management’s assertion…We believe the company has sufficient cash to fund its operations until it turns profitable.”(M Tong—Wachovia 5/14/03) |
l | | “Even if the deal is not completed, we see limited downside for SLXP based on the valuation exercise above.”(M Tong—Wachovia 4/10/03) |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 32
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_33.jpg)
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH ANALYSTS’
COMMENTS
(CONTINUED)
COLAZAL
l | | “The company has raised its forecast for 2003 COLAZAL sales to $53 million from $50 million…Note that as of the week ending 5/2/03, COLAZAL had an annual run rate of almost $58 million…, which could indicate that the company’s expectations might prove conservative.” (CJ Sylvester—UBSW 5/15/03) |
l | | “Axcan suggests that COLAZAL’s growth is decelerating. We disagree again.” (M Tong—Wachovia 5/20/03) |
l | | “Sequentially, (Colazal) scripts increased 9.3% during the quarter (Q1 2003 over Q4 2002) and channel inventory levels at the end of Q1 (2003) stood at 1.1 months, vs. 1.5 months in Q4 2002.”(M Hearle—Leerink Swann 5/14/03) |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 33
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_34.jpg)
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH ANALYSTS’
COMMENTS
(CONTINUED)
RIFAXIMIN
l | | “We continue to believe that the company will provide the FDA with all necessary data for a Rifaximin approval in mid-2004 and that this will drive company profitability.. We believe this (travelers’ diarrhea) represents the first of several indications Salix will seek for Rifaximin. Other indications for which we expect Salix to seek Rifaximin approval in the near-term include: hepatic encephalopathy, small bowel overgrowth, pouchitis, diverticulitis, andC. difficile diarrhea.” (D Ellis—TWP 5/14/03) |
l | | “We have raised our 2005 Rifaximin forecast to $40 million from $15 million to account for the product’s substantial market opportunities.”(CJ Sylvester—UBS Warburg (USBW) 5/15/03) |
l | | ”Given Rifaximin’s low systemic absorption and resistance potential, it could be an ideal product for treatment of a broad range of GI infections, in our view… Management expects Rifaximin sales to exceed $550 million in its fifth year after launch (2009). This would equate to average market share of approximately 15% (in the sub-segments listed in Table 1).”(M Tong—Wachovia 5/14/03) |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 34
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_35.jpg)
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH ANALYSTS’
COMMENTS
(CONTINUED)
GRANULATED MESALAMINE
l | | “Given the potential for improved dosing (qd or bid vs. current tid administration), we believe peak sales (of granulated mesalamine product) could be $250-300MM—addressing a market of roughly 500,000 adults in the U.S.”(M Hearle—Leerink Swann 5/14/03) |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 35
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_36.jpg)
WHY SUPPORT THE INCUMBENT
BOARD OF DIRECTORS?
| l | | Strong business execution |
| — | | Salix’s Board has consistently made decisions that have enhanced stockholder value |
| — | | Salix is at the cusp of realizing the benefit of our efforts and success in executing our business plan |
| — | | Salix is poised for significant growth and profitability, and can better enhance stockholder value by continuing to execute its business plan |
| l | | Good Corporate Governance |
| — | | Independent, experienced Board |
| l | | Incumbent Board more aligned with stockholders |
| — | | Salix’s D&O own 15.5% of outstanding common stock |
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 36
![LOGO](https://capedge.com/proxy/DEFA14A/0000950109-03-003571/g37415exl28_37.jpg)
FORWARD-LOOKING
STATEMENTS
Statements presented in this overview which are not historical facts are forward looking statements that involve risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ from projected results.
Factors that could cause actual results to differ materially include our dependence on balsalazide and rifaximin and their market acceptance, the risks of clinical trials and regulatory review, our limited sales and marketing experience and the need to acquire new products. These and other relevant risks are detailed in the Company’s Securities and Exchange Commission filings.
Salix Pharmaceuticals, Ltd. 37