QuickLinks -- Click here to rapidly navigate through this document
Exhibit 10.12

EXECUTIVE CASH INCENTIVE PLAN
PURPOSE
Guaranty Bancorp (the "Company") is the sponsor of this Executive Cash Incentive Plan (the "Plan"). The Company has designed the Plan to provide incentives to the Company's executive officers to achieve the Company's annual business plan during a particular Performance Period (defined below). The Plan is designed to be self-funding.
The Plan is intended to provide significant award opportunities to the Company's executive team for exceptional corporate and individual performance. In particular, the Plan is intended to:
- 1.
- Link incentive payments to performance against defined goals (Company-wide and individual) and overall adherence to the Company's enterprise risk management program.
- 2.
- Reward achievement of performance targets, results and contributions.
- 3.
- Serve as a retention tool.
- 4.
- Ensure goals and potential incentive payments are transparent and measurable.
- 5.
- Achieve a proper balance of market competitive base salaries and bonuses as to not incentivize undue risk-taking.
- 6.
- Align employee performance with stockholder expectations.
APPROVAL AND ADMINISTRATION
The Plan has been approved by the Compensation, Nominating and Governance Committee of the Board of Directors (the "CNG Committee"). The CNG Committee shall administer the Plan and shall monitor the performance, and regularly review the design and function, of the Plan.
With respect to each Performance Period (defined below), the Company's CEO will recommend to the CNG Committee, for its consideration and approval as early in the Performance Period as possible: Quantitative Performance Measures; Quantitative Performance Measure Weights; Performance Targets; Achievement Levels and corresponding Award Opportunities; and Qualitative Performance Measures (each as defined herein). Notwithstanding any recommendations from the CEO, the CNG Committee shall solely be responsible for determining and approving each of the Quantitative Performance Measures; Quantitative Performance Measure Weights; Performance Targets; Achievement Levels and corresponding Award Opportunities; and Qualitative Performance Measures. At the end of the Performance Period, the Company's CEO will review achievements against Quantitative Performance Measures, present results and recommend awards ("Awards") to the CNG Committee for its review and approval; provided, however, that the CNG Committee will review achievements against Quantitative Performance Measures with respect to the CEO. In addition, the Company's CEO
| | |
Guaranty Bancorp | | Executive Cash Incentive Plan Approved February 7, 2012 |
1
will provide the CNG Committee with an evaluation of any Qualitative Performance Measures and recommend any appropriate adjustments to Awards; provided, however, that the CNG Committee will evaluate any Qualitative Performance Measures with respect to the CEO. In evaluating Awards, the CNG Committee shall do so outside the presence of management, except that the CNG Committee may request the presence of the CEO when considering Awards to members of executive management other than the CEO. Notwithstanding any recommendations from the CEO, the CNG Committee will be solely responsible for determining and granting any Awards pursuant to the Plan.
Subject to any authority granted to the full Board of Directors or a committee of the independent directors thereof, the CNG Committee has the sole and absolute power and authority to make all factual determinations, construe and interpret terms and make eligibility and Award determinations in accordance with its interpretation and application of the Plan.
ELIGIBILITY/PARTICIPANTS
Only executive officers of the Company subject to Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 are eligible for participation in the Plan. An individual who has been recommended for participation in the Plan by the CEO and approved by the CNG Committee is a participant (the "Participants").
PERFORMANCE PERIOD
The performance period for the Plan is the Company's fiscal year, January 1- December 31 ("Performance Period").
PERFORMANCE MEASURES
The Company's CEO will select one or more quantitative performance measures for the Performance Period for approval by the CNG Committee ("Quantitative Performance Measures"). All Quantitative Performance Measures will be key indicators of financial performance, including but not limited to: (i) net income; (ii) return on average assets ("ROA"); (iii) loan growth; (iv) asset quality ratios; (v) cash ROA; (vi) return on average equity ("ROE"); (vii) cash ROE; (viii) earnings per share ("EPS"); (ix) cash EPS; (x) stock price; (xi) efficiency ratio; and (xii) book value per share. Quantitative Performance Measures may be established on a consolidated basis and/or for specified subsidiaries or business units of the Company (determined either in absolute terms or relative to the performance of one or more similarly situated companies or a published index covering the performance of a number of companies).
Each Quantitative Performance Measure will operate independently (i.e., it is possible for one Quantitative Performance Measure to generate an Award and not the other). Likewise, it is possible for one Quantitative Performance Measure to be achieved at a higher level than the other. Quantitative Performance Measures will be individually weighted (i.e., one Quantitative Performance Measure may be counted more heavily in calculating Awards than the other). Weights for each Quantitative Performance Measure will be recommended by the CEO for approval by the CNG Committee ("Quantitative Performance Measure Weights"); however, the CNG Committee will retain absolute authority over the selection of, and weights accorded to, any Quantitative Performance Measures. A targeted level of achievement with respect to each Quantitative Performance Measure (the "Performance Target") will be established for the Performance Period, along with the percentages of achievement of the Performance Target (the "Achievement Levels") that may lead to corresponding Awards under the Plan (the "Award Opportunities").
In addition to Quantitative Performance Measures, the Company's CEO may select one or more qualitative performance measures for the Performance Period for approval by the CNG Committee ("Qualitative Performance Measures"). Qualitative Performance Measures may include or relate to, but
2
are not limited to: (i) execution of strategic goals; (ii) quality of regulatory relationships; (iii) individual contributions to the Company's performance; (iv) credit-related goals; (v) expense management; (vi) overall adherence to the Company's enterprise risk management program, which covers but is not limited to the management of credit and underwriting risk, compliance and legal risk, operational and transaction risk, interest rate risk and reputation risk; or (vii) such other key qualitative measures tied to current or future Company performance.
The CNG Committee will have the authority to subjectively evaluate the achievement of Qualitative Performance Measures and increase or decrease Awards based on its evaluation. The Qualitative Performance Measures will operate together, will not be individually weighted and will operate to increase or decrease Awards as determined based on the achievement of Quantitative Performance Measures. The achievement or non-achievement of Qualitative Performance Measures may be determined on a Participant-by-Participant basis. Accordingly, it is possible for one Participant to have achieved Qualitative Performance Measures while another Participant did not. Likewise, it is possible for Qualitative Performance Measures to affect the Awards of different Participants differently. It is possible, therefore, that the Award for one Participant may be increased more significantly than the Award for another Participant based on the achievement of Qualitative Performance Measures. The CNG Committee will retain absolute authority over the selection of, and determination of effect of, any Qualitative Performance Measures.
ACHIEVEMENT LEVELS AND AWARD OPPORTUNITIES
Achievement Levels and Award Opportunities for a Performance Period approved by the CNG Committee will generally be set forth in the format below. The table shows achievement of various levels of the established Quantitative Performance Measure(s), as a percentage of the Performance Target(s), during a Performance Period and illustrates the corresponding Award Opportunity at each specified Achievement Level. Award Opportunities will generally be expressed as a percentage of base salary. Mathematical interpolation will be used to calculate Awards for achievement between the levels established.
Performance Period: January 1, xxxx—December 31, xxxx
Quantitative Performance Measure(s): Performance Target(s) :
Award Opportunities
| | | | | | | | | | |
| | Achievement Level (% of Performance Target(s)) | |
---|
Participant | | (Threshold) [ ]% | | (Target) 100% | | (Maximum) [ ]% | |
---|
CEO | | | | | | | | | | |
Other Executive Officers | | | | | | | | | | |
Awards earned on the basis of the Quantitative Performance Measure(s) may be increased or decreased based on the achievement of Qualitative Performance Measure(s) for a Performance Period. For the avoidance of doubt, achievement of the Qualitative Performance Measure(s) may result in Awards even if the Quantitative Performance Measure(s) are not achieved at the threshold level and may result in Awards above the maximum Award Opportunity. Likewise, non-achievement of Qualitative Performance Measures may result in no Awards even if Quantitative Performance Measures are achieved at the threshold level and may result in Awards below the minimum level of Award Opportunity.
The Quantitative Performance Measures, Performance Targets, Achievement Levels, Award Opportunities and Qualitative Performance Measures, as approved by the CNG Committee, will be set forth inSchedule I and updated for each Performance Period during which this Plan is in effect.
3
AWARDS
Awards under the Plan will be based upon achievement of Quantitative Performance Measures and Qualitative Performance Measures as described above. When determining the achievement of a Quantitative Performance Measure, the CNG Committee may exclude any or all "extraordinary items" as determined under U.S. generally accepted accounting principles including, without limitation, the charges or costs associated with restructurings of the Company, discontinued operations, other unusual or non-recurring items, and the cumulative effects of accounting changes. The CNG Committee will retain absolute authority over the selection of, and determination of the effect of, any Qualitative Performance Measures.
For purposes of the Plan, "base salary" means annual base salary in effect at the end of the Performance Period. Awards under the Plan will be considered eligible compensation as permitted or defined by each specific employee benefit plan for purposes of employee benefit calculations.
Awards for individuals who are Participants for less than a full Performance Period will be prorated using Participant's length of employment with the Company. Awards for Participants who leave the Company during a Performance Period due to retirement, total and permanent disability or death will be prorated using the same method.
To be eligible to receive an Award under the Plan, a Participant must have a performance rating of "3" or better during the Performance Period.
Results achieved under the Plan must not be achieved through inappropriate means.
ADJUSTMENTS
Participants, Quantitative Performance Measures, Quantitative Performance Measure Weights, Performance Targets, Achievement Levels, Award Opportunities and Qualitative Performance Measures may be adjusted during the Performance Period only upon approval by the CNG Committee, as it deems appropriate. It is anticipated that such adjustments will be made infrequently and only in the most extraordinary circumstances.
PAYMENT OF AWARDS
Awards will be paid as soon as administratively feasible after review of performance against targets and approval by the CNG Committee. Any Award with respect to a Performance Period will be paid within 21/2 months of the end of the calendar year in which the Performance Period ends. Awards will be paid through the payroll system, minus any legally required and authorized deductions.
To be eligible for an Award payment, a Participant must have been an employee of the Company for at least three months and be actively employed on the date that Awards are paid or have left the Company during the Performance Period due to retirement, total and permanent disability or death. Any Awards for Participants who have left the Company during the Performance Period due to retirement, total and permanent disability or death will be prorated using the Participant's actual base salary paid during the time of participation in the Performance Period. There will be no Award paid to Participants who leave the Company for any other reason.
Participants otherwise eligible to receive an Award and who were assigned to a different role within the organization during the Performance Period will have their Award calculated based upon the part of the organization they are in at the end of the Performance Period and the performance achieved by that group for the Performance Period.
4
SELF-FUNDING PLAN
The Plan is designed to be self-funding for each Performance Period. Award payments under the Plan shall be funded by an incentive pool created as part of the Company's annual budget process. If the Company achieves each of the Performance Targets at the "target" Achievement Level, then the pool would be funded at 100% of the aggregate "target" Achievement Level for all Participants. If only the "threshold" Achievement Level is achieved for each of the Performance Targets, the pool would be funded at the threshold percentage identified inSchedule I with respect to the aggregate "target" Achievement Level for all Participants. If the "maximum" Achievement Level is achieved for each of the Performance Targets, the pool would be funded at the maximum percentage identified inSchedule I with respect to the aggregate "target" Achievement Level for all Participants. A pro-rata adjustment to the amount of funding for the pool will be made where the achievement of a specific Performance Target falls in between the "threshold" and "target" Achievement Levels or in between the "target" and "maximum" Achievement Levels. To the extent a particular Performance Target does not achieve the "threshold" Achievement Level, there would generally be no funding for that particular objective unless the CNG Committee determines in its discretion that some level of funding is appropriate. If there is no "maximum" Achievement Level identified, the CNG Committee may also approve a total pool funding of up to 150% of aggregate "target" Achievement Level for all Participants if it determines that the Company has materially exceeded the Performance Targets for the Performance Period, provided that such pool is determined to be self-funded by the Company's achievements for such Performance Period. Once the amount of pool funding has been determined for a Performance Period, specific Award payments from the pool to each of the Participants will depend on an evaluation of achievement of the identified Qualitative Performance Measures for such Performance Period.
NO RIGHT OF ASSIGNMENT
No right or interest of any Participant in the Plan is assignable or transferable. In the event of a Participant's death, payment of any earned but unpaid Awards will be made to the Participant's legal successor, if not prohibited by law.
NO RIGHT OF EMPLOYMENT
The Plan does not give any employee any right to continue in the employment of the Company and does not constitute any contract or agreement of employment or interfere in any way with the right the Company has to terminate such person's employment. The Company is an "at will" employer and, as such, can terminate an employment relationship between itself and any of its employees at will, with or without cause and with or without notice.
AMENDMENT OR TERMINATION OF THE PLAN
The Company reserves the right to change, amend, modify, suspend, continue or terminate all or any part of the Plan either in an individual case or in general, at any time without notice.
5
Schedule I
6
QuickLinks
EXECUTIVE CASH INCENTIVE PLANAward OpportunitiesSchedule I