TRANSPRO, INC.
100 GANDO DRIVE
NEW HAVEN, CT 06513
September 16, 2004
VIA EDGAR
Securities and Exchange Commission
450 Fifth Street N.W.
Washington, DC 20549
Attention: Beverly A. Singleton
Re: Transpro, Inc.
Item 4.01 Form 8-K, filed August 26, 2004
File No. 1-13894
Dear Ms. Singleton:
I am attaching the response of Transpro, Inc. (the "Company") to the
comments of the staff (the "Staff") of the Securities and Exchange Commission
(the "Commission") contained in the Staff's letter dated September 9, 2004
relating to the above-referenced filings.
We have recited the comment of the Staff in bold type below, and have
followed each comment with the response of the Company. We intend to revise our
10-Q/A Amendment No. 1 for the quarter ended March 31, 2004 as promptly as
practicable following the Staff's review of this response letter.
As requested in your letter, Transpro, Inc. acknowledges that:
- - the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in
these filings;
- - Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments in the
filings reviewed by the Staff do not foreclose the Commission from taking any
action with respect to the filing; and
- - the Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding
initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of
the United States.
Please contact Kenneth T. Flynn, Jr., Controller at (203) 859-3557, or
the undersigned at (203) 859-3552, should you have any questions regarding this
response.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Richard A. Wisot
- --------------------
Richard A. Wisot
Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
ITEM 4.01 OF FORM 8-K
REPORTABLE CONDITION: INTERNAL CONTROL WEAKNESS
1. WE NOTE THE DISCLOSURE REGARDING A MATERIAL WEAKNESS RELATED TO CERTAIN
INTERNAL CONTROLS THAT IS CONSIDERED TO BE A REPORTABLE CONDITION. PLEASE
PROVIDE US SUPPLEMENTALLY, WITH A COPY OF ALL WRITTEN REPORTS, LETTERS OR
COMMUNICATIONS FROM PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS, LLP TO MANAGEMENT, THE BOARD OF
DIRECTORS OR THE AUDIT COMMITTEE REGARDING THE MATERIAL WEAKNESS IN
INTERNAL CONTROLS.
Response: We have attached a written presentation from
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP ("PwC") to the Company's Audit Committee which
was presented at the meeting of the Audit Committee held on August 12,
2004. We have also provided miscellaneous email correspondence from PwC to
Company management. There were no further written reports, letters or
communications from PwC to management, the Board of Directors or the Audit
Committee regarding the material weakness in internal controls.
2. REFER TO THE MATERIAL WEAKNESS RELATED TO CERTAIN INTERNAL CONTROLS
SURROUNDING THE PROPER REPORTING PERIOD IN WHICH TO RECOGNIZE REVENUES FOR
SALES WITH FOB DESTINATION SHIPPING TERMS. TELL US THE NATURE AND TERMS OF
THE SHIPPING ARRANGEMENTS AND WHY THE RESTATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS NOW
COMPLY WITH GAAP AND SAB 101.
Response: Traditionally, with isolated exceptions, the Company's customer
agreements contained the shipping terms "FOB Shipping Point." These terms
resulted in revenue being recognized at the time products were shipped from
Company facilities to the customer. The Company's accounting systems were
configured on this basis. During recent years, certain new customers
negotiated the shipping terms "FOB Destination", which result in the
recognition of revenue upon receipt by the customer. At the end of the
fourth quarter of 2003, management reviewed the issue of revenue
recognition and determined that two of its larger retail customers had
written agreements which included shipping terms of FOB Destination. As a
result, an adjustment was recorded to reverse the impact of shipments which
were not received by the customers before the end of 2003 in accordance
with GAAP.
During the review of the results for the second quarter of 2004, management
determined that a more extensive review was required to determine which of
its customers had agreements with shipping terms of FOB Destination. As a
result, reported results for the first quarter of 2004 were restated, with
sales being reduced by $1.3 million and pretax profit lowered by $0.2
million. The impact on other periods was evaluated and determined not to be
material.
In addition to the review of customer contracts, the Company has revised
its procedures to properly determine at the end of each quarterly reporting
period the
amount of shipments which have not been received by customers with FOB
Destination terms, and ensure that these sales are reversed and properly
accounted for in accordance with GAAP. The Company is also attempting to
change all customer shipping terms to FOB Shipping Point.
MARCH 31, 2004 QUARTERLY REPORT ON FORM 10-Q, AS AMENDED
3. REFERENCE IS MADE TO THE ITEM 4.01 FORM 8-K AND THE MATERIAL WEAKNESS
COMMUNICATED TO YOU BY PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS, LLP. ALSO REFER TO THE ITEM
4 DISCLOSURES IN YOUR MARCH 31, 2004 QUARTERLY REPORT ON FORM 10-Q, AS
AMENDED. WE NOTE YOU DO NOT DISCLOSE THE CONCLUSIONS ABOUT THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF YOUR DISCLOSURE CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES, AS REQUIRED UNDER
ITEM 307(A) OF REGULATION S-K. THE MATERIAL CONTROL WEAKNESS DISCLOSED IN
YOUR ITEM 4.01 FORM 8-K AND AS DUPLICATED HERE, APPEAR TO INDICATE YOU MAY
LACK THE NECESSARY DISCLOSURE CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES, AS WELL AS INTERNAL
CONTROLS NECESSARY TO PROVIDE TRUE AND ACCURATE ITEM 4 DISCLOSURES IN THE
FORM 10-Q. ALSO, PLEASE NOTE THAT MANAGEMENT MAY NOT STATE THAT ITS
CONTROLS ARE EFFECTIVE "EXCEPT" TO THE EXTENT THAT CERTAIN PROBLEMS HAVE
BEEN IDENTIFIED OR EXPRESS SIMILAR QUALIFIED CONCLUSIONS. RATHER,
MANAGEMENT MUST TAKE THOSE PROBLEMS INTO ACCOUNT WHEN CONCLUDING WHETHER
THE CONTROLS ARE EFFECTIVE. IF THE CONTROLS ARE INEFFECTIVE, MANAGEMENT
SHOULD STATE THE SPECIFIC REASONS WHY THEY ARE INEFFECTIVE. PLEASE REVISE
YOUR ITEM 4 DISCLOSURES IN THE FORM 10-Q TO COMPLY WITH ITEM 307 OF
REGULATION S-K.
Response: In response to this comment, the Company proposes to replace Part
I, Item 4 in its entirety with the following:
ITEM 4. CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES
The Company maintains disclosure controls and procedures that are
designed to ensure that information required to be disclosed in the
Company's Exchange Act reports is recorded, processed, summarized and
reported within the time periods specified in the SEC's rules and forms,
and that such information is accumulated and communicated to the Company's
management, including its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial
Officer, as appropriate, to allow timely decisions regarding required
disclosure based on the definition of "disclosure controls and procedures"
in Rule 13a-15(e). In designing and evaluating the disclosure controls and
procedures, management recognizes that any controls and procedures, no
matter how well designed and operated, can provide only reasonable
assurance of achieving the desired control objectives, and management
necessarily is required to apply its judgment in evaluating the
cost-benefit relationship of possible controls and procedures.
The Company carried out an evaluation, under the supervision and with
the participation of the Company's management, including the Company's
Chief Executive Officer and the Company's Chief Financial Officer, of the
effectiveness of
the design and operation of the Company's disclosure controls and
procedures as of March 31, 2004. In conjunction with the evaluation carried
out as of June 30, 2004, the Company detected a material internal control
weakness associated with determining the revenue recognition impact of
shipping terms to certain customers near quarters' end. It was determined
that $1.3 million of net sales and $0.2 million of net income associated
with shipments having terms of FOB Destination had been recorded in the
quarter ended March 31, 2004 instead of in the quarter ended June 30, 2004.
As a result, the Company is restating its results for the quarter ended
March 31, 2004 and filing this amended Form 10-Q. The Company has
determined that the impact of this issue on other prior periods was not
material. Based upon the foregoing facts, management has concluded that its
disclosure controls and procedures contained a material weakness as of
March 31, 2004 and were therefore not effective as of that date.
Subsequent to the end of the second quarter of 2004 in conjunction with
the preparation of the financial statements for that period, the Company
has implemented process and control improvements to insure that revenue is
recognized in the proper periods. Specifically, these procedures include a
review of all customer contracts in place and the implementation of a
policy requiring sign-off by a senior financial officer if any new customer
contract is entered into or existing customer contract is revised to
contain shipping terms other than "FOB Shipping Point." There have been no
other changes in the Company's internal control over financial reporting
during the quarter ended March 31, 2004 that have materially affected, or
are reasonably likely to materially affect the Company's internal control
over financial reporting.
4. ALSO, DISCLOSE ANY SIGNIFICANT CHANGES IN INTERNAL CONTROLS TO COMPLY
WITH ITEM 307(B) OF REGULATION S-K. WE NOTE FROM THE 8-K DISCLOSURE THAT
YOU HAVE IMPLEMENTED PROCESS AND CONTROL IMPROVEMENTS.
Response: We have provided additional disclosure regarding changes in
internal controls in response to the Staff's comment. We refer you to the
proposed revised language in Part I, Item 4 provided above in response to
comment 3.
SUPPLEMENTAL DOCUMENTS:
Materials Provided to Audit Committee
Transpro, Inc.
Report to the Audit Committee
August 12, 2004
*connectedthinking [PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LOGO OMITTED]
Chronology of Sales Cutoff Issue
o Q4 2003 o Transpro reversed $660 thousand of sales and
$250 thousand of margin for shipments made to
Advance in the last two days of the period
o Q1 2004 o During the Q1 review, PwC inquired whether any
cutoff issues exist at 3/31/04 and was
informed that none existed
o Q2 2004 o During the Q2 review, PwC inquired whether any
cutoff issues exist and was provided with an
analysis indicating an issue at Q1 and Q2
Page 2
PricewaterhouseCoopers August 12, 2004
Company Approach and Analysis
o Data Accumulation o Sales for last four days of each period were
analyzed
o Proofs of delivery were obtained for shipments
made in Q4 2003, Q1 2004 and Q2 2004
o Analysis of Data o The analysis indicates that three days
reasonably approximate the period from
shipment to customer receipt. The quarterly
and annual impact for 2002 and 2003 were
determined by applying the three day estimate
o Legal Interpretations o Wiggin & Dana to provide written opinions:
Required
- supporting title and risk of loss passage
when goods are placed on AutoZone-owned
trucks
- concluding that the Advance terms and
company invoicing practices result in FOB
shipping point and not FOB destination
Page 3
PricewaterhouseCoopers August 12, 2004
Assessment of Financial Reporting Impact
o Company's o Materiality evaluated from a quantitative and
Assessment qualitative perspective
o Conclusion to amend Q1 2004 Form 10-Q reducing
revenues by $1.3 million and income by $249
thousand
o Legal Counsel's o Wiggin & Dana was consulted and concurs with
View the Company's conclusion
o PwC's View o PwC agrees with the Company's conclusion
o Internal Control o Disclosure of a material weakness in Item 4 of
Form 10-Q.
Page 4
PricewaterhouseCoopers August 12, 2004
Communications from PwC to Management
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Diana To "Rich Giannino" *rgiannino@transpro.com** @INTL
Montauti/US/ABAS/PwC
cc
07/20/2004 01:13 PM
860-241-7159 bcc
Hartford, CT
US Subject Re: FW: Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Also Rich, does your excel file give visibility to the book value of the sales
(meaning, the related inventory value)? If yes, can you include this in the
print out as well. Thanks,
Diana Montauti
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
100 Pearl Street
Hartford, CT 06103
P:(860) 241-7159
F:(813) 207-3718
"Rich Giannino" *rgiannino@transpro.com**
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
"Rich Giannino"
*rgiannino@transpro.com** To Diana Montauti/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
07/20/2004 11:44 AM cc
Subject FW: Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
Diana
Received the email back for a second time with the same message. The file may be
too large for what you have in your inbox.
let me know if a print out is good enough or if you have another address to send
it to.
Rich
-----Original Message-----
From: System Administrator
Sent: Tuesday, July 20, 2004 11:42 AM
To: 'diana.montauti@us.pwc.com'
Subject: Undeliverable: Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
Your message did not reach some or all of the intended recipients.
Subject: FW: Last 2 Sales Day for Ql & Q2 2004.xls
The following recipient(s) could not be reached:
'diana.montauti@us.pwc.com' on 7/20/2004 11:42 AM
This message is larger than the current system limit or the
recipient's mailbox is full. Create a shorter message body or remove
attachments and try sending it again.
*tprnhmail.domain.com #5.2.3 smtp;552 5.2.3 Message exceeds
maximum fixed size (14680064)**
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Diana To CDelucia@transpro.com
Montauti/US/ABAS/PwC
KFlynn@transpro.com, Neil G. Mitchill
07/23/2004 03:08 PM cc Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
860-241-7159
Hartford, CT bcc
US
Subject BOL and PO selections
Hi Chris,
As discussed with Ken, please pull the following selections (there are 10). We
will need the Bill of Lading and the P.O. for each.
Thank you,
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
BOL and PO selections.xls
Diana Montauti
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
100 Pearl Street
Hartford, CT 06103
P:(860) 241-7159
F:(813) 207-3718
Selections for BOL and PO
ALT-HE Advance
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # QTY AMT DATE CUS CUS # BU LOC INV #
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432184 4 335.92 6/30/2004 ADVANCE 30048 10579 MEMPHIS 3887254
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432392 12 1128.36 6/30/2004 ADVANCE 30048 10579 MEMPHIS 3887254
ALT-HE Advance
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # DOC TYPE LINE TYPE CHN GRP CODE GRP Quarter cpu Cost
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432184 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 51.8738 207.4952
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432392 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 43.4357 521.2284
ALT-HE Autozone
- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # QTY AMT DATE CUS CUS # BU LOC INV #
- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
433716 26 2189.2 6/30/2004 ADVANCE 30048 10579 MEMPHIS 3887254
- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432305 2 338.48 6/30/2004 ADVANCE 30048 10579 MEMPHIS 3887253
ALT-HE Autozone
- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # DOC TYPE LINE TYPE CHN GRP CODE GRP Quarter cpu Cost
- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
433716 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 56.0983 1458.556
- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432305 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 106.0662 212.1324
ALT-HE Ozark
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # QTY AMT DATE CUS CUS # BU LOC INV #
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
431405 7 755.44 6/30/2004 OZARK P_ 6897 10579 MEMPHIS 3887090
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
433918 9 565.92 6/29/2004 OZARK P_ 6897 10579 MEMPHIS 3884735
ALT-HE Ozark
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # DOC TYPE LINE TYPE CHN GRP CODE GRP Quarter cpu Cost
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
431405 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 58.8383 411.8681
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
433918 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 45.4387 408.9483
ALT-HE CSK
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # QTY AMT DATE CUS CUS # BU LOC INV #
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432391 7 779.31 6/30/2004 CSK AUTO 46164 10579 MEMPHIS 3887097
ALT-HE CSK
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # DOC TYPE LINE TYPE CHN GRP CODE GRP Quarter cpu Cost
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
432391 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 43.4357 304.0499
ALT-HE Pep Boys
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # QTY AMT DATE CUS CUS # BU LOC INV #
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
433184 8 684.24 6/30/2004 PEP BOYS 7044 10579 MEMPHIS 3887129
ALT-HE Pep Boys
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # DOC TYPE LINE TYPE CHN GRP CODE GRP Quarter cpu Cost
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
433184 RI S RTL 2nd Qtr 52.2638 466.1104
ALT-TC Autozone
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # QTY AMT DATE CUS CUS # BU LOC INV #
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2642 93 11000.04 3/30/2004 AUTOZONE 14289 11963 READY-AI 3738097
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORE CH, 329 2138.5 3/30/2004 AUTOZONE 14289 11963 READY-AI 3738097
ALT-TC Autozone
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART # DOC TYPE LINE TYPE CHN GRP CODE GRP Quarter cpu Cost
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2642 RI S RTL 1st Qtr 0 0
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORE CH, RI I RTL 1st Qtr 0 0
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Diana To KFlynn@transpro.com
Montauti/US/ABAS/PwC
cc Neil G. Mitchill Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
07/23/2004 03:20 PM
860-241-7159 bcc
Hartford, CT
US Subject Sales File and Agreement Pages
Ken,
As discussed.
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Last 2 Sales Day for Q1 & Q2 2004.zip
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Pep - AZ - CSK Page.pdf
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Advance page.PDF
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
OReilley.pdf
Diana Montauti
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
100 Pearl Street
Hartford, CT 06103
P: (860) 241-7159
F: (813) 207-3718
PwC Sales Cutoff Analysis - 2004
B.U. CUSTOMER Q1 3/30 Q1 3/31 Q2 6/29 Q2 6/30
ALT-HE Autozone 92,792 (9,125) 212,889 41,009
Advance (24,397) 38,932 (8,645) 100,881
CSK 5,435 25,982 3,308 52,198
Pep Boys 62,722 6,525 2,215 16,221
Ozark 147,180 216,002 247,244 153,663
ALT-TC Autozone 713,366 -- 10,994 6,166
CSK 4,158 72 14,049 16,148
Pep Boys 55,344 50,044 41,094 1,014
Proposition 65, the Merchandise shall be labeled so that the sale of the
Merchandise by Pep Boys, assuming that Pep Boys has posted non-merchandise
specific warning signs, will not cause Pep Boys to be in violation of
Proposition 65); (h) all of the information provided by Manufacturer to Pep Boys
with respect to the Merchandise shall be true and correct, and sufficient
substantiation shall exist for the same for Pep Boys to publish and use the same
in compliance with the provisions of all federal, state and local laws and
regulations (and those of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico) now in effect or
hereafter enacted; (i) the equal opportunity requirements set forth in 41 CFR
60-1.4, 60-250.40 and 60-741.5, as amended, are incorporated herein, and
Manufacturer shall comply with them while supplying the Merchandise to Pep Boys;
and (j) Manufacturer will comply with all of the requirements set forth in Pep
Boys' Bar Code Compliance Manual supplied from time to time.
Manufacturer agrees to an annual Merchandise line review and to remove for full
credit all slow moving and overstocked Merchandise and/or any Merchandise which
was discontinued by Manufacturer.
10. PURCHASE ORDERS: NO MERCHANDISE SHALL BE SHIPPED UNLESS A PURCHASE ORDER HAS
BEEN RECEIVED FROM PEP BOYS. Pep Boys shall have the right, at any time prior to
shipment of the Merchandise to make changes to the applicable purchase order.
11. FREIGHT: Manufacturer will ship all Merchandise directly to Pep Boys'
designated DCs F.O.B. Pep Boys' DC with Manufacturer responsible for all
freight, shipping and insurance charges. Merchandise shall be packaged and
shipped in accordance with Pep Boys' instructions and procedures, which may be
modified from time to time by Pep Boys. The risk of loss with respect to any
Merchandise shall not pass to Pep Boys until the Merchandise has been delivered
in full conformity with the applicable purchase order and this Agreement to Pep
Boys' designated DC. All Merchandise shall be subject to inspection and approval
by Pep Boys within 24 hours after receipt, notwithstanding payment therefor, and
may be rejected in whole or in part, as if it had never been accepted, if the
Merchandise is not in compliance with the assurances set forth above.
Manufacturer shall supply, at its sole cost and expense, all materials requested
by Pep Boys for the repackaging of any Merchandise deemed by Pep Boys to be not
sellable due to damaged packaging.
12. PACKAGING: Merchandise will be shipped in standard packaging, using
specified part numbers and UPC codes.
13. LIFT OF PEP BOYS' EVAPORATOR INVENTORY. Manufacturer shall purchase Three
Million Dollars ($3,000,000) (measured at Pep Boys' gross acquisition cost) of
Pep Boys' undesirable evaporator inventory per the following:
a. Pep Boys to remove undesirable evaporator inventory from Pep Boys'
stores and to consolidate at Pep Boys' DCs. Pep Boys to appropriately package
for truckload shipments and ship via Pep Boys' specified carrier. Pep Boys will
pay freight from Pep Boys' DCs to Manufacturer.
b. Manufacturer will issue check/three credits of Six hundred
sixty-six thousand-six hundred and sixty six dollars (S666,666) each to Pep Boys
on February 20, 2003
The Heat Transfer Professionals
[TRANSPRO, INC. LOGO OMITTED]
ADDENDUM TO VENDOR AGREEMENT
This Addendum to Vendor Agreement is entered into by AutoZone, Inc.
("AutoZone"), a Nevada corporation, and Transpro, Inc. ("Transpro"), a Delaware
corporation, as of the 31st day of October, 2003, and is attached to and made
a part of the Vendor Agreement (the "Agreement") dated September 8, 2003 between
AutoZone and Transpro, Inc. All capitalized terms not defined herein shall have
the meanings ascribed to them in the Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and the mutual agreements of
the parties set forth herein, and other good and valuable consideration, the
receipt adequacy and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the parties
hereby agree as follows;
1. LIFTED INVENTORY. (a) On the terms and subject to the conditions contained
herein, AutoZone agrees to sell to Transpro, and Transpro agrees to purchase
from AutoZone in accordance with the timeline specified herein, free and clear
of any security interest, mortgage, lien, charge, restriction, encumbrance,
conditional sale agreement, claim, pledge or right of any party (each a "Lien"
and collectively, "Liens"), the types and quantities of accessories products
identified on Schedule 1 hereto and as the same may be amended by the parties in
writing at the time of each Closing (the "Lifted Inventory"). AutoZone warrants
that it has good and marketable title to the Lifted Inventory free and clear of
all Liens and that it has the right to sell the Lifted Inventory pursuant to the
terms of this Addendum. For purposes of this Agreement, the parties agree that
the Lifted Inventory shall only consist of and, accordingly, Transpro shall only
purchase from AutoZone pursuant to the terms of this Addendum, Lifted Inventory
in its original packaging and is in good and saleable condition. Transpro hereby
acknowledges and agrees that, except as otherwise provided herein, all of the
Lifted Inventory conveyed hereunder is being sold AS IS, WHERE IS in its current
condition as of die date of the Closing (as defined below). Transpro
acknowledges and agrees that lawful disposal of Lifted Inventory is the
responsibility of Transpro. At all times after title to the Lifted Inventory has
passed to Transpro pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, Transpro agrees to
indemnify AutoZone against, and hold it harmless from, any liability, cost,
loss, or expense arising out of any claim, demand, or action alleging that
negligent, improper or illegal use or disposal of the Lifted Inventory has
occurred.
(b) The parties agree that the Lifted Inventory will be divided into three
categories: Purchased Inventory, Slow Moving Inventory, and Non-Cross Inventory.
The Lifted Inventory is divided into these categories in Schedule 1 and Schedule
2 of this Addendum.
2. SCHEDULE OF CLOSINGS. The parties acknowledge that the sale and purchase of
the Lifted Inventory described in Section I above must be consummated in a
manner that does not disrupt either party's normal business activities.
Accordingly, the parties agree that each such sale and purchase transaction
shall occur pursuant to separate "phased" closings of Midas distribution centers
and Parts Warehouse, Inc. locations serviced by such closed Midas distribution
center (each, a "Closing" and, collectively, the "Closings"), with the last
Closing occurring no later than November 30, 2003.
3. DELIVERY. The parties agree to work together in good faith to develop an
orderly delivery schedule for the Lifted Inventory which is mutually acceptable
to the parties. AutoZone shall be responsible for the freight charges relating
to all shipments of Lifted Inventory from AutoZone to Transpro (FOB shipment
destination point). All right, title and interest in and to the Lifted Inventory
shall transfer to Transpro upon completion of shipment and Transpro may dispose
of the Lifted Inventory as Transpro, in its sole opinion deems appropriate.
4. PRICING. Transpro agrees to pay AutoZone an amount equal to the number of
units per model lifted multiplied by the price per model as set forth on the
price listing, which is attached hereto and incorporated herein as Schedule 2.
for the Lifted Inventory (the "Price List"). The total amount to be paid by
Transpro for
1
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
--------------------
APPLICABLE TO MASTER VENDOR AGREEMENT
-------------------------------------
1. Pricing and Lead Times. CSK and Vendor shall mutually agree in writing upon
the prices and lead times of each and every Product to be purchased by CSK
from Vendor. Vendor shall offer CSK allowances, discounts, credits, prices
and lead times that are equal to or better than those Vendor offers to any
other customer. In the event that CSK orders a Product prior to Vendor and
CSK reaching agreement upon the price, the price shall be the same as
Vendor offers its best customer, unless CSK and Vendor subsequently agree
to a lower price. Vendor shall provide CSK with ninety (90) days prior
written notice of any proposed price increase.
2. Allowances and Discounts. Vendor shall deduct all applicable allowances
and discounts from the amount invoiced to CSK. At CSK's option, any
allowance or discount may be used by CSK as a credit against amounts due
Vendor to the extent Vendor has not previously deducted such allowances and
discounts in full from the amount due from CSK. If for six consecutive
months, Vendor's records indicate that CSK has a credit balance. Vendor
shall promptly pay the amount of any credit balance to CSK.
3. Ordering, Delivery, and Inspection. Vendor shall supply all Products
ordered by CSK during the term of this MVA in accordance with previously
agreed lead times. If the parties have not agreed upon specific lead times,
Vendor shall supply the Products in accordance with their best lead times
at no additional cost. Nothing contained herein shall require CSK to order
any Products from Vendor. CSK may cancel any order placed with Vendor,
without cost if CSK determines in its sole discretion that it no longer
requires the Product. Products shall be packed by Vendor for shipment to
CSK in accordance with written instructions provided by CSK. If CSK has not
provided such written instructions, Vendor shall pack Products for shipment
in accordance with good commercial practice so that Products arrive at
their destination undamaged. Vendor shall ship Products to CSK in the
manner mutually agreed by the parties in writing. If the parties have not
so mutually agreed in writing, Vendor shall deliver Product FOB to CSK's
designated location at no additional cost to CSK. Vendor shall fill CSK's
orders at a rate of no less than 95% on the first pass, unless Vendor has
agreed to a higher fill rate. As used in this MVA, the terms "purchase
order" and "order" shall include each other, as well as any other form of
request from CSK to Vendor to ship Product to CSK, including requests by
EDI and correspondence.
All Product furnished hereunder is subject to inspection and approval by
CSK upon receipt, notwithstanding prior payments or acceptance of
previously shipped similar Product, and may be rejected in whole or in
part, by CSK if inferior in quality or workmanship or if not in conformity
with representations made by Vendor or for any other sufficient reason.
Further, if after receipt of any Product or any part thereof, the Product
is determined by CSK in its good faith discretion to be contaminated, not
in compliance with the terms, specifications or requirements of this MVA
or otherwise unfit for sale, such Product is subject to rejection at that
time as if it had never been accepted. If so rejected by CSK, such Product
(and in case of Product shipped in excess of a purchase order, the excess)
shall be subject to return to Vendor, at Vendor's expense for
transportation both ways, labor and other costs of unloading and reloading,
trucking and similar costs. Product so rejected may not be replaced except
upon receipt of written instructions from CSK. In no event shall CSK's
acceptance of any Product be deem a waiver by CSK of any rights with
respect to the accepted Product, or with respect to any other Products.
Vendor shall reimburse CSK for any costs, damage or expense incurred by
CSK arising or resulting from the sale by CSK of Product which is not in
conformance with the terms, requirements and specifications applicable to
such Product.
Page 5 of 9 Rev 1/25/00
Purchase Level Goals Rebate Amount
------------------------ -------------
$22,000,000 - 23,999,999 0.5
$24,000,000 - 25,999,999 0.9
$26,000,000 - 27,999,999 1.3
$28,000,000 - 29,999,999 1.7
$30,000,000 - plus 2.1
All rebates will be paid on total net sales. All credits will be issued
within 30 days of Volume Incentive period end.
Example One: Advance Purchase $24,500,000
x 0.9 = $220,500 rebate paid to Buyer
Example Two: Advance Purchase $26,500,000
x 1.3 = $344,500 rebate paid to Buyer
12. Freight Terms - Seller will ship prepaid F.O.B. from shipping point to
Buyer's distribution centers minimum orders of $1,500. PDQ warehouse orders
will be shipped prepaid on minimum orders of $750.
13. Shipments - Seller will ship to Buyer all Products in accordance with
Seller's current Vendor Service Agreement which is incorporated herein.
14. Net Purchases - Net Purchases will be defined as gross purchases less
credits for alleged defective returns. No other credits or deductions will
be allowed in determining Net Purchases.
15. Term - Upon acceptance of this Agreement by Buyer and Seller, this
instrument shall constitute an agreement for the term of three (3) years,
effective May 19, 2002 through May 19, 2005.
16. Pricing - Seller agrees to hold quoted prices for the term of this
agreement except in the event where there are substantial increases in raw
materials and or freight cost not controlled by Seller.
Raw materials will be defined as only aluminum, copper, brass, lead, and
tin. Freight cost will be defined as fuel only.
Seller agrees to supply Buyer a quote attachment (A) and both Buyer and
Seller will approve such quote prior to signing.
17. Catalog - Seller agrees to provide Buyer an up to date catalog or
supplement each year at no additional cost. Current paper catalog
requirements are two per Buyer's store per catalog. Electronic revisions
are required in the QuickCat format or APAA format at no additional cost.
3
PAYMENT TERMS
-------------
ALL DATING SHALL BEGIN AT THE DATE OF RECEIPT OF THE GOODS AT 0'REILLY'S DOCK ON ALL PROX (PROXIMO) DATINGS, GOODS INVOICED AFTER
THE 25TH OF A MONTH SHALL BE PAYABLE AS IF RECEIVED IN THE FOLLOWING MONTH. INVOICES SHOULD BE MAILED ON THE SAME DAY GOODS ARE
SHIPPED AND SHALL DATE FROM O'REILLY'S RECEIPT OF THE GOODS.
0% Cash Discount 120 days until discount payment is due, net 121 days.
________ 15th prox, net _______ days
______ % Early Pay/Anticipation Discount
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O'Reilly's Purchase Order terms should read as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Operating Order or Changeover Terms:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QUALITY
-------
Vendor agrees to supply O'Reilly Auto Parts product that meets or exceeds the original equipment manufacturers specifications. Any
changes in product makeup or design from those agreed upon by O'Reilly Auto Parts at time of original purchase must be communicated
to the Product Manager with said list of changes, along with specifications and independent lab test results. Any product that does
not hold up to these standards, or changes that create lessor quality than those agreed upon, will bring about immediate termination
of our association.
SHIPPING AGREEMENT
------------------
COMMITTED
DISTRIBUTION CENTERS YOUR SHIPPING POINTS LEAD TIME PENALTY
- ------------------------------------------------------ -------------------- ----------------- -------
SPRINGFIELD: 233 S. Patterson, Springfield, MO 65802 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
KANSAS CITY: 4134 Front St, Kansas City, MO 64120 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
OKLAHOMA CITY: 11 S. MacArthur, Oklahoma City, OK 73127 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
DES MOINES: 1800 Guthrie, Des Moines, IA 50316 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
HOUSTON: 8601 Tavenor, Houston, TX 77075 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
MCALLEN: 820 South 23rd, McAllen, TX 78501 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
DALLAS 301 Neal Street, Seagoville, TX 75159 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
LITTLE ROCK, 4350 Stockton Drive, Little Rock, AR 72117 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
NASHVILLE: 485 Craighead Street, Nashville, TN 37204 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
KNOXVILLE: 915 North Cherry Street, Knoxville, TN 37917 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
ALABAMA: 120 Jacintoport Blvd., Saraland, AL 36571 MEMPHIS, TN days ___%
------------ --------
Vendor guarantees to ship at a minimum fill rate of 93% within ____ 15_____ days from date of order until receipt on our dock or a
penalty of 15% of the total not shipped will be charged on a monthly basis for stock orders shipped out of our Memphis DC ONLY.
ALL MERCHANDISE TO BE SHIPPED F.O.B DESTINATION FREIGHT REQUIREMENTS
- ----------------------------------------------- --------------------
[X] Prepaid Pounds Dollars
------ ------
[_] Collect Units Cases
------ ------
[_] F.O.B. Pallets Other
------ ------
Split Shipment Dropoff Charge?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pick-up Allowance?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pallet Charges?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------- -------
------- -------
SHIPPING REQUIREMENTS
- ---------------------
O'Reilly Auto Parts requires that the following guidelines be stricly adhered to for shipments coming into our distribution
facilities:
1. All shipments must include a packing list.
--- ----
2. All packing lists being released with the shipments need to be placed in one carton and the outside of the carton should
be marked: "Packing List Enclosed".
3. The carton containing the packing list(s) should be placed on the top layer of the skid.
4. The bill of lading provided to the freight carrier should list all purchase order numbers that are included in that
shipment. This information should also appear on the freight carriers bill of lading.
5. All shipments must be separated by each individual DSO code/purchase order number and not mixed on pallets.
Should we receive merchandise improperly we will impose a penalty accordingly to cover the added expense of processing your order.
This penalty will be $50.00 per each occurrence at each DC location.
3
[PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LOGO OMITTED]
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sales Cutoff
1. Data validation
2. Bills of lading / Purchase orders / Invoices
3. Verify shipping point / destination for items shipped on last two days
4. Detail of credits (summary by customer)
5. Impact of non-retail customers
6. Impact of other quarters
7. Schedule of quarterly financial data and trends (Sales / Margin /
Pretax income)
8. Legal Counsel
9. Audit Committee
10. PwC Risk Management
TRANSPRO, INC.
SALES CUTOFF REVIEW
DATA AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS
1. Data Collection
a. Populate sales data matrix
b. Obtain the following information for ME -2 and ME -1 day
sales (source from amounts which generated reported
financials):
i. Customer name
ii. Ship/invoice date
iii. Invoice amount
iv. Cost amount
v. Ship From location
vi. Ship To location
vii. Shipping terms
c. Customer shipping terms
i. Query of customers and related terms
d. Summary of customer waterfall allowances
2. Data Validation
a. Sample of bill of ladings, purchase orders, and invoices to
validate two day cutoff assumptions
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Diana TO RGiannino@transpro.com
Montauti/US/ABAS/PwC
cc KFlynn@transpro.com
07/26/2004 10:08 AM bcc
860-241-7159
Hartford, CT Subject Quarterly data file
US
Rich,
Here is the updated electronic version of the spreadsheet reviewed in this
morning's meeting.
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Analytic of Sales by Customer by Qtr by day.xls
Diana Montauti
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
100 Pearl Street
Hartford, CT 06103
P: (860) 241-7159
F: (813) 207-3718
TRANSPRO, INC.
SALES CUTOFF REVIEW
2002 2003 2004
----------------- ----------------- -------
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Ql Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
ALT-HE
Total Gross Sales
Autozone
Advance
Pep Boys
Ozark
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Actual sales for quarter end
Difference 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Month end -3 Days
Autozone
Advance
Pep Boys
Ozark
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Month end -2 Days
Autozone
Advance
Pep Boys
Ozark
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Month end -1 Day
Autozone
Advance
Pep Boys
Ozark
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ALT-TC
Total Gross Sales
Autozone
Pep Boys
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Actual sales for the quarter end
Difference 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Month end -3 Days
Autozone
Pep Boys
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Month end -2 Days
Autozone
Pep Boys
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Month end -1 Day
Autozone
Pep Boys
CSK
Other FOB Destination
Other FOB Shipping Point
Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Diana To CSawicki@transpro.com
Montauti/US/ABAS/PwC
cc
07/27/2004 10:47 AM
860-241-7159 bcc
Hartford, CT
US Subject files
Hi Chet,
I haven't seen the other files come through yet (for all quarters other than Q1
2004). Can you resend to me? Thanks,
Diana Montauti
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
100 Pearl Street
Hartford, CT 06103
P: (860) 241-7159
F: (813) 207-3718
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Thomas To "Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com** @INTL
Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC
rwisot@transpro.com, Raj K.
08/02/2004 05:45 PM cc Dansinghani/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US, Jeremy J.
(860)241-7019 Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
Hartford
US bcc John F Gabranski/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
Subject Re: FW: Freight Policy Change [GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Ken,
Any thought to explicitly indicating that the new terms will be FOB shipping
point?
Tom
"Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
"Ken Flynn"
*KFLYNN@transpro.com** To Thomas Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
08/02/2004 05:33 PM cc
Subject FW: Freight Policy Change
FYI, this is the letter which has been sent to each of the five FOB destination
customers.
- ----------------------------------------
From: Cindy O'Brien
Sent: Monday, August 02, 2004 5:28 PM
To: Whitey McLean - NAW
Cc: SR STAFF
Subject: Freight Policy Change
The following letter is being sent via overnight mail to AutoZone.
**FOB Policy Change Ltr - Zone.doc****
Cindy O'Brien
Transpro
800-755-2160 Ext 354[attachment "FOB Policy Change Ltr - Zone.doc" deleted by
Thomas Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC]
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Thomas To "Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**@INTL
Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC
cc "Rich Giannino" *rgiannino@transpro.com**,
08/02/2004 05:23 PM "Richard Wisot" *RWISOT@transpro.com**
(860) 241-7019
Hartford bcc
US
Subject Re: Sales cutoff [GRAPHIC OMITTED]
will do
Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
"Ken Flynn"
*KFLYNN@transpro.com** To Thomas Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
08/02/2004 05:16 PM cc "Richard Wisot" *RWISOT@transpro.com**,
"Rich Giannino"
*rgiannino@transpro.com**
Subject Sales cutoff
I've spoken with Rich G., and we should have information for you to go through
tomorrow afternoon. Can you have Jeremy come up tomorrow afternoon? This would
include sales summaries for the last four shipping days of each quarter and
summaries of the deliveries on each of those days which were made prior to the
end of the month. We're going to go over the information with Rich first thing
in the morning, and will give you a telephone call to review the findings.
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Thomas To "Ken Flynn" *kflynn@transpro.com**
Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC
cc
08/06/2004 08:18 AM
bcc
Subject Re: Cutoff comparison
It may be premature
- ------Original Message------
From: "Ken Flynn" [KFLYNN@transpro.com]
Sent: 08/06/2004 08:04 AM
To: Thomas Gaidimas
Cc: Richard Wisot" *RWISOT@transpro.com**
Subject: RE: Cutoff comparison
Tom, this would be the meeting to clear the quarter with them.
From: thomas.gaidimas@us.pwc.com [mailto: thomas.gaidimas@us.pwc.com]
Sent: Thursday, August 05, 2004 7:18 PM
To: Ken Flynn
Subject: Re: Cutoff comparison
This the first I've heard of a call on Monday. What's the subject?
- ------Original Message------
From: "Ken Flynn" [KFLYNN@transpro.com]
Sent: 08/05/2004 06:02 PM
To: Thomas Gaidimas; Neil Mitchill Jr.; Jeremy Budzian
Cc: Richard Wisot" *RWISOT@tranapro.com**
Subject: Cutoff comparison
Attached is an updated comparison with receipt data for 2002.
Tom, Rich wanted me to remind you that tomorrow we'll need an agenda for the
Audit Committee conference call which we're going to try to set up for Monday.
We'll also need an agenda for the meeting on Thursday.
Rich and I will be in at 8 tomorrow morning so you can give us an update.
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Thomas To "Ken Flynn" *kflynn@transpro.com**
Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC
cc
08/05/2004 07:17 PM
bcc
Subject Re: Cutoff comparison
This the first I've heard of a call on Monday, What's the subject?
- ------Original Message------
From: "Ken Flynn" [KFLYNN@transpro.com]
Sent: 08/05/2004 06:02 PM
To: Thomas Gaidimas; Neil Mitchill Jr.; Jeremy Budzian
Cc: Richard Wisot" *RWISOT@transpro.com**
Subject: Cutoff comparison
Attached is an updated comparison with receipt data for 2002.
Tom, Rich wanted me to remind you that tomorrow we'll need an agenda for the
Audit Committee conference call which we're going to try to set up for Monday.
We'll also need an agenda for the meeting on Thursday.
Rich and I will be in at 8 tomorrow morning so you can give us an update.
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Jeremy J. To Neil G. Mitchill Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC
cc
09/13/2004 05:16 PM
(860)241-7178 bcc
Hartford
US Subject Fw: Sales cutoff
FYI
- --- Forwarded by Jeremy J. Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC on 09/13/2004 05:16 PM ---
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Jeremy J.
Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC To "Rich Giannino" *rgiannino@transpro.com**,
"Steve Mucha" *SMucha@transpro.com**,
08/09/2004 05:46 PM s.miller@transpro.com
(860)241-7178 cc "Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com** @INTL, Neil G.
Hartford Mitchill Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
US Subject Sales cutoff [GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Rich / Steve and Sharon:
We've been through the cutoff summary, sales & margin reports, pivot tables and
PODs provided and here's where we stand as far as remaining questions /
concerns:
1. Please email me the raw data files for all quarters prior to 4q 2003. As of
Thursday, I had only requested 2q 2004, 1q 2004 and 4q 2003. I just want to
do a sanity check on the earlier quarters as far as the mapping of the data
from the G/L file dumps to the pivot tables, etc.
2. With respect to the AutoZone "private fleet" shipments, why were there no
shipments on AZ trucks in 4q 2003? If on AZ trucks on 12/31/03, shouldn't
they be included as eligible sales in 2003 consistent with the 2004
quarters? How were the AZ "private fleet" shipments verified? Also, we
still need some evidence regarding the usage of AZ trucks for Ready Aire
shipments of container #s 7264750 and 7284294 in 1q 2004. Also, how do we
know Ready Aire container # 7342098 in 1q 2004 was on a AZ truck? How do we
know AZ container # 7342141 (Paschall) for $162k in sales was not delivered
on an AZ truck? In 2q 2004, we need evidence of the usage of AZ trucks for
Ready Aire container #s 8475705 and 84753733.
3. Need to understand why the following were excluded from eligible sales - In
1q 2004, AZ container # 7309592 for $151k of sales rec'd on 03/29/04; In 2q
2004, AZ container # 36717 for $40k of sales rec'd on 06/30/04.
4. Need to understand why the following were included within eligible sales -
In 1q 2004, Pep Boys container # 603512 for $36k of sales dropped on
03/30/04 and not signed by receiver until 04/02/04.
Once the above questions are addressed, we will be comfortable with the impact
summary prepared by Ken and discussed last Thursday. I'd be happy to walk you
through any of these items in further detail at your convenience.
Thanks,
Jeremy
(860) 241-7178 today
(860) 728-6393 tomorrow
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Neil G. Mitchill To rwisot@transpro.com, kflynn@transpro.com
Jr./US/ABAS/PwC
cc
08/09/2004 06:01 PM
860-241-7390 bcc
Hartford, CT Subject Cutoff Schedule
US
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Sales Cutoff Analysis Transpro Inc 8-4-2004 3 days wo advance.xls
Transpro, Inc.
Evaluation of Sales Cutoff
(ASSUMES 3 DAY EXCLUSION)
Excludes Advance
Q4 2001 YTD 2001 Q1 2002 Q2 2002 Q3 2002 Q4 2002 YTD 2002
------------------ ------------------------------------------------
Reported pre-tax - continuing operations (6,331) (17,598) 103 1,722 2,213 (1,732) 2,306
Operating income reversal (108) (108) (427) (268) (198) (183) (183)
Operating income addition -- -- 108 427 268 198 108
------------------ ------------------------------------------------
Adjusted pre-tax income (loss) - cont ops (6,439) (17,708) (216) 1,881 2,283 (1,717) 2,231
------------------ ------------------------------------------------
% change from reported pre-tax -1.7% -0.6% 309.7% -9.2% -3.2% 0.9% 3.3%
Net Impact to period (108) (108) (319) 159 70 15 (75)
Income tax (benefit) expense 6,889 2,710 (3,853) 177 513 (1,390) (4,353)
Adjusted income (loss) before acct change & ext i (13,328) (20,416) 3,437 1,704 1,770 (327) 6,584
Cumulative effect of accounting change -- -- (4,671) -- -- -- (4,671)
Adjusted Loss (income) before ext item (13,328) (20,416) (1,234) 1,704 1,770 (327) 1,913
Extraordinary item (150) (530) -- -- -- -- --
Adjusted Net (loss) income (13,478) (20,946) (1,234) 1,704 1,770 (327) 1,913
Reported Net (loss) income (13,370) (20,838) (915) 1,545 1,700 (342) 1,988
(108) (108) (319) 159 70 15 (75)
0.8% 0.5% 34.9% 10.3% 4.1% -4.4% -3.8%
Period end pre-tax impact of ineligible sales 108 108 427 268 198 183 183
(Assumes full 3 day exclusion)
Q1 2003 Q2 2003 Q3 2003 Q4 2003 YTD 2003 Q1 2004 Q2 2004 YTD 2004
------------------------------------------------ -----------------------------
Reported pre-tax - continuing operations (4,736) (2,285) 2,899 (1,575) (5,699) (447) 851 404
Operating income reversal (120) (92) (205) 141 141 (249) (234) (234)
Operating income addition 183 120 92 205 183 (141) 249 (141)
------------------------------------------------ -----------------------------
Adjusted pre-tax income (loss) - cont ops (4,675) (2,257) 2,788 (1,229) (5,375) (637) 666 29
------------------------------------------------ -----------------------------
% change from reported pre-tax 1.3% 1.2% 3.9% 22.0% 5.7% -87.2% -1.8% 92.8%
Net impact to period 63 28 (113) 348 324 (390) 15 (375)
Income tax (benefit) expense (403) (1,678) 938 (20) (1,163) (34) 63 29
Adjusted Income (loss) before acct change & ext i (4272) (579) 1,848 (1,209) (4,212) (603) 803 --
Cumulative effect of accounting change -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Adjusted Loss (income) before ext item (4,272) (579) 1,848 (1,209) (4,212) (803) 803 --
Extraordinary item -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Adjusted Net (loss) income (4,272) (579) 1,848 (1,209) (4,212) (803) 803 --
Reported Net (loss) income (4,335) (607) 1,961 (1,555) (4,536) (413) 788 375
63 28 (113) 346 324 (390) 15 (375)
-1.5% -4.6% -5.8% -22.3% -7.1% 94.4% 1.9% -100.0%
Period end pre-tax impact of ineligible sales 120 92 205 -141 -141 249 234 234
(Assumes full 3 day exclusion)
Reported Q4 2001 YTD 2001 Q1 2002 Q2 2002 Q3 2002 Q4 2002 YTD 2002
Reported Pre-Tax - Continuing Operations (6,331) (17,598) 103 1,722 2,213 (1,732) 2,306
Income tax (benefit) expense 6,889 2,710 (3,653) 177 513 (1,390) (4,353)
Income (loss) before acct change & ext item (13,220) (20.308) 3,756 1,545 1,700 (342) 6,659
Cumulative effect of accounting change -- -- (4,671) -- -- -- (4,671)
Loss (income) before ext item (13,220) (20,306) (915) 1,545 1,700 (342) 1,988
Extraordinary item (150) (530) -- -- -- -- --
Net (loss) income (13,370) (20,838) (915) 1,545 1,700 (342) 1,988
Tax rate -108.8% -15.4% -3548.8% 10.3% 23.2% 80.3% -188.8%
Discrete tax items
Reported Q1 2003 Q2 2003 Q3 2003 Q4 2003 YTD 2003 Q1 2004 Q2 2004 YTD 2004
Reported Pre-Tax - Continuing Operations (4,738) (2,285) 2,895 (1,575) (5,599) (447) 851 404
Income tax (benefit) expense (403) (1,678) 938 (20) (1,163) (34) 63 29
Income (loss) before acct change & ext item (4,335) (607) 1,961 (1,555) (4,536) (413) 788 375
Cumulative effect of accounting change -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Loss (income) before ext item (4,335) (607) 1,961 (1,555) (4,536) (413) 788 375
Extraordinary item -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Net (loss) income (4,335) (607) 1,961 (1,555) (4,536) (413) 788 375
Tax rate 8.5% 73.4% 32.4% 1.3% 20.4% 7.6% 7.4% Quart
Discrete tax items
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Neil G. Mitchill To kflynn@transpro.com
Jr./US/ABAS/PwC cc
bcc
Subject SAB 99
08/09/2004 06:40 PM
860-241-7390
Hartford, CT
US
Here you go....
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
SAB 99..doc
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Jeremy J. To Neil G. Mitchill Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC
cc
09/13/2004 05:17 PM
(860)241-7178 bcc
Hartford
US Subject Fw: restatement
FYI
- ----- Forwarded by Jeremy J. Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC on 09/13/2004 05:16 PM -----
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Jeremy J.
Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC To "Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**@INTL,
08/10/2004 01:51 PM "Maurice Bafumi" *mbafumi@transpro.com**
(860) 241-7178 cc Neil G. Mitchill Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
Hartford
US Subject RE: restatement [GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Ken / Maurice:
When the entries have been recorded, can you send me the revised management
reporting package and the latest draft of the 10-Q? I will start going through
this afternoon and will be down tomorrow to finish up.
Thanks,
Jeremy
728-6393
"Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
"Ken Flynn"
*KFLYNN@transpro.com** "Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**, Neil G.
Mitchill
08/10/2004 08:53 AM To Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US, Jeremy J.
Budzian/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
cc "Maurice Bafumi" *mbafumi@transpro.com**
Subject RE: restatement
I'm going to have Maurice make the entry rounded to the nearest thousand.
- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: Ken Flynn
Sent: Tuesday, August 10, 2004 8:40 AM
To: 'neil.g.mitchill.jr@us.pwc.com'; 'jeremy.j.budzian@us.pwc.com'
Subject: restatement
Ignore the 2002 and 2003 numbers.
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Neil G. Mitchill To rwisot@transpro.com
Jr./US/ABAS/PwC
cc
08/11/2004 01:43 PM
860-241-7390 bcc
Hartford, CT
US Subject Agenda for AC Meeting
Rich,
Attached is the agenda for tomorrow's meeting.
Thanks
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Neil Transpro Q2 AC Agenda 8-12-04.doc
TRANSPRO, INC.
SECOND QUARTER 2004
AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING
AUGUST 12, 2004
[ ] Scope of Review
[ ] Sales Cutoff & Ql 2004 Restatement
[ ] Required Communications
o Summary of unadjusted differences
o Changes in significant accounting policies
o Internal control weakness
o Accounting and disclosure
[ ] Other Matters
o PwC continuance
o Management letter
[PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LOGO OMITTED]
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Thomas To "Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**@INTL
Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC
"Charley Johnson" *CJohnson@transpro.com**,
"Grundei,
08/13/2004 02:03PM cc Michael" *MGrundei@wiggin.com**, Neil G.
(860) 241-7019 Mitchill
Hartford Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US, "Richard Wisot"
US *RWISOT@transpro.com**
bcc
Subject Re: 8-K draft [GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Ken,
No comments on the 8-k.
Tom
"Ken Flynn" *KFLYNN@transpro.com**
[GRAPHIC OMITTED]
"Ken Flynn"
*KFLYNN@transpro.com** "Grundei, Michael" *MGrundei@wiggin.com**,
08/13/2004 11:07 AM Thomas
To Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US, Neil G,
Mitchill
Jr./US/ABAS/PwC@Americas-US
cc "Richard Wisot *RWISOT@transpro.com**, "Charley
Johnson" *CJohnson@transpro.com**
Subject 8-K draft
Attached is a draft of the 8-K on Monday's press release for your review and
comments. [attachment "8-K 2004 second quarter press release-Aug 16.doc" deleted
by Thomas Gaidimas/US/ABAS/PwC]